Moscow–Washington hotline

The Moscow–Washington hotline (formally known in the United States as the Washington–Moscow Direct Communications Link;^[1] Russian: Горячая линия Вашингтон – Москва, tr. Goryachaya liniya Vashington–Moskva) is a system that allows direct communication between the leaders of the United States and the Russian Federation (formerly the Soviet Union). This hotline was established in 1963 and links the Pentagon with the Kremlin (historically, with Soviet Communist Party leadership across the square from the Kremlin itself).^[1][2] Although in popular culture it is known as the "red telephone", the hotline was never a telephone line, and no red phones were used. The first implementation used Teletype equipment, and shifted to fax machines in 1986.^[3] Since 2008, the Moscow–Washington hotline has been a secure computer link over which messages are exchanged by a secure form of email.^[4]

The Pentagon in Arlington County, Virginia, U.S. (left) and the Kremlin in Moscow, Russia (right), the two facilities linked by the hotline.

Origins

Background

Several people came up with the idea for a hotline, including Harvard professor Thomas Schelling, who had worked on nuclear war policy for the Defense Department previously. Schelling credited the pop fiction novel Red Alert (the basis of the film Dr. Strangelove) with making governments more aware of the benefit of direct communication between the superpowers. In addition, Parade editor Jess Gorkin personally badgered 1960 presidential candidates John F. Kennedy and Richard Nixon, and buttonholed the Soviet premier Nikita Khrushchev during a U.S. visit to adopt the idea.^[1] During this period Gerard C. Smith, as head of the State Department Policy Planning Staff, proposed direct communication links between Moscow and Washington. Objections from others in the State Department, the U.S. military, and the Kremlin delayed introduction.^[1]

The 1962 Cuban Missile Crisis made the hotline a priority. During the standoff, official diplomatic messages typically took six hours to deliver; unofficial channels, such as via television network correspondents, had to be used too as they were quicker.^[1] The experience of the crisis convinced both sides of the need for better communications.^[5]

During the crisis, the United States took nearly twelve hours to receive and decode Nikita Khrushchev's 3,000-word-initial settlement message – a dangerously long time. By the time Washington had drafted a reply, a tougher message from Moscow had been received, demanding that U.S. missiles be removed from Turkey.^{[citation needed]} White House advisers thought faster communications could have averted the crisis, and resolved it quickly. The two countries signed the Hot Line Agreement on June 20, 1963^[6] – the first time they formally took action to cut the risk of starting a nuclear war unintentionally.^[7] It was used for the first time by U.S. President John F. Kennedy on August 30, 1963.^[8]

Agreement

The "hotline", as it would come to be known, was established after the signing of a "Memorandum of Understanding Regarding the Establishment of a Direct Communications Line" on June 20, 1963, in Geneva, Switzerland, by representatives of the Soviet Union and the United States.^[3]

Political criticism

The Republican Party criticized the hotline in its 1964 national platform; it said the Kennedy administration had "sought accommodations with Communism without adequate safeguards and compensating gains for freedom. It has alienated proven allies by opening a 'hot line' first with a sworn enemy rather than with a proven friend, and in general pursued a risky path such as began at Munich a quarter century ago."^[9]

Technology and procedure

 

ITT Intelex Teletype L015, as displayed in the Lyndon Baines Johnson Library and Museum.

 

An East German Siemens T63-SU12 teleprinter from the hotline, as displayed in the National Cryptologic Museum of the NSA. The black box behind the teleprinter is an ETCRRM II encryption machine.

 

In Finland there are still several signs marking the cable's location. This one is in Forssa. The text reads "Post and telegraph department". The cable was also used for the ordinary national telephone service.

The Moscow–Washington hotline was intended for text only; speech might be misinterpreted. Leaders wrote in their native language and messages were translated at the receiving end.^[10]

Teletype

The first generation of the hotline used two full-time duplex telegraph circuits. The primary circuit was routed from Washington, D.C. via London, Copenhagen, Stockholm and Helsinki to Moscow. TAT-1, the first submarine transatlantic telephone cable carried messages from Washington to London. A secondary radio line for back-up and service messages linked Washington and Moscow via Tangier. This network was originally built by Harris Corporation.^[11]

In July 1963 the United States sent four sets of teleprinters with the Latin alphabet to Moscow for the terminal there. A month later the Soviet equipment, four sets of East German teleprinters with the Cyrillic alphabet made by Siemens, arrived in Washington. The hotline started operations on August 30, 1963.^[12]

