Hermano Pule

In this Spanish name, the first or paternal surname is de la Cruz.

Apolinario de la Cruz (July 22, 1815 – November 4, 1841^[1]), better known as Hermano Pule (Spanish: [eɾˈmano puˈle], Spanish for "Brother Pule";^[2][3] also spelled Hermano Puli), was a Filipino religious leader who founded and led the Cofradía de San José (Confraternity of St. Joseph). The cofradía was established in 1832 in response to the racially discriminatory practices of the Catholic Church in the Philippines. During the Spanish colonial period, Catholic religious orders refused to admit native Filipinos as members. In retaliation, Pule established his own religious order that was exclusive for native Filipinos. During its peak, the cofradía had 4,500 to 5,000 members from the provinces of Tayabas, Batangas, and Laguna. Fearing an armed rebellion, the Spanish colonial government sent military forces to suppress the cofradía, an attack that was resisted by Hermano Pule and his followers on October 23, 1841. However, more troops were sent and the cofradía was finally quelled by the colonial military forces on November 1, 1841. Pule was then captured, tried, and executed.

Hermano Pule
Image of Hermano Pule, courtesy of Ryan Palad, head of the Tayabas Studies and Creative Writing Center
Born	Apolinario de la Cruz (1815-07-22)July 22, 1815 Lucban, Tayabas province, Captaincy General of the Philippines, Spanish Empire (now in Quezon province, Philippines)
Died	November 4, 1841(1841-11-04) (aged 26) Tayabas, Tayabas province, Captaincy General of the Philippines, Spanish Empire
Occupations	Lay brother religious leader
Years active	1832–1841
Known for	Cofradía de San José Revolt

Early life

Apolinario de la Cruz was born on July 22, 1815,^[a] in Barrio Pandác in the town of Lucban in Tayabas province (now Quezon Province) back when the Philippines was a colony of the Spanish Empire. His parents—Pablo de la Cruz and Juana Andres—were peasants^[b] and devout Catholics.^[1][7][8] Apolinario de la Cruz was literate, but stated that he had no formal education.^[5][9] Despite that, it is very likely that he received primary religious instruction and attended the local public primary school in Lucban.^[5][6][10] In 1829, he decided to become a priest and tried to join the Order of Preachers in Manila. During those times, Roman Catholic religious orders barred indios (native people of the Philippines) from joining, thus De la Cruz's application was rejected for the sole reason of his race.^[11][12][13] He then decided to work as a donado (lay brother) at the San Juan de Dios Hospital where he was admitted to the Cofradía de San Juan de Dios, a brotherhood affiliated with the hospital open to indios. During this time, he improved his public speaking and studied the Bible along with other religious writings.^[1][10][11]

Cofradía de San José

Formation and expansion

In December 1832, 18-year-old De la Cruz, along with indio secular priest Br. Ciriaco de los Santos and 19 other individuals from Tayabas, founded the Hermandad de la Archi-Cofradia del Glorioso Señor San Jose y de la Virgen del Rosario (Brotherhood of the Great Sodality of the Glorious Lord Saint Joseph and of the Virgin of the Rosary), shortened to Cofradía de San José (Confraternity of St. Joseph). He then became known to his followers as Hermano Pule (Brother Pule).^[10][14][15] The brotherhood fostered the practice of Christian virtues centered around the cults of Saint Francis of Assisi and the Virgin of Antipolo.^[14] They also incorporated elements of pre-colonial pagan beliefs such as the use of anting-anting (talismans).^[16] Most of its adherents were from Tayabas, Laguna, Cavite, and Batangas, and some were from Camarines Norte and Camarines Sur.^[1][15][17] The cofradía prohibited Spaniards and mestizos from joining without Pule's permission as a form of retaliation against the Church for discriminating against natives.^[11] Hermano Pule continued to work at the San Juan de Dios Hospital and regularly corresponded with his followers through letters, which were read aloud to the cofradía members. Some cofradía members also found time to visit Pule in Manila. In Pule's absence, the cofradía was led by hermano mayor Octavio Ygnacio "Purgatorio" de San Jorge^[c] and Br. Ciriaco delos Santos, who was the cofradía's treasurer and spiritual adviser.^[13][20][21]

Members of the cofradía met monthly on the 19th day to honor the feast of Saint Joseph. They also paid monthly fees of one real to cover the cost of their monthly Masses and fiestas. The monthly Mass was held in the parish church of Lucban, and was facilitated by the parish priest, Fr. Manuel Sancho.^[14][22][23]

