Helen Fraser (feminist)

Helen Miller Fraser, later Moyes (14 September 1881 – 2 December 1979),^[1] was a Scottish suffragist, feminist, educationalist^[2] and Liberal Party politician who later emigrated to Australia.

Helen Fraser
Born	Helen Miller Fraser (1881-09-14)14 September 1881 Leeds, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland
Died	2 December 1979(1979-12-02) (aged 98)
Occupation(s)	Politician, suffragist, and activist
Spouse	James Moyes

Background

Fraser was born in Leeds, Yorkshire to Scottish parents, James Fraser (1856 - 1908) and Christina Sutherland. She was one of ten children. Her father began work as a tailor's cutter, moving from Caithness to Edinburgh to Leeds, before finally settling in Glasgow when Helen was a child. There, he opened a wholesale clothing firm.^[1] She was educated at Queen's Park Higher Grade School, Glasgow. She opened a studio in Glasgow that specialised in black and white illustration work, embroidery and painting.^[3][4] In June 1908, Votes for Women, the newspaper of the Women's Social and Political Union reported that she had given up her art work to become an organiser for them.^[5] She was also an honorary treasurer of the Glasgow branch.

Her family was progressive politically, believing that conditions for workers should be improved. As a middle class young woman in Glasgow, her life involved dances and balls, theatre, raising money for charity, playing tennis, and visiting poor families in the city.^[1]

Political career in suffrage movement

She joined the Women's Social and Political Union (WSPU) after hearing Teresa Billington speak in Glasgow.^[1] She travelled to England to help the WSPU campaign at the 1906 Huddersfield by-election. She became Treasurer of the Glasgow WSPU and a WSPU Scottish Organiser, one of the fifty-eight funded branches in the UK.^[6] On 20 December 1906, with Flora Drummond, Fraser and three others attempted to enter the Stranger's Lobby in the Parliament, and after a skirmish Drummond was arrested.^[6]

Although suffragettes tended towards more direct action, and law-abiding suffragists preferred more legal, democratic means, they both took the opportunity of national and local elections to raise awareness of the cause of votes for women. They supported candidates who wanted to extend the franchise, and spoke against candidates who did not support it.^[7][8]

In 1907, Fraser organised the WSPU campaign, using press publicity handbills about the experiences of the demonstrators, which read: 'CRUSHED BY THE MOUNTED POLICE AGAINST THE RAILINGS OF THE ABBEY, AND TRAMPLED UNDER THEIR HORSES HOOFS'.^[6] Fraser had the help of Mary Phillips in East Fife and during the 1907 Aberdeen South by-election she met Adela Pankhurst with whom she remained close friends throughout her life.^[1]

Her sister Annie, along with Maggie Moffatt, became one of the first Scottish suffragettes to be arrested.^[9]

During that early period, when suffragette tactics consisted of trying to reach the House of Commons, and in the first arrests when speaking in the lobby, my sister Anne was the first Scotswoman arrested. She had gone to London a day or two before. Called by my father to come downstairs, I found him with the Glasgow Herald open before him with a banner headline in the centre page: “Glasgow Councillor’s daughter arrested”. He said, “did you know about this.” I replied, “I knew she was going to a meeting but I did not know anything else. He looked at me under his brows in the way we regarded as serious and I oozed out of the room. He came home in the evening quite reconciled to it, and when Anne came home after fourteen cold days in Holloway Prison he took her to a municipal reception saying to her, “Put on your prettiest dress and come with me.” She looked charming and he introduced her all round as “My prisoner daughter”.

— Helen Fraser, Moyes, H (1971) A Woman in a Man’s World

In 1907, Janie Allan, being inspired by Fraser and Theresa Billington-Greig speaking about suffragette activity and organised a large WSPU meeting in St. Andrew's Hall, Glasgow.^[6]

Fraser took a prominent role in the WSPU's 1907 Hexham by-election campaign; for which by the Daily Mail praised her. She worked with Rachel Barrett, Elsa Gye and Mary Gawthorpe during the Dundee by-election the next year.^[6] During the Montrose burghs by-election in April 1908, as organising secretary for the WSPU, she was "heckled at considerable length".^[10] In 1908, Fraser attended the 'monster meeting' Women's Sunday and wrote to Isabel Seymour that it was 'successful but not entirely satisfactory'. Fraser estimated half a million people attended (a number supported by The Times estimates) but said that at three of the speaker platforms 'there was much rowdyism' and said 'it seemed to me that the mass of people were simply curious - not opposed- simply indifferent.^[6]