Encryption

A Japanese-built device called Electronic Teleprinter Cryptographic Regenerative Repeater Mixer II (ETCRRM II) encrypted the teletype messages using a shared one-time pad.^[13] Each country delivered keying tapes used to encode its messages via its embassy abroad. An advantage of the one-time pad was that neither country had to reveal more sensitive encryption methods to the other.^[14][15]

Satellite

In September 1971, Moscow and Washington decided to upgrade the system. The countries also agreed for the first time when the line should be used. Specifically, they agreed to notify each other immediately in the event of an accidental, unauthorized or unexplained incident involving a nuclear weapon that could increase the risk of nuclear war.^[16][17][18] Two new satellite communication lines supplemented the terrestrial circuits using two U.S. Intelsat satellites, and two Soviet Molniya II satellites. This arrangement lasted from 1971 to 1978; it made the radio link via Tangier redundant.^{[citation needed]}

Facsimile

In May 1983, President Ronald Reagan proposed to upgrade the hotline by the addition of high-speed facsimile capability. The Soviet Union and the United States agreed formally to do this on July 17, 1984.

According to the agreement, upgrades were to take place through use of Intelsat satellites and modems, facsimile machines, and computers.^[19] The facsimile terminals were operational by 1986.^[3] The teletype circuits were cut in 1988 after several years of testing and use proved the fax links to be reliable. The Soviets transferred the hotline link to the newer, geostationary Gorizont-class satellites of the Stationar system.^[20]

In 1988, the US side of the hotline system was located at the National Military Command Center in the Pentagon. Each MOLINK (Moscow Link) team worked an eight-hour shift: a non-commissioned officer looked after the equipment, and a commissioned officer who was fluent in Russian and well-briefed on world affairs was translator.^[1] The hotline was tested hourly. U.S. test messages included excerpts of William Shakespeare, Mark Twain, encyclopedias, and a first-aid manual; Soviet tests included passages from the works of Anton Chekhov. MOLINK staffers took special care not to include innuendo or literary imagery that could be misinterpreted, such as passages from Winnie the Pooh, given that a bear is considered the national symbol of Russia. The Soviets also asked, during the Carter administration, that Washington not send routine communications through the hotline.^[1]

Upon receipt of the message at the NMCC, the message was translated into English, and both the original Russian and the translated English texts are transmitted to the White House Situation Room. However, if the message were to indicate "an imminent disaster, such as an accidental nuclear strike", the MOLINK team would telephone the gist of the message to the Situation Room duty officer who would brief the president before a formal translation was complete.^[1]

Email

In 2007, the Moscow–Washington hotline was upgraded; a dedicated computer network links Moscow and Washington. The new system started operations on January 1, 2008.^[4] It continues to use the two satellite links but a fiber optic cable replaced the old back-up cable. Commercial software is used for both chat and email: chat to coordinate operations, and email for actual messages. Transmission is nearly instantaneous.

Usage

The first message transmitted over the hotline was on August 30, 1963. Washington sent Moscow the text: "THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG'S BACK 1234567890". The message was sent in all capital letters, since the equipment did not support lowercase.^[21]

The primary link was accidentally cut several times, for example near Copenhagen by a Danish bulldozer operator, and by a Finnish farmer who ploughed it up once. Regular testing of both the primary and backup links took place daily.^[22] During the even hours, the US sent test messages to the Soviet Union. In the odd hours, the Soviet Union sent test messages to the US.^{[citation needed]}

The line was used during:^[21]

• 1963: Assassination of President Kennedy
• 1967: Six Day War
• 1971: War between India and Pakistan
• 1973: Yom Kippur War
• 1974: Turkish Invasion of Cyprus
• 1979: Soviet–Afghan War
• 1981: Threat of Soviet Invasion of Poland
• 1982: Israeli Invasion of Lebanon
• 1991: Gulf War
• 2003: Aftermath of Iraq War

On October 31, 2016, the Moscow–Washington hotline was used to reinforce Barack Obama's September warning that the U.S. would consider any interference on Election Day a grave matter.^[23]

Other hotlines with Moscow

Another hotline for record communications between Washington and Moscow is part of the American Nuclear Risk Reduction Center and the Russian National Nuclear Risk Reduction Center, which was initiated by Ronald Reagan in 1988.^[24] This was done in the aftermath of the Chernobyl Disaster.

