Child marriage in India

Child marriage in India, according to the Indian law, is a marriage where the woman and man is below the age of 18 and 21 respectively . Most child marriages involve girls, many of whom are poor socio-economic conditions.

Child Marriage India by SDRC

Child marriages are prevalent in India. Estimates vary widely between sources as to the extent and scale of child marriages. A 2015–2016 UNICEF report estimated that India's child marriage rate is 27%.^[1] The Census of India has counted and reported married women by age, with proportion of females in child marriage falling in each 10 year census period since 1981. In its 2001 census report, India stated zero married girls below the age of 10, 1.4 million married girls out of 59.2 million girls aged 10–14, and 11.3 million married girls out of 46.3 million girls aged 15–19.^[2] Times of India reported that 'since 2001, child marriage rates in India have fallen by 46% between 2005 and 2009.^[3] Jharkhand is the state with highest child marriage rates in India (14.1%), while Kerala is the only state where child marriage rates have increased in recent years.^[3][4] Jammu and Kashmir was reported to be the only state with lowest child marriage cases at 0.4% in 2009.^[3] Rural rates of child marriages were three times higher than urban India rates in 2009.^[3]

Child marriage was outlawed in 1929, under Indian law. However, in British colonial times, the legal minimum age of marriage was set at 14 for girls and 18 for boys. Under protests from Muslim organizations in undivided British India, a personal law Sharia Act was passed in 1937 that allowed child marriages with consent from a girl's guardian.^[5] After India's independence in 1947, the act underwent two revisions. The minimum legal age for marriage was increased to 15 for girls in 1949, and to 18 for females and 21 for males in 1978.^[6] The child marriage prevention laws have been challenged in Indian courts,^[5] with some Muslim Indian organizations seeking no minimum age and that the age matter be left to their personal law.^[7][8] Child marriage is an active political subject as well as a subject of continuing cases under review in the highest courts of India.^[7]

Several states of India have introduced incentives to delay marriages. For example, the state of Haryana introduced the so-called Apni Beti, Apna Dhan program in 1994, which translates to "My daughter, My wealth". It is a conditional cash transfer program dedicated to delaying young marriages by providing a government paid bond in her name, payable to her parents, in the amount of ₹25,000 (US$310), after her 18th birthday if she is not married.

Definitions of child marriage

India

Child marriage is a complex subject under Indian law. It was defined by The Child Marriage Restraint Act in 1929,^[9] which set the minimum age of marriage for females to be 14 and males 18. The law was opposed by Muslims and subsequently superseded for Muslims of British India by the Muslim Personal Law (Shariat) Application Act of 1937,^[5] which implied no minimum limit and allowed parental or guardian consent in case of Muslim marriages.

The 1929 law for non-Muslims was amended twice after India gained independence in 1947. In 1949, the minimum age for girls was increased to 15, and in 1978 the minimum age was increased for both genders: to 18 for females and 21 for males.^[6][10] The applicability and permissibility of child marriage among Muslims under the 1937 Act, under India's Constitution adopted in 1950, remains a controversial subject, with a series of Supreme Court cases and rulings.^[5]

The definition of child marriage was last updated by India with its The Prohibition of Child Marriage Act of 2006, which applies to all Indians except the state of Jammu and Kashmir and the renoucants of the union territory of Puducherry. For Muslims of India, child marriage definition and regulations based on Sharia and Nikah has been claimed by some as a personal law subject but has been ruled by various courts that it applies to Muslims also.^[5][7] For all others, The Prohibition of Child Marriage Act of 2006 defines "child marriage" means a marriage, or a marriage about to be solemnized, to which either of the contracting parties is a child; and child for purposes of marriage is defined based on gender of the person – if a male, it is 21 years of age, and if a female, 18 years of age.^[11]

World

UNICEF defines child marriage as a formal marriage or informal union before 18 years of age,^[12][13] because it can lead to a lifetime of suffering for girls who are more likely to experience domestic violence or die due to complications in pregnancy and childbirth.^[12][14] UN Women proposes that child marriage be defined as a forced marriage because they believe children under age are incapable of giving a legally valid consent.^[15]

Statistics

Child marriage rate estimates in India vary significantly between sources.

