Modi'in (ancient city)

Modi’in (Hebrew: מוֹדִיעִין, also transliterated as Modein), also Modi’im (Hebrew: מוֹדִיעִים), and later, Moditha (Greek: Μωδιθα), was an ancient Jewish city located in Judea, near the modern city of Modi'in, Israel. First mentioned in the Books of Maccabees,^[1] it was the hometown of the priestly Hasmonean family, who assumed leadership over Judea following the victorious Maccabean uprising.^[2]

A Jewish burial cave unearthed at Khirbet Midiyeh, near Mevo Modi'im, one of several proposed sites for the ancient city of Modi'in

Modi’in was known in ancient times for housing the mausoleum of the Hasmonean family, commonly referred to as the Tomb of the Maccabees. This monumental structure, erected in the 2nd century BC by Simon Thassi, is described in both the Book of Maccabees and the writings of Josephus. During the Byzantine period, Eusebius noted its continued existence. However, its remains were lost over time.^[1]

The precise geographical location of Modi’in remains a subject of scholarly dispute, with various proposed sites including Tell er-Ras near al-Midya, Givat HaTitora, Umm el-Umdan, and Khirbet Midya, all located in the vicinity of the modern city of Modi'in-Maccabim-Re'ut, which takes its name from the ancient city.^[1] The remnants of the Hasmonean mausoleum, once linked to several sites now attributed to the Byzantine era, remain undiscovered, and its precise location still unknown.^[1][3][4]

Ancient sources

Books of Maccabees (2nd century BC)

 

Mattathias refuses to sacrifice to the idols, Gustave Popelin (1882)

The first reference to Modi'in is found in the text of 1 Maccabees, a book likely written by a court historian during the reign of the Hasmonean ruler John Hyrcanus (134–104 BC). It records the relocation of Mattathias the Hasmonean, along with his family, from Jerusalem to Modi'in around ~168–167 BC:^[1]

During that time, Mattathias, son of John son of Simeon, a priest of the clan of Joarib, left Jerusalem and settled at Modein.

— 1 Maccabees 2:1^[5]

Later in the book's narrative detail the construction by Simon, Matthatias's son, of an elaborate monument built atop an existing family burial site in Modi'in:^[1]

Over the tomb of his father and his brothers Simon constructed a monument impressive for its height, built of hewn stone on both its front and rear sides. He set up seven pyramids, one in front of the other, for his father, his mother, and his four brothers. For the pyramids he contrived an elaborate setting: he surrounded them with massive pillars on which he places full suits of armor as a perpetual memorial; besides the full suits of armor, there were carved ships, intended to be seen by all who sailed the sea. This tomb, which he erected in Modein, still exists today.

— 1 Maccabees 13:27-30^[6]

According to 1 Maccabees, Simon designated the monument for the interment of his father, mother and four brothers. The monument's description mentioned elaborate architectural features, including pyramids (or nefashot, signifying sepulchral monuments typically situated near or above underground tombs), sculptured armaments or panoplies representing military weaponry, and maritime representations, all adhering to Hellenistic aesthetic norms. The book states that the monument still stood in its day.^[1]

A later passage describes Hasmonean forces late in Simon's reign gathering in Modi'in before descending to the coastal plain for a battle against a Seleucid army:^[1]

He raised from the land a force of twenty thousand picked warriors and cavalrymen, and they marched out against Kendebaios. They spent the night at Modein. On rising in the morning, they marched out into the plain. There, a large force of infantry and cavalry confronted them. Between the two armies there was a rushing brook.

