Shaj Mohan
Shaj Mohan is an Indian philosopher.[4][5][6][7] His philosophical works are in the areas of metaphysics, reason, philosophy of technology, philosophy of politics, and secrecy.[8][9][10][11] Mohan's works are based on the principle of anastasis according to which philosophy is an ever-present possibility on the basis of a reinterpretation of reason.[12][13]
Shaj Mohan | |
|---|---|
Shaj Mohan, philosopher | |
| Alma mater | St. Stephen's College, Delhi |
| Era | Contemporary philosophy |
| School | Deconstruction Post-metaphysics |
| Institutions | St Stephen's College, Delhi |
| Language | English |
Main interests | Ontology Metaphysics Philosophy of technology Philosophy of politics Reason Anastasis |
Notable ideas | Stasis,[1] anastasis, hypophysics,[2] Comprehending law[3] |
Biography edit
Mohan completed his early education in Thiruvananthapuram, Kerala, and studied philosophy at St. Stephen's College, Delhi where he taught for some time.[12][14] He has academic degrees in economics and philosophy.[5][15] Mohan is originally from Tirunelveli. His grandfather Nadaraja Pillai participated in the Indian independence movement with the congress party.[16]
He has published in the areas of metaphysics, reason, nature,[17] secrecy, philosophy of technology,[18] and philosophy of politics.[19][20][21]
He has written philosophical essays against the rise of Hindu nationalism in The Indian Express,[22] Mediapart,[23] Outlook, La Croix,[24] The Wire, The Caravan,[25] Le Monde[26] and Libération.[27] As per Le Monde he has faced difficulties due to his political writings.[28]
In 2021 the American critical theory journal Episteme published a special issue on the philosophy of Mohan and Divya Dwivedi.[29]
Philosophical work edit
Mohan's work shows a new possibility for philosophy which is neither metaphysics nor deconstruction, and its orientation was described as deconstructive materialism.[30] According to Counter Currents there is “something which can be called a revolutionary theory, but not under that name” in his work.[31]
His work combines the formalism and argumentation of analytic philosophy with the intuitive exegetical style of continental philosophy.[32] Mohan is credited with having "created a new voice in philosophy" resembling the style of prophesy.[12] Mohan said that it is possible to practice philosophy without anchoring it to any tradition.[33] He argued that the principle of reason has an important role in philosophy in spite of the criticisms of it in the 20th century. Reason exceeds mechanical thinking as it has a relation to "the obscure".[34][35] This rethinking of the principle of reason is made possible through interpreting the philosophical tradition of faculties in a new way.[30] His works are opposed to exceptionalist style of thinking, including state of exception.[36]
Mohan wrote the book Gandhi and Philosophy: On Theological Anti-politics published by Bloomsbury Academic, UK[37] with the philosopher Divya Dwivedi. Jean-Luc Nancy wrote the foreword to Gandhi and Philosophy and described the originality this work in terms of the relation shown by it between truth and suffering. Nancy wrote that this work creates the new beginning for philosophy following the end of metaphysics,
This is how this book comes to our attention and contributes to orient us, if I may say so, toward a thought, and even a world, neither humanist nor reduced to suffering in the name of Truth. In the terms of this work: neither metaphysics nor hypophysics.[38]
Rachel Adams and Crain Soudien assert that Mohan's "thought is increasingly becoming one of the most radical and important contributions to the philosophy of the world, today".[39]
Gandhi and Philosophy: On Theological Anti-politics edit
According to Jean-Luc Nancy Gandhi and Philosophy leads to a new orientation outside of the theological, metaphysical and nihilistic tendencies in philosophy. Bernard Stiegler said that this work "give us to reconsider the history of nihilism in the eschatological contemporaneity and shows its ultimate limits" and offers a new path.[40][41] Gandhi and Philosophy calls this new beginning the anastasis of philosophy.[42] Robert Bernasconi said that the inventiveness and the constructivism behind the concept of ana-stasis, or the overcoming of stasis, has a relation to the project of re-beginning of philosophy by Heidegger.[43]
Gandhi and Philosophy proposed that parallel to the metaphysical tendency in philosophy there is hypophysics. Hypophysics is defined as "a conception of nature as value". Mohan said "This non-philosophical system, which we call hypophysics, is necessarily interesting for philosophy. "[6] The distance from nature that human beings and natural objects come to have through the effects of technology lessens their value, or brings them closer to evil. Gandhi's concept of passive force or nonviolence is an implication of his hypophysical commitment to nature.[44] Livio Boni in Le collectif de pantin noted that the concept of hypophysics is influenced by Kant. Hypophysics enables a rational reading of Gandhi's works to learn from it without falling into the errors of mysticism.[45]
The philosophical direction outside of metaphysics and hypophysics is created through the invention of a new conceptual order. It is meant to enable philosophy to step outside the regime of sign, signifier, and text.[42][6] The Book Review said that the philosophical project of Gandhi and Philosophy is to create new evaluative categories, "the authors, in engaging with Gandhi's thought, create their categories, at once descriptive and evaluative" while pointing to the difficulty given by the rigour of a "A seminal if difficult read for those with an appetite for philosophy".[46] Some of the conceptual inventions have been noted to have come from mathematics and biology.[30]
The constructionist tendency of Gandhi and Philosophy places it between the dominant philosophical styles of continental philosophy and analytical philosophy.[42] The conclusion of Gandhi and Philosophy emphasizes the construction of a new dimension in philosophy.
