1990s Donbas miners' strikes

Strikes by coal miners in the eastern Donbas region of Ukraine occurred throughout most of the 1990s. Beginning in 1989, coal miners went on strike against poor pay amidst poor economic conditions. Originally part of the 1989 Soviet miners' strikes [ru], the demands of miners in the Donbas also reflected sentiments in favour of Ukrainian nationalism, and they were supported publicly by pro-independence groups such as the People's Movement of Ukraine.

1990s Donbas miner strikes
Part of the 1989–1991 Ukrainian revolution (until 1991)
Miners protesting near the Ministry of Coal Industry building (Donetsk, 1990)
Date	15 July 1989 – 19 June 1993 (1989-07-15 – 1993-06-19) 1 February 1996 – 1997 May–17 June 1998
Location	Ukraine^[a] (Mainly Donbas)
Caused by	1989–1993: Communist Party committees within businesses (until 1991) Low wages Era of Stagnation High food prices Distrust of trade unions in the Soviet Union 1996–1997, 1998: Low wages Non-payment of wages End of coal industry subsidies
Goals	1989–1991: Resignation of Volodymyr Shcherbytsky and Valentyna Shevchenko End of one-party rule Raising of wages Economic independence of the Ukrainian SSR from the Soviet Union Adoption of the Declaration of State Sovereignty of Ukraine End of Communist Party committees within businesses Resignation of Mikhail Gorbachev, Volodymyr Shcherbytsky, and Valentyna Shevchenko (politician) Trade union independence Direct elections 1991–1993, 1996–1997, 1998: Paying of wages Raising of wages
Methods	Strike action, political demonstration, sit-in
Concessions	1989–1991: Resignation of Volodymyr Shcherbytsky as First Secretary of the Communist Party of Ukraine Economic independence of the Ukrainian SSR from the Soviet Union Declaration of State Sovereignty of Ukraine adopted End of Communist Party committees within businesses 1991–1993: 1994 parliamentary and presidential elections held early Resignation of the Krasnodon municipal government 1996–1997, 1998: Payment of wages
Parties
Miners Independent Trade Union of Ukrainian Miners Supported by: People's Movement of Ukraine  Soviet Union (until 1991) Government of Ukraine  Donetsk Oblast  Luhansk Oblast Berkut
Lead figures
Volodymyr Biletskyy Mykola Volynko [uk] Mykhailo Volynets [uk] Volodymyr Shcherbytsky Leonid Kravchuk Leonid Kuchma  Donetsk Oblast: Viktor Kurchenko Yuriy Smyrnov [uk] Viktor Yanukovych  Luhansk Oblast: Anatoliy Kasianov [uk] Eduard Khananov [uk] Hennadiy Fomenko [uk] Oleksandr Yefremov Viktor Tikhonov
Number
500,000–1.5 million (1993) 800,000 (1996)
Casualties and losses
1 dead (suicide) 22 injured 15 injured

Background and early strikes

By 1989, the Donbas region in the eastern part of the Ukrainian Soviet Socialist Republic was in a state of severe economic decline. As part of the Era of Stagnation, the region's industrial economy had significantly declined. More broadly, the state response to the 1986 Chernobyl disaster, Russification, and the Revolutions of 1989 had generated increased distaste for First Secretary Volodymyr Shcherbytsky's government throughout Ukraine.^[1] Additionally, in pursuit of Stakhanovite goals of increased productivity, safety requirements were neglected.^[2] Outside Ukraine, broader Soviet policies and conditions encouraged the emergence of the strikes. The failures of Perestroika frustrated workers,^[3] and widespread shortages for basic necessities like soap led to tensions reaching a boiling point.^[4]

1989–1991 strikes

On 10 July 1989, coal miners in the Kuznetsk Basin region went on strike, citing poor pay. Word of the strikes soon spread to coal-mining regions throughout the Soviet Union, particularly the Donbas. Following the Kuzbass workers, miners at Yasynova-Hluboka mine in Makiivka went on strike on 15 July 1989.^[5] The first strikes' demands were primarily higher wages and increased social protections. In addition to these economic demands, however, many miners were sympathetic to the cause of Ukrainian independence, viewing it as a means of achieving self-governance from the Soviet Union. Some mines outside the city of Donetsk initially refused to join the strikes out of fear of government retaliation, but were eventually convinced to join.^[6]

