Book of Ingenious Devices

The Book of Ingenious Devices (Arabic: كتاب الحيل Kitab al-Hiyal, Persian: كتاب ترفندها Ketab tarfandha, literally: "The Book of Tricks") is a large illustrated work on mechanical devices, including automata, published in 850 by the three brothers of Persian^[1] descent, known as the Banu Musa (Ahmad, Muhammad and Hasan bin Musa ibn Shakir) working at the House of Wisdom (Bayt al-Hikma) in Baghdad, Iraq, under the Abbasid Caliphate.^[2] The book described about one hundred devices and how to use them.^[3]

Drawing of Self trimming lamp in Ahmad ibn Mūsā ibn Shākir's treatise on mechanical devices. The manuscript was written in Arabic.
Author	Banū Mūsā
Original title	كتاب الحيل

Overview

The book was commissioned by the Abbasid Caliph of Baghdad, Abu Jafar al-Ma'mun ibn Harun (786–833), who instructed the Banu Musa to acquire all of the Hellenistic texts that had been preserved by monasteries^[specify] and by scholars^[who?] during the decline and fall of Roman civilization.^{[4][clarification needed]} The Banū Mūsā brothers invented a number of automata (automatic machines) and mechanical devices, and they described a hundred such devices in their Book of Ingenious Devices.^[3]

Some of the devices described in the Book of Ingenious Devices were inspired by the works of Hero of Alexandria^[5] and Philo of Byzantium, as well as ancient Persian, Chinese and Indian engineering.^[6] Many of the other devices described in the book, however, were original inventions by the Banu Musa brothers.^[7] While they took Greek works as a starting point, the Banu Musa went "well beyond anything achieved by Hero or Philo." Their preoccupation with automatic controls distinguishes them from their Greek predecessors, including the Banu Musa's "use of self-operating valves, timing devices, delay systems and other concepts of great ingenuity."^[8] Many of their innovations involved subtle combinations of pneumatics and aerostatics.^[8] The closest modern parallel to their work lies in control engineering and pneumatic instrumentation.^[9]

In turn, the Banu Musa's work was later cited as an influence on the work of Al-Jazari, who produced a similarly titled book in 1206.^[10] Given that the Book of Ingenious Devices was widely circulated across the Muslim world, some of its ideas may have also reached Europe through Islamic Spain, such as the use of automatic controls in later European machines or the use of conical valves in the work of Leonardo da Vinci.^[9]

Mechanisms and components

Automatic controls

The Banu Musa brothers described a number of early automatic controls.^[11] Two-step level controls for fluids, an early form of discontinuous variable structure controls, were developed by the Banu Musa brothers.^[12] They also described an early feedback controller.^{[13][page needed]} Donald Routledge Hill wrote the following on the automatic controls underlying the mechanical trick devices described in the book:

The trick vessels have a variety of different effects. For example, a single outlet pipe in a vessel might pour out first wine, then water and finally a mixture of the two. Although it cannot be claimed that the results are important, the means by which they were obtained are of great significance for the history of engineering. The Banu Musa were masters in the exploitation of small variations in aerostatic and hydrostatic pressures and in using conical valves as "in-line" components in flow systems, the first known use of conical valves as automatic controllers.^[14]

The Banu Musa also developed an early fail-safe system for use in their trick devices, as described by Hill:

In several of these vessels, one can withdraw small quantities of liquid repeatedly, but if one withdraws a large quantity, no further extractions are possible. In modern terms, one would call the method used to achieve this result a fail-safe system.^[14]

Automatic crank

The non-manual crank appears in several of the hydraulic devices described by the Banū Mūsā brothers in their Book of Ingenious Devices.^[15] These automatically operated cranks appear in several devices, two of which contain an action which approximates to that of a crankshaft, anticipating Al-Jazari's invention by several centuries and its first appearance in Europe by over five centuries. However, the automatic crank described by the Banu Musa would not have allowed a full rotation, but only a small modification was required to convert it to a crankshaft.^[16]

Valves

A mechanism developed by the Banu Musa, of particular importance for future developments, was the conical valve, which was used in a variety of different applications.^[8] This includes using conical valves as "in-line" components in flow systems, which was the first known use of conical valves as automatic controllers.^[14] Some of the other valves they described include:

• Plug valve^[13][14]
• Float valve^[13]
• Tap^[17]

