Thousand Talents Plan

The Thousand Talents Plan or Thousand Talents Program (TTP) (Chinese: 千人计划; pinyin: Qiān rén jìhuà), or Overseas High-Level Talent Recruitment Programs (Chinese: 海外高层次人才引进计划; pinyin: Hǎiwài gāo céngcì réncái yǐnjìn jìhuà) is a program by the central government of China to recruit experts in science and technology from abroad, principally but not exclusively from overseas Chinese communities. The current iteration of the program is called Qiming, administered by the Ministry of Industry and Information Technology.^[1]

Thousand Talents Plan
Logo of the Thousand Talents Plan
Simplified Chinese	千人计划
Traditional Chinese	千人計劃
Transcriptions Standard Mandarin Hanyu Pinyin Qiān rén jìhuà
Alternative Chinese name
Simplified Chinese	海外高层次人才引进计划
Traditional Chinese	海外高層次人才引進計劃
Literal meaning	Overseas High-Level Talent Recruitment Programs
Transcriptions Standard Mandarin Hanyu Pinyin Hǎiwài gāo céngcì réncái yǐnjìn jìhuà

Law enforcement and counterintelligence agencies in the United States, Australia, Canada, and other countries have raised concerns about the program as a vector for intellectual property theft and espionage.^[2]

Background

Further information: Human capital flight

Many Chinese students often go abroad for advanced studies and the vast majority of whom decide to remain abroad after their studies.^[3] To reverse this trend and to build the size and prestige of China's university system, the central government of China recognized the need and turned to attracting overseas Chinese and top foreign-born talent from the world's best universities.^[4][5][6]

The Thousand Talent program is the most prominent of China's more than 200 talent recruitment programs.^[7] It grew out of the "Talent Superpower Strategy" of the 17th National Congress of the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) in 2007.^[8] The CCP Central Committee and State Council of the People's Republic of China elevated the program in 2010 to become the top-level award given through China's National Talent Development Plan to strengthen innovation and international competitiveness within China.^[3][9] In 2019, the program was re-branded as the "National High-end Foreign Experts Recruitment Plan."^[10][11] The CCP's United Front Work Department's Western Returned Scholars Association is the official representative body for program participants.^[12][2]

China also administers a "Young Thousand Talents" program as a "youth" branch of the Thousand Talents Plan.^[7] It focuses on the recruitment of early career STEM scholars.^[7]

Previous attempts to attract foreign scientific talent through a decentralized network of approximately 600 "talent recruitment stations" worldwide had been largely ineffective at convincing top researchers to leave developed countries permanently.^[6]

Selection

The Thousand Talents program primarily targets Chinese citizens who were educated in elite programs overseas and who have been successful as entrepreneurs, professionals, and researchers.^[4] The program also recognizes a small number of elite foreign-born experts with skills that are critical to China's international competitiveness in science and innovation.^[4] International experts in the latter category are typically winners of major prizes such as the Nobel Prize and the Fields Medal, and are expected first to have made internationally renowned contributions to a field of technological importance to China, and secondly to hold either a tenured position at one of the world's top universities or a senior role in an internationally important research organization.^[13]

In 2013, the Junior Thousand Talent Plan was created to attract faculty members under the age of 40 who have performed high impact research at one of the world's top universities.^[13] Although these professorships can be affiliated with any university in China, they are awarded disproportionately to individuals affiliated with the most prestigious (C9 League) universities; the few individuals who receive both this and the Changjiang (Yangtze River) Scholar award are typically associated with the C9 League.^[14]

The program includes two mechanisms: resources for permanent recruitment into Chinese academia, and resources for short-term appointments that typically target international experts who have full-time employment at a leading international university or research laboratory.^[4]

Within a decade of the announcement of the Thousand Talents Plan in 2008, it had attracted more than 7,000 people overall.^[4] More than 1,400 people participating in the Thousand Talents Plan, including several foreigners, specialize in life sciences fields.^[15]

More than 300 scientists and scholars at Australian tertiary institutions are connected to the program, according to research by Australian Strategic Policy Institute.^[16]

