Kalabhra dynasty

The Kalabhra dynasty, also called Kaḷabrar, Kaḷappirar, Kallupura or Kalvar,^[4] were rulers of all or parts of Tamil region sometime between the 3rd century and 6th century CE, after the ancient dynasties of the early Cholas, the early Pandyas and Chera. Information about the origin and reign of the Kalabhras is uncertain and scarce.^[5] It is believed by historians that the Kalabhras belonged to the Vellalar community of warriors who were possibly once the feudatories of the Cholas and the Pallavas.^[6] Their proposed roots vary from southeast region of modern Karnataka, Kalappalars of Vellalar community, to Kalavar chieftains.^[5][7][8] This age is generally called "The Augustan age of Tamil Literature", in a 1922 book by the name "Studies in South Indian Jainism" written by M. S. Ramaswami Ayyangar and B. Seshagiri Rao. The Kalabhra era is sometimes referred to as the "dark period" of Tamil history, and information about it is generally inferred from any mentions in the literature and inscriptions that are dated many centuries after their era ended.^[9]

Kalabhra Kingdom
3rd century–6th century
Kalabhra conquered parts or all of ancient Tamilakam
Capital	Kaveripumpattinam, Madurai
Common languages	Prakrit,^[1] Tamil,^[2] Kannada ^[3]
Religion	Buddhism Jainism Hinduism
Government	Monarchy
History
• Established	3rd century
• Disestablished	6th century
Preceded by Succeeded by Three Crowned Kings Ancient Tamil country Pallava dynasty Pandyan dynasty

Historian Upinder Singh states that Shivaskandavarman rise in the 4th century, as evidenced by inscriptions, show Kalabhras were not in power at that time near rivers Penner and Vellar (close to Kaveri). The Kalabhras dynasty had ended for certain by the last quarter of 6th century when Pallava Simhavishnu consolidated his rule up to the Kaveri river, south of which the Pandyas led by Kadungon consolidated their power.^[10] Cholas became subordinates of Pallavas and they were already ruling Telugu region of Rayalaseema.

Identification

The origin and identity of the Kalabhras is uncertain. One theory states that they were probably hill tribes that rose out of obscurity to become a power in South India.^[11] Historical documents of the Vettuva Gounder community show that the Piramalai Kallars,^[12] who were a formerly a criminal tribe of Tamil Nadu were the Kalabhras.^[13] of the Other theories state that they were Karnatas probably from north of Tamil-speaking region (modern southeast Karnataka),^[7][8] or on etymological grounds may have been the Kalappalars of Vellala community or the Kalavar chieftains.^[5]

According to Kulke and Rothermund, "nothing is known about the origins or tribal affiliations" of the Kalabhras, and their rule is called the "Kalabhra Interregnum".^[14] They are reviled in texts written centuries later, particularly by Tamil Hindu scholars.^[11] This has led to the inference that the Kalabhra rulers may have ended grants to Hindu temples and persecuted the Brahmins, and supported Buddhism and Jainism during their rule.^[11][14] However, the textual support for these conjectures is unclear. In support of their possible Jaina patronage, is the 10th-century Jain text on grammar which quotes a poem that some scholars attribute to Acchuta Vikkanta, a Kalabhra king.^[14] A non-Tamil language Buddhist text Vinayaviniccaya by Buddhadatta was composed in the 5th-century Tamil region. According to Shu Hikosaka, Buddhadatta in this Pali language text mentions "Putamarikalam in the Chola country".^[15] According to Karl Potter in Encyclopedia of Indian Philosophies: Buddhist philosophy from 360 to 650 AD, multiple scholars place the 5th-century Buddhadatta in the Chola kingdom near Kaveri river.^[16] According to Arunachalam, the Pali manuscripts of this text includes the name Acutavikkante Kalambakulanandane and therefore he states Acutavikkante must have been a Kalabhra king.^[17] However, the oldest surviving Vinayaviniccaya manuscript in Pali does not have that name, it has Kalabbha. This could be Kalabhra.^[18]

 

South-Asia
400-450 CE

KALABHRAS

WESTERN
GANGAS

SASANIAN
HIND

TRAITAKUTAS

VAKATAKAS

KADAMBAS

SAMATATAS

VARMANS

ALCHON HUNS

HEPHTHALITES

SASANIAN
EMPIRE

 

Location of the Kalabhras and neighbouring polities circa 400-450 CE.^[19]

Buddhadatta in his manuals (in the Nigamanagātha of Vinayavinicchaya, verse 3179) identifies his patron as follows:^[20]

Accut' Accutavikkante Kalambakulanandane mahin samanusāsante āraddho ca samāpito.

