Scottish independence

Scottish independence (Scottish Gaelic: Neo-eisimeileachd na h-Alba; Scots: Scots unthirldom)^[1] is the idea of Scotland regaining its independence and once again becoming a sovereign state, independent from the United Kingdom. The term Scottish independence refers to the political movement that is campaigning to bring it about.^[2][3][4][5]

Location of Scotland (dark green) – in Europe (green & dark grey) – in the United Kingdom (green)

Scotland independence march in Glasgow in 2019.

Scotland was an independent kingdom through the Middle Ages, and fought wars to maintain its independence from England. The two kingdoms were united in personal union in 1603 when the Scottish King James VI became James I of England, and the two kingdoms united politically into one kingdom called Great Britain in 1707.^[6] This movement united the countries which ended the wars of independence and created relative peace. Political campaigns for Scottish self-government began in the 19th century, initially in the form of demands for home rule within the United Kingdom. Two referendums on devolution were held in 1979 and 1997, with a devolved Scottish Parliament being established on 1 July 1999.

The pro-independence Scottish National Party first became the governing party of the devolved parliament in 2007, and it won an outright majority of seats at the 2011 Scottish Parliament election. This led to an agreement between the Scottish and UK governments to hold the 2014 Scottish independence referendum. Voters were asked: "Should Scotland be an independent country?"^[7] 44.7 percent of voters answered "Yes" and 55.3 percent answered "No", with a record voter turnout of 85 percent. This resulted in Scotland remaining in the United Kingdom.^[8][9]

A second referendum on independence has been proposed, particularly since the UK voted to leave the European Union in a June 2016 referendum and since pro-independence parties increased their majority in the 2021 Scottish Parliament election. In June 2022 Nicola Sturgeon proposed the date of 19 October 2023 for a new referendum on Scottish independence, subject to confirmation of its legality and constitutionality.^[10] In November 2022 the Supreme Court of the United Kingdom ruled that the Scottish Parliament did not have the power to legislate for a second referendum.^[11]

History

Kingdom of Scotland

Main article: Kingdom of Scotland

Scotland emerged as an independent polity during the Early Middle Ages with some historians dating its foundation from the reign of Kenneth MacAlpin in 843.^[12][a] The level of independence of the Scottish kingdom was fought over by the Scottish kings and by the Norman and Angevin rulers of England who petitioned the Pope and other foreign rulers.^[12]

A watershed in the Scottish kingdom's history was a succession crisis that erupted in 1290 when Edward I of England claimed the right of appointment to the Scottish throne. The Auld Alliance of Scotland and France against English interests was first invoked at that time and remained active through to the 16th century. The Wars of Scottish Independence ended in a renewed kingdom under Robert the Bruce (crowned 1306), whose grandson Robert II of Scotland was the first Scottish king of the House of Stuart.

Union

 

A treatise of union of the two realmes of England and Scotland by the English historian Sir John Hayward, 1604

From 1603 Scotland and England shared the same monarch in a personal union when James VI of Scotland was declared King of England and Scotland in what was known as the Union of the Crowns. After James II and VII was deposed in 1688 amid Catholic-Protestant disputes, and as the line of Protestant Stuarts showed signs of failing (as indeed occurred in 1714), English fears that Scotland would select a different monarch, potentially causing conflict within Great Britain, and the bankruptcy of many Scottish nobles through the Darien scheme led to the formal union of the two kingdoms in 1707, with the Treaty of Union and subsequent Acts of Union, to form the Kingdom of Great Britain. Scottish Jacobite resistance to the union, led by descendants of James II and VII including Bonnie Prince Charlie, continued until 1746.

The United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland was formed by the Acts of Union 1800, which united the Kingdom of Great Britain and the Kingdom of Ireland. Following the Irish War of Independence (1919–21) and the Anglo-Irish Treaty that ended the war, Ireland was partitioned into two states: Southern Ireland, which opted to become independent (and is now known as Republic of Ireland), and Northern Ireland, which – given its geographical extent which tended to ensure a Unionist majority – chose to remain within the United Kingdom.

Home rule movement

Main article: Scottish Assembly

The "Home Rule" movement for a Scottish Assembly was first taken up in 1853 by the National Association for the Vindication of Scottish Rights, a body close to the Conservative Party. A key element in this movement was the comparison with Ireland. The original movement broadened its political appeal and soon began to receive Liberal Party backing.^{[13][failed verification]} In 1885, the post of Secretary for Scotland and the Scottish Office were re-established to promote Scotland's interests and express its concerns to the UK Parliament. In 1886, however, Liberal Prime Minister William Ewart Gladstone introduced the Irish Home Rule Bill. It was not regarded as an immediate constitutional priority however, particularly when the Irish Home Rule Bill was defeated in the House of Commons.

Immediately before the First World War, the Liberal Government led by H. H. Asquith supported the concept of "Home Rule all round", whereby Scottish home rule would follow the Irish home rule proposed in the Government of Ireland Act 1914.^[14] Asquith believed that there was an iniquity in that the component parts of the United Kingdom could come together to act together in common purposes, but those components could not deal with internal matters that did not require consent across the UK.^[14] This was not a nationalist philosophy, but instead Asquith was acting in the belief that federalism was the "true basis of union" and that centralising power in Westminster was a political blunder.^[15] A Scottish Home Rule bill was first presented to Parliament in 1913, but its progress was soon ended as Parliament focused on emergency measures necessitated by the First World War.^[15]

Unlike Ireland, which rebelled in the Easter Rising and fought a War of Independence, Scotland did not resist central rule.^[15] There was, however, a persistent demand for Scottish home rule.^[15] The Scottish Office was relocated to St Andrew's House in Edinburgh during the 1930s.^[13][16] The Scottish Covenant was a petition to the UK Government asking for home rule. It was first proposed in 1930 by John MacCormick and formally written in 1949. The petition "was eventually signed by two million people"^[17] (the population of Scotland was recorded as 5,100,000 in the 1951 UK Census^[18]). The covenant was ignored by the main political parties.^[17] In 1950 the Stone of Destiny was removed from Westminster Abbey by a group of Scottish nationalist students.

The question of full independence, or the less controversial home rule, did not re-enter the political mainstream until 1960, after the famous Wind of Change speech by Conservative Prime Minister Harold Macmillan. This speech marked the start of a rapid decolonisation in Africa and the end of the British Empire. The UK had already suffered the international humiliation of the 1956 Suez Crisis, which showed that it was no longer the superpower it had been before World War II. For many in Scotland, this served to undermine one of the principal raisons d'être for the United Kingdom and also symbolised the end of popular imperialism and the Imperial unity that had united the then-prominent Scottish Unionist Party. The Unionist Party subsequently suffered a steady decline in support.^[19][20]

1979 First devolution referendum

Main article: 1979 Scottish devolution referendum

The Scottish National Party (SNP) won their second-ever seat in the House of Commons in 1967, when Winnie Ewing was the unexpected winner of the 1967 Hamilton by-election. The seat was previously a safe Labour Party seat, and this victory brought the SNP to national prominence, leading to Edward Heath's 1968 Declaration of Perth and the establishment of the Kilbrandon Commission.^[21] The discovery of North Sea oil off the east coast of Scotland in 1970 further invigorated the debate over Scottish independence.^[22] The SNP organised a hugely successful campaign entitled "It's Scotland's oil", emphasising how the discovery of oil could benefit Scotland's struggling deindustrialising economy and its populace.^[23] At the February 1974 general election, seven SNP MPs were elected. The general election resulted in a hung parliament, so Prime Minister Harold Wilson called a second election for October 1974, when the SNP performed even better than in February, winning 11 seats and obtaining over 30% of the total vote in Scotland.^[24]

In January 1974, the Conservative government had commissioned the McCrone report, written by Professor Gavin McCrone, a leading government economist, to report on the viability of an independent Scotland. He concluded that oil would have given an independent Scotland one of the strongest currencies in Europe. The report went on to say that officials advised government ministers on how to take "the wind out of the SNP sails". Handed over to the incoming Labour government and classified as secret because of Labour fears over the surge in Scottish National Party popularity, the document came to light only in 2005, when the SNP obtained the report under the Freedom of Information Act 2000.^{[25][26] [failed verification]}

The Labour Party, led by Harold Wilson, won the October 1974 general election with the very narrow majority of only three seats. Following their election to Parliament, the SNP MPs pressed for the creation of a Scottish Assembly: a viewpoint which was given added credibility by the conclusions of the Kilbrandon Commission. However, opponents demanded that a referendum be held on the issue. Although the Labour Party and the Scottish National Party both officially supported devolution, support was split in both parties. Labour was divided between those who favoured devolution and those who wanted to maintain a full central Westminster government. In the SNP, there was division between those who saw devolution as a stepping stone to independence and those who feared it might detract from that ultimate goal.^[22] The resignation of Harold Wilson from office in 1976 brought James Callaghan to power, but his small majority was eroded by several by-election losses, and the government became increasingly unpopular. Deals were made with the SNP and Plaid Cymru to hold referendums on devolution in exchange for their support, helping to prolong the government's life.

The result of the referendum in Scotland was a narrow majority in favour of devolution (52% to 48%),^[22] but a condition of the referendum was that 40% of the total electorate should vote in favour in order to make it valid. But the turnout was only 63.6%, so only 32.9% of the electorate voted "Yes". The Scotland Act 1978 was consequently repealed in March 1979 by a vote of 301–206 in Parliament. In the wake of the referendum, the supporters of the bill conducted a protest campaign under the slogan "Scotland said yes". They said that the 40% rule was undemocratic and that the referendum results justified the establishment of the assembly. Campaigners for a "No" vote countered that voters had been told before the referendum that failing to vote was as good as a "No".^[27] It was therefore incorrect to conclude that the relatively low turnout was entirely due to voter apathy.

In protest, the SNP withdrew their support from the government. A motion of no confidence was then tabled by the Conservatives and supported by the SNP, the Liberals and Ulster Unionists. It passed by one vote on 28 March 1979, forcing the May 1979 general election, which was won by the Conservatives led by Margaret Thatcher. Prime Minister Callaghan described the decision of the SNP to bring down the Labour government as "turkeys voting for Christmas".^[28][29] The SNP group was reduced from 11 MPs to 2 at the 1979 general election, while devolution was opposed by the Conservative governments led by Margaret Thatcher and John Major.

1997 Second devolution referendum

Main article: 1997 Scottish devolution referendum

 

The Debating chamber of the Scottish Parliament, commonly known as Holyrood.