The response from Shcherbytsky's government was largely negative. State media discredited the miners or avoided discussing the matter outright, and disrupted communications between the 28 mines that first went on strike. This hampered the ability of the strikers to successfully organise strikes at other mines, though they were joined by a pipe plant in Makiivka.^[6] Facing increasingly-agitated rhetoric from miners and a Communist Party of the Soviet Union that sought to remove the last vestiges of Brezhnev's rule, Shcherbytsky chose to resign rather than continue governing Ukraine in September 1989. Chair of the Supreme Soviet Valentyna Shevchenko also resigned.^[7]

The resignations were celebrated as a victory for the miners, but by that point demands had become more political,^[7] demanding Ukraine's economic independendence and increased autonomy from the Soviet Union.^[8] A two-hour strike on 1 November 1989 protested the rule of Mikhail Gorbachev, demanding an end to the Communist Party's one-party rule and direct elections to the office of President of the Soviet Union. A vote by the regional strike committee to go on strike in all of Donetsk Oblast ended in a 14–14 deadlock. Miners complained that shortages were still widespread, and additionally called for a parliamentary committee on government corruption.^[9] Demands for Ukraine to decouple its economic management from the broader Soviet Union was met by the Supreme Soviet of the Ukrainian Soviet Socialist Republic in August 1990, with the Law on the Ukrainian SSR's Economic Independence.^[7]

Among the most serious of the strikes began on 1 March 1991.^[10] Supported by the pro-independence People's Movement of Ukraine (abbr. Rukh) organisation,^[5] the strikes brought the conflict to a new level, calling for Gorbachev's resignation, the dissolution of the Council of People's Deputies, and recognition of the 1990 Declaration of State Sovereignty of Ukraine. They were supported by miners from the Lviv-Volyn coal basin, who marched to the Ukrainian capital of Kyiv. The leaders of Rukh met with miners in Donetsk, and in April 1991 miners occupied the main Khreshchatyk street in Kyiv.^[10] Following the 1991 Soviet coup attempt and subsequent Declaration of Independence of Ukraine, strikes did not come to an end, although they decreased in strength and focused primarily on being paid unpaid wages.^[11]

1993 strikes

In the face of the post-independence economic downturn experienced by Ukraine and the non-payment of miners' wages, Donetsk miners began a strike on 7 June 1993. The strikes quickly grew in scale, encompassing all of Donetsk and Luhansk oblasts and reaching into parts of Dnipropetrovsk and Kharkiv oblasts. Around 228 mines participated in the strikes, with the total number of participants being between 500,000^[12] and 1.5 million. The latter number would make the 1993 strike the largest singular protest in Ukrainian history, surpassing the 2013–2014 Euromaidan.^[8] Popular anger was directed at President Leonid Kravchuk's refusal to liberalise the economy, with a report by The New York Times describing strike leaders as sounding like "born-again capitalist[s]".

Contrary to the previous strikes, this strike also involved directors of mines, with director of the Donetsk-based October Mine Yuri Byelomestnov referring to the strikes as a "director's strike".^[13] Miners called for their pay to be doubled and for economic connections with foreign countries (particularly Russia, a vital supplier of fuel to Ukraine) to be strengthened, as well as for a referendum on both the Verkhovna Rada and Kravchuk's presidency. The pay increases were criticised by Rukh parliamentarian Mykhailo Shvaika [uk], who noted that it would cause prices to increase by several times more than wages.^[14]

Conceding to the demands of the strikes, Kravchuk's government first promoted Yukhym Zvyahilsky,^[13] a member of the Donetsk Clan of oligarchs,^[15] as First Deputy Prime Minister of Ukraine.^[13] Later, they also held presidential and parliamentary elections in 1994.^[11] As a result of the elections, Kravchuk was replaced by former Prime Minister Leonid Kuchma.^[16]

Autonomy debate

The political nature of the strikes, in particular calls for autonomy, has been subject to some dispute. The main rallying cry of the protests, that residents of the Donbas "can feed themselves", has been described as either based on opposition to Ukrainian independence and support for Russophilia^[13] or as a broader call for decentralisation involving all of Ukraine.^[8]

1996–1997 strikes

See also: 1996 Ukrainian miner protests

The miners' strikes returned on 1 February 1996, again citing unpaid wages. The strikes occurred simultaneously with coal miners' strikes in Russia, similarly based on low pay (though Russian strikes also included elements of opposition to the First Chechen War). The simultaneous strikes reached from the Donbas to the Russian Far East,^[17] and were also supported by coal miners in western Ukraine.^[11] Other issues included a proposal by the World Bank to shut down 114 of Ukraine's 227 active mines in order to restore profitability to the industry.^[18] In an effort to increase pressure on the government, railway lines and highways were blocked by miners, with only food supplies and ambulances being let through.^[8]

