Subcomandante Marcos

In this Spanish name, the first or paternal surname is Guillén and the second or maternal family name is Vicente.

Rafael Sebastián Guillén Vicente (born 19 June 1957)^[1] is a Mexican insurgent, the former military leader and spokesman for the Zapatista Army of National Liberation (EZLN) in the ongoing Chiapas conflict,^[2] and a prominent anti-capitalist and anti-neoliberal.^[3] Widely known by his initial nom de guerre Subcomandante Insurgente Marcos (frequently shortened to simply Subcomandante Marcos), he has subsequently employed several other pseudonyms: he called himself Delegate Zero during the Other Campaign (2006–2007), and since May 2014 has gone by the name Subcomandante Insurgente Galeano (again, frequently with the "Insurgente" omitted), which he adopted in honor of his fallen comrade Jose Luis Solis Lopez, his nom de guerre being Galeano, aka "Teacher Galeano".^[4] Marcos bears the title and rank of Subcomandante (or "Subcommander" in English), as opposed to Comandante (or "Commander" in English), because he is under the command of the indigenous commanders who constitute the EZLN's Clandestine Revolutionary Indigenous Committee's General Command (CCRI-CG in Spanish).

Subcomandante Marcos
Marcos, smoking a pipe atop a horse in Chiapas, Mexico in 1996.
Born	(1957-06-19) 19 June 1957 (age 66) Tampico, Tamaulipas, Mexico
Other names	Subcomandante Insurgente Galeano Delegado Cero (Delegate Zero)
Education	Instituto Cultural Tampico
Alma mater	National Autonomous University of Mexico (BA, MA)
Occupations	Spokesperson Writer
Movement	Neozapatismo
Military career
Allegiance	Zapatista Municipalities
Service/branch	EZLN
Years of service	1994–2014
Rank	Subcommander
Battles/wars	Chiapas conflict  • Zapatista uprising
Website	Official website

Born in Tampico, Tamaulipas, Marcos earned a degree from the Faculty of Philosophy and Literature at the prestigious National Autonomous University of Mexico (UNAM),^[5] and taught at the Autonomous Metropolitan University (UAM) for several years during the early 1980s.^[1] During this time he became increasingly involved with a guerrilla group known as the National Liberation Forces (FLN), before leaving the university and moving to Chiapas in 1984.^[1]

The Ejército Zapatista de Liberación Nacional (EZLN) (Zapatista Army of National Liberation; often simply called the Zapatistas) was the local Chiapas wing of FLN, founded in the Lacandon Jungle in 1983, initially functioning as a self-defense unit dedicated to protecting Chiapas' Mayan people from evictions and encroachment on their land. While not Mayan himself, Marcos emerged as the group's military leader, and when the EZLN, acting independently of the FLN, began its rebellion on 1 January 1994, he served as its spokesman.^[2]

Known for his trademark ski mask and pipe and for his charismatic personality, Marcos coordinated the EZLN's 1994 uprising, headed up the subsequent peace negotiations, and played a prominent role throughout the Zapatistas' struggle in the following decades. After the ceasefire the government declared on day 12 of the revolt, the Zapatistas transitioned from revolutionary guerrillas to an armed social movement, with Marcos's role transitioning from military strategist to public relations strategist. He became the Zapatistas' spokesperson and interface with the public, penning communiqués, holding press conferences, hosting gatherings, granting interviews, delivering speeches, devising plebiscites, organizing marches, orchestrating campaigns, and twice touring Mexico, all to attract national and international media attention and public support for the Zapatistas.^[6]

In 2001, he headed a delegation of Zapatista commanders to Mexico City to deliver their message on promoting indigenous rights before the Mexican Congress, attracting widespread public and media attention. In 2006, Marcos made another public tour of Mexico, which was known as The Other Campaign. In May 2014, Marcos stated that the persona of Subcomandante Marcos had been "a hologram" and no longer existed.^[7] Many media outlets interpreted the message as Marcos retiring as the Zapatistas' military leader and spokesman.^[8]

Marcos is a prolific writer whose considerable literary talents have been widely acknowledged by prominent writers and intellectuals,^[9] with hundreds of communiqués and several books being attributed to him. Most of his writings are anti-capitalist while advocating for indigenous people's rights, but he has also written poetry, children's stories, and folktales and co-authored a crime novel.^[9] He has been hailed by Régis Debray as "the best Latin American writer today". Published translations of his writings exist in at least 14 languages.^[10]

Early life

Guillén was born on 19 June 1957, in Tampico, Tamaulipas, to Alfonso Guillén and Maria del Socorro Vicente.^[11] He was the fourth of eight children.^[1] A former elementary school teacher,^[5] Alfonso owned a local chain of furniture stores, and the family is usually described as middle-class.^[12][11] In a 2001 interview with Gabriel García Márquez and Roberto Pombo, Guillén described his upbringing as middle class and "without financial difficulties", and said his parents fostered a love for language and reading in their children.^[13] While still "very young", Guillén came to know of and admire Che Guevara^[14]— an admiration that would persist throughout his adulthood.^[15]

Guillén attended high school at the Instituto Cultural Tampico, a Jesuit school in Tampico.^[16][17] Later he moved to Mexico City and graduated from the National Autonomous University of Mexico (UNAM), majoring in philosophy. There he became immersed in the school's pervasive Marxist rhetoric of the 1970s and 1980s and won an award for the best dissertation (drawing on the then-recent work of Althusser and Foucault) of his class. He began working as a professor at the Autonomous Metropolitan University (UAM) while finishing his dissertation at UNAM, but left after a couple of years. It is thought that it was at UAM where he came into contact with, and subsequently joined the ranks of, the Forces of National Liberation, the Maoist mother organization of what would later become the EZLN.^{[citation needed]}

