Operation Gideon (2020)

This article is about the 2020 Venezuela operation. For other uses, see El Junquito raid and Operation Gideon.

This article uses Spanish naming customs: the paternal surname is first, and the maternal surname is second.

Operation Gideon (Spanish: Operación Gedeón) was an unsuccessful attempt by the Active Coalition of the Venezuelan International Reserve, Venezuelan dissidents, and a private security firm, Jordan Goudreau's Silvercorp USA, to infiltrate Venezuela by sea and remove Nicolás Maduro from power. The plan executed from 3 to 4 May 2020 was for expatriate Venezuelan military living in Colombia to enter the country by boat at Macuto, take control of an airfield, capture Maduro and other high-level figures in his administration, and expel them from the country.

Operation Gideon
Part of the crisis in Venezuela and the Venezuelan presidential crisis
Top to bottom, left to right: Venezuelan authorities intercepting a boat; Nicolás Maduro holding the US passports of captured former Green Berets; SEBIN agents displaying captured dissidents
Date 3–4 May 2020 Location Venezuela Macuto, Vargas Chuao, Aragua Action Attempt to remove Nicolás Maduro and other high-level figures from power Result Plot infiltrated and foiled by Maduro administration Maduro administration begins Bolivarian Shield military response 99 arrest warrants issued by the Maduro administration, including for Jordan Goudreau, J. J. Rendón and Sergio Vergara, on 8 May^[1]^[2] Jordan Goudreau investigated by US federal authorities^[3]
Belligerents
Venezuela military and intelligence National Bolivarian Armed Forces of Venezuela Bolivarian Intelligence Service	Venezuelan dissidents Active Coalition of the Venezuelan International Reserve (CARIVE) American contractors Silvercorp USA
Commanders and leaders
Nicolás Maduro Diosdado Cabello Vladimir Padrino López Néstor Reverol	Jordan Goudreau Clíver Antonio Alcalá Cordones Javier Enrique Nieto Quintero Roberto Levid Colina Ibarra  † Antonio Sequea Torres (POW)
Strength
Unknown	300–800 (planned)^[4]^[5] ≈60 (from sea)^[6]^[7]
Casualties and losses
None	6 killed^[8]^[9]^[10] 91 captured (including 2 American mercenaries)^[11]

A landing attempt to initiate the operation went forward despite its impracticality. Two boats were launched from eastern Colombia toward the Caribbean coast of Venezuela north of Caracas, carrying approximately 60 Venezuelan dissidents and two American former Green Berets employed as mercenaries by Silvercorp. Both boats were intercepted before they reached land. At least six Venezuelan dissidents in the first boat were killed, and all but four of the invaders were captured during the attempted landing or subsequent search operations, including the two Americans from the second boat, whose interrogations were broadcast on state television in the hours following the event.

The operation occurred in the broader context of an ongoing presidential crisis beginning in January 2019 over the identity of the legitimate president of Venezuela – Maduro or Guaidó. Throughout 2019, Maduro had maintained control of Venezuela's military agencies and key governmental institutions. After the incident, various news outlets published an agreement between the Guaidó administration's Strategy Committee and Silvercorp, signed in October 2019, the terms of which provided that Silvercorp would organize an operation to remove Maduro and establish the Guaidó administration in exchange for a share of future oil sale profits. Committee members said that they had withdrawn from the agreement and cut off ties with Silvercorp and Goudreau in November 2019.

Colombian and Venezuelan intelligence agencies, as well as the Associated Press (AP), had prior knowledge of the operation. Commentators and observers described the operation as amateurish, underfunded, poorly organized, impossible, and a suicide mission, and divergent narratives led to questions about how the plot unfolded. Sources criticized the poor planning and execution, alternating between characterizing Operation Gideon as an attempted invasion, infiltration, raid, ambush, assassination or coup. Maduro and his representatives described the attacking force as terrorists who planned to kill him in a plot coordinated by Colombia and the United States, Guaidó and some supporters described the event as a false flag orchestrated by Maduro, and Goudreau described the team as freedom fighters seeking to restore democracy. Guaidó, his Strategy Committee, and officials of the Colombian and United States governments denied any role in the events that occurred on 3 to 4 May 2020.

Background

Main article: Venezuelan presidential crisis

Nicolás Maduro first took office as president of Venezuela in 2013 as the hand-picked successor of Hugo Chávez after Chávez's death from cancer.^[12] Javier Corrales wrote in a Journal of Democracy article that the "questionable electoral integrity" and the "slim margin" by which Maduro won the 2013 Venezuelan presidential election brought resistance to his mandate from "opposition parties, the media, civil society, elements of the military, and international actors".^[12] Corrales states that Maduro "presided over one of the most devastating national economic crises seen anywhere in modern times."^[12] Beginning with the 2014 Venezuelan protests, Popular Will leader Leopoldo López had sought to expel Maduro, calling for "direct action to remove" him, according to an article published by The Wall Street Journal.^[13]

According to Rafael Villa – writing in Defence Studies in 2022 – "Maduro's leadership [was] not consensual" and among the changes he had made to overcome his "political fragility" was promoting an excessive number of officers within the military, and the election of a 2017 Constituent National Assembly to replace the opposition-led National Assembly, which was elected in 2015.^[14][15] Victor Mijares writes, in the book Latin American Politics and Development, that increased authoritarianism and control of the military in an environment of extreme poverty and inflation during a period marked by protests and repression, brought about a "legitimacy crisis coming from dubious elections" with the "combination of these tactics of political control and illegal rule" leading to the presidential crisis between Maduro and Popular Will politician Juan Guaidó.^[16] According to unnamed sources cited by The Wall Street Journal article, the 2018 election – "widely seen as fraudulent" – convinced López that negotiations were not an option,^[13] with BBC News saying that "[m]any believe" he was the "father" of the policy to remove Maduro in any way, even through violence.^[17]

A power struggle for the presidency of Venezuela began in January 2019 following the 2018 presidential election; according to The Washington Post, incumbent Nicolás Maduro was "accused of stealing the 2018 elections" and leading a repressive administration.^[10][15] In January 2019, Guaidó was named president of the National Assembly – the "nation's last democratic institution" according to The Washington Post.^[10] He was later recognized by more than 50 countries, including the United States, as interim president of Venezuela.^[4] James DeFronzo wrote in the 2021 book, Revolutions and Revolutionary Movements, that: "Critics questioned whether there was really constitutional justification for Guaidó to become interim president in place of Maduro."^[18] The US administration of Donald Trump pressured for the exit of Maduro,^[19] charged him with narcoterrorism, and put a US$15 million reward for information leading to his capture and arrest.^[20][21] Yet throughout 2019, the Maduro administration maintained control of Venezuela's military agencies and key governmental institutions.^[22] Maduro enjoyed the support of the higher ranks of the military, but less so among the middle and lower ranks.^[14][15]

Establishing a government in Venezuela required three crucial elements: according to Villa, "the people, the international community, and the armed forces."^[14] Following the failed 2019 Venezuelan uprising attempt led by Guaidó against Maduro on 30 April, Guaidó's movement lost momentum;^[14][19] according to William Neuman – writing in the 2022 book Things Are Never So Bad That They Can't Get Worse: Inside the Collapse of Venezuela – with waning support and other options not materializing, Guaidó and López sought "another way out of Venezuela's impasse".^[22] The Wall Street Journal states that, "according to several people involved in the planning", López dedicated months to find and hire mercenaries who would overthrow the Maduro government without the knowledge of other opposition parties.^[13]

After the unsuccessful April 2019 uprising, some former military and police defectors who sided with Guaidó took refuge in Colombia;^[4] they considered their aim was to "liberate their homeland from the socialist government of [an] autocratic" president, according to The Washington Post.^[10] Businesses began to approach the Guaidó administration, seeking to profit from contracts they expected to become available as Guaidó replaced Maduro,^[10] and proposals of an armed operation to support Guaidó began to be discussed.^[4]

Planning

Operation Gideon was primarily planned by Clíver Alcalá Cordones and Jordan Goudreau.^[4][10][23]

Alcalá was a Major General in the Venezuelan Army with close ties to the Hugo Chávez government until he defected under Maduro^[5] to Colombia in 2013 and began gathering other defectors, stationing them in the La Guajira Peninsula.^[4] In 2011, he was charged by the US with providing the Colombian FARC with arms, and was indicted for narcoterrorism in March 2020 as a member of the Cartel of the Suns.^[4][10]

Goudreau served in the Canadian Armed Forces^[10][23] and later moved to Washington, D.C. and enlisted in the United States Army, eventually reaching the rank of Sergeant First Class in the 10th Special Forces Group.^[23] He became a naturalized US citizen and retired at the age of 40 due to injuries.^[23] In 2018, he founded Silvercorp USA, with the initial idea being "to embed counter-terror agents in schools disguised as teachers".^[4][24]

Goudreau is reported to have provided security at a political rally for Donald Trump in Charlotte, North Carolina in October 2018 based on material on the Silvercorp website and Instagram account.^[6][25][26] In February 2019, Silvercorp provided security services at the Venezuela Aid Live concert in Colombia, and Goudreau turned his attention to Venezuela.^[27][28] According to Goudreau's friend and business partner, Drew White, he saw a business opportunity in the Trump administration's intensified efforts to remove Maduro from power.^[4] White said he distanced himself from Silvercorp and Goudreau when Goudreau began discussing launching a military operation in Venezuela.^[23]

Journalist Sebastiana Barráez [es], who specializes in Venezuelan military reporting,^[29] writes that what came to be known as Operation Gideon was three different plans at different times: one was the preparation in the Colombian camps of exiled Venezuelan military led by Alcalá until he was extradited to the U.S. in March 2020; another was the period after that when Antonio Sequea took over the camps until he led the men on what she calls a "suicide mission" to an ambush at Macuto; and yet another phase was what related to SilverCorp and Diosdado Cabello^[30] who had infiltrated the camps and had advance knowledge of the plans.^[31][a]

Initial promotion: March–May 2019

Further information: Venezuelan crisis defection

Alcalá openly discussed his plans to overthrow the Maduro government with a 1,000 men strong force with The Wall Street Journal, saying "If you don't do this now, the republic is lost."^[33] The Wall Street Journal reported that Alcalá planned to use dissident soldiers from the Venezuelan army and national guard, hoping to involve officers in the operation prior to their purging by the Maduro government.^[33]

Through connections within the private security community, Goudreau was acquainted with Keith Schiller, the longtime director of security for Donald Trump.^[4] Schiller brought Goudreau to a March 2019 fundraising event focused on security in Venezuela and future investments in the nation following a potential end of the Maduro government, which took place at the University Club of Washington, DC.^[4][10] Lester Toledo [es], the director of humanitarian aid for Guaidó's government, also attended.^[4]

Weeks later, according to an AP article, Toledo introduced Goudreau to Alcalá at JW Marriott Bogotá during a conference where groups of Venezuelan exiles, some of whom were involved in Guaidó's failed uprising, gathered.^[4] The Wall Street Journal reported that Alcalá and Goudreau had been introduced by "associates" of Leopoldo López and that opposition officials were convinced about the plot's feasibility.^[13] During the two-day meeting with Toledo and Goudreau, Alcalá disclosed that he had recruited some 300 men stationed at training camps on the Guajira Peninsula near Riohacha, Colombia, ready to carry out "a 'mad plan' to push across the western border, take the oil center of Maracaibo and force their way to Caracas, the capital".^[10][4] Goudreau indicated that instead of 300 as Alcalá promised, there were only 60 trainees.^[34] Goudreau proposed an alternative approach, suggesting that his company, Silvercorp, could train and equip the soldiers for a rapid strike at a cost of US$1.5 million.^[4] Goudreau said he had contacts with Trump administration officials, though reportedly did not provide support for his statements.^[4][10] Men familiar with the missions said Goudreau "had convinced the men that they were training for a U.S.-backed incursion into Venezuela", according to The Washington Post.^[10] Following the meeting at JW Marriott, Toledo and some Guaidó officials indicated that they ended contact with Goudreau because they believed the operation was a suicide mission and they did not trust Alcalá.^[4][35]

In May 2019, Schiller and Goudreau met with Guaidó administration officials in Miami, Florida, where Goudreau promoted the idea of providing security for Guaidó officials.^[4] Schiller distanced himself from Goudreau following the meeting, believing that Goudreau was incapable of providing the services he was offering.^[4][5]