The total number of workers who went on strike in 1996 and 1997 was much lower than in 1989–1991 or 1993, numbering at 2,700 according to NATO research fellow Elena Kurilo.^[18] In response to the strikes, the government took a hard line, arresting leaders and defaming striking workers on television. The disruption of the strikes caused by the arrests and court proceedings eventually brought an end to the strikes without concessions.^[8] However, workers' resentment continued to grow, eventually peaking a year later.^[11]

1998 strikes

Beginning in 1998, a convoy of about 5,000 miners from the western Donbas and Pavlohrad began to march towards the city of Dnipropetrovsk, seeking payment of 8–9 months' worth of wages. From there, a group of around 1,000 miners marched on to Kyiv. In an effort to counter government propaganda, an independent television channel led by former miners from Pavlohrad also travelled alongside the convoy, interviewing strikers.^[11]

The convoy attracted widespread sympathy from the Ukrainian public, and the symbol of miners' orange helmets being pounded on pavement became a widespread symbol of discontent with Kuchma's government. Individuals donated food and water to the convoy, with so much being sent that two busloads of food were donated by the miners to orphanages. Ukrainian nationalist and left-wing parties also expressed support for the strikes, though workers emphasised their apolitical goals.^[19] The convoy reached the capital on 29 May, and began blockading the Presidential Office Building, the Government Building, and the Verkhovna Rada building, camping on Trukhaniv Island.^[20] Prime Minister Valeriy Pustovoitenko met with strike leader Mykhailo Volynets^[21] and described payment of wages as a "priority",^[22] but negotiations stalled^[21] amidst parliamentary infighting^[22] until an agreement to pay all wages was finally reached on 17 June 1998, and the convoy's participants returned home.^[11]

Luhansk anti-Berkut clashes

Following the end of the convoy, local-level strikes continued. Among these was one in the city of Luhansk, in which three Krasnodon-based mines launched a picket at the offices of the Luhansk Oblast Council and the Governor of Luhansk Oblast. Beginning on 15 July 1998, the strike continued until 24 August, when members of the Berkut special police force attacked the miners.^[11] The strikers retaliated violently, and in the ensuing clashes 22 workers, 12 Berkut officers, and three other law enforcement officers were injured. The incident has sometimes been incorrectly referred to as the first instance of law enforcement attacking a peaceful protest in Ukraine,^[12] but it was preceded by the 1995 Funeral of Patriarch Volodymyr of Kyiv.^[11]

Later, smaller-scale protests also took place in Luhansk Oblast during the remainder of 1998, including the self-immolation of miner Oleksandr Mykhailevych in December. The next year, strikes did not take place, owing to the payment of wages, the fatigue of workers, and disagreements among the leaders of independent trade unions.^[12]

Legacy

The miners' strikes of 1989 were the largest in the Soviet Union.^[5] They were also the origin of the 1989–1991 Ukrainian revolution, which eventually resulted in Ukrainian independence and the dissolution of the Soviet Union. Later strikes have failed to replicate the success of the 1990s in terms of scale or public support.^[8] In present-day Ukraine, the miners' strikes are regarded as particularly important as demonstrating the role of the Donbas in establishing Ukraine's independence from the Soviet Union.^[7][5] The strikes' nature as a collective action to improve Ukrainians' status has also achieved importance since the beginning of the Russo-Ukrainian War,^[11] and been compared by some, such as Euromaidan Press journalist Olena Makarenko, to the civil volunteer movement helping Ukrainian forces in the war in Donbas.^[8] In the Donbas, the strikes are sometimes referred to as the "Miners' Revolution" (Ukrainian: Шахтарська революція, romanized: Shakhtarska revoliutsia; Russian: Шахтёрская революция, romanized: Shakhtyorskaya revolyutsiya).^[23][24]