Fraser was also becoming disillusioned with the violent militant tactics of the WSPU. She criticised the actions of one WSPU member who broke the windows of Prime Minister H. H. Asquith. She resigned from the WSPU soon afterwards, and was approached by the National Union of Women's Suffrage Societies (NUWSS) and agreed to work for them.^[1] She was a member of the NUWSS national executive committee for fourteen years.^[3]

Fraser was effective as a public speaker and had speaking engagements not just in Scotland, but all around the UK. In a one-year period (1908–09), her meetings collected a total of £56.19.10 for the NUWSS.^[3] She spoke at the Aberdeen University Women's Suffrage Association, with Mary Gawthorpe, on the campaign to oppose Liberal candidates due to the government opposition to women's franchise, when a group of male students disrupted the event.^[11] Her action in moving a vote of no confidence in the Government at a public meeting where Mr Haldane was speaking in Rutherglan in 1908 led to her being ejected from the hall.^[12] Dr Marion Gilchrist joined Fraser in opening a suffrage campaign in the Christian Institute in Glasgow in the same year, and at a meeting in Motherwell also in 1908 Fraser spoke alongside Mrs Pankhurst and Mrs Pethick Lawrence.^[13]

In 1909, she conducted what the 'Dundee Courier' described as the 'longest continuous tour ever undertaken in Scotland to propagate women's suffrage',^[14] The article lists twenty-one different towns that were only part of the tour. Bridgend in Wales saw Fraser contrast the anomalies in men's votes being amended by Parliament whereas what she described as 'the greatest anomaly there was, was the injustice of excluding women from all rights of citizenship because they were women'^[15]

Chrystal MacMillan, Dr Elsie Inglis were just two of those who supported Fraser at the 1911 Glasgow (Tradeston) By-election in an event organised by the Glasgow and West of Scotland Association for Women's Suffrage.^[16]

In 1912, she spoke at a meeting in Cambridge organised by the Cambridge Women's Suffrage Association, held during a course of University Extension Lectures.

Rotten eggs were thrown at Helen after a meeting in Baltinglass (Ireland) in 1913. The meeting had taken place under the auspices of the Irish Women's Reform League.^[17] In contrast, Fraser's reception in Belfast was 'cordial', and the reporter reported applause being accorded to her a number of times during her talk; the event on this occasion being organised by the Irish Women's Suffrage Federation.^[18]

In 1915, she acted as temporary Honorary Secretary of the Penarth Women's Suffrage Society.^[3]

Political career, from 1914 onward

During the First World War, she worked as a Commissioner for the National War Saving Committee,^[19] in the course of which she personally set up 109 local War Savings Committees in England and Wales.^[20] She was seconded to the Board of Agriculture to persuade women to work on the land.^[1] In 1917, at the suggestion of Millicent Fawcett, she was included by the UK Government as part of the official British War Mission to the US,^[19] to speak about Britain's war effort. She travelled through 40 states and spoke 332 times in 312 days.^[1][3] She also had a meeting with President Woodrow Wilson.^[21] In 1918, upon her return to Britain, her book of the tour Women and War Work was published.^[3]

In 1918, when women gained the right to stand as parliamentary candidates, she turned her attention to the campaign to elect women as Members of Parliament. She spoke in Cardiff on behalf of the Joint Committee for Getting Women into Parliament.^[3] She did not contest the 1918 general election. She took an active role in the affairs of a number of organisations; she was a member of the Executive Committee, of the NUWSS successor organisation the National Union of Societies for Equal Citizenship, she was a member of the Common Interests Committee of the English-Speaking Union, she was involved in the Reunion of British War Missions in USA, she was a member of the Council for the Representation of Women in the League of Nations and she was a Member of the British Institute of International Affairs.^[19]

