Common Brittonic

This article is about an ancestral Celtic language. For the group of languages descended from it, see Brittonic languages.

Common Brittonic (Welsh: Brythoneg; Cornish: Brythonek; Breton: Predeneg), also known as British, Common Brythonic, or Proto-Brittonic,^[3][4] was a Celtic language spoken in Britain and Brittany.

Common Brittonic
*Brittonikā
Region	Great Britain
Ethnicity	Britons
Era	c. 6th century BC to mid-6th century AD^[1] Developed into Old Welsh, Cumbric, Cornish, Breton and probably Pictish^[2]
Language family	Indo-European Celtic Insular Celtic Brittonic Common Brittonic
Language codes
ISO 639-3	–
Linguist List	brit
Glottolog	None
Linguasphere	50-AB

It is a form of Insular Celtic, descended from Proto-Celtic, a theorized parent tongue that, by the first half of the first millennium BC, was diverging into separate dialects or languages.^[5][6][7][8] Pictish is linked, likely as a sister language or a descendant branch.^[9][10][11]

Evidence from early and modern Welsh shows that Common Brittonic took a significant amount of influence from Latin during the Roman period, especially in terms related to the church and Christianity.^[12] By the sixth century AD, the tongues of the Celtic Britons were more rapidly splitting into Neo-Brittonic: Welsh, Cumbric, Cornish, Breton, and possibly the Pictish language.

Over the next three centuries it was replaced in most of Scotland by Scottish Gaelic and by Old English (from which descend Modern English and Scots) throughout most of modern England as well as Scotland south of the Firth of Forth.^[13] Cumbric disappeared in the 12th century^[13] and, in the far south-west, Cornish probably became extinct in the eighteenth century, though its use has since been revived.^[14][a] O'Rahilly's historical model suggests a Brittonic language in Ireland before the introduction of the Goidelic languages, but this view has not found wide acceptance.^[16] Welsh and Breton are the only daughter languages that have survived fully into the modern day.

History

Sources

 

Bath curse tablet featuring possible Common Brittonic

No documents in the tongue have been found, but a few inscriptions have been identified.^[17] The Bath curse tablets, found in the Roman feeder pool at Bath, Somerset (Aquae Sulis), bear about 150 names – about 50% Celtic (but not necessarily Brittonic). An inscription on a metal pendant (discovered there in 1979) seems to contain an ancient Brittonic curse:^[18] "Adixoui Deuina Deieda Andagin Uindiorix cuamenai". (Sometimes the final word has been rendered cuamiinai.) This text is often seen as: "The affixed – Deuina, Deieda, Andagin [and] Uindiorix – I have bound."^[19] else, at the opposite extreme, taking into account case-marking – -rix "king" nominative, andagin "worthless woman" accusative, dewina deieda "divine Deieda" nominative/vocative – is: "May I, Windiorix for/at Cuamena defeat [or "summon to justice"] the worthless woman, [oh] divine Deieda."^[20]

A tin/lead sheet retains part of 9 text lines, damaged, with likely Brittonic names.^[21]

Local Roman Britain toponyms (place names) are evidentiary, recorded in Latinised forms by Ptolemy's Geography discussed by Rivet and Smith in their book of that name published in 1979. They show most names he used were from the tongue. Some place names still contain elements derived from it. Tribe names and some Brittonic personal names are also taken down by Greeks and, mainly, Romans.

Tacitus's Agricola says that the tongue differed little from that of Gaul. Comparison with what is known of Gaulish confirms the similarity.^[22]

Pictish and Pritenic

Pictish, which became extinct around 1000 years ago, was the spoken language of the Picts in Northern Scotland.^[2] Despite significant debate as to whether this language was Celtic, items such as geographical and personal names documented in the region gave evidence that this language was most closely aligned with the Brittonic branch of Celtic languages.^[2] The question of the extent to which this language was distinguished, and the date of divergence, from the rest of Brittonic, was historically disputed.^[2]

Pritenic (also Pretanic and Prittenic) is a term coined in 1955 by Kenneth H. Jackson to describe a hypothetical Roman era (1st to 5th centuries) predecessor to the Pictish language.^[2] Jackson saw Pritenic as having diverged from Brittonic around the time of 75-100 AD.^[2]

The term Pritenic is controversial. In 2015, linguist Guto Rhys concluded that most proposals that Pictish diverged from Brittonic before c. 500 AD were incorrect, questionable, or of little importance, and that a lack of evidence to distinguish Brittonic and Pictish rendered the term Prittenic "redundant".^[2]

Diversification and Neo-Brittonic

Common Brittonic vied with Latin after the Roman conquest of Britain in 43 AD, at least in major settlements. Latin words were widely borrowed by its speakers in the Romanised towns and their descendants, and later from church use.