UN and other estimates

Source	% Females married (< 18)	Data Year	Sampling method	Reference
ICRW	47	1998	small sample survey	^[16]
UN	30	2005	small sample survey	^[17]
NFHS-3	44.5	1998–2002	small sample survey	^[18]^[19]
UNICEF	47	2005–06		^[20]
UNICEF	27	2015–16		^[20]
NFHS-4	26.8	2015–2016		^[21]

The small sample surveys have different methods of estimating overall child marriages in India, some using multi-year basis data. For example, NFHS-3 and NFHS-4 data for 2005 mentioned in above table, used a survey of women aged 20–24, where they were asked if they were married before they were 18.^[18] The NFHS-3 also surveyed older women, up to the age of 49, asking the same question. The survey found that many more 40–49 were married before they turned 18, than 20–24 age women who were interviewed. In 1970s, the minimum legal age of marriage, in India, for women was 15.^[10]

According to UNICEF report published in 2005–06, child marriage rates in India were estimated to be around 47%. This figure declined to 27% in 2015–16 according to a new report published by UNICEF. UNICEF also reported that the child marriage was wide spread in three Indian states (Rajasthan, Bihar and West Bengal) and there is a 40% prevalence of child marriage in these states.^[20]

Javier Aguilar, UNICEF’s chief of child protection, stated that the India accounts for the highest number of child marriages in South Asia given its size and population.^[22]

Indian government estimate

Source	% Females married (< 18)	Data Year	Sampling method	Reference
Census of India	43.4	1981	Nationwide census	^[23]
Census of India	35.3	1991	Nationwide census	^[23]
Census of India	14.4	2001	Nationwide census	^[2]
Census of India	3.7	2011	Nationwide census	^[24]

The states with highest observed marriage rates for under-18 girls in 2009, according to a Registrar General of India report, were Jharkhand (14.1%), West Bengal (13.6%), Bihar (9.3%), Uttar Pradesh (8.9%) and Assam (8.8%).^[3] According to this report, despite sharp reductions in child marriage rates since 1991, still 7% of women passing the age of 18 in India were married as of 2009. UNICEF India has played a significant role in highlighting the Indian child marriage rate prevalence data from its 1990s study.

According to 2011 nationwide census of India, the average age of marriage for women is 21.2.^[25][26] In the age group 15–19, 69.6% of all women surveyed in India had never been married.^[27]

Criticism

Several activists have expressed skepticism regarding the decline in child marriage cases in India.^[28] They believe that "the UNICEF report might not be reflecting reality on the ground and the numbers are likely not as low as they appear in the report".^[28] They state that the data relating to child marriage is colled by local government and not by UNICEF. In India, the government ask about the age of bride and groom as a part of census data, which is collected every year. However, since the people know that child marriage is illegal in India, so they are less likely to tell the authorities that they have broken the law.^[28] Dhuwarakha Sriram, child protection specialist at UNICEF India, says that "everyone knows that there is underreporting in India – even the UNICEF is aware of it". According to Sriram, people are aware of the illegal age of marriage in India, so they are less likely to tell the truth, which in turn leads to underreporting.^[28]

Kriti Bharti, who runs a non-government organization called Saarthi, says people in Rajasthan have developed ways of evading the law.^[28] For example, marriage ceremonies for underage persons will be held at night, with small groups of people attending. This reduces the chance of neighbours or relatives alerting authorities.^[28] Once the marriage has taken place, the underage bride remains with her parents until she reaches puberty. This way, even if the authorities have been tipped off, the families can deny any wrongdoing. Bharti states in addition to this, 'in some parts of India, authorities are not always interested and child marriage may be accepted as a part of the culture.^[28]

Laws against child marriage

The Child Marriage Restraint Act of 1929

The Child Marriage Restraint Act, also called the Sarda Act,^[29] was a law to restrict the practice of child marriage. It was enacted on 1 April 1930, extended across the whole nation, with the exceptions of some princely states like Hyderabad and Jammu and Kashmir. This Act defined the age of marriage to be 18 for males and 14 for females. In 1949, after India's independence, the minimum age was increased to 15 for females, and in 1978, it was increased again for both females and males, to 18 and 21 years, respectively.

The punishment for a male between 18 and 21 years marrying a child became imprisonment of up to 15 days, a fine of 1,000 rupees, or both. The punishment for a male above 21 years of age became imprisonment of up to three months and a possible fine. The punishment for anyone who performed or directed a child marriage ceremony became imprisonment of up to three months and a possible fine, unless he could prove the marriage he performed was not a child marriage. The punishment for a parent or guardian of a child taking place in the marriage became imprisonment of up to three months or a possible fine.^[30] It was amended in 1940 and 1978 to continue raising the ages of male and female children.^[29]

