fbpx
Wikipedia

Epictetus

Epictetus (/ˌɛpɪkˈttəs/, EH-pick-TEE-təss;[3] Greek: Ἐπίκτητος, Epíktētos; c. 50 – c. 135 AD) was a Greek Stoic philosopher.[4][5] He was born into slavery at Hierapolis, Phrygia (present-day Pamukkale, in western Turkey) and lived in Rome until his banishment, when he went to Nicopolis in northwestern Greece, where he spent the rest of his life. His teachings were written down and published by his pupil Arrian in his Discourses and Enchiridion.

Epictetus
18th-century portrait of Epictetus, including his crutch
Bornc. AD 50
Diedc. 135 (aged c. 85)
Notable work
EraHellenistic philosophy
RegionWestern philosophy
SchoolStoicism
Main interests
Ethics
Notable ideas
Memento mori[1]

Epictetus taught that philosophy is a way of life and not simply a theoretical discipline. To Epictetus, all external events are beyond our control; he argues that we should accept whatever happens calmly and dispassionately. However, individuals are responsible for their own actions, which they can examine and control through rigorous self-discipline.

Life edit

Epictetus was born around AD 50,[6][7] presumably at Hierapolis, Phrygia.[8] The name his parents gave him is unknown. The word epíktētos (ἐπίκτητος) in Greek simply means "gained" or "acquired";[9] the Greek philosopher Plato, in his Laws, used the term to mean property that is "added to one's hereditary property."[10] He spent his youth in Rome as a slave to Epaphroditus, a wealthy freedman and secretary to Nero.[11] His social position was thus complicated, combining the low status of a slave with the high status of one with a personal connection to Imperial power.[12]

Early in life, Epictetus acquired a passion for philosophy and, with the permission of his wealthy master, he studied Stoic philosophy under Musonius Rufus.[13] Becoming more educated in this way raised his social status.[14] At some point, he became disabled. Celsus, quoted by Origen, wrote that this was because his leg had been deliberately broken by his master.[15] Simplicius, in contrast, wrote that Epictetus had been disabled from childhood.[16]

 
Roman-era ruins (the Nymphaeum) at Nicopolis

Epictetus obtained his freedom sometime after the death of Nero in AD 68,[17] and he began to teach philosophy in Rome. Around AD 93, when the Roman emperor Domitian banished all philosophers from the city,[18] Epictetus moved to Nicopolis in Epirus, Greece, where he founded a school of philosophy.[19]

His most famous pupil, Arrian, studied under him as a young man (around AD 108) and claimed to have written his famous Discourses based on the notes he took on Epictetus's lectures. Arrian argued that his Discourses should be considered comparable to the Socratic literature.[20] Arrian described Epictetus as a powerful speaker who could "induce his listener to feel just what Epictetus wanted him to feel."[21] Many eminent figures sought conversations with him.[22] Emperor Hadrian was friendly with him[23] and may have heard him speak at his school in Nicopolis.[24][25]

Epictetus lived a life of great simplicity, with few possessions.[16] He lived alone for a long time,[26] but in his old age, he adopted a friend's child who otherwise would have been left to die, and raised him with the aid of a woman.[27] It is unclear whether Epictetus and she were married.[28] He died sometime around AD 135.[29] After his death, according to Lucian, his oil lamp was purchased by an admirer for 3,000 drachmae.[30]

Thought edit

 
An eighteenth century engraving of Epictetus

No writings by Epictetus are known. His discourses were transcribed and compiled by his pupil Arrian (c. 86/89 – c. after 146/160 AD).[21] The main work is The Discourses, four books of which have been preserved (out of the original eight).[31] Arrian also compiled a popular digest, entitled the Enchiridion, or Handbook. In a preface to the Discourses that is addressed to Lucius Gellius, Arrian states that "whatever I heard him say I used to write down, word for word, as best I could, endeavouring to preserve it as a memorial, for my own future use, of his way of thinking and the frankness of his speech."[21] In the sixth century, the Neoplatonist philosopher Simplicius wrote an extant commentary on the Enchiridion.[32]

Epictetus maintains that the foundation of all philosophy is self-knowledge; that is, the conviction of our ignorance and gullibility ought to be the first subject of our study.[33] Logic provides valid reasoning and certainty in judgment, but it is subordinate to practical needs.[34] The first and most necessary part of philosophy concerns the application of doctrine, for example, that people should not lie. The second concerns reasons, e.g., why people should not lie. While the third, lastly, examines and establishes the reasons.[35] This is the logical part, which finds reasons, shows what is a reason, and that a given reason is a correct one.[35] This last part is necessary, but only on account of the second, which again is rendered necessary by the first.[36]

Both the Discourses and the Enchiridion begin by distinguishing between those things in our power (prohairetic things) and those things not in our power (aprohairetic things).[37]

That alone is in our power, which is our own work; and in this class are our opinions, impulses, desires, and aversions. On the contrary, what is not in our power, are our bodies, possessions, glory, and power. Any delusion on this point leads to the greatest errors, misfortunes, and troubles, and to the slavery of the soul.[38]

We have no power over external things, and the good that ought to be the object of our earnest pursuit, is to be found only within ourselves.[39]

The determination between what is good and what is not good is made by the capacity for choice (prohairesis).[40] Prohairesis allows us to act, and gives us the kind of freedom that only rational animals have.[41] It is determined by our reason, which of all our faculties, sees and tests itself and everything else.[42] It is the correct use of the impressions (phantasia) that bombard the mind that is in our power:[43]

Practice then from the start to say to every harsh impression, "You are an impression, and not at all the thing you appear to be." Then examine it and test it by these rules you have, and firstly, and chiefly, by this: whether the impression has to do with the things that are up to us, or those that are not; and if it has to do with the things that are not up to us, be ready to reply, "It is nothing to me."[44]

We will not be troubled at any loss, but will say to ourselves on such an occasion: "I have lost nothing that belongs to me; it was not something of mine that was torn from me, but something that was not in my power has left me." Nothing beyond the use of our opinion is properly ours. Every possession rests on opinion. What is to cry and to weep? An opinion. What is misfortune, or a quarrel, or a complaint? All these things are opinions; opinions founded on the delusion that what is not subject to our own choice can be either good or evil, which it cannot.[39] By rejecting these opinions, and seeking good and evil in the power of choice alone, we may confidently achieve peace of mind in every condition of life.[45]

Reason alone is good, the irrational is evil, and the irrational is intolerable to the rational.[46] The good person should labour chiefly on their own reason; to perfect this is in our power.[47] To repel evil opinions by the good is the noble contest in which humans should engage; it is not an easy task, but it promises true freedom, peace of mind (ataraxia), and a divine command over the emotions (apatheia).[48] We should especially be on our guard against the opinion of pleasure because of its apparent sweetness and charms.[49] The first object of philosophy, therefore, is to purify the mind.[50]

