Z-class Melbourne tram

The Z-class are single-unit bogie trams that operate on the Melbourne tram network. Between 1975 and 1983, 230 trams spanning three sub-classes were built by Comeng, Dandenong. The design was based on two similar Gothenburg tram models, and a prototype built by the Melbourne & Metropolitan Tramways Board. While the Z1 and Z2-class trams were very similar, the Z3-class had significant design changes.

Z-class
Z3 139 on Swanston Street in December 2013
Refurbished Z3 class interior
Manufacturer	Comeng
Designer	Melbourne & Metropolitan Tramways Board
Assembly	Dandenong
Constructed	1975–1983
Entered service	1975
Number built	230
Number in service	87
Number preserved	6
Number scrapped	34
Successor	Z1/Z2: C1, D, and E classes Z3: G1-class
Fleet numbers	Z1 1–Z1 100 Z2 101–Z2 115 Z3 116–Z3 230
Capacity	Z1/Z2: 48/70 Z3: 42/70 (seated/standing)
Depots	Brunswick Essendon Glenhuntly Malvern
Specifications
Train length	Z1/Z2: 16 m (52 ft 6 in) Z3: 16.64 m (54 ft 7 in)
Width	2.67 m (8 ft 9 in)
Height	Z1/Z2: 3.55 m (11 ft 8 in) Z3: 3.41 m (11 ft 2 in)
Doors	4 double, 2 single (Z3 only)
Wheel diameter	Z1/Z2: 680 mm (27 in) Z3: 660 mm (26 in)
Wheelbase	1.8 m (5 ft 11 in)
Maximum speed	70–72 km/h (43–45 mph) (design) 60 km/h (37 mph) (service)
Weight	Z1/Z2: 19 t (19 long tons; 21 short tons) Z3: 21.8 t (21.5 long tons; 24.0 short tons)
Traction system	Z1/Z2: ASEA Tramiac resistance control Z3: AEG/Siemens chopper control
Traction motors	Z1/Z2: 4 × ASEA LJB 23/2 57 kW (76 hp) Z3: 2 × AEG ABS 3322^[1] 195 kW (261 hp)
Power output	Z1/Z2: 228 kW (306 hp) Z3: 390 kW (520 hp)
Acceleration	1.5 m/s^2 (4.9 ft/s^2)
Deceleration	1.6 m/s^2 (5.2 ft/s^2) (Dynamic braking) 1.4 m/s^2 (4.6 ft/s^2) (Mechanical braking) 3 m/s^2 (9.8 ft/s^2) (Emergency)
Electric system(s)	600 V DC (nominal) from overhead catenary
Current collector(s)	Pantograph
UIC classification	Bo′Bo′ (Z1/Z2) B′B′ (Z3)
Bogies	Z1/Z2: ASEA Z3: Duewag tandem-drive
Track gauge	1,435 mm (4 ft 8+1⁄2 in) standard gauge
Notes/references
^[2]^[3]^[4]^[1]

Since introduction they have had a variety of liveries, and modifications. The Z1 and Z2-class trams have been retired, with 87 Z3-class trams remaining in service.

History

 

Gothenburg, M29 (front) and M28 (rear) trams, the inspiration for the prototype PCC 1041 and Z-class trams

 

Preserved prototype PCC 1041, in Melbourne & Metropolitan Tramways Board's marigold livery, at the Hawthorn Tram Museum in October 2023

When Melbourne & Metropolitan Tramways Board (MMTB) staff were sent to Europe in 1965 to investigate other tramway operations, they took interest in Swedish trams, and upon return in 1966 drew up specifications, and had a timber mockup built. This mockup was to be the basis for a new tram design for Melbourne. The MMTB approved of the design, and in 1972 requested a prototype be constructed, the result was PCC 1041 being built at Preston Workshops. It was 'European in appearance' and utilised some components bought new, and many recycled from an earlier prototype tram, PCC 980.^{[5]: 195–196} Prototype PCC 1041 became the basis of the Z-class trams, influenced by the M28 design running in Gothenburg, Sweden. PCC 1041 was to be launched by Premier Rupert Hamer on 26 August 1973, but the tram failed at the launch in front of the media. Due to constant electrical failures, PCC 1041 was infrequently used and was out of service between April 1975 and October 1976. PCC 1041 was finally withdrawn in 1984.^[6]