Other mechanisms

The double-concentric siphon and the funnel with bent end for pouring in different liquids, neither of which appear in any earlier Greek works, were also original inventions by the Banu Musa brothers.^[6] Some of the other mechanisms they described include a float chamber^[11] and an early differential pressure sensor.^[18]

Machines and devices

Automatic fountains

The book describes the construction of various automatic fountains, an aspect that was largely neglected in earlier Greek treatises on technology.^[6] In one of these fountains, the "water issues from the fountainhead in the shape of a shield, or like a lily-of-the-valley," i.e. "the shapes are discharged alternately—either a sheet of water concave downwards, or a spray." Another fountain "discharges a shield or a single jet," while a variation of this features double-action alternation, i.e. has two fountainheads, with one discharging a single jet and the other a shield, and the two alternating repeatedly. Another variation features one main fountainhead and two or more subsidiary ones, such that when the main one ejects a single jet, the subsidiaries eject shields, with the two alternating.^[3]

The Banu Musa brothers also described the earliest known wind-powered fountain,^[19] which is described as, "operated by wind or water, it discharges a single jet or a lily-of-the-valley." A variation of this fountain incorporates a worm-and-pinion gear, while another variation features double-action alternation. The book also describes a fountain with variable discharge.^[3] The book also describes fountains that change shapes at intervals.^[14]

Mechanical musical machines

The Banu Musa invented an early mechanical musical instrument, in this case a hydropowered organ which played interchangeable cylinders automatically. According to Charles B. Fowler, this "cylinder with raised pins on the surface remained the basic device to produce and reproduce music mechanically until the second half of the nineteenth century."^[20]

The Banu Musa also invented an automatic flute player which may have been the first programmable machine.^[21] The flute sounds were produced through hot steam and the user could adjust the device to various patterns so that they could get various sounds from it.^[22]

Practical tools

The mechanical grab,^[6] specifically the clamshell grab,^[14] is an original invention by the Banu Musa brothers that does not appear in any earlier Greek works.^[6] The grab they described was used to extract objects from underwater,^[3] and recover objects from the beds of streams.^[14]

The Banu Musa also described bellows that could remove foul air from wells.^[3] They explained that these instruments allow a worker to "descend into any well he wishes for a while and he will not fear it, nor will it harm him, if God wills may he be exalted."^[23]

Water dispensers

The book describes a dispenser for hot and cold water, where the two outlets alternate, one discharging cold water and the other hot, then vice versa repeatedly. It also describes a vessel with a basin by its side where, when cold water is poured into the top of the vessel, it discharges from the mouth of a figure into the basin; when hot water or another liquid is poured into the basin, the same quantity of cold water is discharged from the mouth of the figure.^[3]

The book also describes a boiler with a tap to access hot water. The water is heated through cold water being poured into a pipe which leads to a tank at the bottom of the boiler, where the water is heated with fire. A person can then access hot water from the boiler through a tap.^[17]

Other devices

Some of the other devices the Banu Musa described in their book include:

• Mechanical trick devices^[14]
• Hurricane lamp^[14]
• Self-trimming lamp^[14] (by Ahmad ibn Mūsā ibn Shākir)
• Self-feeding lamp^[14]

See also

• Banū Mūsā, the authors of the book
• Al-Jazari, who wrote a book with a similar name
• Inventions in medieval Islam
• Islamic Golden Age
• Physics in medieval Islam
• Science and technology in Iran