Epictetus teaches that the preconceptions (prolepsis) of good and evil are common to all.[51] Good alone is profitable and to be desired, and evil is hurtful and to be avoided.[52] Different opinions arise only from the application of these preconceptions to particular cases, and it is then that the darkness of ignorance, which blindly maintains the correctness of its own opinion, must be dispelled.[51] People entertain different and conflicting opinions of good, and in their judgment of a particular good, people frequently contradict themselves.[53] Philosophy should provide a standard for good and evil.[54] This process is greatly facilitated because the mind and the works of the mind are alone in our power, whereas all external things that aid life are beyond our control.[54]

The essence of divinity is goodness; we have all good that could be given to us.[55] The deities too gave us the soul and reason, which is not measured by breadth or depth, but by knowledge and sentiments, and by which we attain to greatness, and may equal even with the deities. We should, therefore, cultivate the mind with special care.[56] If we wish for nothing, but what God wills, we shall be truly free, and all will come to pass with us according to our desire; and we shall be as little subject to restraint as Zeus himself.[57]

Every individual is connected with the rest of the world, and the universe is fashioned for universal harmony.[56] Wise people, therefore, will pursue, not merely their own will, but also will be subject to the rightful order of the world.[58] We should conduct ourselves through life fulfilling all our duties as children, siblings, parents, and citizens.[59]

For our country or friends we ought to be ready to undergo or perform the greatest difficulties.[60] The good person, if able to foresee the future, would peacefully and contentedly help to bring about their own sickness, maiming, and even death, knowing that this is the correct order of the universe.[61] We have all a certain part to play in the world, and we have done enough when we have performed what our nature allows.[62] In the exercise of our powers, we may become aware of the destiny we are intended to fulfil.[63]

We are like travellers at an inn or guests at a stranger's table; whatever is offered we take with thankfulness, and sometimes, when the turn comes, we may refuse; in the former case we are a worthy guest of the deities, and in the latter we appear as a sharer in their power.[64] Anyone who finds life intolerable is free to quit it, but we should not abandon our appointed role without sufficient reason.[65] The Stoic sage will never find life intolerable and will complain of no one, neither deity nor human.[66] Those who go wrong we should pardon and treat with compassion, since it is from ignorance that they err, being as it were, blind.[67]

It is only our opinions and principles that can render us unhappy, and it is only the ignorant person who finds fault with another.[68] Every desire degrades us, and renders us slaves of what we desire.[68] We ought not to forget the transitory character of all external advantages, even in the midst of our enjoyment of them; but always to bear in mind that they are not our own, and that therefore, they do not properly belong to us. Thus prepared, we shall never be carried away by opinions.[69]

The final entry of the Enchiridion, or Handbook, begins: "Upon all occasions we ought to have these maxims ready at hand":

Conduct me, Zeus, and thou, Destiny,
Wherever thy decree has fixed my lot.
I follow willingly; and, did I not,
Wicked and wretched would I follow still.
(Diogenes Laërtius quoting Cleanthes; quoted also by Seneca, Epistle 107.)"

Whoe'er yields properly to Fate is deemed
Wise among men, and knows the laws of Heaven.
(From Euripides' Fragments, 965)

Crito, if it thus pleases the gods, thus let it be.
(From Plato's Crito)

Anytus and Meletus may indeed kill me, but they cannot harm me.
(From Plato's Apology)

Influence edit

Dialogue between the Emperor Hadrian and Epictetus edit

 
Hadrian and Epictetus, 15th century manuscript, Bodleian library

Epictetus appears in a 2nd or 3rd century Dialogue between the Emperor Hadrian and Epictetus the Philosopher.[70] This short Latin text consists of seventy-three short questions supposedly posed by Hadrian and answered by Epictetus.[70] This dialogue was very popular in the Middle Ages with many translations and adaptations.[70]

Philosophy edit

Marcus Aurelius edit

The philosophy of Epictetus influenced the Roman emperor Marcus Aurelius (AD 121 to AD 180), who cites Epictetus in his Meditations.[71]

Philosophers of the French Enlightenment edit

Voltaire, Montesquieu, Denis Diderot and Baron d'Holbach all read the Enchiridion when they were students.[72]

Literature edit

The philosophy of Epictetus plays a key role in the 1998 novel A Man in Full by Tom Wolfe. This was in part the outcome of discussions Wolfe had with James Stockdale (see below). The character Conrad, who through a series of mishaps finds himself in jail and accidentally acquires a copy of the Enchiridion of Epictetus, the Stoic's manual, discovers a philosophy that strengthens him to endure the brutality of the prison environment. He experiences Joseph Campbell's 'hero's journey' call to action and becomes a strong, honorable, undefeatable protagonist. The importance of Epictetus' Stoicism for Stockdale, its role in A Man in Full, and its significance in Ridley Scott's film Gladiator are discussed by William O. Stephens in The Rebirth of Stoicism?.[73]

Mohun Biswas, in the novel A House for Mr Biswas (1961), by V.S. Naipaul, is pleased to think himself a follower of Epictetus and Marcus Aurelius; the irony is that he never actually behaves as a Stoic.

"Everything has two handles, the one by which it may be carried, the other by which it cannot" is the theme of Disturbances in the Field (1983), by Lynne Sharon Schwartz. Lydia, the central character, turns often to The Golden Sayings of Epictetus – the latter being a modern selection from Epictetus's writings, compiled and translated by Hastings Crossley.

A line from the Enchiridion is used as a title quotation in The Life and Opinions of Tristram Shandy, Gentleman by Laurence Sterne, which translates to, "Not things, but opinions about things, trouble men."[74]

Epictetus is mentioned in A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man by James Joyce: in the fifth chapter of the novel the protagonist Stephen Dedalus discusses Epictetus's famous lamp with a dean of his college.[75] Epictetus also is mentioned briefly in Franny and Zooey by J. D. Salinger, and is referred to by Theodore Dreiser in his novel Sister Carrie. Both the longevity of Epictetus's life and his philosophy are alluded to in John Berryman's poem, "Of Suicide."

Epictetus is referred to, but not mentioned by name, in Matthew Arnold's sonnet "To a Friend". Arnold provides three historical personalities as his inspiration and support in difficult times (Epictetus is preceded by Homer and succeeded by Sophocles):

Much he, whose friendship I not long since won,

That halting slave, who in Nicopolis
Taught Arrian, when Vespasian's brutal son

Cleared Rome of what most shamed him.[76]

François Rabelais edit

In the Chapter XXX of François Rabelais' Pantagruel (c. 1532), Pantagruel's tutor Epistemon had his head cut off after a battle. After he had his head reattached and was brought back to life, he recounts his experience of the damned in hell:

Their estate and condition of living is but only changed after a very strange manner;

...After this manner, those that had been great lords and ladies here, got but a poor scurvy wretched living there below. And, on the contrary, the philosophers and others, who in this world had been altogether indigent and wanting, were great lords there in their turn.

