fbpx
Wikipedia

Bourgeoisie

The bourgeoisie (/ˌbʊərʒwɑːˈz/ BOOR-zhwah-ZEE, French: [buʁʒwazi] ) is a class of business owners and merchants which emerged in the Late Middle Ages, originally as a "middle class" between peasantry and aristocracy. They are traditionally contrasted with the proletariat by their wealth, political power, and education,[1][2] as well as their access to and control of cultural, social and financial capital.

The bourgeoisie in its original sense is intimately linked to the political ideology of liberalism and its existence within cities, recognized as such by their urban charters (e.g., municipal charters, town privileges, German town law), so there was no bourgeoisie apart from the citizenry of the cities.[3] Rural peasants came under a different legal system.

In Communist philosophy, the bourgeoisie is the social class that came to own the means of production during modern industrialization and whose societal concerns are the value of private property and the preservation of capital to ensure the perpetuation of their economic dominance in society.[4]

Etymology edit

The Modern French word bourgeois (/ˈbʊərʒwɑː/ BOORZH-wah or /bʊərˈʒwɑː/ boorzh-WAH, French: [buʁʒwa] ) derived from the Old French borgeis or borjois ('town dweller'), which derived from bourg ('market town'), from the Old Frankish burg ('town'); in other European languages, the etymologic derivations include the Middle English burgeis, the Middle Dutch burgher, the German Bürger, the Modern English burgess, the Spanish burgués, the Portuguese burguês, and the Polish burżuazja, which occasionally is synonymous with the intelligentsia.[5]

In the 18th century, before the French Revolution (1789–1799), in the French Ancien Régime, the masculine and feminine terms bourgeois and bourgeoise identified the relatively rich men and women who were members of the urban and rural Third Estate – the common people of the French realm, who violently deposed the absolute monarchy of the Bourbon King Louis XVI (r. 1774–1791), his clergy, and his aristocrats in the French Revolution of 1789–1799. Hence, since the 19th century, the term "bourgeoisie" usually is politically and sociologically synonymous with the ruling upper class of a capitalist society.[6][7] In English, the word "bourgeoisie", as a term referring to French history, refers to a social class oriented to economic materialism and hedonism, and to upholding the political and economic interests of the capitalist ruling-class.[8]

Historically, the medieval French word bourgeois denoted the inhabitants of the bourgs (walled market-towns), the craftsmen, artisans, merchants, and others, who constituted "the bourgeoisie". They were the socio-economic class between the peasants and the landlords, between the workers and the owners of the means of production. As the economic managers of the (raw) materials, the goods, and the services, and thus the capital (money) produced by the feudal economy, the term "bourgeoisie" evolved to also denote the middle class – the businessmen and businesswomen who accumulated, administered, and controlled the capital that made possible the development of the bourgs into cities.[9][need quotation to verify]

Contemporarily, the terms "bourgeoisie" and "bourgeois" (noun) identify the ruling class in capitalist societies, as a social stratum; while "bourgeois" (adjective / noun modifier) describes the Weltanschauung (worldview) of men and women whose way of thinking is socially and culturally determined by their economic materialism and philistinism, a social identity famously mocked in Molière's comedy Le Bourgeois gentilhomme (1670), which satirizes buying the trappings of a noble-birth identity as the means of climbing the social ladder.[10][11][page needed] The 18th century saw a partial rehabilitation of bourgeois values in genres such as the drame bourgeois (bourgeois drama) and "bourgeois tragedy".

Emerging in the 1970s, the shortened term "bougie" became slang, referring to things or attitudes which are middle class, pretentious and suburban.[12] In 2016, a hip-hop group Migos produced a song Bad and Boujee, featuring an intentional misspelling of the word as "boujee"[12] – a term which has particularly been used by African Americans in reference to African Americans. The term refers to a person of lower or middle class doing pretentious activities or virtue signalling as an affectation of the upper-class.[13]

History edit

Origins and rise edit

 
The 16th-century German banker Jakob Fugger and his principal accountant, M. Schwarz, registering an entry to a ledger. The background shows a file cabinet indicating the European cities where the Fugger bank conducts business (1517).

The bourgeoisie emerged as a historical and political phenomenon in the 11th century when the bourgs of Central and Western Europe developed into cities dedicated to commerce and crafts. This urban expansion was possible thanks to economic concentration due to the appearance of protective self-organisation into guilds. Guilds arose when individual businessmen (such as craftsmen, artisans and merchants) conflicted with their rent-seeking feudal landlords who demanded greater rents than previously agreed.

In the event, by the end of the Middle Ages (c. AD 1500), under regimes of the early national monarchies of Western Europe, the bourgeoisie acted in self-interest, and politically supported the king or queen against legal and financial disorder caused by the greed of the feudal lords.[citation needed] In the late-16th and early 17th centuries, the bourgeoisies of England and the Netherlands had become the financial – thus political – forces that deposed the feudal order; economic power had vanquished military power in the realm of politics.[9]

From progress to reaction (Marxist view) edit

According to the Marxist view of history, during the 17th and 18th centuries, the bourgeoisie were the politically progressive social class who supported the principles of constitutional government and of natural right, against the Law of Privilege and the claims of rule by divine right that the nobles and prelates had autonomously exercised during the feudal order.

The English Civil War (1642–1651), the American War of Independence (1775–1783), and French Revolution (1789–1799) were partly motivated by the desire of the bourgeoisie to rid themselves of the feudal and royal encroachments on their personal liberty, commercial prospects, and the ownership of property. In the 19th century, the bourgeoisie propounded liberalism, and gained political rights, religious rights, and civil liberties for themselves and the lower social classes; thus the bourgeoisie was a progressive philosophic and political force in Western societies.

After the Industrial Revolution (1750–1850), by the mid-19th century the great expansion of the bourgeoisie social class caused its stratification – by business activity and by economic function – into the haute bourgeoisie (bankers and industrialists) and the petite bourgeoisie (tradesmen and white-collar workers).[2] Moreover, by the end of the 19th century, the capitalists (the original bourgeoisie) had ascended to the upper class, while the developments of technology and technical occupations allowed the rise of working-class men and women to the lower strata of the bourgeoisie; yet the social progress was incidental.

Denotations edit

Marxist theory edit

 
Karl Marx

According to Karl Marx, the bourgeois during the Middle Ages usually was a self-employed businessman – such as a merchant, banker, or entrepreneur[2] – whose economic role in society was being the financial intermediary to the feudal landlord and the peasant who worked the fief, the land of the lord. Yet, by the 18th century, the time of the Industrial Revolution (1750–1850) and of industrial capitalism, the bourgeoisie had become the economic ruling class who owned the means of production (capital and land), and who controlled the means of coercion (armed forces and legal system, police forces and prison system).[2][14]

In such a society, the bourgeoisie's ownership of the means of production allowed them to employ and exploit the wage-earning working class (urban and rural), people whose only economic means is labour; and the bourgeois control of the means of coercion suppressed the sociopolitical challenges by the lower classes, and so preserved the economic status quo; workers remained workers, and employers remained employers.[15]

In the 19th century, Marx distinguished two types of bourgeois capitalist:

  • the functional capitalists, who are business administrators of the means of production;
  • rentier capitalists whose livelihoods derive either from the rent of property or from the interest-income produced by finance capital, or both.[16]

In the course of economic relations, the working class and the bourgeoisie continually engage in class struggle, where the capitalists exploit the workers, while the workers resist their economic exploitation, which occurs because the worker owns no means of production, and, to earn a living, seeks employment from the bourgeois capitalist; the worker produces goods and services that are property of the employer, who sells them for a price.