Supporters of Scottish independence continued to hold mixed views on the Home Rule movement, which included many supporters of union who wanted devolution within the framework of the United Kingdom. Some saw it as a stepping stone to independence, while others wanted to go straight for independence.^[30]

In the years of the Conservative government after 1979, the Campaign for a Scottish Assembly was established, eventually publishing the Claim of Right 1989. This led to the Scottish Constitutional Convention. The convention promoted consensus on devolution on a cross-party basis, though the Conservative Party refused to co-operate and the Scottish National Party withdrew from the discussions when it became clear that the convention was unwilling to discuss Scottish independence as a constitutional option.^[22] Arguments against devolution and the Scottish Parliament, levelled mainly by the Conservative Party, were that the Parliament would create a "slippery slope" to Scottish independence and provide the pro-independence Scottish National Party with a route to government.^[31] Prime Minister John Major campaigned during the 1997 general election on the slogan "72 hours to save the union". His party ultimately suffered the worst electoral defeat in 91 years.^[32]

The Labour Party won the 1997 general election in a landslide, and Donald Dewar as Secretary of State for Scotland agreed to the proposals for a Scottish Parliament. A referendum was held in September and 74.3% of those who voted approved the devolution plan (44.87% of the electorate).^[33] The Parliament of the United Kingdom subsequently approved the Scotland Act 1998 which created an elected Scottish Parliament with control over most domestic policy.^[22] In May 1999, Scotland held its first election for a devolved parliament, and in July 1999, the Scottish Parliament held session for the first time since the previous parliament had been adjourned in 1707, after a gap of 292 years. Donald Dewar of the Labour Party subsequently became the First Minister of Scotland, while the Scottish National Party became the main opposition party. The egalitarian song "A Man's A Man for A' That", by Robert Burns, was performed at the opening ceremony.^[34]

The Scottish Parliament is a unicameral legislature comprising 129 members. 73 members (57 pc) represent individual constituencies and are elected on a first past the post system. 56 members (43 pc) are elected in eight different electoral regions by the additional member system. Members serve for a four-year term. The monarch appoints one Member of the Scottish Parliament, on the nomination of the Parliament, to be First Minister, with the convention being that the leader of the party with the largest number of seats is appointed First Minister, although any member who can command the confidence of a majority of the chamber could conceivably be appointed First Minister. All other Ministers are appointed and dismissed by the First Minister, and together they make up the Scottish Government, the executive arm of government.^[35]

The Scottish Parliament has legislative authority for all non-reserved matters relating to Scotland, and has a limited power to vary income tax, nicknamed the Tartan Tax, a power it did not exercise and which was later replaced by wider tax-varying powers. The Scottish Parliament can refer devolved matters back to Westminster to be considered as part of United Kingdom-wide legislation by passing a Legislative Consent Motion if United Kingdom-wide legislation is considered to be more appropriate for certain issues. The programmes of legislation enacted by the Scottish Parliament since 1999 have seen a divergence in the provision of public services compared to the rest of the United Kingdom. For instance, the costs of a university education, and care services for the elderly are free at point of use in Scotland, while fees are paid in the rest of the UK. Scotland was the first country in the UK to ban smoking in enclosed public places in March 2006.^[36]

2014 independence referendum

Main article: 2014 Scottish independence referendum

 

Survey of the importance of holding a referendum, carried out by the BBC in April 2011.

 

Referendum result

In its manifesto for the 2007 Scottish Parliament election, the Scottish National Party (SNP) pledged to hold an independence referendum by 2010.^[37][38] After winning the election,^[39] the SNP-controlled Scottish Government published a white paper entitled "Choosing Scotland's Future", which outlined options for the future of Scotland, including independence.^[40][41] Scottish Labour, the Scottish Conservatives and Scottish Liberal Democrats opposed a referendum offering independence as an option. Prime Minister Gordon Brown also publicly attacked the independence option.^[42] The three main parties opposed to independence instead formed a Commission on Scottish Devolution, chaired by Kenneth Calman.^[43][44] This reviewed devolution and considered all constitutional options apart from independence.^[45] In August 2009, the Scottish Government announced that the Referendum (Scotland) Bill, 2010, which would detail the question and conduct of a possible referendum on the issue of independence, would be part of its legislative programme for 2009–10. The Bill was not expected to be passed, because of the SNP's status as a minority government and the opposition of all other major parties in Parliament.^[46][47] In September 2010, the Scottish Government announced that no referendum would occur before the 2011 Scottish Parliament election.^[48]

The SNP won an overall majority in the Scottish Parliament at the 2011 Scottish election.^[49][50] First Minister Alex Salmond stated his desire to hold a referendum "in the second half of the parliament", which would place it in 2014 or 2015.^[51] In January 2012, the UK Government offered to provide the Scottish Parliament with the specific powers to hold a referendum, providing it was "fair, legal and decisive".^[52][53] Negotiations continued between the two governments until October 2012, when the Edinburgh Agreement was reached.^[54] The Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Act 2013 was passed by the Scottish Parliament on 27 June 2013 and received Royal Assent on 7 August 2013.^[55] On 15 November 2013, the Scottish Government published Scotland's Future, a 670-page white paper laying out the case for independence and the means through which Scotland might become an independent country.^[56]

 

UK Prime Minister David Cameron in Edinburgh to discuss the new powers that Scotland would obtain through the Scotland Act 2016

After a protracted period of negotiation, a public debate between Salmond and Better Together leader Alistair Darling was arranged.^[57] On the morning before the televised debate, a joint statement, pledging greater devolved powers to Scotland in the event of a "No" vote, was signed by Prime Minister David Cameron (Leader of the Conservative Party), Deputy Prime Minister Nick Clegg (Leader of the Liberal Democrats), and Leader of the Opposition Ed Miliband (Leader of the Labour Party).^[58]

The BBC website announced the final result of the referendum at 06:24 on 19 September 2014: the "No" vote prevailed with 55% (2,001,926) of the votes from an overall voter turnout of 84.5%. Chief counting officer Mary Pitcaithly stated: "It is clear that the majority of people voting have voted No to the referendum question." The "Yes" vote received 45% (1,617,989) support—the winning total needed was 1,852,828. Results were compiled from 32 council areas, with Glasgow backing independence—voting 53.5% "Yes" to 46.5% "No" (turnout in the area was 75%)—and Edinburgh voting against independence by 61% to 39% (turnout in the area was 84%). Darling stated in his post-result speech, "The silent have spoken", while Salmond stated, "I accept the verdict of the people, and I call on all of Scotland to follow suit in accepting the democratic verdict".^{[8][59][60][61][62]}

UK withdrawal from the European Union

See also: Proposed second Scottish independence referendum, Brexit, and 2016 United Kingdom European Union membership referendum

 

Ministers from the Scottish and UK Governments meet to discuss Brexit, 2017

In 2016, the UK voted to leave the EU in the Brexit referendum, however Scotland voted to remain by 62% to 38%.^[63] Leading pro-independence figures suggested a second independence referendum.^[64][65] For example, First Minister of Scotland Nicola Sturgeon said that she was looking at all options to "secure our place in the EU", and that a second referendum was "highly likely".^[66] However, a spokesperson for Prime Minister Theresa May said that "The prime minister and the government does not believe that there is a mandate for [a second referendum]. There was one only two years ago. There was an extremely high turnout and there was a resounding result in favour of Scotland remaining in the UK".^[67][68]

At the 2019 United Kingdom general election, the SNP won 48 out of 59 Scottish seats. Sturgeon asked Prime Minister Boris Johnson for his consent to hold another referendum.^[69] However, Johnson declined her request. He said that Sturgeon and her predecessor Alex Salmond had promised that the 2014 referendum would be a "once in a generation" vote.^[70]

Shortly before the UK left the European single market, the Boris Johnson regime sought through the United Kingdom Internal Market Act 2020 to restrict the legislative competence of the Scottish Parliament. The primary purpose of the act is to constrain the capacity of the devolved institutions to use their regulatory autonomy.^[71] The legislation undermines the capability of the Scottish legislature to make different economic or social choices from those made in Westminster.^[80] In a January 2021 editorial concerning rising support for independence and its potential to break up the union, the Financial Times indicates that the Internal Market Act may serve to further the cause of independence:^[81]

An example of what not to do was the government’s Internal Market Act, in which London retook control of structural funds previously disbursed by the EU.

This view was mirrored by the Scottish Government in a report published in March 2021, which states that the act is "radically undermining the powers and democratic accountability of the Scottish Parliament."^[82]

2021 Scottish elections

 

Following the 2021 election, the SNP and Scottish Greens agreed a power sharing agreement known as the Bute House Agreement, giving the SNP government a majority in the Scottish Parliament

In January 2021, Nicola Sturgeon said that another referendum would be held if pro-independence parties won a majority of seats at the 2021 Scottish Parliament election. Opposition parties criticised the SNP, stating that they were putting independence ahead of the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic.^[83] Although the SNP fell one seat short of winning outright, the eight seats won by the Scottish Greens meant that pro-independence parties had won a majority of seats in the election.^[84] Speaking after the election, both SNP and Conservative representatives said that a referendum would not occur during the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic.^[85]

The Scottish Government plans to hold a second independence referendum before the end of the current Scottish Parliament.^[86] Nicola Sturgeon has indicated the vote would be held by 2023. Boris Johnson has stated that he would not grant authorisation for a referendum, but the SNP has indicated it is prepared to hold a referendum regardless. According to a poll of 1000 voters conducted for Politico Europe, 43% said they agreed that Scotland should only hold a second independence referendum if the U.K. government agrees to it.^[87]

In January 2022, The Herald reported that the Scottish Government were paying eleven civil servants a total of £700,000 per year to plan for Scottish independence. In its response to the newspaper, the government stated "As set out in the 2021/22 Programme for Government (PfG), the Scottish Government will work to ensure that a legitimate and constitutional referendum can be held within this Parliament, and if the Covid crisis is over, within the first half of this Parliament." The Scottish Conservatives constitution spokesperson Donald Cameron and Scottish Liberal Democrats leader Alex Cole-Hamilton opposed the spending. Cole-Hamilton said "to spend more than £500,000 on a fool's errand of another prospectus for independence makes it less of a white paper and more of a white elephant" and suggested the SNP and Green Party are "off their rockers". SNP President Michael Russell remarked that the SNP and Green Party's victory in the election indicated they have a mandate to hold a second referendum to make Scotland an independent country.^[86]

Proposed 2023 independence referendum

Main article: Proposed second Scottish independence referendum

 

The Scottish Government began publishing independence prospectus papers, Building a New Scotland, under First Minister Nicola Sturgeon in 2022

On 28 June 2022, First Minister Nicola Sturgeon proposed to hold a second Scottish independence referendum on 19 October 2023, provided that the legality and constitutionality of the referendum is guaranteed.^[88] She set out a three-stage process, starting with the Scottish Government making a request for a Section 30 order (parliamentary powers) to hold a referendum.^[88] If that was rejected, it would ask the UK Supreme Court to adjudicate whether the Scottish Parliament could legislate for a referendum without that transfer of powers.^[88] If that was also rejected, she wished to turn the next UK general election into a "de facto" referendum.^[88]

A week later, Prime Minister Boris Johnson rejected the request for a Section 30 transfer of powers.^[89] The Scottish Government lodged a case with the Supreme Court to determine whether the powers to hold a referendum are within the competence of the Scottish Parliament. A hearing took place on 11 and 12 October 2022,^[90][91] and a month later the Supreme Court ruled that the Scottish Parliament does not have the power to legislate for an independence referendum.^[92]

Before the Supreme Court hearing Nicola Sturgeon said that, in the eventuality of the Court ruling that the Scottish Parliament did not have the authority to act unilaterally, the SNP would contest the next UK general election as a de facto referendum on independence.^[88] This tactic has been previously used by Irish and Catalan nationalists.^[93] It has been criticised on the grounds that "elections and [...] referendums [...] are quite distinct" and that general elections "[are] often about a range of issues" and "it's not for a political party to dictate the terms of an election".^[93]: 97 Prof Jim Gallagher, chair of Our Scottish Future, said that "whatever UK government emerges won't treat it as having been an independence referendum".^[93]: 97

Legal position

See also: 2014 Scottish independence referendum § Legality of a referendum

Power to declare independence

While in Northern Ireland, the system of devolution includes a provision for independence referendums, under the Scottish devolution framework, there is no equivalent provision. Therefore, Scottish independence would need to be enacted exceptionally by a competent authority. Due to the UK having no codified constitution, there is dispute over which authorities have competence to enact Scottish independence.^[93]

The UK Parliament retains parliamentary sovereignty over the United Kingdom as a whole.^[94][95][96] Under this principle, the UK Parliament could enact Scottish independence without the need for a referendum.^[93] In AXA General Insurance Ltd and others v HM Advocate and others, the Deputy President of the Supreme Court, Lord Hope of Craighead, stated that "the sovereignty of the Crown in Parliament [...] is the bedrock of the British constitution. Sovereignty remains with the United Kingdom Parliament."^[97] However, the application of the principle of parliamentary sovereignty to Scotland has been disputed. In MacCormick v The Lord Advocate, the Lord President of the Court of Session, Lord Cooper of Culross stated obiter dicta that "the principle of the unlimited sovereignty of Parliament is a distinctively English principle which has no counterpart in Scottish Constitutional Law."^[98] It has been suggested that the doctrine of popular sovereignty,^[99] proclaimed in the 1320 Declaration of Arbroath ^{[citation needed]}, articulated by Scottish political thinkers like George Buchanan and reasserted by the Claim of Right 1989 (signed by nearly every Labour and Liberal Democrat MP in Scotland at the time),^[100][101] is of greater relevance to Scotland.