...I saw Epictetus there, most gallantly apparelled after the French fashion, sitting under a pleasant arbour, with store of handsome gentlewomen, frolicking, drinking, dancing, and making good cheer, with abundance of crowns of the sun. Above the lattice were written these verses for his device:

To leap and dance, to sport and play,
And drink good wine both white and brown,
Or nothing else do all the day
But tell bags full of many a crown.

When he saw me, he invited me to drink with him very courteously, and I was willing to be entreated, tippled and chopined together most theologically. In the meantime came Cyrus to beg one farthing of him for the honour of Mercury, therewith to buy a few onions for his supper. No, no, said Epictetus, I do not use in my almsgiving to bestow farthings. Hold, thou varlet, there's a crown for thee; be an honest man."

Military edit

James Stockdale edit

 
Prisoner of war James Stockdale receiving the Medal of Honor from American president Gerald Ford; Stockdale claims he was able to retain his sanity during capture by relying on the philosophy of Epictetus

James Stockdale, a fighter pilot who was shot down while serving in the Vietnam War, was influenced by Epictetus. He was introduced to his works while at Stanford University. In Courage under Fire: Testing Epictetus's Doctrines in a Laboratory of Human Behavior (1993), Stockdale credits Epictetus with helping him endure his seven and a half years in captivity, which included torture and four years in solitary confinement.[77] When he was shot down, he reportedly said to himself "I'm leaving the world of technology and entering the world of Epictetus!" as he bailed out.[78]

Quoting Epictetus, Stockdale concludes the book with:

The emotions of grief, pity, and even affection are well-known disturbers of the soul. Grief is the most offensive; Epictetus considered the suffering of grief an act of evil. It is a willful act, going against the will of God to have all men share happiness.[79]

Psychology edit

Psychologist Albert Ellis, the founder of Rational Emotive Behavior Therapy, credited Epictetus with providing a foundation for his system of psychotherapy.[80][81][82]

Religion edit

Kiyozawa Manshi, a controversial reformer within the Higashi Honganji branch of Jodo Shinshu Buddhism, cited Epictetus as one of the three major influences on his spiritual development and thought.[83]

See also edit

Notes edit

  1. ^ Discourses of Epictetus, 3.24.
  2. ^ "Nicopolis Actia | Greece | Britannica". www.britannica.com.
  3. ^ Jones, Daniel; Roach, Peter, James Hartman and Jane Setter, eds. Cambridge English Pronouncing Dictionary. 17th edition. Cambridge UP, 2006.
  4. ^ Elizabeth Carter; Epictetus (9 July 2017). The Complete Works of Epictetus. Independently Published. ISBN 978-1521800355.
  5. ^ Rowan Stevens (28 February 2022). Wise Quotes – Epictetus (294 Epictetus Quotes): Greek Stoic Philosophy | Quote Collections | Epicurean. Rowan Stevens. ISBN 978-1636051833.
  6. ^ Graver, Margaret. "Epictetus". In Zalta, Edward N. (ed.). Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.
  7. ^ The year of his birth is uncertain. He was born a slave. We do know that he was born early enough to be teaching philosophy by around AD 93, when Domitian banished all philosophers from Rome, because he was among those who left the city. He also described himself as an old man to Arrian around 108 AD cf. Discourses, i.9.10; i.16.20; ii.6.23; etc.
  8. ^ Suda. Epictetus.
  9. ^ "Greek Word Study Tool". www.perseus.tufts.edu.
  10. ^ "Plato, Laws, section 924a". www.perseus.tufts.edu.
  11. ^ Epaphroditus, livius.org
  12. ^ P. Christoforou, Imagining the Roman Emperor (2023), p. 22
  13. ^ Epictetus, Discourses. i.7.32.
  14. ^ Epictetus, Discourses, i.9.29.
  15. ^ Origen, Contra Celcus. vii.
  16. ^ a b Simplicius, Commentary on the Enchiridion, 13.
  17. ^ Douglas J. Soccio, Archetypes of Wisdom: An Introduction to Philosophy (2012), p. 197
  18. ^ Suetonius, Domitian, x.
  19. ^ Aulus Gellius, Attic Nights, xv. 11.
  20. ^ Hendrik Selle: Dichtung oder Wahrheit – Der Autor der Epiktetischen Predigten. Philologus 145 [2001] 269–290
  21. ^ a b c Epictetus, Discourses, prologue.
  22. ^ Epictetus, Discourses, i.11; ii.14; iii.4; iii. 7; etc.
  23. ^ Historia Augusta, Hadrian, 16.
  24. ^ Fox, Robin The Classical World: An Epic History from Homer to Hadrian Basic Books. 2006 p. 578
  25. ^ A surviving second- or third-century work, Altercatio Hadriani Et Epicteti gives a fictitious account of a conversation between Hadrian and Epictetus.
  26. ^ Simplicius, Commentary on the Enchiridion, 46. There is a joke at Epictetus' expense in Lucian's Life of Demonax about the fact that he had no family.
  27. ^ Simplicius, Commentary on the Enchiridion, 46. It is possible that he married her, but Simplicius' language on that subject is ambiguous.
  28. ^ Lucian, Demoxan, c. 55, torn, ii., ed Hemsterh., p. 393; as quoted in A Selection from the Discourses of Epictetus With the Encheiridion (2009), p. 6
  29. ^ He apparently was alive in the reign of Hadrian (117–138). Marcus Aurelius (born AD 121) was an admirer, but never met him, and Aulus Gellius (ii.18.10) writing mid-century, speaks of him as if he belonged to the recent past.
  30. ^ Lucian, Remarks to an illiterate book-lover.
  31. ^ Photius, Bibliotheca, states that there were eight books.
  32. ^ George Long, (1890), The Discourses of Epictetus, with the Encheridion and Fragments, p. 390. George Bell and Sons
  33. ^ Epictetus, Discourses, ii.11.1
  34. ^ Epictetus, Discourses, i.7.1–8
  35. ^ a b Heinrich Ritter, Alexander James William Morrison, (1846), The History of Ancient Philosophy, Volume 4, p. 201
  36. ^ Epictetus, Discourses, iii.2.1–6; Enchiridion, 52
  37. ^ Epictetus, Discourses, i.1; Enchiridion, 1
  38. ^ Heinrich Ritter, Alexander James William Morrison, (1846), The History of Ancient Philosophy, Volume 4, p. 204
  39. ^ a b Heinrich Ritter, Alexander James William Morrison, (1846), The History of Ancient Philosophy, Volume 4, p. 206
  40. ^ Giovanni Reale, John R. Catan, 1990, A History of Ancient Philosophy: The schools of the Imperial Age, p. 80. SUNY Press
  41. ^ Christopher Gill, 1995, The Discourses of Epictetus, p. xx. Everyman
  42. ^ Epictetus, Discourses, i.1.4; i.20
  43. ^ Epictetus, Discourses, ii.19.32.
  44. ^ Epictetus, Enchiridion, 1
  45. ^ Epictetus, Discourses, iii.3.14–19; Enchiridion, 6
  46. ^ Epictetus, Discourses, i.2.1
  47. ^ Epictetus, Discourses, iii.8; iii.15.1–13; Enchiridion, 29
  48. ^ Epictetus, Discourses, ii.18.19–31; iii.3.14–22
  49. ^ Epictetus, Enchiridion, 34.
  50. ^ Heinrich Ritter, Alexander James William Morrison, (1846), The History of Ancient Philosophy, Volume 4, p. 207
  51. ^ a b Heinrich Ritter, Alexander James William Morrison, (1846), The History of Ancient Philosophy, Volume 4, p. 208
  52. ^ Epictetus, Discourses, i.22.1; ii.11.3
  53. ^ Epictetus, Discourses, ii.11.8–13; iii.14.11–14
  54. ^ a b Heinrich Ritter, Alexander James William Morrison, (1846), The History of Ancient Philosophy, Volume 4, p. 209
  55. ^ Heinrich Ritter, Alexander James William Morrison, (1846), The History of Ancient Philosophy, Volume 4, p. 217
  56. ^ a b Heinrich Ritter, Alexander James William Morrison, (1846), The History of Ancient Philosophy, Volume 4, p. 218
  57. ^ Epictetus, Discourses, ii.17.22–33
  58. ^ Epictetus, Discourses, i.12.16–17
  59. ^ Epictetus, Discourses, iii.2.4
  60. ^ Epictetus, Discourses, iii.20.4–14
  61. ^ Epictetus, Discourses, ii.10.4–5
  62. ^ Epictetus, Discourses, i.2.33–37; Enchiridion, 24, 37
  63. ^ Heinrich Ritter, Alexander James William Morrison, (1846), The History of Ancient Philosophy, Volume 4, p. 220
  64. ^ Epictetus, Enchiridion, 11, 15
  65. ^ Epictetus, Discourses, i.29.29; iii.24.97–101
  66. ^ Heinrich Ritter, Alexander James William Morrison, (1846), The History of Ancient Philosophy, Volume 4, p. 210
  67. ^ Epictetus, Discourses, i.18.6–8; i.28.9–10
  68. ^ a b Heinrich Ritter, Alexander James William Morrison, (1846), The History of Ancient Philosophy, Volume 4, p. 211
  69. ^ Heinrich Ritter, Alexander James William Morrison, (1846), The History of Ancient Philosophy, Volume 4, p. 212
  70. ^ a b c Boter, Gerard J. (2011). "Epictetus". In Brown, Virginia; Hankins, James; Kaster, Robert A. (eds.). Catalogus Translationum Et Commentariorum: Medieval and Renaissance Latin Translations and Commentaries. Vol. 9. The Catholic University of America Press. p. 6. ISBN 978-0813217291.
  71. ^ Stanton, G. R. (1969). "Marcus Aurelius, Emperor and Philosopher". Historia: Zeitschrift für Alte Geschichte. 18 (5): 570–587. JSTOR 4435105.
  72. ^ Kors, Alan Charles (1990). Atheism in France, 1650–1729, Volume 1: The Orthodox Sources of Disbelief. Princeton, New Jersey: Princeton University Press. p. 188. ISBN 0691055750.
  73. ^ The Rebirth of Stoicism December 31, 2009, at the Wayback Machine
  74. ^ Laurence Sterne, The Life and Opinions of Tristram Shandy, Gentleman, ed. Ian Campbell Ross (Oxford Univ. Press, 1983), p. 540.
  75. ^ pp. 202–203 of the Penguin Edition.
  76. ^ Matthew Arnold, To A Friend
  77. ^ Stockdale, James Bond. 1993. Courage Under Fire: Testing Epictetus's Doctrines in a Laboratory of Human Behavior. Stanford: Hoover Institution/Stanford University.
  78. ^ Obituary: Vice Admiral James Stockdale The Guardian 2005
  79. ^ B., Stockdale, James (1995). Thoughts of a philosophical fighter pilot. Stanford, Calif.: Hoover Institution Press. ISBN 0817993916. OCLC 32625408.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
  80. ^ Green, Adam (2003-10-13). "Ageless, Guiltless". The New Yorker.
  81. ^ Schatzman, Morton (2007-07-30). . The Independent. Archived from the original on 2007-10-18.
  82. ^ Burkeman, Oliver (2007-08-10). "Albert Ellis: Influential American psychologist who led the revolution in cognitive therapy". The Guardian.
  83. ^ Blum, Mark L. (1988). "Kiyozawa Manshi and the Meaning of Buddhist Ethics". The Eastern Buddhist. 21 (1): 63. ISSN 0012-8708. JSTOR 44361820. A year after his study of the Āgamas, he received a copy of the Stoic philosopher Epictetus from his disciple Akegarasu Haya, and again Kiyozawa was deeply moved.
  • Origen's Contra Celcus, Book vii, episode is in chapter LIII, with a secondary mention of the episode in chapter LIV.

