Unification Church
The Family Federation for World Peace and Unification (FFWPU), widely known as the Unification Church, is a new religious movement derived from Christianity, whose members are called Unificationists or Moonies, although many "Unificationists" consider the "M" word derogatory but will use it amongst themselves in the same way that Black people have come to "own" the "N" word, or Irish people call each other "Paddies", but might resent others using such slurs.[2] Sun Myung Moon (1920–2012) started amassing followers after the Second World War ended and, on 1 May 1954 in Seoul, South Korea, officially founded the Holy Spirit Association for the Unification of World Christianity (HSA-UWC), the organization's full name until 1994. Its leaders are Moon (prior to his death) and his wife Hak Ja Han, whom their followers honor with the title "True Parents".
| Family Federation for World Peace and Unification (Unification Church) 세계평화통일가정연합 | |
|---|---|
Official emblem | |
| Abbreviation | FFWPU, UM, UC |
| Classification | New religious movement |
| Scripture | Bible Divine Principle |
| Acting Leader | Hak Ja Han |
| Founder | Sun Myung Moon |
| Origin | 1 May 1954 Seoul, South Korea |
| Members | Approximately 3 million[1] |
| Other name(s) |
|
| Official website | familyfed |
Moon's book, The Divine Principle, was, he claims revealed to him over a period of 9 years after he claims Jesus appeared to him on Easter Sunday 1936 on mountainside and asked him to continue the work that he couldn't finish while he was on earth, due to the "tragedy" of his crucifixion[3]. Divine Principle informs the beliefs of the Unification Church (FFWPU). Moon considered himself the Second Coming of Christ, claiming to complete the mission started by Jesus Christ of beginning a new family, and a larger human lineage, free from sin.[4] The Unification Church is well known for its mass weddings known as Blessing ceremonies.[5] It has been criticized for its teachings and for its social influence, with some critics calling it a "dangerous cult".[6][7] Its involvement in politics includes anti-communism and support for Korean reunification.[8][9][10] Its members have founded, owned, and supported related organizations in business,[11] education,[12] politics,[13] and more.[14]
Popular terminologies
Moon did not originally intend on founding a separate organization or denomination,[15] and did not give his group of followers its official name, Holy Spirit Association for the Unification of World Christianity (Korean: 세계 기독교 통일 신령 협회 Segye Gidoggyo Tong-il Sinryeong Hyeobhoe), until 1954.[16] The informal name "Unification Church" (Korean: 통일교; RR: Tong-il-gyo) has been commonly used by members, the public, and the news media.[17]
Moonie is a colloquial term,[18] which was first used in 1974 by some American media outlets.[19] Unification Church members have used the word, including Moon himself,[20] the president of the Unification Theological Seminary David Kim,[21] and Bo Hi Pak, Moon's aide and president of Little Angels Children's Folk Ballet of Korea.[22] In the 1980s and 1990s the Unification Church of the United States undertook an extensive public relations campaign against the use of the word by the news media.[23][24] In other contexts it is still sometimes used and not always considered pejorative.[25][26] By 2018, the term "Unification Movement" was widely used.[27]
Moon and his wife, Hak Ja Han, are regarded by Unificationists as "True Father" and "True Mother", respectively, and as "True Parents" collectively.
History
Background and origins
On 25 February 1920, Moon was born Mun Yong-myeong in Sangsa-ri (Korean: 상사리; Hanja: 上思里), Deogun-myon (덕언면), Jeongju-gun, North P'yŏng'an Province, at a time when Korea was under Japanese rule. His birthday was recorded as January 6 by the traditional lunar calendar (25 February 1920, according to the Gregorian Calendar).[28] Around 1930, his family, who followed traditional Confucianist beliefs, converted to Christianity and joined a Presbyterian Church, where he later taught Sunday school.[29]
In 1945, Moon attended the Israel Monastery (Israel Jesus Church near Seoul) with his wife, Choi Sun-Kil (최선길; 崔先吉; Choe Seon-gil), to learn the teachings of Kim Baek-moon, including his book The Fundamental Principles of Christianity (基督教根本原理 drafted March 2, 1946, published March 2, 1958).[30][31][32] After World War II and the Japanese rule ended in 1945, Moon began preaching.[29] In 1946, Moon traveled alone to Pyongyang in Communist-ruled North Korea.[33] He was arrested on allegations of spying for South Korea and given a five-year sentence to the Hŭngnam labor camp.[34]
Holy Spirit Association for the Unification of World Christianity (1954–1994)
Moon founded the Holy Spirit Association for the Unification of World Christianity (HSA-UWC) in Seoul on 1 May 1954. It expanded rapidly in South Korea and, by the end of 1955, had 30 centers nationwide.[16] The HSA-UWC expanded throughout the world with most members living in South Korea, Japan, the Philippines, and other nations in East Asia.[35][16] In the 1970s, American HSA-UWC members were noted for raising money for Unification Church projects.[36]
The HSA-UWC also sent missionaries to Europe. They entered Czechoslovakia in 1968 and remained underground until the 1990s.[37] Unification movement activity in South America began in the 1970s with missionary work. Later, the HSA-UWC made large investments in civic organizations and business projects, including an international newspaper.[38] Starting in the 1990s, the HSA-UWC expanded in Russia and other former communist nations. Hak Ja Han, Moon's wife, made a radio broadcast to the nation from the State Kremlin Palace.[39] As of 1994, the HSA-UWC had about 5,000 members in Russia.[40] About 500 Russian students had been sent to the US to participate in 40-day workshops.[41]
Moon moved to the United States in 1971, although he remained a citizen of the Republic of Korea. In the 1970s, he gave a series of public speeches in the United States, including one in Madison Square Garden in New York City in 1974; two in 1976 in Yankee Stadium in New York City; and one on the grounds of the Washington Monument in Washington, DC, where he spoke on "God's Hope for America" to 300,000 people. In 1975, the HSA-UWC held one of the largest peaceful gatherings in history, with 1.2 million people in Yeouido, South Korea.[42]
In the 1970s, the Unification Church, along with some other new religious movements, became a target of the anti-cult movement. Activists have accused the movement of having "brainwashed" its members.[43][44] In 1976, American Unification Church president Neil Albert Salonen met with Senator Bob Dole to defend the HSA-UWC against charges which were made by its critics, including the parents of some members.[45]
The Unification Church's involvement in the seafood industry began at the direction of Moon who ordered an expansion into "the oceanic providence." In 1976 and 1977 the Church invested nearly a million dollars into the United States seafood industry.[46] Moon delivered a speech in 1980 entitled "The Way of Tuna" in which he claimed that "After we build the boats, we catch the fish and process them for the market, and then have a distribution network. This is not just on the drawing board; I have already done it." and declared himself the "king of the ocean." He also suggested that they could get around the recently imposed 200 nautical miles exclusive economic zone by marrying American and Japanese members, allowing the Japanese ones to become American citizens, because once married, "we are not foreigners; therefore Japanese brothers, particularly those matched to Americans, are becoming ..... leaders for fishing and distribution." He also declared that "Gloucester is almost a Moonie town now!"[46]
In 1976 UC members founded News World Communications, an international news media corporation.[47] Its first two newspapers, The News World (later renamed the New York City Tribune) and the Spanish-language Noticias del Mundo, were published in New York from 1976 until the early 1990s. In 1982 The New York Times described News World as "the newspaper unit of the Unification Church."[48] Moon's son Hyun Jin Moon is its chairman of the board.[49] News World Communications owns United Press International, The World and I, Tiempos del Mundo (Latin America), The Segye Ilbo (South Korea), The Sekai Nippo (Japan), the Zambezi Times (South Africa), The Middle East Times (Egypt).[50] Until 2008 it published the Washington, D.C.-based newsmagazine Insight on the News.[47] Until 2010, it owned The Washington Times. On November 2, 2010, Sun Myung Moon and a group of former Times editors purchased the paper from News World.[51]
Starting in the 1980s, Moon instructed HSA-UWC members to take part in a program called "Home Church" in which they reached out to neighbors and community members through public service.[52]
In April 1990, Moon visited the Soviet Union and met with President Mikhail Gorbachev. Moon expressed support for the political and economic transformations underway in the Soviet Union. At the same time, the movement was expanding into formerly communist nations.[53]
The Women's Federation for World Peace(세계평화여성연합,WFWP) was founded in 1992 by Hak Ja Han. Its stated purpose is to encourage women to work more actively in promoting peace in their communities and greater society. It has members in 143 countries.[54][55][56]
Family Federation for World Peace and Unification (1994–present)
On 1 May 1994 (the 40th anniversary of the founding of the HSA-UWC), Moon declared that the era of the HSA-UWC had ended and inaugurated a new organization: the Family Federation for World Peace and Unification (FFWPU) would include HSA-UWC members and members of other religious organizations working toward common goals, especially on issues of sexual morality and reconciliation between people of different religions, nations, and races. The FFWPU co-sponsored Blessing ceremonies in which thousands of couples from other churches and religions were given the marriage blessing previously given only to HSA-UWC members.[57]
In the 1980s and 1990s, the Church's businesses expanded greatly and encountered significant success, leading to it becoming wealthy despite its declining number of members.[11] In 1991 Moon announced that members should return to their hometowns, to undertake apostolic work there. Massimo Introvigne, who has studied the Unification Church and other new religious movements, said that this confirmed that full-time membership was no longer considered crucial to church members.[58] In 1994, The New York Times recognized the movement's political influence, saying it was "a theocratic powerhouse that is pouring foreign fortunes into conservative causes in the United States."[59] In 1998, the Egyptian newspaper Al-Ahram criticized Moon's "ultra-right leanings" and suggested a personal relationship with conservative Israeli prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu.[60]
In 1995, the former U.S. President George H. W. Bush and his wife, Barbara Bush, spoke at an FFWPU event in the Tokyo Dome.[61] Bush told the gathering: "If as president I could have done one thing to have helped the country more, it would have been to do a better job in finding a way, either through speaking out or through raising a moral standard, to strengthen the American family."[62] Hak Ja Han, the main speaker, credited her husband with bringing about the Fall of Communism and declared that he must save America from "the destruction of the family and moral decay".[63]
In 2000, Moon founded the World Association of Non-Governmental Organizations (WANGO), which describes itself as "a global organization whose mission is to serve its member organizations, strengthen and encourage the non-governmental sector as a whole, increase public understanding of the non-governmental community, and provide the mechanism and support needed for NGOs to connect, partner, and multiply their contributions to solve humanity's basic problems." It has been criticized for promoting conservatism in contrast to some of the ideals of the United Nations.[64][65][66]
In 2000, the FFWPU co-sponsored the Million Family March, a rally in Washington, D.C., to celebrate family unity and racial and religious harmony, along with the Nation of Islam.[67] Louis Farrakhan was the main speaker at the event which was held on 16 October 2000; the fifth anniversary of the Million Man March, which was also organized by Farrakhan.[68] FFWPU leader Dan Fefferman wrote to his colleagues acknowledging that Farrakhan's and Moon's views differed on multiple issues but shared a view of a "God-centered family".[69]
In 2003, Korean FFWPU members started a political party in South Korea, "The Party for God, Peace, Unification, and Home". An inauguration declaration stated the new party would focus on preparing for Korean reunification by educating the public about God and peace. An FFWPU official said that similar political parties would be started in Japan and the United States.[70] Since 2003, the FFWPU-related Universal Peace Federation's Middle East Peace Initiative has been organizing group tours of Israel and Palestine to promote understanding, respect, and reconciliation among Jews, Muslims, and Christians.[71][72]
On 15 August 2012, Moon was reported to be gravely ill and was put on a respirator at the intensive care unit of St. Mary's Hospital at The Catholic University of Korea in Seoul. He was admitted on 14 August 2012, after suffering from pneumonia earlier in the month.[73] He died there on September 2.[74]
Moon was a member of the Honorary Committee of the Unification Ministry of the Republic of Korea.[75] The church member Jae-jung Lee had been once a unification minister of the Republic of Korea.[76] Another, Ek Nath Dhakal, is a member of the Nepalese Constituent Assembly,[77] and a first Minister for Co-operatives and Poverty Alleviation Ministry of the Government of Nepal.[78] In 2016, a study sponsored by the Unification Theological Seminary found that American members were divided in their choices in the 2016 United States presidential election, with the largest bloc supporting Senator Bernie Sanders.[79]
Hak Ja Han has been acting as a leader and public spokesperson for the movement. In 2019, she spoke at a rally in Japan and called for greater understanding and cooperation between the Pacific Rim nations.[80] In 2020, she spoke at a UPF sponsored in-person and virtual rally for Korean unification, which drew about one million attendees.[81] In 2020 former Secretary General of the United Nations Ban Ki-moon received the Sunhak Peace Prize, which is sponsored by the Unification Church, and an award of US$1,000,000.[82][83]
In 2021, Donald Trump and Shinzo Abe gave speeches at the Rally of Hope event hosted by an affiliate of the Unification Church.[84][85][86][87][88] Five ministers of the Cabinet of Japan have relationships with the Unification Church, including the Minister of Health, Labour, and Welfare and the head of the Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communications.[89]
Beliefs
Moon's teachings, called the Divine Principle, were first published as Wolli Wonbon (Korean: 원리 원본; Hanja: 原理原本, 'Original Text of the Divine Principle') in 1945. The earliest manuscript was lost in North Korea during the Korean War. A second, expanded version, Wonli Hesol (원리 해설; 原理解說), or Explanation of the Divine Principle, was published in 1957. The Divine Principle or Exposition of the Divine Principle (원리강론; 原理講論; Wolli Gangnon) is the main theological textbook of the movement. It was co-written by Sun Myung Moon and early disciple Hyo Won'eu and first published in 1966. A translation entitled Divine Principle was published in English in 1973.[90] The Divine Principle lays out the core of Unification Church theology and is held by its believers to have the status of holy scripture. Following the format of systematic theology, it includes God's purpose in creating human beings, the fall of man, and restoration – the process through history by which God is working to remove the ill effects of the fall and restore humanity back to the relationship and position that God originally intended.[91] David Václavík and Dušan Lužný described the details of those 3 points as follows:
- Principle of Creation: This first principle states that God created the world in his image. All of reality is then composed of bipolarities. The basic bipolarity is expressed by the terms sung-sang (Korean: 성상; Hanja: 性相, 'inner character' – the inner, invisible aspect of the created world) and hyung-sang (Korean: 형상; Hanja: 形相, 'outer form' – the outer, visible aspect of the created world). In addition to this, there is another bipolarity, denoted by the terms yin and yang. The first-mentioned bipolarity of sung-sang and hyung-sang reflects the relationship between soul (mind) and matter (body), while yin-yang reflects the relationship between femininity and masculinity. Hierarchy, described by the first principle (the basis of the four positions) then guarantees order in the world – God or higher purpose is placed highest, in the middle are man and woman, and finally, children are placed as the result. As Václavík and Lužný further characterize the doctrine, "God is an absolute reality transcending time and space. The fundamental energy of God's being is also eternal. By the action of this energy, entities enter into a relationship with each other, the basis of which is the activity of giving and receiving. The goal is to achieve a balanced and harmonious relationship of giving and receiving, i.e., love." According to the teachings of the Church, the highest level of relationship is the relationship with God. By properly developing the relationship of giving and receiving, it should be possible to achieve union with God. The goal of creation is then the realization of the kingdom of heaven and can be achieved by fulfilling the three biblical blessings. Principle describes three blessings as follows. The first blessing concerns the nature of man: God created man in his own image. The second blessing was to be fulfilled through Adam and Eve by establishing an ideal family that was pure and loving, but they failed to do so. The third blessing concerns man's position as a mediator between God and nature. Man is to master nature in order to perfect himself and nature itself and thus create the kingdom of heaven. Principle then describes three stages of growth of everything including man, namely, origin (formation), growth, and completion.[92]
- The Fall of Man: according to the teaching of the Church, there was no fulfillment of God's plan. God endowed man with free will and responsibility. Like everything in the universe, Adam and Eve went through three phases of development (origin, growth, and completion). This part describes that, before completion could occur, the orientation of the give-and-take relationship was reversed when Eve established a sexual relationship with Satan. Thus occurred the fall of man and the creation of a world "with Satan at the center, and all men have become children of Satan." According to this belief, the world is from that time dominated by Satan's lineage through the human race, and men with evil natures transmit evil. Through their children, they then create evil families and thus an evil world.[92]
- The principle of restoration: According to the teaching of the Church, the primary purpose of creation was to build the Kingdom of Heaven on earth. This means that God will eventually save this sinful world and restore it to its original, sinless state. This is the basis of the principle of restoration. This is the perspective through which the Unification Church views the entire history of humanity. For the church, history is the history of restoration and of God's efforts to save fallen men. At the end of this history, the Last Days are to come. Restoration teaches, that God has tried to end the sinful world and restore the original good world several times in human history. However, men have failed in their responsibility and thwarted God's will. Doctrine claims that God made several such attempts: in the case of Noah, God first destroyed the sinful world with a flood, yet Noah's second born son Ham sinned again. Another attempt to restore the original sinless world was the coming of Jesus Christ when God sent the Messiah to establish the perfect family and thus create the Kingdom of Heaven on earth. Jesus did not fulfill this mission because he was crucified. Václavík and Lužný summarize: "According to the doctrine of the Unification Church, we are currently living in the period of the Last Days, that is, the period of the Second Coming of Christ. However, today's situation is very different from previous ones. For Christ will be successful at His Second Coming – God will send the 'True Parents of humanity' and through them fulfill the purpose of creation. During the previous two thousand years, God has prepared, according to the principle of restoration, a suitable democratic, social, and legal environment that will protect Christ at the Second Coming."[92]
Followers take as a starting point the truth of the Christian Old and New Testaments, with the Divine Principle an additional text that intends to interpret and "fulfill" the purpose of those older texts.[91] Moon was intent on replacing worldwide forms of Christianity with his new unified vision of it,[34] Moon being a self-declared messiah. Moon's followers regard him as a separate person from Jesus but with a mission to basically continue and complete Jesus's work in a new way, according to the Principle.[4] The Unification Church regards a person's destination after death as being dependent on how much one's work during this life corresponds to its teachings. Moon's followers believe in Apocatastasis, that everyone will eventually receive salvation.[93]
In 1977, Frederick Sontag analyzed the teachings of the Divine Principle and summarized it in 12 concise points:[94]
- God: Divine Principle teaches, that there is one living, eternal and true God, a person beyond space and time, who has a perfect reason, emotion, and will, whose deepest heart essence is love, which includes both masculinity and femininity, a person who is the source of all truth, beauty and goodness, and who is the creator and sustainer of man, the universe and all things visible and invisible. Man and the universe reflect his personality, character, and purpose.
