Neutral Moresnet

"Moresnet" redirects here. For other uses, see Moresnet (disambiguation).

Neutral Moresnet (French pronunciation: [mɔʁɛsnɛt],^[6] [mɔʁɛsnɛ],^[7] German pronunciation: [ˈmɔʁəsnɛt], [ˌmɔʁəsˈnɛt]) was a small Belgian–Prussian condominium in western Europe that existed from 1816 to 1921 and was administered jointly by the United Kingdom of the Netherlands (Belgium after its independence in 1830) and the Kingdom of Prussia. It was 1.5 kilometres (1 mi) wide and five kilometres (3 mi) long, with an area of 360 hectares (900 acres). After 1830, the territory's northernmost border point at Vaalserberg connected it to a quadripoint shared additionally with the Dutch Province of Limburg, the Prussian Rhine Province, and the Belgian Liège Province.^[8] Its former location is represented presently by the Three-Country Point, the meeting place of the borders of Belgium, Germany, and the Netherlands.

Neutral Moresnet^[1] Neutraal Moresnet (Dutch) Moresnet Neutre (French) Neutral-Moresnet (German) Neutraal Moresent (Limburgish) Neŭtrala Moresnet (Esperanto)
1816–1921
Flag Coat of arms (1908)
Anthem: The Amikejo-March^[2]^[3] (Marche Amikejo^[4])
Dutch Province of Limburg (1)   Belgian Liège Province (2)   Neutral Moresnet (3)   Prussian Rhine Province (4)
Status	Neutral zone
Capital	Kelmis
Languages	Dutch French German Low Dietsch dialect of Limburgish^[5] Esperanto (from 1908)
Demonym(s)	Moresnetic
Government	Condominium sui iuris
Mayor
• 1817–1859 (first)	Arnold de Lasaulx
• 1918–1921 (last)	Pierre Grignard
Historical era	Late modern
• Aachen Agreement	26 June 1816
• Prussian annexation	27 June 1915
• Treaty of Versailles	28 June 1919
• Belgian annexation	10 January 1921
Area
• Total	3.5 km^2 (1.4 sq mi)
Population
• 1900	3,000
• 1914	3,500
Currency	French franc
Preceded by Succeeded by Kingdom of France Belgium
Today part of	Belgium

During the First World War, Neutral Moresnet was annexed by Germany, although the allies did not recognise the annexation. The armistice between France and Germany in November 1918 forced Germany to withdraw from Belgium and Neutral Moresnet. A year later, the Treaty of Versailles awarded Neutral Moresnet to Belgium, effective 10 January 1921, when the territory was annexed by Belgium to become the municipality of Kelmis.

During World War II, Kelmis and the area surrounding was again annexed by Germany and had its name reverted to Moresnet, but the territory was returned to Belgium during 1944.

History

Origins

After the demise of Napoleon's Empire, the Congress of Vienna of 1814–15 redrew the European map, intending to create a balance of power in Europe. One of the borders to be delineated was the one between the newly created United Kingdom of the Netherlands and the Kingdom of Prussia. Both parties could agree on the larger part of the territory, as borders mostly followed older lines, but the district of Moresnet proved problematic, mainly because of a valuable zinc spar mine named Altenberg (German) or Vieille Montagne (French) located there. The governments of both the Netherlands and Prussia desired to appropriate this resource, which was needed for the production of zinc and brass – at that time, Bristol in the United Kingdom was the only other place where zinc ore was processed.^[9]

In December 1815, Dutch and Prussian representatives convened in nearby Aachen, and on 26 June 1816 a compromise was obtained, dividing the district of Moresnet into three parts. The Dutch absorbed the village of Moresnet itself into Liège Province, while the Prussian village Moresnet (renamed Neu-Moresnet after World War I) became part of the Prussian Rhine Province and the mine and village adjacent became a neutral territory pending a future agreement. The two powers, whose armies were prohibited from occupying the area, established a joint administration.^{[citation needed]}

When Belgium gained its independence from the Netherlands in 1830, the Belgians assumed control of the Dutch role in Neutral Moresnet (though the Dutch never formally ceded their claim).^{[citation needed]}

Borders

Formal installation of border demarcation markers for the territory occurred on 23 September 1818. The territory of Neutral Moresnet had a somewhat triangular shape with the base being the main road from Aachen to Liège. The village and mine lay just to the north of this road. To east and west, two straight lines converged on the Vaalserberg.