Further reading edit

Primary sources
Studies
  • Jonathan Barnes, Logic and Imperial Stoa, Leiden: Brill, 1997 (Chapter Three: Epictetuts, pp. 24–127).[ISBN missing]
  • Adolf Friedrich Bonhoffer, The Ethics of the Stoic Epictetus, William O. Stephens trans., Bern: Peter Lang, 2000 ISBN 0820451398.
  • Michel Foucault, The Hermeneutics of the Subject: Lectures at the Collège de France, 1981–1982, New York: Picador, 2005 ISBN 0312425708.
  • Pedro P. Fuentes González. art. "Épictète", in R. Goulet (ed.), Dictionnaire des Philosophes Antiques III, Paris, CNRS, 2000, pp. 106–151 ISBN 2271057485
  • Ryan Holiday; Stephen Hanselman (2020). "Epictetus the Free Man". Lives of the Stoics. New York: Portfolio/Penguin. pp. 250–266. ISBN 978-0525541875.
  • Brian E. Johnson, The Role Ethics of Epictetus: Stoicism in Ordinary Life, Lanham: Lexington Books, 2014 ISBN 978-0739179673.
  • A. A. Long, Epictetus: A Stoic and Socratic Guide to Life, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2002 ISBN 0199245568.
  • Theodore Scaltsas, Andrew S. Mason (ed.), The Philosophy of Epictetus. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2007 ISBN 978-0199585519.
  • Keith Seddon, Epictetus' Handbook and the Tablet of Cebes: Guides to Stoic Living, Routledge, 2005.
  • Werner Sohn, Epictetus: Ein erzkonservativer Bildungsroman mit liberalen Eselsohren (German version) Norderstedt: BoD, 2010 ISBN 978-3839152317.
  • William O. Stephens, Stoic Ethics: Epictetus and Happiness as Freedom, London: Continuum, 2007 ISBN 0826496083.

