Sanctuary city

Not to be confused with Cities of Refuge.

"City of Sanctuary" redirects here. For the British charity, see City of Sanctuary (UK).

A sanctuary city is a municipality that limits or denies its cooperation with the national government in enforcing immigration law.

Leaders of sanctuary cities say they want to reduce fear of deportation and possible family break-up among people who are in the country illegally, so that such people will be more willing to report crimes, use health and social services, and enroll their children in school.

In the United States, municipal policies include prohibiting police or city employees from questioning people about their immigration status and refusing requests by national immigration authorities to detain people beyond their release date, if they were jailed for breaking local law.^[1] Such policies can be set expressly in law (de jure) or observed in practice (de facto), but the designation "sanctuary city" does not have a precise legal definition. The Federation for American Immigration Reform estimated in 2018 that 564 U.S. jurisdictions, including states and municipalities, had adopted sanctuary policies.^[2][3][4]

Studies on the relationship between sanctuary status and crime have found that sanctuary policies either have no effect on crime or that sanctuary cities have lower crime rates and stronger economies than comparable non-sanctuary cities.^[5][6][7][8] Sanctuary city policies substantially reduce deportations of undocumented immigrants who do not have criminal records, but have no impact on those who have violent criminal records.^[9] Opponents of sanctuary cities argue that cities should assist the national government in enforcing immigration law, and that sanctuary cities increase crime. Supporters of sanctuary cities argue that enforcement of federal law is not the duty of localities, and that law enforcement resources can be prioritized towards better purposes.^[10]

European cities have been inspired by the same political currents of the sanctuary movement as American cities, but the term "sanctuary city" now has different meanings in Europe and North America.^[11] In the United Kingdom and in continental Europe, sanctuary city refers to cities that are committed to welcoming refugees and asylum seekers. There are at least 80 towns, cities, and local areas with this policy in England, Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland.^[12] with an emphasis on building bridges of connection and understanding through raising awareness, befriending schemes and forming cultural connections. However, this is in relation to documented refugees and asylum seekers, not illegal immigrants.^[13] Glasgow and Swansea have become noted sanctuary cities.^[12][14][15]

United States

See also: Illegal immigration to the United States

History

The movement that established sanctuary cities in the United States began in the early 1980s. The movement traces its roots to religious philosophy, as well as the histories of resistance movements to perceived state injustices.^[16] The sanctuary city movement took place in the 1980s to challenge the US government's refusal to grant asylum to certain Central American refugees.^[17] These asylum seekers were arriving from countries in Central America like El Salvador and Guatemala that were politically unstable. More than 75,000 Salvadoreans and 200,000 Guatemalans were killed in civil wars in these countries.^[18] Faith-based groups in the US Southwest initially drove the movement of the 1980s, with eight churches publicly declaring to be sanctuaries in March 1982.^[19] John Fife, a minister and movement leader, famously wrote in a letter to Attorney General William Smith: "the South-side United Presbyterian Church will publicly violate the Immigration and Nationality Act by allowing sanctuary in its church for those from Central America."^[20]

A milestone in the U.S. sanctuary city movement occurred in 1985 in San Francisco, which passed the largely symbolic “City of Refuge” resolution. The resolution was followed the same year by an ordinance which prohibited the use of city funds and resources to assist federal immigration enforcement–the defining characteristic of a sanctuary city in the U.S.^[21] As of 2018, more than 560 cities, states and counties considered themselves sanctuaries.^[4]

Terminology

 

Sanctuary cities in the United States*

  State has legislation in place that establishes a statewide sanctuary for undocumented immigrants

  County or county equivalent either contains a municipality that is a sanctuary for undocumented immigrants, or is one itself

  All county jails in the state do not honor ICE detainers

  Alongside statewide legislation or policies establishing sanctuary for undocumented immigrants, the county contains a municipality that has policy or has taken action to further provide sanctuary to undocumented immigrants

*Map is based on data published by ICE in a February 2017 report outlining jurisdictions that have declined ICE detainers.

Several different terms and phrases are used to describe immigrants who enter the U.S. illegally. The term alien is considered insensitive by many^[who?] and a LexisNexis search showed that its use in reports on immigration has declined substantially, making up just 5% of terms used in 2013.^[22] Usage of the word "illegal" and phrases using the word (e.g., illegal alien, illegal immigrant, illegal worker and illegal migrant) has declined, accounting for 82% of language used in 1996, 75% in 2002, 60% in 2007, and 57% in 2013.^[22] Several other phrases are competing for wide acceptance: undocumented immigrant (usage in news reports increased from 6% in 1996 to 14% in 2013); unauthorized immigrant (3% usage in 2013 and rarely seen before that time), and undocumented person or undocumented people (1% in 2007, increasing to 3% in 2013).^[22] "The U.S. Citizenship Act of 2021", which President Joe Biden proposed to Congress, would eliminate the word "alien" from federal immigration laws and replace it with "noncitizen".^[23][24]

Media outlets' policies as to use of terms differ, and no consensus has yet emerged in the press.^[25][26] In 2013, the Associated Press changed its AP Stylebook to provide that "Except in direct quotes essential to the story, use illegal only to refer to an action, not a person: illegal immigration, but not illegal immigrant. Acceptable variations include living in or entering a country illegally or without legal permission."^[27] Within several weeks, major U.S. newspapers such as Chicago Tribune, the Los Angeles Times, and USA Today adopted similar guidance.^[26] The New York Times style guide similarly states that the term illegal immigrant may be considered "loaded or offensive" and advises journalists to "explain the specific circumstances of the person in question or to focus on actions: who crossed the border illegally; who overstayed a visa; who is not authorized to work in this country."^[25] The style book discourages the use of illegal as a noun and the "sinister-sounding" alien.^[25] Both unauthorized and undocumented are acceptable, but the stylebook notes that the former "has a flavor of euphemism and should be used with caution outside quotation" and the latter has a "bureaucratic tone."^[25] The Washington Post stylebook "says 'illegal immigrant' is accurate and acceptable, but notes that some find it offensive"; the Post "does not refer to people as 'illegal aliens' or 'illegals,'" per its guidelines.^[28]

Sanctuary Restaurants are a related idea.^[29] It is a program run by Presente.org and the Restaurant Opportunities Center.^[29]

Electoral politics

This issue entered presidential politics in the race for the Republican Party presidential nomination in 2008. Colorado Congressman Tom Tancredo ran on an anti-illegal immigration platform and specifically attacked sanctuary cities. Former Massachusetts Governor Mitt Romney accused former New York City Mayor Rudy Giuliani of running it as a sanctuary city.^[30] Mayor Giuliani's campaign responded saying that Governor Romney ran a sanctuary Governor's mansion, and that New York City is not a "haven" for undocumented immigrants.^[30]

Following the shooting death of Kathryn Steinle in San Francisco (a sanctuary city) by an undocumented immigrant, former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton (D-NY) told CNN that "The city made a mistake, not to deport someone that the federal government strongly felt should be deported. I have absolutely no support for a city that ignores the strong evidence that should be acted on."^[31] The following day, her campaign stated: "Hillary Clinton believes that sanctuary cities can help further public safety, and she has defended those policies going back years."^[32]

Trump administration agenda

On March 6, 2018, the U.S. Justice Department sued the state of California, the Governor Jerry Brown, and the state's attorney general, Xavier Becerra, over three recently-passed state laws, saying the laws made it impossible for federal immigration officials to do their jobs and deport criminals who were born outside the United States. The Justice Department called the laws unconstitutional and asked a judge to block them. The lawsuit said the state laws “reflect a deliberate effort by California to obstruct the United States’ enforcement of federal immigration law.”^[33] The Trump administration previously released a list of immigration principles to Congress. The list included funding a wall along the U.S.-Mexico border, a crackdown on the influx of Central American minors, and curbs on federal grants to sanctuary cities.^[34] A pledge to strip "all federal funding to sanctuary cities" was a key Trump campaign theme. President Trump issued an executive order which declared that jurisdictions that "refuse to comply" with 8 U.S.C. 1373—a provision of federal law on information sharing between local and federal authorities—would be ineligible to receive federal grants.^[35]

States and cities have shown varying responses to the executive order. Thirty-three states introduced or enacted legislation requiring local law enforcement to cooperate with ICE officers and requests to hold non-citizen inmates for deportation. Other states and cities have responded by not cooperating with federal immigration efforts or by showcasing welcoming policies towards immigrants.^[35] California openly refused the administration's attempts to "clamp down on sanctuary cities". A federal judge in San Francisco agreed with two California municipalities that a presidential attempt to cut them off from federal funding for not complying with deportation requests was unconstitutional,^[36] ultimately issuing a nationwide permanent injunction against the facially unconstitutional provisions of the order.^[37] On March 27, 2018, the all-Republican Board of Supervisors in Orange County, California voted to join the Justice Department's lawsuit against the state.^[38] In Chicago a federal judge ruled that the Trump administration may not withhold public safety grants to sanctuary cities. These decisions have been seen as a setback to the administration's efforts to force local jurisdictions to help federal authorities with the policing of illegal immigrants.^[39] On July 5, 2018, a federal judge upheld two of California's Sanctuary laws, but struck down a key provision in the third.^[40]

