fbpx
Wikipedia

Subhash Kak

January 07, 2023

Subhash Kak is an Indian-American computer scientist and historical revisionist.[1] He is the Regents Professor of Computer Science Department at Oklahoma State University–Stillwater,[2] an honorary visiting professor of engineering at Jawaharlal Nehru University,[3] and a member of the Indian Prime Minister's Science, Technology and Innovation Advisory Council (PM-STIAC).[4]

Subhash Kak
Kak at Foundations of Quantum Mechanics Conference, Växjö, Sweden.
Born
Srinagar, Jammu and Kashmir, British India
Academic background
Alma materNIT Srinagar, IIT Delhi
Academic work
DisciplineComputer Science
Sub-discipline
InstitutionsOklahoma State University–Stillwater
Notable works
Notable ideasInstantaneously trained neural networks

Kak has published on the history of science, the philosophy of science, ancient astronomy, and the history of mathematics.[2] Kak has also published on archaeoastronomy, and advocated the idea of Indigenous Aryans.[5] Many scholars have rejected his theories on these topics in entirety, and his writings have been heavily criticized. Kak has been associated with Hindu fanatics and many scholars do not take his opinion seriously.[5][6]

In 2019, the Government of India awarded him the Padma Shri,[7] the fourth highest civilian award in India,[8] for his contributions on the history of mathematics, science, ancient astronomy and philosophy of science.[9]

Early life and education

Kak was born to Ram Nath Kak, a government veterinary doctor and Sarojini Kak in Srinagar, India.[10][11] His brother is the computer scientist Avinash Kak and his sister is the literary theorist Jaishree Odin.[12]

Kak received a Bachelor of Engineering degree from the Regional Engineering College, Srinagar (now the National Institute of Technology, Srinagar) and a Ph.D. from the Indian Institute of Technology Delhi in 1970.[13]

Academic career

During 1975–1976, Kak was a visiting faculty at Imperial College, London, and a guest researcher at Bell Laboratories, Murray Hill. In 1977, he was a visiting researcher at the Tata Institute of Fundamental Research, Bombay.[14] In 1979, he joined Louisiana State University, Baton Rouge, where he was appointed the Donald C. and Elaine T. Delaune Distinguished Professor of Electrical and Computer Engineering. In 2007, he joined the Computer Science department at Oklahoma State University–Stillwater.[15]

Kak proposed an efficient three-layer feed-forward neural network architecture and developed four corner classification algorithms for training it.[16] Despite being criticized for scalability issues; it gained the attention of the electronic hardware community.[16] Kak has argued that there are limits to artificial intelligence and that it cannot match biological intelligence.[17] Kak has been critical of the generalization of the quantum computing to commercial scale; he argues error correction is a significant challenge for scalability although it's fundamental to multi-purpose computing.[18]

Kak is the Regents Professor of Computer Science Department at Oklahoma State University–Stillwater[2] and an honorary visiting professor of engineering at Jawaharlal Nehru University.[3] He is also an honorary visiting professor of media studies at Jawaharlal Nehru University.[19]

On 28 August 2018, he was appointed member of the Prime Minister's Science, Technology and Innovation Advisory Council (PM-STIAC) in India.[4]

Indology

Indigenous Aryanism

Kak primarily advocates for an autochthonous origin of the Indo-Aryans from Punjab[5] ("Indigenous Aryans" hypothesis) in contradiction of the scholarly consensus about the validity of Indo-Aryan migration theory; Kak reads the promotion of the latter theory to stem from racist tendencies.[20] Scholars have noted his charges to be without any basis, lacking in any critical examination and primarily intended to promote Hindu supremacy.[21]

Ancient astronomy in the Rig Veda

Kak has also claimed to find evidences of advanced computing and astronomy in the Rig Veda, in what Noretta Koertge deems to be a "social constructivist and postmodern attack on modern science".[22][23] He insists that Vedic scientists discovered the physical laws by Yogic meditation and that it is a valid scientific method which can be only evaluated within the paradigm of Vedic assumptions and by those who have attained Yogic enlightenment.[22] According to Meera Nanda, Kak believes in the superiority of Hindus over Muslims.[24] In a 2004 critique, she summarized some of Kak's views on the matter : according to Kak, Hindus built "cultural empires" without military conquest, in contrast to Muslim "military empires" reliant on conquest.[24]

Reviewed works

Archaeoastronomy – The Astronomical Code of the Rigveda

In the book, Kak proposes that the organization of hymns in the Rig Veda was dictated by an astronomic code concerning the courses of planets—length of solar year and lunar year, the distance between sun and earth et al.[5][25] He then leverages the proposition to argue for the existence of a tradition of sophisticated observational astronomy as far back as 3000 or 4000 BCE.[5] Kak also states that the construction of fire-altars were a coded representation of their astronomic knowledge[5] and that the Vedic civilisation were aware of the speed of light.[26] He prepared the section on archaeoastronomical sites in India for the thematic study on Heritage Sites of Astronomy and Archaeoastronomy in the context of the UNESCO World Heritage Convention prepared for UNESCO by the International Council on Monuments and Sites (ICOMOS) and the International Astronomical Union (IAU).[27]

