Crannog

A crannog^[1][2][3] (/ˈkrænəɡ/; Irish: crannóg [ˈkɾˠan̪ˠoːɡ]; Scottish Gaelic: crannag [ˈkʰɾan̪ˠak]) is typically a partially or entirely artificial island, usually built in lakes and estuarine waters of Scotland, Wales, and Ireland. Unlike the prehistoric pile dwellings around the Alps, which were built on the shores and not inundated until later, crannogs were built in the water, thus forming artificial islands.

A reconstructed crannog near Kenmore, Perth and Kinross, on Loch Tay, Scotland

Crannogs were used as dwellings over five millennia, from the European Neolithic Period^[4] to as late as the 17th/early 18th century.^[3] In Scotland there is no convincing evidence in the archaeological record of Early and Middle Bronze Age or Norse Period use. The radiocarbon dating obtained from key sites such as Oakbank and Redcastle indicates at a 95.4 per cent confidence level that they date to the Late Bronze Age to Early Iron Age. The date ranges fall after around 800 BC and so could be considered Late Bronze Age by only the narrowest of margins.^[3][5]

Crannogs have been variously interpreted as free-standing wooden structures, as at Loch Tay,^[3] although more commonly they are composed of brush, stone or timber mounds that can be revetted with timber piles. However, in areas such as the Outer Hebrides of Scotland, timber was unavailable from the Neolithic era onwards.^[6] As a result, crannogs made completely of stone and supporting drystone architecture are common there.^[7] Today, crannogs typically appear as small, circular islets, often 10 to 30 metres (30 to 100 ft) in diameter, covered in dense vegetation due to their inaccessibility to grazing livestock.

Etymology and uncertain meanings

The Irish word crannóg derives from Old Irish crannóc,^[8] which referred to a wooden structure or vessel, stemming from crann, which means "tree", suffixed with "-óg" which is a diminutive ending ultimately borrowed from Welsh. The suffix -óg is sometimes misunderstood by non-native Irish-speakers as óg, which is a separate word that means "young". This misunderstanding leads to a folk etymology whereby crannóg is misanalysed as crann óg, which is pronounced differently and means "a young tree". The modern sense of the term first appears sometime around the 12th century; its popularity spread in the medieval period along with the terms isle, ylle, inis, eilean or oileán.^[9][10]

There is some confusion on what the term crannog originally referred to, as the structure atop the island or the island itself.^[9] The additional meanings of Irish crannóg can be variously related as 'structure/piece of wood', including 'crow's nest', 'pulpit', or 'driver's box on a coach'; 'vessel/box/chest' more generally; and 'wooden pin'.^[11] The Scottish Gaelic form is crannag and has the additional meanings of 'pulpit' and 'churn'.^[12] Thus, there is no real consensus on what the term crannog actually implies, although the modern adoption in the English language broadly refers to a partially or completely artificial islet that saw use from the prehistoric to the Post-Medieval period in Ireland and Scotland.^[9]

Location

Crannogs are widespread in Ireland, with an estimated 1,200 examples,^[13] while Scotland has 389 sites officially listed as such.^[14] The actual number in Scotland varies considerably depending on definition—between about 350 and 500, due to the use of the term "island dun" for well over one hundred Hebridean examples—a distinction that has created a divide between mainland Scottish crannog and Hebridean islet settlement studies.^[15][16] Previously unknown crannogs in Scotland and Ireland are still being found as underwater surveys continue to investigate loch beds for completely submerged examples.^[17]

The largest concentrations of crannogs in Ireland are found in the Drumlin Belt of the Midlands, North and Northwest. In Scotland, crannogs are mostly found on the western coast, with high concentrations in Argyll and Dumfries and Galloway.^[5][18] In reality, the Western Isles contain the highest density of lake-settlements in Scotland, yet they are recognised under varying terms besides "crannog".^[19] One lone Welsh example exists at Llangorse Lake, probably a product of Irish influence.^[20]