In 1837, the confraternity was renamed Cofradía del Sr. San José i voto del Santisimo Rosario and evangelized in Lucban, Majayjay, and Sariaya.^[14] By 1841, the cofradía had grown to an estimated 4,500 to 5,000 members.^[1]

Suppression

The Spanish authorities were unaware of the cofradía's existence until 1840. However, as early as 1833, Filipino priests have noticed their activities in the vicinity of Mount San Cristobal and Mount Banahaw.^[14][24]

In 1840, Fr. Antonio Mateo, the Vicar of Tayabas, became suspicious of the cofradía's monthly masses and fees, thus Fr. Manuel Sancho stopped holding Masses for the cofradía.^[23] Mateo and Sancho then accused the cofradía of conducting heretical activities.^[24] Due to religious persecution and the increasing number of its members, Pule decided to have the cofradía recognized by the colonial government and the Roman Catholic Church. He first sought recognition and authorization from the Bishop of Camarines but his request was denied. Not discouraged, he then sought the approval of the Real Audiencia but he was also ignored.^[1][25]

In addition to the accusations of heresy, there was a rumor that the cofradía was planning to murder the alcaldes of Camarines and Laguna.^[26] The Franciscan friars of Tayabas passed this information to the gobernadorcillo of Lucban, who ordered a raid on October 19, 1840, during the cofradía's monthly meeting. The authorities arrested 243 cofradía members and confiscated their cash box, two large portraits of Pule stylized as a saint, and Pule's letters to the cofradía.^[27] The Spanish alcalde mayor (provincial governor) of Tayabas, Don Joaquín Ortega, whose wife was a member of the cofradía, ordered the release of the prisoners, reasoning that it was an ecclesiastical matter. Afterwards, in early 1841, the cofradía transferred to Majayjay, hometown of "Purgatorio" de San Jorge.^[26][28]

Hermano Pule immediately sent a letter to Archbishop José Seguí in Manila rebuking the acts of the Tayabas friars, and accusing them of beatings and threatening the excommunication of cofradía members. He also challenged the friars' authority to perform such acts because the aims of the cofradía were never against the Catholic faith. On January 29, 1841, Pule sent a letter to the Bishop of Nueva Cáceres restating that the cofradía was not against canon law. The letter was forwarded to the juez provisor of the bishopric, who endorsed it to Fr. Antonio Mateo and Fr. Manuel Sancho, who rejected Pule's petition.^[1]

In June 1841, with the help of influential supporters (including Domingo Róxas), Pule again sent a letter to the Real Audiencia requesting for the cofradía to be recognized. This letter was forwarded to the office of Governor-General Marcelino de Oraá Lecumberri.^[29] The Governor-General personally reviewed the petition and was disturbed by the cofradía's rule that excluded Spaniards and mestizos from joining without Pule's permission. This made De Oraá believe that it was a seditious organization where religion was used as a blind for potential insurgence against Spanish authorities.^[12][24] De Oraá then recommended Pule's dismissal from San Juan de Dios Hospital and had the cofradía outlawed in July 1841, ordering its disbandment and the arrests of its members. Pule immediately went into hiding to avoid capture.^[1][24][25]

In September 1841, Hermano Pule traveled from Manila to Bay, Laguna, to meet with the cofradía members that evaded capture.^[28][30] Anticipating an imminent attack, Pule and Purgatorio rallied 4,000 followers at Barrio Isabang on the slopes of Mount Banahaw. A group of pagan Aetas from Sierra Madre also allied themselves with the cofradía.^[31]

On October 23, 1841, alcalde mayor Joaquín Ortega, with orders from Manila, led 300 men in an attack on the cofradía's camp. The 4,000-strong cofradía was able to resist the attack, which resulted in the deaths of Ortega and many of his men.^[8][11][32] Pule then transferred his camp to Alitao, near Tayabas town, where his followers crowned him "King of the Tagalogs". By that time, he had considered severing his ties with the Church.^[1][25]