Besides describing the social class who owns the means of production, the Marxist use of the term "bourgeois" also describes the consumerist style of life derived from the ownership of capital and real property. Marx acknowledged the bourgeois industriousness that created wealth, but criticised the moral hypocrisy of the bourgeoisie when they ignored the alleged origins of their wealth: the exploitation of the proletariat, the urban and rural workers. Further sense denotations of "bourgeois" describe ideological concepts such as "bourgeois freedom", which is thought to be opposed to substantive forms of freedom; "bourgeois independence"; "bourgeois personal individuality"; the "bourgeois family"; et cetera, all derived from owning capital and property (see The Communist Manifesto, 1848).

France and Francophone countries edit

In English, the term bourgeoisie is often used to denote the middle classes. In fact, the French term encompasses both the upper and middle economic classes,[17] a misunderstanding which has occurred in other languages as well. The bourgeoisie in France and many French-speaking countries consists of five evolving social layers: petite bourgeoisie, moyenne bourgeoisie, grande bourgeoisie, haute bourgeoisie and ancienne bourgeoisie.

Petite bourgeoisie edit

The petite bourgeoisie is the equivalent of the modern-day middle class, or refers to "a social class between the middle class and the lower class: the lower middle class".[18]

Nazism edit

Nazism rejected the Marxist concept of proletarian internationalism and class struggle, and supported the "class struggle between nations", and sought to resolve internal class struggle in the nation while it identified Germany as a proletariat nation fighting against plutocratic nations.[19] The Nazi Party had many working-class supporters and members, and a strong appeal to the middle class. The financial collapse of the white collar middle-class of the 1920s figures much in their strong support of Nazism.[20] In the poor country that was the Weimar Republic of the early 1930s, the Nazi Party realised their social policies with food and shelter for the unemployed and the homeless—who were later recruited into the Brownshirt Sturmabteilung (SA – Storm Detachments).[20]

Adolf Hitler was impressed by the populist antisemitism and the anti-liberal bourgeois agitation of Karl Lueger, who as the mayor of Vienna during Hitler's time in the city, used a rabble-rousing style of oratory that appealed to the wider masses.[21] When asked whether he supported the "bourgeois right-wing", Hitler claimed that Nazism was not exclusively for any class, and he also indicated that it favoured neither the left nor the right, but preserved "pure" elements from both "camps", stating: "From the camp of bourgeois tradition, it takes national resolve, and from the materialism of the Marxist dogma, living, creative Socialism."[22]

Hitler distrusted capitalism for being unreliable due to its egotism, and he preferred a state-directed economy that is subordinated to the interests of the Volk.[23] Hitler told a party leader in 1934, "The economic system of our day is the creation of the Jews."[23] Hitler said to Benito Mussolini that capitalism had "run its course".[23] Hitler also said that the business bourgeoisie "know nothing except their profit. 'Fatherland' is only a word for them."[24] Hitler was personally disgusted with the ruling bourgeois elites of Germany during the period of the Weimar Republic, whom he referred to as "cowardly shits".[25]

Modern history in Italy edit

Because of their ascribed cultural excellence as a social class, the Italian fascist régime (1922–45) of Prime Minister Benito Mussolini regarded the bourgeoisie as an obstacle to Modernism.[26] Nonetheless, the Fascist State ideologically exploited the Italian bourgeoisie and their materialistic, middle-class spirit, for the more efficient cultural manipulation of the upper (aristocratic) and the lower (working) classes of Italy.

In 1938, Prime Minister Mussolini gave a speech wherein he established a clear ideological distinction between capitalism (the social function of the bourgeoisie) and the bourgeoisie (as a social class), whom he dehumanised by reducing them into high-level abstractions: a moral category and a state of mind.[26] Culturally and philosophically, Mussolini isolated the bourgeoisie from Italian society by portraying them as social parasites upon the fascist Italian state and "The People"; as a social class who drained the human potential of Italian society, in general, and of the working class, in particular; as exploiters who victimised the Italian nation with an approach to life characterised by hedonism and materialism.[26] Nevertheless, despite the slogan The Fascist Man Disdains the ″Comfortable″ Life, which epitomised the anti-bourgeois principle, in its final years of power, for mutual benefit and profit, the Mussolini fascist régime transcended ideology to merge the political and financial interests of Prime Minister Benito Mussolini with the political and financial interests of the bourgeoisie, the Catholic social circles who constituted the ruling class of Italy.

Philosophically, as a materialist creature, the bourgeois man was stereotyped as irreligious; thus, to establish an existential distinction between the supernatural faith of the Roman Catholic Church and the materialist faith of temporal religion; in The Autarchy of Culture: Intellectuals and Fascism in the 1930s, the priest Giuseppe Marino said that:

Christianity is essentially anti-bourgeois. ... A Christian, a true Christian, and thus a Catholic, is the opposite of a bourgeois.[27]

Culturally, the bourgeois man may be considered effeminate, infantile, or acting in a pretentious manner; describing his philistinism in Bonifica antiborghese (1939), Roberto Paravese comments on the:

Middle class, middle man, incapable of great virtue or great vice: and there would be nothing wrong with that, if only he would be willing to remain as such; but, when his child-like or feminine tendency to camouflage pushes him to dream of grandeur, honours, and thus riches, which he cannot achieve honestly with his own "second-rate" powers, then the average man compensates with cunning, schemes, and mischief; he kicks out ethics, and becomes a bourgeois. The bourgeois is the average man who does not accept to remain such, and who, lacking the strength sufficient for the conquest of essential values—those of the spirit—opts for material ones, for appearances.[28]

The economic security, financial freedom, and social mobility of the bourgeoisie threatened the philosophic integrity of Italian Fascism, the ideological monolith that was the régime of Prime Minister Benito Mussolini. Any assumption of legitimate political power (government and rule) by the bourgeoisie represented a fascist loss of totalitarian state power for social control through political unity—one people, one nation, and one leader. Sociologically, to the fascist man, to become a bourgeois was a character flaw inherent to the masculine mystique; therefore, the ideology of Italian fascism scornfully defined the bourgeois man as "spiritually castrated".[28]

Bourgeois culture edit

Cultural hegemony edit

Karl Marx said that the culture of a society is dominated by the mores of the ruling-class, wherein their superimposed value system is abided by each social class (the upper, the middle, the lower) regardless of the socio-economic results it yields to them. In that sense, contemporary societies are bourgeois to the degree that they practice the mores of the small-business "shop culture" of early modern France; which the writer Émile Zola (1840–1902) naturalistically presented, analysed, and ridiculed in the twenty-two-novel series (1871–1893) about Les Rougon-Macquart family; the thematic thrust is the necessity for social progress, by subordinating the economic sphere to the social sphere of life.[29]

Conspicuous consumption edit

 
Clothing worn by ladies belonging to the bourgeoisie of Żywiec, Poland, 19th century (collection of the Żywiec City Museum)

The critical analyses of the bourgeois mentality by the German intellectual Walter Benjamin (1892–1940) indicated that the shop culture of the petite bourgeoisie established the sitting room as the centre of personal and family life; as such, the English bourgeois culture is, he alleges, a sitting-room culture of prestige through conspicuous consumption. The material culture of the bourgeoisie concentrated on mass-produced luxury goods of high quality; between generations, the only variance was the materials with which the goods were manufactured.

