Purushamedha (or Naramedha) is a Śrauta ritual of human sacrifice. The Vajasaneyi Samhita-Sataphana Brahmana-Katyayana Srauta Sutra sequence of Shukla Yajur Veda texts contains the most details.[1]
Whether actual human sacrifice was taking place has been debated since Colebrooke brought the issue under attention in 1805. He regarded it as a symbolic ritual.[2] Since there is no inscriptural or other record of Purushamedha ever being performed, some scholars suggest it was invented simply to round out sacrificial possibilities.[1]Asko Parpola suggests actual human sacrifices are described in Vedic texts, while the Brahmanas show the practice diminishing.[note 1] In Shatapatha Brahmana 13.6.2, an ethereal voice intervenes to halt the proceedings.[1] The dhatupatha of Aṣṭādhyāyī by Pāṇini defines the root medha as synergizing the energy to perform something fruitful.
Scholars doubt the Purushamedha was ever performed.[1][note 2][3] However, according to Jan Houben, the actual occurrence of human sacrifice would be difficult to prove, since the relevant pieces of evidence would be small in number.[4]
According to Jan Houben, the Later Vedic period was followed by a period of embarrassment about violence in rituals. This period corresponds to the rise of Sramanic religions such as Buddhism and Jainism, both of which place emphasis on nonviolence (ahimsa). This period also corresponds to the composition of the Shatapatha Brahmana, which states that the victims of a Purushamedha are supposed to be released, and the composition of the Chandogya Upanishad, which lists nonviolence as a virtue.[4][5]
According to Jan Houben, the Sramanic period was followed by another period where Vedic ritualists tried to defend their actions against Buddhist and Jain criticism. This period corresponds to the rise of the Mīmāṃsā school of philosophy, which claimed that the Vedas were the sole authority regarding matters of dharma.
Medieval period
By the 10th century, the Purushamedha was included in lists of Kali-varjyas, or actions which were prohibited for the Kali Yuga. This suggests that human sacrifice had become obsolete by the time the texts were composed. However, it also suggests that the Purushamedha may have in some cases consummated with the actual sacrificing of a human. That is, the existence of inclusion of the prohibition in the list of Kali-varjyas demonstrates that at least one author seriously feared the possibility that a ritual practitioner might take the description of the ritual as a moral license to perform the rite to the extent of murder and cannibalism. This is a plausible reason to include it in the list of Kali-varjyas, even if it was a purely symbolic ceremony during the period of the composition of the Śatapatha Brāhmaṇa.[4] Whether or not the rite ever consummated in the slaughter of a human and the consumption of their flesh, however, remains so far a matter of scholarly speculation.
Performance in Hindu epics
The Aitareya Brahmana tells the story of a sacrifice carried out by King Harischandra. The childless king asked Varuna to provide him with a son, and in return, Varuna asks him to sacrifice the child to him. Harischandra delays the performance of the sacrifice and allows his son, named Rohita, to grow older. Eventually, Rohita wanders into the forest to find a substitute for himself. He comes across a poor Brahmin named Ajigarta, who sells his son Sunahsepa to him. Sunahsepa is bound to the stake, but he frees himself by reciting some mantras that were taught to him by Vishvamitra.[6] This story is reproduced in the Bhagavata Purana.[7]
In Vedanta and the Puranas
Human sacrifice and cannibalism are explicitly condemned in the Bhagavata Purana (5.26.31). The Chandogya Upanishad (3.16) states that the Purushamedha is actually a metaphor for life itself, and it compares the various stages of life to the oblations that are offered.
Views
Helmer Ringgren regarded that the traces of Purushameda are not clearly detectable.[8]
In November 2000, a modern version of Purushamedha was organised by All World Gayatri Pariwar at Shantikunj Haridwar, marking the completion of 12 year Yugsandhi Mahapurascharana. In this program, named Srijan Sankalp Vibhuti Mahayagya, participants had to tie themselves with Yup and take an oath to dedicate their life to social causes as a sacrifice.[9]Yagya was performed on 1551 kundas on the bank of the Ganges and was attended by four million devotees.
