fbpx
Wikipedia

Constitution of Hungary

The Fundamental Law of Hungary (Hungarian: Magyarország alaptörvénye), the country's constitution, was adopted by parliament on 18 April 2011, promulgated by the president a week later and entered into force on 1 January 2012. It is Hungary's first constitution adopted within a democratic framework and following free elections.

Constitution of Hungary
Overview
JurisdictionHungary
Ratified18 April 2011
Date effective1 January 2012
SystemUnitary parliamentary republic
Government structure
Branches3
Head of statePresident
ChambersUnicameral (National Assembly)
ExecutiveGovernment
JudiciaryCuria (Supreme Court)
Constitutional Court
FederalismUnitary
Electoral collegeNo
History
Amendments12
Last amended2023
Citation"Magyarország Alaptörvénye". (in Hungarian)
"The Fundamental Law of Hungary". (in English)
Author(s)Parliamentary Committee
SignatoriesPál Schmitt
SupersedesHungarian Constitution of 1949
Full text
Fundamental Law of Hungary at Wikisource
Constitution of Hungary at Hungarian Wikisource

The document succeeded the 1949 Constitution, originally adopted at the creation of the Hungarian People's Republic on 20 August 1949 and heavily amended on 23 October 1989. The 1949 Constitution was Hungary's first permanent written constitution and, until it was replaced, Hungary was the only former Eastern Bloc nation without an entirely new constitution after the end of communism.

Both domestically and abroad, the 2011 constitution has been the subject of controversy. Among the claims critics make are that it was adopted without sufficient input from the opposition and society at large, that it reflects the ideology of the ruling Fidesz party, and enshrines it in office, that it is rooted in a conservative Christian worldview despite Hungary not being a particularly devout country, and that it curtails and politicizes previously independent institutions. The government that enacted the charter has dismissed such assertions, saying it was enshrined lawfully and reflects the popular will.

Contents edit

The Fundamental Law is divided into sections and articles as outlined below.

Section and article(s) Subject area(s) Notes
National Avowal (preamble)
Foundation 21 articles (A-U) specifying the country's name, capital, official language, symbols, etc.
Freedom and Responsibility 31 articles (I-XXXI) covering citizens' rights and duties
The State 54 articles covering the state's attributes
1-7 The National Assembly
8 National Referendums
9-14 The President of the Republic
15-22 The Government
23 Autonomous Regulatory Organs
24 The Constitutional Court
25-28 Courts
29 The Prosecution Service
30 The Commissioner for Fundamental Rights
31-35 Local Governments
36-44 Public Finances
45 The Hungarian Defence Forces
46 The Police and National Security Services
47 Decisions on Participation in Military Operations
48-54 Special Legal Orders Provisions concerning state of national crisis, state of emergency,
state of preventive defence, unexpected attack and state of danger
Closing and Miscellaneous Provisions[1][2][3]

Overview edit

Described as socially and fiscally conservative,[4] the constitution initiates a number of changes. In an effort to push the public debt below 50% of gross domestic product (from above 80% at the time of adoption), the powers of the Constitutional Court on budget and tax matters are restricted until debt falls below 50%. The President is allowed to dissolve Parliament if a budget is not approved, and only companies with transparent activities and ownership structures are allowed to bid for government contracts. The powers of the head of the Hungarian National Bank are also limited, and the modification of tax and pension laws requires a two-thirds majority.[5][4] The life of a fetus is protected from the moment of conception, and although the move is seen as opening the possibility for a future ban or restrictions on abortion,[4] existing laws were unaffected.[6] Same-sex couples may legally register their partnerships, but marriage is defined as being between one man and one woman. A ban on discrimination does not mention age or sexual orientation, and the constitution allows life imprisonment for violent crimes without the possibility of parole.[4]

The constitution lowers judges' mandatory retirement age from 70 to the general retirement age, which was 62 at the time of adoption and is set to rise to 65 by 2022.[7][8][9] The provision also covers prosecutors but exempts the Prosecutor General and the head of Hungary's highest court, the Curia.[10] The country's name is changed from "Hungarian Republic" to "Hungary" but the country remains a republic.[11] The preamble of the constitution contains references to the Holy Crown, God, Christianity, the fatherland and traditional family values.[12] Laws affecting areas such as family policy, the pension system and taxation can be altered only through special legislation (cardinal acts) passed by a two-thirds majority of Parliament and are not subject to constitutional review.[13][14]

History edit

Background edit

For centuries, the Hungarian constitution was unwritten, based upon customary law.[15] There was no civil code either; lawyers worked with the Corpus Iuris Hungarici.[16] Among the laws that acquired constitutional force were a series of liberal statutes enacted during the 1848 Revolution; Statute XII of 1867 (enacting the Ausgleich); and further guarantees for constitutionalism, such as Statute IV of 1869, separating the executive and the judiciary; or the post-1870 statutes regulating local self-government and state administration.[17]

Following the advent of the Hungarian Soviet Republic, the Revolutionary Governing Council adopted a Provisional Constitution on 2 April 1919, providing for a Soviet-style political system. On 23 June, the National Assembly of Allied Councils adopted Hungary's first charter-like constitution, the Constitution of the Socialist Allied Council Republic of Hungary. However, that regime was crushed two months later and Hungary returned to its historical, unwritten pre-1918 constitution.[17]

Despite the lack of a written constitution, several constitutional laws were passed during the interwar period of the Kingdom of Hungary. Statute I of 1920 confirmed the monarchical form of government (albeit with a vacant throne, the king's powers being exercised by regent Miklós Horthy and his ministers) and vested legislative power in the diet. Statute XLVII dethroned the Habsburg-Lorraine dynasty. A second chamber was established by Statute XXII of 1926. Successive constitutional acts increased the power of the regent, who was empowered to nominate forty senators at first, and during World War II, eighty-seven.[18]

1949 Constitution edit

In August 1949, with the Hungarian Working People's Party in complete control of the country, a constitution based on the 1936 Soviet Constitution was adopted,[19] the party's leading role enshrined in the document.[20] Its basic features remained in place until 1989, although a number of important amendments were made, including one in 1972 that proclaimed Hungary a socialist state.[21] While the constitution guaranteed certain fundamental rights, their scope was limited by provisions stating they had to be exercised in harmony with the interests of the socialist society.[22]