The roads from Germany and Belgium to the Three‑Country Point are named Dreiländerweg (lit. 'Three Countries Way') and Route des Trois Bornes ('Three Border Stones Road') respectively; the road from the Netherlands is called Viergrenzenweg ('Four Borders Way').^[10]

Flag

 

Emblem of the Vieille Montagne company may have inspired the Moresnet flag.

From 1883, Neutral Moresnet used a tricolour with horizontal bars in black, white and blue as its territorial flag. The origin is unknown and has been explained in two different ways:^[11]

• It is argued by some that the colours were taken from the two conflicting powers' flags, with black and white representing Prussia and white and blue the Netherlands.
• According to Flags of the World, "it seems more likely that the colours have been taken from the emblem of the Vieille Montagne", a mining company.^[12]

Status

 

Neutral Moresnet on a postcard c. 1900

The territory was governed by two royal commissioners, one from each neighbour. Eventually, these commissioners were commonly civil servants from the Belgian Verviers and the Prussian Eupen. The municipal administration was directed by a mayor appointed by the commissioners.

The Napoleonic civil and penal codes, introduced during French rule, remained in force throughout the existence of Neutral Moresnet. However, since no law court existed in the neutral territory, Belgian and Prussian judges had to come in and decide cases based on the Napoleonic laws. Since there was no administrative court either, the judge's decision could not be appealed.

In 1859, Neutral Moresnet was granted a greater measure of self-administration by the installation of a municipal council of ten members. The council, as well as a welfare committee and a school committee, were appointed by the mayor and served an advisory function only. The people had no voting rights.^[13]

Life in Neutral Moresnet was dominated by the Vieille Montagne mining company, which not only was the major employer but also operated residences, shops, a hospital and a bank. The mine attracted many workers from the neighboring countries, increasing the population from 256 in 1815 to 2,275 in 1858 and 4,668 in 1914. Most services, such as the mail, were shared between Belgium and Prussia (in a fashion similar to Andorra). There were five schools in the territory, and Prussian subjects could attend the schools in Prussian Moresnet.

Living in the territory had several benefits. Among these were the low taxes (the national budget being fixed at 2,735 Belgian francs throughout most of its history), the absence of import tariffs from both neighbouring countries, and low prices compared to just across the border. A downside to their special status was the fact that people from Neutral Moresnet were considered to be stateless and were not allowed a military of their own.

Many immigrants settled in Moresnet so they would be exempt from military service, but in 1854 Belgium began to conscript its citizens who had relocated to Moresnet, and Prussia did likewise in 1874. From then on, the exemption applied only to descendants of the original inhabitants.^[14]

Currency

Neutral Moresnet did not have its own currency. The French franc was legal tender. The currencies of Prussia (and then Germany, after 1871), Belgium and the Netherlands were also in circulation. In 1848 local currency began circulating, though these coins were not considered the official medium.^[15]

Uncertain future

 

The Three-Country Point on the Vaalserberg presently. Until 1915 this was also the location of Neutral Moresnet's apex.

When the mine was exhausted in 1885, the continued survival of Neutral Moresnet was in doubt. Perhaps in response, the next year Dr. Wilhelm Molly (1838–1919), the mine's chief medical doctor and an avid philatelist, tried to organise a local postal service with its own stamps. This enterprise was quickly thwarted by Belgian intervention.^[16]

About 1900, Germany began a more aggressive policy concerning the territory and was accused of sabotage and obstructing the administrative process in order to force the issue.