Local officials who oppose the president's policies say that complying with federal immigration officers will ruin the trust established between law enforcement and immigrant communities. Supporters of the president's policies say that protection of immigrants from enforcement makes communities less safe and undermines the rule of law.^[39] On July 12, 2019, federal appeals court in Seattle in a 2-to-1 opinion overturned a nationwide injunction issued last year by a federal judge in Los Angeles. The appeals court said awarding extra points in the application process to cities that cooperate was consistent with the goals of the grant program created by Congress.^[41]

United States federal law

The Illegal Immigration Reform and Immigrant Responsibility Act of 1996 addressed the relationship between the federal and local governments. Minor crimes, such as shoplifting, became grounds for possible deportation.^[42] Additionally, the legislation outlawed cities' bans against municipal workers reporting a person's immigration status to federal authorities.^[43] However, nothing in the law forces states or local governments to help the federal government with immigration enforcement.^[44]

Section 287(g) makes it possible for state and local law enforcement personnel to enter into agreements with the federal government to be trained in immigration enforcement and, subsequent to such training, to enforce immigration law. However, it provides no general power for immigration enforcement by state and local authorities.^[45] This provision was implemented by local and state authorities in five states, California, Arizona, Alabama, Florida and North Carolina by the end of 2006.^[46] On June 16, 2007, the United States House of Representatives passed an amendment to a United States Department of Homeland Security spending bill that would withhold federal emergency services funds from sanctuary cities. Congressman Tom Tancredo (R-Colo.) was the sponsor of this amendment. 50 Democrats joined Republicans to support the amendment. The amendment would have to pass the United States Senate to become effective.^[47]

In 2007, Republican representatives introduced legislation targeting sanctuary cities. Reps. Brian Bilbray, R-Calif., Ginny Brown-Waite, R-Fla., Thelma Drake, R-Va., Jeff Miller, R-Fla., and Tom Tancredo introduced the bill. The legislation would make undocumented immigrant status a felony, instead of a civil offense. Also, the bill targets sanctuary cities by withholding up to 50 percent of Department of Homeland Security funds from the cities.^[48]

On September 5, 2007, Department of Homeland Security Secretary Michael Chertoff told a House committee that he certainly wouldn't tolerate interference by sanctuary cities that would block his "Basic Pilot Program" that requires employers to validate the legal status of their workers. "We're exploring our legal options. I intend to take as vigorous legal action as the law allows to prevent that from happening, prevent that kind of interference."^[49][50]

On January 25, 2017, President Donald Trump signed Executive Order 13768 directing the Secretary of Homeland Security and Attorney General to defund sanctuary jurisdictions that refuse to comply with federal immigration law.^[51] He also ordered the Department of Homeland Security to begin issuing weekly public reports that include "a comprehensive list of criminal actions committed by aliens and any jurisdiction that ignored or otherwise failed to honor any detainers with respect to such aliens."^[51] Ilya Somin, Professor of Law at George Mason University, has argued that Trump's withholding of federal funding would be unconstitutional: "Trump and future presidents could use [the executive order] to seriously undermine constitutional federalism by forcing dissenting cities and states to obey presidential dictates, even without authorization from Congress. The circumvention of Congress makes the order a threat to separation of powers, as well."^[52] On April 25, 2017, U.S. District Judge William Orrick issued a nationwide preliminary injunction halting this executive order.^[53][54] The injunction was made permanent on November 20, 2017, when Judge Orrick ruled that section 9(a) of the order was "unconstitutional on its face".^[55] The judgment concluded that the order violates "the separation of powers doctrine and deprives [the plaintiffs] of their Tenth and Fifth Amendment rights."^[56]

In December 2018 the Ninth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals struck down a federal law that criminalized encouraging people to enter or live in the U.S. illegally. The court said the law was too broad in restricting the basic right of free speech under the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution. Opponents of the law argued that it was a danger to lawyers advising immigrants and to public officials who support sanctuary policies.^[57][58][59]

Jurisdiction

Whether federal or local government has jurisdiction to detain and deport undocumented immigrants is a tricky and unsettled issue, because the U.S. Constitution does not provide a clear answer. Both federal and local government offer arguments to defend their authority. The issue of jurisdiction has been vigorously debated dating back to the Alien Act of 1798.^[60] Opponents of local level policing tend to use the Naturalization Clause and the Migration clause in the Constitution as textual confirmation of federal power. Because the Supremacy Clause is generally interpreted to mean that federal law takes priority over state law, the U.S. Supreme Court in the majority of cases has ruled in favor of the federal government. Certain states have been affected by illegal immigration more than others and have attempted to pass legislation that limits access by undocumented immigrants to public benefits. A notable case was Arizona's SB 1070 law, which was passed in 2010 and struck down in 2012 by the Supreme Court as unconstitutional.^[61]

States like Arizona, Texas and Nevada justify the aggressive actions they have taken to be the result of insufficient efforts by the federal government to address issues, like the use of schools and hospitals by undocumented immigrants, and changes to the cultural landscape—impacts that are most visible on a local level.^[62] Ambiguity and confusion over jurisdiction is one of the reasons why local and state policies for and against sanctuary cities vary widely depending on the location in the country.

Effects

Crime

Studies show that US sanctuary cities either have no impact on crime or that they lower the crime rate.^{[7][63][64][65][66][6][67][68][9]}

According to an article done by Gale Opposing Viewpoints, a 2015 study by the American Immigration Council "determined that both documented and undocumented immigrants are less likely to engage in criminal behavior than native-born Americans," and that there was a decrease in "violent crime and serious property crime in cities with growing migrant populations."^[44]

A 2017 study in the journal Urban Affairs Review found that sanctuary policy itself has no statistically meaningful effect on crime.^{[66][5][69][70][71]} The findings of the study were misinterpreted by Attorney General Jeff Sessions in a July 2017 speech when he claimed that the study showed that sanctuary cities were more prone to crime than cities without sanctuary policies.^[72][73] A third study in the journal Justice Quarterly found evidence that the adoption of sanctuary policies reduced the robbery rate, but had no impact on the homicide rate except in cities with larger Mexican undocumented immigrant populations, which had lower rates of homicide.^[65]

According to a study by Tom K. Wong, associate professor of political science at the University of California, San Diego, published by the Center for American Progress, a progressive think tank: "Crime is statistically significantly lower in sanctuary counties compared to non-sanctuary counties. Moreover, economies are stronger in sanctuary counties – from higher median household income, less poverty, and less reliance on public assistance, to higher labor force participation, higher employment-to-population ratios, and lower unemployment."^[6] The study also concluded that sanctuary cities build trust between local law enforcement and the community, which enhances public safety overall.^[74] The study evaluated sanctuary and non-sanctuary cities while controlling for differences in population, the foreign-born percentage of the population, and the percentage of the population that is Latino."^[6]

A 2020 study found that California Senate Bill 54 (2017), a sanctuary city legislation, had no significant impact on violent and property crime rates in California.^[75]

A 2021 US study found that Latinos were more likely to report crime victimization to law enforcement after sanctuary policies were adopted in their areas of residence.^[76]

Economy

Advocates of local enforcement of immigration laws argue that more regulatory local immigration policies would cause immigrants to flee those cities and possibly the United States altogether,^[77] while opponents argue that regulatory policies on immigrants wouldn't affect their presence because immigrants looking for work will relocate towards economic opportunity despite challenges living there.^[10] Undocumented migrants tend to be attracted to states with more economic opportunity and individual freedom.^[78] Because there is no reliable data that asks for immigration status, there is no way to tell empirically if regulatory policies do have an effect on immigrant presence. A study comparing restrictive counties with nonrestrictive counties found that local jurisdictions that enacted regulatory immigration policies experienced a 1–2% negative effect in employment.^[10]

Health and well-being

A preliminary study's results imply that the number of sanctuary cities in the U.S. positively affects well-being in the undocumented immigrant population.^[79] Concerning health, a study in North Carolina found that after implementation of section 287(g), prenatal Hispanic/Latina mothers were more likely than non-Hispanic/Latina mothers to have late or inadequate prenatal care. The study's interviews indicated that Hispanics/Latinos in the section 287(g) counties had distrust in health services among other services and had fear about going to the doctor.^[80]

Laws and policies by state and city

 

Pro-sanctuary states are in blue, states which have banned sanctuary cities are in red, and states in gray have no official policy.

