Scientology
Scientology is a set of beliefs and practices invented by American author L. Ron Hubbard, and an associated movement. It has been variously defined as a cult, a business, or a new religious movement.[11] A 2008 survey found that there were about 25,000 followers in the United States. The most recent census data indicate there were around 1,800 followers in England (2021);[12] 1,400 in Canada (2021);[13] and about 1,600 in Australia (2021).[14][15] Hubbard initially developed a set of ideas that he called Dianetics, which he represented as a form of therapy. This he promoted through various publications, as well as through the Hubbard Dianetic Research Foundation that he established in 1950. The foundation went bankrupt, and Hubbard lost the rights to his book Dianetics in 1952. He then recharacterized the subject as a religion and renamed it Scientology, retaining the terminology, doctrines, and the practice of "auditing".[7][16][17] By 1954 he had regained the rights to Dianetics and retained both subjects under the umbrella of the Church of Scientology.[24]
Scientology teaches that a human is an immortal, spiritual being (Thetan) that resides in a physical body and has had innumerable past lives. Some Scientology texts are only revealed after followers have spent more than $200,000 in the organization, and it charges tens of thousands of dollars for access to these texts in what it calls "Operating Thetan" levels. The organization has gone to considerable lengths to try to keep these secret, but they are freely available on the internet.[25] These texts say that lives preceding a Thetan's arrival on Earth were lived in extraterrestrial cultures. The Scientology doctrine states that any Scientologist undergoing "auditing" will eventually come across and recount a common series of events.[26] They include reference to an extraterrestrial life-form called Xenu. The secret Scientology texts say this was a ruler of a confederation of planets 70 million years ago who brought billions of alien beings to Earth and then killed them with thermonuclear weapons. Despite being kept secret from most followers, this forms the central mythological framework of Scientology's ostensible soteriology: attainment of a status referred to by Scientologists as "clear". These aspects have become the subject of popular ridicule.[27]
From soon after their formation, Hubbard's groups have generated considerable opposition and controversy, in several instances because of their illegal activities.[28] In January 1951, the New Jersey Board of Medical Examiners brought proceedings against the Dianetic Research Foundation on the charge of teaching medicine without a license.[29] During the 1970s, Hubbard's followers engaged in a program of criminal infiltration of the U.S. government, resulting in several executives of the organization being convicted and imprisoned for multiple offenses by a U.S. Federal Court.[30][31][32] Hubbard himself was convicted in absentia of fraud by a French court in 1978 and sentenced to four years in prison.[33] In 1992, a court in Canada convicted the Scientology organization in Toronto of spying on law enforcement and government agencies, and criminal breach of trust, later upheld by the Ontario Court of Appeal.[34][35] The Church of Scientology was convicted of fraud by a French court in 2009, a judgment upheld by the supreme Court of Cassation in 2013.[36]
The Church of Scientology has been described by government inquiries, international parliamentary bodies, scholars, law lords, and numerous superior court judgments as both a dangerous cult and a manipulative profit-making business.[43] Following extensive litigation in numerous countries,[44][45] the organization has managed to attain a legal recognition as a religious institution in some jurisdictions, including Australia,[46][47] Italy,[45] and the United States.[48] Germany classifies Scientology groups as an "anti-constitutional sect",[49][50] while the French government classifies the group as a dangerous cult.[51][52]
History
L. Ron Hubbard
L. Ron Hubbard (1911–1986) was the only child of Harry Ross Hubbard, a United States Navy officer, and his wife, Ledora Waterbury. Hubbard spent three semesters at George Washington University (in Washington, D.C.), but was placed on probation in September 1931. He failed to return for the fall 1932 semester.[53]
During World War II in July 1941, Hubbard was commissioned as a Lieutenant (junior grade) in the U.S. Naval Reserve. On May 18, 1943, his subchaser left Portland. That night, Hubbard ordered his crew to fire 35 depth charges and a number of gun rounds at what he believed were Japanese submarines.[54] His ship sustained minor damage and three crew were injured. Having run out of depth charges and with the presence of a submarine still unconfirmed by other ships, Hubbard's ship was ordered back to port. A navy report concluded that "there was no submarine in the area." A decade later, Hubbard claimed in his Scientology lectures that he had sunk a Japanese submarine.[55]
On June 28, 1943, Hubbard ordered his crew to fire on the Coronado Islands. Hubbard apparently did not realize that the islands belonged to US-allied Mexico, nor that he had taken his vessel into Mexican territorial waters.[56] He was reprimanded and removed from command on July 7.[56] After reassignment to a naval facility in Monterey, California, Hubbard became depressed and fell ill. Reporting stomach pains in April 1945, he spent the remainder of the war as a patient in Oak Knoll Naval Hospital in Oakland, California.[57] According to his later teachings, during this time Hubbard made scientific "breakthroughs" by use of "endocrine experiments".[58]
On October 15, 1947, Hubbard wrote a letter to the Veterans Administration formally requesting psychiatric treatment, and said he was unable to afford to pay for it himself.[16] Within a few years, Hubbard would condemn psychiatry as evil, and this would grow into a major theme in Scientology.[59]
Excalibur and Babalon Working
In April 1938, Hubbard reportedly reacted to a drug used in a dental procedure. According to his account, this triggered a revelatory near-death experience. Allegedly inspired by this experience, Hubbard composed a manuscript, which was never published, with the working titles of "The One Command" or Excalibur.[60][61] The contents of Excalibur formed the basis for some of his later publications.[62] Arthur J. Burks, who read the work in 1938, later recalled it discussed the "one command": to survive. This theme would be revisited in Dianetics, the set of ideas and practices regarding the metaphysical relationship between the mind and body which became the central philosophy of Scientology.[63] Hubbard later cited Excalibur as an early version of Dianetics.[64][better source needed]
In August 1945, Hubbard moved into the Pasadena mansion of John "Jack" Whiteside Parsons, an avid occultist and Thelemite, follower of the English ceremonial magician Aleister Crowley and leader of a lodge of Crowley's magical order, Ordo Templi Orientis (OTO).[65][66] Parsons and Hubbard collaborated on the "Babalon Working", a sex magic ritual intended to summon an incarnation of Babalon, the supreme Thelemite goddess.[31] In a 1969 letter to the Sunday Times, the Church of Scientology admitted to Hubbard's involvement with Parsons. They claimed that Hubbard remained a US Navy officer and "was sent in to handle the situation, he went to live at the house and investigated the black magic rites and the general situation and found them very bad". Neither the Church of Scientology nor any researcher has located any evidence for this claim.[67]
A spokesperson for the Scientology organisation would later say that Hubbard was "sent in there by Robert Heinlein, who was running off-book intelligence operations for naval intelligence at the time". The book that the Church of Scientology claimed would confirm this contains no mention of Heinlein sending Hubbard to break up the ring, and the author of the book said Scientologists had been the source of the claim, and that the material referred to by the organization did not support their factual assertions.[68]
In the late 1940s, Hubbard practiced as a hypnotist and he worked in Hollywood posing as a swami.[69][70] The Scientology organization says that Hubbard's experience with hypnosis led him to create Dianetics.[71]
Dianetics
In May 1950, Hubbard's Dianetics: The Evolution of a Science was published by pulp magazine Astounding Science Fiction.[72][73] In the same year, he published the book-length Dianetics: The Modern Science of Mental Health, considered the seminal event of the century by Scientologists.[citation needed] Scientologists sometimes use a dating system based on the book's publication; for example, "A.D. 25" does not stand for Anno Domini, but "After Dianetics".[74]
Dianetics describes a "counseling" technique known as "auditing" in which an auditor assists a subject in conscious recall of traumatic events in the individual's past. It was originally intended to be a new psychotherapy.[75][76] Hubbard variously defined Dianetics as a spiritual healing technology and an organized science of thought.[77] The stated intent is to free individuals of the influence of past traumas by systematic exposure and removal of the engrams (painful memories) these events have left behind, a process called clearing.[77] Rutgers scholar Beryl Satter says that "there was little that was original in Hubbard's approach", with much of the theory having origins in popular conceptions of psychology.[78] Satter observes that in "keeping with the typical 1950s distrust of emotion, Hubbard promised that Dianetic treatment would release and erase psychosomatic ills and painful emotions, thereby leaving individuals with increased powers of rationality."[78][79]
According to Gallagher and Ashcraft, in contrast to psychotherapy, Hubbard stated that Dianetics "was more accessible to the average person, promised practitioners more immediate progress, and placed them in control of the therapy process." Hubbard's thought was parallel with the trend of humanist psychology at that time, which also came about in the 1950s.[78] Passas and Castillo write that the appeal of Dianetics was based on its consistency with prevailing values.[80] Shortly after the introduction of Dianetics, Hubbard introduced the concept of the "Thetan" (or soul) which he claimed to have discovered. Dianetics was organized and centralized to consolidate power under Hubbard, and groups that were previously recruited into Dianetics were no longer permitted to organize autonomously.[81]
Two of Hubbard's key supporters at the time were John W. Campbell Jr., the editor of Astounding Science Fiction, and Campbell's brother-in-law, physician Joseph A. Winter.[82] Dr. Winter, hoping to have Dianetics accepted in the medical community, submitted papers outlining the principles and methodology of Dianetic therapy to the Journal of the American Medical Association and the American Journal of Psychiatry in 1949, but these were rejected.[83][84]
Dianetics: The Modern Science of Mental Health spent six months on the New York Times bestseller list.[a][85] Publishers Weekly gave a posthumous plaque to Hubbard to commemorate Dianetics' appearance on its list of bestsellers for one hundred weeks.[74] Studies that address the topic of the origins of the work and its significance to Scientology as a whole include Peter Rowley's New Gods in America, Omar V. Garrison's The Hidden Story of Scientology, and Albert I. Berger's Towards a Science of the Nuclear Mind: Science-fiction Origins of Dianetics. More complex studies include Roy Wallis's The Road to Total Freedom.[74]
Dianetics appealed to a broad range of people who used instructions from the book and applied the method to each other, becoming practitioners themselves.[79] Dianetics soon faced criticism. Morris Fishbein, the editor of the Journal of the American Medical Association and well known at the time as a debunker of quack medicine, dismissed Hubbard's book.[86] An article in Newsweek stated that "the Dianetics concept is unscientific and unworthy of discussion or review".[87] Hubbard asserted that Dianetics is "an organized science of thought built on definite axioms: statements of natural laws on the order of those of the physical sciences".[88]
Hubbard became the leader of a growing Dianetics movement. He started giving talks about Dianetics and established the Hubbard Dianetic Research Foundation in Elizabeth, New Jersey, where he trained his first Dianetics "counselors" or auditors.[79]
Some practitioners of Dianetics reported experiences that they believed had occurred in past lives, or previous incarnations.[79] Hubbard took the reports of past life events seriously and introduced the concept of the Thetan, an immortal being analogous to the soul.[79] This was an important factor in the transition from secular Dianetics to the presenting of Scientology as an ostensible religion. Sociologists Roy Wallis and Steve Bruce suggest that Dianetics, which set each person as his or her own authority, was about to fail due to its inherent individualism, and that Hubbard started Scientology, framed as a religion, to establish himself as the overarching authority.[89][81]
Also in 1951, Hubbard incorporated the electropsychometer (E-meter for short), a kind of electrodermal activity meter, as an auditing aid. Based on a design by Volney Mathison, the device is held by Scientologists to be a useful tool in detecting changes in a person's state of mind. The global spread of Scientology in the latter half of the 1950s culminated with the opening of Church of Scientology buildings in Johannesburg and Paris, while world headquarters transferred to England in Saint Hill, a rural estate. Hubbard lived there for the next seven years.[90]
Dianetics is different from Scientology in that Scientology's advocates like to frame it as a religion. The purpose of Dianetics is the improvement of the individual, the individual or "self" being only one of eight "dynamics".[91] According to Hugh B. Urban, Hubbard's early science of Dianetics would be best comprehended as a "bricolage that brought together his various explorations in psychology, hypnosis, and science fiction". If Dianetics is understood as a bricolage, then Scientology is "an even more ambitious sort of religious bricolage adapted to the new religious marketplace of 1950s America", continues Urban. According to Roy Wallis, "Scientology emerged as a religious commodity eminently suited to the contemporary market of postwar America." L. Ron Hubbard Jr. said in an interview that the spiritual bricolage of Scientology, as written by Hugh B. Urban, "seemed to be uniquely suited to the individualism and quick-fix mentality of 1950s America: just by doing a few assignments, one can become a god".[7]
Harlan Ellison has told a story of seeing Hubbard at a gathering of the Hydra Club in 1953 or 1954. Hubbard was complaining of not being able to make a living on what he was being paid as a science fiction writer. Ellison says that Lester del Rey told Hubbard that what he needed to do to get rich was start a religion.[92]
Church of Scientology
In January 1951, the New Jersey Board of Medical Examiners began proceedings against the Hubbard Dianetic Research Foundation for teaching medicine without a license, which eventually led to that foundation's bankruptcy.[93][94][95] In December 1952, the Hubbard Dianetic Foundation filed for bankruptcy, and Hubbard lost control of the Dianetics trademark and copyrights to financier Don Purcell.[96] Author Russell Miller argues that Scientology "was a development of undeniable expedience, since it ensured that he would be able to stay in business even if the courts eventually awarded control of Dianetics and its valuable copyrights to ... Purcell".[97][98]
L. Ron Hubbard originally intended for Scientology to be considered a science, as stated in his writings. In May 1952, Scientology was organized to put this intended science into practice, and in the same year, Hubbard published a new set of teachings as Scientology, a religious philosophy.[99] Marco Frenschkowski quotes Hubbard in a letter written in 1953, to show that he never denied that his original approach was not a religious one: "Probably the greatest discovery of Scientology and its most forceful contribution to mankind has been the isolation, description and handling of the human spirit, accomplished in July 1951, in Phoenix, Arizona. I established, along scientific rather than religious or humanitarian lines that the thing which is the person, the personality, is separable from the body and the mind at will and without causing bodily death or derangement. (Hubbard 1983: 55)."[100]
Following the prosecution of Hubbard's foundation for teaching medicine without a license, in April 1953 Hubbard wrote a letter proposing that Scientology should be transformed into a religion.[101] As membership declined and finances grew tighter, Hubbard had reversed the hostility to religion he voiced in Dianetics.[102] His letter discussed the legal and financial benefits of religious status.[102] Hubbard outlined plans for setting up a chain of "Spiritual Guidance Centers" charging customers $500 for twenty-four hours of auditing ("That is real money ... Charge enough and we'd be swamped."). Hubbard wrote:[103]
I await your reaction on the religion angle. In my opinion, we couldn't get worse public opinion than we have had or have less customers with what we've got to sell. A religious charter would be necessary in Pennsylvania or NJ to make it stick. But I sure could make it stick.
In December 1953, Hubbard incorporated three organizations – a "Church of American Science", a "Church of Scientology" and a "Church of Spiritual Engineering" – in Camden, New Jersey.[104] On February 18, 1954, with Hubbard's blessing, some of his followers set up the first local Church of Scientology, the Church of Scientology of California, adopting the "aims, purposes, principles and creed of the Church of American Science, as founded by L. Ron Hubbard".[104] In 1955, Hubbard established the Founding Church of Scientology in Washington, D.C.[79] The group declared that the Founding Church, as written in the certificate of incorporation for the Founding Church of Scientology in the District of Columbia, was to "act as a parent church for the religious faith known as 'Scientology' and to act as a church for the religious worship of the faith".[105]
During this period the organization expanded to Australia, New Zealand, France, the United Kingdom and elsewhere. In 1959, Hubbard purchased Saint Hill Manor in East Grinstead, Sussex, United Kingdom, which became the worldwide headquarters of the Church of Scientology and his personal residence. During Hubbard's years at Saint Hill, he traveled, providing lectures and training in Australia, South Africa in the United States, and developing materials that would eventually become Scientology's "core systematic theology and praxis.[106] Throughout this period, Hubbard continued to develop the materials of Dianetics and Scientology as well as the organizational structure necessary to the administration of the Church of Scientology.[107]
The Scientology organization experienced further challenges. The United States Food and Drug Administration (FDA) began an investigation concerning the claims the Church of Scientology made in connection with its E-meters. On January 4, 1963, FDA agents raided offices of the organization, seizing hundreds of E-meters as illegal medical devices and tons of literature that they accused of making false medical claims.[108] The original suit by the FDA to condemn the literature and E-meters did not succeed,[109] but the court ordered the organization to label every meter with a disclaimer that it is purely religious artifact,[110] to post a $20,000 bond of compliance, and to pay the FDA's legal expenses.[111]
In the course of developing Scientology, Hubbard presented rapidly changing teachings that some have seen as often self-contradictory.[112][113] According to Lindholm, for the inner cadre of Scientologists in that period, involvement depended not so much on belief in a particular doctrine but on unquestioning faith in Hubbard.[113]
In 1966, Hubbard purportedly stepped down as executive director of Scientology to devote himself to research and writing.[79][115] The following year, he formed the ship-based Sea Organization or Sea Org which operated three ships: the Diana, the Athena, and the flagship the Apollo.[79] One month after the establishment of the Sea Org, Hubbard announced that he had made a breakthrough discovery, the result of which were the "OT III" materials purporting to provide a method for overcoming factors inhibiting spiritual progress. These materials were first disseminated on the ships, and then propagated by Sea Org members reassigned to staff Advanced Organizations on land.[citation needed]
Hubbard in hiding, death, and aftermath
In 1972, facing criminal charges in France, Hubbard returned to the United States and began living in an apartment in Queens, New York.[116] When faced with possible indictment in the United States, Hubbard went into hiding in April 1979. He hid first in an apartment in Hemet, California, where his only contact with the outside world was via ten trusted messengers. He cut contact with everyone else, even his wife, whom he saw for the last time in August 1979.[117] In February 1980 he disappeared into deep cover in the company of two trusted messengers, Pat and Anne Broeker.[118][119]
In 1979, as a result of FBI raids during Operation Snow White, 11 senior people in the organization's Guardian's Office were convicted of obstructing justice, burglary of government offices, and theft of documents and government property. In 1981, Scientology took the West German government to court for the first time.[120]
On January 24, 1986, L. Ron Hubbard died at his ranch in Creston, California.[121] David Miscavige emerged as the new head of the organization.