Some lawyers have said that Parliament cannot repeal the Acts of Union because the Treaty of Union is a treaty in international law, made by two no longer existing, independent states.^[93] The law scholar David Walker wrote that regardless of any amendment or repeal of the Acts, the Treaty would remain in force because Parliament cannot alter the terms of international treaties.^[102] Professors James Crawford and Alan Boyle write that it is unlikely the Treaty of Union can be considered a treaty, but rather, as Smith^[103] wrote, it was a 'record of negotiations' and that the UK could not 'be bound by a treaty to which it was not party'.^[104] This notion that Parliament cannot amend the terms of the Union's creation is challenged by the fact that the Acts have been successfully amended by the Parliament several times.^[93] David Walker writes that simply because Parliament purports to amend an Act does not mean it has done so.^[102] When HM Government ratifies a treaty, it does not however bring it into domestic law, it only creates certain rights or duties for the Government. An Act is only brought into domestic law by Parliament legislating thus. According to a 2017 Supreme Court ruling, ministers cannot make changes to UK constitutional arrangements without an Act of Parliament. There is no legal role for the Scottish Parliament or Government in treaties and under devolution, treaty-making is the sole responsibility of the UK Government.^[105]

The legality of any UK constituent country attaining de facto independence or declaring unilateral independence outside the framework of British constitutional convention is debatable. Under international law, a unilateral declaration might satisfy the principle of the "declarative theory of statehood", but not the "constitutive theory of statehood". Some legal opinion following the Supreme Court of Canada's decision on what steps Quebec would need to take to secede is that Scotland would be unable to unilaterally declare independence under international law if the UK Government permitted a referendum on an unambiguous question on secession.^[106][107] The SNP have not sought a unilateral act, but rather state that a positive vote for independence in a referendum would have "enormous moral and political force... impossible for a future [Westminster] government to ignore",^[108] and hence would give the Scottish Government a mandate to negotiate for the passage of an act of the UK Parliament providing for Scotland's secession, in which Westminster renounces its sovereignty over Scotland.^[109]

The United Nations Charter enshrines the right of peoples to self-determination, and the Universal Declaration of Human Rights also guarantees peoples' right to change nationality; the UK is a signatory to both documents. Politicians in both the Scottish and UK parliaments have endorsed the right of the Scottish people to self-determination, including former UK Prime Ministers John Major and Margaret Thatcher.^[110]

Power to hold an independence referendum

 

The Lord Advocate, Dorothy Bain, argued the Scottish Government's case for the granting of a Section 30 order before the Supreme Court in October 2022

The issue of the Scottish Government's power to hold and the Scottish Parliament's competence to legislate for an independence referendum is a subject of intense debate both inside and outside Scotland. In November 2022 the UK Supreme Court gave a judgment that the Scottish Parliament does not have the power to legislate for an independence referendum.^[92] The Scotland Act 1998 reserved powers over "the Union of the Kingdoms of Scotland and England" to the UK Parliament. Any provision is outwith the competence of the Scottish Parliament if "it relates to reserved matters" under Section 29(2) of the Act. This formed the basis of the UK Supreme Court's judgment on the Scottish Parliament's competence to legislate on the matter.^[92]

To ensure the undisputed constitutional legality of the 2014 Scottish independence referendum, the Scottish and UK Governments signed the Edinburgh Agreement stating that both would accept and "continue to work together constructively in the light of the outcome [of the referendum], whatever it is, in the best interests of the people of Scotland and of the rest of the United Kingdom".^[111] The agreement, with the subsequent approval of the UK Parliament, gave the Scottish Parliament special legal authority to hold an independence referendum before the end of 2014.^[111][112]

No such agreement has been reached in respect of a second referendum, throwing doubt over its legal status. In December 2019, Martin Keatings, a pro-independence independent candidate, sought a declarator to the Court of Session. However Lady Carmichael said the case lacked standing due to its hypothetical nature. Nevertheless, Mr Keatings brought an appeal forward in April 2021 as the Scottish Government had now published a bill,^[93] however this appeal was lost.^[113]

With the publication of the draft Independence Referendum Bill^[114] on 22 March 2021^[115] the question of legality was raised again. On 28 June 2022, Sturgeon proposed to hold a referendum in 2023, provided that the legality and constitutionality of the referendum is guaranteed.^[88] The Scottish Government stated that their proposed referendum is "consultative, not self-executing". In UK law, a referendum can be consultative (such as the Brexit referendum) or determinative (such as the AV referendum, which, if passed, would have automatically brought in provisions for the Alternative Vote).^[93] The Scotland Act does not explicitly state whether non-binding referendums on reserve powers were reserved.^[93] In the Scottish Government's written case published in July 2022, the Lord Advocate observed that "the Union of the Kingdoms of Scotland and England has been superseded as a matter of law and exists only as an historical fact. The [Scotland Act] would therefore reserve something that no longer exists."^[93]

The Scottish Government lodged a case with the Supreme Court to determine whether the powers to hold a referendum are within the competence of the Scottish Parliament, and a hearing took place on 11 and 12 October 2022.^[90] A month later, the UK Supreme Court gave a judgment that the Scottish Parliament does not have the power to hold an independence referendum because it relates to the Union of England and Scotland and the sovereignty of the UK Parliament, which are matters reserved to the UK Parliament.^[92]

Issues

Culture

In 2014, the Scottish Government wrote that "[Scotland's] approach [to culture] has been, and will continue to be, distinct from that of Westminster". The Scottish Government position was that Scottish independence would give the Scottish Government more powers to encourage culture and creative sectors. In the event of independence, the Scottish Government planned to increase domestic creative production opportunities, such as by setting up a new national broadcaster, while maintaining access to current TV channels and with no additional cost to viewers and listeners.^[116]

Democracy

The concept of a democratic deficit is the most frequently invoked argument in favour of independence. England has a majority (84%) of the UK population. Thus, constituency results for Scotland rarely affect the outcome of general elections. From the 1960s onwards, average voting patterns in Scotland and England have diverged.^[117] Scotland has only elected a majority of governing MPs in three of the 11 UK general elections since 1979.^[118] Devolution was intended to close this deficit,^[119] but Brexit, which happened despite 62% of voters in Scotland voting against it,^[120] has highlighted this concern.^[121] The Conservative Party, which often forms the UK Government by winning general elections, has not won a plurality of seats in Scotland since 1955.

Underpinning the democratic deficit argument is an assumption that Scotland is a nation with a right to self-determination.^[117] Were Scotland independent, Scotland's population would possess full decision-making power in regard to the political affairs of its nation. Alex Salmond stated in a May 2012 launch that "the people who live in Scotland are best placed to make the decisions that affect Scotland."^[122]

In January 2023, the UK Government blocked the Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill from going to royal assent after it passed the Scottish Parliament 86 to 39. The UK Government overruled the bill by using for the first ever time Section 35 powers under the Scotland Act; the justification for the move was that they believed it would impact equalities legislation, which is reserved to Westminster.^[123] Nicola Sturgeon responded, arguing that the block had 'no grounds' and constituted a 'full-frontal attack on democracy'.^[124]

Nationality and citizenship

The United Kingdom is a plurinational, rather than multinational, state, where overlapping national identities exist. According to Keating, both Scottishness and Britishness can be understood as a national identity and one can hold one of them alone or both at the same time.^[125][117] Many people in Scotland have multiple national identities. 59% in Scotland surveyed by the BBC in 2018 said they felt strongly British, though the figure is lower than the equivalent in Wales (79%) and England (82%).^[126] However, the majority of Scots feel closer affinity to a Scottish, rather than a British national identity. In a 2021 survey, when asked about their national identity and only allowed to pick one option, 64% of Scottish residents identify as Scottish and 29% as British.^[127] Furthermore, many in Scotland do not feel a national affinity to the UK at all. In a poll taken in early 2021 by Panelbase, a third of respondents in Scotland said they felt Scottish but not British.^[128]

A category of 'Scottish citizenship' does not currently exist, as nationality law is reserved to Westminster. In the event of independence, Scotland and the rest of the UK would need to set new citizenship laws to allocate British and/or Scottish citizenship to existing British citizens and set out Scotland's new nationality laws. For the 2014 referendum, the Yes side said Scotland would tolerate dual citizenship. British citizens habitually resident in Scotland and Scottish-born British citizens elsewhere would have been able to become Scottish citizens automatically.^[129] SNP MP Pete Wishart said in 2013 that Scots would 'of course' be able to keep a UK passport, but Home Secretary Theresa May said Scots may not have that option.^[130]

Economy

 

Edinburgh, Scotland's capital city and financial centre, the fourth largest financial hub in Europe^[131]

Independence would mean a much greater change for business than devolution.^[132]: 219 While Scottish nationalists generally assert that independence would not be economically disruptive, unionists and the UK government tend to assert the opposite.^[132]: 231 Journalist Peter Jones writes that calculating the real economic impacts of independence (i.e. whether Scotland would be richer or poorer outwith the UK) is "an extremely hazard, if not impossible, task".^[133]

If businesses concluded that independence would yield benefits, there could be positive economic effects. However, if businesses do not, they could postpone spending or investment plans or even leave Scotland entirely.^[132]: 219 Uncertainty caused by independence referendums can also have negative implications for financial markets and the wider economy, depending on the likelihood that separation wins. This uncertainty has impacts not only in Scotland, but in the whole of the UK. Due to the relative size of Scotland in the UK, any negative economic effects would be felt worse in Scotland.^[132]: 232

Economic modelling by the Centre for Economic Performance found that independence would hit Scotland's economy ‘two to three times’ harder than Brexit. According to their model, leaving the UK after Brexit could reduce Scottish income per capita between 6.5 per cent and 8.7 per cent, depending on trade barriers. Rejoining the EU would do little to mitigate the costs of Brexit, because the cost of removing trade barriers with the EU is outweighed by the cost of erecting trade barriers with the UK.^[134] Scotland's largest trading partner is the rest of the UK, which accounts for £51.2 billion in exported goods and services, compared to only £16.1 billion to EU countries.^[135] According to Nicola Sturgeon, a customs border with the rest of the UK would be needed.^[136][137] 42% of those in Scotland think it would be financially worse off outside the Union (compared to 36% who think it would be better).^[128]

Natural resources

 