Alabama

Alabama has banned sanctuary cities.^[81] The state law (Alabama HB 56) was enacted in 2011, calling for proactive immigration enforcement; however, many provisions are either blocked by the federal courts or subject to ongoing lawsuits.^[82]

• On January 31, 2017, William A. Bell, the mayor of Birmingham, declared the city a "welcoming city" and said that the police would not be "an enforcement arm of the federal government" with respect to federal immigration law. He also stated that the city would not require proof of citizenship for granting business licenses. The Birmingham City Council subsequently passed a resolution supporting Birmingham being a "sanctuary city".^[83]

Arizona

Arizona has banned sanctuary cities.^[81] Following the passage of Arizona SB 1070, a state law, few if any cities in Arizona are "sanctuary cities." A provision of SB 1070 requires local authorities to "contact federal immigration authorities if they develop reasonable suspicion that a person they've detained or arrested is in the country illegally."^[84]

• The Center for Immigration Studies, an anti-immigration group, labels only one city in the state, South Tucson, a "sanctuary city"; the label is because South Tucson does not honor ICE detainers "unless ICE pays for cost of detention".^[84]
• In 2019, Tucson held a citywide vote on Proposition 205, which would have declared it a sanctuary city. However, the proposition failed 70–30. Amongst others, Democratic outgoing Mayor Jonathan Rothschild and mayoral candidates Steve Farley, Randi Dorman and eventual winner Regina Romero, alongside city councilmembers and US Senate candidate Mark Kelly endorsed a "No" vote.^{[85][86][87][88]}

Arkansas

Arkansas has banned sanctuary cities.^[81]

California

On October 5, 2017, Governor Jerry Brown signed a bill, SB 54, that makes California a "sanctuary state". It prohibits local and state agencies from cooperating with ICE regarding undocumented individuals who have committed misdemeanors.^[89] According to the National Immigration Law Center in 2016, about a dozen California cities have some formal sanctuary policy, and none of the 58 California counties "complies with detainer requests by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement."^[90]

• Berkeley became the first city in the United States to pass a sanctuary resolution on November 8, 1971.^[91] Additional local governments in certain cities in the United States began designating themselves as sanctuary cities during the 1980s.^[92][93] Some have questioned the accuracy of the term "sanctuary city" as used in the US.^[94] The policy was initiated in 1979 in Los Angeles, to prevent the Los Angeles Police Department (LAPD) from inquiring about the immigration status of arrestees. Many Californian cities have adopted "sanctuary" ordinances banning city employees and public safety personnel from asking people about their immigration status.^[95][96]
• Coachella – 95% Latino, 2nd highest percentage Latino city in Southern California, adopted the sanctuary policy in 2015.^[97]
• Huntington Beach obtained a ruling from the state Supreme Court that the protections in California for immigrants who are in the country illegally do not apply to the 121 charter cities. The Orange County city is the first to successfully challenge SB 54.^[98]
• Los Angeles – In 1979, the Los Angeles City Council adopted Special Order 40, barring LAPD officers from initiating contact with a person solely to determine their immigration status.^[99] However, the city frequently cooperates with federal immigration authorities.^[90] Los Angeles Mayor Eric Garcetti did not use the phrase "sanctuary city" to describe the city because the label is unclear.^[90]
• San Francisco "declared itself a sanctuary city in 1989, and city officials strengthened the stance in 2013 with its 'Due Process for All' ordinance. The law declared local authorities could not hold immigrants for immigration officials if they had no violent felonies on their records and did not currently face charges."^[90] The city issues a Resident ID Card regardless of the applicant's immigration status.^[100] The 2015 shooting of Kathryn Steinle provoked debate about San Francisco's "sanctuary city" policy.^[101]
• Seaside – On March 29, 2017, Seaside became Monterey County's first sanctuary city.^[102]
• Williams – 75% Latino, largest percentage Latino town in Northern California, adopted the policy in 2015.^[103]

Colorado

On May 29, 2019, Governor Jared Polis signed House Bill 1124 immediately prohibiting law enforcement officials in Colorado from holding undocumented immigrants solely on the basis of a request from U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement.^[104]

• Boulder^[105] became a sanctuary city in 2017.
• Denver does not identify as a sanctuary city. The Denver Post reports: "The city doesn't have an ordinance staking out a claim or barring information-sharing with federal officials about a person's immigration status, unlike some cities. But it is among cities that don't enforce immigration laws or honor federal 'detainer' requests to hold immigrants with suspect legal status in jail past their release dates.^[106]
• Estes Park police chief Wes Kufeld stated that, "As far as day-to-day policing, people are not required to provide proof of immigration status, and our officers are not required by ICE to check immigration status, nor to conduct sweeps for undocumented individuals. So, we don’t do these things." He added that town police do assist ICE in the arrest and detainment of any undocumented immigrant suspected of a felony.^[107]

Connecticut

See also: Elm City Resident Card

In 2013, Connecticut passed a law that gives local law enforcement officers discretion to carry out immigration detainer requests, though only for suspected felons.^[108]

• Hartford passed an ordinance providing services to all residents regardless of their immigration in 2008. Said ordinance also prohibits police from detaining individuals based solely on their immigration status, or inquiring as to their immigration status. In 2016, the ordinance was amended to declare that Hartford is a "Sanctuary City", although the term itself does not have an established legal meaning.^[109]
• On February 3, 2017, Middletown, CT declared itself a sanctuary city. This was in direct response to President Trump's executive order. Middletown's mayor, Daniel T Drew, said: “We don't just take orders from the President of the United States”^[110]

Florida

Florida has banned sanctuary cities.^[81][111]

• In January 2017 Miami-Dade County rescinded a policy of insisting the U.S. government pay for detention of persons on a federal list. Republican Mayor Carlos Gimenez ordered jails to "fully cooperate" with Presidential immigration policy. He said he did not want to risk losing a larger amount of federal financial aid for not complying. The mayor said Miami-Dade County has never considered itself to be a sanctuary city.^[112]
• St. Petersburg Democratic Mayor Rick Kriseman said residents from all backgrounds implored him to declare a sanctuary city. In February 2017 he blogged that, "I have no hesitation in declaring St. Petersburg a sanctuary from harmful federal immigration laws. We will not expend resources to help enforce such laws, nor will our police officers stop, question or arrest an individual solely on the basis that they may have unlawfully entered the United States." He said the county sheriff's office has ultimate responsibility for notifying federal officials about people illegally in the city. The mayor criticized President Trump for "demonization of Muslims."^[113][114]
• In June 2019, Florida Governor Ron DeSantis signed a bill that bans sanctuary cities. The bill prohibits local governments from enacting "sanctuary" policies that protect undocumented immigrants from deportation and all law enforcement agencies in Florida will have to cooperate with federal immigration authorities.^{[115][116][117]} Florida became the 12th state to ban sanctuary cities.^[118]

Georgia

Georgia banned "sanctuary cities" in 2010, and in 2016 went further by requiring local governments, in order to obtain state funding, to certify that they cooperate with federal immigration officials.^[119]

• The mayor of Atlanta, Georgia in January 2017 declared the city was a “welcoming city” and “will remain open and welcoming to all”. This statement was in response to President's Trump's executive orders related to “public safety agencies and the communities they serve”. Nonetheless, Atlanta does not consider itself to be a “sanctuary city”.^[120] Atlanta also has refused to house new ICE detainees in its jail, but will keep the current detainees.

Illinois

On August 28, 2017, Illinois Governor Bruce Rauner signed a bill into law that prohibited state and local police from arresting anyone solely due to their immigration status or due to federal detainers.^{[121][122][123][124]} Some fellow Republicans criticized Rauner for his action, claiming the bill made Illinois a sanctuary state. However, the Illinois associations for Sheriffs and Police Chiefs stated that the bill does not prevent cooperation with the federal government or give sanctuary for undocumented immigrants. Both organizations support the bill.^{[125][126][127]}

• Chicago's history as a self-proclaimed sanctuary city dates back to 1985, when Mayor Harold Washington issued an executive order prohibiting city employees from enforcing federal immigration laws.^[128]Chicago became a "de jure" sanctuary city in 2012 when Mayor Rahm Emanuel and the City Council passed the Welcoming City Ordinance.^[129][130] The ordinance protects residents' rights to access city services regardless of immigration status and states that Chicago police officers cannot arrest individuals on the basis of immigration status alone.^[131] The status was reaffirmed in 2016.^[132][133]
• Urbana, Illinois^[134]
• Evanston, Illinois^[135]

Iowa

Iowa has banned sanctuary cities.^[81]

Kansas

Kansas has banned sanctuary cities.^[136]

Louisiana

• In New Orleans^[137] the New Orleans Police Department began a new policy to "no longer cooperate with federal immigration enforcement" beginning on Feb. 28, 2016.^[137] However, according to the U.S. Department of Justice, there is "no evidence" that New Orleans is a sanctuary city.^[138]

Maine

A 2004 executive order prohibited state officials from inquiring about immigration statuses of individuals seeking public assistance, but in 2011, the incoming Maine governor Paul LePage rescinded this, stating “it is the intent of this administration to promote rather than hinder the enforcement of federal immigration law."