Goudreau's October 2020 lawsuit stated that a $500-million proposal had been submitted by Blackwater founder Erik Prince that involved 5,000 troops and mercenaries.^[36][37] Guaidó and his representatives, as well as Prince and his representatives, denied such reports.^[38][36]

Colombia Silvercorp established: June 2019

A Colombian branch of Silvercorp was opened in mid-2019 by Goudreau and Yacsy Alezandra Álvarez Mirabal, who acted as a translator for Alcalá and Goudreau.^[39][40] Álvarez was an assistant of Franklin Durán, a Venezuelan businessman who had business ties with the Venezuelan government for about two decades until his company was expropriated by the government; one of his businesses had a history of importing military equipment.^[41][42] Durán and his brothers were friends with Alcalá prior to the event; the AP described Durán as "close to the government of the late Hugo Chávez".^[42]

In June 2019, Alcalá met with the National Intelligence Directorate of Colombia asking for support, saying Goudreau was a former CIA agent.^[43][4] CIA contacts in Bogotá reportedly denied that Goudreau had ever been a CIA agent.^[4] According to Álvarez, former president of Colombia Álvaro Uribe and then president Iván Duque expressed support for Goudreau's efforts, offering them a training camp, an airstrip and safe passage for individuals in exchange for combatting militants of the National Liberation Army in the area.^[39] US officials learned of the "hundreds of Venezuelan soldiers who had defected and were living precariously in Colombia" and discussed a plan to reorganize them to assist victims of the Venezuelan refugee crisis, thus diverting them from illegal activities.^[5] When reports emerged that they might be used for an armed operation, one anonymous US official described the notion as "completely insane".^[5]

By 16 June 2019, Goudreau had compiled a list of required equipment, according to former United States Navy SEAL Ephraim Mattos, who met with Alcalá's troops while working in Colombia.^[4] The list included "320 M4 assault rifles, an anti-tank rocket launcher, Zodiac boats, US$1 million in cash and state-of-the-art night vision goggles".^[4] According to Mattos, the trainees believed they had the backing of the U.S. government; after reviewing Silvercorp on the internet, he said: "I was like, 'Guys, guys, guys, this guy is not who he says he is.'"^[10][44]

Negotiations with Guaidó representatives: August–November 2019

Main article: Guaidó administration–Silvercorp agreement

 

The General Services Agreement Attachments signed between Guaidó government officials and Silvercorp USA in October 2019. Vergara and Rendón, who have since resigned their positions on the Strategy Committee, acknowledge they signed the agreement and the attachments, but say it was quickly cancelled.^[45][46][47]

 

The General Services Agreement document that was allegedly signed by Guaidó.^[48] Guaidó has denied he signed the agreement and accused the Maduro government of forgery.^[49][50]

Guaidó established a Strategic Committee in August 2019 and named J. J. Rendón to head it.^[22][5] The committee was tasked with exploring possibilities and testing scenarios for the removal of Maduro from power, with methods ranging from increased international condemnation of Maduro to armed action.^[5] After reviewing all legal means of removing Maduro,^[51][45] the group adopted the position that the Venezuelan Constitution, the United Nations Convention against Transnational Organized Crime, and other treaties provided justification for pursuing a change of government.^[5] Among other options, Rendón considered an insurrection against the Maduro government. Foreign contractors would advise and support Venezuelans in a military operation to capture Maduro and replace his government with Guaido's.^{[51][45][52][30]}

Sources told the Wall Street Journal that López and others had reviewed six or more bids from private military companies to enter Venezuela, encourage a rebellion in the armed forces and to overthrow Maduro.^[13] Rendón stated that he was told by Guaidó that "all options were on the table, and under the table."^[5][45] Sucre stated that such discourse, together with phrases used by some in the opposition proclaiming "that there is no electoral exit before a criminal government", could lead to "any possible means to force Maduro's departure".^[53] By 7 September 2019, Goudreau made a sales pitch to Rendón proposing the capture of Maduro and his officials and their extraction from Venezuela^[5][54] with a self-financed plan at a cost of $212.9 million, backed by future oil sales.^[5][48]

General Services Agreement

A General Services Agreement between Venezuela and Silvercorp was signed on 16 October 2019, by Goudreau on behalf of Silvercorp and Rendón and Sergio Vergara, on behalf of the Guaidó administration, with the contract – "contingent on funding and other conditions" according to The Washington Post – discussing what Neuman described as an invasion of Venezuela.^[22][5] DeFronzo calls it an "exploratory agreement";^[55] Mijares writes that "Rendón admitted he had had contact with Goudreau's group, but the operation was never paid for or approved".^[56]

Within a week of signing the agreement, Goudreau reportedly claimed to have secured funding for the operation, but provided no proof.^[5] Rendón told reporters that shortly after signing the agreement, Goudreau began acting suspicious and demanding immediate payment of the $1.5 million retainer that was due within a five-day period according to the agreement.^[5][57] Rendón transferred Goudreau $50,000 from his personal account for "expenses" (confirmed publicly by Goudreau^[33]) to buy more time, but the relationship between the two quickly deteriorated.^[5][58]

On 8 November 2019, Goudreau met Rendón and a heated argument took place.^[5] According to Rendón, he and other Guaidó administration officials "considered the operation dead" after this encounter.^[4][5][3] Rendón attempted to provide a letter canceling the agreement, though Gourdeau refused.^[5]

Signature dispute

It was reported that Juan Guaidó himself signed a preliminary contract.^[59][22] Guaidó and his allies denied that he signed the contract directly, though he was listed as the main party twice and had his representatives sign off.^[22][49] Goudreau provided a covert recording of "what appears to be", according to the Miami Herald,^[36] a video call with Guaidó on 16 October 2019^[22][5] in which Guaidó purportedly says, "We are doing the right thing for our country" and "I'm about to sign".^[22][5] Guaidó and his allies state that Rendón and Vergara signed on Guaidó's behalf;^[60] Rendón said that Guaidó "grew suspicious" of the "exploratory plan" having seen only an outline.^[5][61][62]

Although an agreement had been previously signed, the opposition attempted to distance themselves from their past interactions with Goudreau.^[40][38] The AP wrote that Goudreau said that he advanced the operation "without Guaidó's support".^[40] The Washington Post wrote: "Goudreau counters that the agreement ... bound the opposition to his services and initial fee. A seven-page document provided by Goudreau carries Guaidó's signature" with Rendón's and Vergara's.^[5]

Alcalá and Goudreau resume preparations: December 2019

External videos
Troops practicing clearing drills with model firearms on YouTube from Vice magazine^[38]
Another clearing drill on YouTube from Vice magazine^[38]

Goudreau and Alcalá reportedly distanced themselves from the Venezuelan opposition due to their perception that the opposition was insincere and hypocritical because of alleged secret negotiations with the Maduro government.^[4] Though they no longer had the support of the opposition government, they resumed their preparations.^[4] Without aid from the US government or the Guaidó administration, Goudreau and Alcalá did not have the means required for a successful operation.^[3]

Former Venezuelan National Guard captain Javier Enrique Nieto Quintero, a leader of an international network of Venezuelan dissidents known as the Active Coalition of the Venezuelan International Reserve (CARIVE, Spanish: Coalición Activa de la Reserva Internacional Venezolana), was approached to help provide operators. According to Nieto, CARIVE asked him to meet with Alcalá and that the tactical equipment presented by the former general, including rifles and night vision goggles,^{[clarification needed]} with Nieto stating the materials "showed the political leaders in Venezuela and the international community that the commitment was already there".^[63]

By December 2019, Silvercorp had purchased a 41-foot (12 m) fiberglass boat in Florida that was equipped with navigational equipment two months later.^[3] Silvercorp received funding from an anonymous source on 13 January 2020, according to lien records.^[54] With Goudreau and translator Álvarez, two other former Green Beret operators, Airan Berry and Luke Denman, traveled to Colombia on a 16 January private flight from Opa-Locka, Florida to Barranquilla, Colombia provided by Durán.^[42] Berry was a special forces engineer sergeant in the Army from 1996 to 2013.^[64] Berry deployed to Iraq in 2003, from 2004 to 2005, and in 2007.^[64] Denman was a former Army Special Forces communications sergeant who left the Army in December 2011.^[65] More than sixty Venezuelan dissidents gathered in Riohacha, Colombia to train.^[5]

Denman reportedly believed the United States government and President Trump backed the operation^[66] according to a childhood friend^[67] and Denman's brother.^[54] A lifelong friend of Denman also reported that Denman indicated in October 2019 that one of his friends from the military was in the process of obtaining government approval for training operations in order to earn more engagement with the United States government.^[68] Denman's parents reported that he did not disclose details about the operation.^[65] Similarly, Luke's girlfriend told the Military Times she was unaware of the planned operation, reporting that she "didn't know very much, other than Luke trusted [Goudreau] and that he had a job opportunity with him".^[68]

In March 2020, Goudreau traveled to Jamaica in the Silvercorp-owned fiberglass boat named Silverpoint where he met with former special forces friends and discussed Operation Gideon.^[54][3] According to Jack Murphy, self-identified as a former US Ranger, the CIA learned about the plan and warned Silvercorp not to go through with it on numerous occasions.^[38][69] Goudreau then contacted Guaidó's officials one last time asking for funding.^[54] The Wall Street Journal reported that the planned operation was "widely known to former Venezuelan soldiers who considered participating, Venezuelan opposition figures, senior Colombian intelligence officials and even the CIA, which monitored their activities in La Guajira".^[33] On 28 March, the boat was damaged, triggering an emergency position-indicating radio beacon that alerted authorities in Curaçao, who rescued Goudreau.^[3] They returned him to Florida and COVID travel restrictions prevented him from rejoining his men.^[3]

Hernán Alemán, an opposition politician who initially supported the plan, while describing Goudreau as a friend, indicated in an interview following the event that he did not know any details surrounding the contract or discussions that took place in the United States.^{[38][70][71][72]} He stated that Rendón never financed the operation and that he and Alcalá undertook the operation with Goudreau without his party's knowledge,^[70] deciding to finance the operation themelves.^[70][3] Alemán said that at its peak, the group consisted of four camps occupied by 150 military.^[70] He added that the operation was compromised and had been infiltrated, saying that after Alcalá's arrest, the operation's control was transferred to other people, there was no contact with the new leaders, and other insurgents said Sequea Torres was a mole^[72] – an allegation repeated by others^[73][29] but denied by Jorge Arreaza, Maduro's foreign minister.^[52]

The Venezuelan government later published an audio recording of Alemán by Venezuelan intelligence, in which he reportedly tells a listener that he had met a CIA officer at the U.S. ambassador's house; Vice magazine printed a portion of Alemán's alleged conversation (noting the recording "could very well have been tampered with by a security service loyal to Maduro") which has Alemán saying, "Here in a meeting with all the bigwigs in the house of the [U.S. ambassador] ... I was even speaking with the guy from the CIA. They put me there so that the CIA guy would talk to me".^[38] Alemán later acknowledged in an interview with Infobae that the voice on the recording was his, at a social gathering celebrating the 4 and 5 July, saying that the distortion to make it appear they had conspired with the US was untrue. He stated that, "If there was one thing we were always very clear about, it was that the United States was not going to get involved in an action like the one [we] planned."^[74]

Extradition of Alcalá to the United States: March 2020

 

Clíver Alcalá Cordones, one of the alleged leaders of the operation, indicted by the United States

A shipment of weapons and tactical gear was confiscated on 23 March 2020 by Colombian authorities tipped off by the Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA), with former DEA officials initially believing that the equipment was being sent to leftist guerrillas or criminal gangs.^[3][4] The impounded truck was headed for Venezuela carrying 26 semi-automatic rifles, night vision goggles, radios, and 15 combat helmets produced by High-End Defense Solutions, a company owned by Venezuelan Americans.^[4][75]