In 1989, as the Communist regime ended, the legislature overwhelmingly approved nearly a hundred changes to the constitution which purged the document's Communist character. Hungary was now defined as a civil democratic and constitutional republic that respected "the values of both bourgeois democracy and democratic socialism."[23][24] After the opposition won free elections in 1990, references to democratic socialism and the planned economy were dropped.[25] Further modifications followed over the ensuing two decades,[26] as successive plans for a new constitution did not reach fulfillment.[27]

2011 Constitution edit

Drafting process edit

In 2010, a new government led by Fidesz initiated a drafting process for a new constitution.[28][29] A parliamentary committee for drafting the constitution was set up, with all five parliamentary parties represented;[30] the draft was composed on the iPad of József Szájer, then a member of the European Parliament.[31] The following February, a body responsible for national consultations on a draft was set up by Szájer; its members included János Csák, Hungarian ambassador to the United Kingdom; Zsigmond Járai, chairman of the supervisory board of the National Bank; József Pálinkás, president of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences and former Minister of Education; and Katalin Szili, former Hungarian Socialist Party Speaker of the National Assembly.[32] The consultation involved questionnaires being mailed out to all citizens for their opinions; some 917,000 or 11% were returned.[33] Provisions were then included or excluded based on consensus among respondents; for instance, a proposal to adopt voting rights for minors was shelved after citizens expressed disapproval.[34]

The following April 18, Parliament approved the constitution by the required two-thirds majority, on a 262–44 vote, with Fidesz and their Christian Democrat coalition partners in favor and Jobbik opposed. The Hungarian Socialist Party and Politics Can Be Different (LMP), citing the ruling party's unwillingness to compromise on issues and their inability to change the outcome, boycotted both the drafting process and the vote.[31][12][35] On April 25, President Pál Schmitt signed the document into law, and it entered into force on the first day of 2012.[11] The enactment came halfway through Hungary's six-month Presidency of the Council of the European Union.[5]

Domestic reactions and subsequent developments edit

According to Fidesz parliamentary group chairman János Lázár, the constitution marks a break with Hungary’s communist past,[5] while Prime Minister Viktor Orbán said it completes a transition to democracy and allows for sound finances and clean government after years of mismanagement and scandals.[4] However, the opposition accused Fidesz of using its two-thirds majority in Parliament to push through its own constitution without cross-party consensus.[11] Prior to and during the vote to adopt the constitution, thousands of protesters demonstrated in Budapest against its adoption; among their complaints are that it is an attempt by the government to cement its power beyond its term, force its Christian ideology on the country and limit civil liberties. Lack of opposition participation was also mentioned, but Deputy Prime Minister Tibor Navracsics responded that other parties were invited to participate but refused.[12] Members of the Hungarian business community mentioned possible future difficulties in adopting the euro, noting a provision that enshrines the forint as legal tender. However, a government official said that, if the two-thirds majority to change this provision could not be attained, it could be circumvented by other means, such as a referendum.[36]

One section of the preamble criticized by some historians as well as by the head of Hungary's Jewish community is the statement that the country lost its independence when it was invaded and occupied by Nazi Germany in March 1944. They asserted that the provision implies the state was not responsible for the ensuing deportation of Jews to extermination camps as part of the Holocaust and that it could affect future restitution claims.[37] Historian Géza Jeszenszky strongly rejected criticism of the passage, saying the loss of Hungarian sovereignty in March 1944 due to foreign invasion is simply a historical fact that should not be denied. In its support, he also mentioned Germany's direct intervention into Hungarian politics, such as the arrest of cabinet members and of anti-German politicians.[38] Socialist leader Attila Mesterházy denounced what he called "Fidesz's party constitution" and promised to change the constitution "on the basis of a national consensus" following the next elections.[12][39] László Sólyom, former President of Hungary and of the Constitutional Court, is a critic of limits imposed on the court and of the "common parliamentary wrangling" through which the charter was adopted.[40][41]

The day after New Year's Day 2012, the government held a gala celebration at the Hungarian State Opera House to mark the entry into force of the constitution. Outside on Andrássy út, tens of thousands of people protested the occasion, with opponents claiming the constitution threatens democracy by removing checks and balances. Demonstrators included representatives from various civil groups and opposition parties, among them the Socialists. Fidesz MP Gergely Gulyás, who helped write the constitution, responded to critics by saying that it improves the legal framework of life in Hungary.[42][43]

International reactions edit

The Venice Commission and the Hungarian Helsinki Committee expressed concern over the provision on cardinal acts; opposition parties asserted these could bind future governments to Fidesz' actions, but did promise to participate in the debate on the acts.[14][13] Amnesty International believes the document "violates international and European human rights standards", citing the clauses on fetal protection, marriage and life imprisonment, and sexual orientation not being covered in the anti-discrimination clause. Left-wing and liberal members of the European Parliament asserted that it fails to protect citizens' rights and reduces legislative checks and balances.[11] Among these was Guy Verhofstadt, head of the Alliance of Liberals and Democrats for Europe, who said the constitution could limit "fundamental human rights" and was adopted without transparency, flexibility, a spirit of compromise and sufficient time for debate.[44] Werner Hoyer, Germany's deputy foreign minister, expressed his country's concern as well,[12] prompting the Hungarian Foreign Affairs Ministry to dismiss the remarks as "inexplicable and unacceptable".[45] Additionally, United Nations Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon suggested the government should address concerns about the constitution.[46]

In neighboring Slovakia, which has a significant Hungarian minority, at least three parties, including the governing Slovak Democratic and Christian Union, expressed concern about clauses that afford certain rights to ethnic Hungarians abroad, including the right to dual citizenship and the right to vote, and critics there fear that the move has expansive and nationalist objectives. Slovakia's Foreign Affairs Ministry stated that it would oppose any other country’s infringement of the Slovak Constitution, its sovereignty or the rights of its citizens.[47] In response, Foreign Minister János Martonyi assured his Slovak counterpart that the constitution has no extraterritorial effect.[48]