Splinter groups: Independent Scientology, Freezone, and Miscavige's RTC
While Scientology generally refers to the Miscavige-led Church of Scientology, other groups practice Scientology. These groups, collectively known as Independent Scientologists, consist of former members of the official Church of Scientology as well as entirely new members.
In 1950, founding member Joseph Winter cut ties with Hubbard and set up a private Dianetics practice in New York.[83] In 1965, a longtime member of the Scientology organization and "Doctor of Scientology" Jack Horner (born 1927), dissatisfied with the organization's "ethics" program, developed Dianology.[122] Capt. Bill Robertson, a former Sea Org member, was a primary instigator of the movement in the early 1980s.[123] The Church of Scientology labels these groups "squirrels" (Scientology jargon) and often subjects them to considerable legal and social pressure.[124][125][126]
On January 1, 1982, Miscavige established the Religious Technology Center (RTC).[127] On November 11, 1982, the Free Zone was established by top Scientologists in disagreement with RTC.[128] The Free Zone Association was founded and registered under the laws of Germany, and espouses the doctrine that the official Church of Scientology led by David Miscavige has departed from Hubbard's original philosophy.[129]
The Advanced Ability Center was established by Hubbard's personal auditor David Mayo after February 1983 – a time when some of Scientology's upper and middle management split with Miscavige's organization.[130]
More recently, high-profile defectors Mark Rathbun and Mike Rinder have championed the cause of Independent Scientologists wishing to practice Scientology outside of the Church of Scientology organization.[131][132]
Beliefs and practices
According to Scientology, its beliefs and practices are based on rigorous research, and its doctrines are accorded a significance equivalent to scientific laws.[133] Scientologist cosmology is, however, at odds with modern science, with claims of memories going back "76 trillion years",[134] much longer than the age of the universe. Blind belief is held to be of lesser significance than the practical application of Scientologist methods.[133] Adherents are encouraged to validate the practices through their personal experience.[133] Hubbard put it this way: "For a Scientologist, the final test of any knowledge he has gained is, 'did the data and the use of it in life actually improve conditions or didn't it?'"[133]
He defined Scientology's aims as: "A civilization without insanity, without criminals and without war; where the world can prosper and honest beings can have rights, and where man is free to rise to greater heights, are the aims of Scientology".[135][136] He described Scientology as an "applied religious philosophy" because, according to him, it consists of a metaphysical doctrine, a theory of psychology, and teachings in morality.[137] The core of Scientology teaching lies in the belief that "each human has a reactive mind that responds to life's traumas, clouding the analytic mind and keeping us from experiencing reality." Scientologists undergo auditing to discover sources of this trauma, believing that re-experiencing it neutralizes it and reinforces the ascendancy of the analytic mind, with the final goal believed to be achieving a spiritual state that Scientology calls "clear".[138]
Theological doctrine
Scientology claims not to preach or impose a particular idea of god on Scientologists. According to Scientology promotional materials, followers are expected to discover the truth through their own observations as their awareness advances.
... the Church of Scientology has no set dogma concerning God that it imposes on its members. As with all its tenets, Scientology does not ask individuals to accept anything on faith alone. Rather, as one's level of spiritual awareness increases through participation in Scientology auditing and training, one attains his own certainty of every dynamic. Accordingly, only when the Seventh Dynamic (spiritual) is reached in its entirety will one discover and come to a full understanding of the Eighth Dynamic (infinity) and one's relationship to the Supreme Being.[139]
Many Scientologists avoid using the words "belief" or "faith" to describe how Hubbard's teachings impacts their lives. They perceive that Scientology is based on verifiable technologies, speaking to Hubbard's original scientific objectives for Dianetics, based on the quantifiability of auditing on the E-meter. Scientologists call Dianetics and Scientology as technologies because of their claim of their scientific precision and workability.[140]
Reactive mind, traumatic memories, and auditing
Scientology presents two major divisions of the mind.[141] The reactive mind is thought to record all pain and emotional trauma, while the analytical mind is a rational mechanism that serves consciousness.[142][143] The reactive mind stores mental images which are not readily available to the analytical (conscious) mind; these are referred to as engrams.[144] According to Scientology, engrams are painful and debilitating; as they accumulate, people move further away from their true identity.[145] To avoid this fate is Scientology's basic goal.[145]
Some engrams are taught by Hubbard to happen by accident while others are inflicted by "Thetans who have gone bad and want power", as described by the Los Angeles Times. These engrams are named Implants in the doctrine of Scientology. Hubbard said, "Implants result in all varieties of illness, apathy, degradation, neurosis and insanity and are the principal cause of these in man."[146]
L. Ron Hubbard described the analytical mind in terms of a computer: "the analytical mind is not just a good computer, it is a perfect computer." According to him it makes the best decisions based on available data. Errors are made based on erroneous data and is not the error of the analytical mind.[140]
David V. Barrett, a sociologist of religion who has written widely about the subject, says that according to Scientology, the "first major goal is to go Clear." Clearing was described to represent "the attainment of Man's dreams through the ages of attaining a new and higher state of existence and freedom from the endless cycle of birth, death, birth … Clear is the total erasure of the reactive mind from which stems all the anxieties and problems the individual has".[147]
Scientology asserts that people have hidden abilities which have not yet been fully realized.[148] It teaches that increased spiritual awareness and physical benefits are accomplished through sessions referred to as "auditing", for which the organization charges hundreds of dollars per hour. There is no evidence of any of these notional benefits being realized.[149] Scientology doctrine claims that through auditing, people can solve their problems and free themselves of engrams.[150] It also claims that this restores them to their "natural condition" as Thetans and enables them to be "at cause" in their daily lives, responding rationally and creatively to life events, rather than reacting to them under the direction of stored engrams.[151] Accordingly, those who study Scientology materials and receive auditing sessions advance from a status of Preclear to Clear and Operating Thetan.[152] Scientology's utopian aim is to "clear the planet", that is, clear all people in the world of their engrams.[153]
Auditing is a one-on-one session with a Scientology "counselor" or "auditor."[154] The auditor's task is to help a person discover and understand the "universal principles of affinity, reality, and communication" (ARC).[154] Most auditing requires an E‑meter, a device that measures minute changes in electrical resistance through the body when a person holds electrodes (metal "cans"), and a small current is passed through them.[150][154]
Scientology teaches that the E-meter helps to locate spiritual difficulties.[154] Once an area of concern has been identified, the auditor asks the individual specific questions about it to help him or her eliminate the difficulty, and uses the E-meter to confirm that the "charge" has been dissipated.[154] As the individual progresses up the "Bridge to Total Freedom", the focus of auditing moves from simple engrams to engrams of increasing complexity and other difficulties.[154] At the more advanced OT levels, Scientologists act as their own auditors ("solo auditors").[154]
Douglas E. Cowan writes that the e-meter "provides an external, material locus for the legitimation of [Scientology] practice". Scientologists depend on the "appearance of objectivity or empirical validity" of the e-meter rather than simply trusting an auditor's abstract interpretation of a participant's statements. He also states that without the e-meter, "Scientology could not have achieved whatever status it enjoys as a new religious movement." He also argues that without it, the Church of Scientology may not have survived the early years when Dianetics was just formed.[155]
Emotional Tone Scale and survival
Scientology uses an emotional classification system called the tone scale.[156] The tone scale is a tool used in auditing; Scientologists maintain that knowing a person's place on the scale makes it easier to predict his or her actions and assists in bettering his or her condition.[157]
Scientology emphasizes the importance of survival, which it subdivides into eight classifications that are referred to as "dynamics".[158] An individual's desire to survive is considered to be the first dynamic, while the second dynamic relates to procreation and family.[158] The remaining dynamics encompass wider fields of action, involving groups, mankind, all life, the physical universe, the spirit, and infinity, often associated with the Supreme Being.[158] The optimum solution to any problem is believed to be the one that brings the greatest benefit to the greatest number of dynamics.[158]
Toxins and purification
The Purification Rundown[159] is a controversial "detoxification" program used by the Church of Scientology as an introductory service.[159][160] It features high-dose dietary supplements and extended time in a sauna (up to five hours a day for five weeks).[161] The Church of Scientology claims it is the only effective way to deal with the long-term effects of drug abuse or toxic exposure.[160]
Narconon is a "drug education and rehabilitation program" founded on Hubbard's beliefs about "toxins" and "purification".[162] Narconon is offered in the United States, Canada and a number of European countries; its Purification Program also uses high-dose vitamins and extended sauna sessions, combined with auditing and study.[162]
Introspection Rundown
The Introspection Rundown is a controversial Church of Scientology auditing process that is intended to handle a psychotic episode or complete mental breakdown. Introspection is defined for the purpose of this rundown as a condition where the person is "looking into one's own mind, feelings, reactions, etc."[163] The Introspection Rundown came under public scrutiny after the death of Lisa McPherson in 1995.[164]
Rejection of psychology and psychiatry
Scientology is vehemently opposed to psychiatry and psychology.[165][166][167] Psychiatry rejected Hubbard's theories in the early 1950s and in 1951, Hubbard's wife Sara consulted doctors who recommended he "be committed to a private sanatorium for psychiatric observation and treatment of a mental ailment known as paranoid schizophrenia".[168][169] Thereafter, Hubbard criticized psychiatry as a "barbaric and corrupt profession".
Hubbard taught that psychiatrists were responsible for a great many wrongs in the world, saying that psychiatry has at various times offered itself as a tool of political suppression and "that psychiatry spawned the ideology which fired Hitler's mania, turned the Nazis into mass murderers, and created the Holocaust".[168] Hubbard created the anti-psychiatry organization Citizens Commission on Human Rights (CCHR), which operates Psychiatry: An Industry of Death, an anti-psychiatry museum.[168]
From 1969, CCHR has campaigned in opposition to psychiatric treatments, electroconvulsive shock therapy, lobotomy, and drugs such as Ritalin and Prozac.[170] According to the official Church of Scientology website, "the effects of medical and psychiatric drugs, whether painkillers, tranquilizers or 'antidepressants', are as disastrous" as illegal drugs.[138]
Body and Thetan
Scientology beliefs revolve around the immortal soul, the Thetan.[142][145][171] Scientology teaches that the Thetan is the true identity of a person – an intrinsically good, omniscient, non-material core capable of unlimited creativity.[142][145]
Hubbard taught that Thetans brought the material universe into being largely for their own pleasure.[145] The universe has no independent reality but derives its apparent reality from the fact that Thetans agree it exists.[142] Thetans fell from grace when they began to identify with their creation rather than their original state of spiritual purity.[145] Eventually they lost their memory of their true nature, along with the associated spiritual and creative powers. As a result, Thetans came to think of themselves as nothing but embodied beings.[142]
Thetans are reborn time and time again in new bodies through a process called "assumption", which is analogous to reincarnation.[145] Scientology posits a causal relationship between the experiences of earlier incarnations and one's present life, and with each rebirth, the effects of the MEST universe (MEST here stands for matter, energy, space, and time) on the Thetan become stronger.[145]
Space opera and the Wall of Fire
The Church of Scientology organization holds that at the higher levels of initiation ("OT levels"), mystical teachings are imparted that may be harmful to unprepared readers. These teachings are kept secret from members who have not reached these levels. The organization says that the secrecy is warranted to keep its materials' use in context and to protect its members from being exposed to materials for which they are not yet prepared.[150]
These are the OT levels, the levels above Clear, whose contents are guarded within Scientology. The OT level teachings include accounts of various cosmic catastrophes that befell the Thetans. Hubbard described these early events collectively as "space opera".[citation needed]
In the OT levels, Hubbard explains how to reverse the effects of past-life trauma patterns that supposedly extend millions of years into the past.[172] Among these advanced teachings is the story of Xenu (sometimes Xemu), introduced as the tyrant ruler of the "Galactic Confederacy". According to this story, 75 million years ago Xenu brought billions of people to Earth in spacecraft resembling Douglas DC-8 airliners, stacked them around volcanoes and detonated hydrogen bombs in the volcanoes. The Thetans then clustered together, stuck to the bodies of the living, and continue to do this today. Scientologists at advanced levels place considerable emphasis on isolating body Thetans and neutralizing their ill effects.[173]
Excerpts and descriptions of OT materials were published online by a former member in 1995 and then circulated in mainstream media. This occurred after the teachings were submitted as evidence in court cases involving Scientology, thus becoming a matter of public record.[172][174] There are eight publicly known OT levels, OT I to VIII.[175] The highest level, OT VIII, is disclosed only at sea on the Scientology cruise ship Freewinds.[175] It has been rumored that additional OT levels, said to be based on material written by Hubbard long ago, will be released at some appropriate point in the future.[176]
A large Church of Spiritual Technology symbol carved into the ground at Scientology's Trementina Base is visible from the air.[177] Washington Post reporter Richard Leiby wrote, "Former Scientologists familiar with Hubbard's teachings on reincarnation say the symbol marks a 'return point' so loyal staff members know where they can find the founder's works when they travel here in the future from other places in the universe."[178]
Ethics, suppressives, and disconnection
The Ethics system regulates member behavior,[179] and Ethics officers are present in every Scientology organization. Ethics officers ensure "correct application of Scientology technology" and deal with "behavior adversely affecting a Scientology organization's performance", ranging from "Errors" and "Misdemeanors" to "Crimes" and "Suppressive Acts", as those terms defined by Scientology.[180]
Scientology asserts some people are truly malevolent, and Hubbard taught 20 percent of the population were suppressive persons, which includes some hopelessly antisocial personalities who are the truly dangerous individuals in humanity: "the Adolf Hitlers and the Genghis Khans, the unrepentant murderers and the drug lords".[181][182] Scientology disconnection policy prohibits most contact with Suppressive Persons.[181][182] The Church of Scientology organization denies that a disconnection policy exists, and quotes Hubbard's definition of disconnection as "a self-determined decision made by an individual that he is not going to be connected to another".[183]
A Scientologist who communicates with a suppressive person risks being declared a Potential Trouble Source.[184][185] Defectors who turn into critics of the movement are declared suppressive persons,[186][187][188][189] and the Church of Scientology has a reputation for moving aggressively against such detractors.[citation needed]
Fair game
The term Fair Game is used to describe policies and practices carried out against people the Scientology organization perceives as its enemies. Hubbard established the policy in the 1950s, in response to criticism both from within and outside his organization.[31][32] Individuals or groups who are "Fair Game" are judged to be a threat to the organization and, according to the policy, can be punished and harassed using any and all means possible.[31][32]
Hubbard and his followers targeted many individuals as well as government officials and agencies, including a program of illegal infiltration of the IRS and other U.S. government agencies during the 1970s.[31][32] They also conducted private investigations, character assassination and legal action against the organization's critics in the media.[31] The policy remains in effect and has been defended by the Church of Scientology as a core "religious practice".[190][191][192]
Scientology ceremonies
In Scientology, ceremonies for events such as weddings, child naming, and funerals are observed.[145] Friday services are held to commemorate the completion of a person's services during the prior week.[145] Ordained Scientology ministers may perform such rites.[145] However, these services and the clergy who perform them play only a minor role in Scientologists' lives.[193]
Church of Scientology organization
The internal structure of Scientology organizations is strongly bureaucratic with a focus on statistics-based management.[179] Organizational operating budgets are performance-related and subject to frequent reviews.[179]
Membership statistics
The 2008 American Religious Identification Survey estimated there were around 25,000 Scientologists in the United States.[194][195][196][197][198] That was a drop from the 2001 ARIS survey that estimated 55,000 people in the U.S. claimed to be Scientologists. In 2010, Barry Kosmin, the principal ARIS researcher, said though the sample size was too small to reliably count Scientologists, the data strongly suggested that the number of Scientologists in the U.S. was in the tens of thousands.[199] Worldwide estimates of Scientology's core practicing membership range between 40,000 and 200,000, and are mostly in the U.S., Europe, South Africa and Australia.[150] Scientology membership has also been declining in the United Kingdom.[200][195] In 2011, high-level defector Jeff Hawkins estimated there were 40,000 Scientologists worldwide.[195] According to the 2016 Australian census data, less than 1,700 people listed themselves as Scientologists.[201][15]
Although the Church of Scientology claims to be the "fastest growing religious movement" on Earth, the organization's estimates of its membership numbers "in the millions" are significantly exaggerated.[202][203][204][199]
Sea Org
The highest ranking people in the Scientology hierarchy are the members of the Sea Organization, or Sea Org.[179] The organization includes some 5,000 of Scientology's most dedicated adherents, who work for low pay, and sign a billion-year contract.[179]
Rehabilitation Project Force
The Rehabilitation Project Force (RPF) is a controversial part of the Scientology "justice" system.[180] When Sea Org members are found guilty of a violation, they are assigned to the RPF.[180] The RPF involves a daily regimen of five hours of auditing or studying, eight hours of work, often physical labor, such as building renovation, and at least seven hours of sleep.[180] Douglas E. Cowan and David G. Bromley state that scholars and observers have come to radically different conclusions about the RPF and whether it is "voluntary or coercive, therapeutic or punitive".[180] The Church of Scientology has been criticized for having children as young as twelve on the RPF, for forced labor and denial of access to their parents as a violation of Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights.[205]
Office of Special Affairs
The Office of Special Affairs or OSA (formerly the Guardian's Office) is a department of the Church of Scientology which has been characterized as a non-state intelligence agency.[206][207][208] It has targeted critics of the organization for "dead agent" operations, which is mounting character assassination operations against perceived enemies.[209]
A 1990 article in the Los Angeles Times reported that in the 1980s the Scientology organization more commonly used private investigators, including former and current Los Angeles police officers, to give themselves a layer of protection in case embarrassing tactics were used and became public.[210]
Church of Spiritual Technology
The Church of Spiritual Technology (CST) has been described as the "most secret organization in all of Scientology".[211] The organization owns the copyrights to all Scientology materials and the bulk of Hubbard's estate. CST licenses this intellectual property to the Religious Technology Center who then sub-licenses it to Church of Scientology International.