On 26 March 2020, the United States accused Maduro of narcoterrorism, and through its Narcotics Rewards Program offered a US$15 million reward for information leading to his arrest, plus an additional US$10 million each for information leading to the arrest of four close Maduro allies: Diosdado Cabello, Maikel Moreno, Tareck El Aissami, Vladimir Padrino López and Cilver Alcalá, one of the alleged leaders of the operation.^{[76][77][78][79]} The same day, Alcalá placed a video on Twitter where he assumed responsibility for "a military operation against the Maduro dictatorship" that included the shipment of weapons captured in Colombia, stating that the United States, Colombia, and Guaidó officials had signed an agreement to overthrow Maduro.^[22][75] After Alcalá assumed responsibility for the weapons shipment, the Colombian attorney general announced on 28 March that an investigation into Alcalá's role in the shipment had been opened.^[80]

Guaidó denied knowledge of the event while United States Special Representative to Venezuela Elliott Abrams described Alcalá's statement as "despicable and quite dangerous". Abrams later said that Alcalá "was put up to making those terrible charges by the [Maduro] regime".^[75] Alcalá was extradited to the United States on drug trafficking charges after voluntarily surrendering on about 27 March.^[81][82]

The Venezuelan government said that Alcalá was a US agent and that, after the operation failed, the United States government used narcoterrorism charges as a way to transport him to the United States to prevent him from revealing more secrets.^[75] In the context of reacting to the intercepted shipment on 26 March, Maduro stated that Alcalá was hired by the DEA to assassinate him, "but he failed because we made him fail".^[83]

According to Alemán, who acknowledges participating in the planning of the operation up until the point Alcalá was extradited to the United States, Sequea took control of the operation and replaced military personnel.^[70] Alemán remarked that Goudreau was unable to exercise command because he was in the United States.^[70] Alemán, saying he was basing his statements on others, accused Sequea of being a mole and of selling the group out.^[70]

In November 2021, Alcalá's lawyers lodged a motion to have the US charges dismissed along with a statement that US officials at the highest levels of the CIA, Department of the Treasury, Department of Justice, the National Security Council and the DEA were aware of his efforts to overthrow Maduro. The attorney also stated Rendón and two Guaidó allies were aware of Alcalá's coup plan.^[84] In June 2023, Alcalá pled guilty in the U.S. to "two counts of providing material support to a terrorist group and illicit transfer of firearms", with the narcotics charges dropped.^[85]

Prior knowledge of operation

According to the Associated Press, the operation "was infiltrated by Maduro's vast, Cuban-trained intelligence network" early on.^[3] The Venezuelan government knew the location of the camps on Guajira Peninsula by September 2019, with Vice President of Venezuela Delcy Rodríguez announcing the coordinates of the militants while speaking at the general debate of the United Nations General Assembly.^[86][87] The Washington Post wrote that Maduro "was well-informed of the effort virtually from its start".^[10]

Two days after the confiscation of weapons and munitions in Colombia, on 25 March, the Venezuelan Minister of Communication and Information, Jorge Rodríguez, gave a televised press conference in which he published details related to the training camps. Rodríguez named former Venezuelan army captain Roberto Levid "Pantera" Colina Ibarra,^[73][88][89] whom he identified as a murderer, as the leader of one of the training sites with the support of Colombian President Iván Duque.^[90] Rodríguez mentioned that there were three American instructors at the training camps.^[90] "We know their cover names: agent Jordan, agent Luke, and agent Aaron," he announced.^[90]

On 28 March, Diosdado Cabello identified Goudreau as an adviser for Alcalá during episode 294 of the television show Con El Mazo Dando.^{[22][58][91][92]} Cabello also identified by first name the two Americans; he referred to Denman and Berry only as "Luke" and "Aaron" [phonetic spelling].^[91] Cabello also exhibited photographs purportedly showing Goudreau, Silvercorp and content from their social media profiles,^[91] and photographs from Instagram depicting Goudreau providing security services during the Venezuela Aid Live concert in Cúcuta and at a Trump rally in Charlotte.^[58][91] The purpose of broadcasting the images was to show that the United States was allegedly behind the international effort to remove Maduro from power and was conspiring with narcotics traffickers, referring to Alcalá.^[91] The program also exhibited excerpts from various media organizations discussing the alleged contract between Guaidó and Silvercorp.^[91][93]

Around the middle of 2019, Maduro stated there was a "plan ... to get 32 mercenaries into Venezuela to kill me and to kill Venezuelan revolutionary leaders".^[10] After news of the event broke, Maduro was explicit about the level of insider knowledge his government had, saying in his first public appearance: "We knew everything: what they were talking about, what they ate, what they drank, what they didn't drink, who financed them."^[90][94] According to The Washington Post, a "senior opposition official called the Alcalá-Goudreau plan 'the worst-kept secret in Venezuela'.^[10]

According to McClatchy and Goudreau, officials within the Trump administration had advance knowledge of the plan^[36][95] while The Wall Street Journal said that the CIA monitored and knew about the plot.^[33] The United States denied involvement and when asked about its knowledge by The Wall Street Journal, the CIA deferred comments to the White House, which said it did not have direct roles in the operation.^[33][10] The Colombian government said it first had knowledge of the plot after its authorities captured weapons destined for the operation and following the detention of Alcalá, though the Venezuelan opposition said that Colombian intelligence and high-level officials knew of the plot for months.^[10] In an audio recording, members of the Venezuelan opposition are heard discussing that President of Colombia Álvaro Uribe opposed any cooperation with Alcalá.^[10]

Final preparations, Associated Press article: April–May 2020

By the time of the landing attempt, many of the dissidents had abandoned their camps following the arrest of Alcalá, investigations by Colombian authorities, and the growing pandemic;^[4] because Goudreau's promises had failed to materialize; and due to rumors that Maduro had infiltrated the operation.^[10] The Guardian suggested that Goudreau went ahead with the operation despite its poor planning because he was seeking the US$15 million reward that the US government placed on Maduro.^[51]

In November 2020, the Miami Herald published an article based on an interview with an anonymous source known by the nickname Cacique, "a Venezuelan rebel officer who operated the communications center for the failed incursion from an undisclosed city in the United States"^[88] and was a CARIVE member and Nieto confidant.^[38] He stated that the Maduro government had offered a reward for Colina, and two to three days before the operation, a member of the group, who directed a faction of five moles, "sold the exact landing coordinates shortly before departure", seeking to collect on the reward.^[88] According to the report, Maduro intelligence knew the exact coordinates where the invaders would attempt their landing, and were expecting their arrival.^[88]

As the planned operation approached, a new commander moved the group into the arid area on the Guajira Peninsula of northern Colombia, with one of the dissidents saying that the group spent their time hiding and held conviction for their cause of overthrowing Maduro.^[38]

The AP published a 1 May 2020 article written by Joshua Goodman about Goudreau, the plan and its history, and the training camps, writing that the scheme was "far-fetched" and that people who knew him believed he was "in way over his head".^[6] The article suggested that the Maduro government may have known of the plan since late-March 2020, but certainly knew by 1 May.^[6] Maduro confirmed that he knew of the plan by the evening of 1 May, and said that it had been initially planned for 10 March, but postponed due to the COVID-19 pandemic.^[94]

Objectives included securing the General Directorate of Military Counterintelligence headquarters, neutralizing the Presidential Honor Guard at Miraflores Palace and securing an airfield, where they would extract Maduro, who was code named "Jackpot".^[54] Silvercorp would then stay to maintain humanitarian aid distribution while Goudreau would arrive in Caracas following the operation's success.^[54] When asked why his troops would land at one of Venezuela's most fortified coastlines, twenty miles from Caracas and next to the country's biggest airport, he cited as inspiration the Battle of Gaugamela, won by Alexander the Great, who had "struck deep into the heart of the enemy".^[96] During the event, Goudreau gave an interview by telephone from Florida to an AP reporter.^[3] Goudreau said that his intention in launching the raid was to "introduce a catalyst", acknowledging that it is impractical to believe "60 guys can come in and topple a regime".^[3] Despite the long odds, he expressed his belief that "60 guys can go in and inspire the military and police to flip and join in the liberation of their country".^[3]

Landing attempt

 

Venezuelan authorities monitoring the Caribbean coast during the Bolivarian Shield exercises

The boats launched from a beach in the Guajira Peninsula of northern Colombia, on 2 May 2020 in two waves, beginning with a pilot boat carrying 10–11 men, and followed by a larger boat carrying 46–47, including two former United States Army Special Forces members employed as private military contractors for Silvercorp.^{[6][38][88][52]} The force traveled about 400 miles (640 km) through the ocean, passing Aruba and Curaçao, planning to meet with other insurgents stationed inland that possessed weapons caches and fighting vehicles.^[54] The two boats eventually lost contact with one another.^[38]

The Maduro administration first acknowledged a "maritime invasion" at 07:30 a.m. on Sunday, 3 May 2020, in an announcement from Interior Minister Néstor Reverol.^[6] According to their version, a firefight ensued when the occupants of the first boat, led by Colina, shot at the Venezuelan authorities who were waiting for them to reach the shore at Macuto, La Guaira.^{[52][88][89][97]} Opposition lawmaker Wilmer Azuaje and journalist Sebastiana Barráez said that Venezuelan authorities had advance knowledge of the landing and that they staged the firefight, at odds with the government's account^[88] that the confrontation began after Colina started shooting.^[73][97]

The first boat was sunk by Venezuelan security forces in the pre-dawn hours of Sunday, 3 May 2020, near Macuto, La Guaira.^[52][88][89] After initially reporting that eight individuals were killed and two captured, Venezuelan spokespersons revised the number of deceased to six.^[8] One of the men killed was the first boat's leader Colina, who was alleged to have directed a training camp in Riohacha.^[7][88][98]

In the afternoon of 3 May – after the first boat's arrival at Macuto and before the second boat was intercepted – Goudreau released a video to Twitter, appearing next to the CARIVE leader Nieto, in which he dubbed the plot Operation Gideon, and announced that "[a]t 1700 hours, a daring amphibious raid was launched from the border of Colombia deep into the heart of Caracas".^[6] Goudreau said that the operation was ongoing and that "units have been activated in the south, east and west of Venezuela".^[6][52] Goudreau later acknowledged misleading the media with false information to allow time for the men to escape.^[36] In the video, Nieto said that the objective of the operation was to detain the leadership of the Maduro government and free political prisoners.^[6]

The occupants of the second boat were reportedly destined for an area near Caracas where they would set up a camp under the supervision of Berry and Denman in preparation for an invasion force they hoped would attract disaffected Venezuelan soldiers looking to join the efforts to remove Maduro from power.^[38] According to a source close to the mission, the plan was for the men to spend a few days in safe houses before moving covertly to Caracas.^[52] A survivor of the second boat who managed to evade capture told VICE News that his group had received word from the operation's leadership that the mission was a failure and that they should attempt to escape into the mountains.^[38] An individual on the second boat later reported that the craft had experienced engine problems and had difficulty navigating due to excessive weight,^[88] with the boat's canopy, the uniforms of soldiers and even other gear being thrown overboard in an attempt to make it to shore.^[99] Goudreau told the Washington Post that he last spoke to the crew on 4 May around noon and that he engaged in efforts to "secure a vessel out of Aruba to 'extract' them".^[89] Most of the men on the second boat were dropped off along the shoreline to attempt escape from Venezuelan authorities, but Sequea, Denman, and Berry remained on board, possibly with the intention of seeking refuge in international waters.^[38][52][54]

Those remaining in the second boat were intercepted off the coast of Chuao by helicopters and Coast Guard boats, and did not put up any resistance.^{[38][94][100]} Eight men, including Sequea, Berry, Denman, and Josnars Adolfo Baduel, son of former Chávez Defense Minister Raúl Baduel, were captured from the second boat.^[94][101] Two other individuals were detained in Puerto Cruz later that day.^[6][101]

 

Equipment and identity documents allegedly brought into Venezuela during the incursion

The Venezuelan military reported that the "mercenaries" had "war materials" on their boats.^[102] The Maduro government reported that the items seized included vehicles for mounting machine guns, weapons, and uniforms embroidered with an American flag.^[103] Speaking on national television that day, Reverol said that the Venezuelan military's defensive operation was ongoing, and would be for several days.^[102] By 15 May, the Maduro government reported that it had arrested 39 other defectors who had attempted to flee Venezuela, reporting a total of 91 arrested in the plot.^[11] All but four of those who left the Guajira Peninsula were killed, arrested during the attempted landing, or captured in subsequent search operations.^[88]

Aftermath

Different versions of the narrative led to questions about the operation.^{[22][52][104][b]}