2013 amendments edit

In March 2013, Parliament amended the constitution for the fourth time, on a 265-11 vote, with Fidesz, the Christian Democrats and three independents in favor and the Socialists boycotting the vote; there were also 33 abstentions.[49][50] Subsequently, President János Áder signed the amendment into law, citing his legal duty and the need to preserve national unity.[51][52] The fifteen-page amendment touches on several aspects. It annuls rulings of the Constitutional Court made before the 2011 constitution went into force, while allowing their legal effects to remain. It endows the president of the Curia and the chief prosecutor with the power to initiate constitutional review of laws. While giving the Constitutional Court the power to review the constitution itself on procedural grounds, it stipulates that the court cannot annul a law passed by a two-thirds parliamentary majority. Judges and prosecutors are obliged to retire at the general retirement age, although that age is left unstated; the Curia head and the chief prosecutor are exempt. The amendment enshrines freedom of religion and allows constitutional complaints regarding the church law. It allows civil lawsuits for hate speech targeting an individual's community, and declares that communism is condemned. The measure requires students whose education is subsidized by the state to work in Hungary for a period after graduation or reimburse their tuition costs to the state. It allows only public media to air political advertising prior to general and European elections. The importance of the traditional family is stressed, and authorities are empowered to ban living in certain public spaces, although homelessness is not outlawed. A prior proposal on requiring voters to register prior to elections was not included after being earlier voided by the Constitutional Court.[53]

The amendment drew criticism both within Hungary and abroad. The Socialist floor leader labeled the measure an attempt to restrict the Constitutional Court's powers, and party members hung black flags from the Hungarian Parliament Building's windows, in sign of mourning for democracy. The LMP charged that the government was "dismantling constitutional values", while former prime minister Ferenc Gyurcsány, head of the small Democratic Coalition, also drew attention to the diminution in the court's prerogatives.[49] A protest in Budapest held in the days before parliamentary approval was given drew several thousands,[54] while on the day of the vote, a few hundred turned out.[55] José Manuel Barroso, President of the European Commission, and Thorbjørn Jagland, Secretary General of the Council of Europe, together raised concerns about the amendment's impact on the rule of law,[56] while prominent EU politicians, including Verhofstadt and Martin Schulz, expressed more forceful criticism.[57] Orbán denied that the powers of the Constitutional Court had been curtailed, challenging critics to explain just how the amendment is undemocratic,[58] while his party explained that the measure was needed in order to delineate the new constitution from the previous one.[50]

That September, a fifth amendment was passed in response to recommendations from the Constitutional Court, the European Commission and the Venice Commission. Approved by Fidesz parliamentarians, it was opposed by LMP and the Socialists, while Jobbik abstained. The provision granted the National Bank oversight of financial markets; eliminated a provision allowing judicial cases to be transferred from one court to another, as well as one allowing taxes to be raised for financing fines charged to the Hungarian state by international court rulings; clarified the recognition of religious communities and allowed political campaign ads to be aired on public as well as commercial television and radio free of charge.[59] Following the amendment's adoption, Jagland praised government efforts to address international criticism.[60]