Notes

1. Ukrainian SSR, Soviet Union until 1991

References

1. "Ukraine under Shcherbytsky". Encyclopædia Britannica. Retrieved 17 December 2023.
2. Marples, David R. (1991). Ukraine under Perestroika: Ecology, Economics and the Workers' Revolt. University of Alberta Press. p. 176. ISBN 9780888642295.
3. Moskoff, William (18 September 1992). "Impoverishment and Protest in the Perestroika Years" (PDF). University of Pittsburgh Center for International Studies. p. 35. Retrieved 29 February 2024.
4. Safire, William (20 July 1989). "A Cake of Soap". The Washington Post. from the original on 19 December 2017. Retrieved 29 February 2024.
5. Kurennaia, Daria; Demchenko, Oleksandr; Yakubovych, Tetiana; Noskov, Volodymyr; Stryzhova, Olha (25 August 2016). ""Донбасс'91": какую роль сыграл Донбасс в становлении Независимости Украины?" ["Donbas'91": what role did the Donbas play in establishing Ukraine's independence?]. Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty (in Russian). Retrieved 29 February 2024.
6. Walkowitz, Daniel J. "Interviews with the Strike Leaders". Seventeen Moments in Soviet History. Retrieved 29 February 2024.
7. ""Досить годувати Москву". Історик Каретніков про те, як Донецьк зустрічав незалежність України" ["Enough to feed Moscow": Historian Karetnikov on how Donetsk greeted Ukraine's independence]. Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty (in Ukrainian). 24 August 2021. Retrieved 29 February 2024.
8. Makarenko, Olena (29 January 2016). "The Donbass protests you haven't heard of". Euromaidan Press. Retrieved 29 February 2024.
9. Dobbs, Michael (2 November 1989). "Miners strike is 'warning' in Ukraine". The Washington Post. from the original on 27 August 2017. Retrieved 29 February 2024.
10. Pyvovarov, Serhii (1 March 2019). "28 лет назад на Донбассе началась массовая забастовка шахтеров. Она ускорила распад СССР, лидеры протеста стали политиками Украины" [Mass miners' strikes in the Donbas began 28 years ago: caused collapse of the USSR, protest leaders became Ukrainian politicians]. Babel (in Russian). Retrieved 29 February 2024.
11. Azarov, Vlad; Chernova, Oleksandra; Stoliarova, Tetiana (16 October 2021). "Чуеш гуркіт касок?" [Do you hear the helmets clatter?]. Ukrainska Pravda (in Ukrainian). Retrieved 29 February 2024.
12. Kravchenko, Svitlana (23 April 2015). "Масштабних шахтарських страйків в Україні не було з кінця 90-их". The Ukrainian Week (in Ukrainian). Retrieved 29 February 2024.
13. Perlez, Jane (17 June 1993). "Ukraine's Miners Bemoan The Cost of Independence". The New York Times. from the original on 25 June 2023. Retrieved 29 February 2024.
14. Poletz, Lida (9 June 1993). "Ukrainian miners strike over price hikes". United Press International. Retrieved 29 February 2024.
15. "Помер Юхим Звягільський: сірий кардинал Донбасу" [Yukhym Zvyahilsky dead: grey cardinal of the Donbas]. BBC (in Ukrainian). 6 November 2021. Retrieved 29 February 2024.
16. "Выборы-1994: начало эпохи Кучмы, победа Гурвица и Боделана" [Elections 1994: Beginning of the Kuchma era, victories for Gurvits and Bodelan]. Ukrainian Information Service (in Russian). 26 March 2019. Retrieved 29 February 2024.
17. Hoffman, David (1 February 1996). "1 million miners go on strike in Russia, Ukraine". The Washington Post. Retrieved 29 February 2024.
18. Kurilo, Elena. "The Economic Factor in Ukrainian Ethnic Relations and its Impact Upon the National Security of the Ukraine" (PDF). NATO. p. 16. Retrieved 29 February 2024.
19. "Miners strike vein of public sympathy". Kyiv Post. 12 June 1998. Retrieved 29 February 2024.
20. Konko, Andrii (4 August 2021). "Баталії в парламенті і масові страйки шахтарів: що пережила Україна у 1998 році" [Battles in parliament and mass miners' strikes: what happened in Ukraine in 1998]. 24 Kanal (in Ukrainian). Retrieved 29 February 2024.
21. Korshak, Stefan (9 May 1998). "Ukraine: Miners Continue Strike". Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty. Retrieved 29 February 2024.
22. "Miners bring protest to Kuchma's doorstep". Kyiv Post. 29 May 1998. Retrieved 29 February 2024.
23. "Шахтерская революция-89: доллары, Горбачев и КГБ" [Miners' Revolution-89: Dollars, Gorbachev, and the KGB]. Segodnya (in Russian). 2 July 2009. Retrieved 29 February 2024.
24. "Шахтарська революція. Уривок з книги "Дикий схід" Максима Віхрова" [The Miners' Revolution: Excerpt from Maksym Vikhrov's book "The Wild East"]. My.City (in Ukrainian). 5 December 2018. Retrieved 29 February 2024.