Maduro's Attorney General Tarek William Saab announced that 25,000 national troops were mobilized^[106] in a Venezuelan military mission named "Bolivarian Shield" (Spanish: Escudo Bolivariano) to protect the country from similar attempts.^[94] Saab requested that the Supreme Tribunal of Justice declare Guaidó's political party, Popular Will, a terrorist group due to the attempted sea incursion.^[107] Guaidó responded to the charges, stating that Maduro defended "irregular groups" like the National Liberation Army and the Revolutionary Armed Forces of Colombia.^[107]"

The Venezuelan Operational Zone of Integral Defense (Zodi) of La Guaira announced that Russian Special Operations Forces were assisting Venezuelan soldiers with surveillance from unmanned aerial vehicles, but it was determined that the equipment could not be operated in the region. The announcement was later deleted.^[108][109]

Nieto, one of the organizers of the operation, said on 7 May that the events were only an "advanced tactical reconnaissance" and that CARIVE had 3,000 troops.^[110]

Indictments and arrests

 

Detainees in prone position in custody of Venezuelan authorities

As of 21 May 2020 66 arrests took place and 99 arrests warrants had been issued, 63 of which remained outstanding.^[2]

Following 4 May, more individuals were arrested further inland with caches of weapons, ammunition, communication devices and technical pickup trucks with mounted machine guns.^[54] On 4 May, Maduro said Venezuelan forces had detained 13 "mercenaries", including two Americans working with Goudreau: Berry and Denman.^[34][89] Goudreau said that eight of his soldiers had been captured on 4 May, the two Americans and six Venezuelans, and that an unknown number had been captured on 3 May.^[111]

Maduro stated that "dozens" of "mercenaries" had been captured on 5 May.^[112] Another three individuals were arrested on 6 May.^[9] Adolfo Baduel, son of former Chávez Defense Minister, Raúl Baduel, was among the detainees and said that the two arrested Americans were linked to the Trump administration.^[7][113] By 6 May, the Defense Minister announced an additional three arrests via his Twitter account, publishing a photo of the purported detainees with pixelated faces on their knees with their wrists zip-tied together without disclosing the names or any other additional details regarding the accused.^[9]

Nicolás Maduro held a virtual press conference that day broadcast on state television in which he presented portions of Denman's interrogation,^[7][20] described by Neuman as a "propaganda-style interrogation".^[22] In the video, Denman states that his instructions were to seize Simón Bolívar International Airport in Maiquetía and fly Maduro to the United States, which Maduro cited as proof that the orders came directly from United States President Donald Trump. The video shows Denman answering questions that were asked in English, also indicating that he was hired through Goudreau and that they trained 50 combatants in Colombia in January 2020.^[20] Neumann wrote that, when asked "Who commands [Goudreau]?", Denman rolled his eyes when answering – a gesture that "seemed intended to contradict his words" when he replied it was Trump.^[22] Mattos, the Navy SEAL who had visited the rebel training camps in Colombia but was not involved in the operation, made the same observation, noting that it may have been a covert signal, and that "special operation soldiers are trained to find creative ways to discredit any propaganda videos they are forced to make if captured by the enemy" and that the odd eye movement was "a clear sign from Luke that he is being forced".^[114] Berry was also subject to interrogation which was videotaped and presented in parts on state television on 7 May, during a press release presented by the Jorge Rodríguez.^[115][116]

An additional interrogation video depicting Denman in an orange jumpsuit was aired on state television on 18 May 2020.^[117] In the video, Denman indicates that his objective in embarking on the operation, as relayed by Goudreau, was to arrive in Colombia to train Venezuelans, accompany them to Venezuela for the landing, and once the Venezuelan dissidents' objectives had been achieved, "put Maduro on a plane", and provide support at the airport in order that humanitarian aid could arrive.^[117]

Durán, his brother and seven other individuals were arrested in Venezuela on 24 May 2020.^[42] Durán faced charges of arms trafficking, foreign conspiracy, rebellion, terrorism and treason. <^[86]

The Colombian government informed that on 2 September it had arrested four Venezuelans related to Operation Gedeon. Óscar Pérez had denounced in 2017 that both Rayder Alexander Russo (alias "Pico") and Osman Alejandro Tabosky, both arrested by Colombian officials and the latter also accused as intellectual author of the 2018 Caracas drone attack, were "infiltrated agents" in the resistance movement against Maduro.^[118]

United States federal authorities opened an investigation on Goudreau for arms trafficking.^[119]

In the weeks following the apprehension of Luke Denman and Airan Berry, Denman's brother, an attorney, took on the task of advocating for the release of both.^[68][67]

Criminal charges, extradition requests and sentences

Maduro's Attorney General, Saab, announced on 8 May^[2] that Denman and Berry would face charges for terrorism, conspiracy, "illicit trafficking of weapons of war" and "(criminal) association" – charges which carry a maximum prison sentence of 25 to 30 years.^[120] In addition, his office issued arrest warrants for Goudreau, Rendón, and Vergara for their role in the "design, financing, and execution" of the foiled plot.^[1][121] After Denman and Berry admitted to "conspiracy, association (to commit crimes), illicit trafficking of war weapons and terrorism" a Venezuelan court sentenced both on 6 August 2020 to 20 years in prison.^[122][123]

Saab announced on 15 May 2020 an arrest warrant against Popular Will politician Yon Goicoechea. Goicoechea rejected the accusations of any involvement with Operation Gideon, and accused Maduro's administration of paying and leading the uprising attempt to victimize itself and "persecute political dissent".^[2]

On 16 May 2020, according to a press release published by the Supreme Tribunal of Justice of Venezuela, several trial courts dedicated to terrorism-related crimes ordered that some 40 individuals alleged to have participated in the raid be remanded to preventive detention.^[124][125] Antonio Sequea Torres was also in pretrial confinement and charged with commission of aggravated intentional homicide in connection with his alleged attempt to assassinate Maduro.^[124][125] The Supreme Tribunal of Justice also indicated that most of those involved in the operation are alleged to have committed the crimes of treason, rebellion, arms trafficking, criminal conspiracy, and colluding with a foreign government.^[124] The mother of one of the accused, interviewed by Venezuelan newspaper El Pitazo, demanded assurance that her son was alive after receiving a phone call from her son requesting his brother's telephone number "so that they would stop torturing him".^[124]

According to Berry's videotaped statement, Antonio Sequea Torres and the drug trafficker Elkin Javier López, better known as Doble Rueda [transl. Two-Wheeled], also referred to as la silla [transl. the chair] – met multiple times during the planning period of the operation to coordinate logistics.^[126][127] The estate of López Torres in the Colombian Guajira is alleged to be the point of departure for the two boats involved in the raid.^[126][127] The Valledupar-based López Torres was arrested in December 2019 and his extradition was requested by the United States.^[128][129]

In May 2021, three Venezuelans were sentenced in Colombia to six years in prison for their relation to the operation.^[130]

Investigation of interception and deaths

Statements made to the Miami Herald by Cacique, who was involved in the operation, information about the exact landing was sold to Maduro intelligence a few days before the attempted landing. National Assembly deputy Wilmer Azuaje – president of the Venezuelan Observatory for the Protection of Human Rights^[131] and Guaidó's coordinator for expanding complaints of human rights violations^[132] – alleges that Sequea Torres "was the military infiltrator" who provided the information.^[73]

According to the Maduro administration, authorities awaiting the boat's arrival were fired upon by occupants of the first boat, led by Colina.^[52][88][89] In a press conference on the morning of 3 May, Diosdado Cabello reported that the early-morning exchange resulted in at least eight deaths and two arrests, indicating that it was unknown whether others drowned or swam away.^{[102][133][134]} Venezuelan Defense Minister Vladimir Padrino López later said that the first boat had been sunk by the navy and the military sent ships to look for survivors.^[134] According to Venezuelan Information Minister Jorge Rodríguez, the second boat had changed course after eight occupants of the first boat were killed in a 45-minute shootout with Venezuelan armed forces.^[100]

Reporters from The Miami Herald and McClatchy DC stated that "loyalists of Venezuela leader Nicolás Maduro infiltrated the ranks of the coup plotters, leading to a massacre of some invaders".^[95][88] Barráez and Azuaje – who investigated the incident in connection with a human rights complaint submitted to the International Criminal Court (ICC) – accused Venezuelan authorities of torturing and executing the six men in the first boat, including Colina.^[88][30] Barráez wrote that when Sequea took "control of the camps" after Alcalá's arrest, he "led fifty soldiers into an ambush" and that he facilitated identification to FAES by forcing all of the other men to shave their heads except his brother-in-law, the Americans, and "his most trusted men".^[31] Azuaje argued the deaths were "extrajudicial executions", said that "everything was rigged" and referred to the event as the "Macuto massacre" comparing it to the 2018 El Junquito raid, in which Óscar Pérez and his men were killed after reportedly offering to surrender.^{[131][135][136]} According to Rendón, the operation was compromised for months and intelligence gathered by the Maduro government allowed the Venezuelan armed forces to set the group up for an ambush, to create a "montage" of the events.^[137] Cacique alleged that "the only witnesses to the execution[s]" were held under "extreme security measures".^[88]

The report submitted to the ICC in October 2020 included forensic photographs reportedly taken by the Venezuelan forensic police, CICPC; it argues that there was not an armed confrontation but that the insurgents had been set up, tortured and extrajudicially executed.^{[88][136][131][135]} Azuaje stated that the original photos from the operation,^[136] and information about the bodies, came from anonymous chavista officials.^[138] The opposition official also submitted the report to the Human Rights Commission of the European Parliament.^[132] The report identifies the six former military^[139] dead as Colina along with César Andrés Perales Sequea, Anderson Smith Araque Portilla, Jean Carlo Castro Gutiérrez, Fabián Rodríguez Salazar, and José Roberto Abreu Facúndez.^[73] Maduro stated he ordered all insurgents be taken alive.^[140]

Goudreau lawsuit

In the final days of April 2020, Rendón was contacted by Silvercorp's legal advisors demanding a payment of US$1.45 million; The Washington Post wrote that Guaidó's officials reacted to the demands in fear, believing they were being blackmailed with the threat of the canceled plans being revealed to the public.^[5] Goudreau said that the Trump administration had knowledge of the operation and that the plotters held meetings in the Trump Doral west of Miami. Goudreau sued Rendón in October 2020 for a $1.4 million breach of contract.^[36] According to Neuman, Goudreau's lawsuit says "that he met three times with an obscure Trump official to discuss obtaining a license to export weapons", and that he believed "the plan had U.S. government approval" and Guaidó officials never told him to end his operation.^[22]

Reactions

Domestic

The event was described as a propaganda coup^[43] and "public relations victory" for the Maduro administration that negatively affected public opinion of Guaidó's administration.^[17][141]

Maduro administration

Maduro stated that plans included his possible assassination.^[140]

The Maduro administration accused the United States and Colombian governments of masterminding the attack, which both denied.^[106][142] Goudreau has also denied receiving any help for his operation from US and Colombian authorities.^[143] Maduro's Vice President Delcy Rodríguez called Goudreau "a supremacist fanatic" and warned that "the Venezuelan women are waiting for you, for free, but with deep homeland passion."^[144]

Maduro's Foreign Minister Arreaza criticized foreign governments and international organizations for their "deafening silence in the face of the mercenary aggression against Venezuela" and said that "the same people who always condemn us immediately based on biased or false information, today remain silent in the face of such a serious and full case of evidence." He added that "all those involved in the armed aggression against Venezuela confess that they trained in Colombia, with the knowledge of the Bogotá government and the financing of drug traffickers from that country."^[145]

Guaidó administration and opposition

 

Guaidó's General Strategist J. J. Rendón, who resigned due to his interactions with Silvercorp

Guaidó accused the Maduro administration of "trying to create a state of apparent confusion, an effort to hide what's happening in Venezuela", citing recent events like the gasoline shortages, the Guanare prison riot, a violent gang battle in Caracas, and the COVID-19 pandemic in Venezuela.^[142] Guaidó also demanded that the human rights of the detainees be respected.^[146] Iván Simonovis, security and intelligence commissioner for the Guaidó administration, stated that the events in Macuto would be used by the Maduro government as a pretext to harass opponents and intensify repression, saying that Guaidó's administration would investigate the events and clarify its details.^[147]