In the early part of the 19th century, the bourgeois house contained a home that first was stocked and decorated with hand-painted porcelain, machine-printed cotton fabrics, machine-printed wallpaper, and Sheffield steel (crucible and stainless). The utility of these things was inherent in their practical functions. By the latter part of the 19th century, the bourgeois house contained a home that had been remodelled by conspicuous consumption. Here, Benjamin argues, the goods were bought to display wealth (discretionary income), rather than for their practical utility. The bourgeoisie had transposed the wares of the shop window to the sitting room, where the clutter of display signalled bourgeois success[30] (see Culture and Anarchy, 1869).

Two spatial constructs manifest the bourgeois mentality: (i) the shop-window display, and (ii) the sitting room. In English, the term "sitting-room culture" is synonymous for "bourgeois mentality", a "philistine" cultural perspective from the Victorian Era (1837–1901), especially characterised by the repression of emotion and of sexual desire; and by the construction of a regulated social-space where "propriety" is the key personality trait desired in men and women.[30]

Nonetheless, from such a psychologically constricted worldview, regarding the rearing of children, contemporary sociologists claim to have identified "progressive" middle-class values, such as respect for non-conformity, self-direction, autonomy, gender equality and the encouragement of innovation; as in the Victorian Era, the transposition to the US of the bourgeois system of social values has been identified as a requisite for employment success in the professions.[31][32]

 
The prototypical bourgeois, Monsieur Jourdain, the protagonist in Molière's play Le Bourgeois gentilhomme (1670)

Bourgeois values are dependent on rationalism, which began with the economic sphere and moves into every sphere of life which is formulated by Max Weber.[33] The beginning of rationalism is commonly called the Age of Reason. Much like the Marxist critics of that period, Weber was concerned with the growing ability of large corporations and nations to increase their power and reach throughout the world.

Satire and criticism in art edit

Beyond the intellectual realms of political economy, history, and political science that discuss, describe, and analyse the bourgeoisie as a social class, the colloquial usage of the sociological terms bourgeois and bourgeoise describe the social stereotypes of the old money and of the nouveau riche, who is a politically timid conformist satisfied with a wealthy, consumerist style of life characterised by conspicuous consumption and the continual striving for prestige.[34][35] This being the case, the cultures of the world describe the philistinism of the middle-class personality, produced by the excessively rich life of the bourgeoisie, is examined and analysed in comedic and dramatic plays, novels, and films (see Authenticity).

 
The 17th-century French playwright Molière (1622–73) catalogued the social-climbing essence of the bourgeoisie in Le Bourgeois gentilhomme(1670)

The term bourgeoisie has been used as a pejorative and a term of abuse since the 19th century, particularly by intellectuals and artists.[36]

Theatre edit

Le Bourgeois gentilhomme (The Would-be Gentleman, 1670) by Molière (Jean-Baptiste Poquelin), is a comedy-ballet that satirises Monsieur Jourdain, the prototypical nouveau riche man who buys his way up the social-class scale, to realise his aspirations of becoming a gentleman, to which end he studies dancing, fencing, and philosophy, the trappings and accomplishments of a gentleman, to be able to pose as a man of noble birth, someone who, in 17th-century France, was a man to the manor born; Jourdain's self-transformation also requires managing the private life of his daughter, so that her marriage can also assist his social ascent.[11][page needed][37]

Literature edit

 
Thomas Mann (1875–1955) portrayed the moral, intellectual, and physical decadence of the German upper bourgeoisie in the novel Buddenbrooks (1926)

Buddenbrooks (1901), by Thomas Mann (1875–1955), chronicles the moral, intellectual, and physical decay of a rich family through its declines, material and spiritual, in the course of four generations, beginning with the patriarch Johann Buddenbrook Sr. and his son, Johann Buddenbrook Jr., who are typically successful German businessmen; each is a reasonable man of solid character.

Yet, in the children of Buddenbrook Jr., the materially comfortable style of life provided by the dedication to solid, middle-class values elicits decadence: The fickle daughter, Toni, lacks and does not seek a purpose in life; son Christian is honestly decadent, and lives the life of a ne'er-do-well; and the businessman son, Thomas, who assumes command of the Buddenbrook family fortune, occasionally falters from middle-class solidity by being interested in art and philosophy, the impractical life of the mind, which, to the bourgeoisie, is the epitome of social, moral, and material decadence.[38][39][40]

Babbitt (1922), by Sinclair Lewis (1885–1951), satirizes the American bourgeois George Follansbee Babbitt, a middle-aged realtor, booster, and joiner in the Midwestern city of Zenith, who – despite being unimaginative, self-important, and hopelessly conformist and middle-class – is aware that there must be more to life than money and the consumption of the best things that money can buy. Nevertheless, he fears being excluded from the mainstream of society more than he does living for himself, by being true to himself – his heart-felt flirtations with independence (dabbling in liberal politics and a love affair with a pretty widow) come to naught because he is existentially afraid.

 
The Spanish cinéast Luis Buñuel (1900–83) depicted the tortuous mentality and self-destructive hypocrisy of the bourgeoisie

Yet, George F. Babbitt sublimates his desire for self-respect, and encourages his son to rebel against the conformity that results from bourgeois prosperity, by recommending that he be true to himself:

Don't be scared of the family. No, nor all of zenith. Nor of yourself, the way I've been.[41]

Films edit

Many of the satirical films by the Spanish film director Luis Buñuel (1900–1983) examine the mental and moral effects of the bourgeois mentality, its culture, and the stylish way of life it provides for its practitioners.