- Man: Man was then created by God as a unique creature, made in his image as his children, like him in personality and character, and created with the capacity to respond to his love, to be a source of his joy, and to share his creativity.
- God's desire for man and creation: To the relationship between God and Man, teaching states that God's desire for man and creation is eternal and unchanging, God wants men and women to fulfill three things: First, each should grow to perfection so as to become one with God in heart, will, and action, so that their mind and body are united in perfect harmony centered on God's love; second, to be united with God as husband and wife and give birth to God's sinless children, thereby establishing a sinless family and ultimately a sinless world; third, to become masters of the created world, establishing loving dominion with him in a mutual relationship of giving and receiving. None of this happened because of human sin. Therefore, God's present desire is to solve the sin problem and restore all these things, which will bring about the earthly and heavenly kingdom of God.
- Sin: The Divine Principle describes the origin of sin and the process of the fall of man. The first man and woman (Adam and Eve), before they became perfect, were tempted by the archangel Lucifer to illicit love. Because of this, Adam and Eve willfully turned away from God's will and purpose, bringing spiritual death to themselves and the human race. As a result of this Fall, Satan usurped the position of the true father of mankind, so that all humans since then have been born in sin both physically and spiritually and have sinful tendencies. Therefore, human beings tend to resist God and his will and live in ignorance as to their true nature and parentage and all that they have lost thereby. Thus God suffers for lost children and a lost world and has had to constantly struggle to restore them to himself. Creation groans to give birth while waiting to be reunited through the true children of God.
- Christology: According to the Divine Principle, fallen humanity can only be restored to God through Christ (the Messiah) who comes as the new Adam to become the new head of the human race through whom humanity can be reborn into the family of God. In order for God to send the Messiah, mankind must fulfill certain conditions that restore, what was lost because of the Fall.
- History: The Divine Principle describes, that restoration is accomplished through the payment of the indemnity for a sin. Human history is then a record of God's and man's efforts to make this indemnity over time so that the conditions can be met and God can send the Messiah who comes to begin the final process of restoration. If some efforts fail in fulfilling the conditions of indemnity, they must be repeated, usually by another person after a period of time. This, according to the Divine Principle, is why history shows cyclical patterns. History culminates with the coming of the Messiah, which ends the old age and begins a new age.
- Resurrection: The Divine Principle explains resurrection as the process of restoration to spiritual life and spiritual maturity, ultimately uniting a person with God. It is the transition from spiritual death to spiritual life. This should be accomplished in part by human effort (through prayer, good works, etc.) with the help of the saints in the spirit world and completed by God's effort to bring man to new birth through Christ (the Messiah).
- Predestination: According to the Divine Principle, God has predestined absolutely that all men will be restored to him and have chosen all men for salvation, but he has also given man a portion of responsibility (to be fulfilled by man's free will) for the fulfillment of his original will and his will to bring about restoration. This responsibility remains permanently with man. God has predestined and called certain persons and groups of people to certain responsibilities. If these fail, others must fill their role and greater compensation must be made.
- Jesus: The Divine Principle teaches that Jesus of Nazareth came as the Christ, the second Adam, the only begotten Son of God. He became one with God, spoke God's words, and did God's works, thus showing God to men. However, people eventually rejected and crucified him, preventing him from building God's kingdom on earth. The Divine Principle teaches that Jesus overcame Satan in the crucifixion and resurrection, making spiritual salvation possible for those who are born again through him and the Holy Spirit. The restoration of the Kingdom of God on earth awaits the Second Coming of Christ.
- The Bible: The Divine Principle offers an explanation of the Scriptures of the Old and New Testaments. Both should be the record of God's progressive revelation to mankind. The purpose of the Bible, according to the Divine Principle, is to bring humanity to Christ and reveal to mankind the heart of God. The Divine Principle supports the Bible, as the truth is unique, eternal, and unchanging, so any new messages from God will be consistent with the Bible and will contain deeper explanations. The Divine Principle describes the current time as the last days when the new truth must be communicated by God (in the book 'God's Principle') so that mankind will be able to finish what is still unfinished.
- The ultimate renewal: According to the Divine Principle, a proper understanding of theology focuses simultaneously on man's relationship with God (vertical) and man's relationship with his neighbor (horizontal). Man's sin has disrupted both of these relationships and thus caused all the problems in the world. These problems will be solved through the restoration of man to God through Christ, as well as through such measures as establishing appropriate moral standards and practices, forming true families uniting all peoples and races (Oriental, Western, and African), resolving the tension between science and religion, correcting economic, racial, political, and educational injustices, and overcoming God-denying ideologies such as Communism.
- The Second Coming (Eschatology): The Divine Principle teaches that Christ's Second Coming will occur in this age, which would be similar to the time of his First Coming. Christ should come as before, that is, as a man in the flesh. By marrying his bride in the flesh, he will establish a family and thus become the True Parents of all mankind. Through accepting the 'True Parents (참부모)' (the Second Coming of Christ), obeying them, and following them, the original sin of mankind would be removed and people can eventually become perfect. In this way, true families fulfilling God's ideal will begin, and the Kingdom of God's will should be established both on earth and in heaven. According to the Divine Principle, this day is now at hand in the person of Sun Myung Moon.
Traditions
Blessing ceremony
The Unification Church is well known for its Blessing tradition: a mass wedding ceremony (합동결혼식) and wedding vow renewal ceremony. It is given to engaged or married couples. According to the Church's belief in a serpent seed interpretation of original sin and the Fall of Man, Eve was sexually seduced by Satan (the serpent), and thus the human bloodline is sinful due to being directly descended from Satan.[95][96] Through the Blessing, members believe, the couple is removed from the lineage of sinful humanity and restored back into God's sinless lineage.
The first Blessing ceremony was held in 1961 for 36 couples in Seoul, South Korea by the Moons shortly after their own marriage in 1960. All the couples were members of the church. Moon matched all of the couples except 12 who were already married to each other before joining the church.[97] This was Moon's second marriage. In 1945 he married Sun Kil Choi. They had a son in 1946 and divorced in 1954.[98]
Later Blessing ceremonies were larger in scale but followed the same pattern. All participants were HSA-UWC members and Moon matched most of the couples. In 1982 the first large scale Blessing (of 2,000 couples) outside of Korea took place in Madison Square Garden, New York City.[99] In 1988, Moon matched 2,500 Korean members with Japanese members for a Blessing ceremony held in Korea, partly in order to promote unity between the two nations.[100]
Moon's practice of matching couples was very unusual in both Christian tradition and in modern Western culture and attracted much attention and controversy.[101] The Blessing ceremonies have attracted a lot of attention in the press and in the public imagination, often being labeled "mass weddings".[102] However, in most cases the Blessing ceremony is not a legal wedding ceremony. Some couples are already married and those that are engaged are later legally married according to the laws of their own countries.[103] The New York Times referred to a 1997 ceremony for 28,000 couples as a "marriage affirmation ceremony", adding: "The real weddings were held later in separate legal ceremonies."[104]
Mary Farrell Bednarowski says that marriage is "really the only sacrament" in the Unification movement. Unificationists therefore view singleness as "not a state to be sought or cultivated" but as preparation for marriage. Pre-marital celibacy and marital faithfulness are emphasized.[5] Adherents may be taught to "abstain from intimate relations for a specified time after marriage".[105] The church does not give its marriage blessing to same-sex couples.[106] Moon has emphasized the similarity between Unification views of sexuality and evangelical Christianity, "reaching out to conservative Christians in this country in the last few years by emphasizing shared goals like support for sexual abstinence outside of marriage, and opposition to homosexuality."[107] Since 2001 couples Blessed by Moon have been able to arrange marriages for their own children, without his direct guidance. Also some Unification Church members have married partners who are not church members.[108]
Holy days
Holy Days of the Unification Church:[109]
- True God's Day (하나님의 날, established 1 January 1968) - always 1 January until 2009, then according to the lunar calendar - 23 January 2012
- True Parents' Birthday (참부모성탄 or 기원절,6 January 1920 - 6 January 1943) - Anniversary of the Coronation Ceremony for the Kingship of God (2001), 6. January until 2009, then according to the lunar calendar - 28 January 2012
- True Parents' Day (참부모의 날, established 1 March 1960 according to the lunar calendar) - 28 January 2012
- Day of All True Things (참만물의날established 1 May 1963 according to the lunar calendar) - 20 June 2012
- Chil Il Jeol (칠일절) - Declaration Day of God's Eternal Blessing(하나님 축복영원 선포일, Founded 1 July 1991) - always 1 July until 2009, then according to the lunar calendar - 18 August 2012
- Chil Pal Cheol (칠팔절) or Declaration of the Realm of the Cosmic Sabbath for the Parents of Heaven and Earth (천지부모 천주안식권 선포일) - founded 7 July 1997 according to the lunar calendar - 24 August 2012
- True Children's Day (참자녀의 날, established on 1 October 1960 according to the lunar calendar) - 14 November 2012
- Foundation Day for the Nation of Heaven and Earth (천주통일국 개천일, founded 3 October 1988) - always 3 October until 2009, then 16 November 2012 according to the lunar calendar
Scholarly studies
In the early 1960s John Lofland lived with HSA-UWC missionary Young Oon Kim and a small group of American members and studied their activities in trying to promote their beliefs and win new members. Lofland noted that most of their efforts were ineffective and that most of the people who joined did so because of personal relationships with other members, often family relationships. Lofland published his findings in 1964 as a doctoral thesis entitled "The World Savers: A Field Study of Cult Processes", and in 1966 in book form by Prentice-Hall as Doomsday Cult: A Study of Conversion, Proselytization, and Maintenance of Faith.[110][111][112][113]
In 1977 Frederick Sontag, a professor of philosophy at Pomona College and a minister in the United Church of Christ.,[114] spent 10 months visiting HSA-UWC members in North America, Europe, and Asia as well as interviewing Moon at his home in New York State. He reported his findings and observations in Sun Myung Moon and the Unification Church, published by Abingdon Press. The book also provides an overview of the Divine Principle.[115] In an interview with UPI Sontag compared the HSA-UWC with the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints and said that he expected its practices to conform more to mainstream American society as its members become more mature. He added that he did not want to be considered an apologist but a close look at HSA-UWC's theology is important: "They raise some incredibly interesting issues."[116]
In 1984 Eileen Barker published The Making of a Moonie based on her seven-year study of HSA-UWC members in the United Kingdom and the United States.[117] In 2006 Laurence Iannaccone of George Mason University, a specialist in the economics of religion, wrote that The Making of a Moonie was "one of the most comprehensive and influential studies" of the process of conversion to new religious movements.[118] Australian psychologist Len Oakes and British psychiatry professor Anthony Storr, who have written rather critically about cults, gurus, new religious movements, and their leaders have praised The Making of a Moonie.[119][120] It was given the Distinguished Book Award for 1985 by the Society for the Scientific Study of Religion.[121] In 1997 Barker reported that Unificationists had mostly undergone a transformation in their world view from millennialism to utopianism.[122]
In 1998 Irving Louis Horowitz, sociologist, questioned the relationship between the HSA-UWC and scholars whom it paid to conduct research on its behalf.[123]
Relations with other religions
Judaism
Unificationism holds that the Jewish people as a whole were prepared by God to receive the Messiah in the person of Jesus of Nazareth, with John the Baptist tasked from birth with the mission to lead the Jewish people to Jesus, but failed in his mission. According to the Divine Principle, the Jews went through a "course of indemnity" due to the failure of John the Baptist to recognize Jesus as the Messiah, in spite of publicly testifying to him at the Jordan River, whilst receiving the baptism.[124]
In 1976, the American Jewish Committee released a report by Rabbi A. James Rudin which stated that the Divine Principle contained "pejorative language, stereotyped imagery, and accusations of collective sin and guilt."[125] In a news conference which was presented by the AJC and representatives of Catholic and Protestant churches, panelists stated that the text "contained over 125 anti-Jewish references." They also cited Moon's recent and public condemnation of "antisemitic and anti-Christian attitudes", and called upon him to make a "comprehensive and systematic removal" of antisemitic and anti-Christian references in the Divine Principle as a demonstration of good faith.[126]
In 1977, the HSA-UWC issued a rebuttal to the report, stating that it was neither comprehensive nor reconciliatory, instead, it had a "hateful tone" and it was filled with "sweeping denunciations". It denied that the Divine Principle teaches antisemitism and gave detailed responses to 17 specific allegations which were contained in the AJC's report, stating that the allegations were distortions of teachings and obscurations of the real content of passages or the passages were accurate summaries of Jewish scriptures or New Testament passages.[127]
In 1984, Mose Durst, then the president of the Unification Church of the United States as well as a convert from Judaism,[128] said that the Jewish community had been "hateful" in its response to the growth of the Unification movement, and he also placed blame on the community's "insecurity" and Unification Church members' "youthful zeal and ignorance". Rudin, then the national interreligious affairs director of the American Jewish Committee, said that Durst's remarks were inaccurate and unfair and he also said that "hateful is a harsh word to use".[129] In the same year Durst wrote in his autobiography: "Our relations with the Jewish community have been the most painful to me personally. I say this with a heavy heart, since I was raised in the Jewish faith and am proud of my heritage."[130]
In 1989, Unification Church leaders Peter Ross and Andrew Wilson issued "Guidelines for Members of The Unification Church in Relations with the Jewish People" which stated: "In the past there have been serious misunderstandings between Judaism and the Unification Church. In order to clarify these difficulties and guide Unification Church members in their relations with Jews, the Unification Church suggests the following guidelines."[131] In 2008, the Encyclopaedia Judaica described the statements and guidelines arising from mutual contacts as "excellent".[132]
Christianity
Protestant commentators have criticized Unification Church teachings as being contrary to the Protestant doctrine of salvation by faith alone.[133] In their influential book The Kingdom of the Cults (first published in 1965), Walter Ralston Martin and Ravi K. Zacharias disagreed with the Divine Principle on the issues of Christology, the virgin birth of Jesus, the movement's belief that Jesus should have married, the necessity of the crucifixion of Jesus, and a literal resurrection of Jesus as well as a literal Second Coming.[134]
In 1974 Moon founded the Unification Theological Seminary, in Barrytown, New York, partly in order to improve relations of the movement with other churches. Professors from other denominations, including a Methodist minister, a Presbyterian, and a Roman Catholic priest, as well as a rabbi, were hired to teach religious studies to the students, who were being trained as leaders in the movement.[135][136][137][138][139]
In 1977, Unification member Jonathan Wells, who later became well known as the author of the popular Intelligent Design book Icons of Evolution, defended Unification theology against what he said were unfair criticisms by the National Council of Churches.[140] That same year Frederick Sontag, a professor of philosophy at Pomona College and a minister in the United Church of Christ,[114] published Sun Myung Moon and the Unification Church which gave an overview of the movement and urged Christians to take it more seriously.[115][116][141]
In the 1980s the Unification Church sent thousands of American ministers from other churches on trips to Japan and South Korea to inform them about Unification teachings. At least one minister was dismissed by his congregation for taking part.[142] In 1994 the church had about 5,000 members in Russia and came under criticism from the Russian Orthodox Church.[40] In 1997, the Russian government passed a law requiring the movement and other non-Russian religions to register their congregations and submit to tight controls.[143]
In 1982, Moon was imprisoned in the United States after being found guilty by a jury of willfully filing false Federal income tax returns and conspiracy. (See: United States v. Sun Myung Moon) HSA-UWC members launched a public-relations campaign. Booklets, letters and videotapes were mailed to approximately 300,000 Christian leaders in the United States. Many of them signed petitions protesting the government's case.[144] The American Baptist Churches in the U.S.A, the National Council of Churches, the National Black Catholic Clergy Caucus, and the Southern Christian Leadership Conference filed briefs in support of Moon.[145]
In 1995 the Unification Movement related organization the Women's Federation for World Peace indirectly contributed $3.5 million to help Baptist Liberty University which at that time was in financial difficulty. This was reported in the United States news media as an example of closer relationships between the movement and conservative Christian congregations.[146]
Islam
The Divine Principle lists the Muslim world as one of the world's four major divisions (the others being East Asia, Hindu, and Christendom).[147] Unification movement support for Islamist anti-communists came to public attention in 1987 when church member Lee Shapiro was killed in Afghanistan during the Soviet–Afghan War while filming a documentary.[148][149] The resistance group they were traveling with reported that they had been ambushed by military forces of the Soviet Union or the Afghan government. However, the details have been questioned, partly because of the poor reputation of the group's leader, Gulbuddin Hekmatyar.[150][151]
The Muslim advocacy group Council on American–Islamic Relations listed The Washington Times among media outlets it said "regularly demonstrates or supports Islamophobic themes."[152] In 1998, the Egyptian newspaper Al-Ahram wrote that its editorial policy was "rabidly anti-Arab, anti-Muslim and pro-Israel."[153] In 1997, the Washington Report on Middle East Affairs (which is critical of United States and Israeli policies), praised The Washington Times and the Times' sister publication The Middle East Times (along with The Christian Science Monitor owned by the Church of Christ, Scientist) for their objective and informative coverage of Islam and the Middle East, while criticizing the Times generally pro-Israel editorial policy. The Report suggested that these newspapers, being owned by religious organizations, were less influenced by pro-Israel pressure groups in the United States.[154]
In 2000 the FFWPU co-sponsored the Million Family March, a rally in Washington D.C. to celebrate family unity and racial and religious harmony, along with the Nation of Islam.[67] Louis Farrakhan, the leader of The Nation of Islam, was the main speaker at the event which was held on 16 October 2000; the fifth anniversary of the Million Man March, which was also organized by Farrakhan.[68] Unification Church leader Dan Fefferman wrote to his colleagues acknowledging that Farrakhan's and Moon's views differed on multiple issues but shared a view of a "God-centered family".[69] In 2007 Rev and Mrs Moon sent greetings to Farrakhan while he was recovering from cancer, saying: "We send love and greetings to Minister Farrakhan and Mother Khadijah."[155]
In the 1990s and 2000s the Unification Movement made public statements claiming communications with the spirits of religious leaders including Muhammad and also Confucius, the Buddha, Jesus, and Augustine, as well as political leaders such as Karl Marx, Friedrich Engels, Lenin, Joseph Stalin, Leon Trotsky, Mao Zedong and many more. This was reported to have distanced the movement from Islam as well as from mainstream Christianity.[156] From 2001 to 2009 the Unification movement owned the American Life TV Network (now known as Youtoo TV),[157] which in 2007 broadcast George Clooney's documentary A Journey to Darfur, which was harshly critical of Islamists in Darfur, the Republic of Sudan.[158][159][160] It released the film on DVD in 2008 and announced that proceeds from its sale would be donated to the International Rescue Committee.[161] In his 2009 autobiography Moon praised Islam and expressed the hope that there would be more understanding between different religious communities.[162] In 2011, representatives of the Unification Church took part in an international seminar which was held in Taiwan by the Muslim World League. The said purpose of the seminar was to encourage inter-faith dialogue and discourage people from resorting to terrorism.[163]
Interfaith activities
In 2009 the FFWPU held an interfaith event in the Congress of the Republic of Peru.[164] Former President of the Congress Marcial Ayaipoma[165] and other notable politicians were called "Ambassadors for Peace" of the Unification Church.[166][167][168][169] In 2010, the church built a large interfaith temple in Seoul.[170] Author Deepak Chopra was the keynote at an interfaith event of the Unification Church co-hosted with the United Nations at the Headquarters of the United Nations.[171] In 2011, an interfaith event was held in the National Assembly of Thailand, the President of the National Assembly of Thailand attended the event.[172] In 2012, the Unification movement affiliated-Universal Peace Federation held an interfaith dialogue in Italy that was cosponsored by United Nations.[173] That year, the Universal Peace Federation held an interfaith program for representatives of 12 various religions and confessions in the hall of the United Nations General Assembly. The President of the United Nations General Assembly,[174] the Deputy Secretary-General of the United Nations,[175][176] the Permanent Observer of the Holy See to the United Nations[177] and other UN officials spoke.[178]
Science
The Divine Principle calls for the unification of science and religion: "Religion and science, each in their own spheres, have been the methods of searching for truth in order to conquer ignorance and attain knowledge. Eventually, the way of religion and the way of science should be integrated and their problems resolved in one united undertaking; the two aspects of truth, internal and external, should develop in full consonance."