The opposition political party Justice First demanded that Guaidó immediately dismiss the officials involved with the plot and charged that they "used his government's name for individual purposes".^[148] Julio Borges, Guaidó's foreign minister, called for the dismissal of all officials related to the plot, stating "we worry that energies are put into the creation of a bureaucratic caste and not into political change." Rendon and Vergara resigned on 11 May, with Guaidó thanking the two for "dedication and commitment to Venezuela".^[149] Important members of López's Popular Will party resigned from their positions in the month following the incident, saying that López's strong actions and policies hurt the efforts of the opposition in whole.^[13]

NGOs

The human rights NGO PROVEA asked about the well-being of the people arrested in Macuto and in Chuao and indicated that Tarek William Saab, and the Ombudsman appointed by Maduro, Alfredo Ruiz, would be responsible for possible forced disappearances or torture of the detainees, while stressing that it would only support and promote peaceful and constitutional means that lead to the "restoration of democracy in the country".^[150] Maduro accused PROVEA of being "financed by the CIA" and giving coverage to "terrorists" as a response, accusations that PROVEA rejected.^[151] Human Rights Watch criticized Maduro for alleging that PROVEA had connections to the United States Central Intelligence Agency after the organization called for due process of the captured individuals.^[2] Human Rights Watch wrote: "An international community that's closely watching what happens in Venezuela needs to send the message loud and clear: subjecting human rights defenders to politically motivated prosecution, detention or other abuses would be crossing a line for which those responsible will have to answer".^[2]

The Futuro Presente Foundation was accused by Maduro's administration of financing the operation. Futuro Presente categorically rejected the accusations of the participation of the organization and any of its members, said they were being persecuted, asked for it to end, and said that it was based on "completely false and unfounded accusations".^[152]

International

•   Colombia: The Colombian government rejected the accusations, calling them an attempt by the "dictatorial regime of Nicolás Maduro" to divert attention from problems in the country.^[153] President Duque said that he did not sponsor invasions or tricks in response to the accusations and stated "I do things up front because I am a defender of democracy."^[154]
•   Russia: The Russian Foreign Ministry said that United States' denial was "unconvincing" and pointed to earlier warnings made by the Trump administration that "all options" are on the table, including the possibility of military action. It also said that the actions of the mercenaries deserve "unequivocal and decisive condemnation".^[155]
  • On 20 May 2020, Russia convoked a virtual open debate of the United Nations Security Council (UNSC) for the purpose of urging the members of the council to condemn the attack as a threat to peace in Venezuela and to security in the region.^[156] The United States doubled down on its previous denials of any involvement in the operation, and accused the Maduro administration of using the event as a pretext to persecute political dissidents and distract from other problems in Venezuela. Russia reasserted its assessment that the statements by the United States government that it had no knowledge of the operation were dubious in light of the attackers' plans to fly their captives to the United States. Russia's U.N. ambassador, Dmitry Polyansky, asked how does the attack correlate with the "all options are on the table" messages.^[156]
•   United States: Various US officials (including President Trump) have denied the accusations made by the Maduro administration.^[142]
  • President Trump said that the incident "has nothing to do with our government".^[21][142] Speaking on Fox News, Trump said "If I wanted to go into Venezuela, I wouldn't make a secret about it" and said that the operation would be called an "invasion" if he sends an army into Venezuela.^[114]
  • Secretary of State Mike Pompeo said that there was no US government direct involvement in this operation and added: "[If] we'd have been involved, it would have gone differently." Regarding the detention of two Americans, Pompeo said that the US will use "every tool" available to secure the return of Americans if they are being held in Venezuela.^[157]
  • Secretary of Defense Mark Esper told reporters at the Pentagon that "the United States government had nothing to do with what's happened in Venezuela in the last few days."^[158]
  • A State Department spokesperson said that the Maduro administration has been consistent in its use of misinformation to shift focus from its mismanagement of Venezuela. It also said that there was "little reason to believe anything that comes out of the former regime".^[96]

Characterization

The Maduro administration described the operation as an attempted coup with the goal of assassinating Maduro,^[159][160] which was perpetrated by "terrorists" in a plot coordinated by Colombia and the United States.^[142][56] Initially, Interior Minister Nestor Reverol called the event an attempted "maritime invasion" of the country, carried out by "terrorist mercenaries."^[6] Defense Minister Vladimir Padrino López later said the incident should not be characterized as an "invasion," opting instead to describe it as an "infiltration by sea" that was "a very well-planned military operation, prepared in foreign territory."^[161]

Goudreau referred to the operation as a "daring amphibious raid" by "Venezuelans trying to restore their democracy",^[96] labeling them "freedom fighters".^[100] He also said that he green-lit the operation because he thought it would spur further unrest against the Maduro government.^[33]

Guaidó supporters called it an ambush orchestrated and staged by Maduro;^[88][137] according to The Washington Post, the Maduro administration stated that infiltration by its intelligence agents led to the ambush.^[89] Guaidó and his supporters also characterized the event as a possible false flag.^{[54][88][105]} Colombian President Duque, described by The Wall Street Journal as an "ardent Maduro foe", mentioned speculation of a false flag, saying the operation was "allegedly promoted and financed by the dictatorial regime of Nicolás Maduro".^[105] The Wall Street Journal reported that Trump administration officials had stated that "it could have been a false flag organized by Mr. Maduro's regime to score propaganda points".^[13] Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung wrote that the plot "sounds crazy and joins a series of other alleged coup attempts and assassinations whose backgrounds were so contradictory that they were dismissed as inventions for the purpose of propaganda", though notes that the efforts overall "were real", citing the interviews regarding the operation.^[162] Conspiracy theories have arisen due to the lack of answers about key aspects of the operation.^[54]

U.S. Defense Secretary Mark Esper referred to the event as "what's happened in Venezuela in the last few days," and a U.S. official familiar with the matter labeled the operation as poorly organized and the fighters as "soldiers of fortune."^[100]

Media sources, analysts and individuals used terms like murky^[24][104] and bizarre^[6][52] to describe the plot and events. Sources varied between describing the anti-Maduro plot^[40] as: an operation^[163] referred to by its code name Gideon;^{[15][14][141][56][164]} a failed incursion, infiltration, insurrection, invasion or raid;^{[22][14][165][166][163]} an assassination attempt^{[167][168][169][170]} and an attempted landing,^[15] or coup.^{[36][54][48][52]} Some sources criticized the poor planning and execution,^[26][171] and described the operation as more incompetent than the 1961 failed Bay of Pigs Invasion of Cuba,^[164] with some referring to it as the "Bay of Piglets".^[52][141] Fairness & Accuracy in Reporting writer Joshua Cho criticized the corporate media's coverage of the word mercenary and coverage overall as dismissive or misleading and biased in favor of regime change.^[172]

Villa writes that Operation Gideon was an "attempt of some Venezuelan military and civilian dissidents (mainly exiled in Colombia) and three members of a US private security force to infiltrate Venezuela".^[14] Neuman,^[22] DeFronzo,^[173] Vox,^[174] and Europa Press^[175] said that the goal of the operation was to install Guaidó as president.

See also

•  Venezuela portal

• Colombia–Venezuela relations
• Golpe Azul
• Machurucuto raid

Notes

1. Colombian intelligence sources who later arrested other suspects also stated that Maduro double-agents had infiltrated the camps.^[32]
2. Neuman wrote, "But there were too many questions without answers ... was the point to create a paper trail? Did someone want something to hold over Guaidó's head? Or was someone looking to undermine Guaidó and make him look foolish and reckless? Or was it simply what it appeared to be – an incredibly naive and badly executed effort to hire a mercenary force to solve the problem that the opposition hadn't been able to solve on its own?"^[22]
   * The BBC questioned: "Did they know Nicolas Maduro's government had intelligence about the conspiracy? Venezuelans are some of the most connected people on Earth, but apparently only those in charge had access to cell phones. One source says the commander, Antonio Sequea, was aware of Cabello's TV expose and other comments made by Nicolas Maduro's ministers about the conspiracy, but he assured supporters in the US he had everything under control. Did Jordan Goudreau know the operation was compromised?"^[52]
   * A July 2020 article in The Washington Post states: "There's no question Maduro had moles inside the murky conspiracy ... Yet Maduro's government also alleges that Operation Gideon amounted to a genuine attempt to kill him."^[104] The Post article also stated that "a senior U.S. official who spoke on the condition of anonymity" said: 'The situation of Franklin Durán is puzzling' and 'creates a series of questions about what the regime knew and when they knew it'."^[104]
   * The Wall Street Journal wrote that: "The ease with which Venezuela put down the uprising has stoked speculation that the mission was a false-flag operation organized by Caracas ... "^[105]
   * The Associated Press mentions that court filings by Alcalá "raise fresh questions about what the Trump administration knew ... " ^[43]