Despite the failure of PCC 1041, 100 Z1-class trams were ordered. Between 1974 and 1983, a total of 230 Z1 to Z3-class trams were built by Comeng at Dandenong.^{[5]: 197 [7]: 32}

Between 1995 and 1999, the remaining 106 Z1s and Z2s were refurbished by Goninan.^[8] The bodies were overhauled in an area of Preston Workshops allocated to Goninan, and the bogies were sent to Goninan's Auburn, New South Wales facility. On all except four, the flap type destination displays and route number indicators were replaced by dot-matrix displays.^[9][10][11]

When the Melbourne tram network was privatised in August 1998, M>Tram was allocated 94 Z1s, 12 Z2s and 84 Z3s, and Yarra Trams received 31 Z3s. Yarra Trams later transferred its Z3s to M>Tram in 2002 as the C class trams arrived to replace them. Yarra Trams’ former units were either refurbished and repainted in M>Tram livery or left in the former Met Green & Yellow livery after their transfer to M>Tram^[12]

It was envisaged that the delivery of the C and D class trams would allow for the Z1 and Z2s to be retired after the 2006 Commonwealth Games, but rising patronage levels necessitated the retention of 30 Z1 and three Z2s until the E class trams entered service from 2014. Half of those remained in service in December 2015,^[11] and the last were withdrawn in April 2016.^[9]

In late 2007, the Z3s with analogue signage were fitted with digital signage, replacing the original rolling route destination displays.^[11][13]

Liveries

The Z1 and Z2s were delivered in a livery of marigold (orange) with oriental gold roof; the first four or so were numbered with W2 gold-and-black transfers, but were later changed to the same off-white-and-black as carried by rest of the Z-type in Marigold or Deep Yellow livery. The Z3s were delivered in a livery of deep yellow (pale orange) with a burmese gold roof. For both liveries, the window-level panels were painted off-white (officially "string"), and skirt panels below floor-level were chocolate brown to match the bogies and wheels. From Z3 223 onwards, all were delivered in the Metropolitan Transit Authority's olympic green and wattle yellow livery.^[14]

Subclasses

 

Z1 95 in Metropolitan Transit Authority livery on Swanston Street in September 2006

 

Z1 78 on St Kilda Road in February 2013

 

Interior of a Z1-class in December 2013

The initial 80 were classified as the 'Z class. After modifications were made to the suspension, the next 20 entered service as the Z1 class. As the first 80 received these modifications, they were reclassified as Z1s.^[15] The next two batches were delivered as the Z2 and Z3s'.^[9]

Z1-class

In 1972 Rupert Hamer became Premier of Victoria, promising new trams, which had been highlighted as needed in the 1969 Melbourne Transportation Plan. Comeng, in anticipation of a tender, dispatched workers to Europe who, knowing of the fondness within the MMTB of the Swedish tram design, acquired the plans for the Gothenburg M29 tram from Hägglund & Söner. It was understood that ASEA would supply the electrical equipment, as they had been involved in the supply of equipment for the Gothenburg M28 which was almost identical to the Gothenburg M29 trams, and had recently acquired the rolling stock division of Hägglund & Söner.^{[5]: 196–197}

Tenders for 100 trams based on prototype PCC 1041's design were called for in 1972 with Comeng awarded a contract in 1973.^[16] The plans purchased by Comeng proved to be less useful than anticipated, due to them being metric, single ended (with doors only on one side), and to some extent 'over-designed'. Comeng essentially started anew, but retained elements of the structural design and ASEA as the electrical equipment supplier, who would supply equipment from the Gothenburg M28 design.^{[5]: 197–198 [17][18]}

There were a number of design changes made which differentiated the Z-class from PCC 1041, including the destination display arrangement.^[5]: 198 Internally they, like PCC 1041, had conductors consoles that passengers would have to queue for, and only two doors per side, these two features hampered loading and proved unpopular.^[5]: 196 Fitting the ASEA M28 equipment into the Z-class body, which was heavily based on the M29, posed a problem due to the extra doors, tapered ends, and second cab Comeng had added to make them able to operate in Melbourne, this necessitated lengthening the design to accommodate the equipment.^[5]: 199