The organization also operates the Scientology archiving project, which aims to preserve the works of Hubbard on stainless steel tablets, encased in titanium capsules in specially constructed vaults throughout the world. In addition, the group maintains fully-furnished homes in multiple locations intended to eventually accommodate the reincarnated L. Ron Hubbard.
Shelly Miscavige, wife of leader David Miscavige, who hasn't been seen in public since 2007, is said to be held at a CST compound in Twin Peaks, California.[212][213]
Franchises and advanced organizations
Scientology operates hundreds of Churches and Missions around the world.[162] This is where Scientologists receive introductory training, and it is at this local level that most Scientologists participate.[162] Churches and Missions are licensed franchises; they may offer services for a fee provided they contribute a proportion of their income and comply with the Religious Technology Center (RTC) and its standards.[162][214]
Operating Thetan levels are offered only at Scientology's Advanced Organizations (Los Angeles, Sydney, East Grinstead and Copenhagen). The Flag Service Organization in Clearwater, Florida offers OT levels VI and VII. The Scientology ship Freewinds offers OT VIII.[citation needed]
Celebrity Centres
In 1955, Hubbard created a list of 63 celebrities targeted for conversion to Scientology.[215] In a Church of Scientology policy letter in 1973, L. Ron Hubbard wrote, "The purpose of [the] Celebrity Centre is, to forward the expansion and popularization of Scientology through the arts."[216]
Scientology operates eight locations that are designated Celebrity Centres, designed to minister to celebrity Scientologists.[217] The largest of these is in Hollywood, California, called Church of Scientology Celebrity Centre International.[217] The Celebrity Centre International was the first one that was opened in 1969 and its opening is celebrated the first week of August each year in an evening gala.[218]
Former silent-screen star Gloria Swanson and actors Tom Cruise and John Travolta have spoken publicly about their commitment to Scientology.[215][219][220]
Scientology tech in jails and prisons, schools, and management
The applicability of Hubbard's teachings also led to the formation of secular organizations focused on fields such as drug abuse awareness and rehabilitation, literacy, and human rights.[221] Several Scientology organizations promote the use of Scientology practices as a means to solve social problems. Scientology began to focus on these issues in the early 1970s, led by Hubbard. The Church of Scientology developed outreach programs to fight drug addiction, illiteracy, learning disabilities and criminal behavior. These have been presented to schools, businesses and communities as secular techniques based on Hubbard's writings.[222] The Association for Better Living and Education (ABLE) acts as an umbrella organization for these efforts.[citation needed] Notable examples include:
- Narconon is a Scientology organization promoting the theories of founder L. Ron Hubbard regarding substance abuse treatment and addiction.
- Criminon, an offshoot of Narconon, introduces Scientology practices to criminal offenders.[162]
- Applied Scholastics, founded in 1972, teaches Scientology "study tech" to K-12 students.[223] Delphi Schools operates numerous private schools throughout the United States, including the flagship academy The Delphian School in Yamhill County, Oregon.
- The World Institute of Scientology Enterprises (WISE) applies Scientology practices to business management.[223] The most prominent training supplier to make use of Hubbard's technology is Sterling Management Systems.[223]
- The Way to Happiness Foundation promotes a moral code written by Hubbard, to date translated into more than 40 languages.[223]
Volunteer ministers
The Church of Scientology began its "Volunteer Ministers" program as a way to participate in community outreach projects. Volunteer Ministers sometimes travel to the scenes of major disasters in order to provide assistance with relief efforts. According to critics, these relief efforts consist of passing out copies of a pamphlet authored by Hubbard entitled The Way to Happiness, and engaging in a method said to calm panicked or injured individuals known in Scientology as a "touch assist". Accounts of the Volunteer Ministers' effectiveness have been mixed, and touch assists are not supported by scientific evidence.[224][225][226]
Other entities
Other Scientology-related organizations include:
- International Association of Scientologists (IAS) – Scientology membership organization.
- The National Commission on Law Enforcement and Social Justice – Opposes what it describes as abusive practices by government and police agencies, especially Interpol.[168]
- Scientologists Taking Action Against Discrimination (STAND) – Organization which does public relations for Scientology and Scientologists.[227]
Assets
According to leaked tax documents, the Church of Scientology International and Church of Spiritual Technology in the US had a combined $1.7 billion in assets in 2012, in addition to annual revenues estimated at $200 million a year.[228] This does not include assets and revenue of International Association of Scientologists.
Controversies
The Church of Scientology is a highly controversial organization. A first point of controversy was its challenge of the psychotherapeutic establishment. Another was a 1991 Time magazine article that attacked the organization, which responded with a major lawsuit that was rejected by the court as baseless early in 1992. A third is its religious tax status in the United States, as the IRS granted the organization tax-exempt status in 1993.[231]
It has been in conflict with the governments and police forces of many countries (including the United States, the United Kingdom, Canada,[232] France[233] and Germany).[18][234][235][236][237] It has been one of the most litigious religious movements in history, filing countless lawsuits against governments, organizations and individuals.[238]
Reports and allegations have been made, by journalists, courts, and governmental bodies of several countries, that the Church of Scientology is an unscrupulous commercial enterprise that harasses its critics and brutally exploits its members.[235][236] A considerable amount of investigation has been aimed at the organization, by groups ranging from the media to governmental agencies.[235][236]
The controversies involving the Church of Scientology, some of them ongoing, include:
- Criminal behavior by members of the organization, including the infiltration of the US Government.[234]
- Organized harassment of people perceived as enemies of the Church of Scientology.[234]
- Scientology's disconnection policy, in which some members are required to shun friends or family members who are "antagonistic" to the organization.[200][239]
- The death of Scientologist Lisa McPherson while in the care of the organization. (Robert Minton sponsored the multimillion-dollar lawsuit against Scientology for the death of McPherson. In May 2004, McPherson's estate and the Church of Scientology reached a confidential settlement.)[240]
- Attempts to legally force search engines to censor information critical of the Scientology organization.[241]
- Allegations the organization's leader David Miscavige beats and demoralizes staff, and that physical violence by superiors towards staff working for them is a common occurrence in the organization.[242][243] Scientology spokesman Tommy Davis denied these claims and provided witnesses to rebut them.[242]
Scientology social programs such as drug and criminal rehabilitation have likewise drawn both support and criticism.[244][245][246]
Stephen A. Kent, a professor of sociology, has said that "Scientologists see themselves as possessors of doctrines and skills that can save the world, if not the galaxy."[247] As stated in Scientology doctrine: "The whole agonized future of this planet, every man, woman and child on it, and your own destiny for the next endless trillions of years depend on what you do here and now with and in Scientology."[248] Kent has described Scientology's ethics system as "a peculiar brand of morality that uniquely benefited [the Church of Scientology] ... In plain English, the purpose of Scientology ethics is to eliminate opponents, then eliminate people's interests in things other than Scientology."[205]
Many former members have come forward to speak out about the organization and the negative effects its teachings have had on them, including celebrities such as Leah Remini. Remini spoke about her split from the Church of Scientology, saying that she still has friends within the organization whom she is no longer able to speak with.[249]
Criminal behavior
Much of the controversy surrounding Scientology stems from the criminal convictions of core members of the Scientology organization.
In 1978, a number of Scientologists, including L. Ron Hubbard's wife Mary Sue Hubbard (who was second in command in the organization at the time), were convicted of perpetrating what was at the time the largest incident of domestic espionage in the history of the United States, called "Operation Snow White". This involved infiltrating, wiretapping, and stealing documents from the offices of Federal attorneys and the Internal Revenue Service.[250] L. Ron Hubbard was convicted in absentia by French authorities of engaging in fraud and sentenced to four years in prison.[33] The head of the French Church of Scientology was convicted at the same trial and given a suspended one-year prison sentence.[251]
An FBI raid on the Church of Scientology's headquarters revealed documentation that detailed Scientology's criminal actions against various critics of the organization. In "Operation Freakout", agents of the organization attempted to destroy Paulette Cooper, author of The Scandal of Scientology, an early book that had been critical of the movement.[252] Among these documents was a plan to frame Gabe Cazares, the mayor of Clearwater, Florida, with a staged hit-and-run accident. Nine individuals related to the case were prosecuted on charges of theft, burglary, conspiracy, and other crimes.
In 1988, Scientology president Heber Jentzsch and ten other members of the organization were arrested in Spain on various charges including illicit association, coercion, fraud, and labor law violations.[253]
In October 2009, the Church of Scientology was found guilty of organized fraud in France.[254] The sentence was confirmed by the court of appeal in February 2012, and by the supreme Court of Cassation in October 2013.[255][36]
In 2012, Belgian prosecutors indicted Scientology as a criminal organization engaged in fraud and extortion.[256][257][258] In March 2016, the Church of Scientology was acquitted of all charges, and demands to close its Belgian branch and European headquarters were dismissed.[259]
Organized harassment
Scientology has historically engaged in hostile action toward its critics; executives within the organization have proclaimed that Scientology is "not a turn-the-other-cheek religion".[260] Journalists, politicians, former Scientologists and various anti-cult groups have made accusations of wrongdoing against Scientology since the 1960s, and Scientology has targeted these critics – almost without exception – for retaliation, in the form of lawsuits and public counter-accusations of personal wrongdoing. Many of Scientology's critics have also reported they were subject to threats and harassment in their private lives.[261][262]
According to a 1990 Los Angeles Times article, Scientology had largely switched from using Church members to using private investigators, including former and current Los Angeles police officers, as this gives the organization a layer of protection in case investigators use tactics which might cause the organization embarrassment. In one case, the organization described their tactics as "LAPD sanctioned", which was energetically disputed by Police Chief Daryl Gates. The officer involved in this particular case of surveillance and harassment was suspended for six months.[210]
Journalist John Sweeney reported that "While making our BBC Panorama film Scientology and Me I have been shouted at, spied on, had my hotel invaded at midnight, denounced as a 'bigot' by star Scientologists, brain-washed—that is how it felt to me—in a mock up of a Nazi-style torture chamber and chased round the streets of Los Angeles by sinister strangers".[263]
Violation of auditing confidentiality
During the auditing process, the auditor collects and records personal information from the client.[264]
While the Church of Scientology claims to protect the confidentiality of auditing records, the organization has a history of attacking and psychologically abusing former members using information culled from the records.[264] For example, a December 16, 1969, a Guardian's Office order (G. O. 121669) by Mary Sue Hubbard explicitly authorized the use of auditing records for purposes of "internal security".[265] Former members report having participated in combing through information obtained in auditing sessions to see if it could be used for smear campaigns against critics.[266][267]
Disconnection
The practice of shunning in Scientology is termed "disconnection". Members can disconnect from any person they already know, including existing family members. Many examples of this policy's application have been established in court.[268][269][270] Failure to disconnect from a Suppressive Person is itself labeled a Suppressive act.[271]
Allegation of coerced abortions
The Sea Org originally operated on vessels at sea where it was understood that it was not permitted to raise children on board the ships.[205][failed verification] Pregnant women in the Sea Org have stated that they had been pressured to undergo abortions.[205][failed verification]
In 2003, The Times of India reported "Forced abortions, beatings, starvation are considered tools of discipline in this church".[272]
A former high-ranking source reports that "some 1,500 abortions" have been "carried out by women in the Sea Organization since the implementation of a rule in the late 80s that members could not remain in the organization if they decided to have children". The source noted that "And if members who have been in the Sea Organization for, say, 10 years do decide to have kids, they are dismissed with no more than $1,000" as a severance package.[273]
Many former members have said they were pressured to undergo abortion.
Longtime member Astra Woodcraft reportedly "left Scientology for good when the church tried to pressure her to have an abortion".[274][275] Former Sea Org member Karen Pressley recounted that she was often asked by fellow Scientologists for loans so that they could get an abortion and remain in the Sea Org.[276][277][278] Scientology employee Claire Headley has said she "was forced to have (two) abortions to keep her job and was subjected to violations of personal rights and liberties for the purpose of obtaining forced labor".[279] Laura Ann DeCrescenzo reported she was "coerced to have an abortion" as a minor.[280]
In March 2009, Maureen Bolstad reported that women who worked at Scientology's headquarters were forced to have abortions, or faced being declared a "Suppressive Person" by the organization's management.[281] In March 2010, former Scientologist Janette Lang stated that at age 20 she became pregnant by her boyfriend while in the organization,[282] and her boyfriend's Scientology supervisors "coerced them into terminating the pregnancy".[283] "We fought for a week, I was devastated, I felt abused, I was lost and eventually I gave in. It was my baby, my body and my choice, and all of that was taken away from me by Scientology," said Lang.[283][284]
Australian Senator Nick Xenophon gave a speech to the Australian Parliament in November 2009, about statements he had received from former Scientologists.[285] He said that he had been told members of the organization had coerced pregnant female employees to have abortions.[285] "I am deeply concerned about this organisation and the devastating impact it can have on its followers," said Senator Xenophon, and he requested that the Australian Senate begin an investigation into Scientology.[285] According to the letters presented by Senator Xenophon, the organization was involved in "ordering" its members to have abortions.[286]
Former Scientologist Aaron Saxton sent a letter to Senator Xenophon stating he had participated in coercing pregnant women within the organization to have abortions.[287] "Aaron says women who fell pregnant were taken to offices and bullied to have an abortion. If they refused, they faced demotion and hard labour. Aaron says one staff member used a coat hanger and self-aborted her child for fear of punishment," said Senator Xenophon.[288] Carmel Underwood, another former Scientologist, said she had been put under "extreme pressure" to have an abortion,[289] and that she was placed into a "disappearing programme", after refusing.[290] Underwood was the executive director of Scientology's branch in Sydney, Australia.[288]
Scientology spokesman Tommy Davis said these statements are "utterly meritless".[279] Mike Ferriss, the head of Scientology in New Zealand, told media that "There are no forced abortions in Scientology".[291] Scientology spokesperson Virginia Stewart likewise rejected the statements and asserted "The Church of Scientology considers the family unit and children to be of the utmost importance and does not condone nor force anyone to undertake any medical procedure whatsoever."[292]
Allegation of human trafficking and other crimes against women
A number of women have sued the Church of Scientology, alleging a variety of complaints including human trafficking, rape, forced labor, and child abuse.[293]
Scientology, litigation, and the Internet
In the 1990s, Miscavige's organization took action against increased criticism of Scientology on the Internet and online distribution of Scientology-related documents.[294]
Starting in 1991, Scientology filed fifty lawsuits against Scientology-critic Cult Awareness Network (CAN).[295] Many of the suits were dismissed, but one resulted in $2 million in losses, bankrupting the network.[295] At bankruptcy, CAN's name and logo were obtained by a Scientologist.[295][296] A New Cult Awareness Network was set up with Scientology backing, which says it operates as an information and networking center for non-traditional religions, referring callers to academics and other experts.[297][298]
In a 1993 U.S. lawsuit brought by the Church of Scientology against former member Steven Fishman, Fishman made a court declaration which included several dozen pages of formerly secret esoterica detailing aspects of Scientologist cosmogony.[299] As a result of the litigation, this material, normally strictly safeguarded and used only in Scientology's more advanced "OT levels", found its way onto the Internet.[299] This resulted in a battle between the Church of Scientology and its online critics over the right to disclose this material, or safeguard its confidentiality.[299] The Church of Scientology was forced to issue a press release acknowledging the existence of this cosmogony, rather than allow its critics "to distort and misuse this information for their own purposes".[299] Even so, the material, notably the story of Xenu, has since been widely disseminated and used to caricature Scientology, despite the Church of Scientology's vigorous program of copyright litigation.[299]
In January 1995, Church of Scientology lawyer Helena Kobrin attempted to shut down the newsgroup alt.religion.scientology by sending a control message instructing Usenet servers to delete the group.[300] In practice, this rmgroup message had little effect, since most Usenet servers are configured to disregard such messages when sent to groups that receive substantial traffic, and newgroup messages were quickly issued to recreate the group on those servers that did not do so. However, the issuance of the message led to a great deal of public criticism by free-speech advocates.[301][302] Among the criticisms raised, one suggestion is that Scientology's true motive is to suppress the free speech of its critics.[303][304]
The Church of Scientology also began filing lawsuits against those who posted copyrighted texts on the newsgroup and the World Wide Web, lobbied for tighter restrictions on copyrights in general, and supported the controversial Sonny Bono Copyright Term Extension Act as well as the even more controversial Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA).