The Thousand Talents Plan professorship is the highest academic honor awarded by the State Council, analogous to the top-level award given by the Ministry of Education.^[4]

Benefits to participants

The program confers the prestigious title of "Thousand Talents Plan Distinguished Professor" (千人计划特聘教授) or "Junior Thousand Talents Plan Professor" upon the selected individuals, and provides benefits including this prestigious title, high pay, and visa privileges.^[13] The program is the first ever to enable individuals of extraordinary ability to gain access to Chinese immigration visas,^[17] including "long-stay visas."^[6] The program provides a one-time bonus of 1 million RMB to select individuals, substantial resources for research and academic exchange, and assistance with housing and transportation costs.^[13] Thousand Talents scholars are eligible for high levels of Chinese government funding.^[4]

Participants in the Young Thousand Talents program receive a one-time award of 500,000 RMB and start-up grants between 1 million and three million RMB.^[7] These packages are typically matched by host institutions in China or local governments.^[7] Participants also receive fringe benefits including subsidized housing and prioritization when applying for grants.^[7]

Reaction

Conflict of interest and fraud allegations

Some Thousand Talents Plan Professors have reported fraud in the program including misappropriated grant funding, poor accommodations, and violations of research ethics.^[18] Dismissals due to undisclosed connections to the TTP have taken place.^[19] In 2019, executives and researchers at the H. Lee Moffitt Cancer Center & Research Institute resigned following scrutiny into their links with the TTP.^[20] Individuals who receive either of China's two top academic awards, the Thousand Talents Professorship and the Changjiang (Yangtze River) Scholar award, have become targets for recruitment by China's wealthiest universities so frequently that the Ministry of Education issued notices in both 2013 and 2017 discouraging Chinese universities from recruiting away top talent from one another.^[21][22]

Effectiveness assessments

Evaluations of the program's efficacy and impact have been mixed. Although the program has successfully attracted top international talent to China, its efficacy in retaining these talented individuals has been questioned, with many of the most talented scientists willing to spend short periods in China but unwilling to abandon their tenured positions at major Western universities.^[3] A study published in 2023 concluded that the scholars were high (but not top) caliber and outperformed overseas peers in last-authored publications because of better access to resources in China.^[7]

Foreign government reactions

Further information: Chinese intelligence activity abroad and Allegations of intellectual property theft by China

Canada

Further information: Chinese government interference in Canada

In August 2020, Canadian Security Intelligence Service (CSIS) warned both Canadian universities and Canadian research institutions of the TTP, saying that it recruited researchers and scientists around the world to persuade them to share their research and technology — either willingly or by coercion.^[23]

South Korea

In June 2023, the Seoul Metropolitan Police Agency arrested a Chinese TTP researcher on espionage charges for allegedly stealing thousands of files relating to medical robot technology.^[24]

United States

Further information: Chinese espionage in the United States

The success of the program in recruiting U.S.-trained scientists back to China has been viewed with concern from the U.S., with a June 2018 report from the National Intelligence Council declaring an underlying motivation of the program to be “to facilitate the legal and illicit transfer of US technology, intellectual property and know-how” to China.^[25] US and Canadian authorities have asserted that China intends to use scientists who are involved with this plan to gain access to new technology for economic and military advantage.^[26][27][23] The Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) has indicated that foreign recruitment sponsor talent plans "to bring outside knowledge and innovation back to their countries—and sometimes that means stealing trade secrets, breaking export control laws, or violating conflict-of-interest policies to do so."^[28]

In January 2020, the FBI arrested Charles M. Lieber, the chair of Harvard University's Department of Chemistry and Chemical Biology, for lying about his ties to the program, and was convicted in December 2021.^[29][30][31] In May 2020, the FBI arrested a former researcher at the Cleveland Clinic for failing to disclose ties to the Thousand Talents Program,^[32] although a year later federal prosecutors dismissed the case.^[33] In June 2020, it was reported that the National Institutes of Health had investigations into the behavior of 189 scientists.^[34] In November 2020, Song Guo Zheng, a TTP participant, pled guilty to making false claims to the FBI about his ties to the Chinese government during his employment at Ohio State University.^[35]