Construction started at Comeng Dandenong in 1974, with Dandenong's workforce tripling to cope with the order.^{[5]: 199–200} The first Z1-class tram was delivered in December 1974, and the last in May 1978.^[5]: 203 Major construction was carried out at Dandenong, with bogie frames fabricated at Granville, and final fit out and commissioning occurring at the MMTB's Preston Workshops.^{[5]: 199–200, 202}

After being unveiled to the press on 30 April 1975, the first entered service on route 64 on 5 May 1975 and the second on route 72 two days later.^[19] As more were delivered, the first 15 were concentrated at North Fitzroy depot to operate route 96 from 30 June 1975.^[20][21]

Soon after commissioning it became apparent that the Z-class had ride problems due to stiff suspension, and track differences between Gothenburg and Melbourne. The issues were rectified by the time the 80th tram was constructed, and the fix, rubber secondary suspension, was retrofitted to all trams. The braking systems also had issues, and were seen as insufficient by the MMTB.^{[5]: 203 [22]: 31}

In anticipation of the Z3-class contract, Z1 No. 5 was fitted with chopper control in November 1977 for evaluation purposes and reclassified ZC-class No. 5.^[9][23] Although it was converted back later, the test successfully demonstrated chopper control trams could operate on the Melbourne tram system without causing interference, and all Z3-class trams were fitted with chopper controls.^[22]: 31

In March 2006, Z1-class' 81 was returned to service as the Karachi to Melbourne Tram for the 2006 Commonwealth Games. Renumbered W-11 in recognition of buses operated in Karachi, Pakistan famous for their entertainment value, it was decorated with lush designs and played Bhangra and Pakistani music. For the duration of the games it operated on the City Circle.^[24] It returned to service in the summer of 2006/07 operating Friday night City Circle services.^[25]

Most of Z1-class were withdrawn following the introduction of the C and D class trams in 2001/02. Most were sold at auction, with some being donated to tram museums. The last remaining Z1-class trams were withdrawn on 24 April 2016.^[9][2] Four have been preserved.^[26] Their internal refurbishment had less refurbished features than Z3-class, only seat pads and grab rails/anchors were replaced.^[27]

Z2-class

 

Z2 101 on Swanston Street in October 2012

Between June 1978 and February 1979, 15 more trams were built as Z2-class, as an extension of the Z1-class' order. These varied very little from the Z1-class, the main visual differences being the deeper bumper (6-channel like the Z3-class; Z1-class having 4-channel bumpers), and the slide-opening portion of the drivers side-window also being deeper (although at least one Z2 later had a Z1-type drivers side-window fitted).^[5]: 203 The final Z2-class tram was withdrawn in April 2016, also being replaced with the C and D trams. ^[9][27]

Z3-class

 

Refurbished Z3 183 in December 2009

A tender for 100 new trams was called by the MMTB in early 1977, Ansair, Comeng and Siemens tendered. Although Comeng originally planning on using ASEA control equipment, as in the Z1 and Z2-class, they opted to give the MMTB a variety of options, leading to 28 different possible configurations of control equipment, bogies, and suspension types. Comeng were ultimately selected, and between 1979 and 1983, 115 Z3-class trams were built.^{[22]: 31–36}

Although superficially similar to the preceding Z1 and Z2-class trams' externally, they had significant design differences – and were a significant improvement on the Z1 and Z2-class trams.^{[22]: 31–36 [28]} They are fitted with AEG control equipment and Duewag bogies, have an additional door each side (for a total of three rather than two for the Z1 and Z2), drop down (as opposed to top sliding) Beclawat windows and improved headlights. The unreliable flap type destination displays and route number indicators were replaced by rolling plastic film destination displays. They also had much smoother acceleration and braking performance, and improved suspension. Even though the rear door is only half-width (2-leaf, as opposed to the others being 4-leaf), this in combination with the centre doors being directly opposite contributed to better passenger-flow. The Z3-class build process went smoothly, with few problems, bar a slow delivery of equipment from AEG, and a few minor faults that required remedying after construction.^{[7]: 32 [22]: 31–36 [29]} One (Z3 149) was scrapped after being destroyed in a fire in 1999.^[30]