An oil rig in the North Sea, oil production is centred in the waters off the Scottish northeast coast

The nationalist position is that only an independent Scotland can fully utilise and exploit its national resources, including North Sea oil and gas, for the benefit of its population.^[138] According to the Scottish Government led by Alex Salmond in 2014, 64% of the EU's oil reserves existed in Scottish waters,^[139] while the David Hume Institute think tank^[140] estimated that "Scotland is sitting on oil and gas reserves worth up to £4 trillion".^[141] Investment in and production from the North Sea oilfields dropped sharply after Conservative chancellor George Osborne imposed punitive taxes, undercutting the projected revenue an independent Scotland could claim.^[142]

David Maddox, writing for The Scotsman in 2008, pointed to a future Peak oil decline in North Sea oil revenue,^[143] within ten years oil revenue had fallen to 10% of the 2008 peak.^[144] Some, such as Ruth Davidson of the Scottish Conservatives,^[145] wish to reduce public spending and devolve more fiscal powers to the Scottish Parliament in order to address this issue within the broader framework of the Union.^{[146][147][148]} Outlying regions such as Orkney, Shetland and the Western Isles would be disadvantaged or deserve a greater share of oil revenue.^{[149][150][151][152][153][154]}

Public finances

An independent Scotland would have full autonomy over decisions on tax, spending and borrowing. Scotland would be able to issue sovereign debt and set fiscal limits.^[155] According to the Scottish Government, it is clear that Scotland currently pays its way within the UK.^[116] The Scottish Government has proposed setting up a 'New Scotland Fund' to provide capital investment and boost growth. According to the charity Institute for Fiscal Studies, this fund would likely need to be funded by additional borrowing.^[156]

According to an analysis by the Financial Times, an independent Scotland would have a large hole in its public finances. The paper's analysis suggests this would be due to the combined effect of lower than expected tax revenues, Brexit and the COVID-19 pandemic, which have increased the country's budget deficit.^[157] A publication by the charity Institute for Fiscal Studies claims that in 2020-21 (during the COVID-19 pandemic), the national deficit of Scotland was between 22% and 25% of national income, though this is predicted to fall after the pandemic.^[158] The same publication claims that if it leaves the UK by the middle of the decade, Scotland would have a deficit of almost 10 per cent of GDP. If correct, this would mean Scotland would need to raise taxes or cut public spending^[158] by the equivalent of £1765 per person after independence to make the deficit sustainable.^[157] Short-term forecasts of public spending are inherently uncertain, but can still provide useful predictions.^[159] A report published by the Sustainable Growth Commission set up by the SNP to make recommendations on the economy of an independent Scotland stated that the deficit would need to be cut to 3 per cent of GDP.^[160]

Currency

See also: Irish pound § Second pound

 

The Bank of Scotland, one of the worlds oldest banks, may become the central bank of Scotland upon independence^[161]

Before the 2014 referendum, there were questions over the currency of an independent Scotland and whether it would continue to use the Pound sterling, adopt the Euro, or introduce a Scottish currency (often referred to as the "Scottish pound"^[162]). Uncertainty could be brought in the immediate aftermath of independence, particularly disagreement as to how Scotland would be treated in relation to the European Union, and the unlikelihood of the Bank of England accepting a currency union with an independent Scotland.^[163][164] The chairman of HSBC, Douglas Flint, warned in August 2014 of uncertainty if there was an independent Scottish currency, or if Scotland joined the Eurozone, which could result in capital flight.^[165] In 2018, the SNP suggested keeping the pound for a period after Scottish independence. Dame DeAnne Julius, a founding member of the Bank of England Monetary Policy Committee, has called this a "hugely risky experiment for Scotland".^[166]

Nicola Sturgeon announced in October 2022 her intention for Scotland to continue using the pound sterling after independence. Monetary policy in this period would be set by the Bank of England. Scotland would subsequently develop a central Scottish bank and would move to a Scottish pound "when the economic conditions were right".^[162][167] The establishment of a Scottish pound would be at the decision of the Scottish Parliament, once the Scottish Central Bank has established credibility, foreign exchange reserves are sufficient and Scotland is fiscally sustainable. The Scottish pound could run on a fixed or floating exchange rate.^[155]

Defence

See also: Armed forces in Scotland

 

Soldiers of the Royal Regiment of Scotland, the senior and only current Scottish line infantry regiment of the British Army Infantry

With control over defence and foreign policy, an independent Scotland could demand the removal of Trident nuclear weapons, which are based in the Firth of Clyde. Nuclear disarmament is an issue long associated with the campaign for an independent Scotland, as outlined in the House of Commons Defence Committee's white paper "The future of the UK's strategic nuclear deterrent: the White Paper" of 2006–2007.^[168][169] The Scottish Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament supports independence on this basis.^[170]

Scottish voters are in favour of the Trident nuclear deterrent being in Scotland. Even in the event of a vote for independence, 45 per cent of Scots polled in 2022 think the nuclear deterrent should be maintained in Scotland, compared to 34 percent against.^[171] While in the Union, 58% of Scots believe in the retention of the nuclear deterrent and only 20% definitely want it axed.^[172] In the event that Scottish independence meant the nuclear deterrent could no longer be in Scotland, there is a risk that the costs of relocation would make keeping a nuclear deterrent in the British Isles unfeasible.^[173] In 2019, the NATO Secretary General said the maintenance of a British nuclear deterrent is important to NATO.^[174] In 2022, 73 percent of Scots would want an independent Scotland to be part on NATO and only 8 percent oppose this.^[175]

The UK Defence Journal writes that the defence of Scotland is best served as part of the UK.^[176] Scotland is said to benefit from a collective defence force and an independent Scotland would weaken the UK's defence posture.^[173] There are many UK defence installations in Scotland other than Trident and many Scottish people serve in the British Armed Forces. There are 12,000 service personnel in Scotland and a further 18,500 civilian jobs in the armed forces defence industry. It is expected Scotland would lose defence jobs. For example, Lord West said Scotland could lose 20,000 or 25,000 jobs.^[177]

In 2014, a UK Government report stated that Scotland "plays an integral part in all aspects of the UK's defence". The report said the new Scottish Government would need to set up much defence infrastructure and services from scratch, and that existing defence assets in Scotland are well integrated into a UK-wide defence structure. According to the UK Government, it would be difficult for an independent Scotland to co-opt existing UK armed force units based or recruited in Scotland.^[178]

Foreign affairs

See also: International relations of Scotland

 

Scotland in Europe

Under the Scottish Government's 2014 plans for independence, Scotland would have applied to become a full and equal member of the United Nations, NATO and the European Union and many other international organisations.^[116] With an autonomous voice in international politics, Scottish independence campaigners believe the nation's global influence would increase in regard to the defence of its national interests and the promotion of its values. Furthermore, Scottish embassies could be established globally to promote Scotland internationally, and to lobby other governments on the nation's behalf.^[116]

During the 2014 referendum, a major argument against independence was that Scotland would be outside the EU.^{[citation needed]} Scotland is very supportive of EU membership, with 62% voting to remain in the 2016 EU referendum. Since Brexit, many have called for a second independence referendum to have a chance to re-enter the EU.^[179]

As part of the UK, Scotland is part of NATO, the G7, and as a permanent member of the UN Security Council. 82% of Scots believe that UK membership of these organisations is important.^[172] Opponents of further integration of the European Union have stated that independence, within Europe but outside the EU three, would mean that Scotland would be more marginalised because, as a relatively small independent country, Scotland would be unable to resist the demands of larger member states.^[180]

Links with the rest of the UK

 

Scotland has been a member of the British-Irish Council since 1999, an intergovernmental organisation that aims to improve collaboration between its members

There are strong historical and contemporary ties between Scotland and the rest of the UK from the Reformation and Union of Crowns, to Scottish involvement in the growth and development of the British Empire ^{[citation needed]} and contribution of the Scottish Enlightenment and Industrial Revolution. Contemporary popular culture is also shared, primarily through the prevalence of the English language. Almost half of the Scottish population have relatives in England.^[181] At the time of the 2011 census, approximately 700,000 adults who were born in Scotland lived in the rest of the UK, while about 470,000 adults who were born elsewhere in the UK had moved to live in Scotland.^[182] There are also significant economic links with the Scottish military-industrial complex,^[183] and as argued by David Cameron, close links within the financial sector.^[184]

In Scotland's Future, the Scottish Government wrote that an independent Scotland would "not affect the many other ties that bind Scotland to the other nations of the UK" and that there will still be a social union of family, history, culture and language within the British Isles.^[116]: 215 The UK Government wrote that a relationship of two sovereign states based on self-interest is 'profoundly differently' from being part of one state, and thus any co-operation would need to be in the interest of the rest of the UK, as well as Scotland.^[117] In the Building a New Scotland series of papers, published to support the argument for independence in a proposed second independence referendum, the Scottish Government advocates that "independence would mark a new phase in the evolution of Scotland’s relationships with the UK and Ireland. While the ‘social union’ of shared histories, sport, culture, languages, and family ties would continue as before, a renewed Scottish democracy would be a force for good across these islands". The Scottish Government advocates that an independent Scotland "will have close, mutually beneficial relationships across these islands on defence and security matters".^[185]

The Scottish Government proposes that a reformed British-Irish Council would "provide a formal forum for managing some of these relationships, complementing regular bilateral discussions".^[186]

Comparison to Brexit

The Centre for Constitutional Change stated during the 2016 EU referendum campaign that the "international relations aspect of the Brexit debate looks somewhat similar to the debate about Scottish independence".^[187] There is no agreed process for Scottish independence and there would be no negotiations of the terms of independence before a positive referendum result.^[188] Ruth Davidson has described "independence because of Brexit" as "amputating your foot because you've stubbed your toe".^[189] The common use of the term Brexit has led some sources to describe Scottish independence as "Scexit",^{[190][191][192][193]} a portmanteau of Scotland + exit.^[194]

Support for independence

 

Pro-independence rally in Glasgow, 2018

Scottish independence is supported most prominently by the Scottish National Party, but other parties also support independence. Other pro-independence parties which have held representation in the Scottish Parliament or the UK Parliament include the Scottish Greens,^[195] the Alba Party and the Scottish Socialist Party. Other parties which support Scottish independence include the Independence for Scotland Party, and the Scottish Libertarian Party. At the 2021 Scottish Parliament election, 72 of the 129 seats available were won by pro-independence parties (64 SNP and 8 Greens). The independence movement consists of many factions with varying political views. The SNP wants Scotland to keep the monarchy (see personal union) and become an independent Commonwealth realm, similar to Canada, Australia or New Zealand. All of the other aforementioned pro-independence parties want Scotland to become an independent republic. The SSP has led republican protests and authored the Declaration of Calton Hill, calling for an independent republic.^[196]

 

Vandalized Yes posters from the 2014 pro-independence referendum campaign by a No supporter.

The Independence Convention was set up in 2005, seeking "Firstly, to create a forum for those of all political persuasions and none who support independence; and secondly, to be a national catalyst for Scottish independence."^[197][198] The Scottish Republican Socialist Movement is a Pan-Socialist independence movement that believes that Scotland should be made an independent republic. This movement has a Firebrand socialist ethos, however is not affiliated with the SSP or the Scottish Communist Party. It believes that a failure to become independent should lead to mass emigration elsewhere, or as put as a slogan "Independence or Desertion".

