James McKeen Cattell

James McKeen Cattell (May 25, 1860 – January 20, 1944), an American psychologist, was the first professor of psychology in the United States, teaching at the University of Pennsylvania, and a long-time editor and publisher of scientific journals and publications, including Science. He also served on the board of trustees for Science Service, now known as Society for Science & the Public (SSP) from 1921 to 1944.

James McKeen Cattell
Born	(1860-05-25)May 25, 1860 Easton, Pennsylvania, U.S.
Died	January 20, 1944(1944-01-20) (aged 83) Lancaster, Pennsylvania, U.S.
Alma mater	Lafayette College (BA, MA) University of Leipzig (PhD)
Scientific career
Fields	Psychology, psychometrics
Institutions	University of Cambridge University of Pennsylvania Columbia University
Doctoral advisor	Wilhelm Wundt
Doctoral students	Walter Dearborn Harry L. Hollingworth Shepherd Ivory Franz Edward Thorndike Edward Kellog Strong Jr. John Dashiell
Spouse	Josephine Owen ​ (m. 1888)​
Children	7, including Psyche
Parent	William Cassady Cattell (father)

At the beginning of Cattell's career, many scientists regarded psychology simply as a minor field of study, or as a pseudoscience which is a collection of beliefs or practices regarded as a scientific method when it is not such as phrenology. Considerably more than his peers, Cattell helped establish psychology as a legitimate science, worthy of study at the highest levels of the academy. At the time of his death, The New York Times credited him as "the dean of American science." Yet Cattell may be best remembered for his uncompromising opposition to American involvement in World War I.^[1] His public opposition to the draft led to his dismissal from his position at Columbia University, a move that later led many American universities to establish tenure as a means of protecting unpopular beliefs.^[1]

Early life

Cattell was born in Easton, Pennsylvania in 1860, the eldest child of a wealthy and prominent family. His father, William Cassady Cattell, a Presbyterian minister, became president of Lafayette College in Easton shortly after James' birth. William Cattell could easily provide for his children, because he had married Elizabeth "Lizzie" McKeen in 1859; together they shared Lizzie's substantial inheritance. To this picture of the family's success one could add political power as well: James's uncle Alexander Gilmore Cattell represented New Jersey in the United States Senate.^[2]

Cattell entered Lafayette College in 1876 at the age of sixteen and graduated in four years with the highest honors. In 1883, the faculty at Lafayette awarded him an M.A., again with highest honors. At Lafayette, Cattell spent most of his time devouring English literature and also showed a gift for mathematics. Cattell said Francis Andrew March, a philologist, was a great influence during his time at Lafayette.^[3]

Cattell did not find his calling until after he arrived in Germany for doctoral studies, where he was supervised by Wilhelm Wundt at University of Leipzig. He also studied under Hermann Lotze at the University of Göttingen; an essay on Lotze won Cattell a fellowship at Johns Hopkins University. Cattell left Germany for his fellowship in October 1882.^[3] The fellowship was not renewed,^[3] and Cattell returned to Leipzig the next year as Wundt's assistant.

The partnership between Wundt and Cattell proved highly productive; the two helped to establish the formal study of intelligence. Under Wundt, Cattell became the first American to publish a dissertation in the field of psychology. The title of his German dissertation was Psychometrische Untersuchungen (Psychometric Investigation). The dissertation was accepted by the University of Leipzig in 1886. Cattell tried to explore the interiors of his own mind through the consumption of the then-legal drug hashish. Under the influence of this drug, Cattell once compared the whistling of a schoolboy to a symphony orchestra. While recreational drug use was not uncommon among early psychologists, including Freud, Cattell's experimentation with hashish reflected a willingness to go against conventional opinion and morality.^{[citation needed]}

The main street in the College Hill Neighborhood of Easton, Pennsylvania, home to Lafayette College, is named after Cattell.