Beginning in the middle of 1996 and ensuing for several years, the newsgroup was attacked by anonymous parties using a tactic dubbed sporgery by some, in the form of hundreds of thousands of forged spam messages posted on the group. Some investigators said that some spam had been traced to members of the Church of Scientology.[306][307] Former Scientologist Tory Christman later asserted that the Office of Special Affairs had undertaken a concerted effort to destroy alt.religion.scientology through these means; the effort failed.[308]
On January 14, 2008, a video produced by the Church of Scientology featuring an interview with Tom Cruise was leaked to the Internet and uploaded to YouTube.[309][310][311] The Church of Scientology issued a copyright violation claim against YouTube requesting the removal of the video.[312] Calling the action by the Church of Scientology a form of Internet censorship, participants of Anonymous coordinated Project Chanology, consisting of a series of denial-of-service attacks against Scientology websites, prank calls, and black faxes to Scientology centers.[313][314][315][316][317]
On January 21, 2008, Anonymous announced its intentions via a video posted to YouTube entitled "Message to Scientology", and a press release declaring a "war" against the Church of Scientology and the Religious Technology Center.[316][318] In the press release, the group stated that the attacks against the Church of Scientology would continue in order to protect the freedom of speech, and end what they saw as the financial exploitation of members of the organization.[319]
On January 28, 2008, an Anonymous video appeared on YouTube calling for protests outside Church of Scientology buildings on February 10, 2008.[320][321] The date was chosen because it was the birthday of Lisa McPherson.[322] According to a letter Anonymous e-mailed to the press, about 7,000 people protested in more than 90 cities worldwide.[323] Many protesters wore masks based on the character V from V for Vendetta (who was influenced by Guy Fawkes) or otherwise disguised their identities, in part to protect themselves from reprisals from the Church of Scientology.[324][325] Many further protests have followed since then in cities around the world.[326]
The Arbitration Committee of the Wikipedia internet encyclopedia decided in May 2009 to restrict access to its site from Church of Scientology IP addresses, to prevent self-serving edits by Scientologists.[327][328] A "host of anti-Scientologist editors" were topic-banned as well.[327][328] The committee concluded that both sides had "gamed policy" and resorted to "battlefield tactics", with articles on living persons being the "worst casualties".[327]
Disputes over legal status
The legal status of Scientology or Scientology-related organizations differs between jurisdictions.[44][45][329] Scientology was legally recognized as a tax-exempt religion in Australia,[46] Portugal,[330] and Spain.[331] Scientology was granted tax-exempt status in the United States in 1993.[332][333][334][335] The organization is considered a cult in Chile and an "anticonstitutional sect" in Germany,[49] and is considered a cult (French secte) by some French public authorities.[50]
The Church of Scientology argues that Scientology is a genuine religious movement that has been misrepresented, maligned, and persecuted.[336][337] The organization has pursued an extensive public relations campaign for the recognition of Scientology as a tax-exempt religion in the various countries in which it exists.[338][339][340]
The Church of Scientology has often generated opposition due to its strong-arm tactics directed against critics and members wishing to leave the organization.[187] A minority of governments regard it as a religious organization entitled to tax-exempt status, while other governments variously classify it as a business, cult, pseudoreligion, or criminal organization.[203][341]
In 1957, the Church of Scientology of California was granted tax-exempt status by the United States Internal Revenue Service (IRS), and so, for a time, were other local branches of the organization.[48] In 1958 however, the IRS started a review of the appropriateness of this status.[28] In 1959, Hubbard moved to England, remaining there until the mid-1960s.[79]
In the mid-sixties, the Church of Scientology was banned in several Australian states, starting with Victoria in 1965.[28] The ban was based on the Anderson Report, which found that the auditing process involved "command" hypnosis, in which the hypnotist assumes "positive authoritative control" over the patient. On this point the report stated,[342]
It is the firm conclusion of this Board that most scientology and dianetic techniques are those of authoritative hypnosis and as such are dangerous ... the scientific evidence which the Board heard from several expert witnesses of the highest repute ... leads to the inescapable conclusion that it is only in name that there is any difference between authoritative hypnosis and most of the techniques of scientology. Many scientology techniques are in fact hypnotic techniques, and Hubbard has not changed their nature by changing their names.
The Australian Church was forced to operate under the name of the "Church of the New Faith" as a result, the name and practice of Scientology having become illegal in the relevant states. Several years of court proceedings aimed at overturning the ban followed.[citation needed] In 1973, state laws banning Scientology were overturned in Victoria, South Australia and Western Australia. In 1983 the High Court of Australia ruled in a unanimous decision that the Church of Scientology was "undoubtedly a religion and deserving of tax exemption".[47]
In 1967, the IRS removed Scientology's tax-exempt status, asserting that its activities were commercial and operated for the benefit of Hubbard, rather than for charitable or religious purposes.[48]
Scientology as a religion
Scientology is officially recognized as a religion in the United States.[332][333][334][335] Recognition came in 1993,[343] when the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) stated that "[Scientology is] operated exclusively for religious and charitable purposes."[344][345] Scientology was again recognized as a religion by the U.S. courts when the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed the judgment in Headley v. Church of Scientology International in 2012.[346]
The New York Times noted in this connection that the Church of Scientology had funded a campaign which included a whistle-blower organization to publicly attack the IRS, as well as hiring of private investigators to look into the private lives of IRS officials.[48] In 1991, Miscavige, the highest-ranking Scientology leader, arranged a meeting with Fred T. Goldberg Jr., the Commissioner of the Internal Revenue Service at the time.[347] According to the Church of Scientology's version of events, the meeting was an opportunity for the organization to offer to end its long dispute with the IRS, including the dozens of suits brought against the agency, in exchange for the exemptions that Scientology believed it deserved. Goldberg's response was quite out of the ordinary: he created a special working group to resolve the dispute, bypassing the agency's exempt organizations division. The group met several times with the Scientology legal team and, according to an unnamed official quoted by the New York Times, "was persuaded that those involved in the Snow White crimes had been purged, that church money was devoted to tax-exempt purposes and that, with Mr. Hubbard's death, no one was getting rich from Scientology."[48]
In August 1993, a settlement was reached; the organization would receive its tax-exempt status and end its legal actions against the IRS and its personnel. The organization was required only to resubmit new applications for exemption to the IRS Exempt Organizations (EO) division, which was told "not to consider any substantive matters" because those issues had been resolved by the committee. The secret agreement was announced on October 13, 1993, with the IRS refusing to disclose any of the terms or the reasoning behind the decision.[48] Both the IRS and Scientology rejected any allegations that foul play or undue pressure had been used on IRS officials, insisting that the decision had been based on the merits of the case.[348] IRS officials "insisted that Scientology's tactics had not affected the decision" and that "ultimately the decision was made on a legal basis".[48] Miscavige claims that the IRS's examination of Scientology was the most exhaustive review of any non-profit organization in history.[349]
Elsewhere, Scientology is recognized as a religion in Australia,[333][350] Portugal,[351] Spain,[352] Slovenia,[353] Sweden,[353][354] Croatia,[353] Hungary[353] and Kyrgyzstan.[355] In New Zealand, the Inland Revenue Department classified the Church of Scientology as a charitable organization and stated that its income would be tax exempt.[356] Scientology officials have won the right to perform marriages in South Africa.[357] In Italy, Scientology was judicially recognized as a religious denomination in 2000, when the Supreme Court held that Christian-based definitions of religion are not applicable because they would lead to the exclusion of Taoism, Buddhism, and many polytheistic, shamanistic, or animist religions.[358][359]
Scientology is not recognized as a religion in Canada.[357] In the UK, the Charity Commission for England and Wales ruled in 1999 that Scientology was not a religion and refused to register the organization as a charity, although a year later, it was recognized as a not-for-profit body in a separate proceeding by the UK Revenue and Customs and exempted from UK value added tax.[357][360] In December 2013, the United Kingdom's highest court officially recognized Scientology as a religion. The ruling ended a five-year legal battle by Scientologist Louisa Hodkin, who sought the legal right to marry at the Church of Scientology chapel in central London. The opinion by five supreme court justices redefined religion in law, rendering the 1970 definition "out of date" in restricting religious worship to "reverence or veneration of God or of a Supreme Being".[361][362][363]
In May 2008, the City of London police, senior officers of which had earlier received gifts worth thousands of pounds from the Scientology organization, unsuccessfully attempted to initiate a prosecution of a 15-year-old boy following a peaceful protest at which he held a sign reading "Scientology is not a religion, it is a dangerous cult". This statement is a quote from a superior court judgement against the Scientology organization. The summons was ostensibly issued under the Public Order Act 1986. The City of London police were swiftly instructed by the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) that the word "cult" was "not abusive or insulting" to the Church of Scientology. The CPS advised the force on what action or behaviour at a demonstration might be considered to be threatening, abusive or insulting. The police force was then obliged to accept that their policing of future demonstrations will reflect this advice.[364][365]
Scientology as a commercial enterprise
Scientology has been accused of being "a business, often given to criminal acts, and sometimes masquerading as a religion".[193][6]
In conjunction with the Church of Scientology's request to be officially recognized as a religion in Germany, around 1996 the German state Baden-Württemberg conducted a thorough investigation of the group's activities within Germany.[366] The results of this investigation indicated that at the time of publication, Scientology's main sources of revenue ("Haupteinnahmequellen der SO") were from course offerings and sales of their various publications. Course offerings ranged from (German Marks) DM 182.50 to about DM 30,000 – the equivalent today of approximately $119 to US$19,560. Revenue from monthly, bi-monthly, and other membership offerings could not be estimated in the report.
Since 1997 Germany has considered Scientology to be in conflict with the principles of the nation's constitution. It is seen as an anticonstitutional sect and a new version of political extremism and because there is "evidence for intentions against the free democratic basic order" it is observed by the Federal Office for the Protection of the Constitution.[367][368] In 1997, an open letter to then-German Chancellor, Helmut Kohl, published as a newspaper advertisement in the International Herald Tribune, drew parallels between the "organized oppression" of Scientologists in Germany and the treatment of Jews in 1930s' Nazi Germany.[369][370] The letter was signed by Dustin Hoffman, Goldie Hawn and a number of other Hollywood celebrities and executives.[370][371]
Commenting on the matter, a spokesman for the U.S. Department of State said that Scientologists were discriminated against in Germany, but condemned the comparisons to the Nazis' treatment of Jews as extremely inappropriate, as did a United Nations Special Rapporteur.[371][372] Based on the IRS exemptions, the U.S. State Department formally criticized Germany for discriminating against Scientologists and began to note Scientologists' complaints of harassment in its annual human rights reports,[48] as well as the annual International Religious Freedom Reports it has released from 1999 onwards.[373] Germany will continue to monitor Scientology's activities in the country, despite continued objection from Scientology which cites such monitoring as abuse of freedom of religion.[374]
France and Belgium have not recognized Scientology as a religion, and Stephen A. Kent, writing in 2001, noted that recognition had not been obtained in Ireland, Luxembourg, Israel or Mexico either.[375] Although the Belgian State Prosecution Service recommended that various individuals and organizations associated with Scientology should be prosecuted,[376][377] the Belgian courts finally decided in March 2016 that Scientology is not a criminal organization.[378]
In Greece, Scientology is not recognized as a religion by the Greek government, and multiple applications for religious status have been denied, notably in 2000 and 2003.[379]
In the Netherlands, Scientology was granted tax exempt status in October 2013.[380] The status was revoked in October 2015. The court ruled that because auditing fees and course costs were more expensive than most commercial education institutions, Scientology appeared to be aimed at making a profit.[381][382]
The Church of Scientology maintains strict control over the use of its symbols, icons, and names. It claims copyright and trademark over its "Scientology cross", and its lawyers have threatened lawsuits against individuals and organizations who have published the image in books and on Web sites. The Church of Scientology seeks to make it very difficult for individual groups to attempt to publicly practice Scientology on their own, independent of the official Church of Scientology. Scientology has filed suit against a number of individuals who have attempted to set up their own auditing practices, using copyright and trademark law to shut these groups down.[383]
The Church of Scientology and its many related organizations have amassed considerable real estate holdings worldwide, likely in the hundreds of millions of dollars.[234] Scientology encourages existing members to "sell" Scientology to others by paying a commission to those who recruit new members.[234] Scientology franchises, or missions, must pay the Church of Scientology roughly 10% of their gross income.[384] On that basis, it is likened to a pyramid selling scheme.[385] While introductory courses do not cost much, courses at the higher levels may cost several thousand dollars each.[28]
In November 2009, Australian Senator Nick Xenophon used a speech in Federal Parliament to allege that the Church of Scientology is a criminal organization. Based on letters from former followers, he said that there were "allegations of forced imprisonment, coerced abortions, and embezzlement of church funds, of physical violence and intimidation, blackmail and the widespread and deliberate abuse of information obtained by the organization".[386]
Scientology in religious studies
In the early 2000s, Melton stated that most scholarship about the church had been by either critics of the church or church-affiliated writers that defend the church. In the more recent years, new literature about the church has emerged among scholars of new religious movements. The first scholarly work on the church emerged in 1976, 22 years after the church founding in 1954; the work was entitled The Road to Total Freedom: A Sociological Analysis of Scientology by Roy Wallis. The second scholarly work was Harriet Whitehead’s Renunciation and Reformulation: A Study of Conversion in an American Sect.[387]
Four monographs emerged in the 21st century, adding to the body of scholarship about the Church of Scientology, including Hugh B. Urban’s The Church of Scientology: A History of a New Religion, which focused mainly on L. Ron Hubbard and his creations from the 1950s. A second scholar, Aldo Natale Terrin, wrote Scientology: Freedom and Immortality about Scientology beliefs and practices. Donald Westbrook wrote Among the Scientologists: History, Theology and Praxis based on field interviews; and the most recent was Free Zone Scientology: Contesting the Boundaries of a New Religion, pertaining to Independent Scientologists.[388]
Hugh B. Urban writes that "Scientology's efforts to get itself defined as a religion make it an ideal case study for thinking about how we understand and define religion."[389] Toward the second decade of the 2000s, a new interest for Scientology emerged among scholars, bringing the subject from obscurity.[390]
According to the Encyclopedia of Religious Controversies in the United States, "even as Scientology raises questions about how and who gets to define religion, most scholars recognize it as a religion, one that emerges from and builds on American individualism and the spiritual marketplace that dominated 1950s America."[391] David G. Bromley comments that Scientology "could gain strength by adding to the new perspective on existence, the hope and human meaning that only a transcendent creed can give".[392]
Bromley and Cowan noted in 2008 that Scientology's attempts "to gain favor with new religion scholars" had often been problematic.[339] According to Religious Studies professor Mary Farrell Benarowski, Scientology describes itself as drawing on science, religion, psychology and philosophy but "had been claimed by none of them and repudiated, for the most part, by all".[393]
Régis Dericquebourg writes about the efficacy of Scientology in imparting knowledge: "Scientology indeed not only brings knowledge, it also brings personal introspection through auditing, and transmission in upper levels is not merely reading texts: what is transmitted is experienced through a solo or duo auditing experience." He compared it to psychoanalysis.[390]
Frank K. Flinn, adjunct professor of religious studies at Washington University in St. Louis wrote, "it is abundantly clear that Scientology has both the typical forms of ceremonial and celebratory worship and its own unique form of spiritual life."[394] Flinn further states that religion requires "beliefs in something transcendental or ultimate, practices (rites and codes of behavior) that re-inforce those beliefs and, a community that is sustained by both the beliefs and practices", all of which are present within Scientology.[203] Similarly, World Religions in America states that "Scientology contains the same elements of most other religions, including myths, scriptures, doctrines, worship, sacred practices and rituals, moral and ethical expectations, a community of believers, clergy, and ecclesiastic organizations."[395]