• In 2015, Governor LePage accused Portland of being a sanctuary city based on the fact that “city employees are prohibited from asking about the immigration status of people seeking city services unless compelled by a court or law,"^[139] but Portland city officials did not accept that characterization.^[139]

Maryland

• In 2008, Baltimore and Takoma Park are sometimes identified as sanctuary cities.^[140] However, "[m]ost local governments in Maryland – including Baltimore – still share information with the federal government."^[141] In 2016, Baltimore Mayor Stephanie Rawlings-Blake said that she did not consider Baltimore to be a "sanctuary city."^[142]

Massachusetts

Massachusetts has a pro-sanctuary city law.^[143] The Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court ruled in July 2017 that a person cannot be held solely due to an ICE detainer.^[144][145]

• Boston has an ordinance, enacted in 2014, that bars the Boston Police Department "from detaining anyone based on their immigration status unless they have a criminal warrant."^[146] Cambridge, Chelsea, Somerville, Orleans, Northampton, and Springfield have similar legislation.^[146] In August 2016, Boston Police Commissioner, William B. Evans re-issued a memo stating “all prisoners who are subject to ICE Detainers must receive equal access to bail commissioners, which includes notifying said prisoner of his or her right to seek bail.” Bail commissioners are informed of the person's status on an ICE detainer list and may set bail accordingly.^[147]

Michigan

• Detroit and Ann Arbor are sometimes referred to as "sanctuary cities" because they "have anti-profiling ordinances that generally prohibit local police from asking about the immigration status of people who are not suspected of any crime."^[148] Unlike San Francisco's ordinance, however, the Detroit and Ann Arbor policies do not bar local authorities from cooperating and assisting ICE and Customs and Border Protection, and both cities frequently do so.
• Kalamazoo re-affirmed its status as a welcoming city in 2017. Vice Mayor Don Cooney stated, "We care about you. We will protect you. We are with you." [1]
• Lansing voted to become a sanctuary city in April 2017, but reversed the decision a week later due to public and business opposition. An order by mayor Virg Bernero still prohibits Lansing police officers from asking residents about their immigration status, however.^[149]

Minnesota

• Minneapolis has an ordinance, adopted in 2003,^[150] that directs local law enforcement officers "not to 'take any law enforcement action' for the sole purpose of finding undocumented immigrants, or ask an individual about his or her immigration status."^[151] The Minneapolis ordinance does not bar cooperation with federal authorities: "The city works cooperatively with the Homeland Security, as it does with all state and federal agencies, but the city does not operate its programs for the purpose of enforcing federal immigration laws. The Homeland Security has the legal authority to enforce immigration laws in the United States, in Minnesota and in the city."^[150]

Mississippi

Mississippi has banned sanctuary cities.^[81]

Missouri

Missouri has banned sanctuary cities.^[81]

Montana

On April 2, 2021, Governor Greg Gianforte signed a bill that bans Sanctuary cities in the state of Montana into law.^{[152][153][154]} Montana became the 13th state to ban sanctuary cities.

Nevada

• Clark County and Las Vegas^{[155][156][clarification needed]}

New York

New York has a pro-sanctuary city law.^[157]

• Albany - Mayor Kathy Sheehan stated that the city complies with federal law and cooperates with ICE, but she asserted that comments by national government officials show a failure "to understand what is happening in our cities and why a city like Albany would choose to label itself as a sanctuary city."^[158]
• Ithaca^[159]
• New York City^[160] (see also illegal immigration to New York City)
• Newburgh declared itself a sanctuary city in March 2017.^[161]
• Rochester^[162]
• Syracuse^[163]

New Jersey

In 2018, Attorney General Gurbir Grewal issued the 'Immigrant Trust Directive', which effectively made New Jersey a sanctuary state.^[164] Among the municipalities which are considered sanctuary cities are Asbury Park, Camden, East Orange, Hoboken, Jersey City, Linden, New Brunswick, Newark, North Bergen, Plainfield, Trenton and Union City.^[165] Those with specific executive orders made by mayors or resolution by municipal councils are:

• Jersey City^[166][167]
• Maplewood^[168]
• Newark^[169][170]
• East Orange^[171]
• Prospect Park^[172]
• Union City^[173]
• Highland Park (see:Reformed Church of Highland Park)
• Hoboken^[174][175]

New Mexico

All county jails are prohibited from honoring ICE detainers, unless they have an arrest warrant signed by a judge.^[176]

North Carolina

North Carolina has banned sanctuary cities.^[81] The state currently restricts any city or municipality from refusing to cooperate with federal immigration and customs enforcement officials.^[177] There are therefore no official sanctuary cities in the state. A bill, initially under consideration as of March 2017, is entitled Citizens Protection Act of 2017 or HB 63. Under the new provisions, the state would be able to deny bail to undocumented immigrants for whom Immigration and Customs Enforcements (ICE) has issued a detainer; allow the state to withhold tax revenues from cities who are not in compliance with the statewide immigration regulations; and encourage tipsters to identify municipalities which violate these laws.^[178] A similar version of HB 63 was introduced in February 2023 during the 2023-2024 session.^[179]

Ohio

• Cleveland^[180]
• Cincinnati's mayor declared the city a sanctuary city on January 30, 2017, in response to a federal executive order limiting immigration issued three days earlier.^[181]
• As of 2019, Ohio,^[182][183] Kentucky^[184][185] and Michigan^[186][187] are pushing for 'anti sanctuary cities' measures in their states.

Oregon

State law passed in 1987: "Oregon Revised Statute 181.850, which prohibits law enforcement officers at the state, county or municipal level from enforcing federal immigration laws that target people based on their race or ethnic origin, when those individuals are not suspected of any criminal activities."^[188][189]

• Beaverton city council passed a resolution in January 2017 stating, in part, "The City of Beaverton is committed to living its values as a welcoming city for all individuals ...regardless of a person's ... immigration status" and that they would abide by Oregon state law of not enforcing federal immigration laws.^[190]
• Corvallis^[191]
• Portland^[192]

Pennsylvania

There are currently 18 sanctuary jurisdictions in the state of Pennsylvania.^[193][194] Sanctuary jurisdictions exist in Bradford County, Bucks County, Clarion County, Delaware County, Erie County, Franklin County, Lebanon County, Lehigh County, Lycoming County, Montgomery County, Montour County, Perry County, Philadelphia County, Pike County, and Westmoreland County.

• Philadelphia mayor Jim Kenney said in November 2016 that federal immigration policies lead to more crime, and that crime rates declined the year he reinstated a sanctuary city policy.^[195] U.S. Attorney General Sessions has included Philadelphia on the list of cities threatened with subpoenas if they fail to provide documents to show whether local law enforcement officers are sharing information with federal immigration authorities.^[196]

Rhode Island

In 2014, Governor Lincoln Chafee put in place a new policy instructing the Department of Corrections to stop honoring immigration detainers without a warrant.^[197]

South Carolina

South Carolina has banned sanctuary cities.^[81]

Tennessee

Tennessee state law bars "local governments or officials from making policies that stop local entities from complying with federal immigration law."^[198] In 2017, legislation proposed in the Tennessee General Assembly would go further, withholding funding from local governments deemed insufficiently cooperative with the federal government.^[198]

• In Nashville, mayor David Briley, signed an executive order in September 2019 directing city attorneys to investigate grounds for challenging Tennessee's anti-sanctuary-city law.^[199] However, after losing the 2019 mayoral election, his successor, John Cooper rescinded the order in December 2019, saying that Nashville "cannot and will not be a sanctuary city".^[200] However, Cooper did not support "federalizing the Metropolitan Nashville Police Department", saying that "our police needs to be for us and our local law enforcement and not always being agents of the federal government, the IRS, the EPA, Alcohol and Tobacco or ICE. If they have a non-judicial warrant, that has not ever been before a judge, it needs to be a lower priority for what we need to do."^[201]

Texas

In Texas no city has formally declared "sanctuary" status, but a few do not fully cooperate with federal immigration authorities and have drawn a negative response from the legislature.^[202] Bills seeking to deprive state funding from police departments and municipalities that do not cooperate with federal authorities were introduced into the Texas Legislature several times.^[202] On February 1, 2017, Texas Governor Greg Abbott blocked funding to Travis County, Texas due to its recently implemented de facto sanctuary city policy.^[203][204] On May 7, 2017, Abbott signed Texas Senate Bill 4 into law, effectively banning sanctuary cities by charging county or city officials who refuse to work with federal officials and by allowing police officers to check the immigration status of those they detain if they choose.^[205][206] In May 2018, the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit found that the law does not violate the First Amendment to the United States Constitution.^[207][208]

Vermont

In 2017, Vermont passed a law granting the Governor the sole authority to commit state or local law enforcement to enforce federal immigration law.^[209] Governor Phil Scott said, "I want to be very clear this law has been carefully crafted through a consensus-building process to confirm Vermont remains compliant with federal law, that we would not be establishing a sanctuary state."^[210] Previously, a law had been passed in 2014 directing local law enforcement to disregard immigration detainers, but compliance was optional.^[211]

Washington

Washington enacted a measure in June 2019 in favor of sanctuary cities, similar to California and Oregon laws which are among the strongest statewide mandates in the nation.^[212]

• Seattle^[213]

Washington DC

Washington DC is a sanctuary city.^[214]

Canada

Central Canada

Toronto was the first city in Canada to declare itself a sanctuary city, with the Toronto City Council voting 37–3 on February 22, 2013, to adopt a formal policy allowing undocumented migrants to access city services.^[215] Hamilton, Ontario declared itself a sanctuary city in February 2014 after the Hamilton City Council voted unanimously to allow undocumented immigrants to access city-funded services such as shelters, housing and food banks.^[216] In response to US President Donald Trump's Executive Order 13769, the city council of London, Ontario voted unanimously to declare London a sanctuary city in January 2017^[217] with Montreal doing the same in February 2017 after a unanimous vote. (However Montreal removed its sanctuary city status in 2019).^[218]

Western Canada

While Vancouver is not a sanctuary city, it adopted an "Access to City Services without Fear" policy for residents that are undocumented or have an uncertain immigration status in April 2016.^[219] The policy does not apply to municipal services operated by individual boards, including services provided by the Vancouver Police Department, Vancouver Public Library, or Vancouver Park Board.^[220]

As of February 2017^[update], the cities of Calgary, Ottawa, Regina, Saskatoon, and Winnipeg are considering motions to declare themselves sanctuary cities.^[220][221]

As of September 9, 2018^[update], Edmonton adopted "Access Without Fear" policy for undocumented and vulnerable residents.

United Kingdom

In the United Kingdom, sanctuary cities provide services – such as housing, education, and cultural integration – to asylum seekers (i.e. persons fleeing one country and seeking protection in another).^[13] The movement began in Sheffield in 2005. It was motivated by a national policy adopted in 1999 to disperse asylum seekers to different towns and cities in the UK.