Academic career

After completing his Ph.D. with Wundt in Germany in 1886, Cattell took up a lecturing post at the University of Cambridge in England, and became a Fellow of St John's College, Cambridge.^[4] He made occasional visits to the U.S., where he gave lectures at Bryn Mawr College and the University of Pennsylvania. In 1889, he returned to the U.S. to become a professor of psychology at the University of Pennsylvania in Philadelphia. In 1891, he moved to Columbia University where he became Department Head of Psychology, Anthropology, and Philosophy. In 1895, he was appointed president of the American Psychological Association. He was elected as a member to the American Philosophical Society in 1888.^[5]

From the beginning of his career, Cattell worked to establish psychology as a field as worthy of study as any of the hard physical sciences, such as chemistry or physics. He believed that further investigation would reveal that intellect itself could be parsed into standard units of measurements. He also established the methods of Wilhelm Wundt and Francis Galton, including mental testing, in the U.S.

In 1917, Cattell and English professor Henry Wadsworth Longfellow Dana (grandson of Henry Wadsworth Longfellow and Richard Henry Dana Jr.) were fired from Columbia University for opposing the United States’ conscription policy during World War I.^[6] He later sued the university and won an annuity. In 1921, he used the money that he gained from the settlement to start The Psychological Corporation to foster his interest in applied psychology. Because he was never able to really explain how psychologists apply their work, the organization failed until it was taken over by other psychologists who had experience in applied psychology. Towards the end of his life, Cattell edited and published journals. To help himself in the process, he created the Science Press Printing Company in order to produce his journals. He continued his work on journals until his death in 1944 in Lancaster, Pennsylvania.

Eugenicist beliefs

Like many eminent scientists and scholars of the time, Cattell's thought was influenced by belief in eugenics, defined as the "applied science or the bio-social movement which advocates the use of practices aimed at improving the genetic composition of a population, usually referring to human populations."^[7] Cattell's belief in eugenics was heavily influenced by the research of Charles Darwin, whose theory of evolution motivated Cattell's emphasis on studying “the psychology of individual differences”.^[8]

In connection with his eugenicist beliefs, Cattell's own research found that men of science were likely to have fathers who were clergymen or professors. Incidentally, Cattell's father was both.^[9]

Cattell believed that he had “inherited ability", but he also credited the influence of his environment, saying "it was my fortune to find a birthplace in the sun. A germplasm fairly well compounded [good genes] met circumstances to which it was unusually fit to react”.^[9] Cattell's belief in eugenics even motivated him to offer his own children monetary gifts of $1,000 if they married the offspring of a university professor or academic professional.^[10]

Mental tests

Cattell's research on individual differences played a significant role in introducing and emphasizing the experimental technique and importance of methodology in experimentation in America.^[11] Cattell’s design of mental tests were influenced by Wundt’s definition of psychology in regards to the achievements of psychophysics and by Galton’s view on the importance of the senses for judgement and intelligence.^[12].Regarding the beginnings of his mental tests, in Leipzig, Cattell independently began to measure “simple mental processes”^[10] Between 1883 and 1886, where he borrowed his approach from Sir Francis Galton (1883),^[13] Cattell published nine articles discussing human reaction time rates and individual differences.^[10] As professor at the University of Pennsylvania, Cattell administered a battery of ten tests to student volunteers, and for the first time introduced the term “mental tests” as a general term for his set of tests which included measures of sensation, using weights to determine just-noticeable differences, reaction time, human memory span, and rate of movement. There are two types of perspectives on measuring intelligence which are: 1.) Derived from Aristotle that asserts it is only through the identification of intelligence that its measurement becomes possible, through identification does not necessarily imply a definition 2.) all measurement is based on comparison and that different bases of comparison are possible.^{[14] [10]} When Cattell moved to Columbia University, the battery of tests became compulsory for all freshmen. Cattell believed that his mental tests were measuring intelligence; however, in 1901 Clark Wissler, a student of Cattell, demonstrated that there was no statistical relationship between scores on Cattell's tests and academic performance. The tests were finally rendered irrelevant with the development of Alfred Binet’s intelligence measurements.^[10][15]