The Prohibition of Child Marriage Act, 2006

In response to the plea (Writ Petition (C) 212/2003) of the Forum for Fact-finding Documentation and Advocacy at the Supreme Court, the Government of India brought the Prohibition of Child Marriage Act (PCMA) in 2006, and it came into effect on 1 November 2007 to address and fix the shortcomings of the Child Marriage Restraint Act.^[31] The change in name was meant to reflect the prevention and prohibition of child marriage, rather than restraining it.^[29][31] The previous Act also made it difficult and time consuming to act against child marriages and did not focus on authorities as possible figures for preventing the marriages.^[31]

This Act kept the ages of adult males and females the same but made some significant changes to further protect the children. Boys and girls forced into child marriages as minors have the option of voiding their marriage up to two years after reaching adulthood, and in certain circumstances, marriages of minors can be null and void before they reach adulthood. All valuables, money, and gifts must be returned if the marriage is nullified, and the girl must be provided with a place of residency until she marries or becomes an adult. Children born from child marriages are considered legitimate, and the courts are expected to give parental custody with the children's best interests in mind. Any male over 18 years of age who enters into a marriage with a minor or anyone who directs or conducts a child marriage ceremony can be punished with up to two years of imprisonment or a fine.^[32]

Prohibition of Child Marriage (Amendment) Bill, 2021

In December 2021, the Indian Government presented a bill called the 'Prohibition of Child Marriage (Amendment) Bill, 2021' in Parliament. The purpose of this bill is to equalize the age of marriage for women with that of men by raising it to 21 years.^[33] The underlying premise of the Bill is that by increasing the age of marriage, it will eliminate the prevalence of child marriage.^[33] Shortly after the bill was introduced, Women and Child Development Minister Smriti Irani stated that the bill aims to supersede all current laws, including any traditions, customs, or practices related to marriage.^[34]

Applicability

Muslim organizations of India have long argued^[8][35] that Indian laws, passed by its parliament, such as the 2006 child marriage law do not apply to Muslims, because marriage is a personal law subject.^[5][7] The Delhi High Court, as well as other state high courts of India, have disagreed. The Delhi Court, for example, ruled that Prohibition of Child Marriage Act, 2006 overrides all personal laws and governs each and every citizen of India^[36] The ruling stated that an under-age marriage, where either the man or woman is over 16 years old, would not be a void marriage but voidable one, which would become valid if no steps are taken by such court as has option[s] to order otherwise. In case either of the parties is less than 18 years old, the marriage is void, given the age of consent is 18 in India, sex with minors under the age of 18 is a statutory crime under Section 376 of Indian Penal Code.^[36]

Various other High courts in India – including the Gujarat High Court,^[37] the Karnataka High Court^[38] and the Madras High Court^[39] – have ruled that the act prevails over any personal law (including Muslim personal law).

Legal action on legal confusion

There is a standing legal confusion as to Marital Rape within prohibited Child Marriages in India. Marital rape per se is not a crime in India; but the position with regard to children is confusing. While the exception under the criminal law (section 375, Indian Penal Code, 1860) applicable to adults puts an exception and allows marital rape of a girl child between the age of 15–18 years by her husband. However this provision of exception has been read down by the Supreme Court of India in the case of Independent Thought v. Union of India in October 2017 and it declares that sexual intercourse with all wives below 18 years of age shall be considered as rape; another new and progressive legislation Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 disallows any such sexual relationships and puts such crimes with marriages as an aggravated offense.

CEDAW

The Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women (CEDAW) is an international bill attempting to end discrimination against women. Article 16, Marriage and Family Life, states that all women, as well as men, have the right to choose their spouse, to have the same responsibilities, and to decide on how many children and the spacing between them. This convention states that child marriage should not have a legal effect, all action must be taken to enforce a minimum age, and that all marriages must be put into an official registry.^[40] India signed the convention on 30 July 1980 but made the declaration that, because of the nation's size and population, it is impractical to have a registration of marriages.^[41]

Consequences of child marriage

Early maternal deaths

Girls who marry earlier in life are less likely to be informed about reproductive issues,^[42] and because of this, pregnancy-related deaths are known to be the leading cause of mortality among married girls between 15 and 19 years of age.^[43] These girls are twice more likely to die in childbirth than girls between 20 and 24 years of age.^[44] Girls younger than 15 years of age are five times more likely to die in childbirth.^[45][46]

Infant health

Infants born to mothers under the age of 18 are 60% more likely to die in their first year than to mothers over the age of 19. If the children survive, they are more likely to suffer from low birth weight, malnutrition, and late physical and cognitive development.^[12][46]