Sheffield

In 2009, the city council of Sheffield drew up a manifesto outlining key areas of concern and 100 supporting organizations signed on.^[222]

A city's status as a place of sanctuary is not necessarily a formal governmental designation. The organization City of Sanctuary encourages local grassroots groups throughout the UK and Ireland to build a culture of hospitality towards asylum seekers.^[223]

Glasgow

Glasgow is a noted sanctuary city in Scotland. In 2000 the city council accepted their first asylum seekers relocated by the Home Office. The Home Office provided funding to support asylum seekers but would also forcibly deport them ("removal seizures") if it was determined they could not stay in the UK. As of 2010 Glasgow had accepted 22,000 asylum seekers from 75 different nations. In 2007, local residents upset by the human impact of removal seizures, organized watches to warn asylum seekers when Home Office vans were in the neighborhood. They also organized protests and vigils which led to the ending of the removal seizures.^[12][15]

Iran

National immigration organization has a program to build "guest" cities.^[224][225]

See also

•  United States portal
•  Law portal

• Sanctuary campus
• Second Amendment sanctuary
• US specific articles
  • Kentucky and Virginia Resolutions
  • Rapid response team
  • Safe-haven law
  • Sanctuary movement
  • Secure Communities
• Separation barrier
• Border barrier
• Closed city
• List of cities with defensive walls