In the time of the immortal Accutavikkante, the pride of the Kalamba family this work was accomplished.

and once again the tika (colophon) adds:^[21][22]

Kalambhakulavamsa jāte Accutavikkamanāme Colarājini Colarattham samanusāsante ayam vinicchayo mayā āraddho ceva samāpito cāti

This work Vinicchaya was accomplised, when the king of Cholas, Accutavikkaman, born in the lineage of the Kalamba family was ruling the earth.

Amritasagara, a Jain poet of the 10th century CE and the author of the works Yapparungalam and Yapparungalakkarikai, has also written a few verses about Achyuta Vikranta.^[23][24]

A few verses of the Tamil Navalar Caritai, a later work, is sometimes identified as glorifying Accuta Vikranta. It describes the three kings Chera, Chola and Pandya paying obeisance to king Accuta when they were taken captive.^[25][26]

According to Burton Stein, the Kalabhra interregnum may represent a strong bid by non-peasant (tribal) warriors for power over the fertile plains of Tamil region with support from the heterodox Indian religious tradition (Buddhism and Jainism).^[27] This may have led to persecution of the peasants and urban elites of the Brahmanical religious traditions (Hinduism), who then worked to remove the Kalabhras and retaliated against their persecutors after returning to power.^[27] In contrast, R.S. Sharma states the opposite theory and considers "Kalabhras as an example for peasant revolt to the state" – with tribal elements, albeit around the 6th century.^[28][29] All these theories are hampered by the fact that there is a "profound lack of evidence for the events or nature of Kalabhra rule", states Rebecca Darley.^[28] A few consider the Kalabhras to be a militant branch of the Jainas who were opposed to the Historical Vedic religion and this resulted in their vilification in later times.^[30]

In epigraphs

Pulankurichi inscription

The earliest Kalabhra inscription available is the Pulankurichi (Tamil Nadu) epigraph of king Chēndan Kurran (Kootran) dated to 270 CE. It is also one of the earliest inscriptions in Tamil and extends to over 15 metres in length. It refers to the administrative divisions of the kingdom and also to Vedic sacrifices and temples. Scholar Kamil Zvelebil indicates that the language of the inscription is almost identical to classical Tamil similar to the one used in the Tolkappiyam and Sangam texts.^[2]

8th-century Velvikudi grant inscription

A much-cited and discussed epigraphical evidence for the existence of Kalabhras is the 155-lines-long 8th-century Velvikudi grant copper plate inscription of Nedunjadaiyan.^[31] It was created at least 200 years after the end of the Kalabhras. It opens with an invocation to Shiva and many lines in Sanskrit written in Grantha script, followed by Tamil written in Vatteluttu script. Loaded with myth and exaggerated legends, the inscription has the following few lines about a Kalabhra king and his relatively quick end by Pandya king Kadungon (lines 39–40, translated by H. Krishna Sastri):^[31]

 

8th Century Velvikudi grant that mentions Kalabhras.

L 39: Then a Kali king named Kalabhran took possession of the extensive earth driving away numberless great kings (adhiraja) and resumed the (village mentioned Velvikudi) above.
L 40: After that, like the sun rising from the expansive ocean, the Pandyadhiraja named Kadungon, the lord of the South of sharp javelin who wore (the cloak of) dignity and was the leader of an army, sprang forth, occupied (the throne), spreading around him the brilliant splendour of (his) expanding rays (prowess), destroyed the kings of the extensive earth surrounded by the sea together with (their) strongholds and (their) fame, wielded the sceptre of justice and removed by his strength the evil destiny of the goddess of the earth whose splendour deserved to be under the shade of (his) white umbrella, by terminating by his strength the possession of her under others and establishing her in his own possession in the approved manner and destroyed the shining cities of kings who would not submit to him.