  • L'Âge d'or (The Golden Age, 1930) illustrates the madness and self-destructive hypocrisy of bourgeois society.
  • Belle de Jour (Beauty of the day, 1967) tells the story of a bourgeois wife who is bored with her marriage and decides to prostitute herself.
  • Le charme discret de la bourgeoisie (The Discreet Charm of the Bourgeoisie, 1972) explores the timidity instilled by middle-class values.
  • Cet obscur objet du désir (That Obscure Object of Desire, 1977) illuminates the practical self-deceptions required for buying love as marriage.[42][43][page needed]

See also edit

References edit

  1. ^ "bourgeoisie Facts, information, pictures | Encyclopedia.com articles about bourgeoisie". encyclopedia.com. from the original on 2 October 2016. Retrieved 28 September 2016.
  2. ^ a b c d Siegrist 2001, p. 785.
  3. ^ Hoipkemier 2015, p. 651.
  4. ^ "Bourgeois Society". Marxists Internet Archive. from the original on 27 November 1999. Retrieved 15 November 2021.
  5. ^ Onions, C. T., ed. (1995). The Oxford Dictionary of English Etymology. p. 110.
  6. ^ Cook, Chris, ed. (1983). Dictionary of Historical Terms (3rd ed.). Palgrave Macmillan. p. 267. ISBN 978-0333673478.
  7. ^ Engels, Friedrich (1872). "How Proudhon Solves the Housing Question". The Housing Question – via Marxists Internet Archive.
  8. ^ Oxford English Reference Dictionary (Second ed.). 1996. p. 196.
  9. ^ a b "Bourgeoisie". The Columbia Encyclopedia (Fifth ed.). 1994. p. ?.
  10. ^ Benét 1987, p. 118, 759.
  11. ^ a b Molière 1899.
  12. ^ a b "What Does Boujee Mean And Who Said It First?". Dictionary.com. 11 April 2018. from the original on 22 February 2023. Retrieved 22 February 2023.
  13. ^ Tulp, Sophia. "What you're really saying when you call something 'bougie'". USA Today. from the original on 26 June 2021. Retrieved 26 June 2021.
  14. ^ Berend 2015, p. 94.
  15. ^ Marx, Karl (1850). . Archived from the original on 30 December 2007 – via Marxists Internet Archive.
  16. ^ Bottomore, T. B. A Dictionary of Marxist Thought. p. 272.
  17. ^ Le Wita, Béatrix; Underwood, J. A. (16 June 1994). French Bourgeois Culture. Cambridge University Press. ISBN 9780521466264. from the original on 27 April 2021. Retrieved 16 October 2020 – via Google Books.
  18. ^ "the petite bourgeoisie". Merriam-Webster. from the original on 27 January 2018. Retrieved 26 January 2018.
  19. ^ Nicholls & Nicholls 2000, p. 245.
  20. ^ a b Burleigh, Michael (2000). The Third Reich: A New History. New York, USA: Hill and Wang. p. 77.
  21. ^ Nicholls & Nicholls 2000, pp. 159–160.
  22. ^ Hitler, Adolf; Domarus, Max. The Essential Hitler: Speeches and Commentary. pp. 171, 172–173.
  23. ^ a b c Overy 2004, p. 399.
  24. ^ Overy 2004, p. 230.
  25. ^ Kritika: explorations in Russian and Eurasian history, Volume 7, Issue 4. Slavica Publishers, 2006. Pp. 922.
  26. ^ a b c Bellassai, Sandro (2005). "The Masculine Mystique: Anti-Modernism and Virility in Fascist Italy". Journal of Modern Italian Studies. 10 (3): 314–335. doi:10.1080/13545710500188338. S2CID 144797296.
  27. ^ Marino, Giuseppe Carlo (1983). L'autarchia della cultura. Intellettuali e fascismo negli anni trenta [The Autarchy of Culture: Intellectuals and Fascism in the 1930s] (in Italian). Rome: Editori Riuniti.
  28. ^ a b Paravese, Roberto (1939) "Bonifica antiborghese", in Edgardo Sulis (ed.), Processo alla borghesia, Roma: Edizioni Roma, pp. 51–70.
  29. ^ Émile Zola, Le Rougon-Macquart (1871–1893).
  30. ^ a b Walter Benjamin, The Halles Project.
  31. ^ Gilbert, Dennis (1998). The American Class Structure. New York: Wadsworth Publishing. 0-534-50520-1.
  32. ^ Williams, Brian; Sawyer, Stacey C.; Wahlstrom, Carl M. (2005). Marriages, Families & Intimate Relationships. Boston, MA: Pearson. 0-205-36674-0.
  33. ^ Weber, Max (1927). General economic history. UK: London: Allen & Unwin. 1306359007.
  34. ^ Zinn, Howard (1980). A People's History of the United States.
  35. ^ Sven Beckert "Propertied of Different Kind: Bourgeoisie and Lower Middle Class in the Nineteenth-Century United States" in The Middling Sorts: Explorations in the History of the American Middle Class (2001) Burton J. Bledstein and Robert D. Johnston, Eds. (2001)
  36. ^ McCloskey 2016, p. XVII.
  37. ^ Benét 1987, p. 118, 512.
  38. ^ Benét 1987, p. 118, 137.
  39. ^ Neider, Charles (1968). The Stature of Thomas Mann.
  40. ^ Beutin, Wolfgang (1993). A history of German Literature: From the Beginnings to the Present Day. Routledge. p. 433. ISBN 0-415-06034-6.
  41. ^ Benét 1987, p. 65.
  42. ^ Ebert, Roger (25 June 2000). "The Discreet Charm of the Bourgeoisie movie review (1972)". RogerEbert.com. from the original on 2 June 2013. Retrieved 27 April 2021.
  43. ^ Kinder & Andrew 1999.