In the 1970s and 1980s the Unification Movement sponsored the International Conference on the Unity of the Sciences (ICUS),[179] in order to promote the concept of the unity of science and religion.[180][181] American news media have suggested that the conferences were also an attempt to improve the often controversial public image of the church.[182][183] The first conference, held in 1972, had 20 participants; while the largest conference, in Seoul, South Korea in 1982, had 808 participants from over 100 countries.[184] Participants in one or more of the conferences included Nobel laureates John Eccles (Physiology or Medicine 1963, who chaired the 1976 conference)[179] and Eugene Wigner (Physics 1963).[185]
The relationship of the Unification Movement and science again came to public attention in 2002 with the publication of Icons of Evolution, a popular book critical of the teaching of evolution written by member Jonathan Wells. Wells is a graduate of the Unification Theological Seminary and has been active with the Discovery Institute as an advocate for intelligent design.[186][187][188]
Political activism
Anti-communism
In the 1940s, Moon cooperated with Communist Party members in support of the Korean independence movement against Imperial Japan. After the Korean War (1950–1953), he became an outspoken anti-communist.[162] Moon viewed the Cold War between liberal democracy and communism as the final conflict between God and Satan, with divided Korea as its primary front line.[189] Soon after its founding, the Unification movement began supporting anti-communist organizations, including the World League for Freedom and Democracy founded in 1966 in Taipei, Republic of China (Taiwan), by Chiang Kai-shek,[190] and the Korean Culture and Freedom Foundation, an international public diplomacy organization which also sponsored Radio Free Asia.[191] The Unification movement was criticized for its anti-communist activism by the mainstream media and the alternative press, many of whose members said that it could lead to World War Three and a nuclear holocaust. The movement's anti-communist activities received financial support from Japanese millionaire and activist Ryōichi Sasakawa.[192][193][8]
In 1972, Moon predicted the decline of communism, based on the teachings of the Divine Principle: "After 7,000 biblical years—6,000 years of restoration history plus the millennium, the time of completion—communism will fall in its 70th year. Here is the meaning of the year 1978. Communism, begun in 1917, could maintain itself approximately 60 years and reach its peak. So 1978 is the border line and afterward communism will decline; in the 70th year it will be altogether ruined. This is true. Therefore, now is the time for people who are studying communism to abandon it."[194] In 1973, he called for an "automatic theocracy" to replace communism and solve "every political and economic situation in every field".[195] In 1975, Moon spoke at a government sponsored rally against potential North Korean military aggression on Yeouido Island in Seoul to an audience of around 1 million.[196]
In 1976, Moon established News World Communications, an international news media conglomerate which publishes The Washington Times newspaper in Washington, D.C., and newspapers in South Korea, Japan, and South America, partly in order to promote political conservatism. According to The Washington Post, "the Times was established by Moon to combat communism and be a conservative alternative to what he perceived as the liberal bias of The Washington Post."[197] Bo Hi Pak, called Moon's "right-hand man", was the founding president and the founding chairman of the board.[198] Moon asked Richard L. Rubenstein, a rabbi and college professor, to join its board of directors.[199] The Washington Times has often been noted for its generally pro-Israel editorial policies.[154] In 2002, during the 20th anniversary party for the Times, Moon said: "The Washington Times will become the instrument in spreading the truth about God to the world."[197]
In 1980, members founded CAUSA International, an anti-communist educational organization based in New York City.[200] In the 1980s, it was active in 21 countries. In the United States, it sponsored educational conferences for evangelical and fundamentalist Christian leaders[201] as well as seminars and conferences for Senate staffers, Hispanic Americans and conservative activists.[202] In 1986, CAUSA International sponsored the documentary film Nicaragua Was Our Home, about the Miskito Indians of Nicaragua and their persecution at the hands of the Nicaraguan government. It was filmed and produced by USA-UWC member Lee Shapiro, who later died while filming with anti-Soviet forces during the Soviet–Afghan War.[203][204][205][206] At this time CAUSA international also directly assisted the United States Central Intelligence Agency in supplying the Contras, in addition to paying for flights by rebel leaders. CAUSA's aid to the Contras escalated after Congress cut off CIA funding for them. According to contemporary CIA reports, supplies for the anti-Sandinista forces and their families came from a variety of sources in the US ranging from Moon's Unification Church to U.S. politicians, evangelical groups and former military officers.[207][208][209][210]
In 1980, members in Washington, D.C., disrupted a protest rally against the United States military draft.[211] In 1981, the Appellate Division of New York State Supreme Court ruled that the HSA–UWC was not entitled to property tax exemptions on its New York City properties since its primary purpose was political, not religious.[212] In 1982, this ruling was overturned by the New York State Supreme Court itself, which ruled that it should be considered a religious organization for tax purposes.[213]
In 1983, some American members joined a public protest against the Soviet Union in response to its shooting down of Korean Airlines Flight 007.[214] In 1984, the HSA–UWC founded the Washington Institute for Values in Public Policy, a Washington, D.C. think tank that underwrites conservative-oriented research and seminars at Stanford University, the University of Chicago, and other institutions.[215] In the same year, member Dan Fefferman founded the International Coalition for Religious Freedom in Virginia, which is active in protesting what it considers to be threats to religious freedom by governmental agencies.[216] In August 1985, the Professors World Peace Academy, an organization founded by Moon, sponsored a conference in Geneva to debate the theme "The situation in the world after the fall of the communist empire."[217] After the dissolution of the Soviet Union in 1991 the Unification movement promoted extensive missionary work in Russia and other former Soviet nations.[218]
Korean unification
In 1991, Moon met with Kim Il Sung, the North Korean President, to discuss ways to achieve peace on the Korean Peninsula, as well as on international relations, tourism, and other topics.[219] In 1992, Kim gave his first and only interview with the Western news media to Washington Times reporter Josette Sheeran, who later became executive director of the United Nations World Food Programme.[220] In 1994, Moon was officially invited to Kim's funeral, in spite of the absence of diplomatic relations between North Korea and South Korea.[221]
In 1998, Unification movement-related businesses launched operations in North Korea with the approval of the government of South Korea, which had prohibited business relationships between North and South before.[222] In 2000, the church-associated business group Tongil Group founded Pyeonghwa Motors in the North Korean port of Nampo, in cooperation with the North Korean government. It was the first automobile factory in North Korea.[223]
During the presidency of George W. Bush, Dong Moon Joo, a Unification movement member and then president of The Washington Times, undertook unofficial diplomatic missions to North Korea in an effort to improve its relationship with the United States.[224] Joo was born in North Korea and is a citizen of the United States.[225]
In 2003, Korean Unification Movement members started a political party in South Korea. It was named The Party for God, Peace, Unification and Home. In its inauguration declaration, the new party said it would focus on preparing for Korean reunification by educating the public about God and peace.[70] Moon was a member of the Honorary Committee of the Unification Ministry of the Republic of Korea.[75] Church member Jae-jung Lee was a Unification Minister of the Republic of Korea.[76]
In 2010, in Pyongyang, to mark the 20th anniversary of Moon's visit to Kim Il Sung, de jure head of state Kim Yong-nam hosted Moon's son Hyung Jin Moon, then the president of the Unification Church, in his official residence.[226][227] At that time, Hyung Jin Moon donated 600 tons of flour to the children of Jeongju, the birthplace of Sun Myung Moon.[228][229]
In 2012, Moon was posthumously awarded North Korea's National Reunification Prize.[230] On the first anniversary of Moon's death, North Korean chairman Kim Jong Un expressed condolences to Han and the family, saying: "Kim Jong-un prayed for the repose of Moon, who worked hard for national concord, prosperity and reunification and world peace."[231] In 2017, the Unification Church sponsored the International Association of Parliamentarians for Peace (IAPP)—headed by former Prime Minister of Nepal Madhav Kumar Nepal and former Minister of Peace and Reconstruction Ek Nath Dhakal—visited Pyongyang and had constructive talks with the Korean Workers' Party.[232] In 2020 the movement held an in-person and virtual rally for Korean unification which drew about one million attendees.[81]
Criticism
Criticisms of Moon
Moon's claim to be the Messiah and the Second Coming of Christ has been rejected by both Jewish and Christian scholars.[233][234] Protestant commentators have criticized Moon's teachings as being contrary to the Protestant doctrine of salvation by faith alone.[235][236] In their influential book The Kingdom of the Cults (first published in 1965), Walter Ralston Martin and Ravi K. Zacharias disagreed with the Divine Principle on the issues of the divinity of Christ, the virgin birth of Jesus, Moon's belief that Jesus should have married, the necessity of the crucifixion of Jesus, a literal resurrection of Jesus, as well as a literal second coming of Jesus.[237] Commentators have criticized the Divine Principle for saying that the First World War, the Second World War, the Holocaust, and the Cold War served as indemnity conditions to prepare the world for the establishment of the Kingdom of God.[238]
In 1998, journalist Peter Maass, writing for The New Yorker, reported that some Unification members complained about Blessing being given to non-members who had not gone through the same course that members had.[239] In 2000, Moon was criticized, including by some members of his church, for his support of Nation of Islam leader Louis Farrakhan's Million Family March.[69] Moon was also criticized for his relationship with Jewish scholar Richard L. Rubenstein, an advocate of the "death of God theology" of the 1960s.[240] Rubenstein was a defender of the Unification Church and served on its advisory council,[241] as well as on the board of directors of the church-owned Washington Times newspaper.[242] In the 1990s, he served as president of the University of Bridgeport, which was then affiliated with the church.[243]
In 1998, the Egyptian newspaper Al-Ahram criticized Moon's possible relationship with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and wrote that the Washington Times editorial policy was "rabidly anti-Arab, anti-Muslim and pro-Israel."[244][154] Moon has also been criticized for his advocacy of a world-wide "automatic theocracy",[245] as well as for advising his followers that they should become "crazy for God".[246][247]
Theological disputes with Christianity
Fall of Man and view of Jesus
Central to Unification teachings is the concept that the Fall of Man was caused by the literal mating of Eve and Satan in the Garden of Eden, which contaminated the whole human race with sin. According to the religion, humanity can only be restored to God through a messiah who comes as a new Adam: a new head of the human race, replacing the sinful parents, and siring new children free from Satanic influence. In the Unification Church, Jesus is this messiah, just as he is a messianic figure in more mainstream Christianity;[248] however, since Jesus was prematurely killed before he could start a new sinless family, Moon claims he himself was called upon by God to fulfill Jesus' unresolved mission.[4]
In 1980, Unification theologian Young Oon Kim wrote:
Unification theology teaches that Jesus came to establish the kingdom of Heaven on Earth. As St. Paul wrote, Jesus was to be the new Adam restoring the lost garden of Eden. For this purpose he chose twelve apostles, symbolizing the original twelve tribes of Israel, and sent out seventy disciples, symbolizing all the nations of the world. Like John the Baptist, Jesus proclaimed that the long-awaited kingdom of heaven was at hand (Matt. 4:17). Jesus was appointed God's earthly representative in order to subjugate Satan, cleanse men of original sin and free them from the power of evil. Christ's mission involved liberation from sin and raising mankind to the perfection stage. His purpose was to bring about the kingdom of heaven in our world with the help of men filled with divine truth and love. Jesus' goal was to restore the garden of Eden, a place of joy and beauty in which true families of perfected parents would dwell with God in a full relationship of reciprocal love.[249]
The Unification view of Jesus has been criticized by mainstream Christian authors and theologians. In their influential book The Kingdom of the Cults (first published in 1965), Walter Ralston Martin and Ravi K. Zacharias disagreed with the Divine Principle on the issues of the divinity of Christ, the virgin birth of Jesus, the Unification Church's belief that Jesus should have married and a literal resurrection of Jesus as well as a literal Second Coming. They add: "Moon makes all men equal in "divinity" to Jesus, thereby striking a blow at the uniqueness of Christ."[250]
The Divine Principle states on this point:
There is no greater value than that of a person who has realized the ideal of creation. This is the value of Jesus, who surely attained the highest imaginable value. The conventional Christian belief in Jesus' divinity is well founded because, as a perfect human being, Jesus is totally one with God. To assert that Jesus is none other than a man who has completed the purpose of creation does not degrade the value of Jesus in the least.[251]
Unificationist theologian Young Oon Kim wrote, and some members of the Unification movement believe, that Zechariah was the father of Jesus, based on the work of Leslie Weatherhead, an English Christian theologian in the liberal Protestant tradition.[252][248][253][254]
Indemnity
Indemnity, in the context of Unification theology, is a part of the process by which human beings and the world are restored to God's ideal.[255][256][257][258] The concept of indemnity is explained at the start of the second half of the Divine Principle, "Introduction to Restoration":
What, then, is the meaning of restoration through indemnity? When someone has lost his original position or state, he must make some condition to be restored to it. The making of such conditions of restitution is called indemnity.[259] .... God's work to restore people to their true, unfallen state by having them fulfill indemnity conditions is called the providence of restoration through indemnity.[260]
(Korean original)
그 러면 '탕감복귀'란 무엇을 말하는 것인가? 무엇이든지 그 본연의 위치와 상태 등을 잃어버리게 되었을 때, 그것들을 본래의 위치와 상태에로 복귀하려면 반드시 거기에 필요한 어떠한 조건을 세워야 한다. 이러한 조건을 세우는 것을 '탕감(tang-gam)'이라고 하는 것이다....그리고 이처럼 탕감조건을 세워서 창조본연의 인간으로 복귀해 나아가는 섭리를 탕감복귀섭리라고 말한다[261]
(Significant Differences with the Christian Church in Interpretation of 'tang-gam(탕감)')
The Unification Church gives no explanation, 'tang-gam(탕감)', which means 'forgiveness', was translated into its opposite meaning,"indemnity".[262][263][264][265][266] The Divine Principle does not use the word "forgiveness," a central theme of Christianity.Even just one spot.It is preached as if humans can be saved only by indemnity.