While Kak's interpretation has been included in recent overviews of astronomy in the Vedic period in India and the West,[28] his chronology and astronomical calculations have been critiqued by several Indologists, such as Michael Witzel,[5] and the noted historian of mathematics Kim Plofker.[29]

Kim Plofker rejected Kak's probabilistic analysis of the presence of planetary period numbers in the Rigveda's hymn number combinations, showing that Kak's apparent matches have "no statistical significance whatever".[29] Witzel has rejected his analysis to be suffering from several shortcomings and questioned his usage of arbitrary multiplication factors to lead to the results.[5] Kak's method depends on the structure of the Rigveda as redacted by the shakhas in the late Brahmana period, well within the Indian Iron Age, when it was organized into mandalas ("books"). According to Witzel, this leaves Kak's approach attempt to date the text flawed, because this process of redaction took place long after the composition of the individual hymns during the samhita prose period.[5] Witzel concludes that the entire issue boiled down to an over-interpretation of some facts that were internally inconsistent and more, to the creativeness of Kak who was pre-motivated to find evidence of astronomy at every verse of Rig Veda.[5][30] Meera Nanda criticized the arbitrary and absurd nature of Kak's analysis at length and noted his method to be "breathtakingly ad hoc" which "reads like numerology."[25] M A Mehendale, in a review over Annals of the Bhandarkar Oriental Research Institute, criticized the book for its many shortcomings which did not stand the scrutiny of rigor and remarked it to contain inaccurate and misleading statements.[31] S. G. Dani, a Shanti Swarup Bhatnagar prize recipient rejected Kak's hypothesis as unscientific and highly speculative with extremely vague details and whose results were statistically insignificant.[32]

Klaus Klostermaier in his book A Survey of Hinduism praised Kak, for opening up an "entirely new approach to the study of Vedic cosmology from an empirical astronomical/mathematical viewpoint".[33] Klostermaier's books have been heavily criticized for offering pro-Hindu views that have little currency in scholarship.[34][35][36]

Kak's work influenced Raja Ram Mohan Roy's 1999 book Vedic Physics: Scientific Origin of Hinduism, which sought to prove that the RigVeda was coded per the laws of quantum and particle physics.[26] Kak wrote the foreword to this book commending Roy's interpretations as a new way of looking at Vedic Physics.[26][37] Meera Nanda, one of Kak's foremost critics, noted the result to be a "shameful demeaning of physics as well as the Vedas" and resembling "ravings of mad men".[26]

In Search of the Cradle of Civilization

Kak co-authored In Search of the Cradle of Civilization with Georg Feuerstein and David Frawley, equating the Vedic Aryans with the Harappans and thus, participating in the political controversy around the "Indigenous Aryans" theory.[38][39] The chronology espoused in this book is based on the archaeoastronomical readings obtained by correlating textual references and archaeological remains.

A review by Indian archaeologist M. K. Dhavalikar over Annals of the Bhandarkar Oriental Research Institute noted it to be a "beautifully printed" contribution that made a strong case for their indigenous theory against the supposed migratory hypotheses, but chose to remain silent on certain crucial aspects which need to be convincingly explained.[39] Guy Beck showered glowing praises on the book in his review over the Yoga Journal.[40] Klostermaier et al. praised the book.[41] Prema Kurien noted that the book sought to distinguish expatriate Hindu Americans from other minority groups by demonstrating their superior racial and cultural ties with the Europeans.[42]

Reception

Edwin Bryant calls him a well read and articulate spokesman for the Indigenous Aryan hypothesis and for other issues concerning ancient Indian science and culture.[43]

Scholars have rejected his theories in entirety and his writings have been heavily criticized.[5] Acute misrepresentation of facts coupled with wrong observations, extremely flexible and often self-contradictory analysis, cherry picking of data and forwarding of easily disprovable hypotheses have been located.[5][6][44][45] His understanding of linguistics and subsequent assertion have been challenged.[5][46] Romila Thapar calls Kak an amateur historian whose views on the Indus Civilization were fringe and who was part of a group that had more to do with waging political battles at the excuse of history.[47] Michael Witzel noted him to be a revisionist and part of a "closely knit, self-adulatory group", members of which often write together and/or profusely copy from and cite one another, thus rendering the whole scene into a virtually indistinguishable hotchpotch.[5] Garrett G. Fagan, a noted critic of pseudo-archaeology has concurred with Witzel.[20] Meera Nanda writes about Kak being revered as a stalwart of Hindutva and one of the leading “intellectual Kshatriyas”.[26] Similar concerns of his being a Hindutva-based revisionist have been echoed by other writers.[6][48] In a critique of faulty scientific reasoning in Hindutva ideologies and theories, Alan Sokal sarcastically criticized Kak as "one of the leading intellectual luminaries of the Hindu-nationalist diaspora".[37] Koertge as well as Meera Nanda have remarked that Kak's work advances a Hindutva-based esoteric pseudoscience narrative that seeks to find relatively advanced abstract physics in Vedic texts and assign Indian indigenousness to the Sanskrit-speaking Indic Aryans in a bid to prove the superiority of the ancient Hindu civilization.[22][23]