Reconstructed Irish crannógs are located at Craggaunowen, County Clare, in the Irish National Heritage Park, County Wexford and at Castle Espie, County Down. In Scotland there are reconstructions at the "Scottish Crannog Centre" at Loch Tay, Perthshire; this centre offers guided tours and hands-on activities, including wool-spinning, wood-turning and making fire, holds events to celebrate wild cooking and crafts, and hosts yearly Midsummer, Lughnasadh and Samhain festivals.^[21]

Types and problems with definition

 

A replica crannóg on Loch Tay

Crannogs took on many different forms and methods of construction based on what was available in the immediate landscape. The classic image of a prehistoric crannog stems from both post-medieval illustrations^[13] and highly influential excavations, such as Milton Loch in Scotland by C. M. Piggot after World War II.^[22] The Milton Loch interpretation is of a small islet surrounded or defined at its edges by timber piles and a gangway, topped by a typical Iron Age roundhouse.

The choice of a small islet as a home may seem odd today, yet waterways were the main channels for both communication and travel until the 19th century in much of Ireland and, especially, Highland Scotland. Crannogs are traditionally interpreted as simple prehistorical farmsteads. They are also interpreted as boltholes in times of danger, as status symbols with limited access, and as inherited locations of power that imply a sense of legitimacy and ancestry towards ownership of the surrounding landscape.

A strict definition of a crannog, which has long been debated, requires the use of timber.^[2] Sites in the Western Isles do not satisfy this criterion, although their inhabitants shared the common habit of living on water.^[2][15] If not classed as "true" crannogs, small occupied islets (often at least partially artificial in nature) may be referred to as "island duns.,^[7] But, rather confusingly, 22 islet-based sites are classified as "proper" crannogs due to the different interpretations of the inspectors or excavators who drew up field reports.^[23]

Hebridean island dwellings or crannogs were commonly built on both natural and artificial islets, usually reached by a stone causeway. The visible structural remains are traditionally interpreted^[24] as duns or, in more recent terminology, as "Atlantic roundhouses". This terminology has recently become popular when describing the entire range of robust, drystone structures that existed in later prehistoric Atlantic Scotland.^[19]

The majority of crannog excavations were poorly conducted (by modern standards) in the late 19th and early 20th centuries by early antiquarians, or were purely accidental finds as lochs were drained during the improvements to increase usable farmland or pasture.^[25][26][27] In some early digs, labourers hauled away tons of materials, with little regard to anything that was not of immediate economic value. Conversely, the vast majority of early attempts at proper excavation failed to accurately measure or record stratigraphy, thereby failing to provide a secure context for artefact finds. Thus only extremely limited interpretations are possible. Preservation and conservation techniques for waterlogged materials such as logboats or structural material were all but non-existent, and a number of extremely important finds were destroyed as a result: in some instances dried out for firewood.^[25]

 

Reconstructed crannog

From about 1900 to the late 1940s there was very little crannog excavation in Scotland, while some important and highly influential contributions were made in Ireland.^[28][29][30] In contrast, relatively few crannogs have been excavated since the Second World War. But this number has steadily grown, especially since the early 1980s, and may soon surpass pre-war totals.^[31][32][33] The overwhelming majority of crannogs show multiple phases of occupation and re-use, often extending over centuries. Thus the re-occupiers may have viewed crannogs as a legacy that was alive in local tradition and memory. Crannog reoccupation is important and significant, especially in the many instances of crannogs built near natural islets, which were often completely unused. This long chronology of use has been verified by both radiocarbon dating and more precisely by dendrochronology.^[31]

Interpretations of crannog function have not been static; instead they appear to have changed in both the archaeological and historic records. Rather than the simple domestic residences of prehistory, the medieval crannogs were increasingly seen as strongholds of the upper class or regional political players, such as the Gaelic chieftains of the O'Boylans and McMahons in County Monaghan and the Kingdom of Airgíalla, until the 17th century. In Scotland, the medieval and post-medieval use of crannogs is also documented into the early 18th century.^[3][9] Whether this increase in status is real, or just a by-product of increasingly complex material assemblages, remains to be convincingly validated.^[34]