The Divine Principle goes on to explain three types of indemnity conditions. Equal conditions of indemnity pay back the full value of what was lost. The biblical verse "life for life, eye for eye, tooth for tooth" (Exod.21:23–24) is quoted as an example of an equal indemnity condition. Lesser conditions of indemnity provide a benefit greater than the price that is paid. Faith, baptism, and the eucharist are mentioned as examples of lesser indemnity conditions. Greater conditions of indemnity come about when a person fails in a lesser condition. In that case a greater price must be paid to make up for the earlier failure. Abraham's attempted sacrifice of his son Isaac (Gen. 22:1–18) and the Israelites' 40 years of wandering in the wilderness under Moses (Num.14:34) are mentioned as examples of greater indemnity conditions.[260] The Divine Principle then explains that an indemnity condition must reverse the course by which the mistake or loss came about. Indemnity, at its core, is required of humans because God is pure, and purity cannot relate directly with impurity. Indemnification is the vehicle that allows a "just and righteous" God to work through mankind. Jesus' statement that God had forsaken him (Matt.27:46) and Christianity's history of martyrdom are mentioned as examples of this.[260] The Divine Principle then states that human beings, not God or the angels, are the ones responsible for making indemnity conditions.[267][260][268]
In 2005 scholars Daske and Ashcraft explained the concept of indemnity:
To restart the process toward perfection, God has sent messiahs to Earth who could restore the true state of humanity's relationship with God. Before that can happen, however, humans must perform good deeds that cancel the bad effects of sin. Unificationists call this 'indemnity'. Showing love and devotion to one's fellow humans, especially within families, helps pay this indemnity.[269]
Other Protestant Christian commentators have criticized the concept of indemnity as being contrary to the doctrine of sola fide. Christian historian Ruth Tucker said: "In simple language indemnity is salvation by works."[270][268] Rev. Keiko Kawasaki wrote: "The indemnity condition (of the Unification Church) is an oriental way of thinking, meaning a condition for atonement for sins (unlike Christianity)."[271][272][273] Donald Tingle and Richard Fordyce, ministers with the Christian Church (Disciples of Christ) who debated two Unification Church theologians in 1977, wrote: "In short, indemnity is anything you want to make it, since you establish the conditions. The zeal and enthusiasm of the Unification Church members is not so much based on love for God as it is compulsion to indemnify one's own sins."[274]
Investigation by the United States House of Representatives
In 1977, the Subcommittee on International Organizations of the Committee on International Relations, of the United States House of Representatives, reported that the Unification Church was established by the director of the Korean Central Intelligence Agency (KCIA), Kim Chong Pil.[275] The committee also reported that the KCIA had used the movement to gain political influence with the United States and some of its members had worked as volunteers in Congressional offices. Together they founded the Korean Cultural Freedom Foundation, a nonprofit organization which acted as a public diplomacy campaign for the Republic of Korea.[9] The committee also investigated possible KCIA influence on the Unification Church's campaign in support of Nixon.[276]
Unification Church official Dan Fefferman testified in August 1977 before the Fraser Committee.[277] Testimony from Fefferman confirmed that he had social ties to officials within the South Korean embassy.[278] Fefferman testified that he had arranged a meeting in 1975 between Republican aide Edwin Feulner of the Heritage Foundation and South Korean Minister Kim Yung Hwan, to potentially put together a group of congressional aides who would travel to South Korea.[279][278] Hwan was then-station chief for the KCIA.[278]
During his testimony, Fefferman refused to answer nine questions from the subcommittee, saying that they violated his constitutional rights to freedom of religion and association.[280] The subcommittee recommended that Fefferman be cited for contempt of Congress.[278][280][281] Fefferman, speaking to The Michigan Daily in 1980, said the subcommittee's recommendations were never taken up, and no charges were pressed.[282]
Defamation lawsuit against the Daily Mail
In 1978, the Daily Mail, a British tabloid newspaper, published an article with the headline: "The Church That Breaks Up Families".[283][284] The article accused the Unification Church of brainwashing and separating families. The British Unification Church's director Dennis Orme filed a libel suit against the Daily Mail and Associated Newspapers, its parent company, resulting in one of the longest civil actions in British legal history – lasting six months.[283][285][286] Orme and the Unification Church lost the libel case, the appeal case, and were refused permission to take their case to the House of Lords.[286] The original case heard 117 witnesses, including American anti-cult psychiatrist Margaret Thaler Singer.[283] In the original case, the Unification Church was ordered to pay Associated Newspapers GB£750,000 in costs which was maintained after appeal.[287] The jury of the original case not only awarded Associated Newspapers costs, but it and the judge requested that the Attorney General re-examine the Unification Church's charitable status, which after a lengthy investigation from 1986 to 1988 was not removed.[288][289] According to George Chryssides, about half of the Unification Church's 500 full-time membership in Britain moved to the United States.[290] The Unification Church sold seven of its twelve principal church centers after the ruling.[291] Other anti-cultists in countries like Germany sought to incorporate the London High Court's decision into law.[286] The Unification Church has won other libel and defamation cases in the United Kingdom, including a similar case against The Daily Telegraph.[288]
United States v. Sun Myung Moon
In 1982, Moon was imprisoned in the United States after being found guilty by a jury of willfully filing false Federal income tax returns and conspiracy. (See: United States v. Sun Myung Moon) HSA-UWC members launched a public-relations campaign. Booklets, letters and videotapes were mailed to approximately 300,000 Christian leaders in the United States. Many of them signed petitions protesting the government's case.[144] The American Baptist Churches in the U.S.A, the National Council of Churches, the National Black Catholic Clergy Caucus, and the Southern Christian Leadership Conference filed briefs in support of Moon.[145] In 1982, Moon was convicted in the United States of filing false federal income tax returns and conspiracy: see United States v. Sun Myung Moon. He served 13 months of the sentence at the Federal Correctional Institution, Danbury in Danbury, Connecticut.[292][293] The case was protested as a case of selective prosecution and a threat to religious freedom by, among others, Jerry Falwell, head of Moral Majority, Joseph Lowery, head of the Southern Christian Leadership Conference, Harvey Cox a professor of Divinity at Harvard, and Eugene McCarthy, United States Senator and former Democratic Party presidential candidate.[294]
Crown of Peace event in Washington DC
On March 23, 2004, at a ceremony in the Dirksen Senate Office Building, in Washington, D.C., Moon crowned himself with what was called the "Crown of Peace".[295][296] Lawmakers who attended included Senator Mark Dayton (D-Minn.), Representatives Roscoe Bartlett (R-Md.) and Elijah Cummings (D-Md.), as well as former Representative Walter Fauntroy (D-D.C.). Key organizers of the event included George Augustus Stallings Jr., a former Roman Catholic priest who had been married by Moon, and Michael Jenkins, the president of the Unification Church of the United States at that time.[295] Rep. Danny K. Davis (D-Ill.) played an active role in the ceremony. The New York Times, in 2008, suggested that the participation of federal elected officials in this event was a possible violation of the principle of separation of church and state in United States law.[296]
Spiritual sales
The National Network of Lawyers against spiritual sales, a network of 300 attorneys accuses the Unification Church of engaging in "Spiritual Sales" , alleging that it has made its adherents to invest large amounts of money to the point of bankruptcy. The Unification Church's President in Japan, Tomihiro Tanaka, stated trouble with illegal solicitation and large donation were a thing of the past and since 2009 has had no trouble due to stress on legal compliance.[297][298] The Network of Lawyers, which was set up in 1987 to impose countermeasures to what has been perceived as damages caused by the Unification church[297], amounting to 123.7 billion yen, based on statistics compiled by the association's lawyers between 1987 and 2021, obtained via 34,537 complaints submitted to Government Consumer centers. The network reported that victims were cheated out of about 300 million yen in 2021. [299] One of the lawyers, Hiroshi Yamaguchi, accused the Unification Church of causing considerable pain to the families of those who donated[297] Another lawyer, Yasuo Kawai, accused Japanese politicians and administrators of taking no action against the Unification Church, which he said disintegrates families, for more than 30 years.[300] Kito Masaki called for Japan's National Diet (parliament) to conduct a bipartisan investigation of the case.[301][302][303] In 1984 Yoshikazu Soejima, a senior official of the Unification Church, revealed inside information about the church in the monthly magazine Bungei Shunjū released on June 10, 1984. According to Soejima, in the 1970s about 200 billion yen in donations from Japanese believers were sent to South Korea.[304][citation needed] According to the Washington Post, about 800 million dollars were transferred from Japan to the United States from 1975 to 1984. Soejima stated he had been attacked outside his home in Tokyo and according to police reports, stabbed repeatedly. At the time fo the attack, he claimed to have been preparing an article critical of Moon, that was later published in the Japanese magazine Bungeishunju. During an interview, Soejima unbuttoned his shirt to show scars on his left bicep, neck and chest, which he claimed were from the attack, however no one had been arrested.[304][305]According to Hiroaki Soejima and Inoue in an interview with the Washington Post, the religious icons, marble vases, miniature treasure pagodas and other religious icons that were represented as having supernatural power, were distributed by Happy World Inc., an importing firm based in Tokyo that they said was connected to the church. Hiroshi Sakazume, the Japanese Unification Church's director general of public relations at the time denied that the church had any relationship with Happy World, claiming in their view that "the Unification Church has nothing to do with sales activities," . "We don't know what each church member is doing. But as a church, we don't do any sales . . . . Happy World is a different company, a totally separate organization."[305]
Up to 70% of the Unification Church's income was provided by Japanese devotees. Their fund-raising activities were described as "scanning obituaries" which was followed up by "going door-to-door" instructing people, in particular grieving elderly people, to go to their banks to collect money for the Unification Church on behalf of their deceased loved ones, in order for them to "ascend to heaven".[306] According to Busan Presbyterian University professor Tak Ji-il, "On the surface, they are fighting over religious principles but they are actually fighting over money."[307] One of Moon's sons, Kook Jin Moon, denied the church was pressuring its Japanese members to make large donations to save the spirits of their deceased loved ones, stating instead the members informed him it was their forebears that had instructed them to make large donations in an interview he conducted.[306][308][309]
In civil cases, Japanese courts have issued a number of rulings ordering the Unification Church to pay compensation to the plaintiffs, saying its missionary work is illegal.[310] Criminal cases related to the Unification Church have also occurred. In 2009, the Tokyo District Court sentenced Unification Church members to prison for forcing victims to buy expensive seals. The court ruled that the missionary work was a pernicious act of forcing its victims to buy a seal immediately after instigating their anxiety by linking their worries to their long-time ancestral pasts.[311]
According to the Japanese Communist Party newspaper Akahata, for the Unification Church, Japan has a history of aggression against Korea, therefore has an obligation to serve Korea, and as atonement, internally known as "indemnity", collection of money by "Fortune telling fraud"（霊感商法） is imposed.[312][313] According to Shoichi Fujita of the Religious Information Research Center and the Zenkoku genriundo higaisha fubo no kai (literally, National Association of Parents of Victims of the Moonism, 全国原理運動被害者父母の会) – an organization formed by the parents of Unification Church members – the Unification Church's doctrines make Japanese people the target of its fundraising efforts by disseminating a doctrine which depicts Korea as "the Adam nation" and Japan as "the Eve nation" that committed sins,[314] and therefore obliged to pay money and send people to Korea.[315][316] Moon's theology is that Korea is the Adam country, the home of the ruling race destined to rule the world, and Japan is the Eve country, subordinate to Korea. The church preached that Moon was appointed to save humanity after Eve fell from grace by having sexual relations with Satan.[306] According to Yoshifu Arita, a former journalist and member of the House of Councillors who is investigating the Unification Church, it is taking advantage of Japanese young people's sense of guilt for Japan's 40-year colonial rule of Korea (1905–1945) and defrauding them of money.[317]
Legislation to restrict donations to religious organizations and provide relief to victims
On 9 December 2022, Taro Kono, Minister of State for Consumer Affairs and Food Safety,[318] told the special committee on consumer affairs of the House of Councillors, that his personal understanding placed the Unification Church under the category of "cult",[319][320] a label Sakurai Yoshihide explains, is given in Japan to groups engaged in antisocial activities of a fanatical nature,[321] the view held by Kono for such classification[320] with experts in the field focusing on religious minorities, while the media concentrates on whether those groups commit any crimes The Unification Church, according to Yoshihide, is no longer considered a religious minority due to its numbers.[321]
On 10 December 2022, the House of Representatives of Japan and the House of Councillors passed two bills to restrict the activities of religious organizations such as the Unification Church and provide relief to victims.[322][323][need quotation to verify] These bills were designed to address social problems caused by the Unification Church, and the political parties and the press saw these bills as a way to restrict "cults" in the process leading up to the legislation.[324][325][326][327]
The new law stipulates prohibited acts and duty of care for juridical persons, including religious organizations, when soliciting donations. Prohibited acts include the following: a juridical persons must not induce the donor to borrow money or sell his/her home or fields in order to raise the funds for the donation, a juridical person must not accompany the donor to a place from which the donor is unable to leave, and a juridical person must not prevent the donor from consulting with someone. The duty of care is that the juridical person shall not suppress the free will of the soliciting subject and that the solicitation shall not make life difficult for the soliciting subject's family. If a juridical person commits a prohibited act, a correction order is issued, and a person who repeatedly violates the order is subject to imprisonment for up to one year and a fine of up to 1 million yen. If a juridical person violates its duty of care, the name of the juridical person will be made public. It was also stipulated that contracts for donations or sales of goods through "spiritual sales" (reikan shōhō, 霊感商法) can be revoked up to 10 years after the contract is concluded and up to three years after the target of the solicitation becomes aware of the damage. In addition, it is also stipulated that donations contracted while the target of the solicitation is under brainwashing can be canceled. The law also stipulates that the victim's family can also revoke the donation due to improper solicitation, and that the victim or his or her family can claim from the juridical person the amount of past damages as well as living expenses and child support that the child or spouse is entitled to in the future. The new law then defines spiritual sales, in which a contract can be rescinded, as soliciting donations or selling goods after taking advantage of the anxiety of the target of the solicitation or causing the target of the solicitation to become anxious.[322][323][328][329][330]
These bills were supported by the ruling Liberal Democratic Party and Komeito, and opposition parties the Constitutional Democratic Party of Japan (CDP), Nippon Ishin no Kai, and Democratic Party for the People, and opposed by the opposition parties the Japanese Communist Party (JCP) and the Reiwa Shinsengumi.[323][need quotation to verify] The CDP had opposed the bills, seeking legislation to more strictly restrict religious organizations, but switched to support it after a clause to review the law two years later was specified in the bill. According to the CDP and some Unification Church victims, legislation to restrict religious organizations even more strictly is needed. The JCP had proposed another bill to restrict religious organizations and therefore opposed the bills.[327][need quotation to verify]
Support for North Korea's development of nuclear weapons