See also

References

  1. ^ Kurien, Prema A. (2007). A place at the multicultural table the development of an American Hinduism. Rutgers University Press. pp. 163, 166. ISBN 9780813540559. OCLC 703221465.
  2. ^ a b c Akella, Usha (21 December 2013). "The Renaissance man". The Hindu. Retrieved 2 December 2018.
  3. ^ a b . Jawaharlal Nehru University. Archived from the original on 25 June 2019. Retrieved 23 October 2021 – via Wayback Machine.
  4. ^ a b "New committee formed to advise PM on science, tech-related policy issues". Thehindubusinessline.com. Retrieved 2 December 2018.
  5. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n Witzel 2001.
  6. ^ a b c Guha, Sudeshna (2007). "Review of The Indo-Aryan Controversy: Evidence and Inference in Indian History". Journal of the Royal Asiatic Society. 17 (3): 340–343. doi:10.1017/S135618630700733X. ISSN 1356-1863. JSTOR 25188742. S2CID 163092658.
  7. ^ VK, Anirudh (5 June 2019). "Meet Subhash Kak, AI Visionary & Inventor Of Quantum Neural Computing Who Won The Padma Shri".
  8. ^ "Padma Awards conferred by President Ram Nath Kovind | DD News". www.ddinews.gov.in. Retrieved 23 March 2019.
  9. ^ Zutshi, Vikram (9 January 2020). "Computers, yoga and the science of consciousness: A conversation with Subhash Kak". The Hindustan Times. from the original on 30 May 2020. Retrieved 4 October 2021.
  10. ^ Kak, S. The Circle of Memory. Mississauga, 2016
  11. ^ Sharma, Swati (10 February 2019). "A Renaissance man". Deccan Chronicle. Retrieved 10 May 2019.
  12. ^ Kak, Ram Nath. Autumn Leaves. Vitasta, 1995.
  13. ^ PTI (4 June 2019). "Padma Shri handed over to Dr Subhash Kak in US". The Economic Times. from the original on 22 May 2020. Retrieved 4 October 2021.
  14. ^ "Short Biography" (PDF). Ece.okstate.edu. Retrieved 3 December 2018.
  15. ^ "Kak, Subhash, Ph.D. – School of Electrical and Computer Engineering". Ece.okstate.edu. Retrieved 2 December 2018.
  16. ^ a b SHORTT, A; KEATING, J; MOULINIER, L; PANNELL, C (4 March 2005). "Optical implementation of the Kak neural network" (PDF). Information Sciences. 171 (1–3): 273–287. doi:10.1016/j.ins.2004.02.028. ISSN 0020-0255.
  17. ^ Kak, Subhash. "Will artificial intelligence become conscious?". Theconversation.com. Retrieved 2 December 2018.
  18. ^ Subhash Kak (3 December 2019). "A quantum computing future is unlikely, due to random hardware errors". The Conversation. from the original on 14 July 2021. Retrieved 4 October 2021.
  19. ^ "CMS Faculty".{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: url-status (link)
  20. ^ a b Fagan, Garrett G. (2006). Archaeological Fantasies: How Pseudoarchaeology Misrepresents the Past and Misleads the Public. Psychology Press. p. 217. ISBN 9780415305921.
  21. ^ Sur, Abha; Sur, Samir (2010). "In Contradiction Lies the Hope". In Costa, Beatriz Da; Philip, Kavita (eds.). Tactical Biopolitics: Art, Activism, and Technoscience. MIT Press. p. 210. doi:10.7551/mitpress/9780262042499.001.0001. ISBN 978-0-262-51491-0.
  22. ^ a b c Koertge, Noretta (2005). Scientific values and civic virtues. Oxford University Press. pp. 231, 232. ISBN 978-0195172256. OCLC 803903015.
  23. ^ a b Nanda, Meera (2004). Prophets Facing Backward : Postmodern Critiques of Science and Hindu Nationalism in India. Rutgers University Press. pp. 110, 111. ISBN 9780813536347. OCLC 1059017715.
  24. ^ a b Nanda, Meera (2004). Prophets Facing Backward : Postmodern Critiques of Science and Hindu Nationalism in India. Rutgers University Press. p. 98. ISBN 9780813536347. OCLC 1059017715.
  25. ^ a b Nanda, Meera (2004). Prophets Facing Backward : Postmodern Critiques of Science and Hindu Nationalism in India. Rutgers University Press. p. 112. ISBN 9780813536347. OCLC 1059017715.