Notes

1. Bennison, Amira K. (2009). The great caliphs : the golden age of the 'Abbasid Empire. New Haven: Yale University Press. p. 187. ISBN 978-0-300-15227-2. Another important Persian lineage descended from an astronomer were the three Banu Musa brothers, Muhammad, Ahmad and Hasan, who hailed from the northeastern province of Khurasan.
2. Dimarogonas, 2000, p. 15.
3. Banu Musa (authors), Donald Routledge Hill (translator) (1979), The book of ingenious devices (Kitāb al-ḥiyal), Springer, p. 44, ISBN 90-277-0833-9 {{citation}}: |author= has generic name (help)
4. Rosheim, 1994, p. 9.
5. Bunch, 2004, p. 107
6. Banu Musa (authors), Donald Routledge Hill (translator) (1979), The book of ingenious devices (Kitāb al-ḥiyal), Springer, p. 21, ISBN 90-277-0833-9 {{citation}}: |author= has generic name (help)
7. Banu Musa (authors), Donald Routledge Hill (translator) (1979), The book of ingenious devices (Kitāb al-ḥiyal), Springer, pp. 13, 19, 23, ISBN 90-277-0833-9 {{citation}}: |author= has generic name (help)
8. Banu Musa (authors), Donald Routledge Hill (translator) (1979), The book of ingenious devices (Kitāb al-ḥiyal), Springer, p. 23, ISBN 90-277-0833-9 {{citation}}: |author= has generic name (help)
9. Banu Musa (authors), Donald Routledge Hill (translator) (1979), The book of ingenious devices (Kitāb al-ḥiyal), Springer, p. 24, ISBN 90-277-0833-9 {{citation}}: |author= has generic name (help)
10. Banu Musa (authors), Donald Routledge Hill (translator) (1979), The book of ingenious devices (Kitāb al-ḥiyal), Springer, p. 22, ISBN 90-277-0833-9 {{citation}}: |author= has generic name (help)
11. Ahmad Y Hassan, Transfer Of Islamic Technology To The West, Part II: Transmission Of Islamic Engineering 2008-02-18 at the Wayback Machine
12. J. Adamy & A. Flemming (November 2004), "Soft variable-structure controls: a survey", Automatica, Elsevier, 40 (11): 1821–1844, doi:10.1016/j.automatica.2004.05.017
13. Otto Mayr (1970). The Origins of Feedback Control, MIT Press.
14. Donald Routledge Hill, "Mechanical Engineering in the Medieval Near East", Scientific American, May 1991, p. 64-69. (cf. Donald Routledge Hill, Mechanical Engineering)
15. A. F. L. Beeston, M. J. L. Young, J. D. Latham, Robert Bertram Serjeant (1990), The Cambridge History of Arabic Literature, Cambridge University Press, p. 266, ISBN 0-521-32763-6{{citation}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
16. Banu Musa (authors), Donald Routledge Hill (translator) (1979), The book of ingenious devices (Kitāb al-ḥiyal), Springer, pp. 23–4, ISBN 90-277-0833-9 {{citation}}: |author= has generic name (help)
17. Banu Musa (authors), Donald Routledge Hill (translator) (1979), The book of ingenious devices (Kitāb al-ḥiyal), Springer, pp. 74–7, ISBN 90-277-0833-9 {{citation}}: |author= has generic name (help)
18. Ancient Discoveries, Episode 12: Machines of the East, History Channel, archived from the original on 2021-12-21, retrieved 2008-09-06
19. Bent Sorensen (November 1995), "History of, and Recent Progress in, Wind-Energy Utilization", Annual Review of Energy and the Environment, 20: 387–424, doi:10.1146/annurev.eg.20.110195.002131
20. Fowler, Charles B. (October 1967), "The Museum of Music: A History of Mechanical Instruments", Music Educators Journal, Music Educators Journal, Vol. 54, No. 2, 54 (2): 45–49, doi:10.2307/3391092, JSTOR 3391092, S2CID 190524140
21. Koetsier, Teun (2001), "On the prehistory of programmable machines: musical automata, looms, calculators", Mechanism and Machine Theory, Elsevier, 36 (5): 589–603, doi:10.1016/S0094-114X(01)00005-2.
22. Banu Musa (authors), Donald Routledge Hill (translator) (1979), The book of ingenious devices (Kitāb al-ḥiyal), Springer, pp. 76–7, ISBN 90-277-0833-9 {{citation}}: |author= has generic name (help)
23. Banu Musa (authors), Donald Routledge Hill (translator) (1979), The book of ingenious devices (Kitāb al-ḥiyal), Springer, p. 240, ISBN 90-277-0833-9 {{citation}}: |author= has generic name (help)

References and further reading

• Bunch, Bryan (2004). The History of Science and Technology. Houghton Mifflin Books. ISBN 0-618-22123-9
• Dimarogonas, Andrew D. (2000). Machine Design: A CAD Approach. Wiley-IEEE. ISBN 0-471-31528-1
• Hill, Donald Routledge (Trans). (1978). Book of Ingenious Devices. Kluwer Academic Publishers. ISBN 90-277-0833-9
• Rosheim, Mark E. (1994). Robot Evolution: The Development of Anthrobotics. Wiley-IEEE. ISBN 0-471-02622-0

External links

• A Review of Early Muslim Control Engineering