By 500–550 AD, Common Brittonic had diverged into the Neo-Brittonic dialects:^[2] Old Welsh primarily in Wales, Old Cornish in Cornwall, Old Breton in what is now Brittany, Cumbric in Northern England and Southern Scotland, and probably Pictish in Northern Scotland.^[2]

The modern forms of Breton and Welsh are the only direct descendants of Common Brittonic to have survived fully into the 21st century.^[23] Cornish fell out of use in the 1700s but has since undergone a revival.^[24] Cumbric and Pictish are extinct and today spoken only in the form of loanwords in English, Scots, and Scottish Gaelic.^[25][2]

Phonology

Consonants

(Late) Common Brittonic consonants

	Labial		Dental		Alveolar		Palatal		Velar		Labial– velar
Nasal		m		n						(ŋ)
Stop	p	b	t	d					k	ɡ
Fricative			θ	ð	s				x
Approximant								j				w
Lateral						l
Trill						r

Vowels

Early Common Brittonic vowels

	Front		Central		Back
	short	long	short	long	short	long
Close	i	iː			u
Close-mid	e	eː			o
Open-mid		ɛː				ɔː
Open			a			ɑː

The early Common Brittonic vowel inventory is effectively identical to that of Proto-Celtic. /ɨ/ and /ʉ/ have not developed yet.

Late Common Brittonic vowels

	Front		Central		Back
	unrounded	rounded	unrounded	rounded	rounded
Close	i	y	ɨ	ʉ	u
Close-mid	e	ø			o
Mid			(ə)	(ɵ̞)
Open-mid	ɛ				ɔ
Open			a

By late Common Brittonic, the New Quantity System had occurred, leading to a radical restructuring of the vowel system.

Notes:

• The central mid vowels /ə/ and /ɵ̞/ were allophonic developments of /i/ and /u/, respectively.

Grammar

Through comparative linguistics, it is possible to approximately reconstruct the declension paradigms of Common Brittonic:

First declension

Brittonic *tōtā 'tribe' and cognates in other languages

#	Case	Brittonic	Gaulish	Old Irish	PIE
Singular	Nominative	*tōtā	toutā	túath^L	**tewteh2
	Vocative	*tōtā	toutā	túath^L	**tewteh2
	Accusative	*tōtin	toutim	túaith^N	**tewteh2m
	Genitive	*tōtiās	toutiās	túaithe	**tewteh2s
	Dative	*tōtī	toutī	túaith^L	**tewteh2eh1
	Ablative	*tōtī	toutī		**tewteh2es
	Instrumental	*tōtī	toutī		**tewteh2(e)h1
	Locative	*tōtī	toutī		**tewteh2i
Dual	Nominative accusative vocative	*tōtī	—	túaith^L	**tewteh2h1e
	Genitive	*tōtious	—	túath^L	**tewteh2ows
	Dative	*tōtābon	—	túathaib	**tewteh2b^hām
	Ablative instrumental	*tōtābin	—		**tewteh2b^hām
	Locative	*tōtābin	—		**tewteh2ows
Plural	Nominative vocative	*tōtās	toutās	túatha^H	**tewteh2es
	Accusative	*tōtās	toutās	túatha^H	**tewteh2ns
	Genitive	*tōtābon	toutānon	túath^N	**tewteh2om
	Dative	*tōtābo	toutābi	túathaib	**tewteh2b^hi
	Ablative	*tōtā	—		**tewteh2b^hos
	Instrumental	*tōtā	—		**tewteh2b^his
	Locative	*tōtā	—		**tewteh2su

Notes:

• The dative dual and plural represent the inherited instrumental forms, which replaced the inherited dative dual and plural, from Proto-Celtic *toutābom, *toutābos.