Notes edit

  1. ^ (in Hungarian) Consolidated version of the Fundamental Law of Hungary incorporating the five amendments 2014-02-21 at the Wayback Machine
  2. ^ (in Hungarian) Text of the Fundamental Law of Hungary as adopted by the National Assembly on 18 April 2011
  3. ^ (in English) Consolidated version of the Fundamental Law of Hungary incorporating the five amendments
  4. ^ a b c d e , The Washington Post, 18 April 2011; accessed April 25, 2011
  5. ^ a b c Judy Dempsey, "Hungarian Parliament Approves New Constitution", The New York Times, 18 April 2011; accessed April 25, 2011
  6. ^ (in Hungarian) Kata Janecskó, "Hiába védett a magzat, nem szigorodik az abortusz" ("Despite Fetal Protection, Abortion Law Is Not Tightened"), index.hu, 11 March 2011; accessed June 23, 2011
  7. ^ "Bírói egyesület: átmeneti rendelkezések kellenek" ("Judges' Association: Transitional Provisions Needed")[permanent dead link], mti.hu, 19 April 2011; accessed April 26, 2011
  8. ^ "Judges protest planned mandatory retirement age cut in planned new constitution" 2012-03-11 at the Wayback Machine, politics.hu, 15 April 2011; accessed May 13, 2011
  9. ^ "Hungary" at the OECD Library; accessed April 26, 2011
  10. ^ (in Hungarian) "Botrány lesz a bírák nyugdíjazásából" ("Retirement of Judges Will Be a Scandal") 2011-10-03 at the Wayback Machine, nepszava.hu, 22 June 2011; accessed June 23, 2011
  11. ^ a b c d "Hungarian president signs new constitution despite human rights concerns". Deutsche Welle. 25 April 2011. Retrieved 25 April 2011.
  12. ^ a b c d e "Hungary's parliament passes controversial new constitution", Deutsche Welle, 18 April 2011; accessed April 25, 2011
  13. ^ a b "Socialists, LMP to join parliamentary debate on supermajority laws" 2011-08-17 at the Wayback Machine, politics.hu, 21 April 2011; accessed April 26, 2011
  14. ^ a b Margit Feher, "Hungary Passes New Constitution Amid Concerns", The Wall Street Journal, 18 April 2011; accessed April 26, 2011
  15. ^ Körösényi, p.145
  16. ^ Mezhikovskii, p.122
  17. ^ a b Harmathy, p.4
  18. ^ Ludwikowski, p.30
  19. ^ Ludwikowski, p.31
  20. ^ Harmathy, p.7
  21. ^ Rakowska-Harmstone, p.100
  22. ^ Somody, p.211
  23. ^ "Hungary Purges Stalinism From Its Constitution". The New York Times. October 19, 1989.
  24. ^ Harmathy, p.8-9
  25. ^ Harmathy, p. 9
  26. ^ Dupré, p. 173-4
  27. ^ (in Hungarian) "Magyarázkodásra kényszerül Gyurcsány" ("Gyurcsány Is Forced to Explain") 2011-09-27 at the Wayback Machine, Magyar Nemzet, 4 April 2011; accessed April 25, 2011.
  28. ^ "Hungary's new constitution drafted by next March, says Fidesz official" 2012-03-11 at the Wayback Machine, politics.hu, 2 August 2010; accessed August 18, 2010
  29. ^ (in Hungarian) "Bihari szerint mindig lehet jobb" ("According to Bihari, One May Always Do Better"), FN.hu, 7 August 2010; accessed August 18, 2010
  30. ^ (in Hungarian) "Megalakult az alkotmány-előkészítő bizottság" ("Constitutional Draft Committee Is Formed") 2011-09-28 at the Wayback Machine, hirtv.hu, 28 June 2010; accessed June 23, 2011
  31. ^ a b Zoltán Simon, "Hungary First to Write a Constitution on IPad, Lawmaker Says", Bloomberg, 4 March 2011; accessed April 25, 2011
  32. ^ "Body set up for national consultation on new constitution" 2012-03-09 at the Wayback Machine, politics.hu, 7 February 2011; accessed April 25, 2011
  33. ^ (in Hungarian) "Szájer: Óriási siker a nemzeti konzultáció" ("Szájer: National Consultation a Huge Success") 2011-09-27 at the Wayback Machine, Magyar Nemzet, 4 April 2011; accessed June 23, 2011
  34. ^ (in Hungarian) "Orbán: kivételesen erős lesz az új alkotmány" ("Orbán: New Constitution Will Be Exceptionally Strong") 2011-10-02 at the Wayback Machine, MR1-Kossuth Rádió, 28 March 2011; accessed June 23, 2011
  35. ^ "Hungarian president signs new constitution despite human rights concerns", Deutsche Welle, 25 April 2011; accessed December 29, 2019
  36. ^ "Foreign firms criticize Hungary's new constitution", Deutsche Welle, 20 April 2011; accessed April 25, 2011
  37. ^ Thomas Orszag-Land, "Hungary 'deceitful' over Holocaust", The Jewish Chronicle, 10 June 2011; accessed June 12, 2011
  38. ^ (in Hungarian) "Az alaptörvény és a magyar történelem" ("The Basic Law and Hungarian History") 2011-06-01 at the Wayback Machine Népszabadság, 31 May 2011; accessed June 23, 2011
  39. ^ "Socialists pledge to 'correct' constitution as soon as possible" 2012-03-26 at the Wayback Machine, politics.hu, 13 April 2011; accessed April 26, 2011
  40. ^ "Former state president warns about possible mistakes around new constitution" 2012-03-11 at the Wayback Machine, politics.hu, 7 March 2011; accessed April 26, 2011
  41. ^ "Constitution - Hungary European democracy despite basic law's shortcomings, says ex-president", mti.hu, 18 April 2011; accessed April 26, 2011
  42. ^ Palko Karasz and Melissa Eddy, "Opposition Protests Constitution in Hungary", The New York Times, 2 January 2012; accessed January 15, 2012
  43. ^ "Hungarians protest against new Fidesz constitution", BBC News, 3 January 2012; accessed January 15, 2012
  44. ^ "Hungarian People's Party deputies reject liberal group's concerns about new constitution" 2012-03-11 at the Wayback Machine, politics.hu, 18 April 2011; accessed April 26, 2011
  45. ^ "Orbán spokesman says Germany must not interfere with Hungary's adoption of new constitution" 2012-03-11 at the Wayback Machine, politics.hu, 20 April 2011; accessed April 26, 2011
  46. ^ "UN Secretary-General cautions gov't over constitution and media law" 2012-03-11 at the Wayback Machine, politics.hu, 19 April 2011; accessed April 25, 2011
  47. ^ "Slovakia on edge as Hungary passes new Constitution" 2012-01-18 at the Wayback Machine, thedaily.sk, 19 April 2011; accessed April 25, 2011
  48. ^ (in Hungarian) "Martonyi: Az új alkotmánynak nincs területen kívüli hatálya" ("Martonyi: the New Constitution Has No Extraterritorial Effect") 2011-05-14 at the Wayback Machine, hirtv.hu, 12 May 2011; accessed June 23, 2011
  49. ^ a b "Parliament passes constitutional amendments that critics call undemocratic" 2014-12-22 at the Wayback Machine, politics.hu, 11 March 2013; accessed March 21, 2013
  50. ^ a b "Hungary defies critics over change to constitution", BBC News, 11 March 2013; accessed March 21, 2013
  51. ^ "Áder pledges to sign constitutional amendments, citing need for national unity" 2014-02-22 at the Wayback Machine, politics.hu, 13 March 2013; accessed March 21, 2013
  52. ^ (in Hungarian) "Áder aláírja az alaptörvény-módosítást", hvg.hu, 13 March 2013; accessed March 21, 2013
  53. ^ "Preview: Parliament to vote on controversial constitutional amendments on Monday" 2016-01-16 at the Wayback Machine, politics.hu, 9 March 2013; accessed March 21, 2013
  54. ^ "Thousands demonstrate against new constitutional amendments in Budapest" 2013-12-20 at the Wayback Machine, politics.hu, 9 March 2013; accessed March 21, 2013
  55. ^ "Protesters against constitutional amendments block Chain Bridge in Budapest" 2013-12-20 at the Wayback Machine, politics.hu, 12 March 2013; accessed March 21, 2013
  56. ^ "EU to examine whether Hungary’s constitutional amendments conform with law" 2013-12-20 at the Wayback Machine, politics.hu, 13 March 2013; accessed March 21, 2013
  57. ^ "Top EU politicians condemn Hungary’s decision to amend the Constitution" 2013-12-20 at the Wayback Machine, politics.hu, 12 March 2013; accessed March 21, 2013
  58. ^ "Orbán says Constitutional Court has lost none of its powers to assess laws" 2013-12-20 at the Wayback Machine, politics.hu, 14 March 2013; accessed March 21, 2013
  59. ^ "Hungary’s parliament approves 5th constitutional amendment" 2014-03-07 at the Wayback Machine, politics.hu, 16 September 2013; accessed March 7, 2014
  60. ^ (in Hungarian) "Magyarország bűnlajstroma – ezért támad az EU és Amerika" 2014-11-09 at the Wayback Machine, valasz.hu, 6 November 2014; accessed November 19, 2014

References edit

  • Dupré, Catherine. Importing the Law in Post-communist Transitions (2003), Hart Publishing, ISBN 1-84113-131-8
  • Harmathy, Attila (ed.). Introduction to Hungarian Law (1998), Kluwer Law International, ISBN 90-411-1066-6
  • Körösényi, András. Government and Politics in Hungary (2000), Central European University Press, ISBN 963-9116-76-9
  • Ludwikowski, Rett R. Constitution-making in the Region of Former Soviet Dominance (1996), Duke University Press, ISBN 0-8223-1802-4
  • Mezhikovskii, S. M. et al. Law and Religion in Post-Communist Europe (2003), Peeters Publishers, ISBN 90-429-1262-6
  • Mullerson, Rein et al. Constitutional Reform and International Law in Central and Eastern Europe (1998), Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, ISBN 90-411-0526-3
  • Rakowska-Harmstone, Teresa. Communism in Eastern Europe (1984), Indiana University Press, ISBN 0-253-31391-0
  • Somody, Bernadette. "Raising the Standard? The Current Challenges in Human Rights Protection in Hungary" (2013), in Constitutional Evolution in Central and Eastern Europe, ed. Alexander H E Morawa, Kyriaki Topidi, Ashgate Publishing, ISBN 978-1-40-949740-0
  • Szikinger, István. "Hungary's Pliable Constitution" (2001) in Democratic Consolidation in Eastern Europe: Institutional Engineering, ed. Jan Zielonka, Oxford University Press, ISBN 0-19-924408-1

