Look to the East policy

The Look to the East policy (Persian: نگاه به شرق) is a strategy in Iran's foreign policy that has been proposed since the beginning of Mahmoud Ahmadinejad's presidency in 2005. Of course, there is no consensus among experts as to which countries are among the goals of the Look to the East policy, and from which point of view this policy should be viewed, and there are at least three different views.^[1]

This policy falls within the theoretical framework of constructivism.^[2][3][4][5]

Concept

The concept of Look to the East policy, evokes three states in mind: Development of relations with the East and the limitation of relations with the West, Symmetric balance in relations with East and West, Asymmetric balance in relations with East and West with the priority of the East. Look to the East policy seems to be closer to the third clause; Because the Look to the East policy is based on avoiding Western-oriented unilateralism in foreign policy and a comprehensive view of foreign policy in order to take advantage and create opportunities. Therefore, it is different from the first meaning and at the same time, it has subtle differences with the second meaning; Because the Look to the East policy is based on trying to communicate with the East and the West at the same time, prioritizing the East for geopolitical, cultural, economic and even political reasons. Therefore, this approach does not mean negation and indifference to the West. In fact, the emphasis on the East here is not the negation of the West. In this regard, it should be said that Look to the East policy is a realistic strategy and, above all, seeks to use the opportunities of communication with different countries. In this regard, Ali Akbar Velayati, in describing the Look to the East policy, states: "Wherever our interests, desires and strategy are better and more met, it is natural that we give priority to it."^[6]

Characteristics

In a situation where there is neither a clear reality called the "Eastern bloc" nor the ideological claims of the East, Look to the East policy does not mean following the East and pure compliance with the Eastern countries, as was imagined during the Cold War. Therefore, the characteristics of the Look to the East policy can be listed as follows:^[6]

• In balancing relations between East and West, Iran gives priority to the East, but does not negate the West, but is mainly opposed to an over-inclination to the West.
• It is based on creating advantage and opportunity. Therefore, it has flexibility and fluidity. In other words, it considers the field of relations with countries as wide.
• Nor is it contrary to the policy of "neither East nor West";^[7] Because turning to the East does not mean accepting the domination of the East, and the East, is no longer like the former and has collapsed realistically and ideologically.

History

Since the beginning of the Islamic Republic, Iran has made the slogan "neither East nor West"^[7] its motto and tried to take an independent step in its foreign policy. Until the end of the Cold War, Iran's absolutist approach to this slogan prevented Iran from finding strategic allies.^[8] The Look to the East policy came at a time when Iran's negotiations with European and Western countries over Iran's nuclear program were challenged and failed to serve national interests well; At the same time, the developments that have taken place in Asia in recent years have created new conditions.^[9][10]

One of the most important issues related to foreign policy after the ninth government came to power was the Look to the East policy and expanding Iran's relations with Asian countries. In fact, the failure to achieve the desired goals in relations with Western countries with the continuing hostility between Iran and the United States, especially in the nuclear case, led to the expansion of Iran's relations with the East to be considered and emphasized once again. This policy has so far been practically accompanied by a series of international movements and political stances.^[11]

Due to the issue of Iran's nuclear case, in which the three European countries, Britain, France and Germany, played a key role in the negotiations, and the emergence of a stalemate in this case by the mentioned countries, and that these three countries introduced themselves as representatives of the European Community or of the West in general, increased the tendency to find new horizons in the foreign policy of the Islamic Republic of Iran. The Look to the East policy was in fact derived from the conditions mentioned. However, such a policy was not unprecedented in Iran and in the second presidential term of Mr. Hashemi Rafsanjani, moves were made to strengthen existing ties with important Asian countries such as China, India and Russia within the framework of a strategic alliance.^[12]

The Look to the East policy has been considered in the foreign policy of the Islamic Republic of Iran at different times, with strengths and weaknesses. However, it seems that in the recent years, this strategy has received more and more attention, as Ali Khamenei the Supreme Leader of Iran emphasizes: "In foreign policy, the preference of the East over the West, the preference of the neighbor over the distant, the preference nations and countries that have something in common with us over others is one of our priorities today" (Tabriz, February 18, 2018). In this regard, Ali Akbar Velayati, the International Advisor to the Supreme Leader of Iran, also considers Look to the East policy as a strategic necessity for the Islamic Republic in order to secure its economic, political and defense interests.^[6]