— Velvikudi grant inscription^[31]

The inscription then recites the generations of Pandya and Chola kings who followed the victorious Kadungon, and finally to king Nedunjadaiyan who ruled in the year of the inscription (c. 770 CE). The copper plate records that a Brahmin complainant said that the land grant which was given to his ancestors before Kalabhras "ignobly seized it" has not been returned so far after numerous generations (lines 103–118).^[31] The king sought evidence of past ownership, which he was provided, and thereafter the king restored the grant to the complainant.^[31] The inscription ends in Sanskrit with verses from Vaishnavism and Shaivism traditions of Hinduism, followed by the engraver's colophon.^[31] This inscription has been assumed to be an accurate historical record by some scholars, interpreted to affirm that Kalabhras existed for some period, they conquered some or all parts of the Pandyan kingdom, they seized lands belonging to Brahmin(s) and were defeated by the Pandyas (Pāṇṭiya).^[32] Some scholars dismiss the Kalabhra interregnum as for all practical purposes "a myth".^[32]

The passing mention of Kalabhras in some records have led to a number of theories for the identity of the Kalabhras. T. A. Gopinath Rao equates them with the Mutharaiyars and an inscription in the Vaikunta Perumal temple at Kanchi mentions a Mutharaiyar named as Kalavara-Kalvan. M. Raghava Iyengar, on the other hand, identifies the Kalabhras with the Vellala Kalappalars.^[33] Based on the Velvikudi plates inscription above, R. Narasimhacharya and V. Venkayya believe them to have been Karnatas.^[34][35] K. R. Venkatarama Iyer suggests that the Kalabhras might have emerged from the Bangalore-Chittoor region early in the 5th century.^[33]

Numismatics

A study of unearthed coins of that era show on the two sides of each coin, a range of Brahmi inscriptions in Prakrit language and images. Typically the coins show tiger, elephant, horse and fish icons. In "rare specimens", states Gupta, one finds an image of a seated Jain muni (monk) or the Buddhist Manjushri, or a short sword or the Swastika symbol. Other coins of this era have images of Hindu gods and goddesses with inscriptions in Tamil or Prakrit. According to Gupta, these use of Prakrit language on the coins may reflect the non-Tamil origins of Kalabhra.^[33] Other scholars are skeptical of the coin's dating and interpretation, the origins of the coins and the impact of trade, and the rareness of Jain and Buddhist iconography.^[36][37]

According to Timothy Power – a scholar of Middle East and Mediterranean archaeology and history, coins and texts attest to an on-going trade between the Mediterranean, Middle East and South Indian ports such as Muziris until the 5th century, but then suddenly there is no mention of Indian ports in the Mediterranean texts around mid-6th century.^[38] This "dark age" may be related to the conquest of Kalabhras over Tamilakam in the 6th century. This period of violence and the closure of trading ports probably lasted about 75 years, around the first half of the 6th century.^[38]

Religion and literature

The religious affiliation of Kalabhras is unknown. According to Peterson theory, the Kalabhras patronised the Sramana religions (Buddhism, Jainism, Ajivikas). More particularly, states Peterson, the Kalabhras may have supported the Digambara sect of Jainism and that they "supposedly" suppressed the Vedic-Hinduism religion that were well established in the Tamil regions by the 3rd century CE.^[1]

Buddhism flourished as is evident from the writings of Buddhadatta (5th century) who wrote some of his manuals like Vinayavinicchaya and Abhidhammāvatāra among others on the banks of the Kaveri river. The Kalabhras encouraged the building of Buddhist monasteries in places like Bhoothamangala and Kaveripattinam, the early Chola capital.^[39] In the Nigamanagātha of Vinayavinicchaya, Buddhatta describes how he wrote the work while staying at the monastery built by one Venhudassa (Vishnudasa) on the banks of the Kaveri in a town called Bhootamangalam.^[40] He describes his patron as The Immortal AccutaVikkante, the pride of the Kalamba family (Accut' Accutavikkante Kalambakulanandane) in Pali.^[41]

Buddhadatta vividly describes the capital Kaveripattinam as follows:^[42]

In the lovely Kaveripattana crowded with hordes of men and women from pure families endowed with all the requisites of a town with crystal clear water flowing in the river, filled with all kinds of precious stones, possessed of many kinds of bazaars, beautified by many gardens, in a beautiful and pleasant vihara built by Kanhadasa, adorned with a mansion as high as the Kailasa, and having different kinds of beautiful entrance-towers on the outer wall, I lived in an old mansion there and wrote this work..