Her efforts during the war and after had come to the attention of Prime Minister David Lloyd George and she joined his National Liberal organisation. In 1922, she was the first woman to be adopted in Scotland as an official prospective parliamentary candidate when she was selected as National Liberal candidate for the Govan Division of Glasgow for the 1922 general election.^[1] She was one of only three women candidates (all Liberals) to contest the general election in Scotland.^[22] Govan was a safe Labour seat and she was not expected to win. Fraser was a prominent member of the Glasgow and West of Scotland Association for Women's Suffrage (GWSAWS). She had the GWSAWS backing to stand in Govan on the platform of the Liberal manifesto. This platform included the establishment of widows' pensions and an equal franchise for women. During her campaign she criticised her male Labour party opponent's "appropriation of our feminist ideals and policies."^[23]

1922 general election: Glasgow Govan^[24]

Party		Candidate	Votes	%	±%
	Labour	Neil Maclean	15,441	62.3	+14.5
	National Liberal	Miss Helen Fraser	9,336	37.7	+29.3
Majority			6,105	24.6
Turnout			24,777	78.3
	Labour hold		Swing	-7.4

In 1923 she went to Paris, France to attend the conference of the International Alliance of Women for Suffrage and Equal Citizenship as a delegate of the NUWSS.^[3] Later in 1923, following re-union between Lloyd George and Asquith, she switched constituencies to stand as Liberal party candidate for the Hamilton Division of Lanarkshire at the 1923 general election. Though also a Labour seat, it was believed that her prospects here were a little better. However, abuse and calumny by the Labour Party candidate Duncan Macgregor Graham made the experience a thoroughly unpleasant one.^[1]

General election 1923: Hamilton

Party		Candidate	Votes	%	±%
	Labour	Duncan Macgregor Graham	11,858	58.4	+0.8
	Liberal	Miss Helen Fraser	8,436	41.6	n/a
Majority			3,422	16.8	+1.6
Turnout				73.5	-4.8
	Labour hold		Swing	n/a

Her last political invitation was to fight the 1924 Glasgow Kelvingrove by-election^[25] but the Conservative candidate Walter Elliot was a friend, and she knew that she could poll enough votes to cause him to lose the seat, so she refused and gave up the idea of a career in politics. In 1925, she left the Liberal Party, and joined the Unionist Party.^[26] She cited her reasons in a letter published in the Glasgow Herald, those being the perceived lack of challenge to what she saw as the "tyranny of combinations and unions", which she felt should have been the intention of the party, dedicated as it was to the protection of individual rights against tyrannies.

Fraser then moved to London, earning money from freelance articles on women's issues. She was elected to Kensington Borough Council, sitting as a member for seven years.^[1]

Personal life and political activities in Australia

While living in London, Fraser was in contact with an old friend named James Moyes who had emigrated to Australia. His wife had died, and he asked Fraser to marry him several times before she accepted. She emigrated to Sydney in 1939.^[27] She later became the President of Women for Canberra, an organisation established to get more women to stand for election to the Australian Parliament^[27]

Late in her life she wrote an autobiography, entitled A Woman in a Man's World, which was published in 1971.^[1][28] Fraser died in Australia in 1979.^[6]

Archives

The Mitchell Library in Glasgow has a collection of material sent to them by Helen Fraser (by then known by her married name, Moyes). She sent the small collection of items, which includes some letters, newspaper cuttings, and copy of her autobiography, in 1978. Aware of the importance of preserving the story of participation in the women's movement, she said she wanted Glasgow to "have something" of her.^[29][30]

In 2018, the National Library of Scotland received a diary belonging to Fraser, which had been found in a recycling centre in Ulladulla, Australia.^[31] Also within the collection are some personal letters, correspondence and notes.^[32]

Oral History

Brian Harrison recorded 3 oral history interviews with Fraser, in January, August and September 1975, as part of the Suffrage Interviews project, titled Oral evidence on the suffragette and suffragist movements: the Brian Harrison interviews.^[33]  The interviews have been made available using the name Helen Moyes. Fraser talks about her family, and their support for women's suffrage, her involvement with the NUWSS as well as the WSPU, and the differences between the two organisations, as well as time in Wales, Scotland, France, the USA and Australia.