A casino was established in August 1903 after the Belgians closed all such resorts in Belgium. The Moresnet casino operated with strict limitations, permitting no local resident to gamble, and no more than 20 people to gather at a time. The venture was abandoned, however, when Kaiser Wilhelm II threatened to partition the territory or cede it to Belgium in order to end the gambling. Around this same time, Moresnet boasted three distilleries for the manufacture of gin.^[17]

During 1908, Dr. Molly proposed making Neutral Moresnet the world's first Esperanto‑speaking state, named Amikejo ("friendship-place"). The proposed national anthem was an Esperanto march of the same name,^[16] set to the tune of "O Tannenbaum".^[18] A number of residents learned Esperanto and a rally was held in Kelmis to endorse the idea of Amikejo on 13 August 1908,^[16] and a coat of arms was publicized.^[18] The World Congress of Esperanto, meeting in Dresden, even declared Neutral Moresnet the world capital of the Esperanto community.^[16]

First World War

 

Memorial to the sons of Neutral Moresnet fallen in both armies during World War I, in the right portal of the Our-Lady-of-Assumption church. At bottom, in German: "United in death, R.I.P."

The First World War resulted in the end of neutrality. On 4 August 1914, Germany invaded Belgium, initially leaving Neutral Moresnet as "an oasis in a desert of destruction".^[19] A total of 147 Neutral Moresnet citizens were killed, though it is unclear whether they were killed inside the territory or in fighting outside its borders.^{[citation needed]} On 27 June 1915, Neutral Moresnet was annexed by the Kingdom of Prussia, although the annexation never received international recognition.^{[citation needed]}

In 1918, the armistice between France and Germany, signed on 11 November at Compiègne, forced Germany to withdraw from Belgium and also from Moresnet. It also resulted in the ousting of Mayor Wilhelm Kyll, a German national who had been appointed after the German invasion.

On 28 June 1919, the Treaty of Versailles settled the dispute that had created the neutral territory a century earlier by awarding Neutral Moresnet, along with Prussian Moresnet and the German cantons of Eupen and Malmedy, to Belgium.^[20] The treaty became effective 10 January 1920, ending the territory's existence and converting it into a municipality in Belgium.

To distinguish it from the already existing town of Moresnet (in the neighboring municipality of Plombières), Neutral Moresnet was renamed Kelmis (in French: La Calamine) – after kelme, the local dialect word for zinc spar.

Despite the annexation, Neutral Moresnet Mayor Pierre Grignard effectively stayed in office and became the first mayor of Kelmis. The ten members of Neutral Moresnet's council were confirmed for the Kelmis municipal council after its Prussian members renounced their nationality. They remained in office until the election of a new municipal council on 7 February 1923.^[21][22]

Post-annexation history

 

Local museum dedicated to the former territory

After 1920, Moresnet shared the history of Eupen-Malmedy.^[23] Germany briefly re‑annexed the area during World War II, but it returned to Belgium in 1944. Since 1973, Kelmis has formed a part of the German‑speaking community of Belgium. During 1977, Kelmis absorbed the neighbouring communes of Neu‑Moresnet and Hergenrath.^[24]

A small museum in Kelmis, the Museum Vieille Montagne, includes exhibits on Neutral Moresnet. Of the 60 border markers for the territory, more than 50 are still standing.^[25]

As a company, Vieille Montagne survived Neutral Moresnet. It continues to exist as VMZINC, a part of Union Minière, the latter renamed in 2001 as Umicore, a global materials company.^[9]

On 26 October 2016, Catharina Meessen became the last surviving citizen of the former territory after the death of Alwine Hackens-Paffen.^[26] In early 2020, Meessen died at the age of 105.^[27]