  26. ^ a b c d e Nanda, Meera (2004). Prophets Facing Backward : Postmodern Critiques of Science and Hindu Nationalism in India. Rutgers University Press. p. 114. ISBN 9780813536347. OCLC 1059017715.
  27. ^ Kak, Subhash (2010), "India", in Ruggles, Clive; Cotte, Michel (eds.), Heritage Sites of Astronomy and Archaeoastronomy in the context of the UNESCO World Heritage Convention: A Thematic Study, Paris: ICOMOS / IAU, pp. 99–107, ISBN 978-2-918086-07-9
  28. ^ In S. Wolpert (ed.), "Encyclopedia of India." Scribner's, 2005.
  29. ^ a b Plofker, Kim (December 1996), "Review of Subash Kak, The Astronomical Code of the Ṛgveda", Centaurus, 38 (4): 362–364, doi:10.1111/j.1600-0498.1996.tb00021.x, ISSN 0008-8994
  30. ^ Kurien 2007, p. 255.
  31. ^ Mehendale, M. A. (1996). "Review of THE ASTRONOMICAL CODE OF THE ṚGVEDA". Annals of the Bhandarkar Oriental Research Institute. 77 (1/4): 323–325. ISSN 0378-1143. JSTOR 41702197.
  32. ^ Dani, S. G. (1994). "The astronomical code of the Rigveda". Current Science. 66 (11): 814. ISSN 0011-3891. JSTOR 24095698.
  33. ^ Klaus Klostermaier, A Survey of Hinduism, Second Edition. State University of New York Press, 1995, pp. 129.
  34. ^ Joel P. Brereton (1991). "A Survey of Hinduism by Klaus K. Klostermaier (Review)". Journal of Asian History. 25 (1): 86–87. JSTOR 41930803.
  35. ^ Knut A. Jacobsen (1997). "A Survey of Hinduism by Klaus K. Klostermaier (Review)". Numen. 44 (1): 97–98. JSTOR 3270387.
  36. ^ Patricia M. Greer (2002). "A Concise Encyclopedia of Hinduism by Klaus K. Klostermaier (Review)". International Journal of Hindu Studies. 6 (1): 92–94. JSTOR 20106796.
  37. ^ a b Sokal, Alan (2006). "Pseudoscience and Postmodernism: Antagonists or Fellow-Travelers?". In Garrett G. Fagan (ed.). Archaeological fantasies: how pseudoarchaeology misrepresents the past and misleads the public. Routledge. p. 317. ISBN 978-0-415-30593-8.
  38. ^ Edwin Bryant, The Quest for the Origins of Vedic Culture: The Indo-Aryan Migration Debate. Oxford University Press, 2001.
  39. ^ a b M. K. Dhavalikar (1996). "Untitled [review of In Search of the Cradle of Civilization: New Light on Ancient India, by Georg Feuerstein, Subhash Kak, & David Frawley]". Annals of the Bhandarkar Oriental Research Institute. Bhandarkar Oriental Research Institute. 77 (1/4): 326–327. ISSN 0378-1143. JSTOR 41702199.
  40. ^ Beck, Guy (September–October 1996). "Origins of Yoga [review of In Search of the Cradle of Civilization: New Light on Ancient India, by Georg Feuerstein, Subhash Kak, & David Frawley]". Yoga Journal. 130 (130): 116–117. ISSN 0191-0965.
  41. ^ "Reviews". www.ece.lsu.edu. Retrieved 22 March 2019.
  42. ^ Kurien, Prema A. (2007). A place at the multicultural table the development of an American Hinduism. Rutgers University Press. pp. 242. ISBN 9780813540559. OCLC 703221465.
  43. ^ Bryant, Edwin (6 September 2001). The Quest for the Origins of Vedic Culture: The Indo-Aryan Migration Debate. Oxford University Press. ISBN 9780199881338.
  44. ^ Kazanas, Nicholas (1999). "The Ṛgveda and Indo-Europeans". Annals of the Bhandarkar Oriental Research Institute. 80 (1/4): 15–42. ISSN 0378-1143. JSTOR 41694574.
  45. ^ Nanda, Meera (2004). Prophets Facing Backward : Postmodern Critiques of Science and Hindu Nationalism in India. Rutgers University Press. p. 118. ISBN 9780813536347. OCLC 1059017715.
  46. ^ Jain, Danesh; Cardona, George (26 July 2007). The Indo-Aryan Languages. Routledge. pp. 35, 36. ISBN 9781135797119.
  47. ^ "Romila Thapar: On historical scholarship and the uses of the past (interview with Parita Mukta)". Ethnic and Racial Studies. 23 (3): 594–616. 1 January 2000. doi:10.1080/014198700329006. ISSN 0141-9870. S2CID 151335964.
  48. ^ Brown, C. Mackenzie (19 January 2012). Hindu Perspectives on Evolution: Darwin, Dharma, and Design. Routledge. p. 239. ISBN 9781136484667.