Journals

Cattell was well known for his involvement in creating and editing scientific journals. He was so involved in owning and publishing journals, that his research productivity declined. He founded the journal Psychological Review in 1894 along with James Mark Baldwin. He also acquired the journal Science and, within five years, made it the official publication of the American Association for the Advancement of Science, 1895-1900. In 1900, he purchased Popular Science Monthly from D. Appleton & Company. In 1915, the title was purchased from him and became Popular Science. He, in turn, founded and edited The Scientific Monthly, which went to the subscribers of the old Popular Science Monthly as a substitute.^[11][16]

Cattell was the editor of Science for nearly 50 years. During that time, he did much to promote psychology as a science by seeing to it that empirical studies in psychology were prominently featured in the journal.^[10] Regarding his impact on the development of psychology as a science, Ludy T. Benjamin wrote of Cattell's editorship “there is no denying that it significantly enhanced psychology’s visibility and status among the older sciences.”^[8]: 56

American Men of Science

Cattell was the first compiler of American Men of Science, in 1906.^[17] (Despite the name, two women, Grace Andrews and Charlotte Angas Scott, were listed in this first edition of American Men of Science.^[18])

Skepticism

Cattell was skeptical of paranormal claims and spiritualism. He had dismissed the medium Leonora Piper as a fraud. He was involved in a debate over Piper with the psychologist William James in the Science journal.^[19][20][21] He took issue with James's support for psychical research.^[22] In a letter to James he wrote that the "Society for Psychical Research is doing much to injure psychology".^[23]

Family

He married Josephine Owen, the daughter of an English merchant, in 1888. Their seven children got their pre-college educations at home with their parents as instructors. The whole family shared in Cattell's editorial work.^[3] One daughter, Psyche Cattell (1893–1989) followed in her father's footsteps, established a small child psychology practice in Lancaster, Pennsylvania and developed tests to assess the intelligence of infants.^[24]

Death

Cattell died at Lancaster General Hospital in Lancaster, Pennsylvania on January 20, 1944.^[25]