Works cited edit

Further reading edit

External links edit

  • The Democratic State – A Critique of Bourgeois Sovereignty


bourgeoisie, bourgeois, redirects, here, other, uses, bourgeois, disambiguation, bourgeoisie, ʊər, ɑː, boor, zhwah, french, buʁʒwazi, class, business, owners, merchants, which, emerged, late, middle, ages, originally, middle, class, between, peasantry, aristoc. Bourgeois redirects here For other uses see Bourgeois disambiguation The bourgeoisie ˌ b ʊer ʒ w ɑː ˈ z iː BOOR zhwah ZEE French buʁʒwazi is a class of business owners and merchants which emerged in the Late Middle Ages originally as a middle class between peasantry and aristocracy They are traditionally contrasted with the proletariat by their wealth political power and education 1 2 as well as their access to and control of cultural social and financial capital The bourgeoisie in its original sense is intimately linked to the political ideology of liberalism and its existence within cities recognized as such by their urban charters e g municipal charters town privileges German town law so there was no bourgeoisie apart from the citizenry of the cities 3 Rural peasants came under a different legal system In Communist philosophy the bourgeoisie is the social class that came to own the means of production during modern industrialization and whose societal concerns are the value of private property and the preservation of capital to ensure the perpetuation of their economic dominance in society 4 Contents 1 Etymology 2 History 2 1 Origins and rise 2 2 From progress to reaction Marxist view 3 Denotations 3 1 Marxist theory 3 2 France and Francophone countries 3 2 1 Petite bourgeoisie 3 3 Nazism 3 4 Modern history in Italy 4 Bourgeois culture 4 1 Cultural hegemony 4 2 Conspicuous consumption 5 Satire and criticism in art 5 1 Theatre 5 2 Literature 5 3 Films 6 See also 7 References 7 1 Works cited 8 Further reading 9 External linksEtymology editThe Modern French word bourgeois ˈ b ʊer ʒ w ɑː BOORZH wah or b ʊer ˈ ʒ w ɑː boorzh WAH French buʁʒwa derived from the Old French borgeis or borjois town dweller which derived from bourg market town from the Old Frankish burg town in other European languages the etymologic derivations include the Middle English burgeis the Middle Dutch burgher the German Burger the Modern English burgess the Spanish burgues the Portuguese burgues and the Polish burzuazja which occasionally is synonymous with the intelligentsia 5 In the 18th century before the French Revolution 1789 1799 in the French Ancien Regime the masculine and feminine terms bourgeois and bourgeoise identified the relatively rich men and women who were members of the urban and rural Third Estate the common people of the French realm who violently deposed the absolute monarchy of the Bourbon King Louis XVI r 1774 1791 his clergy and his aristocrats in the French Revolution of 1789 1799 Hence since the 19th century the term bourgeoisie usually is politically and sociologically synonymous with the ruling upper class of a capitalist society 6 7 In English the word bourgeoisie as a term referring to French history refers to a social class oriented to economic materialism and hedonism and to upholding the political and economic interests of the capitalist ruling class 8 Historically the medieval French word bourgeois denoted the inhabitants of the bourgs walled market towns the craftsmen artisans merchants and others who constituted the bourgeoisie They were the socio economic class between the peasants and the landlords between the workers and the owners of the means of production As the economic managers of the raw materials the goods and the services and thus the capital money produced by the feudal economy the term bourgeoisie evolved to also denote the middle class the businessmen and businesswomen who accumulated administered and controlled the capital that made possible the development of the bourgs into cities 9 need quotation to verify Contemporarily the terms bourgeoisie and bourgeois noun identify the ruling class in capitalist societies as a social stratum while bourgeois adjective noun modifier describes the Weltanschauung worldview of men and women whose way of thinking is socially and culturally determined by their economic materialism and philistinism a social identity famously mocked in Moliere s comedy Le Bourgeois gentilhomme 1670 which satirizes buying the trappings of a noble birth identity as the means of climbing the social ladder 10 11 page needed The 18th century saw a partial rehabilitation of bourgeois values in genres such as the drame bourgeois bourgeois drama and bourgeois tragedy Emerging in the 1970s the shortened term bougie became slang referring to things or attitudes which are middle class pretentious and suburban 12 In 2016 a hip hop group Migos produced a song Bad and Boujee featuring an intentional misspelling of the word as boujee 12 a term which has particularly been used by African Americans in reference to African Americans The term refers to a person of lower or middle class doing pretentious activities or virtue signalling as an affectation of the upper class 13 History editOrigins and rise edit Further information History of capitalism Origins of capitalism and Trade History nbsp The 16th century German banker Jakob Fugger and his principal accountant M Schwarz registering an entry to a ledger The background shows a file cabinet indicating the European cities where the Fugger bank conducts business 1517 The bourgeoisie emerged as a historical and political phenomenon in the 11th century when the bourgs of Central and Western Europe developed into cities dedicated to commerce and crafts This urban expansion was possible thanks to economic concentration due to the appearance of protective self organisation into guilds Guilds arose when individual businessmen such as craftsmen artisans and merchants conflicted with their rent seeking feudal landlords who demanded greater rents than previously agreed In the event by the end of the Middle Ages c AD 1500 under regimes of the early national monarchies of Western Europe the bourgeoisie acted in self interest and politically supported the king or queen against legal and financial disorder caused by the greed of the feudal lords citation needed In the late 16th and early 17th centuries the bourgeoisies of England and the Netherlands had become the financial thus political forces that deposed the feudal order economic power had vanquished military power in the realm of politics 9 From progress to reaction Marxist view edit According to the Marxist view of history during the 17th and 18th centuries the bourgeoisie were the politically progressive social class who supported the principles of constitutional government and of natural right against the Law of Privilege and the claims of rule by divine right that the nobles and prelates had autonomously exercised during the feudal order The English Civil War 1642 1651 the American War of Independence 1775 1783 and French Revolution 1789 1799 were partly motivated by the desire of the bourgeoisie to rid themselves of the feudal and royal encroachments on their personal liberty commercial prospects and the ownership of property In the 19th century the bourgeoisie propounded liberalism and gained political rights religious rights and civil liberties for themselves and the lower social classes thus the bourgeoisie was a progressive philosophic and political force in Western societies After the Industrial Revolution 1750 1850 by the mid 19th century the great expansion of the bourgeoisie social class caused its stratification by business activity and by economic function into the haute bourgeoisie bankers and industrialists and the petite bourgeoisie tradesmen and white collar workers 2 Moreover by the end of the 19th century the capitalists the original bourgeoisie had ascended to the upper class while the developments of technology and technical occupations allowed the rise of working class men and women to the lower strata of the bourgeoisie yet the social progress was incidental Denotations editMarxist theory edit nbsp Karl MarxAccording to Karl Marx the bourgeois during the Middle Ages usually was a self employed businessman such as a merchant banker or entrepreneur 2 whose economic role in society was being the financial intermediary to the feudal landlord and the peasant