In 1984, he abandoned his academic career in the capital and left for the mountains of Chiapas to convince the poor, indigenous Mayan population to organize and launch a proletarian revolution against the Mexican bourgeoisie and the federal government.^[18] After hearing his proposition, the Chiapanecans "just stared at him," and replied that they were not urban workers, and that from their perspective the land was not property, but the heart of the community.^[18]

Debate exists as to whether Marcos visited Nicaragua in the years soon following the Sandinista Revolution that took place there in 1979, and, if he did, how many times and in what capacity. He is rumored to have done so, although no official documents (for example, immigration records) have been discovered to attest to this. Nick Henck argues that Guillén "may have journeyed" to Nicaragua, although to him the evidence appears "circumstantial".^[19]

Guillén's sister Mercedes Guillén Vicente is the Attorney General of the State of Tamaulipas, and an influential member of the Institutional Revolutionary Party.^{[20][21][22][5]}

The Zapatista Uprising

Marcos's Debut

Marcos made his debut on 1 January 1994, the first day of the 1994 Zapatista uprisings.^[23] According to Marcos, his first encounter with the public and the press, occurred by accident, or at least was not premeditated. Initially, his role was to have been to secure the police headquarters in San Cristóbal de las Casas. However, with the wounding of a subordinate, whose duty it was to transport the weapons just captured from the police station to the central town square where most of the Zapatista troops were amassed, Marcos took his place and headed there instead. As a group of foreign tourists formed around Marcos, the only English-speaking Zapatista at hand, others, including members of the press, joined the throng. Marcos spent from 8 a.m. until 8 p.m., intermittently interacting with tourists, townsfolk, and reporters, and gave four interviews.^[24]

From this initial spark, Marcos's fame would spread like wildfire. As Henck notes: "The first three months of 1994...saw the Subcomandante...giving 24 interviews (i.e. an average of two a week); and participating in ten days of peace negotiations with the government, during which he also held nine press conferences reporting on the progress being made..."^[25]

In the coming months Marcos would be interviewed by Ed Bradley for 60 Minutes [2] be featured in Vanity Fair [3]. He would also devise, convoke and host of the August 1994 National Democratic Convention that brought together 6000 members of civil society to discuss how to organize peaceful struggle that aimed to make Mexico freer, more just and more democratic.^[26]

The February 1995 Government military offensive

Main article: 1995 Zapatista Crisis

 

Subcomandante Marcos (center, wearing brown cap) in Chiapas

In early 1995, while the Secretary of Interior Esteban Moctezuma was, in good faith, reaching out to Marcos and the Zapatistas to arrange talks aimed at bringing peace to Chiapas, Mexico's Attorney General's Office (PGR) learned of the true identity of Subcomandante Marcos from a former-subcommander-turned-traitor Subcomandante Daniel (alias Salvador Morales Garibay).^[27]

On 9 February 1995, President Ernesto Zedillo, armed with this recently acquired information, publicly announced that Subcomandante Marcos had been identified as Rafael Sebastián Guillén Vicente, and immediately ordered the Mexican military to go on the offensive and capture or annihilate Marcos and the Zapatistas.^[28] Arrest warrants were issued for Marcos,^[29] as well as other key figures in the FLN and EZLN, and Zapatista territory in the Lacandon Jungle was invaded by the Mexican Army.

This sudden betrayal of both the truce proclaimed by President Carlos Salinas a year previously and the secret peace negotiations currently being undertaken by Secretary of Interior Esteban Moctezuma, provoked responses from several protagonists that, combined, forced Zedillo to promptly call off the military offensive:

First, Moctezuma tendered his resignation to Zedillo, who refused it and asked Moctezuma to try to restore conditions that would allow for dialogue and negotiation.^[30]

Second, civil society rallied to Marcos' and the Zapatistas' defense, organizing three massive demonstrations in Mexico City in one week. One of these rallies was attended by 100,000 people, some of whom chanted "We Are All Marcos" as they marched.^[31]

Third, Marcos himself capitalized on this sudden, hostile action, issuing some eloquent communiqués in which he lambasted the government's treachery, or at least duplicity, and portrayed himself as self-effacing mock heroic guerrilla.^[32] Marcos would later tell an interviewer: "It's after the betrayal of '95 that people remember us: Then the [Zapatista] movement took off".^[33]

Finally, it prompted Max Appedole, Rafael Guillén's childhood friend and fellow student at the Instituto Cultural Tampico, to approach Edén Pastora, the legendary Nicaraguan "Commander Zero", to help in preparing a report for Under-Secretary of the Interior Luis Maldonado Venegas, Secretary Moctezuma, and President Zedillo, emphasizing Marcos's pacifist disposition and the unintended, detrimental consequences of a military solution to the Zapatista crisis.^[34] The document concluded that the complaints of marginalized groups and the radical left in México had been vented through the Zapatistas movement, while Marcos remained open to negotiation. If Marcos were eliminated, his function as a safety-valve for social discontent would cease and more-radical groups could take his place. These groups would respond to violence with violence, threatening terrorist bombings, kidnappings and even more belligerent activities, and so the country would then be plunged into a very dangerous downward spiral, with discontent surfacing in areas other than Chiapas.^[35]

 

Zapatista Army of National Liberation (EZLN) insurgents in Mexico

As a result, on 10 March 1995 Zedillo and Moctezuma signed into Chiapas Law the "Presidential Decree for the Dialogue, Reconciliation and Peace with Dignity", which was subsequently debated and approved by the Mexican Congress.^[36] Meanwhile, Moctezuma sent Maldonado to enter into direct peace negotiations with the Zapatistas on behalf of the Zedillo government, and these talks took place commencing April 3.^[37]