References

1. Jonathan Baron (2006). "History: Cattell at Penn". Retrieved 2014-09-24. Baron cites C. S. Gruber (1972), "Academic freedom at Columbia University: The case of James McKeen Cattell", AAUP Bulletin, Autumn, pp. 297-305, with respect to Cattell's views on the war and place in the debate on academic freedom.
2. Smyth, Edward (March 18, 2015). "Cattell, Alexander Gilmore".
3. Dorothy Ross (1973). "Cattell, James McKeen". Dictionary of American Biography. Vol. Supplement Three (1941-1945). New York: Charles Scribner's Sons.
4. "Cattell, James McKeen (CTL886JM)". A Cambridge Alumni Database. University of Cambridge.
5. "APS Member History". search.amphilsoc.org. Retrieved 2021-07-07.
6. Current Opinion, November 1917, p.294
7. "Eugenics", Unified Medical Language System (Psychological Index Terms), National Library of Medicine, 26 Sep. 2010.
8. Benjamin, L.T. Jr. (1993). A history of psychology in letters. Dubuque, IA: Wm. C. Brown. ISBN 978-0697129802. OCLC 26931839.
9. Sokal, M. M. (1980). "Science and James McKeen Cattell, 1894 to 1945". Science. 209 (4452): 43–52. Bibcode:1980Sci...209...43S. doi:10.1126/science.7025202. PMID 7025202.
10. Thorne, B. M., Henley, T. (2001). Connections in the history and systems of psychology. Boston: Houghton Mifflin
11. Pillsbury, W.B. (1947). Biographical Memoir of James McKeen Cattell 1860-1944. National Academy of the Sciences. http://www.nasonline.org/publications/biographical-memoirs/memoir-pdfs/cattell-james-m.pdf
12. “Boeck, P.D., Gore, L. R., Gonzalez, T., & Martin, E. S. (2019). “An Alternative View on the Measurement of Intelligence and its History”. The Cambridge Handbook of Intelligence, 47-74. https://doi.org/10.1017/9781108770422.005
13. “Boeck, P.D., Gore, L. R., Gonzalez, T., & Martin, E. S. (2019). “An Alternative View on the Measurement of Intelligence and its History”. The Cambridge Handbook of Intelligence, 47-74. https://doi.org/10.1017/9781108770422.005
14. “Boeck, P.D., Gore, L. R., Gonzalez, T., & Martin, E. S. (2019). “An Alternative View on the Measurement of Intelligence and its History”. The Cambridge Handbook of Intelligence, 47-74. https://doi.org/10.1017/9781108770422.005
15. Applied History of Psychology/Models of Testing. Wikibooks. http://en.wikibooks.org/wiki/Applied_History_of_Psychology/Models_of_Assessment
16. Cattell, James McKeen (September 1915). "The Scientific Monthly and the Popular Science Monthly". Popular Science Monthly. 87 (3): 307–310.
17. Cattell, J. McKEEN, ed. (1906). American Men of Science. New York: The Science Press. Retrieved November 7, 2018 – via Internet Archive.
18. Bailey, Martha J. (1994). American Women in Science:A Biographical Dictionary. ABC-CLIO, Inc. ISBN 0-87436-740-9.
19. Cattell, J. M. (1898). Mrs. Piper, the medium. Science 7: 534-535.
20. James, W. (1898). Mrs. Piper, "the medium". Science 7: 640-641.
21. Cattell, J. M. (1898). Mrs. Piper, "the medium". Science 7: 641-642.
22. Kimble, Gregory A; Wertheimer, Michael; White, Charlotte. (2013). Portraits of Pioneers in Psychology. Psychology Press. p. 23. ISBN 0-8058-0620-2
23. Goodwin, C. James. (2015). A History of Modern Psychology. Wiley. p. 154. ISBN 978-1-118-83375-9
24. Cattell, Psyche (1940). The Measurement of Intelligence of Infants and Young Children (1st ed.). New York, New York: The Psychological Corporation.
25. "Dr. James M. Cattell". Harrisburg Telegraph. p. 3. Retrieved 2021-05-03 – via Newspapers.com.

Further reading

• Cattell, James McKeen (1886). "Psychometrische Untersuchungen".
• Cattell, James McKeen (1921). American Men of Science: A Biographical Directory (3rd ed.). Garrison, New York: The Science Press.
• Godin (2007). "From eugenics to scientometrics: Galton, Cattell, and men of science". Social Studies of Science. 37 (5): 691–728. doi:10.1177/0306312706075338. PMID 18348397. S2CID 13166578.
• Whipple (2004). "Eminence revisited". History of Psychology. 7 (3): 265–96. doi:10.1037/1093-4510.7.3.265. PMID 15382378.
• Benschop; Draaisma, D (2000). "In pursuit of precision: the calibration of minds and machines in late nineteenth-century psychology". Annals of Science. 57 (1): 1–25. doi:10.1080/000337900296281. PMID 11624166. S2CID 37504910.
• Cattell (1992). "Retrospect: psychology as a profession. 1937". Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology. 60 (1): 7–8, discussion 9–15. doi:10.1037/0022-006X.60.1.7. PMID 1556288.
• Sokal (1980). "Science and James McKeen Cattell, 1894 to 1945". Science. 209 (4452): 43–52. Bibcode:1980Sci...209...43S. doi:10.1126/science.7025202. PMID 7025202.
• Sokal (1971). "The unpublished autobiography of James McKeen Cattell". The American Psychologist. 26 (7): 626–35. doi:10.1037/h0032048. PMID 4934276.

External links

 

Wikimedia Commons has media related to James McKeen Cattell.

 

Wikisource has original works by or about:
James McKeen Cattell

• Short biography, bibliography, and links on digitized sources in the Virtual Laboratory of the Max Planck Institute for the History of Science
• National Academy of Sciences Biographical Memoir
• Works by James McKeen Cattell at Project Gutenberg
• Works by or about James McKeen Cattell at Internet Archive
• James McKeen Cattell at Find a Grave