Sources

  • Witzel, Michael (2001), (PDF), Electronic Journal of Vedic Studies, 7 (3), 70–71, archived from the original (PDF) on 23 May 2013, retrieved 13 February 2013
  • Kurien, Prema A (2007). A place at the multicultural table the development of an American Hinduism. Rutgers University Press. p. 255. ISBN 9780813540559. OCLC 703221465.

External links

 
Wikiquote has quotations related to Subhash Kak.
  • Publications on Physics and Computer Science in the ArXiv.org e-print archive
  • Deccan Chronicle Interview
  • Times of India Interview by Aarti Tikoo Singh

January 07, 2023
subhash, indian, american, computer, scientist, historical, revisionist, regents, professor, computer, science, department, oklahoma, state, university, stillwater, honorary, visiting, professor, engineering, jawaharlal, nehru, university, member, indian, prim. Subhash Kak is an Indian American computer scientist and historical revisionist 1 He is the Regents Professor of Computer Science Department at Oklahoma State University Stillwater 2 an honorary visiting professor of engineering at Jawaharlal Nehru University 3 and a member of the Indian Prime Minister s Science Technology and Innovation Advisory Council PM STIAC 4 Subhash KakKak at Foundations of Quantum Mechanics Conference Vaxjo Sweden BornSrinagar Jammu and Kashmir British IndiaAcademic backgroundAlma materNIT Srinagar IIT DelhiAcademic workDisciplineComputer ScienceSub disciplineCryptography Quantum cryptography Quantum information History of scienceInstitutionsOklahoma State University StillwaterNotable worksIn Search of the Cradle of CivilizationNotable ideasInstantaneously trained neural networksKak has published on the history of science the philosophy of science ancient astronomy and the history of mathematics 2 Kak has also published on archaeoastronomy and advocated the idea of Indigenous Aryans 5 Many scholars have rejected his theories on these topics in entirety and his writings have been heavily criticized Kak has been associated with Hindu fanatics and many scholars do not take his opinion seriously 5 6 In 2019 the Government of India awarded him the Padma Shri 7 the fourth highest civilian award in India 8 for his contributions on the history of mathematics science ancient astronomy and philosophy of science 9 Contents 1 Early life and education 2 Academic career 3 Indology 3 1 Indigenous Aryanism 3 2 Ancient astronomy in the Rig Veda 3 3 Reviewed works 3 3 1 Archaeoastronomy The Astronomical Code of the Rigveda 3 3 2 In Search of the Cradle of Civilization 3 4 Reception 4 See also 5 References 6 Sources 7 External linksEarly life and education EditKak was born to Ram Nath Kak a government veterinary doctor and Sarojini Kak in Srinagar India 10 11 His brother is the computer scientist Avinash Kak and his sister is the literary theorist Jaishree Odin 12 Kak received a Bachelor of Engineering degree from the Regional Engineering College Srinagar now the National Institute of Technology Srinagar and a Ph D from the Indian Institute of Technology Delhi in 1970 13 Academic career EditDuring 1975 1976 Kak was a visiting faculty at Imperial College London and a guest researcher at Bell Laboratories Murray Hill In 1977 he was a visiting researcher at the Tata Institute of Fundamental Research Bombay 14 In 1979 he joined Louisiana State University Baton Rouge where he was appointed the Donald C and Elaine T Delaune Distinguished Professor of Electrical and Computer Engineering In 2007 he joined the Computer Science department at Oklahoma State University Stillwater 15 Kak proposed an efficient three layer feed forward neural network architecture and developed four corner classification algorithms for training it 16 Despite being criticized for scalability issues it gained the attention of the electronic hardware community 16 Kak has argued that there are limits to artificial intelligence and that it cannot match biological intelligence 17 Kak has been critical of the generalization of the quantum computing to commercial scale he argues error correction is a significant challenge for scalability although it s fundamental to multi purpose computing 18 Kak is the Regents Professor of Computer Science Department at Oklahoma State University Stillwater 2 and an honorary visiting professor of engineering at Jawaharlal Nehru University 3 He is also an honorary visiting professor of media studies at Jawaharlal Nehru University 19 On 28 August 2018 he was appointed member of the Prime Minister s Science Technology and Innovation Advisory Council PM STIAC in India 4 Indology EditIndigenous Aryanism Edit Kak primarily advocates for an autochthonous origin of the Indo Aryans from Punjab 5 Indigenous Aryans hypothesis in contradiction of the scholarly consensus about the validity of Indo Aryan migration theory Kak reads the promotion of the latter theory to stem from racist tendencies 20 Scholars have noted his charges to be without any basis lacking in any critical examination and primarily intended to promote Hindu supremacy 