According to Defense Intelligence Agency (DIA) reports in August and September 1994, Moon donated 450 billion yen to Kim Il Sung during his stay in North Korea from November 30, 1991, to December 7, 1992. Those same DIA reports explained an "economic cooperation" for the reconstruction of North Korea's economy was in place. This included establishing a joint venture developing tourism at Kimkangsan, investing in the development of the Tumangang River, in addition to investing in the construction of the "light industry" base located in Wonsan.[331][332] Most of the money was said to have been donated to the Unification Church by Japanese believers.[333][334] According to the former chief executive of Pyeonghwa Motors, a Unification Church auto company, the money collected from Japanese devotees was first transferred to South Korea and money laundered, then transferred to Hong Kong and finally to North Korea. He said he had a close relationship with Ju Kyu-chang, a senior member of the Workers' Party of Korea and its weapons development chief.[335][need quotation to verify] According to Baek Seung-joo, a former South Korean vice defense minister, has analyzed that money donated by Japanese followers of the Unification Church was diverted to North Korea's nuclear development and development of intercontinental ballistic missiles.[335][need quotation to verify] According to Masuo Oe, who was the public relations director of the Unification Church, when Moon said to Kim Il Sung in a meeting, "Please be my brother", Kim Il Sung replied, "Sure, why not?". According to him, believers heard this anecdote and admired that the Messiah had brought Satan to his knees with the power of love. This was a symbolic event that marked a major shift in the anti-communist policies of the Unification Church.[336]
According to a 2016 South Korean Defense Ministry parliamentary report, a Tokyo-run company[vague] operated by members of the Unification Church sold a Russian Golf II-class submarine still loaded with missile launchers to North Korea in 1994, disguised as scrap metal, and the technology was then diverted to North Korea's development of submarine-launched ballistic missiles. The Unification Church has denied having any relationship with the company.[337]
Renaming (Japan)
In 1997, the Japanese Unification Church applied to the Agency for Cultural Affairs (ACA), a department directly under the Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology, to change its name from "The Holy Spirit Association for the Unification of World Christianity" (世界基督教統一神霊協会) to "Family Federation for World Peace and Unification" (世界平和統一家庭連合). According to the then chief of the Religious Affairs Division, Kihei Maekawa, the application was rejected by the ACA because the church was involved in civil lawsuits under its old name at the time. In 2015, while Hakubun Shimomura was Minister of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology under the Third Abe Cabinet, the Unification Church again submitted an application to change its name and this time it was approved. Shimomura denied any involvement in the approval process, explaining that the decision was made by the head of the ACA, but acknowledged he had received reports about it and that this was unusual. The 2015 head of the ACA confirmed Shimomura's description of events.[338][339]
Assassination of Shinzo Abe
The Unification Church has historically had a close relationship with the conservative Liberal Democratic Party, which was founded by Nobusuke Kishi and later led by his grandson, Shinzo Abe, then prime minister of Japan.[340][341][342][343] In 2019, the National Network of Lawyers Against Spiritual Sales released a document protesting congratulatory messages sent by Abe to events organized by the Unification Church and its affiliates because they feared such messages enhanced the church's authority and encouraged what they considered its "anti-social activities".[310][344]
In 2022, Abe was assassinated by Tetsuya Yamagami, who stated that he resented the Unification Church because his mother was "forced" to make a large donation to it,[345] a claim the Church denied.[346] She joined the Unification Church in 1998, and sold the land she inherited from her father along with the house where she lived with her 3 children. In June 1999, she donated about 100 million yen (US$720,000) to the Unification Church, half of which was said to have been returned according to Reuters,[346] leading to her family's bankruptcy in 2002 and significantly affecting their family, according to Yamagami.[347][need quotation to verify] Financially troubled, Yamagami was unable to enter university despite graduating from a prestigious high school. His brother and his father would later commit suicide. Yamagami stated that his original plan was to assassinate Hak Ja Han, the widow of Sun Myung Moon and the current leader of the UC. However, he gave up his plan because he could not get close to her.[348][349] He believes Abe and his grandfather, Nobusuke Kishi, spread the Unification Church in Japan and decided to kill Abe after discovering online that Abe had sent video messages to UC-related organizations.[350][need quotation to verify]
Unification Church spokesperson Tomihiro Tanaka stated in a press conference that in the past it had had problems with its followers due to illegal solicitations and large donations. He claimed that there has been no trouble between the Unification Church and its followers since 2009, when it began to emphasize legal compliance.[297][need quotation to verify] On 11 July 2022 the Unification Church issued a press release stating donation amounts are determined by individual members.[340][341][342][343][need quotation to verify] Chung Hwan Kwak, the Honorary President of the Global Peace Foundation,[351][352] who had long held a position second to Sun Myung Moon in the Unification Church and left it in 2009 after internal strife, apologized on behalf of the Unification Church. He said that the church was responsible for the assassination of Abe.[353] According to Kwak, a wave of bankruptcies, divorces and suicides among Japanese believers had prompted him to attempt to normalize Japan's status as an "economic force" in 2001, but his attempt was thwarted by strong opposition from other church leaders. The Unification Church later denied Kwak's claim, saying that it was Kwak who called for the transfer of Japanese money to the church headquarters.[354][355][citation needed]
The National Public Safety Commission chair Satoshi Ninoyu instructed police authorities to set up a panel to investigate the security lapses which may have been involved in Abe's death.[356] The Commission chair was among several elected officials who promoted a Unification Church event in 2021.[357][need quotation to verify] Japan's main opposition party, the Constitutional Democratic Party of Japan, and two other opposition parties, the Democratic Party for the People and the Japanese Communist Party, have said that they plan to launch their own investigations into the Unification Church's political influence and connections in Japanese politics.[358] On August 31, 2022, the ruling Liberal Democratic Party (LDP), of which Abe was a member, announced that it would no longer have any relationships with the Unification Church and its related organizations. The Liberal Democratic Party has announced that it will expel its members if they do not break any ongoing relationships with the Unification Church.[359] Fumio Kishida, Japan's prime minister and president of the LDP, stated in October 2022 that the Japanese government would start an investigation into the extent of Abe's relationship with the Unification Church.[360][361][362]
Esotericism
The Unification Church is sometimes said to be esoteric in that it keeps some of its doctrines secret from non-members,[363][364][365] a practice that is sometimes called "heavenly deception".[366] In 1979, critics D. Tingle and R. Fordyce commented: "How different the openness of Christianity is to the attitude of Reverend Moon and his followers who are often reluctant to reveal to the public many of their basic doctrines."[367] Since the 1990s, many Unification texts that were formerly regarded as esoteric have been posted on the Family Federation for World Peace and Unification's official websites.[368]
Child adoption
The Unification Church came under investigation by Japan's Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare for allegations about organizing children being transferred between members' families without authorization from the prefectural government. The authorization requirement came into effect in 2018 and if convicted of violation the offender would face imprisonment or a fine. The church reported that there were 31 known adoptions between 2018 and 2022, when questioned by the welfare ministry. Under the Japanese Civil Code, adoptions involving minors require permission from family courts. The issue at hand also raises questions whether family courts' screening was sufficient.[369] The church denies the allegation that they act as an agent in the arrangement, but says that the child adoptions happen between families privately.[370][371] In publications targeting its followers, the church stated that once families agree on adoption, they were to report it to the group's family education bureau. The welfare ministry indicated that such a rule makes the group perceived as mediating adoptions. The welfare ministry's investigation into the matter has no enforcing power, however, and it doesn't know in detail about when adoptions took place or which families were involved.
At the same time, the religious group insists that there has been no organized involvement for about 20 years and that adoptions have been personal unions between followers.[369]
The ministry requested that the church revise their teachings about children to comply with Japan's child welfare laws. Some adoptees complained to the ministry and media that they are emotionally traumatized after learning their adoptions were religiously motivated.[372][373][need quotation to verify] On February 1, 2023, the Unification Church of Japan revised their believers' handbook to remove references to child adoption.[374]
The Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare submitted several questionnaires about the child adoption practice to the Unification Church between November and December 2022,[375] but in the second inquiry the Unification Church refused to answer more than half of the questions, and sent a letter of protest to the ministry.[376]
Controversy in South Korea
In South Korea the Unification Church has been criticized for supporting the interests of Japan over those of South Korea. South Korean media reported links between the UC and Japanese conservatives, referring to them as Chinil (친일) or Sin-chinil (신친일). Some South Korean media reported a connection between Yoon Suk-yeol's pro-Japanese foreign policy and the UC.[377][378]
"Crazy for God"
In The Way of God's Will, a collection of sayings popular among church members, Moon is quoted as saying: "We leaders should leave the tradition that we have become crazy for God."[379] In 1979 Unification Church critic Christopher Edwards titled a memoir about his experiences in the six months he spent as a church member: Crazy for God: The Nightmare of Cult Life.[380]
Related organizations and groups
Moon believed in a literal Kingdom of God on earth to be brought about by human effort, motivating his establishment of numerous groups, some that are not strictly religious in their purposes.[381][181] Moon was not directly involved with managing the day-to-day activities of the organizations that he indirectly oversaw, yet all of them attribute the inspiration behind their work to his leadership and teachings.[14][382][383]
See also
References
- ^ Eileen Barker. Abstract of "The Unification Church: A Kaleidoscopic Introduction." Society Register 2, no. 2 (2018): 19–62.
- ^ Eileen Barker. "The Unification Church: A Kaleidoscopic Introduction." Society Register 2, no. 2 (2018): 19–62.
- ^ "Sun Myung Moon | Founder of Unification Church | Britannica". www.britannica.com. Retrieved 15 August 2023.
- ^ a b c Moon At Twilight: Amid scandal, the Unification Church has a strange new mission 2020-02-16 at the Wayback Machine, Peter Maass New Yorker Magazine, September 14, 1998.
- ^ a b Bednarowski, Mary Farrell (1995). New Religions and the Theological Imagination in America. Indiana University Press. p. 103. ISBN 978-0-253-20952-8. Retrieved 28 December 2008.
- ^ Barker, Eileen, The Making of a Moonie: Choice Or Brainwashing? Modern Revivals in Sociology, illustrated, reprint, revised ed. (Gregg Revivals, 1993)[page needed] ISBN 978-0751201369
- ^ Bromley, David G. and Anson D. Shupe, Jr., "Moonies" in America: Cult, Church, and Crusade, edited by David G. Bromley, Sage Library of Social Research (Sage, 1979)
- ^ a b Goodman, Walter (21 January 1992). "Review/Television; Sun Myung Moon Changes Robes". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved 10 August 2022.
- ^ a b Diamond, Sara (1989). Spiritual Warfare: The Politics of the Christian Right. South End Press. ISBN 978-0-89608-361-5.
- ^ Kent, Stephen A., From Slogans to Mantras: Social Protest and Religious Conversion in the Late Vietnam War Era (Syracuse University Press, 2001), 168.
- ^ a b Fisher, Marc; Leen, Jeff (23 November 1997). "A Church in Flux Is Flush With Cash". The Washington Post. pp. A01. Retrieved 10 August 2022.
- ^ Yamamoto, J. I., 1995, Unification Church, Grand Rapids, Michigan: Zondervan Publishing House ISBN 0-310-70381-6 Excerpt: 2012-02-10 at the Wayback Machine
- ^ Sun Myung Moon forms new political party to merge divided Koreas 2013-09-01 at the Wayback Machine Church and State, May 2003
- ^ a b Swatos, William H. Jr. (1998). Encyclopedia of religion and society. Walnut Creek, CA: AltaMira Press. ISBN 978-0-7619-8956-1. Retrieved 10 February 2018.
- ^ Moon, Sun Myung (2011). "Chapter three, part "A Church with No Denomination"" (PDF). As a peace-loving global citizen. [Washington, D.C.]: Washington Times Foundation. pp. 121–122. ISBN 978-0-615-39377-3. OCLC 638962627.
- ^ a b c Barker, Eileen (3 September 2012). . CNN. Archived from the original on 29 August 2019. Retrieved 10 August 2022.
- ^ U. S. Department of the Army (2001). Religious Requirements and Practices of Certain Selected Groups: A Handbook for Chaplains. The Minerva Group, Inc. pp. 1-41 to 1-47. ISBN 978-0-89875-607-4.
- ^ Miller, Timothy (1995). America's Alternative Religions. State University of New York Press. pp. 223, 414. ISBN 978-0-7914-2398-1.
- ^ "Church leaders unite against Moonies". PacNews. Pacific Island News Agency Service. 17 February 2006.
- ^ Enroth, Ronald M. (2005). A Guide To New Religious Movements. InterVarsity Press. pp. 69, 72. ISBN 978-0-8308-2381-9.
- ^ Shupe, Anson D.; Misztal, Bronislaw (1998). Religion, Mobilization, and Social Action. Praeger. pp. 197, 213, 215. ISBN 978-0-275-95625-7.
- ^ Ofcom (20 February 2006). . Broadcast Bulletin. www.ofcom.org.uk (54). Archived from the original on 30 March 2010. Retrieved 28 September 2009.
- ^ Helvarg, David (2004). The War Against the Greens. Johnson Books. p. 211. ISBN 978-1-55566-328-5.
- ^ Hatch, Walter (13 February 1989). "Big names lend luster to group's causes – Church leader gains legitimacy among U.S. conservatives". The Seattle Times. Seattle Times Company. p. A1.
- ^ Shupe, Anson D.; Misztal, Bronislaw (1998). Religion, Mobilization, and Social Action. Praeger. pp. 197, 213, 215. ISBN 978-0-275-95625-7.
- ^ Jenkins, Philip (2000). Mystics and Messiahs: Cults and New Religions in American History. Oxford University Press. pp. 28, 200. ISBN 0-19-512744-7.
- ^ Petri, Alexandra E. (26 September 2018). "Unification Parents Are Primary Matchmakers for Their Children". The New York Times. Retrieved 14 September 2022.
- ^ . Archived from the original on 26 April 2012. Retrieved 18 July 2018.
- ^ a b "BBC News | Unification Church | Mass Moonie Marriage in the US". BBC News. Retrieved 9 August 2022.
- ^ "김백문의 기독교근본원리 연재 1 – 국역 서론". 기독교포털뉴스 (in Korean). 10 September 2021. Retrieved 9 August 2022.
- ^ "교회와신앙". www.amennews.com. Retrieved 9 August 2022.
- ^ "淫教のメシア・文鮮明伝" 萩原遼編
- ^ Greene, Richard; Kwon, K.J.; Botelho, Greg (3 September 2013). "Rev. Moon, religious and political figure, dies in South Korea at 92". CNN. Retrieved 16 June 2013.
- ^ a b Brown, Emma (2 September 2012). . The Washington Post. ISSN 0740-5421. Archived from the original on 28 September 2013. Retrieved 12 June 2013.
- ^ . The Irish Times. 3 September 2012. Archived from the original on 4 September 2012. Retrieved 4 September 2012.
- ^ , Time, 15 October 1973.
- ^ "Czechs, Now "Naively" Seeking Direction, See Dangers in Cults", The New York Times, February 14, 1996
- ^ "Unification Church Gains Respect in Latin America", The New York Times, November 24, 1996
- ^ The Moonies in Moscow: a second coming?, Green Left Weekly, 28 May 1997.
- ^ a b A Less Secular Approach 2012-02-29 at the Wayback Machine, The Saint Petersburg Times, June 7, 2002
- ^ Schmemann, Serge (28 July 1993). "Religion Returns to Russia, With a Vengeance". The New York Times.
- ^ Quebedeaux, Richard (1982). Lifestyle: Conversations with Members of Unification Church – "Quebedeaux, Richard" – Google Книги. ISBN 9780932894182. Retrieved 23 May 2012.
- ^ Reed, Christoper (2 September 2012). "The Rev Sun Myung Moon obituary Korean founder of the Unification Church – the Moonies". The Guardian. London. Retrieved 10 September 2012.
- ^ "Japan". U.S. Department of State. Retrieved 19 January 2019.
- ^ Dole meeting with Moon aide called cordial, Lawrence Journal-World, February 24, 1976
- ^ a b Sushi and Rev. Moon: How Americans' growing appetite for sushi is helping to support his controversial church Chicago Tribune, April 11, 2006
- ^ a b . The Columbia Journalism Review. 24 November 2003. Archived from the original on 28 July 2012. Retrieved 2 February 2008.
- ^ rSun Myung Moon Paper Appears in Washington from The New York Times
- ^ Global Peace Festival stirs Japan United Press International November 17, 2008
- ^ "Yahoo Finance – Business Finance, Stock Market, Quotes, News". finance.yahoo.com. Retrieved 19 January 2019.
- ^ Shapira, Ian (3 November 2010). "Moon group buys back Washington Times". The Washington Post. p. C1.
- ^ Patrick Hickey Tahoe Boy: A journey back home John, Maryland, Seven Locks Press (2009) ISBN 978-0-9822293-6-1 pp. 163–168
- ^ EVOLUTION IN EUROPE; New Flock for Moon Church: The Changing Soviet Student from The New York Times
- ^ Staff (19 June 1993). "Moon's wife to speak in Lawrence". The Kansas City Star. The Kansas City Star Co. p. E10.
- ^ Cuda, Amanda (28 December 2004). "Event works for understanding through friendships". Connecticut Post. p. Section: Womanwise.
- ^ Peterson, Thair (21 March 1998). "Bridging the Interracial Gap". Long Beach Press-Telegram. p. A3.
- ^ Stymied in U.S., Moon's Church Sounds a Retreat, Marc Fisher and Jeff Leen, The Washington Post, November 24, 1997
- ^ Introvigne, 2000, page 19
- ^ Goodman, Walter (21 January 1992). "Review/Television; Sun Myung Moon Changes Robes". The New York Times.
- ^ The same old game 2009-02-15 at the Wayback Machine, Al-Ahram, November 12–18, 1998, "The Washington Times is a mouthpiece for the ultra-conservative Republican right, unquestioning supporters of Israel's Likud government. The newspaper is owned by Sun Myung Moon, originally a native of North Korea and head of the Unification Church, whose ultra-right leanings make him a ready ally for Netanyahu. Whether or not Netanyahu is personally acquainted with Moon is unclear, though there is no doubt that he has established close friendships with several staff members of The Washington Times, whose editorial policy is rabidly anti-Arab, anti-Muslim, and pro-Israel."
- ^ Pollack, Andrew (15 September 1995). "Bushes Speak at Tokyo Rally of Group Linked to Moon Church". The New York Times.
- ^ Brozan, Nadine (15 July 1995). "CHRONICLE". The New York Times.