The Look to the East policy focused on securance of the country's equipment needs from countries such as China, Russia, and North Korea. Given the success of cooperation with the countries of the Eastern sphere (the mentioned countries), the Look to the East policy as a special strategy used by the Iran's presidents (Messrs. "Akbar Hashemi Rafsanjani", "Mohammad Khatami", "Mahmoud Ahmadinejad" and even "Hassan Rouhani"). Of course, among the mentioned governments, during Ahmadinejad's presidency, due to the unprecedented pressure of the West on the Islamic Republic of Iran under political pretexts, this idea took over the country's diplomatic apparatus, which is the key to solving fundamental problems in foreign policy not located in European capitals but in East Asia. According to this, Ahmadinejad, while reforming the approaches and policies of the previous government (Khatami), which was based on establishing and deepening relations with the West and specifically Europe, made special efforts to establish relations with the Eastern world.^[13]

After the end of the government of Mahmoud Ahmadinejad in 2013, the eleventh government led by Hassan Rouhani, although made special efforts to solve the previous problems and subsequently improve relations with the West through the so-called "Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA, BARJAM)" agreement, but Rouhani did not overlooked from East Asia, and specifically the Indo-Pacific strategic area. Because he knew that given the specific geopolitical and geostrategic situations, these regions would be able to influence the order of the world power pyramid in the coming years. That is why the Rouhani's government set up Iran–China 25-year Cooperation Program as a rising power in politics and international relations.^[13]

The Look to the East policy has so far been seen as an escape rather than an opportunity to turn to in times of trouble with the West. To put it better, it can be said that the strategy of Look to the East in the field of foreign policy of the Islamic Republic of Iran has been more affected by the challenge to the West as a codified policy.^[13]

Target countries

Countries such as Japan,^[9] South Korea,^[9] China,^[1] Malaysia,^[9] Russia,^[1] India^[1] and Pakistan^[1] have been targeted in this policy. Of course, according to some, since Japan and South Korea, by adopting the economic policies of liberal capitalism and cultural dissolution in Western civilization, are no longer defined in the context of Oriental civilization, they can no longer have a place in this policy, and the Look to the East policy is based on the four pillars of Russia, India, China and Malaysia.^[14]

Approaches

Geographical-ideological

Based on this type of view, the definition of the Eastern sphere is based on geographical location and to some extent the confrontation with the Western world.According to this view, Latin American countries are also defined in the Eastern sphere. This approach has been the basis of decision-making in Ahmadinejad's government.^[1]

Ideological

With the ideological view, which is based on the bipolar east–west confrontation and the Islamist view of the Islamic Republic, the countries of the Islamic world are also defined in the Eastern sphere. This view has few fans.^[1]

Pragmatic

This view of the East is based on the Eastern civilization and with a regional and neighborhood perspective and tries to provide a spatial and geographical identity from the East.^[1]

Criticism

Fereydoon Majlesi,^[15][16] former Iranian diplomat, believes that the Look to the East policy not only does not lead to Iran's progress and exit from the current situation, but also traps the country in a non-competitive market and causes uneconomic and harmful trade interactions. According to him, the strategy of Look to the East does not make sense for Iran. With this policy, Iran becomes captive to its inability with the East and remains trapped in this market. Therefore, if they give any goods at any price, Iran will have to buy. While Iran should be free in its relations and become a customer of any market that offers better goods at a more competitive price. According to him, the strategy of Look to the East causes Iranian to pay a lot of financial ransom to the countries of the East for playing as broker in the world market. According to him, in general, the Look to the East policy results in a harmful economy for Iran.^[17]

Qaem Mousavi,^[18] Iranian political science expert, says regarding the Look to the East policy: "Iran has tended to China and Russia because of the influence of the West and the pressures of the United States, but China and Russia have not responded positively to our country despite the apparent-verbal declaration. They did not support us in major crises and troubles. China and Russia deprive us of what was necessary and left us empty-handed". According to him, Russia benefits are served from Iran's troubles with the West and therefore Russia encourages the continuation of this dispute in order to secure its interests. Russia, meanwhile, has not provided adequate support where needed. According to him, Iran is forced to ignore China's bad treatment with its Muslims in the face of US and Western pressure. According to him, Iran should avoid dependence on Russia and China, because they are not reliable and stable allies and will no doubt not provide the necessary support to Iran in sensitive areas.^[19]