While acknowledging that a number of his colleagues accept Scientology as a religion, sociologist Stephen A. Kent writes: "Rather than struggling over whether or not to label Scientology as a religion, I find it far more helpful to view it as a multifaceted transnational corporation, only one element of which is religious" [emphasis in the original].[6][22] Donna Batten in the Gale Encyclopedia of American Law writes, "A belief does not need to be stated in traditional terms to fall within First Amendment protection. For example, Scientology—a system of beliefs that a human being is essentially a free and immortal spirit who merely inhabits a body—does not propound the existence of a supreme being, but it qualifies as a religion under the broad definition propounded by the Supreme Court."[396]
The material contained in the OT levels has been characterized as bad science fiction by critics, while others claim it bears structural similarities to gnostic thought and ancient Hindu beliefs of creation and cosmic struggle.[397]
Scholar Luigi Berzano of the University of Turin listed five religious characteristics of Scientology: a set of doctrines leading to a spiritual goal, a community of believers, an authority figure (Hubbard), ritual practices, and "an ethical-moral view of life".[398]
Hubbard's motives
During his lifetime, Hubbard was accused of using religion as a façade for Scientology to maintain tax-exempt status and avoid prosecution for false medical claims.[6] The IRS cited a statement frequently attributed to Hubbard that the way to get rich was to found a religion.[104] Many of Hubbard's science fiction colleagues, including Sam Merwin, Lloyd Arthur Eshbach and Sam Moscowitz, recall Hubbard raising the topic in conversation.[399][400][401]
Hubbard grew up in a climate that was very critical of organized religion, and frequently quoted anti-religious sentiments in his early lectures.[402] The scholar Marco Frenschkowski (University of Mainz) has stated that it was not easy for Hubbard "to come to terms with the spiritual side of his own movement. Hubbard did not want to found a religion: he discovered that what he was talking about in fact was religion. This mainly happened when he had to deal with apparent memories from former lives. He had to defend himself about this to his friends."[402]
Frenschkowski allows that there were practical concerns in the question of "how to present Scientology to the outside world", but dismisses the notion that the religious format was just an expedient pretense; Frenschkowski points to many passages in Hubbard's works that document his struggle with this question.[402] Frenschkowski suggests that it was a biographical mistake to suggest that Hubbard only became interested in Scientology as a religion in 1954. He notes that Hubbard discussed religion and the concept of god even in the years leading up to the emergence of Scientology, and that he did not "rush into religion" but rather, "discovered it through the development of his work with pre-clears".[100]
Drawing parallels to similar struggles for identity in other religious movements such as Theosophy and Transcendental Meditation, Frenschkowski sees in Hubbard's lectures "the case of a man whose background was non-religious and who nevertheless discovers that his ideas somehow oscillate between 'science' (in a very popular sense), 'religion' and 'philosophy', and that these ideas somehow fascinate so many people that they start to form a separate movement". Hubbard experiments with traditional religious language in a short piece written in 1953 called "The Factors", "a basic expression of Scientologist cosmology and metaphysics", reprinted in current Scientology literature. Frenschkowski observes that the text is partly biblical in structure and that this development is a component of Scientology's metamorphosis into a religion, written at a point when the nature of the new movement was unclear.[403]
The Church of Scientology says that the idea of Hubbard starting a religion for personal gain is an unfounded rumor.[404] The organization also suggests that the origin of the rumor was a remark by George Orwell which had been misattributed to Hubbard.[405] Robert Vaughn Young, who left the organization in 1989 after being its spokesman for 20 years, suggested that reports of Hubbard making such a statement could be explained as a misattribution, despite having encountered three of Hubbard's associates from his science fiction days who remembered Hubbard making statements of that sort in person.[235]
It was Young who by a stroke of luck came up with the "Orwell quote": "but I have always thought there might be a lot of cash in starting a new religion, and we'll talk it over some time". It appears in a letter by Eric Blair (known to the world as George Orwell) to his friend, Jack Common, dated 16 February 1938, and was published in Collected Essays, Journalism and Letters of George Orwell, vol. 1.[406] In 2006, Rolling Stone's Janet Reitman also attributed the statement to Hubbard, as a remark to science fiction writer Lloyd Eshbach and recorded in Eshbach's autobiography.[407]
Scientology as a UFO religion
Scientology can be seen as a UFO religion in which the existence of extraterrestrial entities operating unidentified flying objects (UFOs) are an element of belief. In this context, it is discussed in UFO Religions by Christopher Partridge,[408] and The Encyclopedic Sourcebook of UFO Religions by James R. Lewis,[409] while Susan Palmer draws several parallels with Raelianism.[410] Gregory Reece, in his book UFO Religion: Inside flying saucer cults and culture, writes:[411]
Scientology is unique within the UFO culture because of this secretiveness, as well as because of the capitalist format under which they operate. Scientology is also difficult to categorize. While it bears strong similarities to the Ashtar Command or the Aetherius Society, its emphasis upon the Xenu event as the central message of the group seems to place them within the ancient astronaut tradition. Either way, Scientology is perhaps most different from other UFO groups in their attempt to keep all of the space opera stuff under wraps. They really would have preferred the rest of us not to know about Xenu and the galactic federation. Alas, such secrets are hard to keep
Regardless of such statements by critics, Hubbard wrote and lectured openly about the material he himself called "space opera". In 1952, Hubbard published a book (What to Audit / A History of Man[412]) on space opera and other material that may be encountered when auditing preclears.[413][27]
According to David G. Bromley, Scientology is "part therapy, part religion, part UFO group. It's a mix of things unlike any other religious group out there."[138] Scholar Andreas Grunschlo writes that as a ufogical religion, Scientology "conceives of earthly human beings primarily as extraterrestrial spirits ('Thetans') which have now to put on their 'bridge to freedom' again —a soul conception which is paralleled by the typical ufogical 'star seeds' or 'walk-ins' planted on this earthly 'garden' for spiritual growth".[414]
Influences
The general orientation of Hubbard's philosophy owes much to Will Durant, author of the popular 1926 classic The Story of Philosophy; Dianetics is dedicated to Durant.[415] Hubbard's view of a mechanically functioning mind in particular finds close parallels in Durant's work on Spinoza.[415] According to Hubbard himself, Scientology is "the Western anglicized continuance of many early forms of wisdom".[416] Ankerberg and Weldon mention the sources of Scientology to include "the Vedas, Buddhism, Judaism, Gnosticism, Taoism, early Greek civilization and the teachings of Jesus, Nietzsche and Freud".[417]
Hubbard asserted that Freudian thought was a "major precursor" to Scientology. W. Vaughn Mccall, Professor and Chairman of the Georgia Regents University writes, "Both Freudian theory and Hubbard assume that there are unconscious mental processes that may be shaped by early life experiences, and that these influence later behavior and thought." Both schools of thought propose a "tripartite structure of the mind".[418] Sigmund Freud's psychology, popularized in the 1930s and 1940s, was a key contributor to the Dianetics therapy model, and was acknowledged unreservedly as such by Hubbard in his early works.[419] Hubbard never forgot, when he was 12 years old, meeting Cmdr. Joseph Cheesman Thompson, a U.S. Navy officer who had studied with Freud[420] and when writing to the American Psychological Association in 1949, he stated that he was conducting research based on the "early work of Freud".[421]
In Dianetics, Hubbard cites Hegel as a negative influence — an object lesson in "confusing" writing.[422] According to Mary A. Mann, Scientology is considered nondenominational, accepting all people regardless of their religions background, ethnicity, or educational attainment.[423] Another influence was Alfred Korzybski's General Semantics.[419] Hubbard was friends with fellow science fiction writers A. E. van Vogt and Robert Heinlein, who both wrote science-fiction inspired by Korzybski's writings, such as Vogt's The World of Null-A. Hubbard's view of the reactive mind has clear and acknowledged parallels with Korzybski's thought; in fact, Korzybski's "anthropometer" may have been what inspired Hubbard's invention of the E-meter.[419]
Beyond that, Hubbard himself named a great many other influences in his own writing – in Scientology 8-8008, for example, these include philosophers from Anaxagoras and Aristotle to Herbert Spencer and Voltaire, physicists and mathematicians like Euclid and Isaac Newton, as well as founders of religions such as Buddha, Confucius, Jesus and Mohammed – but there is little evidence in Hubbard's writings that he studied these figures to any great depth.[419]
As noted, elements of the Eastern religions are evident in Scientology,[421] in particular the concept of karma found in Hinduism and Jainism.[424][425] In addition to the links to Hindu texts, Scientology draws from Taoism and Buddhism.[426] According to the Encyclopedia of Community, Scientology "shows affinities with Buddhism and a remarkable similarity to first-century Gnosticism".[427][428]
In the 1940s, Hubbard was in contact with Jack Parsons, a rocket scientist and member of the Ordo Templi Orientis then led by Aleister Crowley, and there have been suggestions that this connection influenced some of the ideas and symbols of Scientology.[429]
J. Gordon Melton writes that Scientology has its roots in Esoteric thought. He cited the significance of understanding Scientology's appeal as aligned with Esoteric tradition. He argues that Scientology is a "significant revision" and "meaningful revitalization" within the esoteric tradition. Melton states that Scientology can also be traced back to Gnosticism, Manicheanism, Freemasonry and Theosophy.[430]
According to James R. Lewis, Scientology is in the same lineage of supernatural religious movements such as New Thought. Scientology goes beyond this and refers to their religio-therapeutic practices as religious technology. Lewis wrote, "Scientology sees their psycho-spiritual technology as supplying the missing ingredient in existing technologies—namely, the therapeutic engineering of the human psyche."[431]
Scientology and hypnosis
Hubbard was said to be an accomplished hypnotist, and close acquaintances such as Forrest Ackerman (Hubbard's literary agent) and A. E. van Vogt (an early supporter of Dianetics) witnessed repeated demonstrations of his hypnotic skills.[104] Scientology literature states that L. Ron Hubbard expertise in hypnosis led to the discovery of the Dianetic engram.[432][7] However, Hubbard wrote that hypnosis is a "wild variable", and compared parlor hypnosis to an atom bomb.[433] He also wrote:
Hypnotism plants, by positive suggestion, one or another form of insanity. It is usually a temporary planting, but sometimes the hypnotic suggestion will not "lift" or remove in a way desirable to the hypnotist.[434]
Etymology of the word Scientology and earlier usage
The word Scientology, as coined by L. Ron Hubbard, is a derivation from the Latin word scientia ("knowledge", "skill"), which comes from the verb scīre ("to know"), with the suffix -ology, from the Greek λόγος lógos ("word" or "account [of]").[435][436] Scientology is further defined as "the study and handling of the spirit in relationship to itself, universes, and other life".[437]
The term scientology had been used in published works at least twice before Hubbard. In The New Word (1901) poet and lawyer Allen Upward first used scientology to mean blind, unthinking acceptance of scientific doctrine (compare scientism).[438] In 1934, philosopher Anastasius Nordenholz published Scientology: Science of the Constitution and Usefulness of Knowledge, which used the term to mean the science of science.[439] It is unknown whether Hubbard was aware of either prior usage of the word.[440][441]
ARC and KRC triangles
The ARC and KRC triangles are concept maps which show a relationship between three concepts to form another concept. These two triangles are present in the Scientology symbol. The lower triangle, the ARC triangle, is a summary representation of the knowledge the Scientologist strives for.[145] It encompasses Affinity (affection, love or liking), Reality (consensual reality) and Communication (the exchange of ideas).[145] Scientology teaches that improving one of the three aspects of the triangle "increases the level" of the other two, but Communication is held to be the most important.[442] The upper triangle is the KRC triangle, the letters KRC positing a similar relationship between Knowledge, Responsibility and Control.[443]
Among Scientologists, the letters ARC are used as an affectionate greeting in personal communication, for example at the end of a letter.[444] Social problems are ascribed to breakdowns in ARC – in other words, a lack of agreement on reality, a failure to communicate effectively, or a failure to develop affinity.[181] These can take the form of overts – harmful acts against another, either intentionally or by omission – which are usually followed by withholds – efforts to conceal the wrongdoing, which further increase the level of tension in the relationship.[181]
Bridge to Total Freedom
Scientologists seek to attain spiritual development through study of Scientology materials and auditing. The subject (called Technology or Tech in Scientology jargon) is structured in a series of levels (or gradients) of gradually increasing complexity. The sequence of study ("training") and auditing ("processing") levels is termed the "Bridge to Total Freedom", or simply "the Bridge".[442][445] Training concerns primarily the principles and techniques of auditing.[445] Processing is personal development through participation in auditing sessions.[445]
Members are required to make donations for study courses and auditing as they move up the Bridge, the amounts increasing as higher levels are reached. Participation in higher-level courses on the Bridge may cost several thousand dollars, and Scientologists usually move up the Bridge at a rate governed by their income.[27]
According to David G. Bromley, religious studies professor, working toward being an "Operating Thetan" means moving up the Bridge to Total Freedom, "which at the highest level transcends material law". He further emphasizes this belief of Scientologists: "You occasionally come across people in Scientology who say they can change the material world with their mind."[138]
Reception
Scientology has influenced a broad range of therapy and spiritual groups formed since the 1960s.[446] Much past-life therapy was influenced by Dianetics,[446] while Werner Erhard's Erhard Seminars Training therapy system also drew on Scientology.[446] Paul Twitchell, who founded Eckankar, had also been a staff member at the Church of Scientology and plagiarised some of Hubbard's writings.[446] In the 1960s, the Process Church of the Final Judgment was established by former Scientologists.[447] In 1986 Harry Palmer – who had previously run a Scientology franchise mission in Elmira, New York for around a decade – established his own group, the Avatar Course.[446]
Academic research into Scientology was for a long time comparatively limited compared to the media and public interest in it.[448] This has been attributed to the Church of Scientology's secrecy,[448] its reputation for litigiousness,[449] and a lack of academic access to documentary material about the organization.[450] Early studies included Roy Wallis' The Road to Total Freedom (1976) and Harriet Whitehead's Renunciation and Reformulation (1987).[451] A handful of monographs and edited volumes followed,[452] while in 2014, the first academic conference on the topic was held in Antwerp, Belgium.[453] Several academics who have studied the movement have described the organization paying close attention to their work by telephoning them and sending representatives to attend their talks on the subject.[448]
Scientology in popular culture
Scientology was lampooned in the 2005 South Park episode "Trapped in the Closet".[454] This publicized the story of Xenu, based directly on the actual Scientology Operating Thetan III document,[455] and accompanied by an onscreen caption reading "This is what Scientologists actually believe". After explaining these beliefs, the character representing the Church of Scientology's president ultimately reveals to Stan that the organization is in reality a money-making scam.[456]
Paul Thomas Anderson's 2012 film The Master features a religious organization called "The Cause" that has many similarities to Scientology.[457][458][459] Also, the character of Lancaster Dodd, played by Philip Seymour Hoffman, shares a physical resemblance to Scientology founder L. Ron Hubbard.[460]
In April 2015, following the recent release of Going Clear: Scientology and the Prison of Belief, Saturday Night Live aired a music video featuring the "Church of Neurotology", a parody of Scientology's 1990 music video "We Stand Tall".[461][462]
In November 2016, cable network A&E began airing Leah Remini: Scientology and the Aftermath, a documentary series. Remini, a TV actress and star, was a member of the Church of Scientology for over 30 years and a public proponent of Scientology for years before a public falling out in 2013. She is an executive producer of the series. The series follows Remini and former Scientology executive Mike Rinder as they explore the history and workings of the Church of Scientology, discuss their experiences and interview ex-members willing to speak out about alleged abuses from the organization. The initial episode drew 2.1 million viewers.[463]
See also
Notes
- ^ June 18 to December 24, 1950
References
- ^ a b Behar, Richard (May 6, 1991). "The Thriving Cult of Greed and Power". TIME. New York: Time Warner.
- ^ Kent, Stephen (2001). "Brainwashing Programs in The Family/Children of God and Scientology". In Zablocki, Benjamin; Robbins, Thomas (eds.). Misunderstanding Cults: Searching for Objectivity in a Controversial Field. University of Toronto Press. pp. 349–358. ISBN 978-0-8020-4373-3. from the original on December 5, 2020. Retrieved July 3, 2020.