Fertility outcomes

A study conducted in India by the International Institute for Population Sciences and Macro International in 2005 and 2006 showed high fertility, low fertility control, and poor fertility outcomes data within child marriages. 90.8% of young married women reported no use of a contraceptive prior to having their first child. 23.9% reported having a child within the first year of marriage. 17.3% reported having three or more children over the course of the marriage. 23% reported a rapid repeat childbirth, and 15.2% reported an unwanted pregnancy. 15.3% reported a pregnancy termination (stillbirths, miscarriages or abortions).^[47] Fertility rates are higher in slums than in urban areas.^[48]

Violence

Young girls in a child marriage are more likely to experience domestic violence in their marriages as opposed to older women. A study conducted in India by the International Centre for Research on Women showed that girls married before 18 years of age are twice as likely to be beaten, slapped, or threatened by their husbands^[45] and three times more likely to experience sexual violence.^[49] Young brides often show symptoms of sexual abuse and post-traumatic stress.^[45]

Prevention programmes

Apni Beti, Apna Dhan (ABAD), which translates to "My daughter, My wealth", is one of India's first conditional cash transfer programmes dedicated to delaying young marriages across the nation. In 1994, the Indian government implemented this programme in the state of Haryana. On the birth of a mother's first, second, or third child, they are set to receive ₹ 500, or US$11 within the first 15 days to cover their post-delivery needs. Along with this, the government gives ₹ 2,500, or US$35, to invest in a long-term savings bond in the daughter's name, which can be later cashed for ₹ 25,000, or US$350, after her 18 birthday. She can only receive the money if she is not married. Anju Malhotra, an expert on child marriage and adolescent girls said of this programme, "No other conditional cash transfer has this focus of delaying marriage... It's an incentive to encourage parents to value their daughters."^[50]

The International Centre for Research on Women will evaluate Apni Beti, Apna Dhan over the course of the year 2012, when the program's initial participants turn 18, to see if the programme, particularly the cash incentive, has motivated parents to delay their daughters' marriages. "We have evidence that conditional cash transfer programmes are very effective in keeping girls in school and getting them immunized, but we don’t yet have proof that this strategy works for preventing marriage," said Pranita Achyut, the program manager for Apni Beti, Apna Dhan. "If Haryana state’s approach proves to be valuable, it could potentially be scaled up to make a significant difference in many more girls' lives – and not only in India."^[50]