21 Ancient astronomy in the Rig Veda Edit Kak has also claimed to find evidences of advanced computing and astronomy in the Rig Veda in what Noretta Koertge deems to be a social constructivist and postmodern attack on modern science 22 23 He insists that Vedic scientists discovered the physical laws by Yogic meditation and that it is a valid scientific method which can be only evaluated within the paradigm of Vedic assumptions and by those who have attained Yogic enlightenment 22 According to Meera Nanda Kak believes in the superiority of Hindus over Muslims 24 In a 2004 critique she summarized some of Kak s views on the matter according to Kak Hindus built cultural empires without military conquest in contrast to Muslim military empires reliant on conquest 24 Reviewed works Edit Archaeoastronomy The Astronomical Code of the Rigveda Edit In the book Kak proposes that the organization of hymns in the Rig Veda was dictated by an astronomic code concerning the courses of planets length of solar year and lunar year the distance between sun and earth et al 5 25 He then leverages the proposition to argue for the existence of a tradition of sophisticated observational astronomy as far back as 3000 or 4000 BCE 5 Kak also states that the construction of fire altars were a coded representation of their astronomic knowledge 5 and that the Vedic civilisation were aware of the speed of light 26 He prepared the section on archaeoastronomical sites in India for the thematic study on Heritage Sites of Astronomy and Archaeoastronomy in the context of the UNESCO World Heritage Convention prepared for UNESCO by the International Council on Monuments and Sites ICOMOS and the International Astronomical Union IAU 27 While Kak s interpretation has been included in recent overviews of astronomy in the Vedic period in India and the West 28 his chronology and astronomical calculations have been critiqued by several Indologists such as Michael Witzel 5 and the noted historian of mathematics Kim Plofker 29 Kim Plofker rejected Kak s probabilistic analysis of the presence of planetary period numbers in the Rigveda s hymn number combinations showing that Kak s apparent matches have no statistical significance whatever 29 Witzel has rejected his analysis to be suffering from several shortcomings and questioned his usage of arbitrary multiplication factors to lead to the results 5 Kak s method depends on the structure of the Rigveda as redacted by the shakhas in the late Brahmana period well within the Indian Iron Age when it was organized into mandalas books According to Witzel this leaves Kak s approach attempt to date the text flawed because this process of redaction took place long after the composition of the individual hymns during the samhita prose period 5 Witzel concludes that the entire issue boiled down to an over interpretation of some facts that were internally inconsistent and more to the creativeness of Kak who was pre motivated to find evidence of astronomy at every verse of Rig Veda 5 30 Meera Nanda criticized the arbitrary and absurd nature of Kak s analysis at length and noted his method to be breathtakingly ad hoc which reads like numerology 25 M A Mehendale in a review over Annals of the Bhandarkar Oriental Research Institute criticized the book for its many shortcomings which did not stand the scrutiny of rigor and remarked it to contain inaccurate and misleading statements 31 S G Dani a Shanti Swarup Bhatnagar prize recipient rejected Kak s hypothesis as unscientific and highly speculative with extremely vague details and whose results were statistically insignificant 32 Klaus Klostermaier in his book A Survey of Hinduism praised Kak for opening up an entirely new approach to the study of Vedic cosmology from an empirical astronomical mathematical viewpoint 33 Klostermaier s books have been heavily criticized for offering pro Hindu views that have little currency in scholarship 34 35 36 Kak s work influenced Raja Ram Mohan Roy s 1999 book Vedic Physics Scientific Origin of Hinduism which sought to prove that the RigVeda was coded per the laws of quantum and particle physics 26 Kak wrote the foreword to this book commending Roy s interpretations as a new way of looking at Vedic Physics 26 37 Meera Nanda one of Kak s foremost critics noted the result to be a shameful demeaning of physics as well as the Vedas and resembling ravings of mad men 26 In Search of the Cradle of Civilization Edit Kak co authored In Search of the Cradle of Civilization with Georg Feuerstein and David Frawley equating the Vedic Aryans with the Harappans and thus participating in the political controversy around the Indigenous Aryans theory 38 39 The chronology espoused in this book is based on the archaeoastronomical readings obtained by correlating textual references and archaeological remains A review by Indian archaeologist M K Dhavalikar over Annals of the Bhandarkar Oriental Research Institute noted it to be a beautifully printed contribution that made a strong case for their indigenous theory