— 1 Maccabees 16:4-5^[7]

The town is briefly mentioned in 2 Maccabees 13, but the reference is not considered very reliable. 2 Maccabees, an independent work separate from 1 Maccabees, was probably written by an Egyptian Jew who does not appear to be very familiar with the geography of Judea due to a number of geographic blunders and implausibilities. According to it, during a campaign by regent Lysias, the army of Judas Maccabeus camped near Modein, then attacked and defeated a Seleucid detachment. However, scholars such as Jonathan A. Goldstein suggest that the writer simply picked a town known for its role in the revolt. The chapter seems to be loosely describing a second campaign from Lysias where 1 Maccabees reports Lysias approached Jerusalem from the southern route, yet Modein was to the north of Jerusalem; hence seeing the mention of Modein in this passage as unreliable or garbled.^[8]

Josephus (1st century AD)

The historian Josephus's work Jewish Antiquities uses 1 Maccabees as a major source and often paraphrases it, but sometimes includes new information, presumably from lost sources such as Nicolaus of Damascus. Antiquities Book 13 provides an account of the Hasmonean royal monument that was apparently still extant during his time, although with some alterations and exclusions to the parallel passage in 1 Maccabees:^[1]

But Simon sent to the city of Basca and brought back the bones of his brother, which he buried in Modein, his birthplace, while all the people made great lamentation over him. And Simon also built for his father and brothers a very great monument of polished white marble, and raising it to a great and conspicuous height, made porticoes round it, and erected monolithic pillars, a wonderful thing to see. In addition to these he built for his parents and his brothers seven pyramids, one for each, so made as to excite wonder by their size and beauty; and these have been preserved to this day.

— Josephus, Jewish Antiquities, Book 13, 210-212^[9]

Rabbinic literature (early centuries AD)

Rabbinical literature describes Modiʽin (also Modiʽim or Modiʽith) as situated on the border between Lydda and western Judea.^[1]

"From Modiʽith and inwards men may be deemed trustworthy in what concerns earth-enware vessels; from Modi'ith and outwards they may not be deemed trustworthy. Thus, if the potter himself sold the pot and came in hither from Modi'ith, in what concerns himself the potter, the selfsame pots, and the selfsame buyers, he may be deemed trustworthy. If he went out [beyond Modi'ith] he may not be deemed trustworthy."^[10]

"What counts as a journey afar off Beyond Modi'ith, or a like distance in any direction. So R. Akiva."^[11]

"Ulla said, "From Modiʽim to Jerusalem is fifteen [Roman] miles."^[12]

Modiʽin may be the birthplace of the priest Rabbi Eleazar ha-Modaʽi, who appears to have been a prominent figure during the Bar-Kochba War. His leadership role is attested to in various sources such as the Mishnah, the Jerusalemite Talmud, and Lamentations Rabbah.^[1]

Patristic literature (3rd to 5th centuries AD)

During the Byzantine period, there are scarce texts mentioning Modiʽin. 4th century bishop and scholar Eusebius wrote:

"Modeeim (1 Maccabees 13:25): A village near Diospolis where the Maccabees were, and where their tombs are still now shown".^[13]

Jerome corroborates Eusebius's account and expresses surprise at claims that the Maccabees' tombstone is in Antioch.^[1] In the Vulgate (Latin translation of the Bible), Jerome added a geographical detail to the mention of Modiʽin: "in monte Modin" ("on the mountain of Modiʽin").^[1]

Madaba Map (6th century)

On the Madaba map, commonly dated to the mid-6th century, Modiʽin appears situated on the border between the coastal plain and the Judaean Lowlands, along the route from Lod to Jerusalem, and between the towns of "Adiathim, now [H]aditha" and "Capher-uta (Ke[f]ar Ruta)". The town, labeled with the inscription "Modiʽim (Μωδεειμ, Mōdeeim), now Moditha (Greek: Μωδιθα), whence came the Maccabees", is indicated with the customary symbol for a village on the map. The site is marked by two towers having a single entranceway.^[14][1]

There are no literary references to Modiʽin or Moditha after the Byzantine period.^[1]

Proposals to identify Modi'in

 

Qubur al-Yahud, pictured in 1960

Ancient texts indicate that Modi'in was strategically located near a major road, positioned at a juncture between the predominantly Jewish-inhabited area and the coastal plain, then predominantly populated with non-Jews. The Hasmonean mausoleum built near Modi'in stood in a high spot, atop a hill. During the Second Temple Period, several Jewish villages were located in this area.^[1]