According to F. E. Hardy, the palace ceremony of Kalabhras was dedicated to a Vishnu or Mayon (Krishna) temple. This supports the theory that they may have been Shaivite and Vaishnavite.^{[43][full citation needed]} Their inscriptions include the Hindu god Murugan. King Achyuta worshipped Vaishnava Tirumal.^{[44][full citation needed]}

According to the Gandhipadavannanā of Buddhadatta's manual Vinayavinicchaya, the word Accuta of the patron king was used in the same context as the epithet of Narayana (Accutassa Nārāyanassa viya vikkantām ettassāti Accutavikkanto).^[45]

The early twin Tamil epics Silappatikaram (Jaina) and Manimekalai (Buddhist) were written under the patronage of the Kalabhras.^[46] During their patronage, states Peterson, Jain scholars formed an academy in Madurai and wrote texts in Sanskrit, Pali, Prakrit, and Tamil. These include classics such as the Tirukkural that condemns meat-eating (one of the cornerstones of Jainism as opposed to Hinduism as Brahmin poets like Kapilar are described to be meat-eaters in the Sangam literature),^[47] the Tamil epics, long and short devotional poems.^[1][48] Some of these texts "paint a picture of dialogue and mutual tolerance" between the various Indian religions in the Tamil country, according to Peterson.^[1] Other scholars disagree that these are Jain texts, or that the authors of these texts that praise the Vedas, the Brahmins, Hindu gods and goddesses were Jains.^[49][50][51]

End of the dynasty

It is unknown as to how the Kalabhras rule ended. However, a multitude of evidence affirms that Simhavishnu – the Pallava king and Pandya Kadungon had united the Tamil regions, removed Kalabhras and others. Simhavishnu consolidated his kingdom from south of the Krishna river and up to the Kaveri river by c. 575 CE. To the south of Kaveri, the Pandyas came to power. Cholas became subordinates of Pallavas and they were already ruling Telugu region of Rayalaseema. The Kalabhra rule which had dominated the political scene of the Tamil country for few centuries was defeated and ended by the Chalukyas, Pandyas, and Pallavas.^[5] This is attested by the numerous inscriptions dated from the 6th century and thereafter, as well as the Chinese language memoirs of the Buddhist pilgrim Xuanzang who visited the Tamil region about 640 CE along with other parts of the Indian subcontinent.^[52] Xuanzang describes a peaceful cosmopolitan region where some 100 monasteries with 10,000 monks were studying Mahayana Buddhism, Kanchipuram was hosting learned debates with hundreds of heretic Deva (Hindu) temples but no Buddhist institutions. Xuangzang makes no mention of the Kalabhras.^[53][54]