Apart from the official Yes Scotland campaign for independence in the 2014 referendum, other groups in support of independence were formed at that time. This included the National Collective, an artist-driven movement which describes itself as "an open and non-party political collaboration of talent focused on driving social and political change in Scotland through a variety of the arts".^[199] It was responsible for organising a mock referendum held at the University of Glasgow in February 2013.^[200][201] Another group, the Radical Independence Campaign, described itself as "fighting for an independent Scotland that is for the millions not the millionaires". RIC was formed after the Radical Independence Conference 2012 in Glasgow, which was attended by at least 650 people and has been described as a "[bringing together of] the Scottish Greens, the Scottish Socialists, some of the more militant trade unionists, nuclear-disarmament campaigners and anti-monarchist republicans".^[202]

 

Fly posters from the Scottish Socialist Party

During the 2014 referendum campaign, independence attracted little support from newspapers. The Sunday Herald was the only publication to endorse a "Yes" vote in the referendum.^[203][204] The National, a daily newspaper supporting independence, was launched in November 2014, in wake of the Yes Scotland campaign's defeat.^[203]

In October 2014, the lobby group All Under One Banner (AUOB) was formed. AUOB stages regular public marches in support of Scottish independence throughout Scotland.

Proponents of Brexit and Scotland's independence share relatively similar, but incompatible, objectives and difficulties.^[205] Despite this, those who voted for Brexit in 2016 tend to be more unionist than those who voted to remain. The BBC reported that 39% of those who voted Leave in 2016 would vote Yes, while 59% of those who voted Remain would do the same.^[128]

Pro Unionism

Main article: Unionism in Scotland

 

A "No thanks" sign from the 2014 anti-independence referendum campaign

The Conservative Party, Labour Party and Liberal Democrats, which all have seats in the Scottish Parliament, are in favour of unionism. In 2012 they established the cross-party Better Together campaign. Other parties that oppose Scottish independence include the UK Independence Party (UKIP),^[206][207] All for Unity,^[207] Reform UK,^[207] Abolish the Scottish Parliament,^[207] the British National Party (BNP),^[208] Britain First,^[b][209] the Scottish Unionist Party (SUP), and the Ulster unionist parties.

The campaign called "Scotland in Union" emerged after the 2014 independence referendum.^[210] It has encouraged a positive outlook on unionism, tactical voting in elections and promoted the Union more generally.^{[210][211][212]}'Scotland in Union' has been subject to criticism after records of its donor base were leaked, including many of the UK's wealthy elite, with major landowners, Lords, aristocrats and CEOs of companies all listed. Scotland in Union claims to be a “grassroots” campaign.^[213][214] In late 2017, a new group called "Unity UK" was formed.^[215] Its supporters said that Unionists needed to be more supportive of Brexit and were critical of Scotland in Union's "agnostic" stance on the issue.^[215]

Many leaders of foreign nations expressed support for Unionism during the 2014 independence referendum. Barack Obama expressed his support for a "strong, robust and united" UK.^[216] Then-Swedish Foreign Minister and former prime minister Carl Bildt opposed the "Balkanisation" of the British Isles.^[217]

The Orange Order, a Protestant brotherhood with thousands of members in Scotland, campaigned against Scottish independence,^[218] and formed a campaign group called British Together.^[219] In September 2014, it held a march of at least 15,000 Orangemen, loyalist bands and supporters from Scotland and across the UK;^[220] described as the biggest pro-Union demonstration of the campaign.^[221]

Third option

Potential UK Confederation membership

Main article: Proposed United Kingdom Confederation

A Confederal UK has been proposed as a concept of constitutional reform of the United Kingdom, in which the countries of the United Kingdom; England, Scotland, Wales, as well as Northern Ireland become separate sovereign groups or states that pool certain key resources within a confederal system.^[222]

Public opinion

Main article: Opinion polling on Scottish independence

Polling ahead of the 2014 referendum

Main article: Opinion polling for the 2014 Scottish independence referendum

Many opinion polls were conducted about Scottish independence during the 2014 referendum campaign.^{[223][224][225][226][227][228][229]} Professor John Curtice stated in January 2012 that polling had shown support for independence at between 32% and 38% of the Scottish population.^[230] This had fallen somewhat since the SNP were first elected to become the Scottish Government in 2007.^[230] The research also showed, however, that the proportion of the population strongly opposed to independence had also declined.^[230] Curtice stated in April 2014 that support for independence had increased since December 2013, although there was disagreement between the polling companies as to the true state of public opinion.^[231] Polls in the run-up to the referendum vote showed a closing of the gap, with one YouGov poll giving the Yes campaign a 51–49 lead. In the referendum Scotland voted against independence by 55.3% to 44.7%, with an overall turnout of 84.5%.^[8][9]

Polling since the 2014 referendum

 

Banner adopted by the Scottish Labour Hub to represent a new direction for the Labour Party in Scotland.

Since six weeks after the 2014 referendum, opinion polls have asked how people would vote in a proposed second referendum.^[232] Twenty-five polls were conducted in the year after the referendum, with seventeen of them having "No" as the predominant answer, seven having "Yes", and one having an equal proportion of respondents for each opinion.^[233]

In the year from September 2016 to September 2017, 25 of 26 polls conducted showed "No" as the most popular answer and only one showed "Yes" as the most popular answer.^[234] "No" continued to show a lead in opinion polls until July 2019, when one poll by Lord Ashcroft showed a narrow majority for "Yes".^[235] Professor John Curtice said after this poll was released that there had recently been a swing towards "Yes", and that this was concentrated among people who had voted to "Remain" in the 2016 Brexit referendum.^[235]

This pro-independence trend continued into 2020, as three polls in the early part of the year put "Yes" support at between 50% and 52%.^[236] In October 2020, an Ipsos MORI/STV News poll saw support for independence at its highest ever level, with 58% saying they would vote "Yes".^[237] As of December 2020, fifteen consecutive opinion polls had shown a lead for "Yes".^[238] The run of polls showing a "Yes" lead continued into January 2021, although the average support for Yes was down by two percentage points compared to polls by the same companies in late 2020.^[239] Polls conducted in early March 2021, following testimony by Alex Salmond and Nicola Sturgeon at a Holyrood parliamentary inquiry, showed narrow leads for "No".^[240]

Support for independence in opinion polling depends upon the format of the question being asked. Polling company Survation have asked Scottish voters the question "Should Scotland remain in the United Kingdom or leave the United Kingdom?". Since 2018, none of these polls have shown a lead for Remain of less than 10%.^[241] The rest of the UK generally supports Scotland remaining a part of the UK. YouGov polling between late 2019 and early 2022 shows that support for Scottish independence is at around 30%, while support for Scotland remaining in the UK is at around 45%.^[242]

Following the Supreme Court Judgement of 23 November 2022, determining that the Scottish Government did not have the power to conduct a consultative independence referendum, the first five polls showed majority support for independence in the range of 51% - 56%. In a separate UK-wide poll, for the first time majority support (55%) was expressed across the UK for the right of the Scottish Government to hold an independence referendum.^[243]

See also

Other major independence or related movements

• Yes Scotland
• All Under One Banner
• Welsh independence
• YesCymru
• Proposed Welsh independence referendum
• United Ireland
• Ireland's Future
• English independence
• List of active separatist movements in Europe

Related topics

• Scottish devolution
• Scottish nationalism
• Scottish republicanism
• Potential breakup of the United Kingdom

Organisations

• Scottish Liberals for Independence
• Scottish Socialist Youth

Notes

1. Writing in 1992, Andrew Marr dated the formation of the Kingdom of Scotland at 1034, with the reign of Duncan I.
2. De-registered by the Electoral Commission in February 2017