References

1. "El régimen de Nicolás Maduro imputó 'por terrorismo y conspiración' a dos estadounidenses y emitió otras 25 órdenes de captura por las incursiones en Venezuela" [Maduro regime charged two Americans with 'terrorism and conspiracy' and issued 25 more arrest warrants for the incursions in Venezuela] (in Spanish). Infobae. 8 May 2020. Retrieved 9 May 2020.
2. "Venezuelan Human Rights Group Under Attack". Human Rights Watch. 8 May 2020. Retrieved 22 May 2020.
3. Goodman, Joshua; Smith, Scott; Lee, Matthew; Herschaft, Randy (6 May 2020). "Sources: US investigating ex-Green Beret for Venezuela raid". Caracas, Washington, New York: Associated Press. Retrieved 11 May 2020.
4. Goodman, Joshua (1 May 2020). "Ex-Green Beret led failed attempt to oust Venezuela's Maduro". Associated Press. Retrieved 5 May 2020.
5. Faiola, Anthony (6 May 2020). . The Washington Post. Archived from the original on 8 May 2020. Retrieved 7 May 2020.
6. Fiorella, Giancarlo (5 May 2020). "The Invasion of Venezuela, Brought To You By Silvercorp USA". Bellingcat. Retrieved 5 May 2020.
7. "Una supuesta confesión televisada y otros detalles de la "fallida incursión armada" en Venezuela por la que se detuvo a dos estadounidenses" [A supposed televised confession and other details regarding the "failed armed incursion" in Venezuela, over which two Americans were detained]. BBC News Mundo (in Spanish). 7 May 2020. Retrieved 11 May 2020.
8. "Venezuela 'failed coup plot': What we know so far". Al Jazeera. 6 May 2020. from the original on 26 December 2020.
9. Mozo Zambrano, Reynaldo (6 May 2020). "Padrino López anuncia captura de tres "mercenarios" en la carretera El Junquito-Carayaca" [Padrino Lopez announces the capture of three "mercenaries" on the El Junquito-Carayaca Highway]. Efecto Cocuyo (in European Spanish). Retrieved 6 May 2020.
10. Faiola, Anthony; Boburg, Shawn; Herrero, Ana Vanessa (10 May 2020). "Venezuela raid: How an ex-Green Beret and a defecting general planned to capture Maduro". The Washington Post. Also at ProQuest 2400242453
11. "Venezuela verkündet Festnahme von 39 "Deserteuren"". Der Standard (in Austrian German). 15 May 2020. Retrieved 20 October 2023.
12. Corrales 2020, p. 39.
13. Vyas, Kejal; Forero, Juan (26 June 2020). . Wall Street Journal. Archived from the original on 27 June 2021. Retrieved 17 September 2023.
14. Villa 2022, sec. "Political dimension under Maduro government: expanding the autonomy of the armed forces".
15. Corrales 2020, pp. 41–42.
16. Mijares 2022, p. 231.
17. Olmo, Guillermo D. (19 May 2020). "Cómo afecta al liderazgo de Juan Guaidó en la oposición venezolana el fracaso de la Operación Gedeón contra Nicolás Maduro" [How the failure of Operation Gedeón against Nicolás Maduro affects Juan Guaidó's leadership in the Venezuelan opposition]. BBC Mundo (in Spanish). Retrieved 21 May 2020.
18. DeFronzo 2021, p. 455.
19. DeFronzo 2021, p. 456.
20. Ellsworth, Brian; Berwick, Angus (6 May 2020). "Detained American claims he plotted Maduro's capture in Venezuela TV statement". Reuters. Retrieved 11 September 2023.
21. Daniels, Joe Parkin (5 May 2020). . The Guardian. Reuters. Archived from the original on 5 May 2020. Retrieved 6 May 2020.
22. Neuman 2022, pp. 273–279, Chapter 30: "The Screw-up at Macuto".
23. Freeze, Colin; Dickson, Janice (5 May 2020). "A Canadian-American military man, a failed Venezuela coup and a Twitter video". The Globe and Mail. Toronto and Ottawa. Retrieved 6 May 2020.
24. Schapiro, Rich; Saliba, Emmanuelle (8 May 2020). "The 'mind-blowing' story of the ex-Green Beret who tried to oust Venezuela's Maduro". NBC News. Retrieved 27 September 2023.
25. Ensor, Josie (6 May 2020). . The Telegraph. Archived from the original on 7 May 2020. Retrieved 7 May 2020.
26. Stieb, Matt (5 May 2020). . New York magazine. Archived from the original on 8 May 2020. Retrieved 17 May 2020.
27. "Venezuela detains two US citizens over speedboat incursion". BBC News. 5 May 2020. Retrieved 5 May 2020.
28. Lafuente, Javier; Manetto, Francesco (16 May 2020). "Mitos, egos y torpeza: anatomía de un complot disparatado en Venezuela" [Myths, egos, and ineptitude: anatomy of ludicrous plot in Venezuela]. El País (in Spanish).
29. "Antonio Sequea habría sido infiltrado del régimen en fallida Operación Gedeón" [Antonio Sequea was infiltrated by the regime in the failed Operation Gideon] (in Spanish). NTN24. 9 May 2020. Retrieved 17 September 2023.
30. Barráez, Sebastiana (2 August 2020). [Step by step, how Operation Gideon was created and ended with the ambush of the Venezuelan military]. Infobae (in Spanish). Archived from the original on 3 August 2020. Retrieved 4 October 2023.
31. Barráez, Sebastiana (11 October 2020). "Las pruebas que dejan al descubierto lo que el Servicio Bolivariano de Inteligencia y Diosdado Cabello pretenden ocultar con la Operación Gedeón" [The evidence that reveals what the Bolivarian Intelligence Service and Diosdado Cabello intend to hide with Operation Gedeón]. Infobae (in Spanish). Retrieved 17 September 2023.
32. "Detenidos por la operación Gedeón contra Nicolás Maduro serían agentes dobles" [Those arrested for the Gedeón operation against Nicolás Maduro would be double agents]. El Espectador (in Spanish). 3 September 2020. Retrieved 3 November 2023.
33. Forero, Juan; Vyas, Kejal (10 May 2020). "Poorly Organized and Barely Hidden, Venezuela Invasion Was Doomed to Fail". The Wall Street Journal. ProQuest 2400243484. the plan, which was widely known to former Venezuelan soldiers who considered participating, Venezuelan opposition figures, senior Colombian intelligence officials and even the CIA, which monitored their activities in La Guajira
34. Smith, Scott; Goodman, Joshua (4 May 2020). "Venezuela: 2 US 'mercenaries' among those nabbed after raid". Associated Press. Retrieved 10 May 2020.
35. "Operación suicida en Venezuela". Semana (in Spanish). 10 May 2020. Retrieved 20 October 2023.
36. Delgado, Antonio M.; Hall, Kevin G.; Dasgupta, Shirsho; Wieder, Ben (30 October 2020). . Miami Herald. Archived from the original on 30 October 2020. Retrieved 10 September 2023.
37. "Exclusive – Blackwater founder's latest sales pitch: mercenaries for Venezuela". Reuters. 30 April 2019. Retrieved 14 June 2023.
38. Makuch, Ben (26 October 2021). "MAGA, the CIA, and Silvercorp: The Bizarre Backstory of the World's Most Disastrous Coup". Vice magazine. from the original on 26 October 2021. Retrieved 14 June 2023.
39. Oliver Craviotto, Marta (11 January 2021). "Yacsy Álvarez in her own words". Miami Herald.
40. "3 Venezuelans plead guilty for aiding anti-Maduro plot". Associated Press. 20 April 2021. Retrieved 14 June 2023.
41. ""Clíver Alcalá siempre estuvo en contacto con la DNI": Yacsy Álvarez sobre la Operación Gedeón". El Espectador (in Spanish). 1 February 2021. Retrieved 14 June 2023.
42. "Failed Maduro coup leader flew on pro-govt magnate's plane". Associated Press. 20 April 2021. Retrieved 14 June 2023. Durán over two decades has had numerous business ties with the socialist government of Venezuela, making him an odd choice to help a band of would-be-mercenaries overthrow Maduro, the handpicked successor of the late Chávez
43. "Alleged Maduro co-conspirator says CIA knew about coup plans". Associated Press. 29 January 2022. Retrieved 14 June 2023.
44. Schapiro, Rich (16 May 2020). "Ex-Green Beret captured in Venezuela believed U.S. backed overthrow plot: family". NBC News. Retrieved 18 May 2020.
45. Rendón, J. J. (7 May 2020). "J. J. Rendón habla sobre la Operación Gedeón" [J. J. Rendón talks about Operation Gideon] (Interview). Interviewed by Fernando del Rincón. CNN en Español (Conclusiones). 'Acuérdate que el gobierno legítimo del presidente Guaidó no controla una fuerza policial en el país, por lo tanto se analizan todos los escenarios: alianzas con otros países, acciones propias, alzas de personas desde adentro, de los militares que están allá, uso eventual de actores que estaban fuera, militares retirados. Todos esos escenarios, como bien lo dijo el presidente: estamos analizando cosas por encima y por debajo de la mesa, se hicieron. De ahí a que se llegara a un acuerdo efectivo con este señor [Jordan Goudreau] al margen de la firma de ese acuerdo, no se le dio nunca luz verde' afirmó J.J. Rendón.
    ['Remember that the legitimate government of President Guaidó does not control a police force in the country, therefore all scenarios are analyzed: alliances with other countries, own actions, recruitment of people from within, of the military who are there, eventual use of actors who were outside, retired soldiers. All those scenarios, as the president said: analyzing things above and below the table, were done. From there, an effective agreement was reached with this man [Jordan Goudreau] apart from the signing of that agreement, it was never given the green light,' said J.J. Rendon.]
46. Amaya, Víctor (8 May 2020). "Esto es lo que dice el contrato firmado por estrategas de Guaidó y Silvercorp" [This is what the contract signed by Guaidó strategists and Silvercorp says] (in Spanish). Tal Cual.
47. Vasquez, Alex. . Bloomberg News. Archived from the original on 5 June 2020. Retrieved 14 May 2020. Documents released by Goudreau show what seems to be Guaidó's signature on a preliminary contract and a video in which he spoke with him at least once.
48. Ward, Alex (11 May 2020). "The 'ridiculous' failed coup attempt in Venezuela, explained". Vox. Retrieved 12 May 2020. plan to send two teams into Maracaibo and Caracas, extract Maduro from his presidential mansion, and install Guaidó as president.
49. "Presidente Guaidó: El montaje de la dictadura fue para generar victimización internacional y persecución interna" [President Guaidó: The dictator's set-up was to generate international victimization and internal persecution]. EVTV (in Spanish). 11 May 2020.
50. "Gobierno encargado de Venezuela alerta que régimen usa documento falso para intentar secuestrar al Presidente (e) Guaidó y desmiente firma de supuesto documento" [Acting government of Venezuela warns that the regime is using a false document to try to abduct President (pro tempore) Guaidó and denies alleged document]. Asamblea Nacional (in Spanish). 6 May 2020. Retrieved 12 May 2020.
51. Borger, Julian; Daniels, Joe Parkin; McGreal, Chris (8 May 2020). . The Guardian. Archived from the original on 8 May 2020. Retrieved 10 September 2023.
52. Pressly, Linda (30 July 2020). "'Bay of Piglets': A 'bizarre' plot to capture a president". BBC News. Retrieved 27 September 2023.
53. Martínez, Deisy (7 May 2020). "La estrategia insurreccional no funciona hoy en Venezuela, advierte Ricardo Sucre" [The insurrectional strategy does not work today in Venezuela, warns Ricardo Sucre]. Efecto Cocuyo (in Spanish). Retrieved 8 October 2023.
54. Borrell, Brendan; Solomon, Christopher (1 July 2020). "The Mercenary Who Botched a Maduro Coup Is Lying Low in Florida". Bloomberg.com. EBSCOhost 144342321. from the original on 1 July 2020. Retrieved 10 September 2023.
55. DeFronzo 2021, p. 457.
56. Mijares 2022, p. 234.
57. "Read the attachments to the General Services Agreement between the Venezuelan opposition and Silvercorp". The Washington Post. 7 May 2020. Retrieved 7 May 2020.
58. Fermín, Yeannaly (17 May 2020). "Operación Gedeón o Macutazo: Un desembarco de versiones incongruentes" [Operation Gideon or Macutazo: A landing of inconsistent stories]. Runrunes (in Spanish). Retrieved 17 May 2020.
59. . Miami Herald. 15 May 2020. Archived from the original on 20 May 2020. In an interview with CNN en Español, J. J. Rendón, a colorful Venezuelan campaign adviser and opposition strategist, said that on Oct. 16, 2019, Guaidó had signed a 'preliminary' contract with Silvercorp.
60. "Guaidó insiste en que falsificaron su firma en el contrato con Silvercorp". Noticiero Digital. 11 May 2020.
61. Itriago, Andreína (4 May 2020). "Guaidó se desvincula de presunta incursión militar contra Maduro" [Guaidó disassociates himself from alleged military incursion against Maduro]. El Tiempo (in Spanish). Retrieved 12 May 2020.
62. "El gobierno interino de Venezuela denunció que la dictadura de Nicolás Maduro intenta utilizar la Operación Gedeón para secuestrar a Juan Guaidó" [Interim government charged that Nicolas Maduro dictatorship is attempting to use Operation Gideon to abduct Juan Guaidó]. infobae (in Spanish). 6 May 2020. Retrieved 12 May 2020.
63. Inside the World's Most Spectacularly Failed Coup. Vice News. 27 October 2021. Event occurs at First 3:55–4:13, Second 7:00–8:15. Retrieved 1 October 2023.
64. Rempfer, Kyle (6 May 2020). "Here's the career info for the former Green Berets involved in Venezuela raid debacle". Military Times. from the original on 15 May 2020. Retrieved 17 May 2020.
65. Wood, David (10 May 2020). "Two Texans Are Accused of Trying to Invade Venezuela. Their Family Members Want Answers". Texas Monthly. Retrieved 11 May 2020.
66. Raddatz, Martha; Finnegan, Conor. "Families of Americans detained by Venezuela in failed raid plead for help". ABC News. Retrieved 18 May 2020.
67. Donati, Jessica (15 May 2020). "Ex-Green Beret Thought U.S. Supported Failed Venezuela Raid, Family Says". The Wall Street Journal. ProQuest 2402946776. Retrieved 17 May 2020.
68. Altman, Howard; Rempfer, Kyle (11 May 2020). "Family of ex-Green Beret captured in Venezuela says men likely believed they were trying to liberate the oppressed". Military Times. Retrieved 18 May 2020.
69. Murphy, Jack (5 May 2020). "Ex-Green Berets tried to recruit this vet for a failed coup. Now he's speaking out". Connecting Vets. Retrieved 10 May 2020.
70. Alemán, Hernán (16 May 2020). "Dip. Hernán Alemán, a ND: Averiguaré quién sacó a Cliver Alcalá así me cueste la vida" [Deputy Hernán Alemán to Noticiero Digital: I will find out who took out Cliver Alcalá if it's the last thing I do] (Interview) (in Spanish). Interviewed by Anaisa Rodríguez.
71. Vásquez, Zurima (8 May 2020). "Diputado Hernán Alemán: Operación Gedeón no era para efectuar un magnicidio sino para que Maduro fuera a la cárcel" [Deputy Hernán Alemán: Operation Gideon was not to assassinate Maduro, it was so he would go to jail]. Contrapunto.com [es] (in Spanish). Retrieved 18 May 2020 – via TVV Noticias.
72. "Hernán Alemán: Nadie financió la Operación Gedeón" [Hernán Alemán: Nobody financed Operation Gideon]. Tal Cual (in Spanish). 19 May 2020. Retrieved 19 May 2020.
73. Goyret, Lucas (14 October 2020). "Wilmer Azuaje dio detalles del informe que presentó en La Haya sobre las ejecuciones extrajudiciales en Venezuela" [Wilmer Azuaje gave details of the report he presented in The Hague on extrajudicial executions in Venezuela]. Infobae (in Spanish). Retrieved 17 September 2023. Contains a link to the full report.
74. Barráez, Sebastiana (19 May 2020). "Hernán Alemán Pérez, sobre la Operación Gedeón: 'No se planificaron asesinatos, pero sí agarrar a los cabecillas del régimen de narcos y entregarlos a los EEUU'" [Hernán Alemán Pérez, on Operation Gedeón: 'Murders were not planned, but the leaders of the drug regime were to be captured and handed over to the United States']. Infobae (in Spanish). Retrieved 19 September 2023.
75. Long, Gideon (4 April 2020). "Mystery surrounds foiled 'plot' to liberate Venezuela". Financial Times. Retrieved 5 May 2020.
76. "Estados Unidos acusó de narcoterrorismo a Nicolás Maduro y ofreció USD 15 millones por datos que lleven a su arresto" [The United States accused Nicolás Maduro of narco-terrorism and offered USD 15 million for data leading to his arrest] (in Spanish). Infobae, 26 March 2020
77. Goodman, Joshua; Smith, Scott (27 March 2020). "A defiant Maduro threatens 'cowboy' Trump after drug charge". Associated Press (Miami). Retrieved 10 May 2020.
78. Goodman, Joshua; Smith, Scott (26 March 2020). "US indicts Venezuela's Maduro on narcoterrorism charges". Associated Press. Miami. Retrieved 10 May 2020.
79. "Nicolás Maduro Moros and 14 Current and Former Venezuelan Officials Charged with Narco-Terrorism, Corruption, Drug Trafficking and Other Criminal Charges" (Press release). Office of Public Affairs: United States Department of Justice. 26 March 2020.
80. "Fiscalía colombiana investiga a Clíver Alcalá". El Carabobeño (in Spanish). 29 March 2020. Retrieved 22 May 2020.
81. "Cliver Alcalá se entregó a la DEA y fue extraditado a EEUU". Noticiero Digital. Reuters. 27 March 2020. Retrieved 9 May 2020.
82. "Alleged Maduro accomplice surrenders to U.S. agents, will help prosecution: sources". Reuters. 28 March 2020. Retrieved 26 May 2020.
83. Barrios, Sarah (26 March 2020). "Maduro a Donald Trump, tras acusaciones: 'Eres un miserable'" [Maduro to Donald Trump, following indictments: "You are a wretch"]. El Universal (Caracas) (in Spanish). Retrieved 18 May 2020.
84. "Alleged Maduro co-conspirator says CIA knew about a 2020 Venezuela coup plan". ABC News. Australia. 29 January 2022. Retrieved 9 March 2022.