In 2012, it was announced that a proposal was being negotiated with Moscow to add cyber warfare to the topics to be discussed on the hotline.^[24]

Since 2007 there has been a hotline between Beijing and Washington and also Beijing and Moscow.^[25]

At the beginning of the Russian invasion of Ukraine, the United States and Russia created a deconfliction line to prevent miscalculations or escalation.^[26] In November 2022, an anonymous U.S. official told Reuters that the line had only been used once in the war. The official said that the line was used to communicate concerns about Russian military operations near Ukrainian infrastructure, but did not elaborate. The official said it was not used when a missile hit Poland.^[27]

In popular culture

 

A non-dial "Red Phone" which is on display in the Jimmy Carter Library and Museum. This telephone is actually a prop, erroneously representing the hotline between Washington and Moscow.^[28]

In numerous books, movies, video games, etc., the hotline between Washington and Moscow is represented by a red phone, although the real hotline has never been a telephone line.

A hotline telephone was depicted in the film Fail-Safe as the "Red 1 / Ultimate 1 Touch phone", and also in Stanley Kubrick's film Dr. Strangelove, both from 1964 and both loosely based on Peter George's Cold War thriller novel Red Alert from 1958.

A more realistic depiction of the Hotline was Tom Clancy's novel The Sum of All Fears from 1991 and its 2002 film adaptation, in which a text-based computer communications system was depicted, resembling the actual Hotline equipment from the 1980s and 1990s.

 

This "Red Phone" was installed in the CINCSAC underground command post at Offutt AFB. Although connected to a hotline for nuclear warfare command communications, it was a component of the SAC Primary Alert System. It did not connect to foreign officials.

In the 1990 HBO film By Dawn's Early Light, the White House Situation Room equipment that receives the (translated) hotline message, apparently relayed by the Pentagon-NMCC MOLINK team, is depicted as a teleprinter^[29] (and not as a fax machine, the technology already in use at the NMCC itself by that year^[3]).

A telephone is used in the intro cinematic of the video game Command & Conquer: Red Alert 2. The call is placed by the US president to the Kremlin in the wake of a global Soviet invasion.^[30]

In "World War Three", a 2005 episode of the British sci-fi television series Doctor Who, the Slitheen await a phone call to plunge the planet into a nuclear holocaust on an actual red telephone, directly pastiching the cold war fears related to the hotline. ^[31]

Political advertising

The "red phone" was the centerpiece of television commercials used in the 1984 Democratic primary and 1984 presidential election and the 2008 Democratic primary elections. In 1984, an advertisement made by Bob Beckel and Roy Spence on behalf of candidate Walter Mondale suggested that "The most awesome, powerful responsibility in the world lies in the hand that picks up this phone." The advertisement was intended to raise questions about candidate Gary Hart's readiness for the presidency.^[32][33]

The red phone was also featured prominently in an advertisement from that year targeting President Ronald Reagan's Strategic Defense Initiative. In the second ad, the ringing phone goes unanswered while the narrator says, "there will be no time to wake a president – computers will take control."^[34][35][36] Roy Spence revived the "red phone" idea in 2008 in an advertisement for candidate Hillary Clinton.^[37][38]

See also

• Islamabad–New Delhi hotline
• Seoul–Pyongyang hotline
• Beijing–Washington hotline