By 9 April 1995, the basis for the Dialogue Protocol and the "Harmony, Peace with Justice and Dignity Agreement" negotiated between the Mexican government and the Zapatistas was signed. On 17 April, the Mexican government appointed Marco Antonio Bernal as Peace Commissioner in Chiapas, and peace talks began in San Andrés Larráinzar on 22 April.^[38]

The Zapatista Struggle Continues (1994– )

 

Subcommander Marcos in Oaxaca on the Other Campaign in February 2006

The weeks, months and years that followed the January 1994 Zapatista uprising saw Marcos play an incredibly active role as spokesperson for the Zapatista movement. In doing so, he helped deter the Mexican government from eradicating the Zapatistas militarily by keeping the national and international media's attention fixed on the movement, and contributed to building bridges and forging solidarity with activist individuals and groups in Mexico and beyond.

(See Appendix below for a list of events at which Marcos acted as spokesperson for the Zapatistas.)

Political and philosophical writings

Further information: Neozapatismo and Subcomandante Marcos bibliography

 

A selection of Marcos' published writings in the original Spanish and translated into various other languages

Marcos's communiqués, in which he outlines his political and philosophical views, number in the hundreds. These writings, as well as his essays, stories and interviews, have been translated into numerous languages and published in dozens of edited collections and other compilations.^[10] Of Marcos's writings, Jorge Alonso claims, "With over 10,000 citations, he has also made a dent in the academic world. Marcos' writings, as well as books based on him, have been referenced by a large number of researchers from different countries and in several languages."^[39]

Much has been written about Marcos's literary style, in particular its poetic nature and his use of humor, especially irony.^[40] He generally appears to prefer indirect expression, and his writings often take the form of fables or allegorical children's stories, though some are more earthy and direct. In a January 2003 letter to Euskadi Ta Askatasuna (the Basque ETA separatist group) titled "I Shit on All the Revolutionary Vanguards of This Planet", Marcos wrote, "We teach [children of the EZLN] that there are as many words as colors and that there are so many thoughts because within them is the world where words are born...And we teach them to speak with the truth, that is to say, to speak with their hearts."^{[41][non-primary source needed]}

La Historia de los Colores (The Story of Colors) is on the surface a children's story, and is one of Marcos's most-read books. Based on a Mayan creation myth, it teaches tolerance and respect for diversity.^[42] The book's English translation was to be published with support from the U.S. National Endowment for the Arts, but in 1999 the grant was abruptly canceled after a reporter brought the book's content and authorship to NEA chairman William J. Ivey's attention.^[43][44] The Lannan Foundation stepped in and provided support after the NEA withdrew.^[45]

In 2005, Marcos wrote the detective story The Uncomfortable Dead with the whodunit writer Paco Ignacio Taibo II. This crime novel bears "a pro-ecology, pro-democracy, anti-discriminatory (racial, gender, and sexual orientation), anti-neoliberal globalization, and anti-capitalist" message.^[46]

Some of Marcos's works that best articulate his political philosophy include "The Fourth World War Has Begun" (1997), alternatively titled "Seven Loose Pieces of The Global Jigsaw Puzzle"[4]; "The Fourth World War" (1999)[5]; The Sixth Declaration of the Lacandon Jungle (2005); the four-part "Zapatistas and the Other: The Pedestrians of History" (2006);^[47] and Marcos's presentations in Critical Thought in the Face of the Capitalist Hydra and The Zapatistas' Dignified Rage: Final Public Speeches of Subcommander Marcos.

 

Flag of the EZLN

Marcos's literary output serves a political purpose, and even performs a combative function, as suggested in a 2002 book titled Our Word is Our Weapon, a compilation of his articles, poems, speeches, and letters.^[48]

Latin America's Pink Tide and being a Revolutionary vs being a Rebel

Marcos's views on Latin American leaders who formed the continent's Pink Tide are complex. For example, in interviews he gave in 2007 he signaled his approval of Bolivian president Evo Morales, but expressed mixed feelings toward Hugo Chavez of Venezuela, whom he labels "disconcerting" and views as too militant, but nonetheless responsible for vast revolutionary changes in Venezuela. He also called Brazil's current president Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva and Nicaragua's current president Daniel Ortega, whom he once served under while a member of the Sandinistas, traitors who have betrayed their original ideals.^[49][50]

In another interview, given to Jesús Quintero the previous year, however, when asked what he thought about the "pre-revolutionary situation" then existing in Latin America, and specifically about "Evo Morales. Hugo Chavez, Fidel Castro, etcetera", Marcos replied:

We are interested in those of below, not in the governments, nor in Chavez, nor in Kirchner, nor in Tabaré, nor in Evo, nor in Castro. We are interested in the processes which are taking place among the people, among the peoples of Latin America, and especially, out of natural sympathy, we are interested when these movements are led by Indian peoples, as is the case in Bolivia and in Ecuador…We say: "Governments come and go, the people remain"…Chavez will last for a time, Evo Morales will last for a time, Castro will last for a time, but the peoples, the Cuban people, the Bolivian people, the Argentine, the Uruguayan, will go on for a much longer time…^[51]

This emphasis on bottom-up (as opposed to top-down) politics, and concentrating on the people over leaders, even leftwing or revolutionary ones, connects with Marcos's stance on revolution and revolutionaries. In the interview with Quintero mentioned above, when asked "...what does it mean to be revolutionary today?", Marcos responded:

The problem with being revolutionary is that the taking of power must be considered and one must think that things can be transformed from above. We do not think that: we think that society, and the world, should be transformed from below. We think we also have to transform ourselves: in our personal relations, in culture, in art, in communication…and create another kind of society…^[52]