References

Citations

1. "Inside Information". The Herald. 31 August 1993. Retrieved 8 September 2014.
2. "Brexit: Scots prefer independence to no-deal, poll finds". The Scotsman. 9 December 2018. Retrieved 12 December 2018.
3. Brooks, Libby (15 November 2018). "Sturgeon: Brexit chaos makes independence case stronger every day". The Guardian. Retrieved 12 December 2018.
4. "Scottish nationalists want to take back control". The Economist. 11 October 2018.
5. Massie, Alex (15 December 2019). "Never mind Brexit – Boris Johnson's biggest battle is Scotland trying to take back control" – via www.thetimes.co.uk.
6. "Union with England Act 1707". British Government. Retrieved 12 August 2021.
7. "Scotland's Referendum 2014 - Background". Retrieved 8 September 2014.
8. "Scottish referendum: Scotland votes 'No' to independence". BBC News. 19 September 2014. Retrieved 19 September 2014.
9. . Scotland Now. 19 September 2014. Archived from the original on 11 April 2020. Retrieved 20 September 2014.
10. Sturgeon, Nicola (28 June 2022). "Nicola Sturgeon's full statement announcing the 2023 independence referendum". Scottish National Party. Retrieved 28 June 2022.
11. "Scottish independence: Will there be a second referendum?". BBC. 23 November 2022. Retrieved 27 November 2022.
12. (Marr 2013, p. 10)
13. "Scottish Referendums". BBC. Retrieved 11 June 2007.
14. (Marr 2013, p. 1)
15. (Marr 2013, p. 2)
16. "Scottish Home Rule". Skyminds.net. 6 July 2007. Retrieved 6 April 2009.
17. "Devolution's swings and roundabouts". BBC News. BBC. 7 April 1999. Retrieved 7 January 2014.
18. "1951 Census: Preliminary Report |". Vision of Britain. 8 April 1951. Retrieved 18 October 2013.
19. Gilson, Mike (16 January 2007). "Come and join great debate on nation's past, present and future". The Scotsman. Edinburgh. Retrieved 17 October 2015.
20. . Archived from the original on 27 January 2007.
21. "Scottish Referendums". BBC. 30 November 1990. Retrieved 6 April 2009.
22. "The Devolution Debate This Century". BBC. Retrieved 11 June 2007.
23. Russell, Ben; Kelbie, Paul (10 June 2007). "How black gold was hijacked: North sea oil and the betrayal of Scotland". The Independent. London. Retrieved 17 October 2015.
24. "Regional distribution of seats and percentage vote". psr.keele.ac.uk. Retrieved 21 June 2007.
25. "Papers reveal oil fears over SNP". BBC. 12 September 2005. Retrieved 9 December 2009.
26. "Scottish Economic Planning Department" (PDF).
27. Department of the Official Report (Hansard), House of Commons, Westminster (26 April 1996). "Hansard record of 26 April 1996 : Column 735". Publications.parliament.uk. Retrieved 6 April 2009.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
28. . BBC. 3 May 1979. Archived from the original on 15 May 2005. Retrieved 6 April 2009.
29. Hansard, House of Commons, 5th series, vol. 965, col. 471.
30. Martin, Campbell (23 August 2003). "SNP should return to the honest argument on independence". The Scotsman. Edinburgh. Retrieved 17 October 2015.
31. "Breaking the Old Place up". The Economist. 4 November 1999. Retrieved 14 October 2006.
32. "Politics 97". BBC. September 1997. Retrieved 14 October 2006.
33. (PDF). The Electoral Commission. Archived from the original (PDF) on 6 August 2012. Retrieved 16 December 2009.
34. "In tune with the people". BBC News. 1 July 1999. Retrieved 31 January 2021.
35. . Archived from the original on 19 November 2013. Retrieved 8 September 2014.
36. BBC Scotland News Online "Scotland begins pub smoking ban", BBC Scotland News, 26 March 2006. Retrieved 17 July 2006.
37. "At-a-glance: SNP manifesto". BBC News. BBC. 12 April 2007.
38. "SNP Manifesto (PDF)" (PDF). BBC News. Retrieved 19 January 2012.
39. Wintour, Patrick (4 May 2007). "SNP wins historic victory". The Guardian. London. Retrieved 20 June 2007.
40. "SNP outlines independence plans". BBC News. BBC. 14 August 2007.
41. "Scotland's Future: A National Conversation". 14 August 2008. Retrieved 8 September 2014.
42. "Scots split would harm UK – Brown". BBC News. 25 November 2006. Retrieved 6 April 2009.
43. "Commission on Scottish Devolution". Commission on Scottish Devolution. Retrieved 6 April 2009.
44. "Scotland | Devolution body members announced". BBC News. 28 April 2008. Retrieved 6 April 2009.
45. Calman devolution commission revealed 20 July 2008 at the Wayback Machine, The Herald, 28 April 2008.
46. . Official website, About > Programme for Government > 2009–10 > Summaries of Bills > Referendum Bill. Scottish Government. 2 September 2009. Archived from the original on 7 June 2011. Retrieved 10 September 2009.
47. MacLeod, Angus (3 September 2009). . The Times. London. Archived from the original on 31 May 2010. Retrieved 10 September 2009.
48. "Scottish independence plan 'an election issue'". BBC News. 6 September 2010.
49. "Scottish election: SNP wins election". BBC News. 6 May 2011.
50. Black, Andrew (11 May 2011). "Scotland's 129 MSPs sworn in after SNP win". BBC News. BBC. Retrieved 26 June 2011.
51. Gardham, Magnus (2 May 2011). "Holyrood election 2011: Alex Salmond: Referendum on Scottish independence by 2015". Daily Record. Retrieved 3 August 2011.
52. Clegg, David (17 January 2012). "Advocate General says SNP's referendum plans would be 'contrary to the rule of law'". The Courier. DC Thomson. Retrieved 9 January 2014.
53. Clegg, David (11 January 2012). "Independence referendum: Scotland facing constitutional chaos". The Courier. DC Thomson. Retrieved 9 January 2014.
54. "Timeline: Scottish independence referendum". BBC News. BBC. 15 October 2012. Retrieved 15 October 2012.
55. Text of the Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Act 2013 as in force today (including any amendments) within the United Kingdom, from legislation.gov.uk.
56. "Scottish independence: Referendum White Paper unveiled". BBC News. 26 November 2013. Retrieved 5 January 2014.
57. "Scottish independence: STV confirm Darling and Salmond TV debate date". BBC News. BBC. 9 July 2014. Retrieved 9 July 2014.
58. Severin Carrell (5 August 2014). "Scotland promised extra tax and legal powers for referendum no vote". The Guardian. Retrieved 5 August 2014.
59. Griff Witte (19 September 2014). "Scotland votes to remain part of United Kingdom". The Washington Post. Retrieved 19 September 2014.
60. "Scottish independence: Edinburgh rejects independence". BBC News. 19 September 2014. Retrieved 19 September 2014.
61. "Scottish independence: Glasgow votes Yes to independence". BBC News. 19 September 2014. Retrieved 19 September 2014.
62. "Scottish referendum: Scotland votes no to independence". BBC News. 19 September 2014. Retrieved 19 September 2014.
63. "UK votes to leave the EU". BBC News. 24 June 2016. Retrieved 24 June 2016.
64. "Nicola Sturgeon Denies She Has 'Machiavellian' Wish For Brexit". The Huffington Post UK. 24 January 2016. Retrieved 3 February 2016.
65. Jolly, Seth (22 June 2016). "The end of the United Kingdom: What Brexit means for the future of Britain". Salon. Retrieved 23 June 2016.
66. "Brexit: Nicola Sturgeon says second Scottish independence vote 'highly likely'". BBC News. 24 June 2016. Retrieved 24 June 2016.
67. "New Scottish independence bill published". BBC News. 20 October 2016. Retrieved 28 February 2017.
68. Macdonell, Hamish (27 March 2017). "May stands firm against second Scottish referendum". The Times.
69. Brooks, Libby (19 December 2019). "Sturgeon demands independence referendum powers be devolved". The Guardian. ISSN 0261-3077. Retrieved 22 December 2019.
70. Brooks, Libby (14 January 2020). "Boris Johnson refuses to grant Scotland powers to hold independence vote". The Guardian. Retrieved 6 March 2020.
71. Dougan, Michael; Hunt, Jo; McEwen, Nicola; McHarg, Aileen (2022). "Sleeping with an Elephant: Devolution and the United Kingdom Internal Market Act 2020". Law Quarterly Review. 138 (Oct). London: Sweet & Maxwell: 650–676. ISSN 0023-933X. SSRN 4018581. Retrieved 4 March 2022 – via University of Liverpool Repository. The Act has restrictive – and potentially damaging – consequences for the regulatory capacity of the devolved legislatures...This was not the first time since the Brexit referendum that the Convention had been set aside, but it was especially notable given that the primary purpose of the legislation was to constrain the capacity of the devolved institutions to use their regulatory autonomy...in practice, it constrains the ability of the devolved institutions to make effective regulatory choices for their territories in ways that do not apply to the choices made by the UK government and parliament for the English market.
72. Keating, Michael (2 February 2021). "Taking back control? Brexit and the territorial constitution of the United Kingdom". Journal of European Public Policy. 28 (4). Abingdon: Taylor & Francis: 6–7. doi:10.1080/13501763.2021.1876156. hdl:1814/70296. S2CID 234066376. The UK Internal Market Act gives ministers sweeping powers to enforce mutual recognition and non-discrimination across the four jurisdictions. Existing differences and some social and health matters are exempted but these are much less extensive than the exemptions permitted under the EU Internal Market provisions. Only after an amendment in the House of Lords, the Bill was amended to provide a weak and non-binding consent mechanism for amendments (equivalent to the Sewel Convention) to the list of exemptions. The result is that, while the devolved governments retain regulatory competences, these are undermined by the fact that goods and services originating in, or imported into, England can be marketed anywhere.
73. Kenny, Michael; McEwen, Nicola (1 March 2021). "Intergovernmental Relations and the Crisis of the Union". Political Insight. 12 (1). SAGE Publishing: 12–15. doi:10.1177/20419058211000996. That phase of joint working was significantly damaged by the UK Internal Market Act, pushed through by the Johnson government in December 2020...the Act diminishes the authority of the devolved institutions, and was vehemently opposed by them.
74. Wolffe, W James (7 April 2021). "Devolution and the Statute Book". Statute Law Review. Oxford: Oxford University Press. doi:10.1093/slr/hmab003. the Internal Market Bill—a Bill that contains provisions which, if enacted, would significantly constrain, both legally and as a matter of practicality, the exercise by the devolved legislatures of their legislative competence; provisions that would be significantly more restrictive of the powers of the Scottish Parliament than either EU law or Articles 4 and 6 of the Acts of the Union...The UK Parliament passed the European Union (Withdrawal Agreement) Act 2020 and the Internal Market Act 2020 notwithstanding that, in each case, all three of the devolved legislatures had withheld consent.
75. Wincott, Daniel; Murray, C. R. G.; Davies, Gregory (17 May 2021). "The Anglo-British imaginary and the rebuilding of the UK's territorial constitution after Brexit: unitary state or union state?". Territory, Politics, Governance. 10 (5). Abingdon/Brighton: Taylor & Francis; Regional Studies Association: 696–713. doi:10.1080/21622671.2021.1921613. Taken as a whole, the Internal Market Act imposes greater restrictions upon the competences of the devolved institutions than the provisions of the EU Single Market which it replaced, in spite of pledges to use common frameworks to address these issues. Lord Hope, responsible for many of the leading judgments relating to the first two decades of devolution, regarded the legislation's terms as deliberately confrontational: 'this Parliament can do what it likes, but a different approach is essential if the union is to hold together'.
76. Dougan, Michael (23 September 2020). Professor Michael Dougan: Evidence on the UK internal market bill. Finance and Constitution Committee (Report). Edinburgh: Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body. 21st Meeting 2020, Session 5. Retrieved 15 October 2020. By imposing widespread obligations of non-discrimination and, more important, mutual recognition, the bill seeks to restrict the way that devolved competences operate in practice.
77. Dougan, Michael; Hayward, Katy; Hunt, Jo; McEwen, Nicola; McHarg, Aileen; Wincott, Daniel (2020). UK and the Internal Market, Devolution and the Union. Centre on Constitutional Change (Report). University of Edinburgh, University of Aberdeen. pp. 2–3. Retrieved 16 October 2020.