^"I therefore discuss first a few important textual references and their interpretation, hoping to establish beyond reasonable doubt that Vedic texts do indeed attest to real human sacrifices performed within the memory preserved by the authors, and that by the time of the Brahmana texts, the actual practice of bloody offering had already begun to diminish." Parpola (2007) p. 161
^"There is no inscriptional or other record that a purusamedha was ever performed, leading some scholars to suggest it was simply invented to round out sacrificial possibilities." (pg. 237)
^Oliver Leaman (2006), Encyclopedia of Asian Philosophy, Routledge, ISBN978-0415172813, page 557, Quote: "It should be mentioned that although provision is made for human sacrifice (purusha-medha) this was purely symbolic and did not involve harm to anyone".
^ abcHouben, Jan E. M.; Kooij, Karel Rijk van (1999). Violence Denied: Violence, Non-Violence, and the Rationalization of Violence in South Asian Cultural History. pp. 120–124, 133, 153. ISBN9004113444.
^"Paths to the Divine: Ancient and Indian", by Vensus A. George, p. 169, ISBN9781565182486
^Akhand Jyoti. Akhand Jyoti Sansthan, Mathura. 64 (1): 59–62. January 2001. {{cite journal}}: Missing or empty |title= (help)
Sources
Printed sources
Knipe, David M. (2015), Vedic Voices: Intimate Narratives of a Living Andhra Tradition, Oxford: Oxford University Press
Parpola, A. 'Human Sacrifice in India in Vedic Times and Before' in Bremmer, J.N. (2007): The Strange World of Human Sacrifice, Peeters
Web sources
January 07, 2023
purushamedha, naramedha, Śrauta, ritual, human, sacrifice, vajasaneyi, samhita, sataphana, brahmana, katyayana, srauta, sutra, sequence, shukla, yajur, veda, texts, contains, most, details, whether, actual, human, sacrifice, taking, place, been, debated, since. Purushamedha or Naramedha is a Srauta ritual of human sacrifice The Vajasaneyi Samhita Sataphana Brahmana Katyayana Srauta Sutra sequence of Shukla Yajur Veda texts contains the most details 1 Whether actual human sacrifice was taking place has been debated since Colebrooke brought the issue under attention in 1805 He regarded it as a symbolic ritual 2 Since there is no inscriptural or other record of Purushamedha ever being performed some scholars suggest it was invented simply to round out sacrificial possibilities 1 Asko Parpola suggests actual human sacrifices are described in Vedic texts while the Brahmanas show the practice diminishing note 1 In Shatapatha Brahmana 13 6 2 an ethereal voice intervenes to halt the proceedings 1 The dhatupatha of Aṣṭadhyayi by Paṇini defines the root medha as synergizing the energy to perform something fruitful Contents 1 Historical development 1 1 During the Vedic period 1 2 Rise of Sramanic religions 1 3 Mimamsa movement 1 4 Medieval period 2 Performance in Hindu epics 3 In Vedanta and the Puranas 4 Views 5 See also 6 Notes 7 References 8 Sources 8 1 Printed sources 8 2 Web sourcesHistorical development EditDuring the Vedic period Edit See also Vedic period Scholars doubt the Purushamedha was ever performed 1 note 2 3 However according to Jan Houben the actual occurrence of human sacrifice would be difficult to prove since the relevant pieces of evidence would be small in number 4 Rise of Sramanic religions Edit Main article Sramaṇa According to Jan Houben the Later Vedic period was followed by a period of embarrassment about violence in rituals This period corresponds to the rise of Sramanic religions such as Buddhism and Jainism both of which place emphasis on nonviolence ahimsa This period also corresponds to the composition of the Shatapatha Brahmana which states that the victims of a Purushamedha are supposed to be released and the composition of the Chandogya Upanishad which lists nonviolence as a virtue 4 5 Mimamsa movement Edit Main article Mimaṃsa According to Jan Houben the Sramanic period was followed by another period where Vedic ritualists tried to defend their actions against Buddhist and Jain criticism This period corresponds to the rise of the Mimaṃsa school of philosophy which claimed that the Vedas were the sole authority regarding matters of dharma Medieval period Edit By the 10th century the Purushamedha was included in lists of Kali varjyas or actions which were prohibited for the Kali Yuga