List of executive officers

List of Royal Commissioners

Name	Term	Occupation etc
Wilhelm Hardt	6 August 1817 – 1819	Mining consultant
Werner Jacob	8 December 1817 – 2 December 1823	Lawyer
Lambert Ernst	8 June 1835 – 1840	Deputy Prosecutor, Court of Appeal in Liège
Joseph Brandès	2 December 1823 – 1830	School inspector
Mathieu Crémer	1 February 1840 – 1889	Judge from Verviers
Johann Martin Daniel Mayer	22 April 1819 – March 1836	Mining consultant
Heinrich Martins	9 July 1836 – 9 November 1853 or 1854	Mining consultant
Peter Benedict Joseph Amand von Harenne	11 August 1852 or 1854 – 7 January 1866	District commissioner of Eupen
Freiherr von der Heydt	12 December 1866 – 1868	Former district commissioner of Eupen
Edward Gülcher	1868–1871	District commissioner of Eupen
Alfred Theodor Sternickel	18 June 1871 – April 1893	District commissioner of Eupen
Fernand Jacques Bleyfuesz	30 November 1889 – 27 March 1915	District commissioner of Verviers
Alfred Jakob Bernhard Theodor Gülcher	18 April 1893 – 1 January 1909	District commissioner of Eupen
Walter Karl Maria The Losen	13 January 1909 – 1 November 1918	District commissioner of Eupen
Dr. Bayer (acting)	27 March – 27 June 1915	Civil commissioner of Verviers
Fernand Jacques Bleyfuesz	November 1918 – 10 January 1920	District commissioner of Verviers

List of mayors

• Arnold Timothée de Lasaulx, 1817 – 2 February 1859
• Adolf Hubert van Scherpenzeel-Thim, 2 February 1859 – 30 May 1859
• Joseph Kohl, 1 July 1859 – 7 February 1882
• Oskar Anton Bilharz, 7 February 1882 – 20 June 1885
• Jérôme Mohsen, 20 June 1885 – 20 June 1885
• Hubert Schmetz, 20 June 1885 – 15 March 1915
• Wilhelm Kyll, 29 March 1915 – 7 December 1918
• Pierre Grignard, 7 December 1918 – 10 January 1920