- ^ a b Anderson, K.V. (1965). (PDF) (Report). Melbourne: State of Victoria. p. 179. Anderson Report. Archived from the original (PDF) on July 5, 2010. Retrieved June 30, 2020.
In reality it is a dangerous medical cult
- ^ a b Edge, Peter W. (2006). Religion and law: an introduction. Ashgate Publishing. ISBN 978-0-7546-3048-7. Retrieved July 3, 2020.
- ^ a b Hunt, John; de Puig, Luis; Espersen, Ole (February 5, 1992). European Council, Recommendation 1178: Sects and New Religious Movements (Report). Strasbourg: Council of Europe. Retrieved June 30, 2019.
It is a cool, cynical, manipulating business and nothing else.
- ^ a b c d e Beit-Hallahmi, Benjamin (September 2003). "Scientology: Religion or Racket?". Marburg Journal of Religion. University of Marburg. 8 (1): 1–56. doi:10.17192/mjr.2003.8.3724. Retrieved June 30, 2006.
- ^ a b c d Urban 2011.
- ^ Halupka, Max (September 2014). "The Church of Scientology: Legitimacy through Perception Management". Politics and Religion. Cambridge University Press. 7 (3): 613–630. doi:10.1017/S1755048314000066. S2CID 143524953.
- ^ Westbrook, Donald A. (August 10, 2018). "The Art of PR War: Scientology, the Media, and Legitimation Strategies for the 21st Century". Studies in Religion/Sciences Religieuses. SAGE Publishing. 47 (3): 373–395. doi:10.1177/0008429818769404. S2CID 149581057.
- ^ Urban, Hugh B. (2015). New Age, Neopagan, and New Religious Movements: Alternative Spirituality in Contemporary America. Berkeley: University of California Press. p. 144. ISBN 978-0-520-28117-2. Retrieved July 3, 2020.
- ^ [1][2][3][4][5][6][7][8][9][10]
- ^ Census 2021 Dataset: Regions, England and Wales (Report). Fareham: Office for National Statistics. November 29, 2022. TS031.
- ^ 2021 Census: Religion by visible minority and generation status (Report). Ottawa: Statistics Canada. 2021.
- ^ Australian Bureau of Statistics (July 4, 2022). "Census of Population and Housing: Census article - Religious affiliation in Australia, 2021". from the original on December 26, 2022. Retrieved December 26, 2022.
- ^ a b Schneiders, Ben (April 4, 2021). "Push for investigation into Scientology's charity status". The Sydney Morning Herald. Retrieved April 12, 2021.
- ^ a b Miller 2016, p. [page needed].
- ^ Aviv, Rachel (January 26, 2012). "Religion, grrrr". London Review of Books. 34 (2). from the original on May 6, 2015. Retrieved September 27, 2019.
- ^ a b . Time. December 22, 1952. Archived from the original on July 21, 2013. Retrieved July 20, 2007.
- ^ Melton, J. Gordon (1992). Encyclopedic Handbook of Cults in America. New York: Garland Pub. p. 190. ISBN 978-0-8153-1140-9.
- ^ Guiley, Rosemary (1991). Harper's Encyclopedia of Mystical & Paranormal Experience. [San Francisco]: HarperSanFrancisco. p. 107. ISBN 978-0-06-250365-7.
- ^ DeChant & Jorgenson 2003, p. 227
- ^ a b Kent, Stephen A. (July 1999). "Scientology – Is this a Religion?". Marburg Journal of Religion. University of Marburg. 4 (1): 1–23. (PDF) from the original on June 10, 2011. Retrieved March 3, 2013.
- ^ Cohen, David (October 23, 2006). . Evening Standard. Archived from the original on June 3, 2013. Retrieved March 3, 2013.
As Miscavige begins to crescendo "our next step is eradicating psychiatry from this planet, we will triumph!"
- ^ [18][19][20][21][22][23]
- ^ Urban, Hugh (2021). "The Third Wall of Fire". Secrecy: Silence, Power, and Religion. Chicago; London: University of Chicago Press. ISBN 978-0-226-74650-0.
- ^ Christensen, Dorthe Refslund (June 24, 2016). "Rethinking Scientology: A Thorough Analysis of L. Ron Hubbard's Formulation of Therapy and Religion in Dianetics and Scientology, 1950–1986". Alternative Spirituality and Religion Review. 7 (1): 155–227. doi:10.5840/asrr201662323.
- ^ a b c Rothstein, Mikael (March 2009). "'His name was Xenu. He used renegades...': Aspects of Scientology's Founding Myth". In Lewis, James R. (ed.). Scientology. New York/Oxford: Oxford University Press. pp. 365–367, 371. ISBN 9780195331493.
the narrative...ultimately, but not necessarily openly, provides the mythological framework for Hubbard's Gnostic soteriology, and thus the machinery of the (often quite expensive) courses that take the patient devotee step by step over the 'Bridge to Total Freedom,' Scientology's metaphor for the path of salvation. ...it is necessary to progress on the Bridge to the advanced stages before the participant is exposed to the myth about Xenu
- ^ a b c d Reitman, Janet (2011). Inside Scientology: The Story of America's Most Secretive Religion. Houghton Mifflin Harcourt. ISBN 978-0-547-54923-1.
- ^ Lebron, Robyn E. (2012). . ISBN 978-1-4627-1261-8. Archived from the original on September 3, 2016. Retrieved January 31, 2016.
- ^ United States v. Heldt, 668 F.2d 1238 (United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit October 2, 1981).
- ^ a b c d e f Urban, Hugh B. Magia sexualis: sex, magic, and liberation in modern Western esotericism, p. 137. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press, 2006. ISBN 978-0-520-24776-5
- ^ a b c d Urban, Hugh B. (2008). "Secrecy and New Religious Movements: Concealment, Surveillance, and Privacy in a New Age of Information". Religion Compass. 2 (1): 66–83. doi:10.1111/j.1749-8171.2007.00052.x. ISSN 1749-8171.
- ^ a b Morgan, Lucy (March 29, 1999). . St. Petersburg Times. Archived from the original on December 19, 2007. Retrieved November 4, 2007.
- ^ Brown, Barry; Cooper, David Y. (August 19, 1992). "Toronto Church Faces Heavy Fine: Scientology Branch is Convicted of Spying on Police, Others". The Buffalo News. Buffalo, NY. Retrieved July 3, 2020.
- ^ Regina v. Church of Scientology of Toronto, 33 O.R. (3d) 65 (Court of Appeal for Ontario April 18, 1997).
- ^ a b "Scientology's fraud conviction upheld in France". The Daily Telegraph. London. AFP. October 17, 2013. from the original on May 30, 2014. Retrieved July 3, 2020.
- ^ "Scientology (Written answer)". Parliamentary Debates (Hansard). United Kingdom: House of Commons. July 25, 1968. col. 189–191W.
- ^ Cottrell, Richard (1984). The Activity of Certain New Religions within the European Community (Report). Strasbourg: European Parliament.
- ^ Conseil d'Europe (1999). European Council, Recommendation 1412: Concernant les activités illégales des sectes (Report). Strasbourg: Conseil d'Europe.
- ^ "Church of Scientology". Parliamentary Debates (Hansard). United Kingdom: House of Lords. December 17, 1996. col. 1392–1394.
- ^ Hubbard and another v. Vosper and another, 1 All ER 1023 (Court of Appeal (England and Wales) November 19, 1971).
- ^ RE B & G (Minors: Custody), F.L.R. 493 (Court of Appeal (England and Wales) September 19, 1984).
- ^ [1][3][4][5][37][38][39][40][41][42]
- ^ a b Richardson 2009
- ^ a b c Carobene, Germana (June 16, 2014). "Problems on the legal status of the Church of Scientology". Stato, Chiese e Pluralismo Confessionale. Milan: University of Milan. 2014 (21). doi:10.13130/1971-8543/4109. Retrieved March 10, 2020.
In this sense the long process of Milan is of great importance, which, after six pronunciations was concluded in 2000 and legally recognized Scientology as a religion in Italy. The case was based on the complaint of a series of criminal offenses against some members of the church: conspiracy, fraud, extortion. After some contradictory rulings, the Milan judges became aware of the need to define the religiosity of the movement, i.e. it is to be considered a religion if all the alleged activities can qualify as normal religious practices
- ^ a b Church of the New Faith v Commissioner of Pay-roll Tax (Vict) [1983] HCA 40, (1983) 154 CLR 120, High Court (Australia) "the evidence, in our view, establishes that Scientology must, for relevant purposes, be accepted as "a religion" in Victoria"
- ^ a b Melton, Gordon (March 19, 2009). "Introduction". In Lewis, James R. (ed.). Scientology. New York/Oxford: Oxford University Press. p. 24. ISBN 9780195331493. Retrieved November 23, 2020.
- ^ a b c d e f g h Frantz, Douglas (March 9, 1997). "Scientology's Puzzling Journey From Tax Rebel to Tax Exempt". The New York Times. from the original on March 21, 2008. Retrieved October 26, 2008.
- ^ a b "Hubbard's Church 'Unconstitutional': Germany Prepares to Ban Scientology – SPIEGEL ONLINE". Spiegel Online. spiegel.de. December 7, 2007. Retrieved March 13, 2017.
- ^ a b "National Assembly of France report No. 2468". assemblee-nationale.fr. Retrieved March 13, 2017.
- ^ A 1995 parliamentary report lists Scientology groups as cults, and in its 2006 report MIVILUDES similarly classified Scientology organizations as a dangerous cult. Rapport au Premier ministre 2006 by MIVILUDES (in French)
- ^ Le point sur l'Eglise de Scientologie, Le Nouvel Observateur
- ^ Wallis 1977, p. 21.
- ^ Atack 1990, p. 75.
- ^ Hubbard, L. Ron (October 23, 1956). CRA Triangle. Fifteenth American Advanced Clinical Lectures. Los Angeles, CA: Golden Era Publications.
- ^ a b Miller 1987, p. 139.
- ^ Atack 1990, p. 82.
- ^ "A Summary on Scientology for Scientists (1969)". wiseoldgoat.com. Retrieved March 13, 2017.
- ^ "The Scandal of Scientology / Chapter 16: Scientology Versus Medicine". www.xenu.net. Retrieved May 30, 2022.
- ^ "'Going Clear': A New Book Delves Into Scientology: NPR". npr.org. Retrieved March 13, 2017.
- ^ "The History of Excalibur". lermanet.com. Retrieved March 13, 2017.
- ^ Hubbard, "The Anatomy Of Thought". Hubbard Communication Office Policy Letter 26 April 1970R, revised March 15, 1975.
- ^ . american-buddha.com. Archived from the original on April 19, 2015. Retrieved March 13, 2017.
- ^ "L. Ron Hubbard explains to a friend the real reason he wrote 'Dianetics' | The Underground Bunker". tonyortega.org. Retrieved November 25, 2019.
- ^ Wright, Lawrence (2013). Going Clear: Scientology, Hollywood and the Prison of Belief. Alfred A. Knopf. p. 43–44. ISBN 978-0-307-70066-7. OL 25424776M.
- ^ Miller 1987, p. 113.
- ^ Urban 2011, p. 41.
- ^ Wright, Lawrence (2013). Going Clear: Scientology, Hollywood and the Prison of Belief. Alfred A. Knopf. p. 347. ISBN 978-0-307-70066-7. OL 25424776M.
[Church of Scientology spokesperson] [Tommy] Davis brought up Jack Parsons's black magic society, which he asserted Hubbard had infiltrated...Davis said that the church had been looking for additional documentation to support its claim: 'A biography that just came out three weeks ago on Bob Heinlein actually confirmed it'...The book Davis was referring to is the first volume of an authorized Heinlein biography, by William H. Patterson, Jr...[Patterson] responded that Scientologists had been the source of the claim in the first place, and that they provided him with a set of documents that supposedly backed it up. Patterson said that the material did not support the factual assertions the church was making. 'I was unable to make any direct connection of the facts of Heinlein's life at the time to that narrative or any of its supporting documents,' Patterson wrote.
- ^ Robinson, Jill (November 11, 1997). "L. Ron Hubbard". Secret Lives. A&E.
- ^ Hubbard, L. Ron (October 1958). The Story of Dianetics and Scientology, Lecture 18 (Speech).
- ^ Hubbard, What is Scientology?, 1998 softcover edition, p. 529.
- ^ . Religious Studies and Theology. Archived from the original on March 12, 2007. Retrieved May 8, 2006. Originally published by Stephen A. Kent in December 1999.
- ^ Grant, Boyd (2014). What is Scientology? History, Beliefs, Rules, Secrets, and Facts. Newark, DE: Speedy Publishing LLC. p. 4.
- ^ a b c Gutjahr, Paul C. (2001). "The State of the Discipline. Sacred Texts in the United States". Book History. 4: 351–352. doi:10.1353/bh.2001.0008. JSTOR 30227336. S2CID 162339753.
- ^ Wilson, Bryan (1970). Religious Sects: A Sociological Study, McGraw-Hill, p. 163
- ^ Lewis, James R (2004). Book: The Oxford Handbook of New Religious Movements By James R. Lewis, p. 110. ISBN 978-0-19-514986-9. Retrieved September 4, 2010.
- ^ a b McCall, W. Vaughn (September 2007). "Psychiatry and Psychology in the Writings of L. Ron Hubbard". Journal of Religion and Health. 46 (3): 437–447. doi:10.1007/s10943-006-9079-9. S2CID 10629230.
- ^ a b c Satter, Beryl (July 3, 2003). "The Sexual Abuse Paradigm in Historical Perspective: Passivity and Emotion in Mid-Twentieth-Century America". Journal of the History of Sexuality. 12 (3): 424–464. doi:10.1353/sex.2004.0014. JSTOR 3704895. S2CID 142875634.
- ^ a b c d e f g h i Cowan & Bromley 2006, p. 172
- ^ Passas, Nikos, and Manuel Escamilla Castillo. "Scientology And Its 'Clear' Business". Behavioral Sciences & The Law 10.1 (1992): 103–116. Academic Search Premier
- ^ a b Wallis, Roy (1975). "Scientology: Therapeutic Cult to Religious Sect". Sociology. 9 (1): 89–100. doi:10.1177/003803857500900105. JSTOR 42851574. S2CID 144335265.
- ^ Wright, Lawrence (2013). Going Clear: Scientology, Hollywood and the Prison of Belief. Alfred A. Knopf. p. 58, 65, 77. ISBN 978-0-307-70066-7. OL 25424776M. Retrieved March 13, 2017.
- ^ a b Wallis 1977.
- ^ Miller 1987, p. 151.
- ^ "Adult New York Times Best Seller Lists for 1950". Hawes.com. from the original on July 13, 2012. Retrieved September 4, 2010.
- ^ Lewis, James R. (2009). Scientology. New York/Oxford: Oxford University Press.
- ^ "Poor Man's Psychoanalysis?". Newsweek. November 6, 1950.
- ^ Carroll, Robert (January 11, 2011). The Skeptic's Dictionary: A Collection of Strange Beliefs, Amusing Deceptions, and Dangerous Delusions. ISBN 978-1-118-04563-3. Retrieved November 23, 2015.
- ^ Wallis, Roy; Steve Bruce (Spring 1984). "The Stark-Bainbridge Theory of Religion: A Critical Analysis and Counter Proposals". Sociological Analysis. 45 (1): 11–27. doi:10.2307/3711319. JSTOR 3711319.
- ^ Lewis, James R. (2009). Scientology. Oxford University Press.
- ^ Chryssides, George D.; Wilkins, Margaret (2006). A Reader in New Religious Movements: Readings in the Study of New Religious Movements. Bloomsbery Academic.
- ^ Underdown, James (2018). "'I Was There...': Harlan Ellison Witnesses the Birth of Scientology". Skeptical Inquirer. 42 (6): 10.
- ^ Flowers 1984, pp. 96–97
- ^ Thomas Streissguth Charismatic Cult Leaders, p. 70, The Oliver Press Inc., 1996 ISBN 978-1-881508-18-2
- ^ George Malko Scientology: the now religion, p. 58, Delacorte Press, 1970 ASIN B0006CAHJ6
- ^ "Jon Atack: The games L. Ron Hubbard played". tonyortega.org.
- ^ Miller 1987, pp. 202–203.
- ^ . solitarytrees.net. Archived from the original on February 8, 2005.
- ^ Christian D. Von Dehsen-Scott L. Harris Philosophers and Religious Leaders, p. 90, Greenwood Publishing Group, 1999 ISBN 978-1-57356-152-5
- ^ a b Frenschkowski, Marco (2016). "Images of Religions and Religious History in the Works of L. Ron Hubbard". Alternative Spirituality and Religion Review. 7: 111–153. doi:10.5840/asrr20166620.
- ^ Miller 1987, p. 213.