References

1. "Dallas County sheriff eases immigration holds on minor offenses". The Dallas Morning News. October 11, 2015.
2. "Cities, States Resist — and Assist — Immigration Crackdown in New Ways". pew.org. 3 August 2018. Retrieved 2019-07-02.
3. "Report: Nearly Half of Americans Live in Jurisdictions With Sanctuary Policies". Fox News Insider. 2018-05-11. Retrieved 2019-07-02.
4. Dinan, Stephen. "Half of all Americans now live in 'sanctuaries' protecting immigrants". The Washington Times. Retrieved 2018-05-10.
5. Loren Collingwood, Benjamin Gonzalez-O'Brien & Stephen El-Khatib Oct (October 3, 2016). "Sanctuary cities do not experience an increase in crime". Washington Post.
6. "The Effects of Sanctuary Policies on Crime and the Economy". Center for American Progress. January 26, 2017.
7. Martínez, Daniel E.; Martínez-Schuldt, Ricardo D.; Cantor, Guillermo (2017). "Providing Sanctuary or Fostering Crime? A Review of the Research on "Sanctuary Cities" and Crime". Sociology Compass. 12: e12547. doi:10.1111/soc4.12547. ISSN 1751-9020.
8. Martínez, Daniel E.; Martínez-Schuldt, Ricardo; Cantor, Guillermo (2018). "Sanctuary Cities" and Crime. pp. 270–283. doi:10.4324/9781317211563-21. ISBN 9781317211563.
9. Hausman, David K. (2020-10-14). "Sanctuary policies reduce deportations without increasing crime". Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. 117 (44): 27262–27267. Bibcode:2020PNAS..11727262H. doi:10.1073/pnas.2014673117. ISSN 0027-8424. PMC 7959582. PMID 33077607. S2CID 224810244.
10. Pham, Huyen; Van, Pham Hoang (November 2012). "The Economic Impact of Local Immigration Regulation: An Empirical Analysis". Cardozo Law Review. 32: 485–518.
11. Randy K. Lippert; Sean Rehaag (2013). Sanctuary Practices in International Perspectives: Migration, Citizenship, and Social Movements. Routledge. ISBN 978-0-415-67346-4.
12. Nicoll, Vivienne (25 August 2014). "City offering sanctuary to refugees from Syria". Evening Times.
13. Van Steenbergen, Marishka (10 May 2012). "City of Sanctuary concern for welfare of asylum seekers as housing contract goes to private security firm". The Guardian.
14. "Swansea City of Sanctuary - Building a culture of hospitality for people seeking sanctuary". swansea.cityofsanctuary.org. Retrieved 27 October 2018.
15. Forrest, Adam (14 June 2010). . The Big Issue. Archived from the original on 8 March 2021. Retrieved 25 November 2016.
16. Paik, A. Naomi (2017). "Abolitionist futures and the US sanctuary movement". Race & Class. 59 (2): 3–25. doi:10.1177/0306396817717858. S2CID 148696547.
17. Luna, Dakota Smith, Cindy Carcamo, Molly O'Toole, Taryn (April 16, 2019). "California hits back as Trump threatens to 'dump' immigrants in 'sanctuary cities'". Los Angeles Times. Retrieved April 16, 2019. The term dates to the 1980s, when Berkeley and a few other municipalities declared themselves as such to accept migrants from Central America.{{cite news}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
18. Bracken, Amy (Dec. 29 2016). "Why You Need To Know About Guatemala's Civil War". Public Radio International.
19. Bauder, Harald(2017-04-01). "Sanctuary Cities: Politics and Practice in International Perspective. International Migration. 55.(2): 174-187. ISSN 1468-2435.
20. Cunningham, Hilary, God and Caesar at the Rio Grande: sanctuary and the politics of religion (Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 1995),
21. Mancina, P. 2013 “The birth of a sanctuary-city: a history of governmental sanctuary in San Francisco”. In R.K. Lippert and S. Rehaag (Eds) Sanctuary Practices in International Perspectives: Migration, Citizenship and Social Movements. Abingdon, UK, Routledge: 205–218.
22. Emily Guskin, 'Illegal,' 'undocumented,' 'unauthorized': News media shift language on immigration", Pew Research Center (March 17, 2013).
23. Shoichet, Catherine E. (January 21, 2021). "Biden wants to remove this controversial word from US laws". CNN. Retrieved 22 January 2021.
24. "FACT SHEET: President Biden Sends Immigration Bill to Congress as Part of His Commitment to Modernize our Immigration System". Biden-Harris Transition. 20 January 2021. Retrieved 22 January 2021.
25. Stephen Hiltner, Illegal, Undocumented, Unauthorized: The Terms of Immigration Reporting, New York Times (March 10, 2017).
26. Rui Kaneya, 'Illegal,' 'undocumented,' or something else? No clear consensus yet, Columbia Journalism Review (December 23, 2014).
27. Andrew Beaujon & Taylor Miller Thomas, AP changes style on 'illegal immigrant', Poynter Institute (April 2, 2013).
28. Derek Hawkins, The long struggle over what to call 'undocumented immigrants' or, as Trump said in his order, 'illegal aliens', Washington Post (February 9, 2017).
29. "Home". Sanctuary Restaurants (Presente.org & Restaurant Opportunities Center). 2018. Retrieved 2022-10-06.
30. Tapper, Jake; Claiborne, Ron (2007-08-08). "Romney: Giuliani's NYC 'Sanctuary' for undocumented Immigrants". ABC News.
31. Bradner, Eric (7 July 2015). "Clinton: 'People should and do trust me'". CNN. Retrieved 21 July 2015.
32. Suzanne Gamboa. "Clinton Campaign: Sanctuary Cities Can Help Public Safety". NBC News. Retrieved 21 July 2015.
33. "Trump Administration Sues California Over Immigration Laws" New York Times, March 6, 2018. Retrieved March 6, 2018
34. Nakamura, David (2017-10-08). "Trump administration releases hard-line immigration principles, threatening deal on 'dreamers'". Washington Post. ISSN 0190-8286. Retrieved 2017-11-21.
35. Chishti, Muzaffar; Pierce, Sarah (2017-04-19). "Despite Little Action Yet by Trump Administration on Sanctuary Cities, States and Localities Rush to Respond to Rhetoric". Migration Policy Institute. Retrieved 2017-11-21.
36. Phillips, Amber (2017-04-25). "Analysis | California is in a war with Trump on 'sanctuary cities.' It just won its first major battle". The Washington Post. Retrieved 2017-11-21.
37. Diamond, Jeremy; McKirdy, Euan (November 21, 2017). "Judge issues blow against Trump's sanctuary city order". CNN. from the original on November 22, 2017. Retrieved November 24, 2017.
38. "Orange County Joins Fight On California Sanctuary Law". CBS SF Bay Area. 2018-03-27.
39. "Federal Court Says Trump Administration Can't Deny Funds To Sanctuary Cities". NPR.org. Retrieved 2017-11-21.
40. "Federal judge denies Trump administration effort to block California's 'sanctuary' law". Los Angeles Times. 5 July 2018.
41. "Trump administration get rare win against sanctuary cities". The New York Times. 13 July 2019.
42. Johnson, Dawn Marie (2001). "Legislative Reform: The AEDPA and the IIRIRA: Treating Misdemeanors as Felonies for Immigration Purposes". Journal of Legislation. 27: 477.
43. Brownstein, Ron (August 22, 2007). "'Sanctuary' as battleground". Los Angeles Times. from the original on January 12, 2012.
44. "Sanctuary Cities - Document - Gale In Context: Opposing Viewpoints". go.gale.com. Retrieved 2021-10-26.
45. IIRIRA 287(g)
46. Katie Zezima, Massachusetts Set for Its Officers to Enforce Immigration Law The New York Times, December 13, 2006
47. . PBS. June 20, 2007. Archived from the original on November 14, 2012. Retrieved September 11, 2017.
48. Moscoso, Eunice (September 18, 2007). . Austin American-Statesman. Archived from the original on December 6, 2007. Retrieved September 22, 2007.
49. Hudson, Audrey (September 6, 2007). "Chertoff warns meddling 'sanctuary cities'". The Washington Times. Retrieved May 26, 2011.
50. "Holding the Department of Homeland Security Responsible for Security Gaps". US House of Representatives. September 5, 2007. Retrieved May 26, 2011.
51. "Executive Order: Enhancing Public Safety in the Interior of the United States". whitehouse.gov. Retrieved January 25, 2017 – via National Archives.,
52. "Why Trump's executive order on sanctuary cities is unconstitutional". Washington Post. Retrieved 2017-01-27.
53. Levin, Sam (April 25, 2017). "Trump's order to restrict 'sanctuary cities' funding blocked by federal judge". The Guardian. Retrieved April 25, 2017.
54. Egelko, Bob (April 25, 2017). "Judge says Trump can't punish cities over sanctuary city policies". San Francisco Chronicle. Retrieved April 25, 2017.
55. Visser, Nick (November 21, 2017). "Judge Permanently Blocks Trump's Executive Order On Sanctuary Cities". Huffington Post. from the original on November 24, 2017. Retrieved November 24, 2017.
56. County of Santa Clara v. Trump (17-cv-00485-WHO), p. 28 (N.D. Cal. November 20, 2017).Text
57. Thanawala, S. (2018, December 05). US law against encouraging illegal immigration struck down. Retrieved March 02, 2019, from https://www.apnews.com/344dab0d2df44a6f995f2773ed61f636
58. United States v. Sineneng-Smith (United States Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit December 4, 2018) (http://cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/opinions/2018/12/04/15-10614.pdf, Dist. file).
59. Title 8 Aliens and Nationality, U.S. Code § 1324. Bringing in and harboring certain aliens (1907).
60. Booth, Daniel. "FEDERALISM ON ICE: STATE AND LOCAL ENFORCEMENT OF FEDERAL IMMIGRATION LAW". Harvard Journal of Law & Public Policy. 29: 1068.
61. Riverstone-Newell, Lori (2013). "The Diffusion of Local Bill of Rights Resolutions to the States". State and Local Government Review. 45 (1): 14–24. doi:10.1177/0160323X12473123. JSTOR 42002358. S2CID 156585121.
62. Fandl, Kevin. "Putting States Out of the Immigration Law Enforcement Business". Harvard Law & Policy Review. 9: 531.
63. Sanctuary Cities: The Politics of Refuge. Oxford, New York: Oxford University Press. 2019-10-23. ISBN 9780190937027.
64. Otsu, Yuki (2019-09-23). "Sanctuary City and Crime". Rochester, NY. SSRN 3453413. {{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires |journal= (help)
65. Martínez-Schuldt, Ricardo D.; Martínez, Daniel E. (2019). "Sanctuary Policies and City-Level Incidents of Violence, 1990 to 2010". Justice Quarterly. 36 (4): 567–593. doi:10.1080/07418825.2017.1400577. ISSN 0741-8825. S2CID 53056328.
66. Gonzalez, Benjamin; Collingwood, Loren; El-Khatib, Stephen Omar (2019). "The Politics of Refuge: Sanctuary Cities, Crime, and Undocumented Immigration". Urban Affairs Review. 55: 3–40. doi:10.1177/1078087417704974. ISSN 1078-0874. S2CID 32604699.
67. Shultz, David (2020-02-15). "Crime did not surge when California became a 'sanctuary state'". AAAS. Retrieved 2020-02-25.
68. Otsu, Yuki (2019-10-24). "Sanctuary City and Crime". Rochester, NY. SSRN 3453413. {{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires |journal= (help)