When the news of the Ortega's defeat reached the Governor-General, better-armed reinforcements from Manila were sent to Tayabas. On November 1, 1841, Col. Joaquín Huet arrived in Tayabas with 800 to 1,000 soldiers.^[11][33][34] They initially offered amnesty to the members of the cofradía, with the exception of Hermano Pule and other senior leaders, but the cofradía refused. Prior to Colonel Huet's arrival, Pule and the cofradía leaders promised their followers of victory through divine intervention. The cofradía fighters were made to believe that they were invulnerable to enemy bullets, and that angels from Heaven would come down and help them in battle, and finally the ground would open up and swallow the enemy troops.^[35] The battle between the cofradía and the government forces lasted for four hours. Three hundred to five hundred men, women, elders, and children were killed on the cofradía side. Afterwards, 500 were taken prisoner, including 300 women. The rest of the cofradía escaped to the forests and were not pursued. Only 11 were wounded on the government's side.^[11][12][36]

Capture, trial, and execution

Pule fled to Barrio Gibanga in Sariaya but was captured by Colonel Huet's forces the following evening. On November 4, 1841, after a summary trial held at the Casa Comunidad in Tayabas town, he was tortured and later executed by firing squad at age 26. The Spanish authorities had his body quartered. His dismembered head, hands, and feet were exhibited throughout Tayabas province.^{[d][14][15][25]}

The other leaders of the Cofradía—Octavio Ygnacio "Purgatorio" de San Jorge, Dionisio de los Reyes, Francisco Espinosa de la Cruz, Gregorio Miguel de Jesus, and around 200 other cofradía prisoners—were also executed the same day as Pule.^[1][25][36]

Aftermath and legacy

 

Historical marker installed in Tayabas, Quezon, by the National Historical Commission of the Philippines to commemorate Hermano Pule

Public reaction and Supreme Court investigation

The 1841 Alitao massacre became a public controversy in Manila, where flyers criticizing the government's actions were circulated. The Real Audiencia blamed De Oraá for his failure to consult them prior to sending troops, and his order to give no quarter to the cofradía fighters. Meanwhile, Governor-General De Oraá blamed Colonel Huet for allegedly exceeding his orders.^[37]

After investigating the massacre, the Supreme Court of Spain officially reprimanded Governor-General De Oraá. The court affirmed that Pule and the cofradía had no political motives. However, they acknowledged that the cofradía had committed an ecclesiastical offense for conducting religious activities without the approval of the Catholic Church.^[1]

Mutiny of the Tayabas Regiment

On January 20, 1843, members of the Spanish Armed Forces' Tayabas Regiment stationed in Manila, led by Sergeant Irineo Samaniego, rose in mutiny in retaliation for the November 1841 massacre of the cofradía members. They managed to capture Fort Santiago and held it for a few hours, but were defeated the next day. Eighty-two mutineers were immediately executed on Bagumbayan Field, while the rest were imprisoned.^[25][38][39]

Revival of the Cofradía and the origin of the colorums

In 1870, the Cofradía de San José was revived under the leadership of Profeta y Pontifice ('Prophet and Pope') Juanario Labios. The members of the revived cofradía claimed to have witnessed the alleged joint apparition of the Virgin of the Rosary, Hermano Pule, and Octavio Ygnacio "Purgatorio" de San Jorge. The activities of the revived cofradía ended in 1871 when Labios and his followers were captured and banished to Mindoro and the Calamian Islands.^[14][15]

The surviving members of the Cofradía de San José, who lived in the vicinity of Mount San Cristobal and Mount Banahaw, continued with their religious activities and were known as colorums, a corruption of the Latin phrase in saecula saeculorum ('unto the ages of ages'), which was used at Mass to end prayers. During the American colonial era, the term colorum was applied to all the cults and insurgent groups characterized by Roman Catholic devotion, folk superstition, and hero worship. Some of these groups are still active today in various provinces in the Philippines.^[12][16][25]

Beginning in the 1930s, the colloquial meaning in the Philippines behind colorum became extended to any illegal activity, notably the unregistered public utility vehicles.^[25][40]

Commemoration

A monument to Hermano Pule now stands on the boundary of Tayabas and Lucena.^[41] His death anniversary, November 4, is a holiday in Quezon.^[7][42]

A play titled "Ang Unang Pagtatanghal ng 'Ang Huling Pasyon ni Hermano Pule'" was written by Rosauro de la Cruz and was first performed in 1975.^[43] It won the first prize for the one-act play in Filipino category of the 1972 Palanca Awards.^[e][44]

The historical film Ang Hapis at Himagsik ni Hermano Puli (The Agony and Fury of Brother Puli), directed by Gil Portes and starring Aljur Abrenica as Hermano Puli, was released in September 2016.^[45]