- ^ a b Kent, Stephen A. "The Creation of 'Religious' Scientology". Religious Studies and Theology 18:2, pp. 97–126. 1999. ISSN 1747-5414
- ^ Hubbard, L. Ron. Letter of April 10, 1953. Quoted in Miller 1987, p. 213.
- ^ a b c d Miller 1987, pp. 140–142
- ^ Stoner, Carroll; Parke, Jo Anne (1977). All Gods Children : The Cult Experience - Salvation or Slavery?. p. 47. ISBN 0-8019-6620-5.
- ^ Westbrook, Donald A. (2015). "Saint Hill and the Development of Systematic Theology in the Church of Scientology (1959–1967)". Alternative Spirituality and Religion Review. 6 (1): 111–155. doi:10.5840/asrr2015577. ISSN 1946-0538
- ^ Westbrook, Donald A. (2019). Among the Scientologists : history, theology, and praxis. New York, NY. ISBN 9780190664978.
- ^ Garrison, Omar V. (1974). The Hidden Story of Scientology. Secaucus, NJ: Citadel Press, Lyle Suart, Inc. p. 135. ISBN 978-0-8065-0440-7.
- ^ Garrison, Omar V. (1974). The hidden Story of Scientology. Secaucus, MJ: Citadel Press, Lyle Stuart, Inc. pp. 136, 142. ISBN 978-0-8065-0440-7.
- ^ . cs.cmu.edu. January 4, 1963. Archived from the original on October 19, 2012. Retrieved September 4, 2010.
- ^ Garrison, Omar V. (1974). The Hidden Story of Scientology. Secaucus, NJ: Citadel Press, Lyle Stuart, Inc. p. 143. ISBN 978-0-8065-0440-7.
- ^ Wallis 1977, p. 153.
- ^ a b Lindholm, Charles (1992). "Charisma, Crowd Psychology and Altered States of Consciousness". Culture, Medicine and Psychiatry. 16 (3): 287–310. doi:10.1007/BF00052152. hdl:2144/3836. PMID 1395698. S2CID 6765004.
- ^ Wright, Lawrence (2013). Going Clear: Scientology, Hollywood and the Prison of Belief. Alfred A. Knopf. p. 227. ISBN 978-0-307-70066-7. OL 25424776M.
...exposed Operation Snow White and created a major crisis in the church. There was a deliberate campaign to provide religious cloaking for the church's activities. A Scientology cross was created. Scientology ministers now appeared wearing Roman collars.
- ^ DeChant & Jorgenson 2003, p. 225
- ^ "The paranoid, depressed L. Ron Hubbard: Jim Dincalci's 1997 'Secret Lives' TV interview ' The Underground Bunker". tonyortega.org. Retrieved March 13, 2017.
- ^ Atack 1990, p. 258.
- ^ Atack 1990, p. 259.
- ^ Miller 1987, p. 364.
- ^ Elisabeth Amveck Researching New Religious Movements, p. 261, Routledge, 2006 ISBN 978-0-415-27754-9
- ^ Rigley, Colin. . New Times San Luis Obispo. Archived from the original on December 17, 2013.
- ^ Melton, J. G., ed. (2003). "Church of Eductivism". Encyclopedia of American Religions. Detroit: Gale. p. 815.
- ^ Free Zone Assoc. (January 30, 2002). . Freezone.org. Archived from the original on November 9, 2013. Retrieved September 4, 2010.
- ^ Meyer-Hauser, Bernard F. (June 23, 2000). . Case No. D2000-0410. Archived from the original on September 28, 2013.
- ^ Brown, Janelle (July 22, 1999). . Salon. Archived from the original on June 26, 2009.
- ^ Colette, Mark. . Caller-Times, Corpus Christi. Archived from the original on November 5, 2013. Retrieved September 6, 2011.
- ^ Lewis & Hammer 2007, p. 24
- ^ William W. Zellner Extraordinary Groups, p. 295, Macmillan, 2007 ISBN 978-0-7167-7034-3
- ^ . Archived from the original on April 9, 2014. Retrieved July 13, 2011.
- ^ Nordhausen & Billerbeck (2008), pp. 469–470
- ^ Sweeney, John (September 26, 2010). "Mr Shouty and Cruise: The Rematch". The Sunday Times. Retrieved December 21, 2022.
Marty Rathbun, who like Rinder is now an independent scientologist ... Rinder, though a 'heretic' to the church, lives and breathes Independent scientology.
- ^ Tobin, Thomas C.; Childs, Joe (January 1, 2012). . Tampa Bay Times. Archived from the original on June 25, 2013. Retrieved January 14, 2012.
Rathbun, now a leading figure in a movement for Scientologists to practice independently of the church
- ^ a b c d Cowan & Bromley 2006, pp. 170–171
- ^ Hubbard, L. Ron (2007). Scientology: the fundamentals of thought. Commerce, CA: Bridge Publications. p. 178. ISBN 978-1-4031-4420-1. Retrieved December 21, 2015.
- ^ Wilkins, Margaret; Chryssides, George D. (2006). A Reader in New Religious Movements: Readings in the Study of New Religious Movements. A&C Black.
- ^ Kent, Stephen A. (2001). From Slogans to Mantras: Social Protest and Religious Conversion in the Late Vietnam War Era. Syracuse University Press.
- ^ Dericquebourg, Regis (2014). . Affinities between Scientology and Theosophy. International Conference – Scientology in a scholarly perspective 24–25th January 2014 (in English and French). Antwerp, Belgium: University of Antwerp, Faculty for Comparative Study of Religions and Humanism. Archived from the original on February 16, 2017.
- ^ a b c d Escobedo, Dan Gilgoff and Tricia (March 22, 2017). "Scientology: What exactly is it?". CNN.
- ^ "Does Scientology have a concept of God?". www.scientology.org. January 0001. Retrieved December 31, 2015.
- ^ a b Lewis, J. (2017). Lewis, James R.; Hellesoy, Kjersti (eds.). Handbook of Scientology. Vol. Brill Handbooks on Contemporary Religion. Brill. ISBN 978-90-04-33054-2.
- ^ Flowers 1984, p. 98
- ^ a b c d e Chryssides, George D. (1999). Exploring New Religions. Continuum International Publishing Group. p. 282-3. ISBN 0304336513.
- ^ Bednarowski, Mary Farrell (1995). New Religions and the Theological Imagination in America (Religion in North America). Bloomington: Indiana University Press. p. 60. ISBN 978-0-253-20952-8.
- ^ Pollock, Robert (2002). The Everything World's Religions Book: Discover the Beliefs, Traditions, and Cultures of Ancient and Modern Religions. Avon, MA: Adams Media Corporation. p. 210. ISBN 978-1-58062-648-4.
- ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m DeChant & Jorgenson 2003, pp. 221–236
- ^ Sappell, Joel; Welkos, Robert W. (June 24, 1990). "Defining the Theology". Los Angeles Times. Retrieved January 14, 2017.
- ^ Barrett, David V. (2011). A Brief Guide to Secret Religions: A Complete Guide to Hermetic, Pagan and Esoteric Beliefs. Little, Brown Book Group.
- ^ J. Gordon Melton The Encyclopedia of American Religion, p. 224, McGrath Publishing Co., 1978 ISBN 978-0-7876-9696-2
- ^ Paul Finkelman Religion and American Law, p. 509, Taylor & Francis, 2000 ISBN 978-0-8153-0750-1
- ^ a b c d Reitman, Janet (February 8, 2011). . Rolling Stone. Archived from the original on March 31, 2014. Retrieved August 22, 2011.
- ^ Cowan & Bromley 2006, p. 175
- ^ Cowan & Bromley 2006, pp. 176–177
- ^ Palmer 2009, p. 316
- ^ a b c d e f g DeChant & Jorgenson 2003, pp. 229–230
- ^ Cowan, Douglas E. (2014). . Clearly Material: Objects, Meaning, and the Ongoing Construction of New Religious Reality. International Conference – Scientology in a scholarly perspective January 24–25, 2014 (in English and French). Antwerp, Belgium: University of Antwerp, Faculty for Comparative Study of Religions and Humanism. Archived from the original on February 16, 2017.
- ^ Malko, George (1970). Scientology: The Now Religion. New York: Delacorte Press. p. 109. ISBN 978-1-112-96373-5.
- ^ John Corrigan (2008). The Oxford Handbook of Religion and Emotion, page 132. ISBN 978-0-19-517021-4.
- ^ a b c d Wallis 1977, p. 1.
- ^ a b Bouma, Gary D. (2006). Australian Soul: Religion and Spirituality in the 21st Century. Cambridge University Press. p. 9. ISBN 978-0-521-67389-1.
- ^ a b Christensen, Dorthe Refslund (2009). "Sources for the Study of Scientology". In James R. Lewis (ed.). Scientology. New York/Oxford: Oxford University Press US. pp. 420–421. ISBN 978-0-19-533149-3.
- ^ Al-Zaki, Taleb; B Tilman Jolly (January 1997). "Severe Hyponatremia After Purification". Annals of Emergency Medicine. 29 (1): 194–195. doi:10.1016/S0196-0644(97)70335-4. PMID 8998113.
- ^ a b c d e f Cowan & Bromley 2006, p. 182
- ^ Technical Bulletins X Bridge Publications, Inc. ISBN 0-88404-481-5 (1991)
- ^ Tobin and Childs (June 21, 2009). "Death in slow motion: Part 2 of 3 in a special report on the Church of Scientology". Tampa Bay Times. Retrieved August 9, 2013.
- ^ "Scientology Beliefs & Practices: What is Scientology? | Scientology's views on the evils of materialism". scientology.org. Retrieved March 13, 2017.
- ^ Cooper, Paulette (1997). Scientology Versus Medicine in Scandal of Scientology. Web Edition.
- ^ Mieszkowskii, Katharine (2005). "Scientology's War on Psychiatry". Salon.com. Archived from the original on July 10, 2012. Retrieved March 14, 2016.
- ^ a b c d Cowan & Bromley 2006, p. 184
- ^ Miller 1987, p. 184.
- ^ Aagaard Petersen, Jesper (2014). Controversial New Religions. Oxford University Press.
- ^ Carl G. Liungman Symbols, p. 297, Ionfox AB, 2004 ISBN 978-91-972705-0-2
- ^ a b Ortega, Tony (December 23, 1999). . Phoenix New Times. Village Voice Media. Archived from the original on June 14, 2009. Retrieved September 16, 2007.
- ^ Sappell, Joel; Robert W. Welkos (June 24, 1990). . Los Angeles Times. pp. A36:1. Archived from the original on January 11, 2008. Retrieved August 9, 2006. Another link: Carnegie-Mellon University
- ^ Hines, Matt (September 8, 2003). . CNET. Archived from the original on November 16, 2006. Retrieved September 16, 2007.
- ^ a b Derek Davis New Religious Movements and Religious Liberty in America, pp. 45–47, Baylor University Press, 2004 ISBN 978-0-918954-92-3
- ^ Lewis & Hammer 2007, p. 36
- ^ Coordinates of Trementina Base 35°30′42″N 104°34′48″W / 35.51167°N 104.58000°W
- ^ Leiby, Richard (November 27, 2005). "A Place in the Desert for New Mexico's Most Exclusive Circles". The Washington Post. Retrieved July 13, 2011.
- ^ a b c d e Cowan & Bromley 2006, p. 180
- ^ a b c d e Cowan & Bromley 2006, p. 181
- ^ a b c d Cowan & Bromley 2006, p. 177
- ^ a b Zellner & Petrowsky 1998, pp. 146–147
- ^ "What is Disconnection?". Retrieved November 30, 2015.
- ^ Bednarowski, Mary Farrell (1995). New Religions and the Theological Imagination in America (Religion in North America). Bloomington: Indiana University Press. p. 114. ISBN 978-0-253-20952-8.
- ^ Miller, Timothy (1995). America's alternative religions. Albany, N.Y: State University of New York Press. p. 388. ISBN 978-0-7914-2397-4.
- ^ Marshall, Gordon (1990). In praise of sociology. Boston: Unwin Hyman. p. 187. ISBN 978-0-04-445687-2.
- ^ a b Flowers 1984, p. 101
- ^ Grossman, Wendy (1997). Net. wars. New York: New York University Press. p. 73. ISBN 978-0-8147-3103-1.
- ^ Greenawalt, Kent (2006). Religion and the Constitution. Princeton, N.J: Princeton University Press. p. 298. ISBN 978-0-691-12582-4.
- ^ Wollersheim v. Church of Scientology, 212 Cal. App. 3d 872 (Cal. App. 2d Dist. 1989)
- ^ Frank K. Flinn testimony in Church of Scientology of California, 1984, vol.23, pp.4032–4160
- ^ Wollersheim v. Church of Scientology of California, Court of Appeal of the State of California, civ.no. B023193, July 18, 1989
- ^ a b Cowan & Bromley 2006, p. 170
- ^ Bernstein, Fred (November 9, 2010). . The New York Times. Archived from the original on May 14, 2013. Retrieved July 13, 2011.
- ^ a b c Ortega, Tony (July 4, 2011). "Scientologists: How Many Of Them Are There, Anyway?". The Village Voice.
- ^ Goodstein, Laurie (March 6, 2010). . The New York Times. Archived from the original on January 14, 2021.
- ^ Urban, Hugh (2017). "The Third Wall of Fire". Nova Religio. 20 (4): 13–36. doi:10.1525/nr.2017.20.4.13.
- ^ Oppenheimer, Mark (October 18, 2011). . The Nation. Archived from the original on July 17, 2015.
- ^ a b Tu, Janet I (July 31, 2010). "Scientology church finds new home in Queen Anne neighborhood". The Seattle Times.
Sociologist Barry Kosmin of Trinity College, one of study’s principal researchers, said the sample size of Scientologists used was too small to give a reliable count of members. Still, he said, the data “strongly suggests that there has been no recent vast increase and that the number of Scientologists (in the U.S.) is in the tens of thousands.” [Bob] Adams, the Church of Scientology International spokesman, estimates there are millions of Scientologists worldwide, though he couldn’t be more specific on the number, and about a million in the U.S.
- ^ a b Cooper, Robert (August 19, 2014). "Scientology Gateshead building still empty after seven years". BBC News.
- ^ Census 2016, Religious Affiliation by Sex (SA2+) (Report). Canberra: Australian Bureau of Statistics. 2017.
- ^ Bromley, David; Cowan, Douglas (2007). Cults and new religions: a brief history. p. 24. ISBN 9781405161282. Retrieved July 29, 2013.
- ^ a b c Flinn, Frank K. (July 5, 2005). "Scientology". Live discussion. Washington Post. Retrieved February 4, 2008.
- ^ Jarvik, Elaine (September 18, 2004). . Deseret News. Archived from the original on June 16, 2008. Retrieved August 1, 2007.
Melton, who has been criticized by some for being too easy on Scientology, and has been criticized by the church for being too harsh, says that the church's estimates of its membership numbers – 4 million in the United States, 8 to 9 million worldwide – are exaggerated. "You're talking about anyone who ever bought a Scientology book or took a basic course. Ninety-nine percent of them don't ever darken the door of the church again." If the church indeed had four million members in the United States, he says, "they would be like the Lutherans and would show up on a national survey" such as the Harris poll.
- ^ a b c d Kent, Stephen (September 2003). . Marburg Journal of Religion. University of Marburg. 8 (1). Archived from the original on June 29, 2006. Retrieved May 21, 2006.; Kent cites Hubbard, L. Ron (1976a). Modern Management Technology Defined. Copenhagen, New Era Publications
- ^ Wakefield, Margery Understanding Scientology
- ^ Cisar, Joe (translator)
- ^ Hamburg Regional Office of the German Constitutional Security Agency Der Geheimdienst der Scientology-Organisation – Grundlagen, Aufgaben, Strukturen, Methoden und Ziele – Zweite Auflage, Stand 06.05.1998"
- ^ Scientologists pay for libel, Clare Dyer, The Guardian, June 9, 1999.
- ^ a b On the Offensive Against an Array of Suspected Foes, Los Angeles Times, Joel Sappell, Robert W. Welkes, page A1, June 29, 1990. This story is also available on the Carnegie Mellon University library website as "Part 6: Attack the Attacker, On the Offensive . . . "
- ^ "Scientology's Secret Vaults: A Rare Interview With a Former Member of Hush-Hush "CST"". Retrieved July 28, 2018.
- ^ "Inside the mysterious Scientology compound that may hold its leader's missing wife". Business Insider. Retrieved July 28, 2018.
- ^ MORAN, LEE. "Scientology compound Twin Peaks, Shelly Miscavige's reputed hideout, exposed". NY Daily News. Retrieved July 28, 2018.
- ^ Bromley 2009, p. 98
- ^ a b Shaw, William (February 14, 2008). "What do Tom Cruise and John Travolta know about Scientology that we don't?". The Daily Telegraph. London. from the original on February 23, 2012. Retrieved June 25, 2009.
- ^ Frantz, Douglas (February 13, 1998). "Scientology's Star Roster Enhances Image". The New York Times, Late Edition (East Coast).