78. Lydgate, Emily (23 September 2020). Dr Emily Lydgate, University of Sussex: Evidence on the UK internal market bill. Finance and Constitution Committee (Report). Edinburgh: Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body. 21st Meeting 2020, Session 5. Retrieved 15 October 2020. In that context, even though the new powers might not be used, I expect that the UK Government wants the legislation to be in place before those statutory instruments come into force, in case the common frameworks fall apart. What we are seeing is the UK Government responding to a threat by trying to centralise power or create a system that will function in case there is a problem...For example, England might authorise a new active substance for pesticides, or a new GMO, and would then be able to freely export those products to devolved nations, even if they had controls domestically. In so doing, England could competitively undercut producers and in effect undermine permitted divergence.
79. Dougan, Michael (2020). Briefing Paper. United Kingdom Internal Market Bill: Implications for Devolution (PDF) (Report). Liverpool: University of Liverpool. pp. 4–5, 9–10. Retrieved 15 October 2020.
80. ^{[71][72][73][74][75][76][77][78][79]}
81. "The battle is under way to save the UK union". Financial Times. London. 28 January 2021. Archived from the original on 10 December 2022. Retrieved 6 February 2021.
82. "Introduction". After Brexit: The UK Internal Market Act and devolution (Report). Edinburgh: Scottish Government. 8 March 2021. p. 4. Retrieved 15 March 2021.
83. Pooran, Neil (23 January 2021). "SNP lays out 'roadmap to independence'". The Independent. Retrieved 1 February 2021.
84. "Scottish nationalists vow independence vote after election win". Reuters. 8 May 2021. Retrieved 13 May 2021.
85. Coates, Sam (8 May 2021). "Conservatives and SNP agree on one thing - indyref2 won't happen any time soon". Sky News. Retrieved 9 May 2021.
86. Bol, David (27 January 2022). "SNP paying £700k-a -year civil servants team to update independence 'prospectus'". The Herald. Retrieved 28 January 2022.
87. "Poll: Scots don't back Nicola Sturgeon's push for 2023 independence vote". Politico. 20 September 2021. Retrieved 28 January 2022.
88. "Scottish independence: 19 October 2023 proposed as date for referendum". BBC News. 28 June 2022. Retrieved 28 June 2022.
89. "Beleaguered Boris Johnson rejects Nicola Sturgeon's indyref2 call". BBC News. 6 July 2022. Retrieved 6 July 2022.
90. "Supreme Court date for indyref2 case set for 11 October". BBC News. 21 July 2022. Retrieved 1 August 2022.
91. Holden, Michael (11 October 2022). "Scottish independence: could there be another referendum?". Reuters.
92. Decision by the Supreme Court of the United Kingdom, 23 November 2022. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-scotland-politics-63727562
93. Torrance, David (19 October 2022). Scottish Independence Referendum: Legal Issues (PDF). UK Parliament (Report). House of Commons Library. CBP9104. (PDF) from the original on 11 July 2022.
94. An introduction to devolution in the UK 10 September 2008 at the Wayback Machine House of Commons Library, Research Paper 03/84, 17 November 2003.
95. . Parliament.uk. 21 November 2007. Archived from the original on 17 July 2009. Retrieved 6 April 2009.
96. Burrows, Noreen (1999). "Unfinished Business: The Scotland Act 1998". Modern Law Review. 62 (2): 241–260. doi:10.1111/1468-2230.00203.
97. AXA General Insurance Ltd and others v HM Advocate and others [2011] 3 WLR 871 at p 895
98. MacCormick v Lord Advocate 1953 SC 396 at p 411
99. "Yes/Yes – Reverend Kenyon Wright". Scottish referendum. BBC. Retrieved 10 January 2012.
100. MacWhirter, Iain (26 February 2009). "That Bloody Woman". New Statesman. Retrieved 10 January 2012. The poll-tax row finally persuaded Labour's ultra-cautious shadow Scottish secretary, Donald Dewar, to join the cross-party Scottish Constitutional Convention in 1988 and sign its "Claim of Right" document, which called for a repatriation of Scottish sovereignty.
101. "Lords Hansard text for 27 Apr 1999 (190427-14)". publications.parliament.uk.
102. "The Union and the law". Law Society of Scotland. Retrieved 12 January 2023.
103. Smith, ‘The Union of 1707 as fundamental law’ (1957) Public Law 99.
104. Boyle, Alan; Crawford, James (2013). "Annex A Opinion: Referendum on the Independence of Scotland - International Law Aspects". Scotland Analysis: Devolution and the Implications of Scottish Independence.
105. Lang, A. (2021). How Parliament treats treaties (Research Briefing), 1 June 2021, House of Commons Library. Retrieved 12 January 2023.
106. Walters, Mark D. (1999). "Nationalism and the Pathology of Legal Systems: Considering the Quebec Secession Reference and Its Lessons for the United Kingdom". The Modern Law Review. 62 (3): 371–396. doi:10.1111/1468-2230.00212. JSTOR 1096974.
107. Naughton, Philippe; Sage, Adam (18 January 2007). "Scotland and the thorny road to independence". The Times. London. Retrieved 6 April 2009.
108. "Your Questions Answered". Scottish Government. 14 August 2008. Retrieved 12 January 2012.
109. "Q&A: Scottish independence referendum". BBC News. BBC. 10 January 2012. Retrieved 12 January 2012.
110. Hazell, Robert. Rites of secession, The Guardian, 29 July 2008.
111. "Agreement between the Scottish Government and the United Kingdom Government on the referendum on independence for Scotland". Scottish Government. Retrieved 8 September 2014.
112. "The Scotland Act 1998 (Modification of Schedule 5) Order 2013" (PDF). legislation.gov.uk. 2013.
113. "Independence campaigner loses appeal on Scottish Parliament's competence to independently legislate for indyref2". Scottish Legal News. 4 May 2021. Retrieved 9 May 2021.
114. "Independence referendum bill published by Scottish government". Irish Legal News. 23 March 2021.
115. "Draft Independence Referendum Bill". Scot.gov. Scottish Government. 22 March 2021.
116. "Scotland's Future". The Scottish Government. Crown Copyright. 26 November 2013. Retrieved 13 June 2014.
117. McHarg, Aileen (2016). "The constitutional case for independence". academic.oup.com. pp. 101–126. doi:10.1093/acprof:oso/9780198755517.003.0005. ISBN 978-0-19-875551-7. Retrieved 4 December 2022.
118. Cook, James (3 May 2021). "Scottish election 2021: Does Scotland's future lie in or out of the Union?". BBC News. Retrieved 27 May 2021. There is no doubt that the UK's 2016 vote to leave the European Union despite the opposition of 62% of voters in Scotland has breathed new life into the old constitutional debate"; "Many nationalists say Brexit is just one example of a "democratic deficit" — in the 11 general elections since the Conservative Margaret Thatcher became prime minister in 1979, Scotland has returned a majority of MPs from the party which formed or led a government on just three occasions.
119. Buchanan, Raymond (8 April 2013). "Margaret Thatcher: The woman who changed Scotland". BBC News. Retrieved 27 May 2021.
120. "Results". BBC News. BBC. Retrieved 30 November 2020.
121. Cook, James (3 May 2021). "Scottish election 2021: Does Scotland's future lie in or out of the Union?". BBC News. Retrieved 27 May 2021. There is no doubt that the UK's 2016 vote to leave the European Union despite the opposition of 62% of voters in Scotland has breathed new life into the old constitutional debate"; "Many nationalists say Brexit is just one example of a "democratic deficit" — in the 11 general elections since the Conservative Margaret Thatcher became prime minister in 1979, Scotland has returned a majority of MPs from the party which formed or led a government on just three occasions.
122. "'Scotland's future will be in Scotland's hands'". Herald Scotland. 26 May 2012. Retrieved 13 June 2014.
123. "UK government blocks Scotland's new gender recognition law". CNN. 16 January 2023.
124. "'Attack on democracy' as London overrules Scottish gender law". euronews. 16 January 2023. Retrieved 15 February 2023.
125. Keating, Michael (15 November 2001), "Plurinational Democracy", Oxford University PressOxford, pp. 160–172, doi:10.1093/0199240760.003.0006, ISBN 0199240760, retrieved 4 December 2022 {{citation}}: Missing or empty |title= (help)
126. "Ten things we learned about Scottishness". BBC News. 5 June 2018. Retrieved 16 May 2021.
127. Clarke, Harold D.; Whiteley, Paul (14 May 2021). "Scots less likely to identify as 'European' than others in the UK, survey reveals". The Conversation. Retrieved 4 December 2022.
128. "How Brexit shapes people's views on Scottish independence". BBC News. 26 January 2021. Retrieved 28 May 2021.
129. "Citizenship in Scotland's Future". Centre on Constitutional Change. Retrieved 15 February 2023.
130. Maddox, David (11 June 2013). "Scottish independence: UK passport loss indication". The Scotsman.
131. "Edinburgh 4th in Europe in new Financial Centres index – Scottish Financial Review". scottishfinancialreview.com. Retrieved 3 April 2024.
132. Jones, Peter (6 August 2019), "CHAPTER 12 A State of Uncertainty", Scottish Independence, Edinburgh University Press, pp. 219–235, doi:10.1515/9781474471190-015, ISBN 978-1-4744-7119-0, S2CID 246908893, retrieved 13 November 2022
133. Jones, Peter (6 August 2019), "CHAPTER 10 Scotland at the Starting Line", Scottish Independence, Edinburgh University Press, pp. 179–199, doi:10.1515/9781474471190-013, ISBN 978-1-4744-7119-0, S2CID 246924762, retrieved 13 November 2022
134. Huang, Hanwei; Sampson, Thomas; Schneider, Patrick (29 January 2021). "Disunited Kingdom? Brexit, trade and Scottish independence". {{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires |journal= (help)
135. "Scotland's biggest trading partner continues to be the UK". GOV.UK. Retrieved 16 May 2021.
136. "Independent Scotland would need border with England, Nicola Sturgeon concedes". The Independent. 25 April 2021. Retrieved 16 May 2021.
137. "Sturgeon admits border checks will be among post-independence 'issues'". The Independent. 14 June 2022. Retrieved 13 November 2022.
138. . Archived from the original on 5 January 2016. Retrieved 8 September 2014.
139. "First Minister: Scotland can be "intellectual powerhouse of green energy"". The Scottish Government. Crown copyright. 8 April 2014. Retrieved 13 June 2014.
140. "The David Hume Institute". David Hume Institute. Retrieved 2 June 2021.
141. Martin Kelly (5 May 2013). "Scottish oil revenues massively underestimated according to new report". Newsnet Scotland. Retrieved 13 June 2014.
142. "Who torpedoed independence?". The Economist. 19 September 2014. Retrieved 19 September 2014.
143. Maddox, David (21 June 2008). "Oil price fuels fresh row on Scots 'deficit'". The Scotsman. Edinburgh. Retrieved 25 June 2008.
144. "Government Expenditure and Revenue Scotland (GERS) 2019-2020". gov.scot. 26 August 2020.
145. Carrell, Severin (26 March 2013). "Scottish Tories reverse anti-devolution stance with call for greater powers". The Guardian. London. Retrieved 3 April 2013.
146. Gray, Louise (26 January 2007). "Study finds no benefit in fiscal autonomy as McCrone calls time on Barnett". The Scotsman. Edinburgh. Retrieved 5 January 2016.
147. "'Billions needed' to boost growth". BBC News. 14 March 2006. Retrieved 18 August 2007.
148. "Public/private sectors in economy need to be rebalanced". The Scotsman. Edinburgh. 15 March 2006. Retrieved 5 January 2016.
149. Tallack, Malachy (2 April 2007) Fair Isle: Independence thinking. London. New Statesman.
150. Riley-Smith, Ben (18 March 2014). "Shetland and Orkney should get vote on whether to leave Scotland". The Daily Telegraph. Archived from the original on 12 January 2022. Retrieved 26 March 2014.
151. Lawless, Jill (23 March 2014). "Scotland's Vikings go own way in independence vote". Associated Press News. Retrieved 9 May 2014.
152. "Scottish islanders seek votes for own independence". Reuters. 24 March 2014. Retrieved 26 March 2014.
153. . Shetland Times. 18 March 2014. Archived from the original on 26 March 2014. Retrieved 26 March 2014.
154. "Petition for independence in the Western Isles, Shetland and Orkney". The Herald. Herald & Times Group. 19 March 2014. Retrieved 26 March 2014.
155. Scottish Government (2022). A stronger economy with independence. Edinburgh, October 2022. Retrieved 12 November 2022.
156. "An immediate response to the Scottish Government's paper on independence and the Scottish economy". Institute for Fiscal Studies. Retrieved 12 November 2022.
157. Giles, Chris; Dickie, Mure (2 April 2021). "Independent Scotland would face a large hole in its public finances". Financial Times. London and Edinburgh. Archived from the original on 10 December 2022. Retrieved 23 May 2021.
158. Phillips, David (29 April 2021). "Updated projections of Scotland's fiscal position - and their implications". www.ifs.org.uk. Retrieved 23 May 2021.