History

The earliest-known constructed crannog is the completely artificial Neolithic islet of Eilean Dòmhnuill, Loch Olabhat on North Uist in Scotland. Eilean Domhnuill^[7] has produced radiocarbon dates ranging from 3650 to 2500 BC.^[4] Irish crannogs appear in middle Bronze Age layers at Ballinderry (1200–600 BC).^[35] Recent radiocarbon dating of worked timber found in Loch Bhorghastail on the Isle of Lewis has produced evidence of crannogs as old as 3380-3630 BC.^[36] Prior to the Bronze Age, the existence of artificial island settlement in Ireland is not as clear. While lakeside settlements are evident in Ireland from 4500 BC, these settlements are not crannogs, as they were not intended to be islands. Despite having a lengthy chronology, their use was not at all consistent or unchanging.

Crannog construction and occupation was at its peak in Scotland from about 800 BC to AD 200.^[5] Not surprisingly, crannogs have useful defensive properties, although there appears to be more significance to prehistoric use than simple defense, as very few weapons or evidence for destruction appear in excavations of prehistoric crannogs. In Ireland, crannogs were at their zenith during the Early Historic period,^[1] when they were the homes and retreats of kings, lords, prosperous farmers and, occasionally, socially marginalised groups, such as monastic hermits or metalsmiths who could work in isolation. Despite scholarly concepts supporting a strict Early Historic evolution,^[2] Irish excavations are increasingly uncovering examples that date from the "missing" Iron Age in Ireland.^[32]

Construction

 

Loughbrickland Crannóg in Northern Ireland.

The construction techniques for a crannog (prehistoric or otherwise) are as varied as the multitude of finished forms that make up the archaeological record. Island settlement in Scotland and Ireland is manifest through the entire range of possibilities ranging from entirely natural, small islets to completely artificial islets, therefore definitions remain contentious. For crannogs in the strict sense, typically the construction effort began on a shallow reef or rise in the lochbed.

When timber was available, many crannogs were surrounded by a circle of wooden piles, with axe-sharpened bases that were driven into the bottom, forming a circular enclosure that helped to retain the main mound and prevent erosion. The piles could also be joined together by mortise and tenon, or large holes cut to carefully accept specially shaped timbers designed to interlock and provide structural rigidity. On other examples, interior surfaces were built up with any mixture of clay, peat, stone, timber or brush – whatever was available. In some instances, more than one structure was built on crannogs.^[4]

In other types of crannogs, builders and occupants added large stones to the waterline of small natural islets, extending and enlarging them over successive phases of renewal. Larger crannogs could be occupied by extended families or communal groups, and access was either by logboats or coracles. Evidence for timber or stone causeways exists on a large number of crannogs. The causeways may have been slightly submerged; this has been interpreted as a device to make access difficult^[24] but may also be a result of loch level fluctuations over the ensuing centuries or millennia. Organic remains are often found in excellent condition on these water-logged sites. The bones of cattle, deer, and swine have been found in excavated crannogs, while remains of wooden utensils and even dairy products have been completely preserved for several millennia.^[3]

Fire and reconstruction

In June 2021, the Loch Tay Crannog was seriously damaged in a fire^[37] but funding was given to repair the structure, and conserve the museum materials retained.^[38] The UNESCO Chair in Refugee Integration through Languages and the Arts, Alison Phipps of Glasgow University and African artist Tawona Sithole considered its future and its impact as a symbol of common human history and 'potent ways of healing' including restarting the creative weaving with Soay sheep wool in 'a thousand touches'.^[39]