69. "Is Philly's sanctuary city status putting residents in danger?". @politifact. Retrieved 2017-04-23.
70. "No Evidence Sanctuary Cities 'Breed Crime' - FactCheck.org". FactCheck.org. 2017-02-10. Retrieved 2017-04-23.
71. "Trump's claim that sanctuary cities 'breed crime'". Washington Post. Retrieved 2017-04-23.
72. "Analysis | Jeff Sessions used our research to claim that sanctuary cities have more crime. He's wrong". Washington Post. Retrieved 2017-07-14.
73. "Academics push back against attorney general's misrepresentation of their study". Retrieved 2017-07-17.
74. "Crime and Poverty Are Lower in Sanctuary Cities". CityLab. Retrieved 2017-02-06.
75. Kubrin, Charis E.; Bartos, Bradley J. (2020). "Sanctuary Status and Crime in California: What's the Connection?". Justice Evaluation Journal. 3 (2): 115–133. doi:10.1080/24751979.2020.1745662. ISSN 2475-1979.
76. Martínez-Schuldt, Ricardo D.; Martínez, Daniel E. (2021-01-11). "Immigrant Sanctuary Policies and Crime-Reporting Behavior: A Multilevel Analysis of Reports of Crime Victimization to Law Enforcement, 1980 to 2004". American Sociological Review. 86: 154–185. doi:10.1177/0003122420978406. ISSN 0003-1224. S2CID 231681112.
77. Kobach, Kris W. (April 2008). "Attrition Through Enforcement: A Rational Approach to Illegal Immigration". Tulsa Journal of Comparative & International Law. 15: 155–163.
78. Nair-Reichert, U. (2015). "Location decisions of undocumented migrants in the United States". Journal of Regional Analysis and Policy. 44 (2): 157–165.
79. Cebula, Richard J. (July 28, 2015). "Give me sanctuary! The impact of personal freedom afforded by sanctuary cities on the 2010 undocumented immigrant settlement pattern with the U.S., 2SLS estimates". Journal of Economics and Finance. 40 (4): 792–802. doi:10.1007/s12197-015-9333-7. S2CID 153098472.
80. Rhodes, Scott D.; Mann, Lilli; Simán, Florence; et al. (2015). "The Impact of Local Immigration Enforcement Policies on the Health of Immigrant Hispanics/Latinos in the United States". American Journal of Public Health. 105 (2): 329–337. doi:10.2105/ajph.2014.302218. PMC 4318326. PMID 25521886.
81. Shoichet, Catherine E. (9 May 2019). "Florida is about to ban sanctuary cities. At least 11 other states have, too". CNN. Retrieved 2019-06-10.
82. Braun, Melissa (November 30, 2011). . The Southeast Sun. Archived from the original on February 28, 2021. Retrieved February 24, 2012.
83. Watkins, Mia (31 January 2017). "Birmingham City Council passes sanctuary city resolution". Retrieved 20 March 2017.
84. Tim Steller, Tucson a 'sanctuary city'? Not so fast, Arizona Daily Star (February 23, 2016).
85. "Tucson, Arizona, Proposition 205, Sanctuary City Initiative (November 2019)". Ballotpedia. Retrieved 2021-07-08.
86. . tucson.com. 2020-01-03. Archived from the original on 2020-01-03. Retrieved 2021-07-08.
87. . azfamily.com. 2019-07-24. Archived from the original on 2019-07-24. Retrieved 2021-07-08.
88. Kozachik, Steve. "Vote No on Prop 205". Tucson Weekly. Retrieved 2021-07-08.
89. "California Governor Signs 'Sanctuary State' Bill" NPR. Retrieved October 5, 2017; "In a Trump-defying move, California's Senate passes sanctuary state bill" CNN.com. Retrieved July 2, 2017
90. Cindy Carcamo, Kate Mather & Dakota Smith, Trump's crackdown on illegal immigration leaves a lot unanswered for sanctuary cities like L.A., Los Angeles Times (November 15, 2016).
91. "Berkeley Is The Original Sanctuary City" East Bay Express, February 14, 2017. Retrieved March 23, 2017
92. Mancina, Peter (2016). In the Spirit of Sanctuary: Sanctuary City Policy Advocacy and the Production of Sanctuary-Power in San Francisco, California (PDF). Nashville: Vanderbilt University Electronic Theses and Dissertations.
93. Mancina, Peter (2012). "The Birth of a Sanctuary City: A History of Governmental Sanctuary in San Francisco". In Lippert, Randy; Rehaag, Sean (eds.). Sanctuary Practices in International Perspectives: Migration, Citizenship, and Social Movements. New York: Routledge. pp. 205–18. ISBN 978-0-415-67346-4.
94. ""Sanctuary Cities," Trust Acts, and Community Policing Explained". American Immigration Council. 2016-07-18. Retrieved 2016-10-28.
95. "Sanctuary Cities, USA". Ohio Jobs & Justice Political Action Committee. Salvi Communications.
96. . Human Events. Archived from the original on 17 February 2012. Retrieved 21 July 2015.
97. Barkas, Sherry (August 23, 2017). "Trump vowed to tighten funding for jurisdictions with sanctuary status. Here's why Coachella isn't concerned". The Desert Sun. Retrieved 2019-04-18.
98. Vega, Priscella (September 28, 2018). "California 'sanctuary' law doesn't apply to charter cities, judge rules in Huntington Beach case". Los Angeles Times. Retrieved 28 September 2018.
99. Kate Mather & Cindy Chang, LAPD will not help deport immigrants under Trump, chief says, Los Angeles Times (November 14, 2016).
100. Buchanan, Wyatt (14 November 2007). "S.F. supervisors approve ID cards for residents". San Francisco Chronicle. Retrieved 17 April 2019.
101. Pearson, Michael (July 8, 2015). "What's a sanctuary city, and why should you care?". CNN. Retrieved 26 February 2017.
102. Schmalz, David. "Seaside becomes the Monterey Peninsula's first sanctuary city". MontereyCountyWeekly.com. Retrieved October 19, 2017.
103. "Maps: Sanctuary Cities, Counties, and States". 22 March 2021.
104. "Protect Colorado Residents From Federal Government Overreach". leg.colorado.gov. Retrieved 2019-05-30.
105. "Boulder City Council Approves Sanctuary City Status". CBS Denver. 4 January 2017. Retrieved 5 January 2017.
106. Jon Murray (January 30, 2017). "Mayor Hancock says he welcomes "sanctuary city" title if it means Denver supports immigrants and refugees". The Denver Post.
107. "Understanding Immigration Enforcement And The Role Of The Estes Park Police"^{[dead link]}. Directed from: Town of Estes Park news, April 21, 2017. Retrieved July 19, 2017.
108. "Connecticut could be in crosshairs of Trump's sanctuary city crackdown". 2016-11-28. Retrieved 20 March 2017.
109. "Hartford Municipal Code". www.municode.com. Retrieved 2017-03-20.
110. "Mayor declares Middletown a sanctuary city". wtnh.com. 3 February 2017. Retrieved 20 March 2017.
111. Koh, Elizabeth (June 14, 2019). "Gov. DeSantis signs 'sanctuary cities' ban into law. There aren't any in Florida". Miami Herald. Retrieved June 14, 2019.
112. "Florida's largest county to comply with Trump's sanctuary crackdown", Ray Sanchez, CNN, 27 January 2017.
113. "Mayor declares St. Petersburg a sanctuary city" Bay News 9, February 04, 2017. Retrieved February 4, 2017.
114. "Shelter in the Sunshine City" Rick Kriseman blog. Retrieved February 4, 2017.
115. "Advocates say Florida governor's 'sanctuary bill' politically motivated". NBC News.
116. "Florida's DeSantis signs controversial sanctuary cities ban into law". Fox News. 14 June 2019.
117. . Miami Herald. Archived from the original on 2019-06-15.
118. "Florida becomes 12th state to ban sanctuary cities".
119. Jeremy Redmon, Are there Sanctuary Cities in Georgia?, Atlanta Journal-Constitution (February 2, 2017).
120. "As Trump enacts ban on refugees, Atlanta doubles down as a 'welcoming city' – SaportaReport". 30 January 2017. Retrieved 20 March 2017.
121. Bernal, Rafael (August 28, 2017). "Illinois Governor Signs Immigration, Automatic Voter Registration Measures". The Hill. Retrieved September 9, 2017.
122. Geiger, Kim (August 28, 2017). "Rauner Signs Immigration, Automatic Voter Registration Bills Into Law". Chicago Tribune. Retrieved September 9, 2017.
123. Runge, Erik (August 28, 2017). "Gov. Rauner Signs Controversial Immigration Bill". WGN-TV. Associated Press. Retrieved September 9, 2017.
124. Tareen, Sophia (August 28, 2017). "Governor Signs Law Limiting Illinois Police on Immigration". ABC News (from the Associated Press). Retrieved September 9, 2017.
125. Sfondeles, Tina (August 22, 2017). "Right Suggests Rauner Immigration Bill Backing 'Beginning of End'". Chicago Sun-Times. Retrieved September 9, 2017.
126. Singman, Brooke (August 28, 2017). "GOP Gov. Rauner Accused of Making Illinois a 'Sanctuary State' with New Law". Fox News. Retrieved September 9, 2017.
127. Schoenburg, Bernard (September 4, 2017). "Some In GOP Upset with Rauner Over Immigration Bill". The State Journal-Register. Retrieved September 9, 2017.
128. Gunderson, Erica. "Welcome to Chicago: Exploring What It Means to Be a Sanctuary City". wttw.com. WTTW. Retrieved 15 January 2023.
129. Chicago code Welcoming City Ordinance Chapter 2-173, chicagocode.org (January 25, 2017).
130. Welcoming City Ordinance Chapter 2-173 Welcoming City Ordinance, City of Chicago (January 25, 2017).
131. City of Chicago Sanctuary City Supportive Resources 2018-10-26 at the Wayback Machine, City of Chicago | Office of New Americans (January 25, 2017).
132. Mayor's Press Office, Mayor Emanuel Reiterates Chicago's Status as Sanctuary City 2018-08-10 at the Wayback Machine, City of Chicago (November 13, 2016).
133. Richard Gonzales, Mayor Rahm Emanuel: 'Chicago Always Will Be A Sanctuary City' NPR (November 14, 2016).
134. Jeff Bossert, Sanctuary City Measure Passes Urbana Council On 5–1 Vote WILL Illinois public media news (December 20, 2016).
135. Bookwalter, Genevieve. "Evanston strengthens sanctuary city ordinance". chicagotribune.com. Retrieved 2017-02-09.
136. Motter, Sarah (11 April 2022). "Governor signs bill to ban sanctuary cities in Kansas". www.kwch.com. Retrieved 2022-08-01.
137. Robert McClendon, 'Sanctuary city' policy puts an end to NOPD's immigration enforcement, NOLA.com | The Times-Picayune (March 01, 2016).
138. "DOJ: No evidence N.O. is a sanctuary city". Fox 8. 18 November 2017. Retrieved 22 July 2019.
139. Despite LePage's remark, the 'sanctuary city' label doesn’t fit Portland, officials say, Randy Billings, September 15, 2015, Portland Press Herald
140. Laura Schwartzman, Legislation would ban Takoma Park sanctuary policies 2017-01-29 at the Wayback Machine, Capital News Service (March 19, 2008).
141. John Fritze, House passes 'sanctuary city' bill, reigniting immigration debate, Baltimore Sun (July 23, 2016).
142. Yvonne Wenger, Mayor: Baltimore is a 'welcoming city' for immigrants and refugees 2017-11-20 at the Wayback Machine, Baltimore Sun (November 16, 2016).
143. Stern, Mark Joseph (2017-07-25). "How Massachusetts Became a Sanctuary State". Slate Magazine. Retrieved 2022-08-01.