Footnotes

1. Filipino historian Gregorio F. Zaide published Hermano Pule's date of birth as July 22, 1815 based on Pule's baptismal record dated July 23, 1815.^[4] This is the date recognized by the National Historical Commission of the Philippines.^[1] Another estimate is July 23, 1814 by Tayabas historian Ryan Palad, for the reason that Hermano Pule (Apolinario de la Cruz) was named after St. Apollinaris of Ravenna, whose feast is on July 23.^[5] Other estimates include: July 31, 1815 by David Reeves Sturtevant, year 1814 by Reynaldo Ileto and Onofre Corpuz, and year 1815 by David Sweet.^[4]
2. Onofre Corpuz believed that Hermano Pule's family was well-established in the community, due to their use of surnames before Governor-General Narciso Clavería required all native Filipinos to adopt Hispanic surnames in 1849. Prior to that decree, many Filipinos did not use surnames.^[4] Despite this, Manuel F. Martinez is certain that Pule's family did not belong to the principalía.^[6]
3. Alternative forms of his name: "Octavio Ignacio de San Jorge",^[1] "Octavio Ignacio San Jorge",^[18] and "Octabio San Jorge".^[19]
4. Quennie Ann Palafox of the National Historical Commission reports that Pule's head was "stored in a cage for public view as it was put on top of a pole stuck along the roadside leading to Majayjay town".^[1] While Teodoro Agoncillo wrote that Pule's head was "hung in front of his parents' house in Lucban" and his hands and feet were "hung inside cages and placed in the guardhouses of Tayabas".^[14]
5. Entries to the Palanca competition are previously unpublished pieces in their manuscript form. Hence, the play won the award before its first performance. See Palanca Awards

References

1. Palafox, Quennie Ann J. (September 6, 2012). . nhcp.gov.ph. National Historical Commission of the Philippines. Archived from the original on August 20, 2016. Retrieved March 15, 2019.
2. "English < > Spanish Dictionary". eubd1.ugr.es. University of Granada. from the original on August 3, 2017. Retrieved June 9, 2017.
3. Martinez 1999, p. 100
4. Diestro et al. 2001, p. 42
5. Palad 2001b, p. 67
6. Martinez 1999, p. 101
7. Mallari, D. T., Jr. (November 13, 2014). Local hero remembered in Quezon ceremony November 8, 2016, at the Wayback Machine. Philippine Daily Inquirer.
8. . The Philippine Star. June 29, 2015. Archived from the original on February 2, 2017. Retrieved March 15, 2019.
9. Diestro et al. 2001, p. 43
10. Ileto 1979, p. 31
11. Duka 2008, pp. 106–107
12. Halili 2004, pp. 122–123
13. Francisco 2006, pp. 533–534
14. Agoncillo 1990, pp. 107–108
15. Miranda 2008, pp. 567–568
16. Guerrero, Milagros C. (1967). (PDF). Asian Studies: Journal of Critical Perspectives on Asia. Quezon City, Philippines: Asian Center, University of the Philippines Diliman. 5 (1): 65–78. Archived from the original (PDF) on February 2, 2017. Retrieved March 15, 2019.
17. Diestro et al. 2001, p. 48
18. Martinez 1999, p. 111
19. Ileto 1979, p. 41
20. Martinez 1999, pp. 105–106
21. Diestro et al. 2001, p. 46
22. Martinez 1999, p. 109
23. Diestro et al. 2001, pp. 55–56
24. Ileto 1979, p. 32
25. Constantino 2008, pp. 135–137
26. Martinez 1999, p. 116
27. Ileto 1979, pp. 41–43
28. Ileto 1979, p. 57
29. Diestro et al. 2001, pp. 58–59
30. Martinez 1999, p. 117
31. Ileto 1979, p. 58
32. Karnow 1989, p. 444
33. Diestro et al. 2001, p. 61
34. Martinez 1999, p. 120
35. Ileto 1979, p. 59
36. Ileto 1979, p. 62
37. Martinez 1999, p. 132
38. Palad 2001a, pp. 89–91
39. Martinez 1999, pp. 138–139
40. Rivero, Angel (March 7, 2012). . The Philippine Star. Manila. Archived from the original on March 24, 2017. Retrieved November 4, 2017.
41. Otordoz, B. M.(2015, July 19). Binay to lead rites for Hermano Pule September 14, 2016, at the Wayback Machine. The Manila Times.
42. Mallari, Delfin, Jr. (November 3, 2015). "Quezon holiday for local hero". Philippine Daily Inquirer. from the original on August 11, 2017. Retrieved August 11, 2017.
43. Fernandez, Doreen (1983). "Contemporary Philippine drama: The liveliest voice". Philippine Studies. Quezon City, Philippines: Ateneo de Manila University. 31 (1): 5–36. from the original on August 3, 2017. Retrieved August 2, 2017.
44. . palancaawards.com.ph. Carlos Palanca Foundation. Archived from the original on October 22, 2009. Retrieved March 15, 2019.
45. Tabora, Brylle (September 19, 2016). "'Hermano Puli,' this year's 'Heneral Luna,' opens Sept. 21". Philippine Daily Inquirer. from the original on September 20, 2016. Retrieved September 22, 2016.