Citations

1. O'Sullivan, A. (2000). Crannogs: Lake Dwellings of Ireland. Dublin: Irish Treasure Series.
2. Lynn, C. J. (1983). "Some 'early' ring forts and crannogs". Journal of Irish Archaeology. 1: 47–58.
3. Dixon, Nicholas (2004). The Crannogs of Scotland: An underwater archaeology. Tempus Publishing, Limited. ISBN 0-7524-3151-X.
4. Armit, Ian (2003). "The Drowners: permanence and transience in the Hebridean Neolithic". In Armit, I.; Murphy, E.; Simpson, D. (eds.). Neolithic Settlement in Ireland and Western Britain. Oxford: Oxbow.
5. Henderson, J. C. (1998). "Islets through time: the definition, dating and distribution of Scottish crannogs". Oxford Journal of Archaeology. 17 (2): 227–44. doi:10.1111/1468-0092.00060.
6. Edwards, K. J.; Ralston, I., eds. (1997). Scotland After the Ice Age: Environment, Archaeology and History, 8000 BC–1000 AD. New York: Wiley & Sons.
7. Armit, Ian (1996). The Archaeology of Skye and the Western Isles. Edinburgh University Press.
8. . American Heritage Dictionary of the English Language. Houghton Mifflin. 2009. Archived from the original on 26 September 2012.
9. Morrison, I. (1985). Landscape with Lake Dwellings. Edinburgh University Press.
10. Ó Cróinín, Dáibhí; Moody, Theodore William (2005). A New History of Ireland: Prehistoric and early Ireland. Oxford University Press. ISBN 0-19-821737-4.
11. Dinneen, Patrick (1927). Foclóir Gaedhilge agus Béarla. Irish Texts Society.
12. Mark, C. (2003). The Gaelic English Dictionary. Routledge. p. 175. ISBN 0-203-22259-8.
13. O'Sullivan, A. (1998). The Archaeology of Lake Settlement in Ireland. Dublin: Discovery Programme.
14. . Archived from the original on 21 October 2012. Retrieved 27 November 2022.
15. Harding, D. W. (2000). "Crannogs and island duns: Classification, dating and function". Oxford Journal of Archaeology. 19 (3): 301–17. doi:10.1111/1468-0092.00111.
16. Harding, D. W. (2007). "Crannogs and island duns: An aerial perspective". In Barber, J.; Clarke, C.; Crone, A.; Hale, A.; Henderson, J.; Housley, R.; Sands, R.; Sheridan, A. (eds.). Archaeology from the Wetlands: Proceedings of the 11th WARP Conference, Edinburgh 2007. Society of Antiquaries of Scotland. pp. 267–73.
17. Lenfert, Robert (2009). Uist Island Dun Investigation – Dun Borosdale, Western Isles (South Uist parish), preliminary investigation. Discovery Excav Scot, New. Vol. 10. Wiltshire, England: Cathedral Communications Limited.
18. Henderson, J. C. (2000). "Shared traditions? The drystone settlement records of Atlantic Scotland and Ireland 700 BC – AD 200". In Henderson, J. C. (ed.). BAR 861. Oxford. pp. 117–54.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
19. Armit, Ian (1992). The Later Prehistory of the Western Isles of Scotland. BAR Brit Ser. 221. Oxford.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
20. Redknap, Mark; Lane, Alan (1994). "The early medieval crannog at Llangors, Powys: an interim statement on the 1989–1993 seasons". International Journal of Nautical Archaeology. 23 (3): 189–205. doi:10.1111/j.1095-9270.1994.tb00460.x.
21. http://www.crannog.co.uk
22. Piggott, C. M. (1953). "Milton Loch Crannog: a native house of the second century AD in Kirkcudbrightshire". Proceedings of the Society of Antiquaries of Scotland. 87: 134–52. doi:10.9750/PSAS.087.134.152. S2CID 257298470.
23. . Archived from the original on 21 October 2012. Retrieved 18 January 2011.
24. Beveridge, E. 1911. North Uist: Its Archaeology and Topography, William Brown, Edinburgh.
25. Munro, R. (1882). Ancient Scottish Lake Dwellings, or Crannogs. Edinburgh: David Douglas.
26. Wilde, W. R. 1840. "Antiquities recently discovered at Dunshanghlin". Proceedings of the Royal Irish Academy, vol. 1 pp. 420–426.
27. Wilson, G. 1873. "Notes on the crannogs and lake dwellings of Wigtownshire", Proceedings of the Society of Antiquaries of Scotland, vol. 9, pp. 368–378.
28. Hencken, H. O.1937. "Ballinderry Crannog 1", Proceedings of the Royal Irish Academy, vol. 43, pp. 103–239.
29. Hencken, H. O. 1942 "Ballinderry Crannog 2" in Proceedings of the Royal Irish Academy 47Ci (1942) 1–76.
30. Hencken, H.O. 1950. "Lagore Crannog: an Irish royal residence of the seventh to tenth century AD", in Proceedings of the Royal Irish Academy 53C, 1–248.
31. Crone, B. A. 2000. "The History of a Scottish Lowland Crannog: Excavations at Buiston, Ayrshire", 1989–90, STAR Monograph 4, AOC/Historic Scotland, Edinburgh.
32. O'Sullivan, A.; Sands, R. (2005). "Impressive, well-appointed, rich and enigmatic: Collure Demense crannog, Lough Derravaragh, County Westmeath". In Barber, J.; Clarke, C.; Crone, A.; Hale, A.; Henderson, J.; Housley, R.; Sands, R.; Sheridan, A. (eds.). Archaeology from the Wetlands: Proceedings of the 11th WARP Conference. Edinburgh: Society of Antiquaries for Scotland. pp. 303–11.
33. Scott, J. 1960. "Loch Glashan", Discovery and Excavation in Scotland no. 354.
34. Fredengren, Christina (2002). Crannogs: A Study of People's Interaction with Lakes, with Special Reference to Loch Gara in the North West of Ireland. Bray: Wordwell.
35. Carol Ruppé, Jan Barstad (2002). National Handbook of Underwater Archaeology. The Springer Series in Underwater Archaeology. Springer. ISBN 0-3064-6345-8.
36. Garrow, D. (2019). "Neolithic crannogs: Rethinking settlement, monumentality and deposition in the Outer Hebrides and beyond". Antiquity. 93 (369): 664–684. doi:10.15184/aqy.2019.41.
37. "'Simply awful': Recreated Iron Age roundhouse gutted by fire overnight". The National. Retrieved 22 August 2021.
38. "Scottish Government gives fire-hit Crannog Centre £51k to help recovery". The National. Retrieved 22 August 2021.
39. "A new vision of the Crannog centre after fire tore through cultural landmark". The National. Retrieved 22 August 2021.