External links edit

  • (in English) Constitutional background, with full list of amendments from 1989 to 2003
  • (in English) , with amendments through 2011
  • (in Hungarian)
  • (in Hungarian) Text of the Fundamental Law of Hungary (as in force on 1 January 2023)
  • (in English) English translation of the Fundamental Law of Hungary (as in force on 1 January 2023)
  • (in English) of the Venice Commission on the 2011 constitution
  • (in English) Resolution of the European Parliament on the 2011 constitution
  • (in English) Text of the Fourth Amendment

constitution, hungary, fundamental, hungary, hungarian, magyarország, alaptörvénye, country, constitution, adopted, parliament, april, 2011, promulgated, president, week, later, entered, into, force, january, 2012, hungary, first, constitution, adopted, within. The Fundamental Law of Hungary Hungarian Magyarorszag alaptorvenye the country s constitution was adopted by parliament on 18 April 2011 promulgated by the president a week later and entered into force on 1 January 2012 It is Hungary s first constitution adopted within a democratic framework and following free elections Constitution of HungaryOverviewJurisdictionHungaryRatified18 April 2011Date effective1 January 2012SystemUnitary parliamentary republicGovernment structureBranches3Head of statePresidentChambersUnicameral National Assembly ExecutiveGovernmentJudiciaryCuria Supreme Court Constitutional CourtFederalismUnitaryElectoral collegeNoHistoryAmendments12Last amended2023Citation Magyarorszag Alaptorvenye in Hungarian The Fundamental Law of Hungary in English Author s Parliamentary CommitteeSignatoriesPal SchmittSupersedesHungarian Constitution of 1949Full textFundamental Law of Hungary at WikisourceConstitution of Hungary at Hungarian Wikisource The document succeeded the 1949 Constitution originally adopted at the creation of the Hungarian People s Republic on 20 August 1949 and heavily amended on 23 October 1989 The 1949 Constitution was Hungary s first permanent written constitution and until it was replaced Hungary was the only former Eastern Bloc nation without an entirely new constitution after the end of communism Both domestically and abroad the 2011 constitution has been the subject of controversy Among the claims critics make are that it was adopted without sufficient input from the opposition and society at large that it reflects the ideology of the ruling Fidesz party and enshrines it in office that it is rooted in a conservative Christian worldview despite Hungary not being a particularly devout country and that it curtails and politicizes previously independent institutions The government that enacted the charter has dismissed such assertions saying it was enshrined lawfully and reflects the popular will Contents 1 Contents 1 1 Overview 2 History 2 1 Background 2 2 1949 Constitution 2 3 2011 Constitution 2 3 1 Drafting process 2 3 2 Domestic reactions and subsequent developments 2 3 3 International reactions 2 3 4 2013 amendments 3 Notes 4 References 5 External linksContents editThe Fundamental Law is divided into sections and articles as outlined below Section and article s Subject area s Notes National Avowal preamble Foundation 21 articles A U specifying the country s name capital official language symbols etc Freedom and Responsibility 31 articles I XXXI covering citizens rights and duties The State 54 articles covering the state s attributes 1 7 The National Assembly 8 National Referendums 9 14 The President of the Republic 15 22 The Government 23 Autonomous Regulatory Organs 24 The Constitutional Court 25 28 Courts 29 The Prosecution Service 30 The Commissioner for Fundamental Rights 31 35 Local Governments 36 44 Public Finances 45 The Hungarian Defence Forces 46 The Police and National Security Services 47 Decisions on Participation in Military Operations 48 54 Special Legal Orders Provisions concerning state of national crisis state of emergency state of preventive defence unexpected attack and state of danger Closing and Miscellaneous Provisions 1 2 3 Overview edit Described as socially and fiscally conservative 4 the constitution initiates a number of changes In an effort to push the public debt below 50 of gross domestic product from above 80 at the time of adoption the powers of the Constitutional Court on budget and tax matters are restricted until debt falls below 50 The President is allowed to dissolve Parliament if a budget is not approved and only companies with transparent activities and ownership structures are allowed to bid for government contracts The powers of the head of the Hungarian National Bank are also limited and the modification of tax and pension laws requires a two thirds majority 5 4 The life of a fetus is protected from the moment of conception and although the move is seen as opening the possibility for a future ban or restrictions on abortion 4 existing laws were unaffected 6 Same sex couples may legally register their partnerships but marriage is defined as being between one man and one woman A ban on discrimination does not mention age or sexual orientation and the constitution allows life imprisonment for violent crimes without the possibility of parole 4 The constitution lowers judges mandatory retirement age from 70 to the general retirement age which was 62 at the time of adoption and is set to rise to 65 by 2022 7 8 9 The provision also covers prosecutors but exempts the Prosecutor General and the head of Hungary s highest court the Curia 10 The country s name is changed from Hungarian Republic to Hungary but the country remains a republic 11 The preamble of the constitution contains references to the Holy Crown God Christianity the fatherland and traditional family values 12 Laws affecting areas such as family policy the pension system and taxation can be altered only through special legislation cardinal acts passed by a two thirds majority of Parliament and are not subject to constitutional review 13 14 History editBackground edit For centuries the Hungarian constitution was unwritten based upon customary law 15 There was no civil code either lawyers worked with the Corpus Iuris Hungarici 16 Among the laws that acquired constitutional force were a series of liberal statutes enacted during the 1848 Revolution Statute XII of 1867 enacting the Ausgleich and further guarantees for constitutionalism such as Statute IV of 1869 separating the executive and the judiciary or the post 1870 statutes regulating local self government and state administration 17 Following the advent of the Hungarian Soviet Republic the Revolutionary Governing Council adopted a Provisional Constitution on 2 April 1919 providing for a Soviet style political system On 23 June the National Assembly of Allied Councils adopted Hungary s first charter like constitution the Constitution of the Socialist Allied Council Republic of Hungary However that regime was crushed two months later and Hungary returned to its historical unwritten pre 1918 constitution 17 Despite the lack of a written constitution several constitutional laws were passed during the interwar period of the Kingdom of Hungary Statute I of 1920 confirmed the monarchical form of government albeit with a vacant throne the king s powers being exercised by regent Miklos Horthy and his ministers and