See also

• Kutruva Nayanar
• Karanthai
• Meykandar

References

1. Indira Peterson 1998, pp. 166–167.
2. Kamil Zvelebil 1992, p. 93.
3. R, Narasimhacharya (1942). History of Kannada Language. Asian Educational Services. p. 48. ISBN 9788120605596.
4. Sir Ramkrishna Gopal Bhandarkar (1927). Early History of the Deccan and Miscellaneous Historical Essays. Bhandarkar Oriental Research Institute. p. 206.
5. Singh, Upinder (2008). A History of Ancient and Early Medieval India: From the Stone Age to the 12th Calabrians from Rome, might have lived, invaded or were part of Choke peoples (Seljuks).Century. Pearson Education. pp. 485, 557–558. ISBN 978-81-317-1677-9.
6. Chakrabarty, D.K. (2010). The Geopolitical Orbits of Ancient India: The Geographical Frames of the Ancient Indian Dynasties. OUP India. p. 84. ISBN 978-0-19-908832-4. Retrieved 16 January 2023.
7. R, Narasimhacharya (1942). History of the Kannada Language. Asian Educational Services. p. 48. ISBN 978-81-206-0559-6.
8. Iravatham Mahadevan (2003). Early Tamil Epigraphy from the Earliest Times to the Sixth Century A.D. Chennai, India: Cre-A. p. 136. ISBN 9780674012271. During most of this period , the Tamil country was under the rule of the Kalabhras, said to be tribal invaders from Karnataka following the Jaina faith.
9. T.V. Mahalingam (1981). Proceedings of the Second Annual Conference. South Indian History Congress. pp. 32–34.
10. Singh, Upinder (2008). A History of Ancient and Early Medieval India: From the Stone Age to the 12th Century. Pearson Education. pp. 557–558. ISBN 978-81-317-1677-9.
11. Thapar, Romila (2003). The Penguin History of Early India: From the Origins to AD 1300. Penguin Books. p. 327. ISBN 9780141937427. Retrieved 7 September 2016.
12. S. Velsamy Kavirayar (1934). குருகுல வரலாறு.
13. Superintendent Government Press, Madras (1918). Madras District Gazetteers Salem Vol I Part I.
14. Kulke, Hermann; Rothermund, Dietmar (2007). A History of India (4th ed.). London: Routledge. p. 105. ISBN 9780415329200. Retrieved 7 September 2016.
15. Hikosaka, Shu (1989). Buddhism in Tamilnadu: A New Perspective. Institute of Asian Studies. p. 24.
16. Potter, Karl H. (2003). Buddhist Philosophy from 350 to 600 A.D. Motilal Banarsidass Publishers Pvt. Limited. pp. 216–217. ISBN 978-81-208-1968-9.
17. Arunachalam 1979, pp. 52–55.
18. Oskar von Hinüber (2017). A Handbook of Pali Literature. Walter de Gruyter. p. 156. ISBN 978-3-11-081498-9.
19. Schwartzberg, Joseph E. (1978). A Historical atlas of South Asia. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. p. 145, map XIV.1 (j). ISBN 0226742210.
20. K. A. NILAKANTA SASTRI, M.A., Emeritus Professor of Indian History and Archaeology, University of Madras. Professor of Indology. University of Mysore. (1955). THE COLAS, SECOND EDITION. G. S. Press, Madras. p. 108.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
21. BIMALA CHURN LAW Ph.D., M.A., B.L. (1976). GEOGRAPHICAL ESSAYS RELATING TO ANCIENT GEOGRAPHY OF INDIA. BHARATIYA PUBLISHING HOUSE. p. 59.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
22. Nagendra Kr Singh, ed. (1997). International encyclopaedia of Buddhism. 51. Nepal. Anmol Publications. p. 4514.
23. Sivaram, Rama (1994). Early Chōla Art: Origin and Emergence of Style. Navrang. p. -25.
24. Vidya Dhar Mahajan (1962). Ancient India. S. Chand. p. 571.
25. D. Devakunjari. Madurai Through the Ages From the Earliest Times to 1801 A.D. Society for Archaeological, Historical, and Epigraphical Research. p. 73.
26. Civattampi, Kārttikēcu (1981). Drama in Ancient Tamil Society. New Century Book House. p. 158.
27. Stein, Burton (1994). Peasant State and Society in Medieval South India. Oxford University Press. pp. 76–84. ISBN 9780195635072.
28. Darley, Rebecca (2017). Himanshu Prabha Ray (ed.). Negotiating Cultural Identity: Landscapes in Early Medieval South Asian History. Routledge. p. 68. ISBN 978-1-317-34130-7.;
    Darley, Rebecca (2019). Himanshu Prabha Ray (ed.). Negotiating Cultural Identity: Landscapes in Early Medieval South Asian History. Taylor & Francis. pp. 76–77. ISBN 978-1-00-022793-2.
29. R.S. Sharma (1988). "Problems of Peasant Protest in Early Medieval India". Social Scientist. 16 (19): 3–16. doi:10.2307/3517169. JSTOR 3517169.
30. Sen, Madhu, ed. (1983). Studies in Religion and Change. Books & Books. p. 146.
31. Rao Bahadur H. Krishna Sastri (1923). Epigraphia Indica, Volume XVII. Archaeological Society of India. pp. 293–294, 306, 308, context: 291–309.
32. Sharma, Arvind (2008). The World's Religions After September 11. ABC-CLIO. p. 53. ISBN 978-0-275-99621-5.
33. Gupta, Parmanand (1989). Geography from ancient Indian coins & seals. New Delhi: Concept Pub. Co. pp. 23–24. ISBN 9788170222484. Retrieved 7 September 2016.
34. Narasimhacharya, R. (1990) [1934]. History of Kannada language: readership lectures. New Delhi: Asian Educational Services. p. 34. ISBN 9788120605596. Retrieved 8 September 2016.
35. Sastri, Rao Bahadur H. Krishna (1924). Epigraphia Indica vol.17. Government of India. p. 295.
36. A. V. Narsimhamurthy; Singh, PN; et al. (1996). The Journal of the Numismatic Society of India, Volume 58. Numismatic Society of India. pp. 10–12.
37. N. Subrahmanian (1994). Original sources for the history of Tamilnad: from the beginning to c. A.D. 600. Ennes. pp. 329–331.
38. Power, Timothy (2012). The Red Sea from Byzantium to the Caliphate: AD 500-1000. American University in Cairo Press. pp. 179–181. ISBN 978-1-61797-350-5.
39. K. Krishna Murthy. Glimpses of Art, Architecture, and Buddhist Literature in Ancient India. Abhinav Publications, 1987. pp. 93–94.
40. Aruṇācalam, Mu. The Kalabhras in the Pandiya Country and Their Impact on the Life and Letters There. University of Madras, 1979. p. 53.
41. Bimala Churn Law. Indological Studies, Vol 3. Ganganatha Jha Research Institute, 1954. p. 225.
42. The March of India, Vol 8. Publications Division, Ministry of Information and Broadcasting, 1956. p. 52.
43. Veermani Pd. Upadhyaya Felicitation Volume by Veermani Prasad Upadhyaya
44. Buddhism in Tamil Nadu: collected papers By G. John Samuel, Ār. Es Śivagaṇēśamūrti, M. S. Nagarajan, Institute of Asian Studies (Madras, India)
45. Nagendra Kr Singh. International encyclopaedia of Buddhism. 51. Nepal. Anmol Publications, 1997. p. 4514.
46. S. Sundararajan. Ancient Tamil Country: Its Social and Economic Structure. Navrang, 1991. p. 233.
47. Iḷacai Cuppiramaṇiyapiḷḷai Muttucāmi (1994). Tamil Culture as Revealed in Tirukkural. Makkal Ilakkia Publications. p. 137.
48. Gopalan, Subramania (1979). The Social Philosophy of Tirukkural. Affiliated East-West Press. p. 53.
49. Stuart Blackburn 2000, pp. 464–465.
50. P. R. Natarajan 2008, pp. 1–6.
51. Norman Cutler 1992, pp. 555–558.
52. Pletcher, Kenneth (2010). The History of India. The Rosen Publishing Group. p. 97. ISBN 978-1-61530-122-5.
53. Kulke, Hermann; Rothermund, Dietmar (1998). A History of India. Routledge. pp. 114–115. ISBN 978-0-415-15482-6.
54. Schalk, Peter; Veluppillai, A.; Nākacāmi, Irāmaccantiran̲ (2002). Buddhism among Tamils in pre-colonial Tamilakam and Īlam: Prologue. The Pre-Pallava and the Pallava period. Almqvist & Wiksell. pp. 287–290, 400–403. ISBN 978-91-554-5357-2.