In November 2019, the US Senate Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations and Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs held an open hearing on the China's Talent Recruitment Plans, including the TTP, and called the programs a threat to national security.^[36][37] The report from the hearing cited TTP contracts as violating research values, TTP members willfully failing to disclose their membership to their home institutions, and cited numerous cases against TTP members for theft of intellectual property and fraud.^[36] One TTP member stole proprietary defense information on U.S. military jet engines.^[36] The report indicated that "TTP targets U.S.-based researchers and scientists, regardless of ethnicity or citizenship, who focus on or have access to cutting-edge research and technology."^[36]

In 2019, the National Institute of Health (NIH) completed a yearlong investigation into research violations. Among other issues, it noticed after going over published papers that scores of researchers revealed their affiliation with or funding from institutions in China but had failed to report those ties to their home institution or the NIH. Michael Lauer, who oversaw the extramural research program, said that while TTP is not a threat, participants should fully disclose that relationship.^[38]

In September 2022, it was reported that TTP programs recruited over 150 scientists who worked on U.S. government-sponsored research at Los Alamos National Laboratory.^[39]

Academia

Although the program has successfully attracted top international talent to China, its efficacy in retaining these talented individuals has been questioned, with many of the most talented scientists willing to spend short periods in China but unwilling to abandon their tenured positions at major Western universities.^[3]

According to academic Scott Moore, the Chinese government had been the most assertive government in the world in introducing policies like the Thousand Talents Plan to trigger “a reverse brain drain."^[6] Moore stated that while the program posed several challenges for developed democracies such as incentivizing recruited professors to improperly transfer of resources to their concurrent workplace in China, the biggest challenges had less to do with national security than to "increasingly outdated and misguided immigration policies common among developed democracies."^[6] According to Moore, the high number of participants in the program with a specialization in the life sciences prompted US policymakers to view the TTP as signaling by Beijing of its intention to “mount a full-spectrum challenge to US leadership in the biotechnology sector”, with one US policymaker saying the TPP helped build China's talent pipeline for the sector.^[15]

Academics Dongbo Shi, Weichen Liu, and Yanbo Wang conducted an analysis of Young Thousand Talent program participants, and concluded "that China’s YTT program has been successful in recruiting and nurturing high-caliber scientists and that YTT scientists outperform their overseas peers in post-return publication, mainly owing to their access to greater funding and larger research teams. These results show the potential of talent programs as a policy tool for countries to attract expatriate scientists and promote their productivity."^[7]