External links edit

epictetus, this, article, about, philosopher, vase, painter, epiktetos, confused, with, epicurus, this, article, lead, section, short, adequately, summarize, points, please, consider, expanding, lead, provide, accessible, overview, important, aspects, article,. This article is about the philosopher For the vase painter see Epiktetos Not to be confused with Epicurus This article s lead section may be too short to adequately summarize the key points Please consider expanding the lead to provide an accessible overview of all important aspects of the article October 2023 Epictetus ˌ ɛ p ɪ k ˈ t iː t e s EH pick TEE tess 3 Greek Ἐpikthtos Epiktetos c 50 c 135 AD was a Greek Stoic philosopher 4 5 He was born into slavery at Hierapolis Phrygia present day Pamukkale in western Turkey and lived in Rome until his banishment when he went to Nicopolis in northwestern Greece where he spent the rest of his life His teachings were written down and published by his pupil Arrian in his Discourses and Enchiridion Epictetus18th century portrait of Epictetus including his crutchBornc AD 50 Hierapolis Phrygia presumed now Pamukkale Denizli Turkey Diedc 135 aged c 85 Nicopolis Epirus now Preveza Epirus Greece 2 Notable workDiscourses EnchiridionEraHellenistic philosophyRegionWestern philosophySchoolStoicismMain interestsEthicsNotable ideasMemento mori 1 Epictetus taught that philosophy is a way of life and not simply a theoretical discipline To Epictetus all external events are beyond our control he argues that we should accept whatever happens calmly and dispassionately However individuals are responsible for their own actions which they can examine and control through rigorous self discipline Contents 1 Life 2 Thought 3 Influence 3 1 Dialogue between the Emperor Hadrian and Epictetus 3 2 Philosophy 3 2 1 Marcus Aurelius 3 2 2 Philosophers of the French Enlightenment 3 3 Literature 3 3 1 Francois Rabelais 3 4 Military 3 4 1 James Stockdale 3 5 Psychology 3 6 Religion 4 See also 5 Notes 6 Further reading 7 External linksLife editEpictetus was born around AD 50 6 7 presumably at Hierapolis Phrygia 8 The name his parents gave him is unknown The word epiktetos ἐpikthtos in Greek simply means gained or acquired 9 the Greek philosopher Plato in his Laws used the term to mean property that is added to one s hereditary property 10 He spent his youth in Rome as a slave to Epaphroditus a wealthy freedman and secretary to Nero 11 His social position was thus complicated combining the low status of a slave with the high status of one with a personal connection to Imperial power 12 Early in life Epictetus acquired a passion for philosophy and with the permission of his wealthy master he studied Stoic philosophy under Musonius Rufus 13 Becoming more educated in this way raised his social status 14 At some point he became disabled Celsus quoted by Origen wrote that this was because his leg had been deliberately broken by his master 15 Simplicius in contrast wrote that Epictetus had been disabled from childhood 16 nbsp Roman era ruins the Nymphaeum at NicopolisEpictetus obtained his freedom sometime after the death of Nero in AD 68 17 and he began to teach philosophy in Rome Around AD 93 when the Roman emperor Domitian banished all philosophers from the city 18 Epictetus moved to Nicopolis in Epirus Greece where he founded a school of philosophy 19 His most famous pupil Arrian studied under him as a young man around AD 108 and claimed to have written his famous Discourses based on the notes he took on Epictetus s lectures Arrian argued that his Discourses should be considered comparable to the Socratic literature 20 Arrian described Epictetus as a powerful speaker who could induce his listener to feel just what Epictetus wanted him to feel 21 Many eminent figures sought conversations with him 22 Emperor Hadrian was friendly with him 23 and may have heard him speak at his school in Nicopolis 24 25 Epictetus lived a life of great simplicity with few possessions 16 He lived alone for a long time 26 but in his old age he adopted a friend s child who otherwise would have been left to die and raised him with the aid of a woman 27 It is unclear whether Epictetus and she were married 28 He died sometime around AD 135 29 After his death according to Lucian his oil lamp was purchased by an admirer for 3 000 drachmae 30 Thought edit nbsp An eighteenth century engraving of EpictetusNo writings by Epictetus are known His discourses were transcribed and compiled by his pupil Arrian c 86 89 c after 146 160 AD 21 The main work is The Discourses four books of which have been preserved out of the original eight 31 Arrian also compiled a popular digest entitled the Enchiridion or Handbook In a preface to the Discourses that is addressed to Lucius Gellius Arrian states that whatever I heard him say I used to write down word for word as best I could endeavouring to preserve it as a memorial for my own future use of his way of thinking and the frankness of his speech 21 In the sixth century the Neoplatonist philosopher Simplicius wrote an extant commentary on the Enchiridion 32 Epictetus maintains that the foundation of all philosophy is self knowledge that is the conviction of our ignorance and gullibility ought to be the first subject of our study 33 Logic provides valid reasoning and certainty in judgment but it is subordinate to practical needs 34 The first and most necessary part of philosophy concerns the application of doctrine for example that people should not lie The second concerns reasons e g why people should not lie While the third lastly examines and establishes the reasons 35 This is the logical part which finds reasons shows what is a reason and that a given reason is a correct one 35 This last part is necessary but only on account of the second which again is rendered necessary by the first 36 Both the Discourses and the Enchiridion begin by distinguishing between those things in our power prohairetic things and those things not in our power aprohairetic things 37 That alone is in our power which is our own work and in this class are our opinions impulses desires and aversions On the contrary what is not in our power are our bodies possessions glory and power Any delusion on this point leads to the greatest errors misfortunes and troubles and to the slavery of the soul 38 We have no power over external things and the good that ought to be the object of our earnest pursuit is to be found only within ourselves 39 The determination between what is good and what is not good is made by the capacity for choice prohairesis 40 Prohairesis allows us to act and gives us the kind of freedom that only rational animals have 41 It is determined by our reason which of all our faculties sees and tests itself and everything else 42 It is the correct use of the impressions phantasia that bombard the mind that is in our power 43 Practice then from the start to say to every harsh impression You are an impression and not at all the thing you appear to be Then examine it and test it by these rules you have and firstly and chiefly by this whether the impression has to do with the things that are up to us or those that are not and if it has to do with the things that are not up to us be ready to reply It is nothing to me 44 We will not be troubled at any loss but will say to ourselves on such an occasion I have lost nothing