Ultimately, this has led Marcos to reject the label "revolutionary", preferring instead to self-identify as a "rebel", because

"…a revolutionary proposes fundamentally to transform things from above, not from below, the opposite to a social rebel. The revolutionary appears: We are going to form a movement, I will take power and from above will transform things. But not so the social rebel. The social rebel organizes the masses and from below, transforming things without the question of the seizure of power having to be raised.^[53]

Elsewhere, in a communiqué, Marcos elaborates on what distinguishes a revolutionary from a rebel, noting how the revolutionary

...throws off whomever [sic] is sitting on the chair [of power] with one shot, sits down and … [t]here he remains until another Revolutionary … comes by, throws him off and history … repeats itself…[T]the rebel...on the other hand...runs into the Seat of Power…, looks at it carefully, analyzes it, but instead of sitting there he goes and gets a fingernail file and, with heroic patience, he begins sawing at the legs until they are so fragile that they break when someone sits down, which happens almost immediately.^[54]

Despite his preference for rebels over revolutionaries however, Marcos has nevertheless expressed admiration for both Fidel Castro and Che Guevara.^[49]

Popularity

Marcos's popularity was at its height during the first seven years of the Zapatista uprising, A cult of personality developed around the Subcomandante based on the romantic premise of a rebel confronting the powerful in defense of society's underdogs, and an accompanying copious press coverage, sometimes called "Marcos-mania".^[55] As a guest on 60 Minutes in March 1994, Marcos was depicted as a contemporary Robin Hood.^[56]

 

Subcomandante Marcos featured on assorted magazine covers

 

Subcomandante Marcos featured on assorted book & DVD covers

That initial period, 1994–2001, saw reporters from all over the world coming to interview Marcos and do features on him. He was also courted by numerous famous figures and literati (e.g. Oliver Stone, Naomi Klein, Danielle Mitterrand, Regis Debray, Manuel Vázquez Montalbán, Juan Gelman, Gabriel García Márquez, José Saramago), and engaged in exchanges of letters with eminent intellectuals and writers (e.g. John Berger, Carlos Fuentes, Eduardo Galeano). Zapatista events Marcos presided over were attended by people from all over the world by the thousands, including media organizations, and he appeared on the front pages of innumerable magazines, and on the covers of many books and DVDs.^{[citation needed]}

When, in February 1995, the Mexican government revealed Marcos's true identity and issued an arrest warrant for him, thousands marched through the streets of Mexico City chanting "We are all Marcos."^{[citation needed]}

The following year (1996), saw a surge in the Subcommander's popularity and exposure in the media. He was visited by Oliver Stone, Danielle Mitterrand and Régis Debray[6], and he acted as host at the Intercontinental Encuentro For Humanity and Against Neoliberalism, which drew around 5,000 participants from 50 countries, including documentary makers, academics and reporters, some of whom published the interviews that Marcos granted them on the event's sidelines.^[57]

The Subcommander also proved popular with certain musicians and bands. For example, Rage Against the Machine, the Mexican rock band Tijuana No!, Mexican singer-songwriter Óscar Chávez and French Basque singer-songwriter Manu Chao expressed their support for Marcos, and in some cases incorporated recordings of his speeches into their songs or concerts. His face appears on the cover of Thievery Corporation's album, Radio Retaliation.

Marcos experienced a general uptick in popularity in 2006 when he toured Mexico on the Other Campaign. On this 3,000-kilometre (1,900 mi) trek to the capital he was welcomed by "huge adoring crowds, chanting and whistling", while "Marcos handcrafted dolls, and his ski mask-clad face adorns T-shirts, posters and badges."^[58]

By 2011, Mexican historian Enrique Krauze wrote that "Marcos [has] remained popular among young Mexicans, but as a celebrity, not as a role model".^[59]

In May 2014, Marcos gave a speech in front of several thousand onlookers as well as independent media organizations in which, among other things, he explained that because back in 1994 "those outside [the movement] did not see us…the character named 'Marcos' started to be constructed", but that there came a point when "Marcos went from being a spokesperson to being a distractor", and so, convinced that "Marcos, the character, was no longer necessary", the Zapatistas chose to "destroy it".^[60]

Marcos has been compared to popular figures such as England's folklore hero Robin Hood, Mexican revolutionary Emiliano Zapata, Argentine guerrilla Che Guevara, India's pacifist independence leader Mahatma Gandhi, South African anti-apartheid icon Nelson Mandela, and even U.S. president John F. Kennedy in the 1960s, on account of his "popularity in virtually all sectors of Mexican society."^[61]

Marcos is often credited with putting Mexico's indigenous population's poverty in the spotlight, both locally and internationally.^[58] His popularity also served the Zapatista cause well in two very concrete ways. Most immediately, it deprived the Mexican government of the option of militarily crushing them. Second, Marcos was able to capitalize on his popularity to win public support, garner international solidarity, and attract media attention to the Zapatistas.^{[citation needed]}

Marcos has continued to attract media attention, and to be seen both in the company of celebrities and as a celebrity himself. For example, he was photographed alongside Mexican actors Gael García Bernal and Ilse Salas in November 2018,^[62] and Diego Luna in December 2019.^[63]

Relationship with Inter Milan

Apart from cheering for local Liga MX side Chiapas F.C., which relocated to Querétaro in 2013, Subcomandante Marcos and the EZLN also support the Italian Serie A football club Inter Milan.^{[64][self-published source?]} The contact between EZLN and Inter, one of Italy's biggest and most famous clubs, began in 2004 when an EZLN commander contacted a delegate from Inter Campus, the club's charity organization which has funded sports, water, and health projects in Chiapas.^{[citation needed]}