On 31 July 2000, Z3 214 was used to convey the Olympic flame along Dandenong Road from the intersection with Hawthorn Road to Chapel Street as part of the 2000 Summer Olympics torch relay.^[31] On 26 October 2011, Z3 158, specially liveried as a Royal Tram was used to convey Queen Elizabeth II and Prince Philip along St Kilda Road from Federation Square to Government House during their visit to Melbourne. The Royal Tram remained in regular service until February 2013.^{[32][33][34][35]}

In 2013, a program commenced to refurbish all remaining 114 Z3-class trams at Preston Workshops. They received new seats, painted interior walls, glass replacement with scratch proof film applied, and the Public Transport Victoria livery at Preston Workshops.^[36][37]

As of March 2022, 101 Z3-class trams remain in service.^[4]

Between 2022 and 2023, 97 Z3-class trams remain in service as 17 Z3-class trams withdrawn including 5 Z3-class trams scrapped.

Use

The Z3-class operate on the following routes:

• 1: East Coburg to South Melbourne Beach
• 3: Malvern East to Melbourne University
• 5: Malvern to Melbourne University
• 6: Glen Iris to Moreland
• 16: Kew to Melbourne University
• 57: West Maribyrnong to Flinders Street Station
• 58: West Coburg to Toorak
• 59: Airport West to Flinders Street Station
• 64: Brighton East to Melbourne University
• 67: Carnegie to Melbourne University
• 72: Camberwell to Melbourne University
• 82: Footscray station to Moonee Ponds Junction

Preservation

Several have been preserved:

• Z1 2 is located at a property in Queensland.
• Z1 3 is privately owned in Yuroke, Victoria.
• Z1 5 by the Tramway Museum Society of Victoria.
• Z1 6 is stored at Newport Workshops.
• Z1 11 by the Bendigo Tramway Trust, No longer in possession of the tramways trust. Current location unknown ^[38]
• Z1 26 is located at Membrey's Transport & Crane Hire, Dandenong.
• Z1 35 was plinthed at Wallan Secondary College, has since moved to an unknown location. ^[39]
• Z1 43 is located at a property in New South Wales.
• Z1 44 is stored at Newport Workshops.
• Z1 49 is located at a property near Nowa Nowa.
• Z1 56 is located at The Melbourne Steam Traction Club, Scoresby.
• Z1 58 is located at the CFA training centre, in Craigieburn.
• Z1 74 by the Bendigo Tramway Trust no longer in possession by the tramways trust. Current location is unknown ^[38]
• Z1 79 is located at a property in Orange, New South Wales.
• Z1 80 by the Darling Downs Historical Rail Society, Toowoomba^[40]
• Z1 81 by VicTrack, on display at Hawthorn depot as the Karachi to Melbourne Tram^[41]
• Z2 107 is stored at Newport Workshops.
• Z2 111 by the Sydney Tramway Museum^[42]
• Z2 112 was located at a garden center in Yea, Victoria, but now has disappeared from that location.