who worked the fief the land of the lord Yet by the 18th century the time of the Industrial Revolution 1750 1850 and of industrial capitalism the bourgeoisie had become the economic ruling class who owned the means of production capital and land and who controlled the means of coercion armed forces and legal system police forces and prison system 2 14 In such a society the bourgeoisie s ownership of the means of production allowed them to employ and exploit the wage earning working class urban and rural people whose only economic means is labour and the bourgeois control of the means of coercion suppressed the sociopolitical challenges by the lower classes and so preserved the economic status quo workers remained workers and employers remained employers 15 In the 19th century Marx distinguished two types of bourgeois capitalist the functional capitalists who are business administrators of the means of production rentier capitalists whose livelihoods derive either from the rent of property or from the interest income produced by finance capital or both 16 In the course of economic relations the working class and the bourgeoisie continually engage in class struggle where the capitalists exploit the workers while the workers resist their economic exploitation which occurs because the worker owns no means of production and to earn a living seeks employment from the bourgeois capitalist the worker produces goods and services that are property of the employer who sells them for a price Besides describing the social class who owns the means of production the Marxist use of the term bourgeois also describes the consumerist style of life derived from the ownership of capital and real property Marx acknowledged the bourgeois industriousness that created wealth but criticised the moral hypocrisy of the bourgeoisie when they ignored the alleged origins of their wealth the exploitation of the proletariat the urban and rural workers Further sense denotations of bourgeois describe ideological concepts such as bourgeois freedom which is thought to be opposed to substantive forms of freedom bourgeois independence bourgeois personal individuality the bourgeois family et cetera all derived from owning capital and property see The Communist Manifesto 1848 France and Francophone countries edit In English the term bourgeoisie is often used to denote the middle classes In fact the French term encompasses both the upper and middle economic classes 17 a misunderstanding which has occurred in other languages as well The bourgeoisie in France and many French speaking countries consists of five evolving social layers petite bourgeoisie moyenne bourgeoisie grande bourgeoisie haute bourgeoisie and ancienne bourgeoisie Petite bourgeoisie edit Main article Petite bourgeoisie The petite bourgeoisie is the equivalent of the modern day middle class or refers to a social class between the middle class and the lower class the lower middle class 18 Nazism edit Nazism rejected the Marxist concept of proletarian internationalism and class struggle and supported the class struggle between nations and sought to resolve internal class struggle in the nation while it identified Germany as a proletariat nation fighting against plutocratic nations 19 The Nazi Party had many working class supporters and members and a strong appeal to the middle class The financial collapse of the white collar middle class of the 1920s figures much in their strong support of Nazism 20 In the poor country that was the Weimar Republic of the early 1930s the Nazi Party realised their social policies with food and shelter for the unemployed and the homeless who were later recruited into the Brownshirt Sturmabteilung SA Storm Detachments 20 Adolf Hitler was impressed by the populist antisemitism and the anti liberal bourgeois agitation of Karl Lueger who as the mayor of Vienna during Hitler s time in the city used a rabble rousing style of oratory that appealed to the wider masses 21 When asked whether he supported the bourgeois right wing Hitler claimed that Nazism was not exclusively for any class and he also indicated that it favoured neither the left nor the right but preserved pure elements from both camps stating From the camp of bourgeois tradition it takes national resolve and from the materialism of the Marxist dogma living creative Socialism 22 Hitler distrusted capitalism for being unreliable due to its egotism and he preferred a state directed economy that is subordinated to the interests of the Volk 23 Hitler told a party leader in 1934 The economic system of our day is the creation of the Jews 23 Hitler said to Benito Mussolini that capitalism had run its course 23 Hitler also said that the business bourgeoisie know nothing except their profit Fatherland is only a word for them 24 Hitler was personally disgusted with the ruling bourgeois elites of Germany during the period of the Weimar Republic whom he referred to as cowardly shits 25 Modern history in Italy edit Because of their ascribed cultural excellence as a social class the Italian fascist regime 1922 45 of Prime Minister Benito Mussolini regarded the bourgeoisie as an obstacle to Modernism 26 Nonetheless the Fascist State ideologically exploited the Italian bourgeoisie and their materialistic middle class spirit for the more efficient cultural manipulation of the upper aristocratic and the lower working classes of Italy In 1938 Prime Minister Mussolini gave a speech wherein he established a clear ideological distinction between capitalism the social function of the bourgeoisie and the bourgeoisie as a social class whom he dehumanised by reducing them into high level abstractions a moral category and a state of mind 26 Culturally and philosophically Mussolini isolated the bourgeoisie from Italian society by portraying them as social parasites upon the fascist Italian state and The People as a social class who drained the human potential of Italian society in general and of the working class in particular as exploiters who victimised the Italian nation with an approach to life characterised by hedonism and materialism 26 Nevertheless despite the slogan The Fascist Man Disdains the Comfortable Life which epitomised the anti bourgeois principle in its final years of power for mutual benefit and profit the Mussolini fascist regime transcended ideology to merge the political and financial interests of Prime Minister Benito Mussolini with the political and financial interests of the bourgeoisie the Catholic social circles who constituted the ruling class of Italy Philosophically as a materialist creature the bourgeois man was stereotyped as irreligious thus to establish an existential distinction between the supernatural faith of the Roman Catholic Church and the materialist faith of temporal religion in The Autarchy of Culture Intellectuals and Fascism in the 1930s the priest Giuseppe Marino said that Christianity is essentially anti bourgeois A Christian a true Christian and thus a Catholic is the opposite of a bourgeois 27 Culturally the bourgeois man may be considered effeminate infantile or acting in a pretentious manner describing his philistinism in Bonifica antiborghese 1939 Roberto Paravese comments on the Middle class middle man incapable of great virtue or great vice and there would be nothing wrong with that if only he would be willing to remain as such but when his child like or feminine tendency to camouflage pushes him to dream of grandeur honours and thus riches which he cannot achieve honestly with his own second rate powers then the average man compensates with cunning schemes and mischief he kicks out ethics and becomes a bourgeois The bourgeois is the average man who does not accept to remain such and who lacking the strength sufficient for the conquest of essential values those of the spirit opts for material ones for appearances 28 The economic security financial freedom and social mobility of the bourgeoisie threatened the philosophic integrity of Italian Fascism the ideological monolith that was the regime of Prime Minister Benito Mussolini Any assumption of legitimate political power government and rule by the bourgeoisie represented a fascist loss of totalitarian state power for social control through political unity one people one nation and one leader Sociologically to the fascist man to become a bourgeois was a character flaw inherent to the