Cartoon

In 1928, 'The Tatler' published a cartoon headed 'A gathering of intelligentsia' featuring Helen, alongside Sir Ernest Benn, Sir Hugh Bell, Lord Leverhulme, Sir Robert Horne, Miss Lister and Lord Knebworth^[34]

Publications

• Women and War Work by Helen Fraser 1918
• A Woman in a Man's World by Helen Moyes 1971

References

1. Leah Leneman, "Moyes , Helen Miller (1881–1979)", Oxford Dictionary of National Biography, Oxford University Press, 2004 accessed 11 Feb 2014
2. Scotsman 11 November 1922
3. Crawford, Elizabeth (2 September 2003). The Women's Suffrage Movement: A Reference Guide 1866–1928. Routledge. pp. 230–232. ISBN 9780415239264.
4. Helen Fraser, Spartacus Educational
5. "Miss Helen Fraser". Votes for Women. 18 June 1908. Retrieved 3 March 2023.
6. Atkinson, Diane (2018). Rise up, women! : the remarkable lives of the suffragettes. London: Bloomsbury. pp. 49, 55, 93–4, 100, 308, 537. ISBN 9781408844045. OCLC 1016848621.
7. "Early suffragist campaigning". UK Parliament. Retrieved 6 March 2023.
8. "Image No: 10222633". www.maryevans.com. Retrieved 6 March 2023.
9. Elizabeth L. Ewan; Sue Innes; Sian Reynolds; Rose Pipes (27 June 2007). Biographical Dictionary of Scottish Women. Edinburgh University Press. pp. 269–. ISBN 978-0-7486-2660-1.
10. "Dundee Evening Telegraph". 16 April 1908.
11. Pedersen, Sarah. "The Aberdeen Women's Suffrage Campaign". suffrageaberdeen.co.uk. copyright WildFireOne. Retrieved 18 March 2023.
12. "Suffragette Leader ejected". The Dundee Courier. 9 January 1908. p. 5.
13. "Votes for women". The Motherwell Times and General Advertiser. 7 February 1908. p. 1.
14. "MISS HELEN FRASER LEADS: Constitutional propaganda for women's suffrage in Scotland". Dundee Courier. 8 September 1909. p. 4.
15. "Votes for women". The Glamorgan Gazette. 10 November 1911. p. 5.
16. "By-elections". The Common Cause. 13 July 1911. p. 250.
17. "Pithy Provincial News". The Irish Independent. 5 April 1913. p. 6.
18. "Women's Suffrage Federation". The Belfast News-Letter. 8 April 1913. p. 21.
19. The Woman's Year Book, 1923.
20. "Miss Helen Fraser's visit to America". Common Cause. 9 November 1917. Retrieved 7 August 2020.
21. Weiss, Elaine F (2008). Fruits of Victory:The women's land army of America in the Great War. Dulles, Virginia: Potomac Books.
22. Pat Thane; Esther Breitenbach, eds. (2012). Women and Citizenship in Britain and Ireland in the 20th Century: What Difference Did the Vote Make. p. 48. ISBN 9780826437495.
23. Gender and Political Identities in Scotland, 1919–1939 By Annmarie Hughes
24. F W S Craig, British Parliamentary Election Results 1918–1949; Political Reference Publications, Glasgow 1949
25. "The By-Elections." Times [London, England] 10 May 1924: 12. The Times Digital Archive. Web. 11 February 2014.
26. "Miss Helen Fraser leaves the Liberal Party". Glasgow Herald. 28 February 1925.
27. Brasher, Stephen (12 April 2015). "The Returning Officer: Suffragettes VI". New Statesman.
28. Moyes, Helen (1971). A Woman in a Man's World. Australia: Alpha Books.
29. "Moyes - Glasgow Libraries Online Library". libcat.csglasgow.org. Retrieved 6 March 2023.
30. corresp and news cuttings rel to women's suffrage movement and Scottish politics. 1908–1978.
31. Egginton, Heidi (Winter 2022). "A woman in a man's world". Discover. 47. National Library of Scotland: 14–16.
32. "Catalogue of Archives and Manuscripts Collections | National Library of Scotland | NLSMSS | Diary and correspondence of Helen Fraser". manuscripts.nls.uk. Retrieved 6 March 2023.
33. London School of Economics and Political Science. "The Suffrage Interviews". London School of Economics and Political Science. Retrieved 12 December 2023.
34. May, Fred (14 November 1928). "A GATHERING OF INTELLIGENTSIA". The Tatler. p. 76.

External links

• Works by Helen Fraser at Project Gutenberg
• Works by or about Helen Fraser at Internet Archive
• Barry York, ed. (1999). Helen Moyes. National Library Australia. p. 123. ISBN 9780642107152. {{cite book}}: |work= ignored (help)