In 2005, Inter's president Massimo Moratti received an invitation from Subcomandante Marcos to have Inter play a football game against a team of Zapatistas with Diego Maradona as referee. Subcomandante Marcos asked Inter to bring the match ball because the Zapatistas' ones were punctured.^[65] Although the proposed spectacle never came to fruition, there has been continuing contact between Inter and the Zapatistas. Former captain Javier Zanetti has expressed sympathy for the Zapatista cause.^[66]

Appendix

The following is a list of events (in chronological order) that were either convened by the Zapatistas, and initiated, organized, orchestrated, or presided over by Marcos, or at which he played a major role; or events put on by other organizations at which Marcos acted as representative of, or spokesperson for, the Zapatistas (EZLN):^[67]

• Peace Talks (March 1994)^[68]
• National Democratic Convention (August 1994)[7][8]
• The First National Indigenous Forum (January 1996)[9][10]
• Meetings with Oliver Stone, Danielle Mitterrand and Régis Debray (April / May 1996)[11]
• The Intercontinental Encuentro For Humanity and Against Neoliberalism (July / August 1996)[12][13]
• The Zapatistas' Second Encuentro with Civil Society (May 1999)[14][15]
• The March of the Color of the Earth / The March for Indian Dignity (February / March 2001)[16]
• The Other Campaign (January—December 2006)
• Spanish Television (TVE) interview with Marcos by Jesús Quintero (June 2006)[17]
• The First Encounter between the Zapatistas and the Peoples of the World (January 2007)[18]
• The 12th Hispano-American Meeting of Writers "Hours of June" at Sonora University (June 2007)[19]
• The "Ethics and Politics" Conference at the UNAM (June 2007)[20]
• The National Forum Against Repression in Mexico City (June 2007)[21]
• The Second Encounter between the Zapatistas and the Peoples of the World (July 2007)[22]
• The "Latin America as seen from the Other Campaign" Round Table at the National School of Anthropology and History (July 2007)[23]
• The "Confronting Capitalist Dispossession: The Defense of Land and Territory" The Press Club (July 2007)[24]
• A Round Table at the University of the Earth in San Cristóbal (July 2007)[25]
• The Encuentro of the Indigenous Peoples of America held in Sonora (October 2007)[26][27]
• The First International Colloquium in Memory of Andrés Aubry: Planet Earth, Anti-systemic Movements (December 2007)^[69]
• The National and International Caravan for Observation and Solidarity with Zapatista Communities (August 2008)^[70]
• The Global Festival of Dignified Rage (January 2009)^[71]
• The Celebration in Homage to Compañeros Luis Villoro Toranzo and Zapatista Teacher Galeano (May 2015)[28][29][30][31]
• The Seminar on Critical Thought in the Face of the Capitalist Hydra (May 2015)[32][33][34]^[72]
• The ConSciences for Humanity (December 2016 – January 2017)[35][36][37][38][39][40][41]
• The "Walls of Capital, the Cracks of the Left" Seminar (April 2017)[42][43][44][45][46]
• ConSciences for Humanity Festival (December 2017)[47][48][49]
• "To Watch, to Listen, to Speak: No Thinking Allowed?" Round Table Discussion (April 2018)[50][51][52]
• The First "Puy ta Cuxlejaltic" Film Festival (November 2018)[53][54]
• The Second "Puy ta Cuxlejaltic" Film Festival (December 2019)[55][56]