See also

• China Scholarship Council
• Made in China 2025

References

1. Zhu, Julie; Potkin, Fanny; Baptista, Eduardo; Martina, Michael (2023-08-24). "China quietly recruits overseas chip talent as US tightens curbs". Reuters. from the original on 2023-08-26. Retrieved 2023-08-26. The primary replacement for TTP is a program called Qiming overseen by the Ministry of Industry and Information Technology
2. Joske, Alex (August 20, 2020). "Hunting the Phoenix: The Chinese Communist Party's global search for technology and talent". Australian Strategic Policy Institute. JSTOR resrep26119. from the original on 2020-08-20. Retrieved 2020-08-20.
3. Sharma, Yojana (28 May 2013). "China's Effort To Recruit Top Academic Talent Faces Hurdles". The Chronicle of Higher Education. from the original on 10 April 2018. Retrieved 8 April 2018.
4. Jia, Hepeng (January 17, 2018). "China's plan to recruit talented researchers". Nature. 553 (7688): S8. doi:10.1038/d41586-018-00538-z. ISSN 0028-0836. PMID 29345644.
5. Robbins, Mark. "The Thousand Talents Program". Conference Board of Canada. from the original on 2016-03-15. Retrieved 2016-03-14.
6. Moore, Scott M. (2022-08-24). China's Next Act: How Sustainability and Technology are Reshaping China's Rise and the World's Future (1 ed.). Oxford University Press. pp. 117–118. doi:10.1093/oso/9780197603994.001.0001. ISBN 978-0-19-760399-4. OCLC 1316703008.
7. Shi, Dongbo; Liu, Weichen; Wang, Yanbo (2023-01-06). "Has China's Young Thousand Talents program been successful in recruiting and nurturing top-caliber scientists?". Science. 379 (6627): 62–65. Bibcode:2023Sci...379...62S. doi:10.1126/science.abq1218. ISSN 0036-8075. PMID 36603081. S2CID 255441013. They found that the scholars were high (but not top) caliber and outperformed overseas peers in last-authored publications because of greater access to larger research teams and better research funding in China.
8. Stoff, Jeffrey (2020-08-03), Hannas, William C.; Tatlow, Didi Kirsten (eds.), "China's Talent Programs", China’s Quest for Foreign Technology (1 ed.), Abingdon, Oxon: Routledge, pp. 38–54, doi:10.4324/9781003035084-4, ISBN 978-1-003-03508-4, OCLC 1153338764, S2CID 225397660, from the original on 2023-07-03, retrieved 2023-03-22
9. Wang, Huiyao (23 Nov 2010). "China's National Talent Plan: Key Measures and Objectives". Brookings Institution. from the original on 10 April 2018. Retrieved 8 April 2018.
10. Fedasiuk, Ryan; Feldgoise, Jacob (August 2020). "The Youth Thousand Talents Plan and China's Military" (PDF). Center for Security and Emerging Technology. (PDF) from the original on 2020-12-26. Retrieved 2020-12-13.
11. Hannas, William C.; Tatlow, Didi Kirsten, eds. (2020-08-03). China's Quest for Foreign Technology: Beyond Espionage (1 ed.). Milton Park, Abingdon, Oxon; New York, NY: Routledge, 2021. |: Routledge. p. 122. doi:10.4324/9781003035084. ISBN 978-1-003-03508-4. S2CID 224931074.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location (link)
12. Joske, Alex (June 9, 2020). "The party speaks for you: Foreign interference and the Chinese Communist Party's united front system". Australian Strategic Policy Institute. JSTOR resrep25132.5. from the original on June 9, 2020. Retrieved June 9, 2020.
13. . Recruitment Program of Global Experts. Archived from the original on 7 June 2019. Retrieved 8 April 2018.
14. Li, Feng; Miao, Yajun; Yang, Chenchen (March 2015). "How do alumni faculty behave in research collaboration? An analysis of Chang Jiang Scholars in China". Research Policy. 44 (2): 438–450. doi:10.1016/j.respol.2014.09.002.
15. Moore, Scott M. (2022-08-24). China's Next Act: How Sustainability and Technology are Reshaping China's Rise and the World's Future (1 ed.). Oxford University Press. p. 188. doi:10.1093/oso/9780197603994.001.0001. ISBN 978-0-19-760399-4. OCLC 1316703008.
16. Maddison, Max (20 January 2021). "China has recruited 'hundreds' of academics". The Australian. Retrieved 20 January 2021.
17. Hvistendahl, Mara (27 Jan 2015). "China dangles green cards to entice foreign science talent". Science. doi:10.1126/science.aaa6406.
18. Hvistendahl, Mara (2014-10-24). "Show me the money". Science. 346 (6208): 411–415. Bibcode:2014Sci...346..411H. doi:10.1126/science.346.6208.411. ISSN 0036-8075. PMID 25342782.