Scholars propose that the ancient name Modi'in is preserved on both sides of Wadi Malakeh, situated north of modern Modi'in-Maccabim-Re'ut, with the Arab village of al-Midya to the east and Khirbet Midieh to the west. Several archaeological sites in the area have been suggested as potential identifications for the ancient city.^[1]

Early suggestions

The Crusaders associated Hasmonean Modiʽin with different locations, including Tzoba/Belmont, near Latrun and near Hebron.^[1]

In the 14th century, the Jewish traveller and geographer Ishtori Haparchi wrote that Modi'in was situated in a village near Jerusalem called Midʽa, probably the modern al-Midya.^[1]

In the early 19th century, Rabbi Joseph Schwarz proposed that Modiʽin was situated at Mount Midan near Tzoba, drawing connections from the similarity of names and the fifteen-mile distance from Jerusalem mentioned in the Babylonian Talmud.^[15][1]

In 1866, Franciscan monk Emmanuel Forner wrote in Le Monde that Modiʽin was located in the Arab village of al-Midya. Forner theorized that this site housed the burial grounds of the Hasmonean family, citing phonetic resemblances in place names and the village's close proximity to Lod, reachable within a two-hour walk.^[1][16] In the summer of 1909, Yitzhak Ben-Zvi visited al-Midya, which he referred to as Modiʽim, as well as Qubur el-Yahud.^[17][1]

Tell er-Ras, Al-Midya

Main article: Al-Midya

Early scholars, including Gustaf Dalman, Père Félix-Marie Abel, and Michael Avi-Yonah, along with subsequent experts, initially associated the name el-Midieh solely with the Arab village of the same name. This led them to identify the location of Modi'in either at Tel er-Ras, an archaeological tell located to the east of the village, or within the village itself.^[1]

A survey conducted by Israel Finkelstein and his team at Tell er-Ras uncovered pottery dating back to the Iron Age and later periods.^[18] Zissu and Perry, describing Tell er-Ras as a "large biblical site", doubted the identification of the site with Modi'in, pointing to the absence of evidence for a significant settlement during the Hellenistic, Roman, and Byzantine periods, as well as the absence of a nearby Roman road mentioned in rabbinic texts.^[1]

Khirbet el-Hammam (Khirbet Midiyeh)

 

Al Midya, Khirbet el-Hammam and Sheikh el-Garbawi in the PEF Survey of Western Palestine (1871–77)

To the west of al-Midya and Nahal Modi'in lies another archaeological site often linked to ancient Modi'in, commonly referred to as Khirbet el-Hammam but also mapped as Khirbet Midiyeh (distinct from Tell er-Ras, which is also occasionally referred to by the same name). In the 19th century, this area has drawn the attention of researchers like Victor Guérin and Charles Simon Clermont-Ganneau, who explored sites such as Sheikh el-Gharbawi and Qubur al-Yahud ("Tombs of the Jews"), uncovering quarries, winepresses, and numerous tombs. During his visit in 1870, Guérin engaged in conversations with village elders, who shared a local Arab tradition indicating that all remnants southwest of the stream—including Khirbet el-Hammam, Qubur al-Yahud, and Horbat HaGardi—were once part of a city known as El-Midya.^[19] Guérin identified ashlar-built structures, tesserae, cisterns, and what locals considered a bathhouse at el-Hammam, hence the name "Khirbet el-Hammam", Arabic for "house of the bathhouse".^[19] Through recent studies a realization emerged that these sites of Sheikh el-Gharbawi and Qubur al-Yahud were adjacent to the remains of an ancient settlement encompassing an area of 8 hectares.^[1]

On the slopes of Khirbet el Hammam, now dissected by the "Patrol Road" which follows an ancient road, there are layered remnants of ancient architecture concealed beneath debris, comprising hewn stones, architectural remnants, and cisterns. Adjacent to this, pottery from the Hellenistic, Roman, and Byzantine periods, along with tesserae, are scattered. In the forested northern section, remnants of hewn-stone structures are surrounded by Byzantine-era pottery shards, while the southern part, now a cultivated field, yields predominantly Iron Age II pottery sherds, with fewer from the Roman and Byzantine periods.^[1]