vested legislative power in the diet Statute XLVII dethroned the Habsburg Lorraine dynasty A second chamber was established by Statute XXII of 1926 Successive constitutional acts increased the power of the regent who was empowered to nominate forty senators at first and during World War II eighty seven 18 1949 Constitution edit Main article Hungarian Constitution of 1949 In August 1949 with the Hungarian Working People s Party in complete control of the country a constitution based on the 1936 Soviet Constitution was adopted 19 the party s leading role enshrined in the document 20 Its basic features remained in place until 1989 although a number of important amendments were made including one in 1972 that proclaimed Hungary a socialist state 21 While the constitution guaranteed certain fundamental rights their scope was limited by provisions stating they had to be exercised in harmony with the interests of the socialist society 22 In 1989 as the Communist regime ended the legislature overwhelmingly approved nearly a hundred changes to the constitution which purged the document s Communist character Hungary was now defined as a civil democratic and constitutional republic that respected the values of both bourgeois democracy and democratic socialism 23 24 After the opposition won free elections in 1990 references to democratic socialism and the planned economy were dropped 25 Further modifications followed over the ensuing two decades 26 as successive plans for a new constitution did not reach fulfillment 27 2011 Constitution edit Drafting process edit In 2010 a new government led by Fidesz initiated a drafting process for a new constitution 28 29 A parliamentary committee for drafting the constitution was set up with all five parliamentary parties represented 30 the draft was composed on the iPad of Jozsef Szajer then a member of the European Parliament 31 The following February a body responsible for national consultations on a draft was set up by Szajer its members included Janos Csak Hungarian ambassador to the United Kingdom Zsigmond Jarai chairman of the supervisory board of the National Bank Jozsef Palinkas president of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences and former Minister of Education and Katalin Szili former Hungarian Socialist Party Speaker of the National Assembly 32 The consultation involved questionnaires being mailed out to all citizens for their opinions some 917 000 or 11 were returned 33 Provisions were then included or excluded based on consensus among respondents for instance a proposal to adopt voting rights for minors was shelved after citizens expressed disapproval 34 The following April 18 Parliament approved the constitution by the required two thirds majority on a 262 44 vote with Fidesz and their Christian Democrat coalition partners in favor and Jobbik opposed The Hungarian Socialist Party and Politics Can Be Different LMP citing the ruling party s unwillingness to compromise on issues and their inability to change the outcome boycotted both the drafting process and the vote 31 12 35 On April 25 President Pal Schmitt signed the document into law and it entered into force on the first day of 2012 11 The enactment came halfway through Hungary s six month Presidency of the Council of the European Union 5 Domestic reactions and subsequent developments edit According to Fidesz parliamentary group chairman Janos Lazar the constitution marks a break with Hungary s communist past 5 while Prime Minister Viktor Orban said it completes a transition to democracy and allows for sound finances and clean government after years of mismanagement and scandals 4 However the opposition accused Fidesz of using its two thirds majority in Parliament to push through its own constitution without cross party consensus 11 Prior to and during the vote to adopt the constitution thousands of protesters demonstrated in Budapest against its adoption among their complaints are that it is an attempt by the government to cement its power beyond its term force its Christian ideology on the country and limit civil liberties Lack of opposition participation was also mentioned but Deputy Prime Minister Tibor Navracsics responded that other parties were invited to participate but refused 12 Members of the Hungarian business community mentioned possible future difficulties in adopting the euro noting a provision that enshrines the forint as legal tender However a government official said that if the two thirds majority to change this provision could not be attained it could be circumvented by other means such as a referendum 36 One section of the preamble criticized by some historians as well as by the head of Hungary s Jewish community is the statement that the country lost its independence when it was invaded and occupied by Nazi Germany in March 1944 They asserted that the provision implies the state was not responsible for the ensuing deportation of Jews to extermination camps as part of the Holocaust and that it could affect future restitution claims 37 Historian Geza Jeszenszky strongly rejected criticism of the passage saying the loss of Hungarian sovereignty in March 1944 due to foreign invasion is simply a historical fact that should not be denied In its support he also mentioned Germany s direct intervention into Hungarian politics such as the arrest of cabinet members and of anti German politicians 38 Socialist leader Attila Mesterhazy denounced what he called Fidesz s party constitution and promised to change the constitution on the basis of a national consensus following the next elections 12 39 Laszlo Solyom former President of Hungary and of the Constitutional Court is a critic of limits imposed on the court and of the common parliamentary wrangling through which the charter was adopted 40 41 The day after New Year s Day 2012 the government held a gala celebration at the Hungarian State Opera House to mark the entry into force of the constitution Outside on Andrassy ut tens of thousands of people protested the occasion with opponents claiming the constitution threatens democracy by removing checks and balances Demonstrators included representatives from various civil groups and opposition parties among them the Socialists Fidesz MP Gergely Gulyas who helped write the constitution responded to critics by saying that it improves the legal framework of life in Hungary 42 43 International reactions edit The Venice Commission and the Hungarian Helsinki Committee expressed concern over the provision on cardinal acts opposition parties asserted these could bind future governments to Fidesz actions but did promise to participate in the debate on the acts 14 13 Amnesty International believes the document violates international and European human rights standards citing the clauses on fetal protection marriage and life imprisonment and sexual orientation not being covered in the anti discrimination clause Left wing and liberal members of the European Parliament asserted that it fails to protect citizens rights and reduces legislative checks and balances 11 Among these was Guy Verhofstadt head of the Alliance of Liberals and Democrats for Europe who said the constitution could limit fundamental human rights and was adopted without transparency flexibility a spirit of compromise and