that belongs to me it was not something of mine that was torn from me but something that was not in my power has left me Nothing beyond the use of our opinion is properly ours Every possession rests on opinion What is to cry and to weep An opinion What is misfortune or a quarrel or a complaint All these things are opinions opinions founded on the delusion that what is not subject to our own choice can be either good or evil which it cannot 39 By rejecting these opinions and seeking good and evil in the power of choice alone we may confidently achieve peace of mind in every condition of life 45 Reason alone is good the irrational is evil and the irrational is intolerable to the rational 46 The good person should labour chiefly on their own reason to perfect this is in our power 47 To repel evil opinions by the good is the noble contest in which humans should engage it is not an easy task but it promises true freedom peace of mind ataraxia and a divine command over the emotions apatheia 48 We should especially be on our guard against the opinion of pleasure because of its apparent sweetness and charms 49 The first object of philosophy therefore is to purify the mind 50 Epictetus teaches that the preconceptions prolepsis of good and evil are common to all 51 Good alone is profitable and to be desired and evil is hurtful and to be avoided 52 Different opinions arise only from the application of these preconceptions to particular cases and it is then that the darkness of ignorance which blindly maintains the correctness of its own opinion must be dispelled 51 People entertain different and conflicting opinions of good and in their judgment of a particular good people frequently contradict themselves 53 Philosophy should provide a standard for good and evil 54 This process is greatly facilitated because the mind and the works of the mind are alone in our power whereas all external things that aid life are beyond our control 54 The essence of divinity is goodness we have all good that could be given to us 55 The deities too gave us the soul and reason which is not measured by breadth or depth but by knowledge and sentiments and by which we attain to greatness and may equal even with the deities We should therefore cultivate the mind with special care 56 If we wish for nothing but what God wills we shall be truly free and all will come to pass with us according to our desire and we shall be as little subject to restraint as Zeus himself 57 Every individual is connected with the rest of the world and the universe is fashioned for universal harmony 56 Wise people therefore will pursue not merely their own will but also will be subject to the rightful order of the world 58 We should conduct ourselves through life fulfilling all our duties as children siblings parents and citizens 59 For our country or friends we ought to be ready to undergo or perform the greatest difficulties 60 The good person if able to foresee the future would peacefully and contentedly help to bring about their own sickness maiming and even death knowing that this is the correct order of the universe 61 We have all a certain part to play in the world and we have done enough when we have performed what our nature allows 62 In the exercise of our powers we may become aware of the destiny we are intended to fulfil 63 We are like travellers at an inn or guests at a stranger s table whatever is offered we take with thankfulness and sometimes when the turn comes we may refuse in the former case we are a worthy guest of the deities and in the latter we appear as a sharer in their power 64 Anyone who finds life intolerable is free to quit it but we should not abandon our appointed role without sufficient reason 65 The Stoic sage will never find life intolerable and will complain of no one neither deity nor human 66 Those who go wrong we should pardon and treat with compassion since it is from ignorance that they err being as it were blind 67 It is only our opinions and principles that can render us unhappy and it is only the ignorant person who finds fault with another 68 Every desire degrades us and renders us slaves of what we desire 68 We ought not to forget the transitory character of all external advantages even in the midst of our enjoyment of them but always to bear in mind that they are not our own and that therefore they do not properly belong to us Thus prepared we shall never be carried away by opinions 69 The final entry of the Enchiridion or Handbook begins Upon all occasions we ought to have these maxims ready at hand Conduct me Zeus and thou Destiny Wherever thy decree has fixed my lot I follow willingly and did I not Wicked and wretched would I follow still Diogenes Laertius quoting Cleanthes quoted also by Seneca Epistle 107 Whoe er yields properly to Fate is deemed Wise among men and knows the laws of Heaven From Euripides Fragments 965 Crito if it thus pleases the gods thus let it be From Plato s Crito Anytus and Meletus may indeed kill me but they cannot harm me From Plato s Apology Influence editDialogue between the Emperor Hadrian and Epictetus edit nbsp Hadrian and Epictetus 15th century manuscript Bodleian libraryMain article Altercatio Hadriani Augusti et Epicteti philosophi Epictetus appears in a 2nd or 3rd century Dialogue between the Emperor Hadrian and Epictetus the Philosopher 70 This short Latin text consists of seventy three short questions supposedly posed by Hadrian and answered by Epictetus 70 This dialogue was very popular in the Middle Ages with many translations and adaptations 70 Philosophy edit Marcus Aurelius edit The philosophy of Epictetus influenced the Roman emperor Marcus Aurelius AD 121 to AD 180 who cites Epictetus in his Meditations 71 Philosophers of the French Enlightenment edit Voltaire Montesquieu Denis Diderot and Baron d Holbach all read the Enchiridion when they were students 72 Literature edit The philosophy of Epictetus plays a key role in the 1998 novel A Man in Full by Tom Wolfe This was in part the outcome of discussions Wolfe had with James Stockdale see below The character Conrad who through a series of mishaps finds himself in jail and accidentally acquires a copy of the Enchiridion of Epictetus the Stoic s manual discovers a philosophy that strengthens him to endure the brutality of the prison environment He experiences Joseph Campbell s hero s journey call to action and becomes a strong honorable undefeatable protagonist The importance of Epictetus Stoicism for Stockdale its role in A Man in Full and its significance in Ridley Scott s film Gladiator are discussed by William O Stephens in The Rebirth of Stoicism 73 Mohun Biswas in the novel A House for Mr Biswas 1961 by V S Naipaul is pleased to think himself a follower of Epictetus and Marcus Aurelius the irony is that he never actually behaves as a Stoic Everything has two handles the one by which it may be carried the other by which it cannot is the theme of Disturbances in the Field 1983 by Lynne Sharon Schwartz Lydia the central character turns often to The Golden Sayings of Epictetus the latter being a modern selection from Epictetus s writings compiled and translated by Hastings Crossley A line from the Enchiridion is used as a title quotation in The Life and Opinions of Tristram Shandy Gentleman by Laurence Sterne which translates to Not things but opinions about things trouble men 74 Epictetus is mentioned in