19. Mervis, Jeffrey (2020-01-19). "Moffitt Cancer Center details links of fired scientists to Chinese talent programs". Science. doi:10.1126/science.aba9662. ISSN 0036-8075. S2CID 213405004.
20. Griffin, Justine (December 18, 2019). "Moffitt Cancer Center shakeup: CEO and others resign over China ties". Tampa Bay Times. from the original on 2023-12-11. Retrieved 2023-12-11.
21. Jia, Hepeng (28 Jun 2017). "China sets ground rules for local talent quest". Nature Index. from the original on 24 April 2018. Retrieved 22 April 2018.
22. "The Office of the Ministry of Education Insists on Correct Guidance in Promoting the Reasonable and Orderly Flow of High-level Talents in Colleges and Universities (教育部办公厅关于坚持正确导向促进高校高层次人才合理有序流动的通知)". Ministry of Education (in Chinese). 25 Jan 2017. from the original on 25 April 2018. Retrieved 22 April 2018.
23. Kao, Josie (August 6, 2020). "CSIS warns about Beijing's efforts to recruit Canadian scientists". The Globe and Mail. from the original on 2020-08-20. Retrieved 2020-08-20.
24. "한국 6000억 의료로봇 기술, 1만여건 중국 빼돌린 中연구원". The Chosun Ilbo (in Korean). 2023-06-07. from the original on 2023-06-07. Retrieved 2023-06-08.
25. Capaccio, Anthony (21 June 2018). "U.S. Faces 'Unprecedented Threat' From China on Tech Takeover". Bloomberg News. from the original on 25 June 2018. Retrieved 1 July 2018.
26. Leonard, Jenny (12 December 2019). "China's Thousand Talents Program Finally Gets the U.S.'s Attention". Bloomberg News. from the original on 28 January 2020. Retrieved 12 November 2020.
27. Wray, Christopher (7 July 2020). "The Threat Posed by the Chinese Government and the Chinese Communist Party to the Economic and National Security of the United States". Federal Bureau of Investigation. from the original on 7 July 2020. Retrieved 12 November 2020.
28. "Chinese Talent Plans". Federal Bureau of Investigation. from the original on 2023-06-24. Retrieved 2022-06-25.
29. Chappell, Bill (28 January 2020). "Acclaimed Harvard Scientist Is Arrested, Accused of Lying About Ties to China". NPR. from the original on 28 January 2020. Retrieved 28 January 2020.
30. Mudie, Luisetta, ed. (January 29, 2020). "U.S. Arrests Harvard Chemistry Professor For 'Making False Statements' About China Ties". Radio Free Asia. from the original on January 30, 2020. Retrieved January 30, 2020.
31. "Harvard University Professor Convicted of Making False Statements and Tax Offenses". United States Department of Justice. 2021-12-21. from the original on 2022-06-25. Retrieved 2022-06-25.
32. Eaton, Sabrina (May 14, 2020). "Former Cleveland Clinic researcher charged with fraud for failing to disclose China ties". The Plain Dealer. from the original on May 24, 2020. Retrieved May 24, 2020.
33. "Fed. prosecutors dismiss criminal case involving former Cleveland Clinic doctor with ties to China". WEWS-TV. 2021-07-15. from the original on 2022-12-26. Retrieved 2022-10-03.
34. Mervis, Jeffrey (2020-06-22). "'Has it peaked? I don't know.' NIH official details foreign influence probe". Science. doi:10.1126/science.abd4593. ISSN 0036-8075. S2CID 225671294.
35. "Former Ohio State researcher pleads guilty for lying to FBI about ties to Chinese government". The Lantern. 2020-11-13. from the original on 2021-01-19. Retrieved 2021-01-26.
36. "Threats to the U.S. Research Enterprise: China's Talent Recruitment Plans" (PDF). United States Senate Homeland Security Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations. (PDF) from the original on 2019-11-22.
37. Leonard, Jenny (December 12, 2019). "China's Thousand Talents Program Finally Gets the U.S.'s Attention". Bloomberg News. from the original on January 28, 2020. Retrieved January 31, 2020.
38. Mervis, Jeffrey (2019-07-05). "Details revealed on NIH probe of foreign ties". Science. 365 (6448): 14. Bibcode:2019Sci...365...14M. doi:10.1126/science.365.6448.14. ISSN 0036-8075. PMID 31273102. S2CID 195807008.
39. Dilanian, Ken (September 21, 2022). "Scientists at America's top nuclear lab were recruited by China to design missiles and drones, report says". NBC News. from the original on 2022-09-21. Retrieved 2022-09-22.

External links

• Chinese Talent Program Tracker at the Center for Security and Emerging Technology