sufficient time for debate 44 Werner Hoyer Germany s deputy foreign minister expressed his country s concern as well 12 prompting the Hungarian Foreign Affairs Ministry to dismiss the remarks as inexplicable and unacceptable 45 Additionally United Nations Secretary General Ban Ki moon suggested the government should address concerns about the constitution 46 In neighboring Slovakia which has a significant Hungarian minority at least three parties including the governing Slovak Democratic and Christian Union expressed concern about clauses that afford certain rights to ethnic Hungarians abroad including the right to dual citizenship and the right to vote and critics there fear that the move has expansive and nationalist objectives Slovakia s Foreign Affairs Ministry stated that it would oppose any other country s infringement of the Slovak Constitution its sovereignty or the rights of its citizens 47 In response Foreign Minister Janos Martonyi assured his Slovak counterpart that the constitution has no extraterritorial effect 48 2013 amendments edit See also Second Orban Government International criticism of Fourth Amendment of the Constitution In March 2013 Parliament amended the constitution for the fourth time on a 265 11 vote with Fidesz the Christian Democrats and three independents in favor and the Socialists boycotting the vote there were also 33 abstentions 49 50 Subsequently President Janos Ader signed the amendment into law citing his legal duty and the need to preserve national unity 51 52 The fifteen page amendment touches on several aspects It annuls rulings of the Constitutional Court made before the 2011 constitution went into force while allowing their legal effects to remain It endows the president of the Curia and the chief prosecutor with the power to initiate constitutional review of laws While giving the Constitutional Court the power to review the constitution itself on procedural grounds it stipulates that the court cannot annul a law passed by a two thirds parliamentary majority Judges and prosecutors are obliged to retire at the general retirement age although that age is left unstated the Curia head and the chief prosecutor are exempt The amendment enshrines freedom of religion and allows constitutional complaints regarding the church law It allows civil lawsuits for hate speech targeting an individual s community and declares that communism is condemned The measure requires students whose education is subsidized by the state to work in Hungary for a period after graduation or reimburse their tuition costs to the state It allows only public media to air political advertising prior to general and European elections The importance of the traditional family is stressed and authorities are empowered to ban living in certain public spaces although homelessness is not outlawed A prior proposal on requiring voters to register prior to elections was not included after being earlier voided by the Constitutional Court 53 The amendment drew criticism both within Hungary and abroad The Socialist floor leader labeled the measure an attempt to restrict the Constitutional Court s powers and party members hung black flags from the Hungarian Parliament Building s windows in sign of mourning for democracy The LMP charged that the government was dismantling constitutional values while former prime minister Ferenc Gyurcsany head of the small Democratic Coalition also drew attention to the diminution in the court s prerogatives 49 A protest in Budapest held in the days before parliamentary approval was given drew several thousands 54 while on the day of the vote a few hundred turned out 55 Jose Manuel Barroso President of the European Commission and Thorbjorn Jagland Secretary General of the Council of Europe together raised concerns about the amendment s impact on the rule of law 56 while prominent EU politicians including Verhofstadt and Martin Schulz expressed more forceful criticism 57 Orban denied that the powers of the Constitutional Court had been curtailed challenging critics to explain just how the amendment is undemocratic 58 while his party explained that the measure was needed in order to delineate the new constitution from the previous one 50 That September a fifth amendment was passed in response to recommendations from the Constitutional Court the European Commission and the Venice Commission Approved by Fidesz parliamentarians it was opposed by LMP and the Socialists while Jobbik abstained The provision granted the National Bank oversight of financial markets eliminated a provision allowing judicial cases to be transferred from one court to another as well as one allowing taxes to be raised for financing fines charged to the Hungarian state by international court rulings clarified the recognition of religious communities and allowed political campaign ads to be aired on public as well as commercial television and radio free of charge 59 Following the amendment s adoption Jagland praised government efforts to address international criticism 60 Notes edit in Hungarian Consolidated version of the Fundamental Law of Hungary incorporating the five amendments Archived 2014 02 21 at the Wayback Machine in Hungarian Text of the Fundamental Law of Hungary as adopted by the National Assembly on 18 April 2011 in English Consolidated version of the Fundamental Law of Hungary incorporating the five amendments a b c d e Hungarian lawmakers approve socially and fiscally conservative new constitution The Washington Post 18 April 2011 accessed April 25 2011 a b c Judy Dempsey Hungarian Parliament Approves New Constitution The New York Times 18 April 2011 accessed April 25 2011 in Hungarian Kata Janecsko Hiaba vedett a magzat nem szigorodik az abortusz Despite Fetal Protection Abortion Law Is Not Tightened index hu 11 March 2011 accessed June 23 2011 Biroi egyesulet atmeneti rendelkezesek kellenek Judges Association Transitional Provisions Needed permanent dead link mti hu 19 April 2011 accessed April 26 2011 Judges protest planned mandatory retirement age cut in planned new constitution Archived 2012 03 11 at the Wayback Machine politics hu 15 April 2011 accessed May 13 2011 Hungary at the OECD Library accessed April 26 2011 in Hungarian Botrany lesz a birak nyugdijazasabol Retirement of Judges Will Be a Scandal Archived 2011 10 03 at the Wayback Machine nepszava hu 22 June 2011 accessed June 23 2011 a b c d Hungarian president signs new constitution despite human rights concerns Deutsche Welle 25 April 2011 Retrieved 25 April 2011 a b c d e Hungary s parliament passes controversial new constitution Deutsche Welle 18 April 2011 accessed April 25 2011 a b Socialists LMP to join parliamentary debate on supermajority laws Archived 2011 08 17 at the Wayback Machine politics hu 21 April 2011 accessed April 26 2011 a b Margit Feher Hungary Passes New Constitution Amid Concerns The Wall Street Journal 18 April 2011 accessed April 26 2011 Korosenyi p 145 Mezhikovskii p 122 a b Harmathy p 4 Ludwikowski p 30 Ludwikowski p 31 Harmathy p 7 Rakowska Harmstone p 100 Somody p 211 Hungary Purges Stalinism From Its Constitution The New York Times October 19 1989 Harmathy p 8 9 Harmathy p 9 Dupre p 173 4 in Hungarian Magyarazkodasra kenyszerul Gyurcsany Gyurcsany Is Forced to Explain Archived 2011 09 27 at the