masculine mystique therefore the ideology of Italian fascism scornfully defined the bourgeois man as spiritually castrated 28 Bourgeois culture editCultural hegemony edit Karl Marx said that the culture of a society is dominated by the mores of the ruling class wherein their superimposed value system is abided by each social class the upper the middle the lower regardless of the socio economic results it yields to them In that sense contemporary societies are bourgeois to the degree that they practice the mores of the small business shop culture of early modern France which the writer Emile Zola 1840 1902 naturalistically presented analysed and ridiculed in the twenty two novel series 1871 1893 about Les Rougon Macquart family the thematic thrust is the necessity for social progress by subordinating the economic sphere to the social sphere of life 29 Conspicuous consumption edit nbsp Clothing worn by ladies belonging to the bourgeoisie of Zywiec Poland 19th century collection of the Zywiec City Museum The critical analyses of the bourgeois mentality by the German intellectual Walter Benjamin 1892 1940 indicated that the shop culture of the petite bourgeoisie established the sitting room as the centre of personal and family life as such the English bourgeois culture is he alleges a sitting room culture of prestige through conspicuous consumption The material culture of the bourgeoisie concentrated on mass produced luxury goods of high quality between generations the only variance was the materials with which the goods were manufactured In the early part of the 19th century the bourgeois house contained a home that first was stocked and decorated with hand painted porcelain machine printed cotton fabrics machine printed wallpaper and Sheffield steel crucible and stainless The utility of these things was inherent in their practical functions By the latter part of the 19th century the bourgeois house contained a home that had been remodelled by conspicuous consumption Here Benjamin argues the goods were bought to display wealth discretionary income rather than for their practical utility The bourgeoisie had transposed the wares of the shop window to the sitting room where the clutter of display signalled bourgeois success 30 see Culture and Anarchy 1869 Two spatial constructs manifest the bourgeois mentality i the shop window display and ii the sitting room In English the term sitting room culture is synonymous for bourgeois mentality a philistine cultural perspective from the Victorian Era 1837 1901 especially characterised by the repression of emotion and of sexual desire and by the construction of a regulated social space where propriety is the key personality trait desired in men and women 30 Nonetheless from such a psychologically constricted worldview regarding the rearing of children contemporary sociologists claim to have identified progressive middle class values such as respect for non conformity self direction autonomy gender equality and the encouragement of innovation as in the Victorian Era the transposition to the US of the bourgeois system of social values has been identified as a requisite for employment success in the professions 31 32 nbsp The prototypical bourgeois Monsieur Jourdain the protagonist in Moliere s play Le Bourgeois gentilhomme 1670 Bourgeois values are dependent on rationalism which began with the economic sphere and moves into every sphere of life which is formulated by Max Weber 33 The beginning of rationalism is commonly called the Age of Reason Much like the Marxist critics of that period Weber was concerned with the growing ability of large corporations and nations to increase their power and reach throughout the world Satire and criticism in art editBeyond the intellectual realms of political economy history and political science that discuss describe and analyse the bourgeoisie as a social class the colloquial usage of the sociological terms bourgeois and bourgeoise describe the social stereotypes of the old money and of the nouveau riche who is a politically timid conformist satisfied with a wealthy consumerist style of life characterised by conspicuous consumption and the continual striving for prestige 34 35 This being the case the cultures of the world describe the philistinism of the middle class personality produced by the excessively rich life of the bourgeoisie is examined and analysed in comedic and dramatic plays novels and films see Authenticity nbsp The 17th century French playwright Moliere 1622 73 catalogued the social climbing essence of the bourgeoisie in Le Bourgeois gentilhomme 1670 The term bourgeoisie has been used as a pejorative and a term of abuse since the 19th century particularly by intellectuals and artists 36 Theatre edit Le Bourgeois gentilhomme The Would be Gentleman 1670 by Moliere Jean Baptiste Poquelin is a comedy ballet that satirises Monsieur Jourdain the prototypical nouveau riche man who buys his way up the social class scale to realise his aspirations of becoming a gentleman to which end he studies dancing fencing and philosophy the trappings and accomplishments of a gentleman to be able to pose as a man of noble birth someone who in 17th century France was a man to the manor born Jourdain s self transformation also requires managing the private life of his daughter so that her marriage can also assist his social ascent 11 page needed 37 Literature edit nbsp Thomas Mann 1875 1955 portrayed the moral intellectual and physical decadence of the German upper bourgeoisie in the novel Buddenbrooks 1926 Buddenbrooks 1901 by Thomas Mann 1875 1955 chronicles the moral intellectual and physical decay of a rich family through its declines material and spiritual in the course of four generations beginning with the patriarch Johann Buddenbrook Sr and his son Johann Buddenbrook Jr who are typically successful German businessmen each is a reasonable man of solid character Yet in the children of Buddenbrook Jr the materially comfortable style of life provided by the dedication to solid middle class values elicits decadence The fickle daughter Toni lacks and does not seek a purpose in life son Christian is honestly decadent and lives the life of a ne er do well and the businessman son Thomas who assumes command of the Buddenbrook family fortune occasionally falters from middle class solidity by being interested in art and philosophy the impractical life of the mind which to the bourgeoisie is the epitome of social moral and material decadence 38 39 40 Babbitt 1922 by Sinclair Lewis 1885 1951 satirizes the American bourgeois George Follansbee Babbitt a middle aged realtor booster and joiner in the Midwestern city of Zenith who despite being unimaginative self important and hopelessly conformist and middle class is aware that there must be more to life than money and the consumption of the best things that money can buy Nevertheless he fears being excluded from the mainstream of society more than he does living for himself by being true to himself his heart felt flirtations with independence dabbling in liberal politics and a love affair with a pretty widow come to naught because he is existentially afraid nbsp The Spanish cineast Luis Bunuel 1900 83 depicted the tortuous mentality and self destructive hypocrisy of the bourgeoisieYet George F Babbitt sublimates his desire for self respect and encourages his son to rebel against the conformity that results from bourgeois prosperity by recommending that he be true to himself Don t be scared of the family No nor all of zenith Nor of yourself the way I ve been 41 Films edit Many of the satirical films by the Spanish film director Luis Bunuel 1900 1983 examine the mental and moral effects of the bourgeois mentality its culture and the stylish way of life it provides for its practitioners L Age d or The Golden Age 1930 illustrates the madness and self destructive hypocrisy of bourgeois society Belle de Jour Beauty of the day 1967 tells the story of a bourgeois wife who is bored with her marriage and decides to prostitute herself Le charme discret de la bourgeoisie The Discreet Charm of the Bourgeoisie 1972 explores the timidity instilled by middle class values Cet obscur objet du desir That Obscure Object of Desire 1977 illuminates the practical self deceptions required for buying love as marriage 42 43 page needed See also edit nbsp Society portalAristocracy class Bourgeois