against the supposed migratory hypotheses but chose to remain silent on certain crucial aspects which need to be convincingly explained 39 Guy Beck showered glowing praises on the book in his review over the Yoga Journal 40 Klostermaier et al praised the book 41 Prema Kurien noted that the book sought to distinguish expatriate Hindu Americans from other minority groups by demonstrating their superior racial and cultural ties with the Europeans 42 Reception Edit Edwin Bryant calls him a well read and articulate spokesman for the Indigenous Aryan hypothesis and for other issues concerning ancient Indian science and culture 43 Scholars have rejected his theories in entirety and his writings have been heavily criticized 5 Acute misrepresentation of facts coupled with wrong observations extremely flexible and often self contradictory analysis cherry picking of data and forwarding of easily disprovable hypotheses have been located 5 6 44 45 His understanding of linguistics and subsequent assertion have been challenged 5 46 Romila Thapar calls Kak an amateur historian whose views on the Indus Civilization were fringe and who was part of a group that had more to do with waging political battles at the excuse of history 47 Michael Witzel noted him to be a revisionist and part of a closely knit self adulatory group members of which often write together and or profusely copy from and cite one another thus rendering the whole scene into a virtually indistinguishable hotchpotch 5 Garrett G Fagan a noted critic of pseudo archaeology has concurred with Witzel 20 Meera Nanda writes about Kak being revered as a stalwart of Hindutva and one of the leading intellectual Kshatriyas 26 Similar concerns of his being a Hindutva based revisionist have been echoed by other writers 6 48 In a critique of faulty scientific reasoning in Hindutva ideologies and theories Alan Sokal sarcastically criticized Kak as one of the leading intellectual luminaries of the Hindu nationalist diaspora 37 Koertge as well as Meera Nanda have remarked that Kak s work advances a Hindutva based esoteric pseudoscience narrative that seeks to find relatively advanced abstract physics in Vedic texts and assign Indian indigenousness to the Sanskrit speaking Indic Aryans in a bid to prove the superiority of the ancient Hindu civilization 22 23 See also Edit Poetry portalScience wars Quantum mysticism Archaeoastronomy and Vedic chronology Unary coding Number theoretic Hilbert transform Veiled nonlocalityReferences Edit Kurien Prema A 2007 A place at the multicultural table the development of an American Hinduism Rutgers University Press pp 163 166 ISBN 9780813540559 OCLC 703221465 a b c Akella Usha 21 December 2013 The Renaissance man The Hindu Retrieved 2 December 2018 a b School of Engineering JNU Associated Faculty Jawaharlal Nehru University Archived from the original on 25 June 2019 Retrieved 23 October 2021 via Wayback Machine a b New committee formed to advise PM on science tech related policy issues Thehindubusinessline com Retrieved 2 December 2018 a b c d e f g h i j k l m n Witzel 2001 a b c Guha Sudeshna 2007 Review of The Indo Aryan Controversy Evidence and Inference in Indian History Journal of the Royal Asiatic Society 17 3 340 343 doi 10 1017 S135618630700733X ISSN 1356 1863 JSTOR 25188742 S2CID 163092658 VK Anirudh 5 June 2019 Meet Subhash Kak AI Visionary amp Inventor Of Quantum Neural Computing Who Won The Padma Shri Padma Awards conferred by President Ram Nath Kovind DD News www ddinews gov in Retrieved 23 March 2019 Zutshi Vikram 9 January 2020 Computers yoga and the science of consciousness A conversation with Subhash Kak The Hindustan Times Archived from the original on 30 May 2020 Retrieved 4 October 2021 Kak S The Circle of Memory Mississauga 2016 Sharma Swati 10 February 2019 A Renaissance man Deccan Chronicle Retrieved 10 May 2019 Kak Ram Nath Autumn Leaves Vitasta 1995 PTI 4 June 2019 Padma Shri handed over to Dr Subhash Kak in US The Economic Times Archived from the original on 22 May 2020 Retrieved 4 October 2021 Short Biography PDF Ece okstate edu Retrieved 3 December 2018 Kak Subhash Ph D School of Electrical and Computer Engineering Ece okstate edu Retrieved 2 December 2018 a b SHORTT A KEATING J MOULINIER L PANNELL C 4 March 2005 Optical implementation of the Kak neural network PDF Information Sciences 171 1 3 273 287 doi 10 1016 j ins 2004 02 028 ISSN 0020 0255 Kak Subhash Will artificial intelligence become conscious Theconversation com Retrieved 2 December 2018 Subhash Kak 3 December 2019 A quantum computing future is unlikely due to random hardware errors The Conversation Archived from the original on 14 July 2021 Retrieved 4 October 2021 CMS Faculty a href Template Cite web html title Template Cite web cite web a CS1 maint url status link a b Fagan Garrett G 2006 Archaeological Fantasies How Pseudoarchaeology Misrepresents the Past and Misleads the Public Psychology Press p 217 ISBN 9780415305921 Sur Abha Sur Samir 2010 In Contradiction Lies the Hope In Costa Beatriz Da Philip