References

1. (PDF). Yarra Trams. Archived from the original (PDF) on 27 March 2023. Retrieved 27 January 2023.
2. Z1 Class 27 November 2020 at the Wayback Machine Vicsig
3. Z2 Class 27 November 2020 at the Wayback Machine Vicsig
4. Z3 Class 17 July 2019 at the Wayback Machine Vicsig
5. Dunn, John (2010). Comeng: A History of Commonwealth Engineering Volume 3: 1966–1977. Kenthurst, New South Wales: Rosenberg Publishing. ISBN 9781877058905.
6. "Melbourne & Metropolitan Tramways Board PCC No 1041". Melbourne Tram Museum. Retrieved 10 October 2023.
7. Wilson, Randall; Budd, Dale (2005). Melbourne tram book. Sydney: University of New South Wales Press. ISBN 0 86840 646 5.
8. "Melbourne to invest more", Railway Gazette International, July 1996, p. 411
9. "The Melbourne Z1 and Z2 Class Tramcars", Railway Digest, July 2016, pp. 28-31
10. "Z Series Cars – Overhauls & Modifications", Trolley Wire, issue 273, May 1998, p. 16
11. Wilson, Randall; Budd, Dale (2015). Destination Waterfront City – A Guide to Melbourne's Trams. Sydney: Transit Australia Publishing. pp. 29–32. ISBN 9780909459277.
12. "Melbourne News", Trolley Wire, issue 279, November 1999, p. 25
13. . Yarra Trams. 21 August 2007. Archived from the original on 10 November 2013. Retrieved 29 September 2013.
14. Cross, Norman; Budd, Dale; Wilson, Randall (1993). Destination City Melbourne's Electric Trams (5th ed.). Sydney: Transit Publishing Australia. pp. 9–16. ISBN 0 909459 18 5.
15. "City Section", Trolley Wire, issue 182, June 1979, p. 20
16. "Melbourne gets tram bid go-ahead", Railway Gazette International, April 1973, p. 164
17. "ASEA and Comeng gain Melbourne tram order", Railway Gazette International, August 1973, p. 285
18. "ASEA equips Comeng tramcars for Melbourne", Railway Gazette International, August 1974, p. 319
19. "Melbourne's new trams", Trolley Wire, issue 158, June 1975, pp. 35
20. "New Cars for North Fitzroy", Trolley Wire, issue 159, August 1975, p. 40
21. "City Section", Trolley Wire, issue 162, February 1976, p. 22
22. Dunn, John (2013). Comeng : A History of Commonwealth Engineering, Volume 4 : 1977-1985. Kenthurst: Rosenberg Publishing. ISBN 9781922013514.
23. "City Section", Trolley Wire, issue 172, October 1977, p. 27
24. Melbourne 2006 25 March 2006
25. "The Karachi Tram – back on the streets of Melbourne every Friday night during daylight savings" 15 March 2017 at the Wayback Machine, Yarra Trams, 23 November 2006
26. Vines, Gary (2012). (PDF). Biosis Research. Department of Transport, Planning and Local Infrastructure. Archived from the original (PDF) on 2 December 2013. Retrieved 26 November 2013.
27. "Zed's nearly dead: Melbourne's first modern trams to be retired within days" 30 April 2016 at the Wayback Machine, The Age, 13 April 2016
28. "Melbourne and Metropolitan Tramways Board – Z3 class tram" (PDF). Council of Tramway Museums of Australasia. (PDF) from the original on 5 February 2014. Retrieved 24 November 2013.
29. "Melbourne's Z3 trams enter service", Railway Gazette International, April 1980, pp. 286–287
30. Z3 149 29 August 2016 at the Wayback Machine Vicsig
31. "Trams and the Olympic Torch Relay", Trolley Wire, issue 283, November 2000, p. 10
32. (Press release). Yarra Trams. 26 October 2011. Archived from the original on 18 March 2012. Retrieved 8 November 2011.
33. Shmith, Michael (27 October 2011). "Not the Rolls or Bentley, but a commoner's conveyance gives Her Majesty a royal ride". The Age. from the original on 28 October 2011. Retrieved 8 November 2011.
34. Zeeman, Rebecca (25 October 2011). "Z-class a tram fit for a Queen". The Age. from the original on 27 August 2013. Retrieved 9 September 2013.
35. "A royal tram journey", Trolley Wire, issue 327, November 2011, p. 16
36. "Makeover for Z-Class trams". Yarra Trams. 22 August 2013. from the original on 28 August 2013. Retrieved 9 September 2013.
37. Z-Class 19 October 2013 at the Wayback Machine Yarra Trams
38. "Two new arrivals", Trolley Wire, issue 292, February 2003, pp. 46-58
39. "Archived copy". from the original on 7 May 2023. Retrieved 7 May 2023.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: archived copy as title (link)
40. "A Z goes narrow gauge", Trolley Wire, issue 306, August 2006, p. 20
41. Melbourne Tram Museum
42. "Z2 class tram 111", Trolley Wire, issue 293, May 2004, pp. 38–39

External links

  Media related to Z class trams at Wikimedia Commons