Wayback Machine Magyar Nemzet 4 April 2011 accessed April 25 2011 Hungary s new constitution drafted by next March says Fidesz official Archived 2012 03 11 at the Wayback Machine politics hu 2 August 2010 accessed August 18 2010 in Hungarian Bihari szerint mindig lehet jobb According to Bihari One May Always Do Better FN hu 7 August 2010 accessed August 18 2010 in Hungarian Megalakult az alkotmany elokeszito bizottsag Constitutional Draft Committee Is Formed Archived 2011 09 28 at the Wayback Machine hirtv hu 28 June 2010 accessed June 23 2011 a b Zoltan Simon Hungary First to Write a Constitution on IPad Lawmaker Says Bloomberg 4 March 2011 accessed April 25 2011 Body set up for national consultation on new constitution Archived 2012 03 09 at the Wayback Machine politics hu 7 February 2011 accessed April 25 2011 in Hungarian Szajer oriasi siker a nemzeti konzultacio Szajer National Consultation a Huge Success Archived 2011 09 27 at the Wayback Machine Magyar Nemzet 4 April 2011 accessed June 23 2011 in Hungarian Orban kivetelesen eros lesz az uj alkotmany Orban New Constitution Will Be Exceptionally Strong Archived 2011 10 02 at the Wayback Machine MR1 Kossuth Radio 28 March 2011 accessed June 23 2011 Hungarian president signs new constitution despite human rights concerns Deutsche Welle 25 April 2011 accessed December 29 2019 Foreign firms criticize Hungary s new constitution Deutsche Welle 20 April 2011 accessed April 25 2011 Thomas Orszag Land Hungary deceitful over Holocaust The Jewish Chronicle 10 June 2011 accessed June 12 2011 in Hungarian Az alaptorveny es a magyar tortenelem The Basic Law and Hungarian History Archived 2011 06 01 at the Wayback Machine Nepszabadsag 31 May 2011 accessed June 23 2011 Socialists pledge to correct constitution as soon as possible Archived 2012 03 26 at the Wayback Machine politics hu 13 April 2011 accessed April 26 2011 Former state president warns about possible mistakes around new constitution Archived 2012 03 11 at the Wayback Machine politics hu 7 March 2011 accessed April 26 2011 Constitution Hungary European democracy despite basic law s shortcomings says ex president mti hu 18 April 2011 accessed April 26 2011 Palko Karasz and Melissa Eddy Opposition Protests Constitution in Hungary The New York Times 2 January 2012 accessed January 15 2012 Hungarians protest against new Fidesz constitution BBC News 3 January 2012 accessed January 15 2012 Hungarian People s Party deputies reject liberal group s concerns about new constitution Archived 2012 03 11 at the Wayback Machine politics hu 18 April 2011 accessed April 26 2011 Orban spokesman says Germany must not interfere with Hungary s adoption of new constitution Archived 2012 03 11 at the Wayback Machine politics hu 20 April 2011 accessed April 26 2011 UN Secretary General cautions gov t over constitution and media law Archived 2012 03 11 at the Wayback Machine politics hu 19 April 2011 accessed April 25 2011 Slovakia on edge as Hungary passes new Constitution Archived 2012 01 18 at the Wayback Machine thedaily sk 19 April 2011 accessed April 25 2011 in Hungarian Martonyi Az uj alkotmanynak nincs teruleten kivuli hatalya Martonyi the New Constitution Has No Extraterritorial Effect Archived 2011 05 14 at the Wayback Machine hirtv hu 12 May 2011 accessed June 23 2011 a b Parliament passes constitutional amendments that critics call undemocratic Archived 2014 12 22 at the Wayback Machine politics hu 11 March 2013 accessed March 21 2013 a b Hungary defies critics over change to constitution BBC News 11 March 2013 accessed March 21 2013 Ader pledges to sign constitutional amendments citing need for national unity Archived 2014 02 22 at the Wayback Machine politics hu 13 March 2013 accessed March 21 2013 in Hungarian Ader alairja az alaptorveny modositast hvg hu 13 March 2013 accessed March 21 2013 Preview Parliament to vote on controversial constitutional amendments on Monday Archived 2016 01 16 at the Wayback Machine politics hu 9 March 2013 accessed March 21 2013 Thousands demonstrate against new constitutional amendments in Budapest Archived 2013 12 20 at the Wayback Machine politics hu 9 March 2013 accessed March 21 2013 Protesters against constitutional amendments block Chain Bridge in Budapest Archived 2013 12 20 at the Wayback Machine politics hu 12 March 2013 accessed March 21 2013 EU to examine whether Hungary s constitutional amendments conform with law Archived 2013 12 20 at the Wayback Machine politics hu 13 March 2013 accessed March 21 2013 Top EU politicians condemn Hungary s decision to amend the Constitution Archived 2013 12 20 at the Wayback Machine politics hu 12 March 2013 accessed March 21 2013 Orban says Constitutional Court has lost none of its powers to assess laws Archived 2013 12 20 at the Wayback Machine politics hu 14 March 2013 accessed March 21 2013 Hungary s parliament approves 5th constitutional amendment Archived 2014 03 07 at the Wayback Machine politics hu 16 September 2013 accessed March 7 2014 in Hungarian Magyarorszag bunlajstroma ezert tamad az EU es Amerika Archived 2014 11 09 at the Wayback Machine valasz hu 6 November 2014 accessed November 19 2014References editDupre Catherine Importing the Law in Post communist Transitions 2003 Hart Publishing ISBN 1 84113 131 8 Harmathy Attila ed Introduction to Hungarian Law 1998 Kluwer Law International ISBN 90 411 1066 6 Korosenyi Andras Government and Politics in Hungary 2000 Central European University Press ISBN 963 9116 76 9 Ludwikowski Rett R Constitution making in the Region of Former Soviet Dominance 1996 Duke University Press ISBN 0 8223 1802 4 Mezhikovskii S M et al Law and Religion in Post Communist Europe 2003 Peeters Publishers ISBN 90 429 1262 6 Mullerson Rein et al Constitutional Reform and International Law in Central and Eastern Europe 1998 Martinus Nijhoff Publishers ISBN 90 411 0526 3 Rakowska Harmstone Teresa Communism in Eastern Europe 1984 Indiana University Press ISBN 0 253 31391 0 Somody Bernadette Raising the Standard The Current Challenges in Human Rights Protection in Hungary 2013 in Constitutional Evolution in Central and Eastern Europe ed Alexander H E Morawa Kyriaki Topidi Ashgate Publishing ISBN 978 1 40 949740 0 Szikinger Istvan Hungary s Pliable Constitution 2001 in Democratic Consolidation in Eastern Europe Institutional Engineering ed Jan Zielonka Oxford University Press ISBN 0 19 924408 1External links edit nbsp Wikisource has original text related to this article Constitution of Hungary in English Constitutional background with full list of amendments from 1989 to 2003 in English 1949 Constitution with amendments through 2011 in Hungarian Act XXXI of 1989 in Hungarian Text of the Fundamental Law of Hungary as in force on 1 January 2023 in English English translation of the Fundamental Law of Hungary as in force on 1 January 2023 in English Opinion of the Venice Commission on the 2011 constitution in English Resolution of the European Parliament on the 2011 constitution in English Text of the Fourth Amendment Retrieved from https en wikipedia org w index php title Constitution of Hungary amp oldid 1215380442 2013 amendments, wikipedia, wiki, book, books, library,

article

, read, download, free, free download, mp3, video, mp4, 3gp, jpg, jpeg, gif, png, picture, music, song, movie, book, game, games.