Second declension

Brittonic *wiros 'man' and cognates in other languages

#	Case	Brittonic	Gaulish	Welsh	Old Irish	PIE
Sg	Nom.	*wiros	wiros	gŵr	fer	*wiHros
	Voc.	*wire	wire		fir^L	*wiHre
	Acc.	*wiron	wirom		fer^N	*wiHrom
	Gen.	*wirī	wirī		fir^L	*wiHrosyo
	Dat.	*wirū	wirū		fiur^L	*wiHroh1
	Abl. ins.	*wirū	—			*wiHroh1
	Loc.	*wirē	—			*wiHrey
Du	Nom. acc. voc.	*wirō	wirō		fer^L	*wiHroh1
	Gen.	*wirōs	—		fer	*wiHrows
	Dat.	*wirobon	—		feraib	*wiHrob^hām
	Abl.	*wirobin	—			*wiHrob^hām
	Ins.	*wirobin	—			*wiHrob^hām
	Loc.	*wirou	—			*wiHrows
Pl	Nom. voc.	*wirī	wirī	gwŷr	fir^L (nom.), firu^H (voc.)	*wiHroy
	Acc.	*wirūs	wirūs		firu^H	*wiHrons
	Gen.	*wiron	wiron		fer^N	*wiHrooHom
	Dat.	*wirobi	wirobi		feraib	*wiHrōys
	Abl.	*wirobi	—			*wiHromos
	Ins.	*wirobi	—			*wiHrōys
	Loc.	*wirobi	—			*wiHroysu

Notes:

• Neuter 2nd declension stems deviate from the paradigm as such:

Neuter 2nd declension stem *cradion

#	Case	Brittonic
Sg	Nom. voc. acc.	*cradion
Pl	Nom. voc. acc.	*cradiā

Notes:

• Dual is same as singular
• All other declensions same as regular 2nd declension paradigm

Third declension

Brittonic *carrecis and cognates in other languages

#	Case	Brittonic	Gaulish	Welsh	Old Irish	PIE
Sg	Nom.	*carrecis	—	carreg	carrac
	Voc.	*carreci	—
	Acc.	*carrecin	—
	Gen.	*carrecēs	—
	Dat.	*carrecē	—
	Abl. ins. loc.	*carrecī	—
Du	Nom.	*carrecī	—
	Gen.	*carreciōs	—
	Dat.	*carrecibon	—
	Abl. ins. loc.	*carrecī	—
Pl	Nom. voc. acc.	*carrecīs	—	cerrig
	Gen.	*carrecion	—
	Dat.	*carrecibo	—
	Abl. ins. loc.	*carrecibi	—

Place names

Brittonic-derived place names are scattered across Great Britain, with many occurring in the West Country; however, some of these may be pre-Celtic. The best example is perhaps that of each (river) Avon, which comes from the Brittonic aβon[a], "river" (transcribed into Welsh as afon, Cornish avon, Irish and Scottish Gaelic abhainn, Manx awin, Breton aven; the Latin cognate is amnis). When river is preceded by the word, in the modern vein, it is tautological.

Examples of place names derived from the Brittonic languages

Main article: Celtic toponymy

Examples are:

• Avon from abonā^[b] = 'river' (cf. Welsh afon, Cornish avon, Breton aven)
• Britain, cognate with Pritani = (possibly) 'People of the Forms' (cf. Welsh Prydain 'Britain', pryd 'appearance, form, image, resemblance'; Irish cruth 'appearance, shape', Old Irish Cruithin 'Picts')
• Cheviot from *cev- = 'ridge' and -ed, a noun suffix^[26]
• Dover: as pre-medieval Latin did not distinguish a Spanish-style mixed [b/v] sound, the phonetic standard way of reading Dubrīs is as [dʊβriːs]. It means 'water(s)' (cognate with old Welsh dwfr, plural phonetically /dəvrʊɪð/, Cornish dowr, Breton dour, and Irish dobhar, its orthography bh denoting [v] or [β] phonetically)
• Kent from canto- = 'border' (becoming in Welsh cant(el) 'rim, brim', in Breton, kant)
• Lothian, (Lleuddiniawn in medieval Welsh) from *Lugudũn(iãnon) 'Fort of Lugus'
• Severn from Sabrīna,^[b] perhaps the name of a goddess (modern Welsh, Hafren)
• Thames from Tamesis = 'dark' (likely cognate with Welsh tywyll 'darkness', Cornish tewal, Breton teñval, Irish teimheal, pointing to a Brittonic approximate word temeselo-)
• Thanet (headland) from tan-eto- = 'bonfire', 'aflame' (cf. Welsh tân 'fire', Cornish tanses, Old Breton tanet 'aflame')
• York from Ebur-ākon^[b] = 'yew tree stand/group' (cognate with Welsh Efrog, from efwr 'cow parsnip, hogweed' + -og 'abundant in', Breton evor 'alder buckthorn', Scottish Gaelic iubhar 'yew', iùbhrach 'stand/grove of yew trees'; cognate with Évreux in France and Évora in Portugal) via Latin Eburacum > OE Eoforwīc (re-analysed by English speakers as eofor 'boar' with Old English wic appended at the end) > Old Norse Jórvík

Basic words tor, combe, bere, and hele from Brittonic common in Devon place-names.^[27] Tautologous, two-tongue names exist in England, such as:

• Derwentwater (for Brittonic part see Dover above)
• Chetwood, (cognate with Welsh coed, Breton koad)^[28]
• Bredon Hill

Notes

1. A study of 2018 found the number of people with at least minimal skills in Cornish as over 3,000, including around 500 estimated to be fluent.^[15]
2. See note on pre-medieval-Latin recording of the letter b at Dover, in this section.

References

1. Common Brittonic at MultiTree on the Linguist List
2. Rhys, Guto. "Approaching the Pictish language: historiography, early evidence and the question of Pritenic" (PDF). University of Glasgow. University of Glasgow.
3. Eska, Joseph F. (2019-12-01). "The evolution of proto-Brit. *-/lth/ in Welsh". Zeitschrift für celtische Philologie. 66 (1): 75–82. doi:10.1515/zcph-2019-0003. ISSN 1865-889X. S2CID 212726410.
4. Sims-Williams, Patrick (November 1984). "The Double System of Verbal Inflexion in Old Irish". Transactions of the Philological Society. 82 (1): 138–201. doi:10.1111/j.1467-968X.1984.tb01211.x. ISSN 0079-1636.
5. Henderson, Jon C. (2007). The Atlantic Iron Age: Settlement and Identity in the First Millennium BC. Routledge. pp. 292–295. ISBN 9780415436427.
6. Sims-Williams, Patrick (2007). Studies on Celtic Languages before the Year 1000. CMCS. p. 1.
7. Koch, John T. (2006). Celtic Culture: A Historical Encyclopedia. ABC-CLIO. p. 1455.
8. Eska, Joseph (2008). "Continental Celtic". In Woodard, Roger (ed.). The Ancient Languages of Europe. Cambridge.
9. Forsyth, Katherine (2006). Koch, John T. (ed.). Celtic Culture: A Historical Encyclopedia. ABC-CLIO. pp. 1444, 1447.
10. Forsyth, Katherine (1997). Language in Pictland: The case against "non-Indo-European Pictish". Utrecht: de Keltische Draak. p. 27.
11. Jackson, Kenneth H. (1955). "The Pictish Language". In Wainwright, F. T. (ed.). The Problem of the Picts. Edinburgh: Nelson. pp. 129–166.
12. Lewis, H. (1943). Yr Elfen Ladin yn yr Iaith Gymraeg. Cardiff: University of Wales Press.
13. Nicolaisen, W. F. H. Scottish Place Names. p. 131.
14. Tanner, Marcus (2004). The last of the Celts. Yale University Press. p. 225. ISBN 0300104642.
15. Ferdinand, Siarl (2018). "The Promotion of Cornish in Cornwall and the Isles of Scilly: Attitudes towards the Language and Recommendations for Policy". Studia Celtica Fennica. 19: 107–130. doi:10.33353/scf.79496.
16. O'Rahilly, Thomas (1964). Early Irish history and mythology. School of Celtic Studies, Dublin Institute for Advanced Studies. ISBN 0-901282-29-4.
17. Freeman, Philip (2001). Ireland and the Classical World. University of Texas Press.^{[page needed]}
18. Tomlin, R. S. O. (1987). "Was ancient British Celtic ever a written language? Two texts from Roman Bath". Bulletin of the Board of Celtic Studies. 34: 18–25.
19. Mees, Bernard (2009). Celtic Curses. Boydell & Brewer. p. 35.
20. Patrick Sims-Williams, "Common Celtic, Gallo-Brittonic, and Insular Celtic", Gaulois et celtique continental, eds. Pierre-Yves Lambert and Georges-Jean Pinault (Geneva: Droz, 2007), 327.
21. Tomlin, 1987.
22. Pierre-Yves Lambert, La langue gauloise, éditions errance 1994. p. 17.
23. Burns Mcarthur, Thomas (2005). Concise Oxford Companion to the English Language. Oxford University Press. ISBN 9780192806376. Retrieved 30 April 2021.
24. "Cornish language no longer extinct, says UN". BBC News Online. 7 November 2010. Retrieved 30 April 2021.
25. "Dictionaries of the Scots Language". Retrieved 30 April 2021.
26. James, Alan. (PDF). SPNS.org.uk. Scottish Place Name Society. Archived from the original (PDF) on 13 August 2017. Retrieved 13 January 2019.
27. Gover, J. E. B.; Mawer, A.; Stenton, F. A. (1932). Place-names of Devon. English Place-name Society.
28. Green, Terry (2003). . NDAS.org.uk. North Devon Archaeological Society. Archived from the original on 4 October 2011. Retrieved 11 January 2011.