Kavita eds Tactical Biopolitics Art Activism and Technoscience MIT Press p 210 doi 10 7551 mitpress 9780262042499 001 0001 ISBN 978 0 262 51491 0 a b c Koertge Noretta 2005 Scientific values and civic virtues Oxford University Press pp 231 232 ISBN 978 0195172256 OCLC 803903015 a b Nanda Meera 2004 Prophets Facing Backward Postmodern Critiques of Science and Hindu Nationalism in India Rutgers University Press pp 110 111 ISBN 9780813536347 OCLC 1059017715 a b Nanda Meera 2004 Prophets Facing Backward Postmodern Critiques of Science and Hindu Nationalism in India Rutgers University Press p 98 ISBN 9780813536347 OCLC 1059017715 a b Nanda Meera 2004 Prophets Facing Backward Postmodern Critiques of Science and Hindu Nationalism in India Rutgers University Press p 112 ISBN 9780813536347 OCLC 1059017715 a b c d e Nanda Meera 2004 Prophets Facing Backward Postmodern Critiques of Science and Hindu Nationalism in India Rutgers University Press p 114 ISBN 9780813536347 OCLC 1059017715 Kak Subhash 2010 India in Ruggles Clive Cotte Michel eds Heritage Sites of Astronomy and Archaeoastronomy in the context of the UNESCO World Heritage Convention A Thematic Study Paris ICOMOS IAU pp 99 107 ISBN 978 2 918086 07 9 In S Wolpert ed Encyclopedia of India Scribner s 2005 a b Plofker Kim December 1996 Review of Subash Kak The Astronomical Code of the Ṛgveda Centaurus 38 4 362 364 doi 10 1111 j 1600 0498 1996 tb00021 x ISSN 0008 8994 Kurien 2007 p 255 Mehendale M A 1996 Review of THE ASTRONOMICAL CODE OF THE ṚGVEDA Annals of the Bhandarkar Oriental Research Institute 77 1 4 323 325 ISSN 0378 1143 JSTOR 41702197 Dani S G 1994 The astronomical code of the Rigveda Current Science 66 11 814 ISSN 0011 3891 JSTOR 24095698 Klaus Klostermaier A Survey of Hinduism Second Edition State University of New York Press 1995 pp 129 Joel P Brereton 1991 A Survey of Hinduism by Klaus K Klostermaier Review Journal of Asian History 25 1 86 87 JSTOR 41930803 Knut A Jacobsen 1997 A Survey of Hinduism by Klaus K Klostermaier Review Numen 44 1 97 98 JSTOR 3270387 Patricia M Greer 2002 A Concise Encyclopedia of Hinduism by Klaus K Klostermaier Review International Journal of Hindu Studies 6 1 92 94 JSTOR 20106796 a b Sokal Alan 2006 Pseudoscience and Postmodernism Antagonists or Fellow Travelers In Garrett G Fagan ed Archaeological fantasies how pseudoarchaeology misrepresents the past and misleads the public Routledge p 317 ISBN 978 0 415 30593 8 Edwin Bryant The Quest for the Origins of Vedic Culture The Indo Aryan Migration Debate Oxford University Press 2001 a b M K Dhavalikar 1996 Untitled review of In Search of the Cradle of Civilization New Light on Ancient India by Georg Feuerstein Subhash Kak amp David Frawley Annals of the Bhandarkar Oriental Research Institute Bhandarkar Oriental Research Institute 77 1 4 326 327 ISSN 0378 1143 JSTOR 41702199 Beck Guy September October 1996 Origins of Yoga review of In Search of the Cradle of Civilization New Light on Ancient India by Georg Feuerstein Subhash Kak amp David Frawley Yoga Journal 130 130 116 117 ISSN 0191 0965 Reviews www ece lsu edu Retrieved 22 March 2019 Kurien Prema A 2007 A place at the multicultural table the development of an American Hinduism Rutgers University Press pp 242 ISBN 9780813540559 OCLC 703221465 Bryant Edwin 6 September 2001 The Quest for the Origins of Vedic Culture The Indo Aryan Migration Debate Oxford University Press ISBN 9780199881338 Kazanas Nicholas 1999 The Ṛgveda and Indo Europeans Annals of the Bhandarkar Oriental Research Institute 80 1 4 15 42 ISSN 0378 1143 JSTOR 41694574 Nanda Meera 2004 Prophets Facing Backward Postmodern Critiques of Science and Hindu Nationalism in India Rutgers University Press p 118 ISBN 9780813536347 OCLC 1059017715 Jain Danesh Cardona George 26 July 2007 The Indo Aryan Languages Routledge pp 35 36 ISBN 9781135797119 Romila Thapar On historical scholarship and the uses of the past interview with Parita Mukta Ethnic and Racial Studies 23 3 594 616 1 January 2000 doi 10 1080 014198700329006 ISSN 0141 9870 S2CID 151335964 Brown C Mackenzie 19 January 2012 Hindu Perspectives on Evolution Darwin Dharma and Design Routledge p 239 ISBN 9781136484667 Sources EditWitzel Michael 2001 Autochthonous Aryans The Evidence from Old Indian and Iranian Texts PDF Electronic Journal of Vedic Studies 7 3 70 71 archived from the original PDF on 23 May 2013 retrieved 13 February 2013 Kurien Prema A 2007 A place at the multicultural table the development of an American Hinduism Rutgers University Press p 255 ISBN 9780813540559 OCLC 703221465 External links Edit Wikiquote has quotations related to Subhash Kak Publications on Physics and Computer Science in the ArXiv org e print archive Deccan Chronicle Interview Times of India Interview by Aarti Tikoo Singh Retrieved from https en wikipedia org w index php title Subhash Kak amp oldid 1131779029, wikipedia, wiki, book, books, library,

article

, read, download, free, free download, mp3, video, mp4, 3gp, jpg, jpeg, gif, png, picture, music, song, movie, book, game, games.