A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man by James Joyce in the fifth chapter of the novel the protagonist Stephen Dedalus discusses Epictetus s famous lamp with a dean of his college 75 Epictetus also is mentioned briefly in Franny and Zooey by J D Salinger and is referred to by Theodore Dreiser in his novel Sister Carrie Both the longevity of Epictetus s life and his philosophy are alluded to in John Berryman s poem Of Suicide Epictetus is referred to but not mentioned by name in Matthew Arnold s sonnet To a Friend Arnold provides three historical personalities as his inspiration and support in difficult times Epictetus is preceded by Homer and succeeded by Sophocles Much he whose friendship I not long since won That halting slave who in Nicopolis Taught Arrian when Vespasian s brutal sonCleared Rome of what most shamed him 76 Francois Rabelais edit In the Chapter XXX of Francois Rabelais Pantagruel c 1532 Pantagruel s tutor Epistemon had his head cut off after a battle After he had his head reattached and was brought back to life he recounts his experience of the damned in hell Their estate and condition of living is but only changed after a very strange manner After this manner those that had been great lords and ladies here got but a poor scurvy wretched living there below And on the contrary the philosophers and others who in this world had been altogether indigent and wanting were great lords there in their turn I saw Epictetus there most gallantly apparelled after the French fashion sitting under a pleasant arbour with store of handsome gentlewomen frolicking drinking dancing and making good cheer with abundance of crowns of the sun Above the lattice were written these verses for his device To leap and dance to sport and play And drink good wine both white and brown Or nothing else do all the day But tell bags full of many a crown When he saw me he invited me to drink with him very courteously and I was willing to be entreated tippled and chopined together most theologically In the meantime came Cyrus to beg one farthing of him for the honour of Mercury therewith to buy a few onions for his supper No no said Epictetus I do not use in my almsgiving to bestow farthings Hold thou varlet there s a crown for thee be an honest man Military edit James Stockdale edit nbsp Prisoner of war James Stockdale receiving the Medal of Honor from American president Gerald Ford Stockdale claims he was able to retain his sanity during capture by relying on the philosophy of EpictetusJames Stockdale a fighter pilot who was shot down while serving in the Vietnam War was influenced by Epictetus He was introduced to his works while at Stanford University In Courage under Fire Testing Epictetus s Doctrines in a Laboratory of Human Behavior 1993 Stockdale credits Epictetus with helping him endure his seven and a half years in captivity which included torture and four years in solitary confinement 77 When he was shot down he reportedly said to himself I m leaving the world of technology and entering the world of Epictetus as he bailed out 78 Quoting Epictetus Stockdale concludes the book with The emotions of grief pity and even affection are well known disturbers of the soul Grief is the most offensive Epictetus considered the suffering of grief an act of evil It is a willful act going against the will of God to have all men share happiness 79 Psychology edit Psychologist Albert Ellis the founder of Rational Emotive Behavior Therapy credited Epictetus with providing a foundation for his system of psychotherapy 80 81 82 Religion edit Kiyozawa Manshi a controversial reformer within the Higashi Honganji branch of Jodo Shinshu Buddhism cited Epictetus as one of the three major influences on his spiritual development and thought 83 See also editList of slavesNotes edit Discourses of Epictetus 3 24 Nicopolis Actia Greece Britannica www britannica com Jones Daniel Roach Peter James Hartman and Jane Setter eds Cambridge English Pronouncing Dictionary 17th edition Cambridge UP 2006 Elizabeth Carter Epictetus 9 July 2017 The Complete Works of Epictetus Independently Published ISBN 978 1521800355 Rowan Stevens 28 February 2022 Wise Quotes Epictetus 294 Epictetus Quotes Greek Stoic Philosophy Quote Collections Epicurean Rowan Stevens ISBN 978 1636051833 Graver Margaret Epictetus In Zalta Edward N ed Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy The year of his birth is uncertain He was born a slave We do know that he was born early enough to be teaching philosophy by around AD 93 when Domitian banished all philosophers from Rome because he was among those who left the city He also described himself as an old man to Arrian around 108 AD cf Discourses i 9 10 i 16 20 ii 6 23 etc Suda Epictetus Greek Word Study Tool www perseus tufts edu Plato Laws section 924a www perseus tufts edu Epaphroditus livius org P Christoforou Imagining the Roman Emperor 2023 p 22 Epictetus Discourses i 7 32 Epictetus Discourses i 9 29 Origen Contra Celcus vii a b Simplicius Commentary on the Enchiridion 13 Douglas J Soccio Archetypes of Wisdom An Introduction to Philosophy 2012 p 197 Suetonius Domitian x Aulus Gellius Attic Nights xv 11 Hendrik Selle Dichtung oder Wahrheit Der Autor der Epiktetischen Predigten Philologus 145 2001 269 290 a b c Epictetus Discourses prologue Epictetus Discourses i 11 ii 14 iii 4 iii 7 etc Historia Augusta Hadrian 16 Fox Robin The Classical World An Epic History from Homer to Hadrian Basic Books 2006 p 578 A surviving second or third century work Altercatio Hadriani Et Epicteti gives a fictitious account of a conversation between Hadrian and Epictetus Simplicius Commentary on the Enchiridion 46 There is a joke at Epictetus expense in Lucian s Life of Demonax about the fact that he had no family Simplicius Commentary on the Enchiridion 46 It is possible that he married her but Simplicius language on that subject is ambiguous Lucian Demoxan c 55 torn ii ed Hemsterh p 393 as quoted in A Selection from the Discourses of Epictetus With the Encheiridion 2009 p 6 He apparently was alive in the reign of Hadrian 117 138 Marcus Aurelius born AD 121 was an admirer but never met him and Aulus Gellius ii 18 10 writing mid century speaks of him as if he belonged to the recent past Lucian Remarks to an illiterate book lover Photius Bibliotheca states that there were eight books George Long 1890 The Discourses of Epictetus with the Encheridion and Fragments p 390 George Bell and Sons Epictetus Discourses ii 11 1 Epictetus Discourses i 7 1 8 a b Heinrich Ritter Alexander James William Morrison 1846 The History of Ancient Philosophy Volume 4 p 201 Epictetus Discourses iii 2 1 6 Enchiridion 52 Epictetus Discourses i 1 Enchiridion 1 Heinrich Ritter Alexander James William Morrison 1846 The History of Ancient Philosophy Volume 4 p 204 a b Heinrich Ritter Alexander James William Morrison 1846 The History of Ancient Philosophy Volume 4 p 206 Giovanni Reale John R Catan 1990 A History of Ancient Philosophy The schools of the Imperial Age p 80 SUNY Press Christopher Gill 1995 The Discourses of Epictetus p xx Everyman Epictetus Discourses i 1 4 i 20 Epictetus Discourses ii 19 32 Epictetus Enchiridion 1 Epictetus Discourses iii 3 14 19 Enchiridion 6 Epictetus Discourses i 2 1 Epictetus Discourses iii 8 iii 15 1 13 Enchiridion 29 Epictetus Discourses ii 18 19 31 iii 3 14 22 Epictetus Enchiridion 34 Heinrich Ritter