Bibliography

• Agoncillo, Teodoro (1990). History of the Filipino People (8th ed.). Quezon City, Philippines: GAROTECH Publishing. pp. 107–108. ISBN 978-9-71-871106-4.
• Constantino, Renato (2008). A history of the Philippines: From the Spanish colonization to the Second World War. New York City: Monthly Review Press. pp. 135–137. ISBN 978-0-85345-394-9.
• Diestro, Dwight David; Boro-Magbanua, Ma. Reina; Mata, Roberto; Ybiernas, Vicente Angel (2001). "Ilang tala tungkol sa buhay, kasaysayan, at pamana ni Hermano Puli". In Diestro, Dwight David A.; Navarro, Atoy M.; Palad, Ryan V. (eds.). Hermano Puli sa Kasaysayan (in Filipino). Quezon City: Limbagang Pangkasaysayan & Tayabas Publication. pp. 41–64. ISBN 978-971-92282-1-9.
• Duka, Cecilio D. (2008). Struggle for Freedom: A Textbook on Philippine History (1st ed.). Manila: REX Book Store. pp. 106–107. ISBN 978-971-23-5045-0.
• Francisco, Jose Mario (2006). "Christianity as church and story and the birth of the Filipino nation in the nineteenth century". In Gilley, Sheridan; Stanley, Brian (eds.). The Cambridge History of Christianity: World Christianities c.1815–c.1914. Vol. 8. Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press. pp. 533–534. ISBN 978-0-521-81456-0.
• Halili, Maria Christine N. (2004). Philippine History (1st ed.). Manila: REX Book Store. pp. 122–123. ISBN 978-971-23-39349.
• Ileto, Reynaldo Clemeña (1979). Pasyon and Revolution: Popular Movements in the Philippines, 1840-1910. Quezon City: Ateneo de Manila University Press. ISBN 978-971-550-232-0.
• Karnow, Stanley (1989). In Our Image: America's Empire in the Philippines. New York City: Random House. p. 444. ISBN 978-0-394-54975-0.
• Martinez, Manuel F. (1999). A History of Quezon Province. Vol. 1. Parañaque, Philippines: MFM Enterprises. ISBN 978-971-93060-0-9.
• Miranda, Evelyn A. (2008). "Marianisation in the Philippines". In Poddar, Prem; Patke, Rajeev; Jensen, Lars (eds.). A Historical Companion to Postcolonial Literatures – Continental Europe and its Empires. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press. pp. 567–568. ISBN 978-0-7486-2394-5.
• Palad, Ryan (2001a). "Kasaysayan ng pag-aaklas ng rehimentong Tayabas 1843 at pananaw sa pag-usbong ng kamalayang Quezonian". In Diestro, Dwight David A.; Navarro, Atoy M.; Palad, Ryan V. (eds.). Hermano Puli sa Kasaysayan (in Filipino). Quezon City: Limbagang Pangkasaysayan & Tayabas Publication. pp. 85–99. ISBN 978-971-92282-1-9.
• Palad, Ryan (2001b). "Samu't saring kontrobersya sa buhay, kasaysayan at pamana ni Hermano Puli". In Diestro, Dwight David A.; Navarro, Atoy M.; Palad, Ryan V. (eds.). Hermano Puli sa Kasaysayan (in Filipino). Quezon City: Limbagang Pangkasaysayan & Tayabas Publication. pp. 65–77. ISBN 978-971-92282-1-9.