of Brussels Bourgeois of Paris Bourgeoisie of Geneva Bourgeoisie of Nigeria Poorter in the Netherlands Beurgeois affluent French Muslims of North African descent Bildungsburgertum Boliburguesia Burgher Burgess Citizenship Conspicuous consumption Conspicuous leisure Cultural hegemony Economic stratification Gemutlichkeit Gentrification Grand Burgher German Grossburger Medieval commune Habitus sociology Hipster contemporary subculture Homo economicus Ilustrado Occupational prestige Oligarchy Petite bourgeoisie Political class Proletariat the opposite of the Bourgeoisie Rational legal authority Russian oligarch Social environment Social class in the United Kingdom Ukrainian oligarchs Upper middle class The Theory of the Leisure Class Vecino Yuppie Le Bourgeois gentilhomme play References edit bourgeoisie Facts information pictures Encyclopedia com articles about bourgeoisie encyclopedia com Archived from the original on 2 October 2016 Retrieved 28 September 2016 a b c d Siegrist 2001 p 785 Hoipkemier 2015 p 651 Bourgeois Society Marxists Internet Archive Archived from the original on 27 November 1999 Retrieved 15 November 2021 Onions C T ed 1995 The Oxford Dictionary of English Etymology p 110 Cook Chris ed 1983 Dictionary of Historical Terms 3rd ed Palgrave Macmillan p 267 ISBN 978 0333673478 Engels Friedrich 1872 How Proudhon Solves the Housing Question The Housing Question via Marxists Internet Archive Oxford English Reference Dictionary Second ed 1996 p 196 a b Bourgeoisie The Columbia Encyclopedia Fifth ed 1994 p Benet 1987 p 118 759 a b Moliere 1899 a b What Does Boujee Mean And Who Said It First Dictionary com 11 April 2018 Archived from the original on 22 February 2023 Retrieved 22 February 2023 Tulp Sophia What you re really saying when you call something bougie USA Today Archived from the original on 26 June 2021 Retrieved 26 June 2021 Berend 2015 p 94 Marx Karl 1850 The Class Struggles in France 1848 to 1850 Archived from the original on 30 December 2007 via Marxists Internet Archive Bottomore T B A Dictionary of Marxist Thought p 272 Le Wita Beatrix Underwood J A 16 June 1994 French Bourgeois Culture Cambridge University Press ISBN 9780521466264 Archived from the original on 27 April 2021 Retrieved 16 October 2020 via Google Books the petite bourgeoisie Merriam Webster Archived from the original on 27 January 2018 Retrieved 26 January 2018 Nicholls amp Nicholls 2000 p 245 a b Burleigh Michael 2000 The Third Reich A New History New York USA Hill and Wang p 77 Nicholls amp Nicholls 2000 pp 159 160 Hitler Adolf Domarus Max The Essential Hitler Speeches and Commentary pp 171 172 173 a b c Overy 2004 p 399 Overy 2004 p 230 Kritika explorations in Russian and Eurasian history Volume 7 Issue 4 Slavica Publishers 2006 Pp 922 a b c Bellassai Sandro 2005 The Masculine Mystique Anti Modernism and Virility in Fascist Italy Journal of Modern Italian Studies 10 3 314 335 doi 10 1080 13545710500188338 S2CID 144797296 Marino Giuseppe Carlo 1983 L autarchia della cultura Intellettuali e fascismo negli anni trenta The Autarchy of Culture Intellectuals and Fascism in the 1930s in Italian Rome Editori Riuniti a b Paravese Roberto 1939 Bonifica antiborghese in Edgardo Sulis ed Processo alla borghesia Roma Edizioni Roma pp 51 70 Emile Zola Le Rougon Macquart 1871 1893 a b Walter Benjamin The Halles Project Gilbert Dennis 1998 The American Class Structure New York Wadsworth Publishing 0 534 50520 1 Williams Brian Sawyer Stacey C Wahlstrom Carl M 2005 Marriages Families amp Intimate Relationships Boston MA Pearson 0 205 36674 0 Weber Max 1927 General economic history UK London Allen amp Unwin 1306359007 Zinn Howard 1980 A People s History of the United States Sven Beckert Propertied of Different Kind Bourgeoisie and Lower Middle Class in the Nineteenth Century United States in The Middling Sorts Explorations in the History of the American Middle Class 2001 Burton J Bledstein and Robert D Johnston Eds 2001 McCloskey 2016 p XVII Benet 1987 p 118 512 Benet 1987 p 118 137 Neider Charles 1968 The Stature of Thomas Mann Beutin Wolfgang 1993 A history of German Literature From the Beginnings to the Present Day Routledge p 433 ISBN 0 415 06034 6 Benet 1987 p 65 Ebert Roger 25 June 2000 The Discreet Charm of the Bourgeoisie movie review 1972 RogerEbert com Archived from the original on 2 June 2013 Retrieved 27 April 2021 Kinder amp Andrew 1999 Works cited edit Benet William Rose 1987 Benet s Reader s Encyclopedia Harper amp Row ISBN 978 0 06 181088 6 Retrieved 7 October 2020 via Google Books Berend Ivan T 2015 Capitalism In Wright James D ed International Encyclopedia of the Social amp Behavioral Sciences Vol 3 2nd ed Oxford Elsevier pp 94 98 doi 10 1016 B978 0 08 097086 8 62003 2 ISBN 9780080430768 Hoipkemier Mark 2015 Citizenship Political In Wright James D ed International Encyclopedia of the Social amp Behavioral Sciences Vol 3 2nd ed Oxford Elsevier pp 650 654 doi 10 1016 B978 0 08 097086 8 93016 2 ISBN 9780080430768 Kinder Marsha Andrew Horton 1999 Bunuel s The Discreet Charm of the Bourgeoisie Cambridge University Press ISBN 978 0 521 56831 9 Retrieved 7 October 2020 via Google Books McCloskey Deirdre Nansen 2016 Bourgeois Equality How Ideas Not Capital or Institutions Enriched the World University of Chicago Press ISBN 978 0 226 33404 2 Retrieved 7 October 2020 via Google Books Moliere 1899 Moliere s Le bourgeois gentilhomme Moliere s The bourgeois gentleman in French D C Heath amp Company ISBN 9781976406379 Retrieved 7 October 2020 via Google Books Nicholls David Nicholls Gill 2000 Adolf Hitler A Biographical Companion ABC CLIO ISBN 978 0 87436 965 6 Retrieved 7 October 2020 via Google Books Overy R J 2004 The Dictators Hitler s Germany and Stalin s Russia W W Norton amp Company ISBN 978 0 393 02030 4 Retrieved 7 October 2020 via Google Books Siegrist Hannes 2001 Bourgeoisie and Middle Classes History of In Wright James D ed International Encyclopedia of the Social amp Behavioral Sciences Vol 2 2nd ed Oxford Elsevier pp 784 789 doi 10 1016 B978 0 08 097086 8 62013 5 ISBN 9780080430768 Further reading editBledstein Burton J Johnston Robert D eds 19 July 2001 The Middling Sorts Explorations in the History of the American Middle Class Routledge ISBN 9780415926423 Brooks David 6 March 2001 Bobos In Paradise The New Upper Class and How They Got There Simon amp Schuster ISBN 978 0684853789 Byrne Frank J 20 October 2006 Becoming Bourgeois Merchant Culture in the South 1820 1865 University Press of Kentucky ISBN 978 0813124049 Cousin Bruno Chauvin Sebastien 2021 Is there a global super bourgeoisie Sociology Compass 15 6 1 15 doi 10 1111 soc4 12883 S2CID 234861167 Dejung Christof Motadel David Osterhammel Jurgen 2019 The Global Bourgeoisie The Rise of the Middle Classes in the Age of Empire Princeton University Press ISBN 9780691177342 Hunt Margaret R 10 December 1996 The Middling Sort Commerce Gender and the Family in England 1680 1780 University of California Press ISBN 978 0520202603 Lockwood David 23 April 2009 Cronies or Capitalists The Russian Bourgeoisie and the Bourgeois Revolution from 1850 to 1917 Cambridge Scholars Publishing ISBN 978 1 4438 0562 9 McCloskey Deirdre N 2006 The Bourgeois Virtues Ethics for an Age of Commerce University of Chicago Press ISBN 978 0 226 55663 5 McCloskey Deirdre N 2010 Bourgeois Dignity Why Economics Can t Explain the Modern World University of Chicago Press ISBN 978 0 2265 5665 9 Siegel Jerrold 1999 Bohemian Paris Culture Politics and the Boundaries of Bourgeois Life 1830 1930 Johns Hopkins University Press ISBN 9780801860638 Stern Robert W 2003 Changing India Bourgeois Revolution on the Subcontinent 2nd ed Cambridge University Press ISBN 9780521009126 Trigilia Carlo 2011 Class Social In Badie Bertrand Berg Schlosser Dirk Morlino Leonardo eds International Encyclopedia of Political Science Vol 1 SAGE Publications pp 270 275 ISBN 9781412959636 External links edit nbsp Look up bourgeoisie in Wiktionary the free dictionary nbsp Wikiquote has quotations related to Bourgeoisie nbsp Wikimedia Commons has media related to Bourgeoisie The Democratic State A Critique of Bourgeois Sovereignty Retrieved from https en wikipedia org w index php title Bourgeoisie amp oldid 1190617233, wikipedia, wiki, book, books, library,

article

, read, download, free, free download, mp3, video, mp4, 3gp, jpg, jpeg, gif, png, picture, music, song, movie, book, game, games.