Alexander James William Morrison 1846 The History of Ancient Philosophy Volume 4 p 207 a b Heinrich Ritter Alexander James William Morrison 1846 The History of Ancient Philosophy Volume 4 p 208 Epictetus Discourses i 22 1 ii 11 3 Epictetus Discourses ii 11 8 13 iii 14 11 14 a b Heinrich Ritter Alexander James William Morrison 1846 The History of Ancient Philosophy Volume 4 p 209 Heinrich Ritter Alexander James William Morrison 1846 The History of Ancient Philosophy Volume 4 p 217 a b Heinrich Ritter Alexander James William Morrison 1846 The History of Ancient Philosophy Volume 4 p 218 Epictetus Discourses ii 17 22 33 Epictetus Discourses i 12 16 17 Epictetus Discourses iii 2 4 Epictetus Discourses iii 20 4 14 Epictetus Discourses ii 10 4 5 Epictetus Discourses i 2 33 37 Enchiridion 24 37 Heinrich Ritter Alexander James William Morrison 1846 The History of Ancient Philosophy Volume 4 p 220 Epictetus Enchiridion 11 15 Epictetus Discourses i 29 29 iii 24 97 101 Heinrich Ritter Alexander James William Morrison 1846 The History of Ancient Philosophy Volume 4 p 210 Epictetus Discourses i 18 6 8 i 28 9 10 a b Heinrich Ritter Alexander James William Morrison 1846 The History of Ancient Philosophy Volume 4 p 211 Heinrich Ritter Alexander James William Morrison 1846 The History of Ancient Philosophy Volume 4 p 212 a b c Boter Gerard J 2011 Epictetus In Brown Virginia Hankins James Kaster Robert A eds Catalogus Translationum Et Commentariorum Medieval and Renaissance Latin Translations and Commentaries Vol 9 The Catholic University of America Press p 6 ISBN 978 0813217291 Stanton G R 1969 Marcus Aurelius Emperor and Philosopher Historia Zeitschrift fur Alte Geschichte 18 5 570 587 JSTOR 4435105 Kors Alan Charles 1990 Atheism in France 1650 1729 Volume 1 The Orthodox Sources of Disbelief Princeton New Jersey Princeton University Press p 188 ISBN 0691055750 The Rebirth of Stoicism Archived December 31 2009 at the Wayback Machine Laurence Sterne The Life and Opinions of Tristram Shandy Gentleman ed Ian Campbell Ross Oxford Univ Press 1983 p 540 pp 202 203 of the Penguin Edition Matthew Arnold To A Friend Stockdale James Bond 1993 Courage Under Fire Testing Epictetus s Doctrines in a Laboratory of Human Behavior Stanford Hoover Institution Stanford University Obituary Vice Admiral James Stockdale The Guardian 2005 B Stockdale James 1995 Thoughts of a philosophical fighter pilot Stanford Calif Hoover Institution Press ISBN 0817993916 OCLC 32625408 a href Template Cite book html title Template Cite book cite book a CS1 maint multiple names authors list link Green Adam 2003 10 13 Ageless Guiltless The New Yorker Schatzman Morton 2007 07 30 Albert Ellis Psychotherapist who preached a rational behavioural approach The Independent Archived from the original on 2007 10 18 Burkeman Oliver 2007 08 10 Albert Ellis Influential American psychologist who led the revolution in cognitive therapy The Guardian Blum Mark L 1988 Kiyozawa Manshi and the Meaning of Buddhist Ethics The Eastern Buddhist 21 1 63 ISSN 0012 8708 JSTOR 44361820 A year after his study of the Agamas he received a copy of the Stoic philosopher Epictetus from his disciple Akegarasu Haya and again Kiyozawa was deeply moved Origen s Contra Celcus Book vii episode is in chapter LIII with a secondary mention of the episode in chapter LIV Further reading editPrimary sourcesAll the Works of Epictetus Which are Now Extant Elizabeth Carter trans 1758 ISBN 978 1171001867 The Complete Works Handbook Discourses and Fragments Robin Waterfield trans 2022 ISBN 978 0226769479 Discourses Fragments Handbook Robin Hard trans Oxford Oxford University Press 2014 ISBN 978 0199595181 Discourses and Selected Writings Robert Dobbin trans Oxford Penguin Classics 2008 ISBN 978 0140449464 The Discourses The Handbook Fragments Robin Hard trans Christopher Gill contrib Everyman Edition 2003 ISBN 0460873121 Epictetus Discourses Book 1 Robert Dobbin trans Clarendon Later Ancient Philosophers Oxford Clarendon Press 1998 ISBN 0198236646 The Handbook Nicholas P White trans Indianapolis Hackett 1983 ISBN 0915145693 Enchiridion George Long trans New York A L Burt 1955 reprint New York Dover 2004 ISBN 0879757035 The Discourses trans W A Oldfather 2 vols Loeb Classical Library edition Cambridge MA Harvard University Press 1925 and 1928 ISBN 0674991451 0674992407 Moral Discourses Enchiridion and Fragments Elizabeth Carter trans W H D Rouse Ed London J M Dent amp Sons 1910 at Open LibraryStudiesJonathan Barnes Logic and Imperial Stoa Leiden Brill 1997 Chapter Three Epictetuts pp 24 127 ISBN missing Adolf Friedrich Bonhoffer The Ethics of the Stoic Epictetus William O Stephens trans Bern Peter Lang 2000 ISBN 0820451398 Michel Foucault The Hermeneutics of the Subject Lectures at the College de France 1981 1982 New York Picador 2005 ISBN 0312425708 Pedro P Fuentes Gonzalez art Epictete in R Goulet ed Dictionnaire des Philosophes Antiques III Paris CNRS 2000 pp 106 151 ISBN 2271057485 Ryan Holiday Stephen Hanselman 2020 Epictetus the Free Man Lives of the Stoics New York Portfolio Penguin pp 250 266 ISBN 978 0525541875 Brian E Johnson The Role Ethics of Epictetus Stoicism in Ordinary Life Lanham Lexington Books 2014 ISBN 978 0739179673 A A Long Epictetus A Stoic and Socratic Guide to Life Oxford Oxford University Press 2002 ISBN 0199245568 Theodore Scaltsas Andrew S Mason ed The Philosophy of Epictetus Oxford Oxford University Press 2007 ISBN 978 0199585519 Keith Seddon Epictetus Handbook and the Tablet of Cebes Guides to Stoic Living Routledge 2005 Werner Sohn Epictetus Ein erzkonservativer Bildungsroman mit liberalen Eselsohren German version Norderstedt BoD 2010 ISBN 978 3839152317 William O Stephens Stoic Ethics Epictetus and Happiness as Freedom London Continuum 2007 ISBN 0826496083 External links editEpictetus at Wikipedia s sister projects nbsp Definitions from Wiktionary nbsp Media from Commons nbsp Quotations from Wikiquote nbsp Texts from Wikisource nbsp Data from Wikidata nbsp Greek Wikisource has original text related to this article Ἐpikthtos Works by Epictetus in eBook form at Standard Ebooks Works by Epictetus at Project Gutenberg Works by or about Epictetus at Internet Archive Works by Epictetus at LibriVox public domain audiobooks nbsp Works by Epictetus at the Internet Classics Archive Works by Epictetus at the Stoic Therapy eLibrary Graver Margaret Epictetus In Zalta Edward N ed Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy Epictetus Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy Dialogue between Hadrian and Epictetus a fictitious 2nd or 3rd century composition translated into English in The Knickerbocker magazine August 1857 Commentary on the Enchiridion of Epictetus by Simplicius of Cilicia 6th century Stockdale on Stoicism I The Stoic Warrior s Triad Archived 2021 07 16 at the Wayback Machine by James Stockdale Who Was Epictetus Stockdale on Stoicism II Master of My Fate Archived 2021 07 16 at the Wayback Machine by James Stockdale Epicteti dissertationes ab Arriano digestae Heinrich Schenkl ed Lipsiae in aedibus B G Teubneri 1916 Portals nbsp Ancient Greece nbsp Philosophy nbsp Biography Retrieved from https en wikipedia org w index php title Epictetus amp oldid 1206998566, wikipedia, wiki, book, books, library,

article

, read, download, free, free download, mp3, video, mp4, 3gp, jpg, jpeg, gif, png, picture, music, song, movie, book, game, games.