In 1995, a salvage excavation unveiled a Jewish rock-cut burial complex containing kokhim tombs and ossuaries inscribed with names in the square Hebrew and Greek scripts, dating from the late Second Temple Period to the Bar-Kochba war era. Another survey in 2000 revealed pottery sherds spanning various periods. In 2005, a survey uncovered rock-cut tombs, including kokhim-type tombs, shaft tombs, and tomb chambers, dating from the 2nd century BC to the early centuries CE.^[1]

 

Part of a Jewish rock-cut burial complex excavated in 1995 at Khirbet el-Hammam

A salvage excavation led by Dalit Weinblatt and conducted in 1996-1997 at the center of the site, revealed signs of settlement activity tracing back to the Iron Age, with evidence of successive layers of occupation spanning the Hellenistic, Roman, Byzantine, and early Arab periods. On top of stratified remains and potsherds from the Iron Age, a stratum dating to the Hellenistic and early Roman periods was found, featuring structures constructed from hewn stones, stone floors, a ritual bath, and pottery items. This settlement appears to have been destroyed during the Bar-Kochba war. The site saw renewed occupation in the late Roman and early Byzantine periods, persisting until the 9th century during the early Muslim period.^[1]

Boaz Zissu and Lior Perry proposed identifying the site of Khirbet el-Hummam/Khirbet Midieh as the location of both the Second Temple Period Modi'in and its successor, the Byzantine-era site of Moditha. They noted that this site meets geographical criteria, preserves the ancient name, and revealed significant findings indicating village existence during both periods. They suggest the Byzantine-period settlement was built upon the remains of Second Temple Period Modi'in.^[1]

Umm el-Umdan

 

The synagogue at Umm el-Umdan

The archaeological site of Khirbet Umm el-Umdan, situated in the southern outskirts of modern Modi'in, has also been proposed as a possible location for the ancient town. The site was unearthed in the 2000s during salvage excavations conducted by the Israel Antiquities Authority amid the development of the Buchman neighborhood. The excavations unveiled a rural settlement featuring homes, burial sites, a synagogue and a ritual bath, dating from second century BC to the Bar Kochba war in 132 AD.^{[20][21][22][23]}

Excavators Shlomit Wexler-Bdolah, Alexander Onn, and Yehuda Rapuano proposed this site as a possible ancient Modi'in, suggesting that its Arabic name, "Umm el-Umdan", preserves the city's ancient name.^[21][22][23] However, the name, Arabic for "the mother of columns", is also present in other places within Israel, such as another site situated in the Jerusalem hills and one in the Judean Lowlands.^[1]

Giv'at Tittora

 

Givat Tittora

Another site proposed as ancient Modi'in is Giv'at haTittora, also known as al-Burj, situated approximately 7 kilometers southeast of Khirbet el-Hammam, in the northern part of modern Modi'in. Surveys and excavations conducted there in the 2000s uncovered several settlement layers, with a Crusader fortress atop the hill. The excavators, Shimon Gibson and Egon Lass, suggested to identify the site with ancient Modi'in.^[24][25] While the hill has a commanding view of the surroundings, excavations have not yielded substantial evidence of a Second Temple Period settlement, and Hellenistic remains are uncommon. Scholars like Zissu and Perry expressed reluctance in accepting this identification due to the lack of clear archaeological evidence and the absence of the ancient name's preservation.^[1]

Sites considered for the Hasmonean burial complex

Historically, Qubur al-Yahud and Horvat HaGardi were associated with the Tombs of the Maccabees. However, scholars now dispute this connection, arguing that these sites date to later periods. The original site might have been destroyed during the Bar Kochba revolt and subsequently lost; the tombs remain undiscovered.^[1][3]

The two sites historically connected with the tombs, include the "Tombs of the Maccabees" (Qubur al-Yahud) and Horvat HaGardi/Sheikh al-Garbawi.^[1][4]

"Tombs of the Maccabees", Qubur al-Yahud

 

"Tombs of the Maccabees" graves at Qubur al-Yahud. Although the Arabic name suggests "Tombs of the Jews", archaeological evidence reveals these tombs date back to the Byzantine period, thus ruling out their association with the earlier, Hellenistic-period Hasmonean mausoleum