See also

• Anti-globalization
• Global justice movement
• Left-wing politics

Notes and references

1. Henck 2007, p. 11.
2. Pasztor, S. B. (2004). Marcos, Subcomandante. In D. Coerver, S. Pasztor & R. Buffington, Mexico: An encyclopedia of contemporary culture and history. Santa Barbara, CA: ABC-CLIO
3. Henck 2019, p. 19.
4. Roitman Rosenmann, Marcos (25 May 2014). "El asesinato de José Luis Solís López, Galeano". La Jornada (in Spanish). Retrieved 16 February 2019.
5. Henck 2007, pp. 29–37.
6. Henck 2019, pp. 26–27.
7. A four-part video, complete with English subtitles, of the Subcommander's final public appearance as Marcos, prior to transforming into Galeano, in which he made this statement, can be found at: 1-Between light and shadow. Sup Marcos' last public speech. English subtitles – YouTube; 2-Between light and shadow. Sup Marcos' last public speech. English subtitles – YouTube; 3-Between light and shadow. Sup Marcos' last public speech. English subtitles; and 4-Between light and shadow. Sup Marcos' last public speech. English subtitles,
8. Althaus, Dudley (27 May 2014). "Mexican Rebel Leader Subcomandante Marcos Retires, Changes Name". Wall Street Journal. from the original on 3 October 2016.
9. Henck 2019, pp. 44–45.
10. See Subcomandante Marcos bibliography
11. Lee Stacy (1 October 2002). Mexico and the United States. Marshall Cavendish. pp. 386–. ISBN 978-0-7614-7402-9.
12. "Subcomandante Marcos: The Punch Card and the Hourglass". New Left Review. 2 (9). May–June 2001. ISSN 0028-6060. from the original on 18 May 2016.
13. The Punch Card and the Hourglass 27 January 2009 at the Wayback Machine by García Márquez and Roberto Pombo, New Left Review, May – June 2001, Issue 9
14. Interview with Raymundo Reynoso (2007) http://www.cedoz.org/site/content.php?doc=518; quoted and translated in Nick Henck, "Subcomandante Marcos: The Latest Reader." The Latin Americanist, Vol. 58, No. 2 (June 2014): 49–73, at p. 50.
15. Henck 2007, p. 27.
16. García Márquez, Gabriel; Pombo, Roberto (25 March 2001). "Habla Marcos". Cambio (Ciudad de México) (in Spanish). from the original on 10 April 2001. A discussion of Marcos's background and views. Marcos says his parents were both schoolteachers and mentions early influences of Cervantes and García Lorca.
17. García Márquez, Gabriel; Marcos, Subcomandante (2 July 2001). "A Zapatista Reading List". The Nation. An abbreviated version of the Cambio article, in English.
18. Farewell to the End of History: Organization and Vision in Anti-Corporate Movements 28 November 2012 at the Wayback Machine by Naomi Klein, The Socialist Register, 2002, London: Merlin Press, 1–14
19. Henck 2007, p. 39.
20. Khasnabish, Alex (2003). "Subcomandante Insurgente Marcos". MCRI Globalization and Autonomy. Archived from the original on 30 May 2012.
21. Carreon, Hector (8 March 2001). . La Voz de Aztlan (in Spanish). Archived from the original on 6 May 2006.
22. El EZLN (2001). . Zapata-Chiapas. Archived from the original on 16 June 2002.
23. The fullest account of the Subcommander's actions on 1 January appears in Nick Henck, Subcommander Marcos: the Man and the Mask (Durham, NC, 2007), pp. 202ff; and Nick Henck, "Laying a Ghost to Rest: Subcommander Marcos's Playing of the Indigenous Card". Estudios Mexicanos/Mexican Studies. 25 (1) (Winter 2009), pp. 155–170. See too, however, John Ross Rebellion from the Roots (Monroe, ME, 1995), pp. 16f; Andres Oppenheimer, Bordering on Chaos. Boston: [1996] 1998), pp. 21–23; and Subcomandante Marcos, Our Word is Our Weapon. Juana Ponce de León (ed.), (New York, 2001), pp. 9–10.
24. Henck, Nick (2009). "Laying a Ghost to Rest: Subcommander Marcos's Playing of the Indigenous Card". Estudios Mexicanos/Mexican Studies. 25 (1): 155–170, at 160 & 164, fn 11. doi:10.1525/msem.2009.25.1.155. JSTOR 10.1525/msem.2009.25.1.155 – via JSTOR.
25. Henck 2019, p. 27.
26. Henck 2019, p. 32.
27. El otro subcomandante 17 October 2013 at the Wayback Machine
28. . Memoria Política de México (in Spanish). Archived from the original on 22 December 2015. Retrieved 14 December 2015.
29. PGR ordena la captura y devela la identidad del Subcomandante Marcos (9 de febrero 1995). tvinsomne. 24 September 2009. from the original on 14 March 2021. Retrieved 5 September 2021 – via YouTube.
30. Moctezuma Barragán, Esteban. "Renuncia en Gobernación". El Universal (in Spanish). from the original on 2 November 2013.
31. Henck 2007, p. 284.
32. Henck 2007, p. 288ff.
33. Henck 2007, p. 285.
34. . Archived from the original on 3 November 2013.
35. "Marcos, en la mira de Zedillo". Proceso (in Spanish). 5 August 2002. from the original on 17 October 2013.
36. "Client Validation". from the original on 2 November 2013.
37. Salas, Javier Rosiles (31 May 2012). "MORENO VALLE-TV AZTECA: EL TÁNDEM POBLANO". Sin Embargo (in Spanish). from the original on 24 July 2016.
38. "Cronologia del Conflicto EZLN". Latin American Studies. from the original on 28 November 2012.
39. Alonso, Jorge (May 2016). "A History of Challenging Messages". Envio Digital.