See also

• Interhelpo
• Couto Misto

References

1. Neutral-Moresnet Archive
2. Avez-vous déjà entendu parler de Moresnet ?
3. Het absurde verhaal van Neutraal Moresnet
4. le lieu de l'amitié
5. Van Reybrouck, David (2018). Zink. De Bezige Bij. ISBN 9789403105604. Taal? Geen. Duits, Frans en Kelmeser Platt dooreen, iets tussen Plattdütsch en Limburgs in. [Language? None. A mix of German, French and Kelmeser Platt, which is somewhere between Low German and Limburgish]
6. "Plombières : visite du Viaduc de Moresnet par les écoles.x". Télé Vesdre. 16 September 2016. Retrieved 18 June 2022.
7. Max Mangold (2005). Das Aussprachewörterbuch. Mannheim/Zürich: Dudenverlag, p. 564.
8. Martin, Lawrence; Reed, John (2006). The Treaties of Peace, 1919–1923. Vol. 1. Lawbook Exchange. p. 46. ISBN 978-1-58477-708-3. LCCN 2006005097. Neutral Moresnet, added to this map as an independent country, is a mile [1.6 km] wide and 3 miles [4.8 km] long. It is so small that it has never been shown on maps of Europe as a whole. It has an area of 900 acres [360 ha] and about 3500 people . . .
9. "VMZINC : un leadership enraciné dans l'histoire". Qui sommes nous? (in French). VMZINC. Retrieved 24 October 2008.
10. (PDF) (in French). GrenzRouten. 2009. pp. 45–46, 49. Archived from the original (PDF) on 15 March 2016. Retrieved 16 March 2016.
11. Neutral-Moresnet: History 12 August 2012 at the Wayback Machine
12. Sache, Ivan; Sensen, Mark (1 May 2005). "The Neutral Territory of Moresnet (1816–1918)". Flags of the World. OCLC 39626054. from the original on 28 September 2015.
13. Robert Shackleton, Unvisited Places of Old Europe, 1914, p. 161.
14. Charles Hoch, The Neutral Territory of Moresnet, trans. William Warren Tucker, 1882, p. 13.
15. Damen, Cees. . Neutral Moresnet. Archived from the original on 4 November 2008. Retrieved 24 October 2008.
16. Hoffmann, Eduard; Nendza, Jürgen (19 September 2003). "Galmei und Esperanto, der fast vergessene europäische Kleinstaat Neutral‑Moresnet" (PDF) (in German). Südwestrundfunk. (PDF) from the original on 15 March 2016. Retrieved 15 March 2016.
17. "Awaiting a Crisis in Belgium" (PDF). The New York Times. 13 September 1903. ISSN 0362-4331. (PDF) from the original on 15 March 2016.
18. Middleton, Nick (2015). An Atlas of Countries That Don't Exist: A Compendium of Fifty Unrecognized and Largely Unnoticed States. London: Macmillan. p. 38. ISBN 978-1-4472-9527-3.
19. Musgrave, George Clarke (1918). "The Belgian Prelude". Under Four Flags for France. New York: D. Appleton & Company. p. 8. hdl:2027/uc2.ark:/13960/t8qb9xr4b. LCCN 18003816. OCLC 1157994. OL 7209571M. As a proof of German preparation, war had come automatically at 7 a.m., 3 August [1914]. At 23  o'clock (Belgian time) the outposts on the main roads holding Pepinster, Battice, Herve and smaller hamlets, were heavily engaged and finally forced back to the fortified lines of [Liège]. The pretty towns defended near the frontier were soon flaming ruins, the quaint neutral territory of Moresnet rising as an oasis in a desert of destruction.  
20. "Peace Treaty of Versailles, Articles 31 – 117, Political Clauses for Europe and Annexes". net.lib.byu.edu.
21. "Kelmis (Municipality, Province of Liège, Belgium)". www.crwflags.com.
22. . www.kelmis.be. Archived from the original on 20 March 2017. Retrieved 20 March 2017.
23. Wenselaers, Selm (2008). De laatste Belgen, een geschiedenis van de oostkantons (The last Belgians, a history of the eastern districts). Meulenhoff/Manteau. ISBN 978-90-8542-149-8.
24. Gemeinde Kelmis (in German)
25. Berns, Eef (2002). "In search of the bordermarkers of Moresnet". Retrieved 1 September 2008.
26. "Dwergstaatje Neutraal Moresnet heeft nog slechts één oud-bewoner". Trouw. 5 November 2016. Retrieved 20 March 2017.
27. "Catharina Meessen (1914–2020), de laatste Moresnetter, is overleden. De ministaat is nu echt historie". Trouw. 7 February 2020. Retrieved 8 February 2020.

Further reading

• Earle, Peter C. (4 August 2012). "Anarchy in the Aachen". Mises Institute. Retrieved 7 September 2017.
• Earle, Peter C. (2014). A Century of Anarchy: Neutral Moresnet through the Revisionist Lens. Intangible Goods. ISBN 978-0-9913059-5-7.
• Press, Steven Michael (29 June 2010). To Govern, or Not to Govern: Prussia, Neutral Moresnet. Rochester, NY: Social Science Research Network. SSRN 2096313.

External links

 

Wikimedia Commons has media related to Neutral Moresnet.

 

Wikisource has the text of the 1911 Encyclopædia Britannica article "Moresnet".

• "Moresnet, Belgium". from the original on 15 March 2016. Pictures of the old mines
• Official website Kelmis (in German)
• Göhltalmuseum 6 January 2017 at the Wayback Machine, a local museum that shows the history of Neutral Moresnet and its zinc mining (in German)
• Anarchy in the Aachen (Mises.org)
• Het vergeten land van Moresnet, documentary, 1990 (48', languages spoken: Dutch, German, French, Esperanto)
• Elbruz interactive map of Neutral Moresnet Elbruz interactive map of Neutral Moresnet

50°43′49″N 6°00′48″E / 50.73028°N 6.01333°E / 50.73028; 6.01333