85. Cohen, Luc (30 June 2023). "Venezuela ex-general pleads guilty to US charges of helping FARC". Reuters. Retrieved 7 September 2023.
86. "Jailed suspect in anti-Maduro plot blames Colombia, Guaido". Associated Press. 20 April 2021. Retrieved 14 June 2023.
87. The Bay of Piglets. Al Jazeera. 29 April 2021. Event occurs at 6:20. Retrieved 14 June 2023.
88. Delgado, Antonio Maria; Hall, Kevin G.; Dasgupta, Shirsho (18 November 2020). . Miami Herald. Archived from the original on 19 November 2020. Retrieved 11 September 2023. Also available via Newspapers.com from Longview Daily News, 22 November 2020, p. B8.
89. Herrero, Ana Vanessa; Faiola, Anthony (3 May 2020). "Venezuelan government says it stopped 'invasion' launched from Colombia". The Washington Post. ProQuest 2397437245. Retrieved 11 May 2020.
90. Meza, Alfredo; Weffer Cifuentes, Laura (11 May 2020). "Gobierno de Maduro sabía de la incursión a Venezuela al menos un mes antes de que ocurriera" [Maduro government knew of incursion into Venezuela at least a month before it occurred]. CNN en Español (in Spanish). Retrieved 16 May 2020.
91. Coscojuela, Sarai (11 May 2020). "Huella digital: Jordan Goudreau dejó todas las opciones sobre un peñero" [Fingerprint (Digital Footprint): Jordan Goudreau left all options on a fishing boat]. runrun.es. Runrunes. Retrieved 15 May 2020.
92. Guerra, Carlos (15 May 2020). "El caso de la 'Operación Gedeón' estremeció la movediza arena política venezolana" [The case of "Operation Gideon" shifted the Venezuelan political quicksand]. Correo del Caroní (in Spanish). Retrieved 18 May 2020.
93. "Clíver Alcalá, exmilitar venezolano, ya está en EE. UU. custodiado por la DEA". ElEspectador.com (in Spanish). 28 March 2020. Retrieved 26 May 2020.
94. "Lo sabíamos todo', dice Maduro sobre incursión en Macuto". Efecto Cocuyo. 5 May 2020. Retrieved 5 May 2020.
95. Hall, Kevin G.; Delgado, Antonio M.; Wilner, Michael (20 May 2021). "Ex-Green Berets jailed in bungled Venezuela coup may have been duped, negotiator says". McClatchy DC. Retrieved 19 October 2023.
96. Goodman, Joshua; Smith, Scott (3 May 2020). "Ex-Green Beret claims he led foiled raid into Venezuela". Associated Press. Retrieved 16 May 2020.
97. "Gobierno sabía sobre planes de incursión armada por las costas, según Jorge Rodríguez" [Government knew about plans for an armed incursion along the coasts, according to Jorge Rodríguez]. Tal Cual (in Spanish). 5 May 2020. Retrieved 8 October 2020.
98. "Confirman la muerte del capitán Robert Colina, alias Pantera, durante enfrentamiento en Macuto" [Death of Robert Colina, known as Pantera, during clash in Macuto confirmed]. El Nacional (in Spanish). 4 May 2020. Retrieved 11 May 2020.
99. The Bay of Piglets. Al Jazeera. 29 April 2021. Event occurs at 17.29. Retrieved 14 June 2023.
100. Otis, John; Vyas, Kejal; Donati, Jessica (6 May 2020). "'Freedom Fighters' Led by American Tried Invading Venezuela". The Wall Street Journal. ProQuest 2398386098. Retrieved 12 May 2020.
101. "El régimen de Nicolás Maduro frustró una segunda "incursión" de la Operación Gedeón: ocho personas fueron detenidas" [Maduro regime thwarted a second "incursion" of Operation Gideon: eight arrested]. infobae. 4 May 2020. from the original on 5 May 2020. Retrieved 26 September 2023.
102. "Venezuela attack: Former US special forces soldier says he led botched plot to overthrow President Maduro". Sky News. Retrieved 5 May 2020.
103. "El Gobierno de Maduro denuncia un ataque por mar que la oposición ve como un montaje". El Heraldo de Aragón. EFE News. 4 May 2020. from the original on 10 May 2020. Retrieved 30 September 2023.
104. "Participant, U.S. puppet or Maduro's mole in coup plot?". The Washington Post. 19 July 2020. ProQuest 2424697894.
105. Vyas, Kejal (3 September 2020). "Colombia Arrests Venezuelans Tied to Failed Invasion; Charges are latest twist in the bizarre saga to overthrow strongman Nicolas Maduro in May". Wall Street Journal. ProQuest 2439717423. from the original on 4 September 2020.
106. "Venezuela: Two US citizens held after failed coup attempt are named". Sky News. Retrieved 5 May 2020.
107. . Agence France-Presse. 26 May 2020. Archived from the original on 10 June 2020. Retrieved 28 May 2020.
108. León, Ibis (8 May 2020). "Agentes rusos rastrean a implicados en 'Operación Gedeón' en Carayaca" [Russian agents track down those implicated in "Operation Gideon" in Carayaca]. Efecto Cocuyo (in Spanish). Retrieved 8 May 2020. 'El grupo ruso operaría equipos aéreos no tripulados, por lo que el Jefe de la División de Drones del Comando de Defensa Aeroespacial Integral (Codal) y el equipo de operadores de la Federación Rusa realizaron una inspección a las instalaciones del Aeropuerto de Maiquetía donde hicieron una evaluación técnica la cual arrojó que no se pueden operar estos equipos desde aquí porque existen obstáculos', refiere el artículo citando información de la cuenta de la Zona Operativa de Defensa Integral (Zodi) de La Guaira. Sin embargo, los tuits citados fueron borrados de la cuenta y no se encuentran disponibles este viernes 8 de mayo.
109. Kinosian, Sarah (8 May 2020). "Russian troops to help Venezuela search for members of failed incursion: report". Reuters. Retrieved 9 May 2020.
110. Leon, Ibis (7 May 2020). "El día 'D' y la hora 'H' no ha llegado, Javier Nieto Quintero sobre 'Operación Gedeón'" [Javier Nieto Quintero on 'Operation Gideon': D Day and H Hour have not arrived]. Efecto Cocuyo (in Spanish).
111. Dominguez, Claudia (5 May 2020). "Venezuela claims to have captured two Americans involved in failed invasion". CNN. Retrieved 5 May 2020.
112. "Venezuela's Maduro: Americans captured in failed coup plot". Al Jazeera. Retrieved 5 May 2020.
113. "Hija del general Baduel denuncia que desconocen el paradero de su hermano" [Daughter of general Baduel denounces that the whereabouts of her brother are unknown]. El Pitazo (in Spanish). 5 May 2020. Retrieved 11 May 2020.
114. Riley-Smith, Ben (8 May 2020). . The Telegraph. Archived from the original on 16 May 2020. Retrieved 11 September 2023.
115. "Maduro presents video confession by captured American" [Venezuela: Pres. Maduro announces the arrest of 4 new terrorists]. The Washington Post (in Spanish). 6 May 2020. Retrieved 16 May 2020 – via YouTube.
116. Phillips, Tom (7 May 2020). "US mercenary says group plotted to seize Venezuela's presidential palace". The Guardian.
117. "¡Le Contamos! Divulgan testimonio del estadounidense Luke Denman sobre el objetivo de la 'Operación Gedeón': Entrenar venezolanos, venir acá y poner a Maduro en un avión (+Video)" [We tell you! They release testimony from American Luke Denman about the objective of 'Operation Gideon': Train Venezuelans, come here and put Maduro on a plane (+Video)]. Maduradas (in Spanish). 18 May 2020. Retrieved 18 May 2020.
118. "Detienen en Colombia a alias "Pico" y otros cabecillas de la Operación Gedeón". Tal Cual (in Spanish). 3 September 2020. Retrieved 17 February 2021.
119. Goodman, Joshua; Smith, Scott; Lee, Matthew; Herschaft, Randy (6 May 2020). "Sources: US investigating ex-Green Beret for Venezuela raid". Associated Press (Caracas, Washington, New York). Retrieved 11 May 2020.
120. "Venezuela charges two ex-US soldiers with 'terrorism, conspiracy'". Al Jazeera. 8 May 2020. Retrieved 9 May 2020.
121. Sequera, Vivian; Cohen, Luc (8 May 2020). "Venezuela's top prosecutor requests extradition of U.S. veteran accused in plot". Reuters. from the original on 8 May 2020. Retrieved 27 September 2023.
122. "Venezuela condena a 20 anos dois ex-militares dos EUA envolvidos em 'invasão' falhada". 8 August 2020.
123. "Venezuela jails two Americans over failed 'invasion'". France24.com. AFP. 8 August 2020. Retrieved 15 September 2023.
124. "Operación Gedeón: tribunales privan de libertad a Josnar Baduel y a capitán Sequea" [Operation Gideon: courts order confinement of Josnar Baduel and Captain Sequea] (in Spanish). 16 May 2020. Retrieved 18 May 2020.
125. "La Justicia venezolana dicta prisión preventiva a 40 personas por ataque fallido" [Venezuelan court orders preventive detention to 40 individuals for failed attack]. EFE (in Spanish). 16 May 2020. Retrieved 18 May 2020 – via Yahoo Finanzas (Yahoo Finance in Spanish).
126. "Señalado por Maduro deapoyar golpe busca acelerar su envío a EE. UU" [Individual identified by Maduro as supporting the coup seeks to speed up being sent to the United States]. El Tiempo (in Spanish). 8 May 2020.
127. "Jorge Rodríguez acusó a Goicoechea de participar en la Operación Gedeón". El Nacional (Venezuela). 18 May 2020. Retrieved 18 May 2020.
128. "EE. UU. pide extradición inmediata del señalado capo alias 'La silla'" [United States requests immediate extradition of crime boss known as 'the chair']. El Tiempo (Colombia) (in Spanish). 14 December 2019.
129. "¿Quién es 'la Silla', el supuesto capo al que Duque ordenó perseguir?" [Who is 'the Chair', the alleged crime boss that Duque ordered be pursued?]. El Tiempo (Colombia) (in Spanish). 28 August 2019.
130. Goodman, Joshua (19 May 2021). "Venezuelans tied to anti-Maduro plot sentenced to 6 years". Associated Press. Retrieved 10 June 2021.
131. "CPI notificó rápido haber recibido informe de Operación Gedeón, dice Wilmer Azuaje" [CPI quickly notified having received a report on Operation Gedeón, says Wilmer Azuaje]. Tal Cual (in Spanish). 15 October 2020. Retrieved 12 September 2023.
132. "Azuaje: 'Denunciamos ante el Parlamento Europeo la masacre de Macuto'" [Azuaje: 'We denounce the Macuto massacre before the European Parliament']. El Pitazo (in Spanish). 14 October 2020. Retrieved 17 February 2021.
133. "Venezuela informa de ocho muertos y dos detenidos por invasión marítima frustrada en el estado de Vargas". El Comercio. 3 May 2020. from the original on 5 May 2020. Retrieved 30 September 2023.
134. "Venezuela accuses Colombia of sea invasion". BBC News. 3 May 2020. from the original on 4 May 2020. Retrieved 5 May 2020.
135. Trillo, Manuel (21 September 2020). "Presentan pruebas de torturas y ejecuciones a miembros de la 'operación Gedeón' de Venezuela" [Evidence of torture and executions of members of Venezuela's 'Operation Gideon' presented]. ABC (Spain) (in Spanish). Retrieved 12 September 2023.
136. "Las fotos que revelan que la Operación Gedeón fue una masacre orquestada por el régimen chavista" [The photos that reveal that Operation Gedeón was a massacre orchestrated by the Chavista regime]. La Razón (in Spanish). 18 October 2020. Retrieved 17 February 2021.
137. "Venezuela: 'No hubo misión militar fallida, sí un montaje del régimen'" [Venezuela: "There was no failed military mission, but there was a regime set-up"]. Diario las Américas (in Spanish). 8 May 2020. Retrieved 12 May 2020.
138. "Operación Gedeón: las fotos presentadas en La Haya que prueban las ejecuciones extrajudiciales de la dictadura de Maduro" [Operation Gideon: the photos presented in The Hague that prove the extrajudicial executions of the Maduro dictatorship]. Infobae (in Spanish). 15 October 2020. Retrieved 17 September 2023. Contains a link to the full report.
139. Montes de Oca, Rodolfo; Barrera Tyszka, Alberto (2022). "Sospechas habituales" [Common suspicions] (PDF) (in Spanish). PROVEA. p. 95. Retrieved 16 September 2023.
140. "Maduro acusa a la DEA de contratar a "narcos" en el golpe frustrado" [Maduro accuses the DEA of hiring 'narcos' in the thwarted coup]. ABC (Spain) (in Spanish). 5 May 2020. Retrieved 6 October 2023.
141. Weeks & Allison 2022, p. 5.
142. Steve Holland (5 May 2020). "Trump denies U.S. role in what Venezuela says was 'mercenary' incursion". Reuters.
143. "Venezuela arrests two US 'mercenaries' after alleged raid to capture Maduro". France 24. 5 May 2020. Retrieved 6 May 2020.
144. "Las venezolanas lo esperamos gratis con profunda pasión patria»: el mensaje de Delcy Rodríguez a Jordan Goudreau" [The women of Venezuela await you with deep patriotic devotion – Delcy Rodríguez's message to Jordan Goudreau]. Alberto News (in Spanish). 4 May 2020. Retrieved 10 May 2020.
145. "Arreaza: Silencio de gobiernos ante agresiones contra Venezuela es complicidad" [Arreaza: The silence of governments in the face of attacks against Venezuela is complicity]. El Universal (Venezuela) (in Spanish). AVN. 8 May 2020. Retrieved 12 May 2020.
146. Sequera, Vivian (6 May 2020). "Venezuelan authorities detain U.S. citizens allegedly involved in incursion". Reuters. Retrieved 6 May 2020.
147. "Según Iván Simonovis lo ocurrido en Macuto fue para profundizar la represión" [According to Ivan Simonovis, what happened in Macuto was for the purpose of increasing repression]. El Pitazo (in Spanish). 3 May 2020. Retrieved 12 May 2020.
148. "Primero Justicia pide destitución de involucrados en complot" [Justice First calls for dismissal of those involved in plot]. Diario las Américas (in Spanish). Retrieved 12 May 2020.
149. "Venezuelan opposition advisers resign after failed operation to oust Maduro". Reuters. 11 May 2020. Retrieved 11 May 2020.
150. "Provea exige garantías a la integridad de detenidos en Macuto y Chuao" [PROVEA demands assurances of the wellbeing of those detained in Macuto and Chuao]. Runrunes (in Spanish). 5 May 2020. Retrieved 7 May 2020.
151. "Provea responde a Maduro: Nadie nos va a desviar del camino" [PROVEA responds to Maduro: Nobody is going to divert us from our path]. Noticiero Digital (in Spanish). Retrieved 7 May 2020.
152. Martínez, Deisy (21 May 2020). "'Nunca he tenido trato con Jordan Goudreau', responde Yon Goicoechea". Efecto Cocuyo (in Spanish). Retrieved 22 May 2020.
153. . Agence France-Presse. 4 May 2020. Archived from the original on 4 May 2020. Retrieved 11 May 2020.
154. "Iván Duque niega acusaciones del Gobierno de Maduro" [Iván Duque denies accusations of Maduro regime]. CNN en español (in Spanish). 8 May 2020. from the original on 9 May 2020. Retrieved 27 September 2023.
155. "Russia weighs in on Donald Trump's 'unconvincing' denial of alleged Venezuelan plot". SBS World News. Agence France-Presse. 6 May 2020. Retrieved 6 May 2020.
156. Lederer, Edith M. (20 May 2020). "UN urges Venezuela's rival political leaders to resume talks". Associated Press. Retrieved 20 May 2020.
157. Spetalnick, Matt; Pamuk, Humeyra (6 May 2020). "U.S. will use 'every tool' to secure release if any Americans held in Venezuela: Pompeo". Reuters. Retrieved 7 May 2020.
158. Sisk, Richard (6 May 2020). "US Not Involved in Bizarre Venezuela Coup Attempt, SecDef Insists". Military. Retrieved 7 May 2020.
159. DeYoung, Karen; Faiola, Anthony; Horton, Alex (6 May 2020). "U.S. denies role in alleged Venezuela raid". The Washington Post. ProQuest 2398393743.
160. "Opositores a Maduro piden por la vida de presos en "Operación Gedeón"". elestimulo.com (in Spanish). 4 May 2020. Retrieved 30 October 2023.
161. Barráez, Sebastiana (15 May 2020). "Disidencias en el régimen de Maduro: Vladimir Padrino López dijo que no se puede calificar a la Operación Gedeón como 'una invasión". infobae. Retrieved 1 October 2023.
162. "Söldner-Invasion in Venezuela: Von langer Hand gescheitert". Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung (in German). 6 May 2020. ISSN 0174-4909. Retrieved 20 October 2023.
163. Bull & Rosales 2023, p. 49.
164. Harwood 2022.
165. Koh 2021, p. 744.
166. DeFronzo 2021, pp. 455–456.
167. "A Florida security company is entangled in the assassination of Haiti's president. How is that possible?". The Washington Post. 20 July 2021.
168. "Venezuela broadcasts video of captured US mercenary". Al Jazeera. Retrieved 6 October 2023.
169. "Maduro says two captured American 'mercenaries' will be tried in Venezuela". France 24. 7 May 2020. Retrieved 6 October 2023.
170. "Colombia's Mercenary Industry is Behind the Haitian Coup". Jacobin. Retrieved 6 October 2023.
171. Jones, Sarah (5 May 2020). . New York Magazine. Archived from the original on 6 May 2020.
172. Cho, Joshua (11 May 2020). "Corporate Media Don't Think Americans Paid to Invade Venezuela Count as Mercenaries". Fairness & Accuracy in Reporting. Retrieved 6 October 2023.
173. DeFronzo 2021, pp. 457, Section: Assassination and Coup Attempts against Maduro and His Government - Quote: "Operation Gideon was supposed to capture and remove Maduro and his close associates from power so that Guaidó could take over Venezuela".
174. Ward, Alex (11 May 2020). "The 'ridiculous' failed coup attempt in Venezuela, explained". Vox. Retrieved 12 May 2020. plan to send two teams into Maracaibo and Caracas, extract Maduro from his presidential mansion, and install Guaidó as president.
175. "Venezuela investiga el uso de lanchas artilladas militares de Colombia en la 'Operación Gedeón'". Europa Press. 11 May 2020. Retrieved 21 November 2023. 'Operation Gideon', an armed intervention of mercenaries and ex-military soldiers aimed at overthrowing President Nicolás Maduro and installing Juan Guaidó as president.