References

1. آدمی, علی (2010). ["Look to the East" Strategy in the Foreign Policy of the Islamic Republic of Iran: Perspectives, Backgrounds and Opportunities]. فصلنامه مطالعات سیاسی (in Persian) (7): 98. Archived from the original on 2021-07-09.
2. آدمی, علی (2010). ["Look to the East" Strategy in the Foreign Policy of the Islamic Republic of Iran: Perspectives, Backgrounds and Opportunities]. فصلنامه مطالعات سیاسی (in Persian) (7): 100–104. Archived from the original on 2021-07-09.
3. "راهبرد نگاه به شرق در سیاست خارجی جمهوری اسلامی ایران دیدگاه ها، زمینه ها و فرصت ها - پرتال جامع علوم انسانی" (in Persian). Retrieved 5 July 2021.
4. علی, آدمی (January 2010). "راهبرد نگاه به شرق در سياست خارجي جمهوري اسلامي ايران ديدگاه ها، زمينه ها و فرصت ها - مرکز اطلاعات علمی جهاد دانشگاهی" (in Persian). pp. 97–126. Retrieved 5 July 2021.
5. "راهبرد نگاه به شرق در سیاست خارجی جمهوری اسلامی ایران دیدگاه، زمینه ها و فرصت ها - نورمگز" (in Persian). Retrieved 5 July 2021.
6. "چیستی و چرایی راهبرد "نگاه به شرق" - بصیرت" (in Persian). Retrieved 5 July 2021.
7. "امام خمینی (س) - اصل نه شرقی و نه غربی" (in Persian). Retrieved 5 July 2021.
8. ثقفی عامری, ناصر (January 2007). "در جست‌وجوی افق‌های جدید در سیاست خارجی ایران: سیاست نگاه به شرق" [In Search of New Horizons in Iranian Foreign Policy: The Look to the East Policy] (in Persian). پژوهش ۵. مرکز تحقیقات استراتژیک: 1. {{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires |journal= (help)
9. ثقفی عامری, ناصر (January 2007). "در جست‌وجوی افق‌های جدید در سیاست خارجی ایران: سیاست نگاه به شرق" [In Search of New Horizons in Iranian Foreign Policy: The Look to the East Policy] (in Persian). پژوهش ۵. مرکز تحقیقات استراتژیک: 2. {{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires |journal= (help)
10. کتاب در جستجوی افق های جدید در سیاست خارجی ایران، سیاست نگاه به شرق - کتابناک (in Persian). Retrieved 5 July 2021.
11. "تحقیقات راهبردی - رویکرد نگاه به شرق در سیاست خارجی جمهوری اسلامی ایران (شماره 5)" (in Persian). Retrieved 5 July 2021.
12. "سیاست نگاه به شرق و ایران - پژوهشکده تحقیقات راهبردی" (in Persian). Retrieved 5 July 2021.
13. (in Persian). Archived from the original on 9 July 2021. Retrieved 5 July 2021.
14. آدمی, علی (2010). ["Look to the East" Strategy in the Foreign Policy of the Islamic Republic of Iran: Perspectives, Backgrounds and Opportunities]. فصلنامه مطالعات سیاسی (in Persian) (7): 104. Archived from the original on 2021-07-09.
15. "فریدون مجلسی - مترجم کتاب منم کلودیوس" (in Persian). Retrieved 5 July 2021.
16. (in Persian). Archived from the original on 9 July 2021. Retrieved 5 July 2021.
17. "راهبرد "نگاه به شرق" ایران را اسیر تعاملات زیان بار می کند" (in Persian). Retrieved 5 July 2021.
18. "سید قائم موسوی - جویشگر علمی فارسی (علم نت)" (in Persian). Retrieved 5 July 2021.
19. "بررسی نگاه ایران به شرق و روابط با چین و روسیه" (in Persian). Retrieved 5 July 2021.

External links

• Iran’s Look East Policy: Analyzing The Possibility Of Establishment Of Strategic Economic Alliance Between The Islamic Republic Of Iran And China (1989 2013)
• Iran’s look east policy may force US rethink
• Iran’s “Look to the East Policy”: Pivot Towards China and Eurasian Economic Union
• Implications of Tehran’s Look to the East Policy for EU-Iran Relations
• Iran sticks to 'Look to the East' doctrine amid frustration with Europe
• Iran Looking East A Shifting Balance of Power in Tehran’s Foreign Policy
• Iran and look to the east policy
• Iran's Look to the East - İRAM Center