- ^ Sanger, David E. (17 September 1995). "SEPT. 10–16; Mr. Bush's Asian Tour". The New York Times.
- ^ Rev. Moon and the United Nations: A Challenge for the NGO Community, Harold Paine and Birgit Gratzer, Global Policy Forum
- ^ "Welcome to WANGO, World Association of Non-Governmental Organizations". www.wango.org. Retrieved 19 January 2019.
- ^ In Ban's UN, Sun Myung Moon's Paper is Praised, While Gambari Raises Him Funds, WFP Demurs Inner City Press, June 5, 2007
- ^ a b "CNN – Breaking News, Latest News and Videos". CNN. Retrieved 19 January 2019.
- ^ a b Families Arrive in Washington For March Called by Farrakhan, The New York Times, October 16, 2000
- ^ a b c Clarkson, Frederick (9 October 2000). "Million Moon March". Salon. Retrieved 5 November 2009.
- ^ a b "Moonies" launch a political party in S Korea,The Independent (South Africa), March 10, 2003
- ^ Universal peace federation, Middle east peace initiative 2013-01-17 at the Wayback Machine
- ^ Andrea Noble, The Gazette, Bowie resident pushes for peace 4 March 2016 at the Wayback Machine, Gazette.net, Jan. 8,
- ^ Yoon, Sangwon (15 August 2012). "Unification Church Says Leader Moon Is 'Gravely Ill'". Bloomberg. Retrieved 16 August 2012.
- ^ Unification Church founder dies, Korea Herald, 2012-9-3
- ^ a b "자유게시판". Unikorea.go.kr. Retrieved 23 May 2012.
- ^ a b "mk 'ş˝ş ĹëŔĎąłŔ°˝ÉŔÇŔ§ °łĂÖ..łťłâ ĹëŔĎąłŔ° šćÇâ źłÁ¤". News.mk.co.kr. 28 December 2006. Retrieved 23 May 2012.
- ^ Nepalese Constituent Assembly 2012-03-02 at the Wayback Machine
- ^ "News in Nepal: Fast, Full & Factual". Myrepublica.Com. 19 May 2012. Retrieved 4 September 2012.
- ^ Unificationists in the Voting Booth
- ^ "Hak Ja Han Moon calls for South Korea Japan Solidarity". The Washington Times. 6 October 2019.
- ^ a b The Washington Times, 11-22-2020, Rally for Hoope Draws Million Attendees
- ^ Khmer Times: "Three leaders chosen to receive Peace Prize"
- ^ . Archived from the original on 14 September 2021. Retrieved 14 September 2021.
- ^ Yeonhap News – Trump: "My greatest achievement during my presidency was contributing to the construction of a new path between the two Koreas."
- ^ Huffington Post: "Trump hails Unification Church"
- ^ Woodward, Alex (21 September 2021). "Trump gives virtual speech to event linked to controversial religious "cult" on 9/11 anniversary". The Independent. Retrieved 18 July 2022.
- ^ Trinidad and Tobago Newsday: "Carmona, Trump call for Korean reunification"
- ^ Akahata (14 October 2006). "Prime Minister Abe sent congratulatory telegrams to Unification Church". Japan Press Weekly (japan-press.co.jp).
- ^ The Guardian – Japan PM Fumio Kishida popularity dives – Unification Church
- ^ John Bowker, 2011, The Message and the Book, UK, Atlantic Books, pp. 13–14
- ^ a b Korean Moon: Waxing of Waning? 16 February 2012 at the Wayback Machine, Leo Sandon Jr., Theology Today, Vol 35, No 2, July 1978.
- ^ a b c Lužný, Dušan; Václavík, David (1997). [Unification Church] (in Czech). Archived from the original on 20 August 2007. Retrieved 14 October 2022.
- ^ Freddy Davis: The Unification Church/Moonies, Marketfaith.org, 25 November 2014.
- ^ Sontag, Frederick (1977). Sun Myung Moon and the Unification Church. Nashville: Abingdon Press. pp. 102–105. ISBN 0-687-40622-6.
- ^ Chryssides, 1991. p. 99
- ^ Yamamoto, J. ISamu (2016). Unification Church. Zondervan.
- ^ . Archived from the original on 28 September 2007. Retrieved 24 June 2007.
- ^ Wakin, Daniel J. (2 September 2012). "Rev. Sun Myung Moon, 92, Unification Church Founder, Dies". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved 2 January 2013.
- ^ "NEW YORK DAY BY DAY; Wedding Day for 4,000". The New York Times. 1 July 1982.
- ^ Marriage by the numbers; Moon presides as 6,500 couples wed in S. Korea 2008-10-08 at the Wayback Machine Peter Maass The Washington Post October 31, 1988
- ^ The men and women entered a large room, where Moon began matching couples by pointing at them."NY Daily News "In the Unification tradition, romantic liaisons are forbidden until the members are deemed by Mr. Moon to be spiritually ready to be matched at a huge gathering where he points future spouses out to one another. His followers believe that his decisions are based on his ability to discern their suitability and see their future descendants. Many are matched with people of other races and nationalities, in keeping with Mr. Moon's ideal of unifying all races and nations in the Unification Church. Though some couples are matched immediately before the mass wedding ceremonies, which are held every two or three years, most have long engagements during which they are typically posted in different cities or even continents, and get to know one another through letters."The New York Times "Many were personally matched by Moon, who taught that romantic love led to sexual promiscuity, mismatched couples and dysfunctional societies. Moon's preference for cross-cultural marriages also meant that couples often shared no common language."Manchester Guardian "Moon's death Sept. 2 and funeral Saturday signaled the end of the random pairings that helped make Moon's Unification Church famous – and infamous – a generation ago." Washington Post "Many of the couples who married at mass weddings were hand-picked by Moon from photos. It led to some strange pairs such as a 71-year-old African Catholic archbishop who wed a 43-year-old Korean acupuncturist. In 1988 Moon entered the Guinness Book of Records when he married 6,516 identically dressed couples at Seoul's Olympic Stadium. Moonie newly-weds were forbidden to sleep together for 40 days to prove their marriage was on a higher plane. They then had to consummate their marriage in a three-day ritual with the sexual positions stipulated by their leader."Daily Mirror
- ^ Despite controversy, Moon and his church moving into mainstream 2008-07-25 at the Wayback Machine Chicago Tribune, April 11, 2006. 'The church's most spectacular rite remains mass weddings, which the church calls the way "fallen men and women can be engrafted into the true lineage of God."'
- ^ At RFK, Moon Presides Over Mass Wedding, The Washington Post, November 3, 1997.
- ^ 28,000 Couples Gather for Rev. Moon Rites, The New York Times, November 30, 1997
- ^ Lucas, Phillip Charles; Robbins, Thomas (2004). New Religious Movements in the Twenty-first Century. Routledge. p. 320. ISBN 978-0-415-96577-4. Retrieved 28 December 2008.
- ^ Unification Church pres sees smaller mass weddings 2009-03-22 at the Wayback Machine, The Monitor (Uganda), 30 December 2008, "Moon said the church does not give its wedding blessing to same sex couples."
- ^ Goodstein, Laurie (28 November 1997). "35,000 Couples Are Invited To a Blessing by Rev. Moon". The New York Times. Retrieved 28 December 2008.
- ^ Children of Moon church's mass-wedding age face a crossroads, The Washington Post, January 3, 2009
- ^ (PDF). tparents.org. Archived from the original (PDF) on 18 May 2021. Retrieved 11 November 2022.
- ^ Introduction to New and Alternative Religions in America: African diaspora traditions and other American innovations, Volume 5 of Introduction to New and Alternative Religions in America, W. Michael Ashcraft, Greenwood Publishing Group, 2006, ISBN 0-275-98717-5, ISBN 978-0-275-98717-6, page 180
- ^ Exploring New Religions, Issues in contemporary religion, George D. Chryssides, Continuum International Publishing Group, 2001ISBN 0-8264-5959-5, ISBN 978-0-8264-5959-6 p. 1
- ^ Exploring the climate of doom 2012-04-23 at the Wayback Machine, Rich Lowry, 2009-12-19 'The phrase "doomsday cult" entered our collective vocabulary after John Lofland published his 1966 study, "Doomsday Cult: A Study of Conversion, Proselytization, and Maintenance of Faith." Lofland wrote about the Unification Church.'
- ^ Conversion 2012-01-21 at the Wayback Machine, Unification Church 2012-01-13 at the Wayback Machine, Encyclopedia of Religion and Society, Hartford Institute for Religion Research, Hartford Seminary
- ^ a b Frederick E. Sontag dies at 84; Pomona College philosophy professor, Los Angeles Times, June 20, 2009
- ^ a b Who is this Pied Piper of Religion?, St. Petersburg Times, February 4, 1978
- ^ a b Moon: an objective look at his theology, Boca Raton News, 1977-11-25
- ^ , William Rusher, National Review, December 19, 1986.
- ^ The Market for Martyrs 2012-01-11 at the Wayback Machine, Laurence Iannaccone, George Mason University, 2006, "One of the most comprehensive and influential studies was The Making of a Moonie: Choice or Brainwashing? by Eileen Barker (1984). Barker could find no evidence that Moonie recruits were ever kidnapped, confined, or coerced. Participants at Moonie retreats were not deprived of sleep; the lectures were not "trance-inducing"; and there was not much chanting, no drugs or alcohol, and little that could be termed "frenzy" or "ecstatic" experience. People were free to leave, and leave they did. Barker's extensive enumerations showed that among the recruits who went so far as to attend two-day retreats (claimed to be Moonie's most effective means of "brainwashing"), fewer than 25% joined the group formore than a week and only 5% remained full-time members one year later. And, of course, most contacts dropped out before attending a retreat. Of all those who visited a Moonie centre at least once, not one in two-hundred remained in the movement two years later. With failure rates exceeding 99.5%, it comes as no surprise that full-time Moonie membership in the U.S. never exceeded a few thousand. And this was one of the most New Religious Movements of the era!"
- ^ Oakes, Len "By far the best study of the conversion process is Eileen Barker's The Making of a Moonie [...]" from Prophetic Charisma: The Psychology of Revolutionary Religious Personalities, 1997, ISBN 0-8156-0398-3
- ^ Storr, Anthony Dr. Feet of clay: a study of gurus 1996 ISBN 0-684-83495-2
- ^ Past Winners 2010-02-06 at the Wayback Machine
- ^ The Coming Deliverer: Millennial Themes in World Religions, Editors: Fiona Bowie, Christopher Deacy Publisher: University of Wales Press, 1997 Original from the University of Virginia Digitized Jun 24, 2008 ISBN 0708313388, 9780708313381
- ^ Kent, Stephen; Krebs, Theresa (1998). "Academic Compromise in the Social Scientific Study of Alternative Religions". Nova Religio. 2 (1): 44–54. doi:10.1525/nr.1998.2.1.44.
- ^ Exposition of the Divine Principle (2nd ed.). Sung Hwa Publishing Co., LTD. 2005. pp. 266–270. ISBN 897132127X.
- ^ Rudin, A. James, 1978 A View of the Unification Church, American Jewish Committee Archives
- ^ Sun Myung Moon Is Criticized by Religious Leaders; Jewish Patrons Enraged, David F. White, The New York Times, December 29, 1976
- ^ Response to A. James Rudin's Report, Unification Church Department of Public Affairs, Daniel C. Holdgeiwe, Johnny Sonneborn, March 1977.
- ^ . Time Magazine. 22 April 1985. Archived from the original on 7 September 2008.
- ^ "Unification Church seen as persecuted", The Milwaukee Sentinel, September 15, 1984, p. 4
- ^ To Bigotry, No Sanction, Mose Durst, 1984
- ^ Guidelines for Members of The Unification Church in Relations with the Jewish People, Peter Ross and Andrew Wilson, March 15, 1989.
- ^ . www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org. Archived from the original on 30 July 2022. Retrieved 26 April 2023.
- ^ Yamamoto, J. 1995, Unification Church, Grand Rapids, Michigan: Zondervan Press, ISBN 0-310-70381-6 p. 40
- ^ Walter Ralston Martin, Ravi K. Zacharias, The Kingdom of the Cults, Bethany House, 2003, ISBN 0764228218 pp. 368–370
- ^ Yamamoto, J. I., 1995, Unification Church, Grand Rapids, Michigan: Zondervan Publishing House ISBN 0-310-70381-6 (Excerpt: 2012-02-10 at the Wayback Machine)
"1. The Unification Theological Seminary- a. The Unification Church has a seminary in Barrytown, New York called The Unification Theological Seminary.
- b. It is used as a theological training center, where members are prepared to be leaders and theologians in the church.
- c. Since many people regard Moon as a cult leader, there is a false impression that this seminary is academically weak.
- d. Moon's seminary, however, has not only attracted a respectable faculty (many of whom are not members of his church), but it also has graduated many students (who are members of his church) who have been accepted into doctoral programs at institutions such as Harvard and Yale."
- ^ Korean Moon: Waxing or Waning 16 February 2012 at the Wayback Machine Leo Sandon Jr. Theology Today, July 1978, "The Unification Church purchased the estate and now administers a growing seminary where approximately 110 Moonies engage in a two-year curriculum which includes biblical studies, church history, philosophy, theology, religious education, and which leads to a Master of Religious Education degree."
- ^ Dialogue with the Moonies 11 December 2008 at the Wayback Machine Rodney Sawatsky, Theology Today, April 1978. "Only a minority of their teachers are Unification devotees; a Jew teaches Old Testament, a Christian instructs in church history and a Presbyterian lectures in theology, and so on. Typical sectarian fears of the outsider are not found among Moonies; truth is one or at least must become one, and understanding can be delivered even by the uninitiated."
- ^ Where have all the Moonies gone? Archived 2012-07-30 at archive.today K. Gordon Neufeld, First Things, March 2008, "While I was studying theology, church history, and the Bible—taught by an eclectic faculty that included a rabbi, a Jesuit priest, and a Methodist minister—most of my young coreligionists were standing on street corners in San Francisco, Boston, and Miami urging strangers to attend a vaguely described dinner."
- ^ Helm, S. Divine Principle and the Second Advent 2008-09-21 at the Wayback Machine Christian Century May 11, 1977 "In fact Moon's adherents differ from previous fringe groups in their quite early and expensive pursuit of respectability, as evidenced by the scientific conventions they have sponsored in England and the U.S. and the seminary they have established in Barrytown, New York, whose faculty is composed not of their own group members but rather of respected Christian scholars."
- ^ New Hope for Dialogue with National Council of Churches of Christ, Chris Antal, February, 2000
- ^ Sontag, Frederick, Sun Myung Moon and the Unification Church, (Abingdon Press, 1977; Korean translation, Pacific Publishing Company, 1981; Japanese translation, Tuttle-Mori Agency, Inc., 1977; German translation, SINUS-Verlag, Krefeld, 1981) ISBN 0-687-40622-6"
- ^ Clear Lake Journal; Congregation Dismisses Its Minister Over Trip, The New York Times, May 25, 1988
- ^ Russian unorthodox The Globe and Mail February 8, 2008.
- ^ a b The Unification Church Aims a Major Public Relations Effort at Christian Leaders Christianity Today April 19, 1985.
- ^ a b Raspberry, William, "Did Unpopular Moonie Get a Fair Trial?", The Washington Post, April 19, 1984
- ^ Fisher, Marc (23 November 1997). "A Church in Flux Is Flush With Cash". The Washington Post. Retrieved 14 November 2007. "Also in 1995, the Women's Federation made another donation that illustrates how Moon supports fellow conservatives. It gave a $3.5 million grant to the Christian Heritage Foundation, which later bought a large portion of Liberty University's debt, rescuing the Rev. Jerry Falwell's Lynchburg, Va., religious school from the brink of bankruptcy."
- ^ Exposition of the Divine Principle 1996 Translation Chapter 3 Eschatology and Human History, accessed September 3, 2010
- ^ Afghanistan: eight years of Soviet occupation, United States Department of State, March 1988, The campaign to target foreign journalists had more tragic results. Two American filmmakers, Lee Shapiro and Jim Lindelof, were apparently killed by a regime attack while traveling with the mujahidin. In 1986, Lindelof had been named paramedic of the year for his efforts training Afghan medical workers. In response to protests, Kabul stated it could not "guarantee the security of foreign subjects" who enter illegally, whose presence it views as "evidence" of "external interference".
- ^ 2 Americans killed in ambush, Pacific Stars and Stripes, October 29, 1987
- ^ Two US journalists reported killed in Afghanistan; details murky, Christian Science Monitor, October 28, 1987 "Two American journalists are believed dead in northwest Afghanistan, diplomatic and resistance forces say here. Filmmaker Lee Shapiro and his soundman, Jim Lindalos, both of New York, were killed Oct. 11, reportedly in a Soviet or Afghan government ambush, according to United States consular officials. However, the resistance group that accompanied the film team has a poor reputation among most informed observers, and doubts have arisen over whether the two Americans did indeed die in an Afghan government or Soviet attack."
- ^ Kaplan, Robert, Soldiers of God : With Islamic Warriors in Afghanistan and Pakistan, New York : Vintage Departures, 2001, p. 170
- ^ Winston, Kimberly (20 June 2016). "Report says list of 'Islamophobic groups' reaches new high". Deseret News. Religion News Service. from the original on 18 April 2020. Retrieved 25 December 2018.