One location historically linked to the Tombs of the Maccabees is a site known in Arabic as "Qubur al-Yahud", meaning "Tombs of the Jews" (31° 55′ 46″ N, 34° 59′ 40″ E).^[1]

In December 1908, during the Hanukkah holiday, students and teachers from Herzliya Gymnasium journeyed to the area seeking the tombs of the Maccabees. Guided by a shepherd, they arrived at the Qubur el-Yahud tombs, where they lit Hanukkah candles, marking the start of a tradition of pilgrimage and candle-lighting at the site. Over the following decades, the tombs became a pilgrimage destination, associated with Zionist ideals, and inspired literary works. In 1937, members of the Maccabi movement organized a race from the tombs to Tel Aviv, carrying a torch lit above the site, a tradition continued after the Six-Day War, establishing Qubur el-Yahud as the official "Tombs of the Maccabees" site marked on maps alongside the name "Modi'im".^[1]

Scholars have highlighted that the tombs are actually shaft tombs characteristic of the Byzantine period, indicating that they cannot be the original burial complex of the Hasmonean family built centuries earlier, in the 2nd century BC.^[1]

Horvat HaGardi/Sheikh al-Garbawi

 

The tomb-shrine of Sheikh al-Garbawi at Horvat HaGardi. It is accompanied by a nearby Byzantine structure ("al-Qal'a"), once mistakenly thought to be the original mausoleum of the Hasmoneans in the 19th century. Its identification as such may have occurred in late antiquity.

Horvat HaGardi, located north of Qubur al-Yahud, was also identified with the Maccabees' Tombs. This site is alternatively known as Sheikh al-Gharbawi ("the western sheikh"), an Islamic tomb-shrine located there. Adjacent to the shrine are the remains of a monumental rectangular structure made of ashlars, referred to in Arabic as "al-Qal'a" ("the fortress").^[1][16]

In 1870, Guérin excavated al-Qal'a, claiming it matched descriptions of the Tomb of the Maccabees in ancient texts. He reported his findings to the French consul and consulted with architect Moss, who affirmed the identification of the site based on its resemblance to historical accounts.^[1][16] This view was also supported by PEF explorer Charles F. Tyrwhitt-Drake.^[16] However, Clermont-Ganneau's extensive excavations in 1871, which uncovered a mosaic depicting a crux immissa and an arcosolium-type burial cave, suggest that the structure likely originated as a Christian structure in the Byzantine period, dating back to the fifth century AD. He proposed that it could have served as a Christian mausoleum commemorating the Maccabees' burial place, a theory supported by Eusebius' mention of the tombs of the Maccabees still being shown in his time.^[1][16]

The theory that the al-Qal'a structure originated as a Christian structure may have been regarded as the burial site of the Hasmoneans during the Byzantine period gained support from recent scholarship, including trial excavations led by Amit Re'em of the Israel Antiquities Authority in 2011.^[16][1] This theory was also accepted by Zissu and Perry.^[1]

Places named after ancient Modi'in

Several modern-day Israeli localities, including the city of Modi'in-Maccabim-Reut, are named after ancient Modi'in, and are situated in the area where it is believed to have once stood.^[26]