159. "What might the public finances of an independent Scotland look like?". Economics Observatory. Retrieved 12 November 2022.
160. Scotland - the new case for optimism (PDF) (Report). Sustainable Growth Commission (Scotland). May 2018.
161. "Currency and fiscal policy". www.gov.scot. Retrieved 3 April 2024.
162. Green, Chris (7 October 2022). "Plan for 'Scottish pound' to be announced next week, Nicola Sturgeon reveals". inews.co.uk. Retrieved 8 October 2022.
163. . Better Together. Archived from the original on 24 October 2013. Retrieved 18 October 2013.
164. . Better Together. Archived from the original on 24 October 2013. Retrieved 18 October 2013.
165. "Weak Scottish currency will cause capital flight after independence says HSBC boss". Scotland News.Net. 23 August 2014. Retrieved 23 August 2014.
166. "SNP's independence currency plan branded 'a hugely risky experiment'". HeraldScotland. 8 February 2021. Retrieved 16 May 2021.
167. Murden, Terry; Editor (8 October 2022). "Sturgeon confirms plan for Scottish pound – Daily Business". Daily Business. Retrieved 8 October 2022. {{cite web}}: |last2= has generic name (help)
168. Great Britain: Parliament: House of Commons: Defence Committee (7 March 2007). The future of the UK's strategic nuclear deterrent: the White Paper, ninth report of session 2006-07, Vol. 2: Oral and written evidence. The Stationery Office. pp. 167–. ISBN 978-0-215-03280-5.
169. "The Modern SNP: From Protest to Power", edited by Gerry Hassan, Edinburgh University Press: Edinburgh, p. 29 and p. 156
170. "Scots CND backs Yes campaign". Herald Scotland. Herald & Times Group. 19 November 2012. Retrieved 13 June 2014.
171. "Voters in favour of an independent Scotland keeping Trident - poll". HeraldScotland. 26 May 2022. Retrieved 4 November 2022.
172. Allison, George (10 May 2022). "Majority of Scots back keeping Trident according to poll". Retrieved 4 November 2022.
173. "Scottish independence and the implications for British defence | Lowy Institute". www.lowyinstitute.org. Retrieved 4 November 2022.
174. "Nicola Sturgeon warned: Trident is important to Nato". www.scotsman.com. 1 December 2019. Retrieved 4 November 2022.
175. Allison, George (26 May 2022). "Second poll this month claims most Scots support Trident". Retrieved 4 November 2022.
176. Allison, George (22 May 2022). "An independent Scotland, NATO & nukes – would it work?". Retrieved 4 November 2022.
177. Economic Affairs Committee Contents. "Chapter 6: Scottish independence and defence: the economic impact - Economic Implications for the United Kingdom of Scottish Independence". parliament.uk. Retrieved 4 November 2022.
178. HM Government (October 2013). Scotland analysis: Defence (PDF) (Report).
179. "Scottish independence: Will there be a second referendum?". BBC News. 22 March 2021.
180. "Scottish Independence – Reality or Illusion?". Global Politician. 5 January 2007. Retrieved 20 June 2007.
181. "The Union Jocks". Scotland on Sunday. 17 February 2008. Retrieved 25 June 2008.
182. Eardley, Nick (7 August 2014). "Scottish independence: The Scots in England who want Scotland to go it alone". BBC News. Retrieved 8 September 2014.
183. Gray, Louise (27 July 2007). "Doubts raised over future of shipyards under independence". The Scotsman. Edinburgh. Retrieved 20 August 2007.
184. "Scots and English flourish in the Union". The Daily Telegraph. London. 11 April 2007. Archived from the original on 12 January 2022. Retrieved 20 June 2007.
185. "Independence and regional and international cooperation". www.gov.scot. Retrieved 3 April 2024.
186. "Independence and regional and international cooperation". www.gov.scot. Retrieved 3 April 2024.
187. "As others see us: The striking similarities between Brexit and Scottish independence debates". Centre on Constitutional Change. Retrieved 28 May 2021.
188. "House of Lords - Scottish independence: constitutional implications of the referendum - Constitution Committee". publications.parliament.uk. Retrieved 23 May 2021. Moreover, unless and until a "yes" vote is delivered, neither the UK nor the Scottish government have any mandate to negotiate independence.
189. "10 reasons against Scottish independence". www.scotsman.com. 3 March 2017. Retrieved 16 May 2021.
190. "Scottish elections: the problems with Scexit". The Parliament Magazine. 12 May 2021. Retrieved 28 May 2021.
191. "Nationalists must face the economic reality that Scottish independence would be much worse than Brexit – Brian Wilson". www.scotsman.com. 6 February 2021. Retrieved 28 May 2021.
192. SPIEGEL, Jörg Schindler, DER (4 May 2021). "A Fateful Election in Scotland: After Brexit Could Come Scexit". Der Spiegel. Retrieved 28 May 2021.{{cite news}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
193. Ferry, John (23 April 2021). "Sturgeon has no credible answers on economics of Scexit | The Spectator". www.spectator.co.uk. Retrieved 28 May 2021.
194. "SCEXIT (noun) definition and synonyms | Macmillan Dictionary". www.macmillandictionary.com. Retrieved 28 May 2021.
195. Dickie, Mure (27 June 2017). "Sturgeon postpones plans for second Scottish independence referendum". Financial Times. Archived from the original on 10 December 2022. Retrieved 24 September 2017.
196. Martin, Lorna (10 October 2004). "Holyrood survives birth pains". The Guardian. London. Retrieved 21 June 2007.
197. Carrell, Severin (22 June 2012). "The claymore count: the groups fighting for and against Scottish independence". The Guardian. Retrieved 29 March 2015.
198. "Introduction: Aims and Questions". Scottish Independence Convention. Retrieved 4 July 2007.
199. "About Us". Retrieved 13 February 2013.
200. "Scottish independence: Glasgow University students plan ballot". BBC News. 18 January 2013. Retrieved 13 February 2013.
201. "Join the Debate: Glasgow Launches Independence Referendum". 18 January 2013. Retrieved 13 February 2013.
202. "Radicals threaten Salmond and Scottish independence campaign". The Independent. London. 24 November 2012. Retrieved 13 February 2013.
203. "The National launches in Scotland 'to fly flag for independence'". The Guardian. 24 November 2014. Retrieved 30 March 2015.
204. "Scottish newspapers divide over referendum vote". HoldTheFrontPage.co.uk. 16 September 2014.
205. Rioux, X. Hubert (2020). "Rival economic nationalisms: Brexit and the Scottish independence movement compared". Canadian Foreign Policy Journal. 26: 8–24. doi:10.1080/11926422.2019.1617759. S2CID 191854170.
206. Mark Aitken (12 May 2013). "UKIP leader Nigel Farage insists he will play a key role in the campaign against Scottish independence". Daily Record. Retrieved 18 October 2013.
207. Brown, Hannah (5 May 2021). "Scottish Election 2021: Who are the 20 smaller parties running for Holyrood including Scottish Family Party, Abolish the Scottish Parliament Party and Alba?". The Scotsman. Retrieved 9 May 2021.
208. . British National Party. 27 July 2014. Archived from the original on 26 August 2014. Retrieved 26 August 2014.
209. Britain First official website. Statement of Principles 9 October 2014 at the Wayback Machine. "Britain First is a movement of British Unionism. We support the continued unity of the United Kingdom whilst recognising the individual identity and culture of the peoples of England, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland. We abhor and oppose all trends that threaten the integrity of the Union". Retrieved 8 July 2014.
210. Cramb, Auslan (2 March 2015). "New pro-Union campaign to identify seats where tactical voting could defeat SNP". The Telegraph. Archived from the original on 12 January 2022.
211. Johnson, Simon (6 March 2015). "Unionists can hold back the SNP 'if they act together'". The Telegraph. Archived from the original on 12 January 2022.
212. Gilligan, Andrew (5 March 2015). "Anti-SNP tactical voting: can it hold back the nationalist tide?". The Telegraph. Archived from the original on 12 January 2022.
213. "Scotland in Union in crisis after donor details are leaked". The National. 3 January 2018.
214. "Doubts over Unionist campaign's future after funding admission". HeraldScotland. 20 February 2018.
215. Gordon, Tom (7 December 2017). "Unionist campaign splits over Brexit and second referendum". The Herald. Retrieved 11 January 2018.
216. "Scottish independence: Barack Obama backs 'strong and united' UK". BBC News. 5 June 2014. Retrieved 23 May 2021.
217. Milne, Richard (3 June 2014). "Bildt warns of British 'Balkanisation'". Financial Times. Archived from the original on 10 December 2022. Retrieved 23 May 2021.
218. "Scottish independence: Orange Lodge registers to campaign for a 'No' vote". BBC News. 25 June 2014. Retrieved 8 September 2014.
219. . Archived from the original on 31 August 2014. Retrieved 8 September 2014.
220. "Orange Order anti-independence march a 'show of pro-union strength'". The Guardian. 13 September 2014.
221. "Orange Order march through Edinburgh to show loyalty to UK". Financial Times. 13 September 2014.
222. Cennydd Jones, Glyndwr (11 October 2019). "A new model for the UK?". Institute of Welsh Affairs. Retrieved 8 April 2022.
223. Hennessy, Patrick; Kite, Melissa (26 November 2006). "Britain wants UK break up, poll shows". The Daily Telegraph. London. Archived from the original on 12 January 2022.
224. Hennessy, Patrick (15 January 2012). "Britain divided over Scottish Independence". The Daily Telegraph. London. Archived from the original on 12 January 2022.
225. Allardyce, Jason (15 March 2009). "Voters ditch SNP over referendum". The Times. London. Retrieved 16 March 2009.
226. . Archived from the original on 21 December 2010. Retrieved 8 September 2014.
227. (PDF). Archived from the original (PDF) on 25 April 2012. Retrieved 8 September 2014.
228. . Herald Scotland. Archived from the original on 22 May 2022. Retrieved 8 September 2014.
229. Dinwoodie, Robbie (5 September 2011). . The Herald. Glasgow. Archived from the original on 22 May 2022. Retrieved 5 September 2011.
230. "Q&A: Scottish independence row". BBC News. BBC. 17 January 2012. Retrieved 19 January 2012.
231. Curtice, John (24 April 2014). "Scottish independence: Depending on the pollster, it looks like a photo finish". The Independent. Retrieved 25 April 2014.
232. "New poll: Scotland would back indy if fresh vote was held now". The Herald. 1 November 2014. Retrieved 13 March 2015.
233. Curtice, John (18 September 2015). "What are the latest polls saying about Scottish independence?". BBC News. BBC. Retrieved 19 September 2015.
234. Curtice, John. "How would you vote in a Scottish independence referendum if held now? (asked after the EU referendum)". WhatScotlandThinks. Scotcen. Retrieved 9 October 2017.
235. "Nicola Sturgeon points to 'growing urgency' for Scottish independence". BBC News. 5 August 2019. Retrieved 6 August 2019.
236. Carrell, Severin (4 February 2020). "Scottish independence surveys 'show Brexit has put union at risk'". The Guardian. Retrieved 5 February 2020.
237. Paterson, Kirsteen (14 October 2020). "Record public support for Scottish independence, new poll shows". The National. Retrieved 14 October 2020.
238. Langfitt, Frank (15 December 2020). "Support For Scottish Independence Is Growing, Partly Due To U.K.'s COVID-19 Response". NPR. Retrieved 30 December 2020.
239. Curtice, John (26 January 2021). "How Brexit shapes people's views on Scottish independence". BBC News. Retrieved 26 January 2021.
240. "Scottish independence: More would vote for remaining in UK if referendum were held tomorrow, poll suggests". Sky News. Retrieved 7 March 2021.
241. For a full list of polls to August 2022, see Opinion polling on Scottish independence#Remain/Leave question.
242. "GB support for Scottish independence". yougov.co.uk. Retrieved 5 August 2022.
243. "UK Voters Back Scottish Independence Referendum". Omnisis for the Byline Times. Retrieved 2 December 2022.

Sources

• Marr, Andrew (2013). The Battle for Scotland. Penguin Books. ISBN 978-0-241-96793-5.

Further reading

• Hassan, Gerry (2011). Radical Scotland: Arguments for Self-Determination. Luath Press.
• Keating, Michael (2009). The Independence of Scotland: Self-Government and the Shifting Politics of Union. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
• Keating, Michael (2013). Nationalism, unionism and secession in Scotland. Routledge. pp. 127–144. {{cite book}}: |work= ignored (help)
• Murkens, Jo Eric (2002). Scottish Independence: A Practical Guide. Edinburgh University Press. ISBN 978-0-7486-1699-2.
• Pittock, Murray (2008). The Road to Independence?: Scotland Since the Sixties. Reaktion Books.

External links

• Scottish independence at Curlie