Bibliography

Journal articles

• Bull, Benedicte; Rosales, Antulio (February 2023). "How sanctions led to authoritarian capitalism in Venezuela". Current History. Oakland. 122 (841): 49–55. doi:10.1525/curh.2023.122.841.49. hdl:10852/99738. S2CID 256449775. ProQuest 2770716344.
• Corrales, Javier (3 July 2020). "Authoritarian survival: why Maduro hasn't fallen" (PDF). Journal of Democracy. 31 (3): 39–53. doi:10.1353/jod.2020.0044. S2CID 226738491. ProQuest 2429461768. (PDF) from the original on 30 September 2023.
• Harwood, Graham (22 June 2022). "A friend and foe teach us how not to handle Venezuela". Chicago Policy Review. Harris School of Public Policy. ProQuest 2679242951. from the original on 22 June 2022.
• Koh, Steven A. (2021). "The criminalization of foreign relations". Fordham Law Review. 90: 737–787. from the original on 29 March 2023.
• Villa, Rafael Duarte (2022). "Venezuelan military: a political and ideological model in Chavista governments" (PDF). Defence Studies. 22 (1): 79–98. doi:10.1080/14702436.2021.1976061. S2CID 246801363. EBSCOhost 155858391. (PDF) from the original on 30 September 2023.

Books

• DeFronzo, James (2021). "Revolution Through Democracy". Revolutions and Revolutionary Movements (6th ed.). United Kingdom: Taylor & Francis. pp. 433–487. doi:10.4324/9781003102649-11. ISBN 9781000434576.
• Mijares, Victor M (2022). "Venezuela: A revolutionary petrostate under stress". In Wade, Christine J.; Kline, Harvey F. (eds.). Latin American Politics and Development (10th ed.). United Kingdom: Taylor & Francis. pp. 223–246. doi:10.4324/9781003223351-16. ISBN 9781000620559.
• Neuman, William (2022). Things Are Never So Bad That They Can't Get Worse: Inside the Collapse of Venezuela (1st ed.). St. Martin's Press. ISBN 978-1250266163.
• Weeks, Gregory B.; Allison, Michael E. (2022). U.S. and Latin American Relations. Cambridge University Press. ISBN 978-1009205993.

External links

• El aparato estatal, sus mecanismos de represión y las restricciones al espacio cívico y democrático: Misión internacional independiente de determinación de los hechos sobre la República Bolivariana de Venezuela* [The state apparatus, its mechanisms of repression and the restrictions on civic and democratic space: Independent international fact-finding mission about the Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela] (PDF) (Report) (in Spanish). Office of High Commissioner of Human Rights, United Nations. 18 September 2023. Retrieved 27 September 2023.