References

1. Zissu, Boaz; Perry, Lior (2015). "Hasmonean Modi'in and Byzantine Moditha: A topographical-historical and archaeological assessment". Palestine Exploration Quarterly. 147 (4): 316–337. doi:10.1179/0031032815Z.000000000137. ISSN 0031-0328.
2. Jacobs, Steven L. (2023). A Short History of Judaism and the Jewish People (First published ed.). London New York Oxford New Delhi Sydney: Bloomsbury Academic. p. 97. ISBN 978-1-350-23646-2. In 165 BCE, guerilla warfare broke out against the Seleucids, led by a family of Hasmonean priests from Modi'in, under the leadership of a father Mattityahu (Mattathias) and his eldest son Yehuda (Judah), nicknamed Ha-Maccabee ("The Hammer") due to his and his followers' guerrilla tactics (strike and pull back). One year later, they had achieved victory over their hated enemies and reconsecrated and rededicated their Temple with, ... For the next 130 years, the Hasmoneans would remain central to the leadership of the peoples of Judea.
3. Schwartz, Joshua J. (1991). Lod (Lydda), Israel: From its Origins through the Byzantine Period (5600 B.C.E. - 640 C.E.). British Archaeological Reports, International Series 571. Oxford: Tempus Reparatum. pp. 61–65.
4. Jacobson, David M. (2013). "Military Symbols on the Coins of John Hyrcanus I". Strata: Bulletin of the Anglo-Israel Archaeological Society. 31: 26.
5. 1 Maccabees 2:11
6. 1 Maccabees 13:27–30
7. 1 Maccabees 16:4–5
8. Goldstein, Jonathan A. (1983). II Maccabees: A New Translation with Introduction and Commentary. The Anchor Bible Series. Vol. 41A. Garden City, NY: Doubleday. pp. 454–457. ISBN 0-385-04864-5.
9. Josephus, Flavius (1943) [c. 93]. "Book XIII, 13.210-212". Jewish Antiquities. Translated by Marcus, Ralph. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University Press. pp. 331–333. ISBN 0-674-99577-5.
10. Mishnah, Hagiga, 3:5
11. Mishnah, Pesachim, 9:2
12. Babylonian Talmud, Pesachim, 93b
13. Eusebius, Onomasticon, 73
14. Zaharoni, Irit (1983). Derekh erets (in Hebrew). Vol. 1. Tel-Aviv: Ḳetsin ḥinukh rashi--"Ba-maḥaneh". p. 75. ISBN 9789650500887. OCLC 10375126.
15. Schwarz, J., A Descriptive Geography and Brief Historical Sketch of Palestine. translated by Isaac Leeser, Philadelphia: A. Hart. p. 96
16. Re'em, Amit (2011). "Horbat Ha-Gardi: Final Report". Hadashot Arkheologiyot: Excavations and Surveys in Israel. Retrieved 2024-02-12.
17. Ben-Zvi, I., Impressions, Jerusalem: Yad Ben-Zvi (Hebrew) p. 33-34
18. Finkelstein and Lederman, 1997, pp. 131-134
19. Segal, Orit (2016). "Khirbat el-Hammam: Final Report". Hadashot Arkheologiyot: Excavations and Surveys in Israel / חדשות ארכיאולוגיות: חפירות וסקרים בישראל. 128. ISSN 1565-043X. JSTOR 26679188.
20. "Umm el-'Umdan, Khirbet (Modi'in)". The BAS Library. Retrieved 2024-02-12.
21. Onn, A., Weksler-Bdolah, S., and Rapuano Y., A synagogue from the Second Temple Period at Hurvat Umel-'Umdan in Modiin’, in Y. Eshel, E. Netzer, D. Amit, and D. Cassuto, (eds.), And Let Them Make Me A Sanctuary: Synagogues from Ancient Times to the Present Day, Ariel: The College of Judaea and Samaria. 2004. pp 25-29
22. Onn, A., and Weksler-Bdolah, S., Khirbet Um el-Umdan– A Jewish village with a synagogue from the Second Temple Period at Modiin. Qadmoniot 130. 2005. pp. 107-116 (Hebrew).
23. Weksler-Bdolah, S., Onn, A., and Rapuano, Y., Identifying the Hasmonaean village of Modiin’, Cathedra 109. 2003. pp. 69-86 (Hebrew)
24. Gibson, S. (2004). "From wildscape to landscape: Landscape archaeology in the Southern Levant – methods and practice." In A. Maeir, S. Dar, and Z. Safrai (Eds.), The Rural Landscape of Ancient Israel. Oxford: Archaeopress. p. 8
25. Negev, A., & Gibson, S. (Eds.). (2001). Archaeological Encyclopedia of the Holy Land (New revised and updated edition). New York, NY/London, UK: Continuum. p. 341
26. "There is a Modi in Israel too". The Economic Times. 2017-07-08. ISSN 0013-0389. Retrieved 2024-02-21.