Bibliography

• Filppula, M.; Klemola, J.; Pitkänen, H. (2001); The Celtic Roots of English, (Studies in Languages, No. 37); University of Joensuu, Faculty of Humanities; ISBN 952-458-164-7.
• Forsyth, K. (1997), Language in Pictland.
• Jackson, Kenneth H. (1953), Language and History in Early Britain.
• Jackson, Kenneth H. (1955), "The Pictish Language"; in F. T. Wainwright, The Problem of the Picts; London: Nelson.
• Koch, John T. (1986), "New Thought on Albion, Ieni and the 'Pretanic Isles'", Proceedings of the Harvard Celtic Colloquium, 6: pp. 1–28.
• Lambert, Pierre-Yves [ed.] (2002), Recueil des inscriptions gauloises II.2. Textes gallo-latins sur instrumentum; Paris: CNRS Editions; pp. 304–306.
• Lambert, Pierre-Yves (2003), La langue gauloise; 2nd ed.; Paris: Editions Errance; p. 176.
• Lockwood, W. B. (1975), Languages of the British Isles Past and Present; London: Deutsch; ISBN 0-233-96666-8.
• Ostler, Nicholas (2005), Empires of the Word; London: HarperCollins; ISBN 0-00-711870-8.
• Price, Glanville. (2000), Languages of Britain and Ireland; Blackwell; ISBN 0-631-21581-6.
• Rivet, A. and Smith, C. (1979), The Place-names of Roman Britain
• Sims-Williams, Patrick (2003), The Celtic Inscriptions of Britain: Phonology and Chronology, c. 400–1200; Oxford, Blackwell; ISBN 1-4051-0903-3.
• Ternes, Elmar [ed.] (2011), Brythonic Celtic – Britannisches Keltisch: From Medieval British to Modern Breton; Bremen: Hempen Verlag.
• Trudgill, P. [ed.] (1984), Language in the British Isles; Cambridge University Press.
• Willis, David (2009), "Old and Middle Welsh"; in The Celtic Languages, 2nd ed.; eds. Martin J. Ball & Nichole Müller; New York: Routledge; ISBN 0-203-88248-2; pp. 117–160.

External links

• Celtic Personal Names of Roman Britain
• Alex Mullen (2007), "Evidence for Written Celtic from Roman Britain: A Linguistic Analysis of Tabellae Sulis 14 and 18", Studia Celtica