- ^ Nafie, Ibrahim (12–18 November 1998). . Al-Ahram. No. 403. Archived from the original on 15 February 2009.
- ^ a b c As U.S. Media Ownership Shrinks, Who Covers Islam?, Washington Report on Middle East Affairs, December 1997
- ^ Prayers for Minister Farrakhan health, recovery continue 2011-07-11 at the Wayback Machine, Frost Illustrated, January 31, 2007
- ^ Unification Church of America History by Lloyd Pumphrey
- ^ Dempsey, John (1 June 2007). "American Life TV targets baby boomers". Variety. Retrieved 9 October 2007.
- ^ American Life TV targets baby boomers: Channel airing Clooney's Darfur docu Variety, June 1, 2007
- ^ Beah, Ishmael (3 May 2007). "The 2007 Time 100". Time. Retrieved 19 January 2019 – via content.time.com.
- ^ Clooney's Docu on Darfur to Air Monday 2008-11-01 at the Wayback Machine
- ^ AmericanLife TV Network (ALN) Donates Proceeds From "A Journey to Darfur" DVD to the International Rescue Committee 2009-01-13 at the Wayback Machine
- ^ a b Moon, Sun Myung (2009). As a Peace-Loving Global Citizen. Gimm-Young Publishers. ISBN 978-0-7166-0299-6.
- ^ World Muslim League plans seminar for Taiwan, Taiwan Today, February 16, 2011
- ^ . Fmp.gob.pe. Archived from the original on 21 August 2010. Retrieved 23 May 2012.
- ^ "Portal Peruano Sociedad y Parlamento". Congreso.gob.pe. Retrieved 7 November 2015.
- ^ "Centro de Noticias el Heraldo". Archived from the original on 30 July 2012. Retrieved 4 May 2012.
- ^ Escrito por Imagen Institucional. . Municportillo.gob.pe. Archived from the original on 3 February 2016. Retrieved 23 May 2012.
- ^ "Centro de Noticias el Heraldo". Archived from the original on 23 July 2012. Retrieved 4 May 2012.
- ^ . Mimdes.gob.pe. Archived from the original on 20 December 2009. Retrieved 23 May 2012.
- ^ . News.mk.co.kr. 18 February 2010. Archived from the original on 1 January 2016. Retrieved 23 May 2012.
- ^ . Dipity.com. Archived from the original on 3 September 2013. Retrieved 23 May 2012.
- ^ http://web.parliament.go.th/php4/radio/temp/news8688.doc[dead link]
- ^ "Incontro per la settimana mondiale per l'armonia interreligiosa a Torino il 4 febbraio". Torinotoday.it. Retrieved 23 May 2012.
- ^ . Unmultimedia.org. Archived from the original on 14 May 2013. Retrieved 23 May 2012.
- ^ "Deputy Secretary-General, at Interfaith Harmony Week Event, Says Common Cause in Mutual Respect for Shared Values Is Only Way to Unite Nations, Peoples". Un.org. 7 February 2012. Retrieved 23 May 2012.
- ^ "UN officials underline religions' role in promoting global harmony". Un.org. 7 February 2012. Retrieved 23 May 2012.
- ^ (PDF). 24 January 2012. Archived from the original (PDF) on 28 July 2018. Retrieved 23 May 2012.
- ^ "UN launches first World Interfaith Harmony Week" (PDF). UN Daily News. 1 February 2011. p. 9. Retrieved 30 March 2019.
- ^ a b Kety Quits Moon-Linked ICF Conference 20 February 2006 at the Wayback Machine Harvard Crimson, 1976-08-10.
- ^ Tingle, D. and Fordyce, R. 1979, Phases and Faces of the Moon: A Critical Examination of the Unification Church and its Principles, Hicksville, NY: Exposition Press ISBN 0-682-49264-7 pp. 86–87
- ^ a b Biermans, J. 1986, The Odyssey of New Religious Movements, Persecution, Struggle, Legitimation: A Case Study of the Unification Church Lewiston, New York and Queenston, Ontario: The Edwin Melton Press ISBN 0-88946-710-2 p. 173
- ^ Church Spends Millions On Its Image The Washington Post. 1984-09-17
- ^ Rev. Moon is sponsor of scholarly conference, St. Petersburg Times, November 12, 1977
- ^ "ICUS". 9 March 2016. Retrieved 19 January 2019.
- ^ Eugene Paul Wigner Papers 2008-02-24 at the Wayback Machine Princeton University Library
- ^ Library journal, Volume 131, Issues 12–15. 2006. p. 45.
Libraries with larger budgets may want to purchase books that represent viewpoints at the extremes of this struggle, including such intelligent design tracts as ... Jonathan Wells's Icons of Evolution ... For example we may be obligated to our patrons to make available works that embody ideas fundamental to significant cultural undercurrents such as "intelligent design" but not to burden budgets and minds with every other form of pseudoscience.
- ^ "Icons of Evolution?". NCSE. 19 October 2008. Retrieved 19 January 2019.
- ^ Survival of the Fakest 2006-12-05 at the Wayback Machine, Jonathan Wells, 2000 (A reprint from the American Spectator)
- ^ Christianity: A Global History, David Chidester, HarperCollins, 2001, ISBN 0062517708, 9780062517708, pages 514 to 515
- ^ The World's Religions: Continuities and Transformations, Peter B Clarke, Peter Beyer, Taylor & Francis, 2008 ISBN 1135211000, 9781135211004
- ^ "Korean denies influence peddling". Bangor Daily News. Retrieved 21 March 2012.
- ^ "CAUSA/The Downfall of Communism". www.tparents.org. Retrieved 10 August 2022.
- ^ . Frontline. PBS. 21 January 1992. Archived from the original on 7 January 2011.
- ^ The Way of Restoration, (April, 1972)
- ^ Sun Myung Moon and the Unification Church, Frederick Sontag, Abingdon Press, Jan 1, 1977, page 122
- ^ Quebedeaux, Richard (1982). Richard Quebedeaux, Lifestyle : Conversations with Members of Unification Church. ISBN 9780932894182. Retrieved 9 October 2012.
- ^ a b Ahrens, Frank (23 May 2002). "Moon Speech Raises Old Ghosts as the Times Turns 20". The Washington Post. Retrieved 16 August 2009.
- ^ Pak was founding president of the Washington Times Corporation (1982–1992), and founding chairman of the board. Bo Hi Pak, Appendix B: Brief Chronology of the Life of Dr. Bo Hi Pak, in Messiah: My Testimony to Rev. Sun Myung Moon, Vol I by Bo Hi Pak (2000), Lanham, MD: University Press of America.
- ^ "Rabbi Joins the Board of Moonie Newspaper", The Palm Beach Post, May 21, 1978
- ^ "Moon's "Cause" Takes Aim At Communism in Americas." The Washington Post. August 28, 1983
- ^ Sun Myung Moon's Followers Recruit Christians to Assist in Battle Against Communism Christianity Today, June 15, 1985
- ^ Church Spends Millions On Its Image, The Washington Post, 1984-09-17. "Another church political arm, Causa International, which preaches a philosophy it calls "God-ism," has been spending millions of dollars on expense-paid seminars and conferences for Senate staffers, Hispanic Americans and conservative activists. It also has contributed $500,000 to finance an anticommunist lobbying campaign headed by John T. (Terry) Dolan, chairman of the National Conservative Political Action Committee (NCPAC)."
- ^ Corry, John (29 July 1986). "On 13, Sandinistas Vs. Miskitos". The New York Times. Retrieved 19 January 2019.
- ^ "Revista Envío – How to Read the Reagan Administration: The Miskito Case". www.envio.org.ni. Retrieved 19 January 2019.
- ^ "FAIR". Retrieved 19 January 2019.
- ^ 2 Americans Reported Killed In an Ambush in Afghanistan The New York Times, 1987-10-28
- ^ "PRIVATE GROUPS REPORT SURGE IN AID TO CONTRAS". cia.gov. 8 May 1985. Retrieved 3 January 2023.
- ^ "'COVERT' WAR ON SANDINISTAS CHANGING HANDS". cia.gov. 22 December 2016. Retrieved 3 January 2023.
- ^ Anderson, Jack (16 August 1984). "CIA, Moonies Cooperate in Sandinista War" (PDF). The Washington Post. Retrieved 3 January 2023.
- ^ McGill, Peter (15 October 2022). "The Dark Shadow Cast by Moon Sun Myung's Unification Church and Abe Shinzo". The Asia-Pacific Journal | Japan Focus. Retrieved 26 November 2022.
- ^ 30,000 participate in anti-draft rally in Washington 2016-09-16 at the Wayback Machine, Daily Collegian, March 24, 1980
- ^ Moon's Sect Is Taxable, Court Rules, The New York Times, May 7, 1981
- ^ N.Y. Upholds Tax Exemption for 'Moonies'[permanent dead link], Los Angeles Times, May 6, 1982
- ^ Miller, Johnny (3 September 1983). "Police chief dies at ballgame". San Francisco Chronicle.
For a second day, the Soviet Consulate in Pacific Heights was the scene of emotional protests against the shooting down of a Korean Air Lines jumbo jet. About 300 people held demonstration yesterday morning. Among them were members of the Unification Church, or "Moonies," whose founder is the Rev. Sun Myung Moon, the South Korean who has melded a fierce anti-communism into his ideology. Eldridge Cleaver, the onetime black radical who recently has had ties with the Moonies, spoke at the rally. Many pickets carried signs accusing the Soviet Union of murdering the 269 passengers and crew aboard the airliner. In another development, San Francisco attorney Melvin Belli filed a $109 billion lawsuit against the Soviet Union on behalf of the 269 victims.
- ^ Isikoff, Michael (17 September 1984). "Church Spends Millions On Its Image". The Washington Post. Retrieved 14 September 2022.
- ^ Ribadeneira, Diego (21 August 1999). "Ire at school Star of David ruling unites ACLU, Pat Robertson". The Boston Globe. p. B2.
- ^ Projections about a post-Soviet world-twenty-five years later. // Goliath Business News
- ^ Carden, Paul (Summer 1998). "Cults and New Religious Movements in the Former Soviet Union". eastwestreport.org.
- ^ At Time of Change for Rev. Moon Church, a Return to Tradition // The New York Times, 14 October 2009
- ^ A Desire to Feed the World and Inspire Self-Sufficiency, The New York Times, August 11, 2007
- ^ 임상균,김규식 (21 December 2011). "金장례식에 日여자마술사 초청한 까닭". mk.co.kr. Retrieved 19 January 2019.
- ^ Kirk, Don (2 May 1998). "Reverend Moon's Group Wants to Talk Investment : Seoul Nods At Church's Foray North". The New York Times.
- ^ Kirk, Don (16 February 2000). "Church Reaches Across Border in Korea Car Venture : Moon's Northward Push". The New York Times.
- ^ The Bush Administration's Secret Link to North Korea, Aram Roston, The Daily Beast, February 7, 2012
- ^ Unification Church president on condolence visit to N. Korea, Yonhap News, December 26, 2011
- ^ "문선명은 김정일 사망 알았나". well.hani.co.kr. Retrieved 19 January 2019.
- ^ "Son of Unification Church founder meets with senior North Korean official in Pyongyang". The San Diego Union-Tribune. 15 December 2011. Retrieved 6 August 2018 – via The Associated Press.
- ^ 김광태 (30 November 2011). "S. Korea says food aid reached intended beneficiaries in N. Korea". Yonhap News Agency. Retrieved 19 January 2019.
- ^ . Sports.kbs.co.kr. Archived from the original on 25 May 2013. Retrieved 23 May 2012.
- ^ , Korean Central News Agency, 7 September 2012, archived from the original on 29 July 2014, retrieved 13 September 2012
- ^ North Korean leader extends condolences over 1 yr anniversary of Unification Church founder death, Yonhap News, August 20, 2013
- ^ , Tehran Times, 2017-11-6
- ^ Rodney Sawatsky, 1978, Dialogue with the Moonies 11 December 2008 at the Wayback Machine Theology Today.
- ^ , Time Magazine, 10 November 1975
- ^ Daske, D. and Ashcraft, W. 2005, New Religious Movements, New York: New York University Press, ISBN 0-8147-0702-5 p142
- ^ Yamamoto, J. 1995, Unification Church, Grand Rapids, Michigan: Zondervan Press, ISBN 0-310-70381-6 p40
- ^ Walter Ralston Martin, Ravi K. Zacharias, The Kingdom of the Cults, Bethany House, 2003, ISBN 0764228218 pages 368–370
- ^ Helm, S. Divine Principle and the Second Advent 21 September 2008 at the Wayback Machine Christian Century 11 May 1977.
- ^ Moon at Twilight 11 April 2001 at the Wayback Machine, Peter Maass, The New Yorker "The campaign has dismayed some church members, because a blessing from Moon used to be a hard-won privilege, typically attained only after a person had joined the church, worked in it for several years, and agreed to marry someone—usually a stranger—selected by Moon. But grumblings about the blessing campaign are just the beginning of Moon's current troubles."
- ^ John Warwick Montgomery and Thomas J. J. Altizer, The Altizer-Montgomery Dialogue: A Chapter in the God is Dead Controversy (InterVarsity Press, Chicago, 1967), p.7
- ^ . www.americanjewisharchives.org. Archived from the original on 29 July 2012. Retrieved 28 January 2018.
- ^ "Rabbi Joins the Board of Moonie Newspaper", The Palm Beach Post, 21 May 1978
- ^ U. of Bridgeport Honors Rev. Moon, Fiscal Savior, The New York Times, 8 September 1995
- ^ The same old game 15 February 2009 at the Wayback Machine, Al-Ahram, 12–18 November 1998, "The Washington Times is a mouthpiece for the ultra conservative right, unquestioning supporters of Israel's Likud government. The newspaper is owned by Sun Myung Moon, originally a native of North Korea and head of the Unification Church, whose ultra-right leanings make him a ready ally for Netanyahu. Whether or not Netanyahu is personally acquainted with Moon is unclear, though there is no doubt that he has established close friendships with several staff members on The Washington Times, whose editorial policy is rabidly anti-Arab, anti-Muslim and pro-Israel."
- ^ Sun Myung Moon and the Unification Church, Frederick Sontag, Abingdon Press, 1 Jan 1977, page 122
- ^ . Unification.org. Archived from the original on 16 July 2011. Retrieved 4 January 2012.
- ^ . Theologytoday.ptsem.edu. Archived from the original on 16 February 2012. Retrieved 4 January 2012.
- ^ a b Sontag, Frederick (1977). Sun Myung Moon and the Unification Church. Abingdon Press. Nashville, Tenn.: Abingdon Press. pp. 102–105. ISBN 0-687-40622-6. OCLC 3071834.
- ^ Kim, Young Oon, 1980, Unification Theology, Barrytown, NY: Unification Theological Seminary, LCCN 80-52872
- ^ Walter Ralston Martin, Ravi K. Zacharias, The Kingdom of the Cults, Bethany House, 2003, ISBN 0764228218 pp. 368–370.
- ^ Divine Principle, Chapter 7, Section 2.2
- ^ United States Department of the Army (2001). Religious Requirements and Practices: A Handbook for Chaplains. The Minerva Group, Inc. pp. 1–42. ISBN 978-0-89875-607-4.
- ^ Weatherhead, L.D. (1965). . England: Hodder and Stoughton. pp. 59–63. Archived from the original on 6 April 2016. Retrieved 8 February 2021.
- ^ Another Gospel: Cults, Alternative Religions, and the New Age Movement by Ruth A. Tucker 1989 ISBN 0-310-25937-1 pp. 250–251
- ^ Daske, D. and Ashcraft, W. 2005, New Religious Movements, New York: New York University Press, ISBN 0-8147-0702-5 "To restart the process toward perfection, God has sent messiahs to earth who could restore the true state of humanity's relationship with God. Before that can happen, however, humans must perform good deeds that cancel the bad effects of sin. Unificationists call this "indemnity". Showing love and devotion to one's fellow humans, especially within families, helps pay this indemnity." p. 142.
- ^ Yamamoto, J. 1995, Unification Church, Grand Rapids, Michigan: Zondervan Press, ISBN 0-310-70381-6 "The doctrine of indemnity. Indemnity is that which people do to restore themselves to God's kingdom. Young Oon Kim describes it this way: 'We atone for our sins through specific acts of penance.' Kwang-Yol Yoo, a Unification teacher, even goes so far as to say that by following the Divine Principle, "man's perfection must be accomplished by his own effort without God's help." God does most of the work, but people must still do their part in order to achieve God's plan of salvation: 'Five percent is only to say that man's responsibility is extremely small compared to God's.' "p35 "The doctrine of indemnity is not biblical. 'In simple language.' states Ruth Tucker, 'indemnity is salvation by works.' Bob Larson makes a distinction between Moon's doctrine and biblical theology, saying, 'Moon's doctrine of sinless perfection by "indemnity [forgiveness of sin by works on Moon's behalf], which can apply even to deceased ancestors, is a denial of the salvation by grace offering through Jesus Christ.' 'Farewell,' said John Calvin. 'to the dream of those who think up a righteousness flowing together out of faith and works.'" p40
- ^ The Power of the Principle: When It Came; Where It Went Richard Quebedeaux, "Rev. Moon calls such a mode of living, such a lifestyle, "restoration through indemnity." With indemnity viewed as a persistent pattern of behavior, not as a mere doctrine to be affirmed or a rational list of rules, God's ideal for human relationships is "restored" through restitution. Restitution-in the sense of a "natural law"-assuages resentment, because it is the means by which the powerful and enfranchised give the people who feel downtrodden and powerless what they believe is rightly theirs. Indemnity means that 'I'm here for you.'"