General and cited references

• Burnett, George (1901). Allardyce, J. (ed.). The Family of Burnett of Leys. Aberdeen: New Spalding Club.
• Armit, Ian (2000). Scotland's Hidden History. Tempus Publishing. ISBN 0-7524-1400-3.
• Crone, A. (2000). The History of a Scottish Lowland Crannog: Excavations at Buiston. Monographs. Edinburgh: AOC/STAR.
• Halsall, Guy (2003). Warfare and Society in the Barbarian West, 450–900. London: Routledge.

External links

 

Wikimedia Commons has media related to Crannogs.

• Robert Lenfert MA PhD, crannogs.weebly.com, "Living on Water: Scottish Crannogs and Island Dwellings".
• Crannog.co.uk, The Scottish Crannog Centre Reconstruction of a crannog.
• McMahonsOfMonaghan.org, Crannog illustration showing attack in Monaghan, Ireland in the 16th century.
• Channel4.com, Time Team on Crannogs.
• Channel4.com, Time Team excavation at Loch Migdale, January 2004.
• Canmore 4 December 2008 at the Wayback Machine, Royal Commission on the Ancient and Historical Monuments of Scotland's Canmore database, a searchable database of archaeological and architectural sites in Scotland, including crannogs.
• About.com 20 July 2008 at the Wayback Machine, Llangors Crannog.
• The Iron Age Crannogs of Ayrshire, www.youtube.com, Crannogs in Ayrshire, Scotland.