144. {{{first}}} {{{last}}}, Recent Case: Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court Holds that Local Law Enforcement Lacks Authority to Detain Pursuant to ICE Detainers, 131 Harv. L. Rev. 666 (2017).
145. Lunn v. Commonwealth, 78 N.E.3d 1143 (Mass. 2017).
146. Kyle Scott Clauss, Boston Already Has Some Sanctuary City Protections: Thanks to the 2014 Trust Act, police can’t detain someone based on their immigration status 2017-07-08 at the Wayback Machine, Boston Magazine (November 15, 2016).
147. "Cops increasingly denying requests to hold illegals". 2017-01-10. Retrieved 20 March 2017.
148. Jonathan Oosting, Push to ban 'sanctuary cities' in Michigan faces criticism from immigrant advocates, MLive (September 30, 2015).
149. Lauren Gibbons, "Lansing no longer a sanctuary city"., MLive (April 12, 2017)
150. Ibrahim Hirsi, What the conflict over 'sanctuary cities'could mean for the Twin Cities, Minn Post (November 23, 2016).
151. Mike Mullen, Betsy Hodges: Minneapolis will remain a 'sanctuary city,' despite Trump threats, City Pages (November 14, 2016).
152. "Montana governor signs bill banning sanctuary cities". April 2021.
153. "Gov. Gianforte Signs 'Sanctuary City' Ban". April 2021.
154. "Gianforte signs bill banning sanctuary cities in Montana". Sioux City Journal. Associated Press. March 31, 2021.
155. "Error" (PDF).
156. "Las Vegas Metro implements sanctuary policy". 17 February 2019.
157. Whitford, Emma (2017-02-07). "NY Assembly Passes 'Sanctuary State' Legislation". Gothamist. Retrieved 2022-08-01.
158. "The Justice Department is stepping up pressure on ‘sanctuary cities.’ Here’s how mayors are responding" PBS Newshour, January 24, 2018. Retrieved January 24, 2018.
159. Weinstein, Matt (February 1, 2017). "Sanctuary City: Ithaca council approves resolution". Ithaca Journal.
160. City Policy Concerning Aliens (PDF), 1989 – via Nyc.gov
161. Sparks, Leonard (March 13, 2017). "Newburgh Council approves 'sanctuary city' immigration policy". recordonline.com. Retrieved April 18, 2019.
162. Goodman, James (20 January 2017). "Mayor Warren to update Rochester's sanctuary city resolution". Rochester Democrat and Chronicle.
163. "In final State of the City speech, Miner declares Syracuse a sanctuary city". WRVO Public Media. 13 January 2017. Retrieved 13 January 2017.
164. Chinchilla, Rudy. "New Jersey to Restrict How Local Law Enforcement Works With ICE". NBC10 Philadelphia. Retrieved 2022-08-01.
165. "What towns in New Jersey are considered sanctuary cities?". New Jersey 101.5 – New Jersey News Radio. Retrieved October 19, 2017.
166. Terrence T. McDonald, The Jersey Journal, November 23, 2016, (via) nj.com, Jersey City will protect immigrants from 'hate and prejudice,' councilman says, Retrieved November 24, 2016
167. Terrence T. McDonald, The Jersey Journal, NJ.com, February 2, 2017, Fulop says he will sign order making Jersey City a true 'sanctuary city', Retrieved February 4, 2017
168. Eric Kiefer, NJ Patch, January 20, 2017, (via) patch.com, Maplewood 1st N.J. Town To Offer Immigrants ‘Sanctuary’ In 2017, Retrieved January 20, 2017
169. Mazzola, Jessica (29 January 2017). "Why these 5 N.J. 'sanctuary' communities could be targeted by Trump". NJ.com. Retrieved 28 March 2017.
170. "Newark mayor signs sweeping sanctuary city executive order". NJ.com. June 2017. Retrieved October 19, 2017.
171. Vereau, Gery. . voicesofny.org. Archived from the original on 16 April 2019. Retrieved 28 March 2017.
172. "Prospect Park Mayor Mohamed Khairullah Wins Kudos for Sanctuary City Exec Order". Observer.com. 6 February 2017. Retrieved October 19, 2017.
173. "Union City becomes a sanctuary city Commissioners vote for designation – Union City has become the second municipality in Hudson County (after Jersey City) to designate itself a sanctuary city in the wake of Donald Trump's executive order pressuri..."
174. "Hoboken Declared 'Fair And Welcoming City' To Support Immigrants". Hoboken, NJ Patch. 2018-01-02. Retrieved 2018-06-21.
175. Bhalla, Ravi (1 January 2018). (PDF). HobokenNJ.gov. Archived from the original (PDF) on 2018-06-21. Retrieved 21 June 2018.
176. Garcia, Uriel J. "Judge: San Juan County cannot honor 'ICE detainers'". Santa Fe New Mexican. Retrieved 2022-08-01.
177. "NC House bill would penalize immigration sanctuary cities". newsobserver. Retrieved 2017-03-25.
178. "N.C. House Committee Advances Anti-Immigrant Measure". American Civil Liberties Union. Retrieved 2017-03-25.
179. https://www.ncleg.gov/BillLookup/2023/H63
180. Allard, Sam (February 10, 2017). "Actually, Cleveland Has Been a "Sanctuary City" Since 1987 According to a City Council Resolution". Cleveland Scene. Retrieved December 29, 2020.
181. "Cincinnati now a 'sanctuary city.' What's that mean?". Cincinnati.com. Retrieved 2017-01-31.
182. Kelley, Jeremy P. "State reps want ban on 'sanctuary' schools and cities for immigration". dayton-daily-news.
183. "Ohio GOP lawmakers want to ban 'sanctuary' cities and school districts".
184. "Bevin announces bill to outlaw, define sanctuary cities in Kentucky". 12 July 2019.
185. "GOP lawmakers, Gov. Bevin throw support behind 'sanctuary city' ban legislation". 12 July 2019.
186. "Michigan House Bills propose elimination of sanctuary cities". 22 April 2019.
187. "State lawmakers consider ban on sanctuary cities in Michigan". 10 April 2019.
188. "Our Opinion: 'Sanctuary' cities not controversial in Oregon history". Retrieved 20 March 2017.
189. Wilson, Conrad (December 6, 2016). "Potential Oregon Ballot Measure Targets 'Sanctuary' Immigration Law". Oregon Public Broadcasting.
190. "Beaverton becomes sanctuary city". Retrieved 20 March 2017.
191. Wilson, Conrad (December 13, 2016). "Corvallis Declares Itself Sanctuary City". Oregon Public Broadcasting.
192. . Archived from the original on 24 November 2017. Retrieved 20 March 2017.
193. Copeland, Rich (2017-03-09). . www.Witf.org. Archived from the original on 2019-08-05. Retrieved 2018-04-25.
194. "Sanctuary City Map". Center for Immigration Studies. 22 March 2021.
195. Terruso, Julia. "Kenney: Philadelphia stays a 'sanctuary city' despite Trump". The Inquirer.
196. Zapotosky, Matt (2018-01-24). "Justice Department threatens to subpoena records in escalating battle with 'sanctuary' jurisdictions". Washington Post. ISSN 0190-8286. Retrieved 2018-04-18.
197. "Rhode Island will require warrant for detainers". WJAR. Associated Press. 2014-07-17. Retrieved 2022-08-01.
198. Ariana Maia Sawyer, Lawmaker introduces Tennessee 'sanctuary city' ban, USA Today Network (February 8, 2017).
199. "Nashville mayor calls for scrapping anti-sanctuary state law". The Associated Press. 2019-09-03. Retrieved 2020-09-18.
200. "Mayor John Cooper overturns Briley's immigration executive order, creates task force". The Tennessean.
201. Jorge, Kaylin (2019-09-13). "Mayor-elect John Cooper: Nashville cannot and will not be a 'Sanctuary City'". WZTV. Retrieved 2020-09-18.
202. Doyin Oyeniyi, Does Texas Have Any Sanctuary Cities?, Texas Monthly (February 11, 2016).
203. "Texas Gov. Abbott Cuts Funding to Austin Over Sanctuary City Policies". Fox News. February 2, 2017. Retrieved February 2, 2017.
204. Svitek, Patrick (February 2, 2017). "In "Sanctuary" Fight, Abbott Cuts Off Funding to Travis County". The Texas Tribune. Retrieved February 2, 2017.
205. "Texas Governor Signs Bill Targeting Sanctuary Cities". Fox News. May 7, 2017. Retrieved May 7, 2017.
206. Carter, Brandon (May 7, 2017). "Texas Governor Signs Law Banning Sanctuary Cities". The Hill. Retrieved May 7, 2017.
207. {{{first}}} {{{last}}}, Recent Case: Fifth Circuit Reverses Injunction of Texas’s Sanctuary Cities Bill, 132 Harv. L. Rev. 1738 (2019).
208. City of El Cenizo v. Texas, 890 F.3d 164 (5th Cir. 2018).
209. Goswami, Neal P. "Scott signs Vt. law defying Trump". Rutland Herald. Retrieved 2022-08-01.
210. Johnson, Mark (2017-03-28). "Scott signs bill 'not ... establishing a sanctuary state'". VTDigger. Retrieved 2022-08-01.
211. Aloe, Jess. "Vermont cities wrestle with sanctuary state rules". Burlington Free Press. Retrieved 2022-08-01.
212. James, Tom (2019-05-23). "Washington joins West Coast bloc of sanctuary states". The Associated Press. Retrieved 2019-06-06.
213. "Seattle will remain sanctuary city for immigrants despite Trump presidency, mayor says". Seattle Times. November 9, 2016. Retrieved January 23, 2017.
214. "Mayor Bowser Issues Statement Reaffirming that DC is a Sanctuary City". mayor.dc.gov. Retrieved 2022-08-01.
215. Keung, Nicholas (February 22, 2013). "Toronto declared 'sanctuary city' to non-status migrants". Toronto Star. Retrieved February 13, 2017.
216. Van Dongen, Matthew (February 12, 2014). "Hamilton to become 'sanctuary city' for newcomers who fear deportation". The Hamilton Spectator.
217. Maloney, Patrick (January 31, 2017). "London, Ont. unanimously backs call to declare itself a sanctuary city against Trump". National Post. Postmedia News. Retrieved February 13, 2017.
218. Shingler, Benjamin (February 20, 2017). "Montreal becomes 'sanctuary city' after unanimous vote". CBC News. CBC. Retrieved February 13, 2017.
219. Fisher, Gavin (April 7, 2016). "Vancouver approves 'Access Without Fear' policy for undocumented immigrants". CBC News. Retrieved February 13, 2017.
220. Lindsay, Bethany; Eagland, Nick (February 11, 2017). "Fearing U.S. crackdown, refugees run to B.C." Times Colonist. Victoria, BC. Retrieved February 13, 2017.
221. Pike, Helen (February 28, 2017). . Metro Calgary. Archived from the original on March 19, 2018. Retrieved March 30, 2017.
222. "John Darling, Craig Barnett, Sarah Eldridge "City of Sanctuary – a UK initiative for hospitality", Forced Migration Review, 9 October 2016" (PDF). FMReview.org. Retrieved 20 October 2017.
223. "About City of Sanctuary". 5 January 2017. Retrieved 20 March 2017.
224. https://www.javanonline.ir/fa/news/980047/%D8%A7%D9%86%D8%B9%DA%A9%D8%A7%D8%B3-%D8%A2%D8%B2%D9%85%D9%88%D9%86-%D9%88-%D8%AE%D8%B7%D8%A7%E2%80%8C%D9%87%D8%A7%DB%8C-%DA%AF%D8%B0%D8%B4%D8%AA%D9%87-%D8%AF%D8%B1-%D9%84%D8%A7%DB%8C%D8%AD%D9%87-%D8%AA%D8%B4%DA%A9%DB%8C%D9%84-%D8%B3%D8%A7%D8%B2%D9%85%D8%A7%D9%86-%D9%85%D9%84%DB%8C-%D9%85%D9%87%D8%A7%D8%AC%D8%B1%D8%AA
225. "مجلس انقلابی "سازمان ملی مهاجرت" راه اندازی می کند+متن لایحه". دیدبان ایران. August 1, 2023.

Further reading

• Laura Lopez-Sanders (2014). "Local governments and immigration". In James Ciment; John Radzilowski (eds.). American Immigration: An Encyclopedia (2nd ed.). M. E. Sharpe. ISBN 9780765682130.
• American Immigration Council: “Sanctuary” Policies: An Overview