Notes and references

1. Stone, Webster (September 18, 1988). "Moscow's Still Holding". New York Times. from the original on June 30, 2015. Retrieved October 28, 2014.
2. Clavin, Tom (19 Jun 2013). "There Never Was Such a Thing as a Red Phone in the White House". Smithsonian Magazine. Retrieved 2013-07-01.
3. Graham, Thomas; La Vera, Damien (2002). "The 'Hot Line' Agreements". Cornerstones of Security: Arms Control Treaties in the Nuclear Era. University of Washington Press. pp. 20–28. ISBN 978-0295801414.
4. Craig, Bell; Richardson, Paul E. (September–October 2009). . Russian Life. Vol. 52, no. 5. Archived from the original on 2015-06-30.^{[dead link]}
5. U.S. State Department. . Atomic Archive. Archived from the original on August 30, 2022. Retrieved August 30, 2022.
6. Kavass, Igor I.; Hein, W. S. (1991). United States Treaty Index: 1776–1990, Consolidation (Volume 6 ed.). W.S. Hein. p. 718. ISBN 978-0899417707. Retrieved 30 August 2022. TIAS 5362
7. Encyclopedia of Russian History^{[ISBN missing][page needed]}
8. . History.com. Archived from the original on May 20, 2023. Retrieved 2023-05-06.
9. Republican Party Platform, Section Two, "Weakness Before Communism" (adopted July 13, 1964). See http://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/ws/index.php?pid=25840
10. Kennedy, Bruce (1998). . Archived from the original on 23 September 2008. Retrieved 18 March 2011.
11. Council on Foreign Relations (1990). International Affairs Fellowship program 1967–1990 directory. Council on Foreign Relations Press. Retrieved 28 June 2013.
12. David K. Barnhart; Allan A. Metcalf (1999). America in So Many Words: Words That Have Shaped America. Houghton Mifflin Harcourt. pp. 252–. ISBN 978-0618002702. Retrieved 28 June 2013.
13. Graff, Garrett M. (2017). Raven Rock: The Story of the U.S. Government's Secret Plan to Save Itself – While the Rest of Us Die. Simon & Schuster.^{[ISBN missing][page needed]}
14. David Kahn, The Codebreakers, pp. 715–716^{[ISBN missing]}
15. . www.dn.no. Archived from the original on 2017-12-08.
16. Jozef Goldblat (International Peace Research Institute) (2002). Arms control. Sage. pp. 301–302. ISBN 0761940162.
17. Coit D. Blacker, Gloria Duffy (Stanford Arms Control Group) (1984). International arms control. Stanford University Press. p. 118. ISBN 0804712115.
18. James Mayall, Cornelia Navari (1980). The end of the post-war era. Cambridge University Press. pp. 135–137. ISBN 0521226988.
19. Larsen, Jeffrey Arthur; Smith, James M. (2005). Historical Dictionary of Arms Control and Disarmament. Scarecrow Press. p. 107. ISBN 978-0810850606. moscow hotline teleprinter fax machine.
20. Stephen L. Thacher, , US Army War College, Carusle Barracks, 1990, p. 10.
21. "Washington Moscow Hotline". www.cryptomuseum.com. Retrieved 2016-02-28.
22. "Electrospaces.net: The Washington-Moscow Hotline". electrospaces.blogspot.co.uk. Retrieved 2016-02-28.
23. "What Obama said to Putin on the Red Phone about the election hacks". NBC News. Retrieved 2016-12-20.
24. "US, Russia plan hotline to prevent cyber war". Total Telecom. 30 April 2012. Retrieved 5 September 2012.
25. "Hotline Agreements". Arms Control Association.
26. Mitchell, Ellen (3 March 2022). "US, Russia set up military communication line to prevent accidental clash". thehill.com. Retrieved December 1, 2022.
27. Stewart, Phil (29 November 2022). "Exclusive: U.S., Russia have used their military hotline once so far during Ukraine war". reuters.com. Retrieved December 1, 2022.
28. The red phone that was NOT on the Hotline, August 30, 2013
29. Lisboa, Maria Manuel (2011). The End of the World: Apocalypse and Its Aftermath in Western Culture. Open Book Publishers. p. 28. ISBN 9781906924508. ...the Americans receive a teletype from their counterparts in the Soviet Union stating that they have now determined that the first missile was not launched by NATO.
30. YouTube – Red Alert 2 intro
31. "The Doctor Who Transcripts - World War Three". www.chakoteya.net. Retrieved 2023-08-16.
32. YouTube – US Democrats – Walter Mondale 1984 Video 10
33. Kurtz, Howard (March 1, 2008), "Clinton Plays the Fear Card", Washington Post, pp. A08
34. YouTube – Mondale/Ferraro Commercial 1984
35. Kaid, Lynda Lee; Anne Johnston (2000). Videostyle in Presidential Campaigns: Style and Content of Televised Political Advertising. Greenwood Publishing Group. p. 59. ISBN 0-275-94071-3.
36. Beckel, Bob (March 19, 2008). "Superdelegates: Whiners or Deciders?". Real Clear Politics. Retrieved 2008-03-20.
37. YouTube – Hillary Clinton Ad – 3 AM White House Ringing Phone
38. Kornblut, Anne E.; Murray, Shailagh (March 1, 2008), "Clinton Ad Hints Obama Is Unprepared for Crisis", Washington Post, pp. A01

External links

• "DCL: The Direct Communications Link", Cryptolog, December 1983, declassified internal newsletter of the National Security Agency; five-page illustrated article detailing the political and technical history of the hotline up to the Reagan administration.
• Top Level Telecommunications: The Washington-Moscow Hot Line
• Crypto Machines: The Washington-Moscow Hot Line
• The original Hotline Agreement Texts of 1963, 1971 and 1984