- ^
- ^ Deliberately misinterpreted. It is completely different from the original meaning and the definition of Sun-myung Moon. (→'Tang-gam (탕감 蕩減)')
- ^ a b c d Exposition of the Divine Principle
- ^ Exposition of the Divine Principle Korea
- ^ Naver Korean-English Dictionary
- ^ Search result for '탕감' Naver English-Korean Dictionary
- ^ Bible verses with tang-gam: Deuteronomy 15:1, 2, 3, 9, 31; Nehemiah 10:31, Matthew 8:27, 32; Luke 7:42, 43.
- ^ goognews-가톨릭정보-성경검색
- ^ 다국어 성경 Holy-Bible "탕감"
- ^ Yamamoto, J. I., 1995, Unification Church, Grand Rapids, Michigan: Zondervan Publishing House ISBN 0-310-70381-6
- ^ a b Daske and Ashcraft[not specific enough to verify]
- ^ Daske, D. and Ashcraft, W. 2005, New Religious Movements, New York: New York University Press, ISBN 0814707025 p142.
- ^ Yamamoto, J. I., 1995, Unification Church, Grand Rapids, Michigan: Zondervan Publishing House ISBN 0-310-70381-6 (Excerpt: 2012-02-10 at the Wayback Machine)
"1. The Unification Theological Seminary- a. The Unification Church has a seminary in Barrytown, New York called The Unification Theological Seminary.
- b. It is used as a theological training center, where members are prepared to be leaders and theologians in the UC.
- c. Moon's seminary, however, has not only attracted a respectable faculty (many of whom are not members of the UC), but it also has graduated many students (who are members of the UC) who have been accepted into doctoral programs at institutions such as Harvard and Yale."
- ^ Rev.Keiko Kawasaki, "Concerned about the Principle Movement"
- ^ "Unification Church" doctrine and money collection that forces Japanese to "indemnity" for "colonial rule"Korean World Times 2022/7/31
- ^ "The Neverending Story - indemnity! indemnity! indemnity !('Anti-Japan Tribalism 반일종족주의, 反日種族主義'edited by Lee Younghoon, p.188)"
- ^ Tingle, D. and Fordyce, R. 1979, The Phases and Faces of the Moon: A Critical Examination of the Unification Church and Its Principles, Hicksville, New York: Exposition Press p53-55
- ^ Halloran, Richard (16 March 1978). "Unification Church Called Seoul Tool". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved 13 July 2022.
- ^ Ex-aide of Moon Faces Citation for Contempt, Associated Press, Eugene Register-Guard, August 5, 1977
- ^ Reid, T.R. (5 August 1977). "House Subcommittee's Report Links Rev. Moon to the KCIA". The Washington Post. p. A7.
- ^ a b c d Babcock, Charles R. (10 November 1977). . The Washington Post. p. A1. Archived from the original on 23 October 2012. Retrieved 27 July 2023.
- ^ Bellant, Russ (1999). The Coors Connection. South End Press. pp. 5–6. ISBN 0-89608-416-7.
- ^ a b Associated Press (5 November 1977). "Moon official balks at probe, faces House contempt action". Eugene Register-Guard.[permanent dead link]
- ^ The New York Times staff (5 August 1977). "New York Times Abstracts". The New York Times. p. 9.
- ^ Hirschel, Alison (20 April 1980). "Rev. Moon's CARP recruits on campus". The Michigan Daily.
- ^ a b c William Borders, "Moon's Sect Loses Libel Suit in London," The New York Times, 1 April 1981.
- ^ "The Church That Breaks Up Families," Daily Mail (London), 29 May 1978.
- ^ Hilary Devries, ed., "Unification Church loses suit against British paper," The Christian Science Monitor, 1 April 1981.
- ^ a b c James T. Richardson and Barend van Driel, "New Religious Movements in Europe: Developments and Reactions" in Anti-Cult Movements in Cross-Cultural Perspective, edited by Anson Shupe and David G. Bromley, 129–170 [144], (New York: Garland, 1994), ISBN 9780815314288.
- ^ Eileen Barker, The Making of a Moonie: Choice or Brainwashing? (1984; repr., Oxford: Basil Blackwell, 1989), 2.[ISBN missing]
- ^ a b Eileen Barker, "General Overview of the "Cult Scene" in Great Britain," Nova Religio: The Journal of Alternative and Emergent Religions 4, no. 2 (2001): 235–240, [236].[ISBN missing]
- ^ George D. Chryssides, Exploring New Religions (London and New York: Cassell, 1999), 358. ISBN 9780304336517
- ^ George D. Chryssides, "Britain's Anti-cult movement," in New Religious Movements: Changes and Responses, edited by Jamie Cresswell and Bryan Wilson, 257–273 [268], (London and New York: Routledge, 1999), ISBN 9780415200509.
- ^ George D. Chryssides, "Britain's Changing Faiths: Adaptation in a New Environment," in The Growth of Religious Diversity: Britain from 1945, Volume II: Issues, edited by G. Parson, 55–84 [79], London: Routledge, 1994. ISBN 978-0415083287
- ^ Moon's Japanese Profits Bolster Efforts in U.S. The Washington Post, September 16, 2008
- ^ The Unification Church Aims a Major Public Relations Effort at Christian Leaders Christianity Today, April 19, 1985.
- ^ Moon's financial rise and fall,Harvard Crimson, October 11, 1984
- ^ a b Babington, Charles; Cooperman, Alan (23 June 2004). "The Rev. Moon Honored at Hill Reception – Lawmakers Say They Were Misled". Washington Post. pp. A01.
- ^ a b . The New York Times. 27 June 2004. Archived from the original on 13 May 2008. Retrieved 13 February 2017.
- ^ a b c d (in Japanese). Yahoo news Japan. 12 July 2022. Archived from the original on 12 July 2022.
- ^ "Transcript: Unification Church news conference on Abe shooting". Nikkei Asia. Retrieved 10 August 2023.
- ^ (in Japanese). National Network of Lawyers Against Spiritual Sales. Archived from the original on 11 July 2022.
- ^ (in Japanese). Abema times/Yahoo news Japan. 12 July 2022. Archived from the original on 12 July 2022.
- ^ 旧統一教会問題「行政も思考停止」 紀藤弁護士、国会での調査求める
- ^ 警察はなぜ旧統一教会を放置し続けた？ 1995年の摘発を退けた「政治圧力
- ^ "Shinzo Abe's ties to the Unification Church may have cost him". The Washington Post.
- ^ a b Tsuyoshi Hida. (2018) 記者襲撃 赤報隊事件30年目の真実. pp.160–168 Iwanami Shoten. ISBN 978-4000612487
- ^ a b The Washington Post. 16 September 1984. Archived from the original on 6 May 1997.
- ^ a b c . Washington Post. 12 July 2022. Archived from the original on 13 July 2022.
- ^ . Financial Times. 16 July 2022. Archived from the original on 16 July 2022.
- ^ (in Japanese). Yahoo news Japan/ Nippon television network. 12 July 2022. Archived from the original on 12 July 2022.
- ^ (in Japanese). Mainichi shimbun. 11 July 2022. Archived from the original on 12 July 2022.
- ^ a b (in Japanese). Mainichi shimbun. 12 July 2022. Archived from the original on 12 July 2022.
- ^ (in Japanese). Consumer law news. Archived from the original on 12 July 2022.
- ^ Japanese Communist Party Newspaper Akahata 2010/05/11
- ^ The LDP’s Tangled Ties to the Unification Church – The Diplomat 2022.7.28
- ^ "How Abe's killing exposes Japan's thin line between church and state". Financial Times. 3 August 2022. Archived from the original on 10 December 2022. Retrieved 10 August 2022.
- ^ (in Japanese). Fukuoka Prefectural Lawyers Association. 26 February 2008. Archived from the original on 28 October 2021.
- ^ (PDF) (in Japanese). Religious Information Research Center. Archived from the original (PDF) on 11 July 2022.
- ^ (in Japanese). Asahi Shimbun/Aera dot. 25 August 2012. Archived from the original on 17 March 2020.
- ^ (in Japanese). Mainichi Shimbun. 7 December 2022. Archived from the original on 9 December 2022. Retrieved 10 December 2022.
- ^ (in Japanese). Jiji Press. 9 December 2022. Archived from the original on 9 December 2022. Retrieved 10 December 2022.
- ^ a b "Unification Church falls into category of cult: Japan Min. Kono". Arab News Japan. Retrieved 1 May 2023.
- ^ a b "La antigua Iglesia de la Unificación y la cultura religiosa de los japoneses". nippon.com (in Spanish). 9 November 2022. Retrieved 3 May 2023.
- ^ a b (in Japanese). The Nikkei. 10 December 2022. Archived from the original on 10 December 2022. Retrieved 10 December 2022.
- ^ a b c (in Japanese). Mainichi Shimbun. 10 December 2022. Archived from the original on 10 December 2022. Retrieved 10 December 2022.
- ^ (in Japanese). Constitutional Democratic Party of Japan. 24 August 2022. Archived from the original on 24 August 2022. Retrieved 11 December 2022.
- ^ (in Japanese). Sankei Shimbun. 11 November 2022. Archived from the original on 12 November 2022. Retrieved 11 December 2022.
- ^ (in Japanese). 9 December 2022. Archived from the original on 10 December 2022. Retrieved 11 December 2022.
- ^ a b (in Japanese). Tokyo Shimbun. 9 December 2022. Archived from the original on 9 December 2022. Retrieved 11 December 2022.
- ^ . 10 December 2022. Archived from the original on 10 December 2022. Retrieved 10 December 2022.
- ^ "Japan passes funds law amid 'cult-like' church controversy – DW – 12/10/2022". Deutsche Welle. Retrieved 10 December 2022.
- ^ "Japan's lower house passes bill to help Unification Church victims". Nikkei Asia. Retrieved 10 December 2022.
- ^ Friday; October 2006, 13; Parry, 1:17 pm Opinion: Robert. "Robert Parry: Moon, North Korea & the Bushes | Scoop News". www.scoop.co.nz. Retrieved 20 April 2023.
{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: numeric names: authors list (link) - ^ "The Consortium". www.consortiumnews.com. Retrieved 20 April 2023.
- ^ (in Japanese). TBS Television. 14 October 2022. Archived from the original on 24 November 2022. Retrieved 10 December 2022.
- ^ (in Japanese). Yahoo Japan News. 8 December 2022. Archived from the original on 9 December 2022. Retrieved 10 December 2022.
- ^ a b (in Japanese). Yahoo Japan News. 8 December 2022. Archived from the original on 9 December 2022. Retrieved 10 December 2022.
- ^ (in Japanese). Bungeishunju. 15 September 2022. Archived from the original on 10 October 2022. Retrieved 10 December 2022.
- ^ (in Japanese). TBS Television. 14 October 2022. Archived from the original on 24 November 2022. Retrieved 10 December 2022.
- ^ "旧統一教会トップと国会議員らがアメリカで面会…目的は？開示された名称変更の理由示した文書は黒塗り…政治家の関与は不明のまま", Tokyo Broadcasting System (in Japanese), 28 July 2022, retrieved 10 August 2022 – via YouTube
- ^ "Name change by Unification Church a baffling issue years later | The Asahi Shimbun: Breaking News, Japan News and Analysis". The Asahi Shimbun. Retrieved 7 March 2023.
- ^ a b "【独自】安倍元首相を撃った山上徹也が供述した、宗教団体「統一教会」の名前（現代ビジネス編集部". Gendai Bijinesu (in Japanese). Kodansha. 9 July 2022. Retrieved 9 July 2022.
- ^ a b "Assassin may have killed Abe as revenge against religious group that bankrupted his mother", Washington Post, 9 July 2022, retrieved 11 July 2022
- ^ a b (in Japanese). Yahoo News. Archived from the original on 14 July 2022. Retrieved 14 July 2022.
- ^ a b (in Japanese). Yahoo News. Archived from the original on 13 July 2022. Retrieved 14 July 2022.
- ^ (in Japanese). National Network of Lawyers Against Spiritual Sales. 11 September 2019. Archived from the original on 10 July 2022.
- ^ 父は急死、母は宗教団体へ多額の金 安倍氏銃撃容疑者の生い立ち：朝日新聞デジタル [Father died suddenly, mother went to a religious group A large amount of money Mr. Abe's background of the shooting suspect]. 朝日新聞デジタル (Asahi Shimbun) (in Japanese). 9 July 2022. from the original on 9 July 2022. Retrieved 9 July 2022.
- ^ a b Kelly, Tim; Park, Ju-min (16 August 2022). "Explainer: Why the Unification Church has become a headache for Japan's Kishida". Reuters. Retrieved 2 May 2023.
- ^ (in Japanese). Yomiuri shimbun. 13 July 2022. Archived from the original on 13 July 2022. Retrieved 13 July 2022.
- ^ (in Japanese). TV asahi. 12 July 2022. Archived from the original on 12 July 2022.
- ^ "Suspected Abe assassin cited religious group grudge as reason". The Asahi Shimbun. from the original on 9 July 2022. Retrieved 9 July 2022.
- ^ (in Japanese). TV asahi. 11 July 2022. Archived from the original on 11 July 2022.
- ^ "Unification Church's founder 'was close' to Shinzo Abe's grandfather". 20 July 2022.
- ^ "Dr. Chung Hwan Kwak | Global Peace Foundation".
- ^ "Unification Church founder was close to former PM Abe's grandfather: ex-chairman".
- ^ (in Korean). The Hankyoreh. 20 July 2022. Archived from the original on July 2022.
{{cite web}}: Check date values in:|archive-date=(help) - ^ (in Japanese). TV Asahi. 20 July 2022. Archived from the original on 20 July 2022.
- ^ "Govt. to set up panel to investigate security lapses in Abe shooting | NHK WORLD-JAPAN News". NHK WORLD. Retrieved 17 July 2022.
- ^ "安倍元首相銃撃事件で注目の旧統一教会「主導イベント」国家公安委員長が呼びかけ人だった！（SmartFLASH）". Yahoo!ニュース (in Japanese). Retrieved 17 July 2022.
- ^ "Unification Church ties to Japan's lawmakers emerge as major political issue". The Japan Times. Retrieved 30 July 2022.
- ^ (in Japanese). Yahoo news Japan. 31 August 2022. Archived from the original on 31 August 2022.
- ^ "Unification Church: Japan to investigate religious group after Abe killing". BBC News. 17 October 2022. Retrieved 1 January 2023.
- ^ Kelly, Tim; Kaneko, Kaori (22 November 2022). "Japan probes Unification Church after backlash over ruling party ties". Reuters. Retrieved 1 January 2023.
- ^ "Japan begins inquiry into Unification church in wake of Shinzo Abe killing". the Guardian. 22 November 2022. Retrieved 1 January 2023.
- ^ Evangelical-Unification Dialogue (Conference series – Unification Theological Seminary; no. 3) Richard Quebedeaux, Rodney Sawatsky, Paragon House, 1979, ISBN 093289402X, pp. 77–99.
- ^ Frederick Sontag,1977, Sun Myung Moon and the Unification Church, Abingdon Press, ISBN 0687406226, p. 185.
- ^ Irving Louis Horowitz, 1978, Science, Sin, and Scholarship: The Politics of Reverend Moon and the Unification Church, MIT Press, ISBN 0262081008, p. 114
- ^ The A to Z of New Religious Movements, George D. Chryssides Scarecrow Press, 2006, p. 155
- ^ Tingle, D. and Fordyce, R. 1979, The Phases and Faces of the Moon: A Critical Examination of the Unification Church and Its Principles, Hicksville, New York: Exposition Press ISBN 0682492647, pp. 20–21
- ^ George D. Chryssides, "Unificationism: A study in religious syncretism", Chapter 14 in Religion: empirical studies, Editor: Steven Sutcliffe, Ashgate Publishing, Ltd., 2004, ISBN 978-0-7546-4158-2, p. 232.
- ^ a b "Editorial: Japan gov't needs to uncover Unification Church's murky adoption practice", Mainichi Shimbun, 1 February 2023, retrieved 8 February 2023
- ^ "旧統一教会の養子縁組、2018年度以降31件 調査に回答" [The Unification Church answered that there have been 31 cases of child adoption arrangements since 2018], The Nikkei (in Japanese), 6 December 2022, retrieved 27 December 2022
- ^ "Japan to probe Unification Church's adoption system", The Japan Times, 18 November 2022, retrieved 28 December 2022
- ^ "Gov't warns Unification Church over murky child adoption practice", Kyodo News, The Japan Times, 24 January 2023, retrieved 25 January 2023
- ^ 「何のため生まれてきたのか」旧統一教会の養子縁組 元2世信者"肉声"で証言 信者向け動画には「養子縁組は美しい伝統」, Tokyo Broadcasting System (in Japanese), 19 November 2022, retrieved 25 January 2023
- ^