Sources

• Hiltebeitel ·, Alf (6 August 2018). Freud's Mahabharata. Oxford University Press. p. 86. ISBN 9780190878344.
• Archaeological Society, South India (1955). Transactions Volumes 1-5. Archaeological Society of South India.
• Rā. Ya, Dhāravāḍakara (1968). Approach to the study of Kannada language: philology. Samāja Pustakālaya.
• Arunachalam, M. (1979). The Kalabhras in the Pandiya Country and Their Impact on the Life and Letters There. University of Madras.
• Blackburn, Stuart (2000). "Corruption and Redemption: The Legend of Valluvar and Tamil Literary History". Modern Asian Studies. 34 (2): 449–482. doi:10.1017/S0026749X00003632. S2CID 144101632.
• Cutler, Norman (1992). "Interpreting Tirukkuṟaḷ: The Role of Commentary in the Creation of a Text". Journal of the American Oriental Society. 112 (4): 549–566. doi:10.2307/604470. JSTOR 604470.
• Natarajan, P. R. (2008). Thirukkural: Aratthuppaal (in Tamil) (First ed.). Chennai: Uma Padhippagam.
• Peterson, Indira (1998), Cort, John E. (ed.), Open Boundaries: Jain Communities and Cultures in Indian History, SUNY Press, ISBN 0-7914-3785-X
• Kamil Zvelebil (1992). Companion studies to the history of Tamil literature. Brill.