40. See: Henck, Nick (2019). Subcomandante Marcos: Global Rebel Icon. Montreal: Black Rose Books. pp. 44–54. ISBN 9781551647043; and Conant, Jeff (2010). The Poetics of Resistance: The Revolutionary public Relations of the Zapatista Insurgency. Oakland, CA: A.K. Press. ISBN 9781849350006. On Marcos' use of irony, see Daniela Di Piramo, "Beyond Modernity: Irony, Fantasy, and the Challenge to Grand Narratives in Subcomandante Marcos's Tales." Mexican Studies/Estudios Mexicanos 27, no. 1 (2011): 177–205; and Kristine Vanden Berghe, "The Carcaol and the Beetle: A Tension between Ideology and Form in the EZLN." KAMCHATKA. REVISTA DE ANÁLISIS CULTURAL 12 (2018), pp. 213–216:https://ojs.uv.es/index.php/kamchatka/article/view/12357/12355.
41. Marcos, Subcomandante (9 January 2003). . La Jornada. Archived from the original on 13 June 2006.
42. Patrick Markee (16 May 1999). "Hue and Cry". New York Times. from the original on 5 March 2016.
43. Byrd, Bobby (2003). . Cinco Puntos Press. Archived from the original on 6 September 2015.
44. Preston, Julia (10 March 1999). "U.S. Cancels Grant for Children's Book Written by Mexican Guerrilla". New York Times. This article was retitled "N.E.A. Couldn't Tell a Mexican Rebel's Book by Its Cover" in late editions.
45. Irvin Molotsky (11 March 1999). "Foundation Will Bankroll Rebel Chief's Book N.E.A. Dropped". New York Times.
46. Henck 2019, p. 50.
47. See: http://www.elkilombo.org/documents/peatonesI.html, http://www.ainfos.ca/06/sep/ainfos00259.html, http://www.elkilombo.org/documents/pedestrians3.html, and http://www.elkilombo.org/documents/pedestrians4.html.
48. On Marcos' use of words as weapons, see: Henck, Nick (2019). Subcomandante Marcos: Global Rebel Icon. Black Rose Books. pp. 52–54. ISBN 978-1551647043; and Henck, Nick (2017). Insurgent Marcos: The Political-Philosophical Formation of the Zapatista Subcommander. Raleigh, N.C.: Editorial A Contracorriente. pp. 168–171. ISBN 978-1945234033.
49. "'Subcomandante Marcos' dice que Chávez tiene 'improntas de caudillo'". Aporrea (in Spanish). 28 April 2008. from the original on 13 October 2013.
50. Tuckman, Jo (12 May 2007). "Man in the mask returns to change world with new coalition and his own sexy novel". The Guardian. London. from the original on 21 September 2016.
51. Quintero, Jesús (2007). Entrevista. Madrid: Aguilar. pp. 90f. ISBN 978-8403097391.
52. Quintero, Jesús (2007). Entrevista. Madrid: Aguilar. p. 86. ISBN 978-8403097391.
53. In Marcos' interview with Julio Scherer, "La entrevista insólita," Proceso no. 1271, 11 March 2001, 14–15; quoted and translated Henck, Nick (2017). Insurgent Marcos: The Political-Philosophical Formation of the Zapatista Subcommander. Raleigh, N.C.: Editorial A Contracorriente. p. 173 ISBN 978-1945234033.
54. Subcomandante Marcos (2005). Conversations with Durito: Stories of the Zapatistas and Neoliberalism (PDF). New York: Autonomedia. p. 309. ISBN 978-1570271182.
55. Henck 2019, pp. 40–41.
56. Millett, Richard; Gold-Biss, Michael (1996). Beyond Praetorianism: The Latin American Military in Transition. North-South Center Press, University of Miami. p. 130. ISBN 978-1-57454-000-0.
57. Henck 2019, p. 33.
58. BBC Profile: The Zapatistas' mysterious leader 18 October 2011 at the Wayback Machine by Nathalie Malinarich, 11 March 2001
59. Krauze, Enrique (2011). Redeemers; Ideas and Power in Latin America. New York: HarperCollins. p. 447. ISBN 978-0060938444.
60. Marcos, Subcomandante (2018). The Zapatistas' Dignified Rage: Final Public Speeches of Subcommander Marcos. Chico, CA: A.K. Press. pp. 218–223. ISBN 978-1849352925.
61. Gossen, Gary H. (1996). "Who is the Comandante of Subcomandante Marcos?". In Gosner, Kevin; Ouweneel, Arij (eds.). Indigenous Revolts in Chiapas and the Andean Highlands. Amsterdam: CEDLA. p. 107. ISBN 978-9070280567.
62. "Gael García "comparte utopías" con el Subcomandante Galeano en el festival de cine del EZLN". El País (in Spanish). 6 November 2018. Retrieved 15 September 2020.
63. "Se encuentran Diego Luna y el Subcomandante Galeano". El Sur: Periódico de Guerrero (in Spanish). 17 December 2019. Retrieved 15 September 2020.
64. "Spegnere il fuoco con la benzina" (in Italian). 12 January 2013. from the original on 3 October 2016.
65. "Il subcomandante Marcos sfida l'Inter "Davanti alla porta non avrei pietà"". La Repubblica (in Italian). 28 May 2005. from the original on 8 September 2012.
66. "Zapatista rebels woo Inter Milan". BBC News. 11 May 2005. from the original on 14 December 2013.
67. Henck, Nick (2019). Subcomandante Marcos: Global Rebel Icon. Black Rose Press. pp. 9–18. ISBN 978-1551647043 has a useful timeline, which goes up to April 2018, that lists most of the events below (as well as others), accompanied by a very brief description of them.
68. Autonomedia. "The Dialogue". In its ¡Zapatistas! Documents of the New Mexican Revolution, Ch. 8. New York: Autonomedia, 1994.[1]
69. See Marcos, Subcomandante (2018). The Zapatistas' Dignified Rage: Final Public Speeches of Subcommander Marcos. Chico, CA: A.K. Press. pp. 39–108. ISBN 978-1849352925.
70. See Marcos, Subcomandante (2018). The Zapatistas' Dignified Rage: Final Public Speeches of Subcommander Marcos. Chico, CA: A.K. Press. pp. 109–122. ISBN 978-1849352925.
71. See Marcos, Subcomandante (2018).The Zapatistas' Dignified Rage: Final Public Speeches of Subcommander Marcos. Chico, CA: A.K. Press. pp. 131–201. ISBN 978-1849352925.
72. See too, Subcomandante Marcos, Critical Thought in the Face of the Capitalist Hydra (Durham, NC, 2016).