This suggests that human sacrifice had become obsolete by the time the texts were composed However it also suggests that the Purushamedha may have in some cases consummated with the actual sacrificing of a human That is the existence of inclusion of the prohibition in the list of Kali varjyas demonstrates that at least one author seriously feared the possibility that a ritual practitioner might take the description of the ritual as a moral license to perform the rite to the extent of murder and cannibalism This is a plausible reason to include it in the list of Kali varjyas even if it was a purely symbolic ceremony during the period of the composition of the Satapatha Brahmaṇa 4 Whether or not the rite ever consummated in the slaughter of a human and the consumption of their flesh however remains so far a matter of scholarly speculation Performance in Hindu epics EditThe Aitareya Brahmana tells the story of a sacrifice carried out by King Harischandra The childless king asked Varuna to provide him with a son and in return Varuna asks him to sacrifice the child to him Harischandra delays the performance of the sacrifice and allows his son named Rohita to grow older Eventually Rohita wanders into the forest to find a substitute for himself He comes across a poor Brahmin named Ajigarta who sells his son Sunahsepa to him Sunahsepa is bound to the stake but he frees himself by reciting some mantras that were taught to him by Vishvamitra 6 This story is reproduced in the Bhagavata Purana 7 In Vedanta and the Puranas EditHuman sacrifice and cannibalism are explicitly condemned in the Bhagavata Purana 5 26 31 The Chandogya Upanishad 3 16 states that the Purushamedha is actually a metaphor for life itself and it compares the various stages of life to the oblations that are offered Views EditHelmer Ringgren regarded that the traces of Purushameda are not clearly detectable 8 Dayananda Saraswati founder of Arya Samaj has rejected any kind of human or animal sacrifice in vaidika yagnas In November 2000 a modern version of Purushamedha was organised by All World Gayatri Pariwar at Shantikunj Haridwar marking the completion of 12 year Yugsandhi Mahapurascharana In this program named Srijan Sankalp Vibhuti Mahayagya participants had to tie themselves with Yup and take an oath to dedicate their life to social causes as a sacrifice 9 Yagya was performed on 1551 kundas on the bank of the Ganges and was attended by four million devotees See also EditHistorical Vedic religionNotes Edit I therefore discuss first a few important textual references and their interpretation hoping to establish beyond reasonable doubt that Vedic texts do indeed attest to real human sacrifices performed within the memory preserved by the authors and that by the time of the Brahmana texts the actual practice of bloody offering had already begun to diminish Parpola 2007 p 161 There is no inscriptional or other record that a purusamedha was ever performed leading some scholars to suggest it was simply invented to round out sacrificial possibilities pg 237 References Edit a b c d Knipe 2015 p 237 Parpola 2007 p 159 Oliver Leaman 2006 Encyclopedia of Asian Philosophy Routledge ISBN 978 0415172813 page 557 Quote It should be mentioned that although provision is made for human sacrifice purusha medha this was purely symbolic and did not involve harm to anyone a b c Houben Jan E M Kooij Karel Rijk van 1999 Violence Denied Violence Non Violence and the Rationalization of Violence in South Asian Cultural History pp 120 124 133 153 ISBN 9004113444 Chandogya Upanishad 3 17 4 Parpola 2007 pp 161 164 Bhagavata Purana Canto 9 Chapter 7 Paths to the Divine Ancient and Indian by Vensus A George p 169 ISBN 9781565182486 Akhand Jyoti Akhand Jyoti Sansthan Mathura 64 1 59 62 January 2001 a href Template Cite journal html title Template Cite journal cite journal a Missing or empty title help Sources EditPrinted sources Edit Knipe David M 2015 Vedic Voices Intimate Narratives of a Living Andhra Tradition Oxford Oxford University Press Parpola A Human Sacrifice in India in Vedic Times and Before in Bremmer J N 2007 The Strange World of Human Sacrifice Peeters Web sources Edit Retrieved from https en wikipedia org w index php title Purushamedha amp oldid 1099174263, wikipedia, wiki, book, books, library,