See also

• Child marriage among Muslims in Kerala
• Child marriage
• Teenage pregnancy

References

1. "Ending Child Marriage: A profile of progress in India". UNICEF DATA. 28 February 2019. Retrieved 20 March 2022.
2. .Table C-2 Marital Status by Age and Sex Subtable C0402, India Total Females Married by Age Group, 2001 Census of India, Government of India (2009)
3. K. Sinha Nearly 50% fall in brides married below 18 The Times of India (February 10, 2012)
4. R Gopakumar, Child marriages high in Kerala Deccan Herald (June 19, 2013)
5. Hilary Amster, Child marriage in India 14 July 2014 at the Wayback Machine University of San Francisco (2009)
6. Graner, Elvira (2020), "Governing Child Marriage in India: The Protracted Reform Process", in Samita Sen, Anindita Ghosh (ed.), Love, Labour and Law: Early and Child Marriage in India, SAGE Publishing, p. 63, ISBN 978-93-81345-60-3, In 1929, the Indian Legislative Assembly passed the Child Marriage Restraint Act. While the Act initially set the marriage age at 14 for girls, two amendments in 1949 and 1978, first increased the age to 15 and later onto 18.
7. M.G. Radhakrishnan and J. Binduraj, In a league of their own India Today (July 5, 2013)
8. Muzaffar Ali Sajjad And Ors. vs State Of Andhra Pradesh on 9 November, 2001 Andhra Pradesh High Court, India
9. The Child Marriage Restraint Act, 1929 British India
10. Child Marriage in India: Achievements, Gaps and Challenges OHCHR, United Nations
11. The Prohibition of Child Marriage Act of 2006 27 January 2018 at the Wayback Machine The Gazette of India, Ministry of Law and Justice, Government of India (January 11, 2007)
12. "Child marriage". UNICEF. Archived from the original on 28 July 2020. Retrieved 6 March 2021.
13. "Child marriage is a violation of human rights, but is all too common". Archived from the original on 27 October 2018. Retrieved 22 July 2021.
14. "Child marriage around the world". UNICEF. Archived from the original on 22 July 2021. Retrieved 22 July 2021.
15. "Definition of forced and child marriage". UN Women. 2012.
16. "Child Marriage Facts and Figures".
17. "United Nations Statistics Division – Demographic and Social Statistics".
18. A Handbook of Statistical Indicators of Indian Women 14 July 2014 at the Wayback Machine Ministry of Women and Child Welfare, Govt of India (2007)
19. Raj, A.; Saggurti, N.; Balaiah, D.; Silverman, J. G. (2009). "Prevalence of child marriage and its effect on fertility and fertility-control outcomes of young women in India: a cross-sectional, observational study". The Lancet. 373 (9678): 1883–1889. doi:10.1016/s0140-6736(09)60246-4. PMC 2759702. PMID 19278721.
20. "Child marriage widespread in Bihar, Rajasthan and Bengal: Unicef report". India Today. 12 February 2019. Retrieved 27 December 2019.
21. 23 million child brides in India, Supreme Court expresses dismay
22. Srivastava, Roli (6 March 2018). "India's child marriage numbers drop sharply, driving down global rate: UNICEF". Retrieved 27 December 2019.
23. Jasodhara Bagchi et al., The Changing Status of Women in West Bengal, 1970–2000: The Challenge Ahead, SAGE Publications, ISBN 978-0761932420, Table 1.10, page 29, rows for India totals
24. Percentage of Female by age at effective marriage and by residence India and bigger States, 2011 Chapter 2, Population Composition, Table Statement 12, India totals for < 18, 2011 Census of India, Government of India (2013), page 26
25. Mean age at effective marriage of Female by residence India and bigger States, 2011 Chapter 2, Population Composition, Table Statement 13, India totals for All ages, 2011 Census of India, Government of India (2013), page 27
26. Women and men in India 2012 12 October 2013 at the Wayback Machine CSO/Census India 2011, Government of India, See page xxi, Highlights item 5
27. National Family Health Survey – India, International Institute for Population Sciences and Government of India (2009), see Table 6.1
28. "UNICEF's Good News About Child Marriage Isn't Quite As Good As It Sounds". npr.org. 14 March 2018. Retrieved 27 December 2019.
29. Goswami, Ruchira (2010). "Child Marriage in India: Mapping the Trajectory of Legal Reforms".
30. . Government of India Ministry of Women and Child Development. Archived from the original on 27 March 2012. Retrieved 10 April 2012.
31. (PDF). Archived from the original (PDF) on 21 October 2014. Retrieved 10 April 2012.
32. "Child Marriage in India: Mapping the Trajectory of Legal Reforms at Sanhati".
33. https://pib.gov.in/PressReleasePage.aspx?PRID=1908007#:~:text=Further%2C%20the%20Government%20has%20introduced,at%20par%20with%20the%20men
34. PTI (21 December 2021). "Modi govt introduces bill to increase women's marriage age to 21 years in Lok Sabha". ThePrint. Retrieved 1 October 2023.
35. Mrs. Tahra Begum vs State Of Delhi & Ors. on 9 May, 2012 Archive of Legal Proceedings, Delhi High Court, India
36. 2012 [Volume No. 3] JCC [Journal of Criminal Cases] Page No. 2148
37. "Prohibition of Child Marriage Act to prevail over personal laws: HC". The Indian Express. 25 September 2015.
38. "Child Marriage Act overrides Muslim Personal Law: Karnataka high court". The Times of India.
39. "Madras HC says anti-child marriage act prevails over Muslim Personal Law". dna. 1 April 2015.
40. "CEDAW 29th Session 30 June to 25 July 2003".
41. . Archived from the original on 23 August 2012. Retrieved 10 April 2012.
42. Chandrasekhar, S., 2010, "Factors Affecting Age and Marriage and Age at First Birth in India," Journal of Quantitative Economics, pg. 83
43. "Statistics by Area- Child Marriage". childinfo.org. 2009.
44. "Early marriage: A childhood interrupted". UNICEF.
45. "Child Marriage Facts and Figures". International Center for Research on Women.
46. Hervish, Alexandra, Charlotte Feldman-Jacobs, 2011, "Who Speaks for Me? Ending Child Marriage," Population Reference Bureau, page 2
47. Raj, A; Saggurti, N; Balaiah, D; Silverman, JG (2009). "Prevalence of child marriage and its effect on fertility and fertility-control outcomes of young women in India: a cross-sectional, observational study". Lancet. 373 (9678): 1883–9. doi:10.1016/S0140-6736(09)60246-4. PMC 2759702. PMID 19278721.
48. Chandrasekhar, S (2010). "Factors Affecting Age and Marriage and Age at First Birth in India". Journal of Quantitative Economics: 86.
49. United States Agency for International Development, 2007, "New Insights on Preventing Child Marriage: A Global Analysis of Factors and Programs," pg. 9
50. "Child Marriage Facts and Figures". International Center for Research on Women.