Bibliography

Primary sources

For a list of Marcos' own works in the Spanish original, as well as those translated into English and more than a dozen other languages, plus all those interviews given by Marcos that were either conducted in English or subsequently translated into English, see Bibliography of Subcomandante Marcos.

Secondary sources

• Berghe, Kristine Vanden (2009). "The Quixote in the Stories of Subcomandante Marcos". In D'haen, Theo; Dhondt, Reindert (eds.). International Don Quixote. Leiden: Brill. pp. 53–69. doi:10.1163/9789042029187_005. ISBN 978-90-420-2583-7.
• Berghe, Kristine; Maddens, Bart (2004). "Ethnocentrism, Nationalism and Post-nationalism in the Tales of Subcomandante Marcos". Mexican Studies. 20 (1): 123–144. doi:10.1525/msem.2004.20.1.123. ISSN 0742-9797. JSTOR 10.1525/msem.2004.20.1.123.
• Burdette, Hannah (2009). "The Man in the Mirrored Mask: Anonymity as Discursive Strategy in Subcomandante Marcos's Letters to the Press". In Martínez Diente, Pablo; Wiseman, David P. (eds.). Border Crossings: Boundaries of Cultural Interpretation. Vanderbilt University. pp. 25–31 – via Academia.edu.
• Castellanos, Laura (2008). "Learning, Surviving: Marcos After the Rupture". NACLA Report on the Americas. 41 (3): 34–39. doi:10.1080/10714839.2008.11725409. ISSN 1071-4839.
• di Piramo, Daniela (2010). Political Leadership in Zapatista Mexico: Marcos, Celebrity, and Charismatic Authority. Boulder, Colorado: FirstForumPress. ISBN 978-1-935049-21-0. OCLC 871258535.
• di Piramo, Daniela (2011). "Beyond Modernity: Irony, Fantasy, and the Challenge to Grand Narratives in Subcomandante Marcos's Tales". Mexican Studies. 27 (1): 177–205. doi:10.1525/msem.2011.27.1.177. ISSN 0742-9797.
• Frankel, Emily Elizabeth (2021). "The Convergence of Past and Present Revolutionary His & Herstories in Subcomandante Marcos- La verdadera leyenda (1995)". A Contracorriente: Una Revista de Estudios Latinoamericanos. 18 (3): 125–160.
• Gregory, Stephen (2000). "John Berger & Subcomandante Marcos". Third Text. 14 (52): 3–9. doi:10.1080/09528820008576861. ISSN 0952-8822.
• Henck, Nick (2007). Subcommander Marcos: The Man and the Mask. Durham, North Carolina: Duke University Press. ISBN 978-0-8223-3978-6. OCLC 86115377.
• Henck, Nick (2009). "Laying a Ghost to Rest: Subcommander Marcos' Playing of the Indigenous Card". Mexican Studies. 25 (1): 155–170. doi:10.1525/msem.2009.25.1.155. ISSN 0742-9797.
• Henck, Nick (2016). Insurgent Marcos: The Political-Philosophical Formation of the Zapatista Subcommander. Raleigh, North Carolina: University of North Carolina Press. ISBN 978-1-945234-27-9. JSTOR 10.5149/9781945234279_henck. OCLC 1028189788.
• Henck, Nick (2019). Subcomandante Marcos: Global Rebel Icon. Montreal: Black Rose Books. ISBN 978-1-551647-06-7. OCLC 1090304110.
• Herlinghaus, Hermann (2005). "Subcomandante Marcos: Narrative Policy and Epistemological Project". Journal of Latin American Cultural Studies. 14 (1): 53–74. doi:10.1080/13569320500062250.
• Jorgensen, Beth Ellen (2004). "Making History: Subcomandante Marcos in the Mexican Chronicle". South Central Review. 21 (3): 85–106. doi:10.1353/scr.2004.0041. ISSN 0743-6831.
• Klein, Naomi (2002). "The Unknown Icon". In Hayden, Tom (ed.). The Zapatista Reader. New York: Thunder’s Mouth Press/Nation Books. pp. 114–23. ISBN 1560253355. OCLC 47696577.
• Krauze, Enrique (2011). "Subcomandante Marcos: The Rise and Fall of a Guerrillero". In Krauze, Enrique (ed.). Redeemers: Ideas and Power in Latin America. New York: Harper Perennial. pp. 433–448. ISBN 0066214734.
• Orr-Álvarez, Brianne (2017). "Masking Revolution: Subcomandante Marcos and the Contemporary Zapatista Movement". In Beauchesne, Kim; Santos, Alessandra (eds.). Performing Utopias in the Contemporary Americas. New York: Palgrave Macmillan. pp. 111–129. doi:10.1057/978-1-137-56873-1_7. ISBN 978-1-137-56873-1.
• Ramírez, Gloria Muñoz (2008). The Fire and the Word: A History of the Zapatista Movement. New York: City Lights Publishers. ISBN 978-0-87286-488-7.
• Rivera, Omar (2011). "Political Ontology (and Representative Politics), Agamben, Dussel... Subcomandante Marcos". Epoché: A Journal for the History of Philosophy. 16 (1): 125–138. doi:10.5840/epoche201116110. ISSN 1085-1968.
• Rubin, Jeffrey W. (2002). "From Che to Marcos: The Changing Grassroots Left in Latin America" (PDF). Dissent. 49 (3): 39–47. ISSN 0012-3846.
• Steele, Cynthia (2002). "The Rainforest Chronicles of Subcomandante Marcos". In Corona, Ignacio; Jörgensen, Beth E. (eds.). The Contemporary Mexican Chronicle: Theoretical Perspectives on the Liminal Genre. SUNY Press. pp. 245–256. ISBN 0-7914-5353-7. LCCN 2001041116.

Further reading

• Anurudda Pradeep (2006). Zapatista.
• Mihalis Mentinis (2006). ZAPATISTAS: The Chiapas Revolt and What It Means for Radical Politics. London: Pluto Press.
• John Ross (1995). Rebellion from the Roots: Indian Uprising in Chiapas. Monroe, ME: Common Courage Press.
• George Allen Collier; Elizabeth Lowery Quaratiello (1995). Basta! Land and the Zapatista Rebellion in Chiapas. Oakland, CA: Food First Books.
• John Womack Jr. (1999). Rebellion in Chiapas: An Historical Reader. New York: The New Press.
• Alma Guillermoprieto (2001). Looking for History: Dispatches from Latin America. New York: Knopf Publishing Group.

External links

 

Wikiquote has quotations related to Subcomandante Marcos.

• Profile: The Zapatistas' mysterious leader, BBC News
• A Place Called Chiapas - a 1998 Documentary by Nettie Wild about the Zapatista movement.
• Revolution Rocks: Thoughts of Mexico's First Postmodern Guerrilla Commander by The New York Times
• From Che to Marcos by Jeffrey W. Rubin, Dissent Magazine, Summer 2002