- ^ a b DeChant & Jorgenson 2003, p. 233
- ^ Melton, J. Gordon, Ed. "Celebrity Centre International (First Week of August)". Religious Celebrations: An Encyclopedia of Holidays, Festivals, Solemn Observances, and Spiritual Commemorations. Vol. 1. Santa Barbara, CA: ABC-CLIO, 2011. 168. Gale Virtual Reference Library. Web. January 8, 2014.
- ^ Cusack 2009, pp. 394–395
- ^ Spitznagel, Eric (December 9, 2010). "Juliette Lewis Explains Why Scientologists Can Celebrate Christmas". Vanity Fair. Retrieved January 14, 2017.
- ^ Christensen, Dorthe Refslund (June 24, 2016). "Rethinking Scientology Thorough Analysis of L. Ron Hubbard's Formulation of Therapy and Religion in Dianetics and Scientology, 1950–1986." Alternative Spirituality and Religion Review. 7: 155–227. doi:10.5840/asrr201662323.
- ^ Neusner, Jacob (2009). World Religions in America (4th ed.). Westminster John Knox Press.
- ^ a b c d Cowan & Bromley 2006, p. 183
- ^ Winn, Patrick (May 15, 2015). "Scientologists are in Nepal trying to 'heal' trauma victims". Global Post. Retrieved December 16, 2015.
- ^ Winn, Patrick (April 11, 2011). "Scientology's global disaster squad". MinnPost. Retrieved December 16, 2015.
- ^ Goodman, Peter S. (January 28, 2005). "For Tsunami Survivors, A Touch of Scientology (washingtonpost.com)". Washington Post. Retrieved February 22, 2022.
- ^ Bruell, Alexandra (October 16, 2017). "Scientologists Urge Advertisers to Boycott A&E's Leah Remini Show". Wall Street Journal. Retrieved November 25, 2019.
- ^ STAFF, RADAR. "Church Of Scientology Worth More Than $1.2 Billion, According To New Tax Docs". Business Insider.
- ^ . Lfv.bayern.de. Archived from the original on February 19, 2012. Retrieved September 4, 2010.
- ^ Department Of State. The Office of Electronic Information, Bureau of Public Affairs. "Germany". 2001-2009.state.gov.
- ^ Lewis, James R. (March 11, 2009). Scientology. Oxford University Press. ISBN 978-0-19-988711-8. Retrieved November 5, 2015.
- ^ Morgan, Lucy (March 29, 1999). . St. Petersburg Times. Archived from the original on May 22, 2011. Retrieved September 7, 2007.
Canada's highest court in 1997 upheld the criminal conviction of the Church of Scientology of Toronto and one of its officers for a breach of trust stemming from covert operations in Canadian government offices during the 1970s and 1980s.
- ^ Souchard, Pierre-Antoine (February 2, 2012). . Huffington Post. Archived from the original on November 3, 2013. Retrieved February 3, 2012.
A French appeals court on Thursday upheld the Church of Scientology's 2009 fraud conviction on charges it pressured members into paying large sums for questionable remedies.
- ^ a b c d e Behar, Richard (May 6, 1991). . Time. Archived from the original on August 19, 2013. Retrieved November 3, 2008.
- ^ a b c d Leiby, Richard (December 25, 1994). "Scientology Fiction: The Church's War Against Its Critics – and Truth". The Washington Post. p. C1. Retrieved June 21, 2006.
- ^ a b c Goodin, Dan (June 3, 1999). "Scientology subpoenas Worldnet". CNET News.com. from the original on January 28, 2007. Retrieved May 4, 2006.
- ^ "Marburg Journal of Religion: Framing Effects in the Coverage of Scientology versus Germany: Some Thoughts on the Role of Press and Scholars" (PDF). Web.uni-marburg.de. May 22, 2009. Retrieved September 4, 2010.
- ^ Richardson 2009, p. 283
- ^ Farley, Robert (June 24, 2006). . St. Petersburg Times. pp. 1A, 14A. Archived from the original on July 3, 2007. Retrieved June 24, 2007.
- ^ Farley, Robert (May 29, 2004). . St. Petersburg Times. Archived from the original on October 29, 2013. Retrieved November 3, 2008.
- ^ Matt Loney; Evan Hansen (March 21, 2002). . CNet. Archived from the original on October 15, 2008. Retrieved May 10, 2007.
- ^ a b Joe Childs, Thomas C. Tobin (June 23, 2009). . St Petersburg Times. Archived from the original on February 9, 2013. Retrieved June 23, 2009.
- ^ Joe Childs, Thomas C. Tobin (June 23, 2009). . St Petersburg Times. Archived from the original on January 17, 2013. Retrieved June 23, 2009.
- ^ Gianni, Luke (February 22, 2007). . local stories > 15 minutes. Sacramento News & Review. Archived from the original on January 30, 2011. Retrieved May 6, 2007.
- ^ . The Politicker. New York Observer. April 20, 2007. Archived from the original on February 5, 2012. Retrieved November 27, 2007.
- ^ Etter, Lauren (January 19, 2007). "Program for prisoners draws fire over Scientology". Wall Street Journal. Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. from the original on January 18, 2012. Retrieved November 27, 2007.
- ^ Reitman, Janet (February 8, 2011). . Rolling Stone Magazine. Archived from the original on March 31, 2014. Retrieved September 6, 2011.
- ^ Hubbard, L.R. (1965): Keeping Scientology working (Series 1), page 7. The Hubbard Communication Office Policy Letter, titled Keeping Scientology Working Series 1, was included in the attached documents submitted to the IRS in 1993. Available from Xenu.net: [1]
- ^ Eggenberger, Nicole (September 10, 2013). "Leah Remini Tells Ellen DeGeneres She 'Lost Friends"'After Leaving Scientology". US Weekly. December 11, 2013, at the Wayback Machine
- ^ Ficsher, Erika. National Reporting, 1941–1986. Walter de Gruyter. p. 302.
- ^ Catholic Sentinel, March 17, 1978
- ^ Charles L. Stafford; Bette Orsini (January 9, 1980). (PDF). St. Petersburg Times. Archived from the original (PDF) on January 24, 2016. Original (18M) August 9, 2007, at the Wayback Machine
- ^ Koff, Stephen (December 22, 1988). "Scientology church faces new claims of harassment". St. Petersburg Times. Retrieved April 19, 2008.
- ^ . Reuters. October 27, 2009. Archived from the original on January 14, 2010., Reuters, October 27, 2009
- ^ "French court upholds Scientology fraud conviction". CBS News., AFP, February 2, 2012
- ^ "Could Belgium Bring Down Scientology? – The Atlantic". thewire.com. December 28, 2012. Retrieved March 13, 2017.
- ^ "Belgium will try two Scientology organizations and 10 Scientologists for fraud ' The Underground Bunker". tonyortega.org. Retrieved March 13, 2017.
- ^ "Our man in Europe reports on Belgium's criminal prosecution of Scientology ' The Underground Bunker". tonyortega.org. Retrieved March 13, 2017.
- ^ Lewins, Dean (March 11, 2016). "Scientology: Belgium court acquits church of organised crime charges – ABC News (Australian Broadcasting Corporation)". ABC News. abc.net.au. Retrieved March 13, 2017.
- ^ . Time. April 5, 1976. Archived from the original on October 14, 2007. Retrieved July 24, 2009.
- ^ Behar, Richard (May 6, 1991). . Time. Archived from the original on November 10, 2007.
- ^ Strupp, Joe (June 30, 2005). . Salon. Archived from the original on January 7, 2007. Retrieved September 19, 2007.
- ^ Sweeney, John (May 14, 2007). "Row over Scientology video". BBC News. Retrieved November 3, 2008.
- ^ a b Donaghy, James (June 9, 2007). . The Guardian. London. Archived from the original on March 7, 2013. Retrieved January 14, 2009.
- ^ Breckenridge, Memorandum of Intended Decision in Church of Scientology of California vs. Gerald Armstrong, Superior Court, Los Angeles County, case no. C420153. quoted in Atack 1990, p. 322
- ^ Koff, Stephen (December 22, 1988). . St. Petersburg Times. Archived from the original on May 15, 2009. Retrieved October 26, 2008.
- ^ Steven Girardi (May 9, 1982). "Witnesses Tell of Break-ins, Conspiracy". Clearwater Sun: 1A.
- ^ Judgement of Mr Justice Latey, Re: B & G (Minors) (Custody) Delivered in the High Court (Family Division), London, July 23, 1984
- ^ "Judge brands Scientology 'sinister' as mother is given custody of children". The Times. July 24, 1984. p. 3.
- ^ "News and Notes: Scientology Libel Action". British Medical Journal. 1 (5743): 297–298. January 30, 1971. doi:10.1136/bmj.1.5743.297. ISSN 0007-1447. PMC 1794922. PMID 5294085.
- ^ Hubbard, L. Ron (2007). Introduction to Scientology Ethics (Latin American Spanish ed.). Bridge Publications. p. 209. ISBN 978-1-4031-4684-7.
- ^ The Times of India staff (July 17, 2003). "Tom Cruise and the Church of Scientology". The Times of India.
- ^ New York Post staff (June 29, 2005). "Abort-Happy Folks". New York Post. News Corporation. p. 011.
- ^ Los Angeles Times staff (February 29, 2008). . Web Scout. Los Angeles Times. Archived from the original on March 2, 2008. Retrieved November 7, 2009.
- ^ Lattin, Don (February 12, 2001). "Leaving the Fold – Third-generation Scientologist grows disillusioned with faith". San Francisco Chronicle. The Chronicle Publishing Co. p. A1.
- ^ MSNBC staff (January 15, 2008). "Exclusive: 'Tom Cruise: An Unauthorized Biography' – Read an excerpt from Andrew Morton's controversial new book". Today.com. NBC. Retrieved November 7, 2009.
- ^ Morton, Andrew (2008). Tom Cruise: An Unauthorized Biography. St. Martin's Press. p. 130. ISBN 978-0-312-35986-7.
- ^ Pressley, Karen Schless (2017). Escaping Scientology: An Insider's True Story. Bayshore Publications. p. 222. ISBN 978-0-9990881-0-4.
- ^ a b Perrault, Michael (March 26, 2009). "Suit alleges wing of Church of Scientology violated labor laws". The Press-Enterprise. The Press-Enterprise Co. p. C01.
- ^ Courthouse News Service staff (April 3, 2009). "Scientology Accused of Human Trafficking". Courthouse News Service. www.courthousenews.com. Retrieved November 7, 2009.
- ^ Baca, Nathan (March 31, 2009). "Former Scientologist Recounts 'Torturous' Past Inside the Church". KESQ-TV.
- ^ "Scientologists forced me to have two abortions". Herald Sun. www.heraldsun.com.au. March 17, 2010. Retrieved March 17, 2010.
- ^ a b Australian Associated Press (March 17, 2010). . News.com.au. News Limited. Archived from the original on March 22, 2010. Retrieved March 17, 2010.
- ^ "Scientologists pressured me to have abortions". ABC News (Australia). Australian Broadcasting Corporation. March 27, 2010. Retrieved March 17, 2010.
- ^ a b c Tedmanson, Sophie (November 19, 2009). "Church of Scientology accused of torture and forced abortions". The Times. Times Newspapers Ltd. Retrieved November 19, 2009.
- ^ Agence France-Presse (November 18, 2009). . Canada.com. Canwest News Service. Archived from the original on November 21, 2009. Retrieved November 19, 2009.
- ^ Collins, Pádraig (November 19, 2009). "Scientology faces allegations of abuse and covering up deaths in Australia". Irish Times. www.irishtimes.com. Retrieved November 19, 2009.
- ^ a b O'Loughlin, Toni (November 18, 2009). "Scientology faces allegations of torture in Australia: Australian prime minister considers inquiry after senator tables allegations including forced abortions, assault and blackmail". The Guardian. Guardian News and Media Limited. Retrieved November 19, 2009.
- ^ Saulwick, Jacob (November 18, 2009). "Pressure mounts for Scientology inquiry". Sydney Morning Herald. Fairfax Digital. Retrieved November 19, 2009.
- ^ Ansley, Greg (November 19, 2009). "Church attacked for 'criminal' activities". New Zealand Herald. APN Holdings NZ Limited. Retrieved November 19, 2009.
- ^ 3 News staff (November 26, 2009). . 3 News. www.3news.co.nz. Archived from the original on April 6, 2012. Retrieved November 26, 2009.
- ^ Australian Associated Press (March 18, 2010). "Scientologists reject claims they forced abortions". Sydney Morning Herald. Retrieved March 17, 2010.
- ^ Mark, Michelle (September 21, 2019). "Lawsuits against the Church of Scientology are piling up, alleging a vast network of human trafficking, child abuse, and forced labor". Insider Inc. Retrieved June 25, 2020.
- ^ Grossman, Wendy (October 1997). "Copyright Terrorists". Net.Wars. New York: New York University Press. pp. 77–78. ISBN 978-0-8147-3103-1. Retrieved June 11, 2006.
- ^ a b c Knapp, Dan (December 19, 1996). . CNN. Time Warner. Archived from the original on April 8, 2014. Retrieved October 29, 2007.
- ^ Russell, Ron (September 9, 1999). "Scientology's Revenge – For years, the Cult Awareness Network was the Church of Scientology's biggest enemy. But the late L. Ron Hubbard's L.A.-based religion cured that–by taking it over". New Times LA.
- ^ Lewis, James R (May 3, 2005). Book: Cults: A Reference Handbook By James R. Lewis, Published by ABC-CLIO, 2005, ISBN 1-85109-618-3, ISBN 978-1-85109-618-3. ISBN 978-1-85109-618-3. Retrieved September 4, 2010.
- ^ Goodman, Leisa, Human Rights Director, Church of Scientology International (2001). "A Letter from the Church of Scientology". Marburg Journal of Religion: Responses From Religions. pp. Volume 6, No. 2, 4 pages. Retrieved October 28, 2007.
- ^ a b c d e Dawson, Lorne L.; Cowan, Douglas E. (2004). Religion Online: Finding Faith on the Internet. New York, NY/London, UK: Routledge Taylor & Francis Group. pp. 262, 264–265. ISBN 978-0-415-97022-8.
- ^ Wendy Grossman Net.wars, p. 77, NYU Press, 1997 ISBN 978-0-8147-3103-1
- ^ Steven Vedro Digital Dharma, p. 190, Quest Books, 2007 ISBN 978-0-8356-0859-6
- ^ Mike Godwin Cyber Rights, p. 219, Massachusetts Institute of Technology Press, 2003 ISBN 978-0-262-57168-5
- ^ Catharine Cookson Encyclopedia of Religious Freedom, p. 432, Taylor & Francis, 2003 ISBN 978-0-415-94181-5
- ^ Wendy Grossman Net.wars, p. 90, New York University Press, 1997 ISBN 978-0-8147-3103-1
- ^ Sarno, David (February 11, 2008). . Los Angeles Times. Archived from the original on November 7, 2012., Los Angeles Times, February 11, 2008.
- ^ Christopher Lueg From Usenet to CoWebs, p. 37, Springer, 2003 ISBN 978-1-85233-532-8
- ^ Wendy Grossman Net.wars, pp. 74–76, NYU Press, 1997 ISBN 978-0-8147-3103-1
- ^ Nordhausen, Frank (2008). Scientology: Wie der Sektenkonzern die Welt erobern will (in German). Links Christoph Verlag. p. 518. ISBN 978-3-86153-470-9.
- ^ John Cook (March 17, 2008). . Radar. Archived from the original on March 23, 2008. Retrieved March 18, 2008.
- ^ Vamosi, Robert (January 24, 2008). "Anonymous threatens to "dismantle" Church of Scientology via internet". cnet.com. CNET. Retrieved May 30, 2015.
- ^ KNBC Staff (January 24, 2008). . KNBC. Archived from the original on August 21, 2008. Retrieved January 25, 2008.
- ^ Vamosi, Robert (January 24, 2008). "Anonymous hackers take on the Church of Scientology". CNET News. CNET Networks, Inc. Retrieved January 25, 2008.
- ^ George-Cosh, David (January 25, 2008). "Online group declares war on Scientology". National Post. Canwest Publishing Inc. Archived from the original on January 28, 2008. Retrieved January 25, 2008.
- ^ Singel, Ryan (January 23, 2008). "War Breaks Out Between Hackers and Scientology – There Can Be Only One". Wired. CondéNet, Inc. from the original on April 4, 2009. Retrieved January 25, 2008.
- ^ Feran, Tom (January 24, 2008). "Where to find the Tom Cruise Scientology videos online, if they're still posted". The Plain Dealer. Newhouse Newspapers. Archived from the original on December 11, 2013. Retrieved January 25, 2008.
- ^ a b Chan Enterprises (January 21, 2008). . Press Release. PRLog.Org. Archived from the original (PDF) on May 8, 2011. Retrieved January 25, 2008.