Anastasis is the obscure beginning which would gather the occidental and the oriental to make of them a chrysalis and set off the imagos born with their own spans and skies; these skies and the imagos set against them will refuse to trade in orientations; and these skies will be invisible to the departed souls of Hegel who sought mercury in the darkest nights.[47]
Reception edit
Jean-Luc Nancy, Robert Bernasconi, Bernard Stiegler and Robert J. C. Young said that his work creates new possibilities for philosophy beyond the impasse of metaphysics and nihilism.[38][41][40] American critical theory journal Episteme published a special issue of critical assessments of the philosophy of Mohan and Divya Dwivedi in 2021.[29]
Mohan's work on Gandhi was criticised from the point of view methodological and stylistic difficulty. Robert Bernasconi noted that Gandhi and Philosophy is a difficult book and it is "not a book that you will understand at first reading".[43] The difficulty due to the constructivist style was noted by other authors as well.[46][42][48]
Gandhi and Philosophy was criticised from the point of view of the recent mounting criticisms of Gandhi in India and internationally. It was said that Gandhi and Philosophy might be exalting Gandhi while being very critical of him at the same time. The ambiguous approach to Gandhi was described in one of the commentaries in The Indian Express as "Mohan and Dwivedi have done a masterful job of avoiding the binary fork – hagiography or vituperation – as much of Gandhi and hagiography comes from a need to spiritualise Gandhi".[49]
Economic and Political Weekly pointed to Mohan and Dwivedi's participation in the paradigm of "western philosophy", especially when Gandhi's goal was to create an alternative to Eurocentrism. EPW said that his work may be of interest only to continental philosophy as he does not participate in Indic discourses.[50]
Bibliography edit
Books
- Indian Philosophy, Indian Revolution: On Caste and Politics, Divya Dwivedi and Shaj Mohan, edited and annotated by Maël Montévil, Hurst Publishers, UK, 2024.[51][1]
- On Bernard Stiegler: Philosopher of Friendship, Ed. Jean-Luc Nancy and Shaj Mohan, Bloomsbury Philosophy, UK, 2024.[52]
- Gandhi and Philosophy: On Theological Anti-politics, Bloomsbury Academic, 2018.
Articles
- “And the Beginning of Philosophy”, Philosophy World Democracy, 2021.
- Deconstruction and Anastasis, Qui Parle (2022) 31 (2): 339–344.
- “Be Held in the Gaze of the Stone”, Philosophy World Democracy, 2022.
- Our Mysterious Being by Jean-Luc Nancy and Shaj Mohan.
- “On the Bastard Family of Deconstruction“, Philosophy World Democracy, 2021. Text of public seminar in École Normale Supérieure on 23 November 2021https://savoirs.ens.fr/expose.php?id=4041
- Teleography and Tendencies: Part 2 History and Anastasis , European Journal of Psychoanalysis, 2022.
- “The Noise of All Things“, Philosophy World Democracy, 2021.
- "«Une Bonne Nuit pour de Longues Promenades »: pour Bernard Stiegler", Amitiés de Bernard Stiegler, réunies par Jean-Luc Nancy, Editions Galilée, 2021.
- L’esperienza oscura in European Journal of Psychoanalysis
- "Nous sommes en état de stase" in France Culture
- „Aber es gibt nichts außerhalb der Philosophie“
- "The Obscure Experience", Coronavirus, Psychoanalysis, and Philosophy, Ed. F. Castrillón, T. Marchevsky, London: Routledge, 2021.
- “On the Relation Between the Obscure, the Cryptic and the Public”, in The Public Sphere From Outside the West, London: Bloomsbury Academic, 2015.
- "What Carries Us On", Coronavirus, Psychoanalysis, and Philosophy, Ed. F. Castrillón, T. Marchevsky, London: Routledge, 2021.
Interviews
- “But, there is nothing outside of philosophy”, Positions Politics.
- ‘I take, and I am taken, by what belongs to philosophy’: Philosophy and the redemption of democracy, South African Journal of Science, vol.118 spe 2 Pretoria 2022.
- Une nuit de philosophie (1/4) : Philosopher en Inde Interview with Les Chemins de la philosophie at the UNESCOHeadquarters Paris, available as Podcast.
- Hindu nationalism and why 'being a philosopher in India can get you killed' Interview at Mediapart
References edit
- ^ "Shaj Mohan : "Nous sommes en état de stase"". France Culture.
- ^ "Gandhi and Philosophy: Hypophysics and the Comparison between Caste and Race". Episteme.
- ^ "Transformative Imagination and the Need for Law". Episteme.
- ^ "Coronavirus and Philosophers".
- ^ a b "Gandhi's Experiments with Hypophysics". Frontline.
- ^ a b c "A new book examines what we talk about when we talk about the Father of the Nation". The Indian Express.
- ^ "Hindu nationalism and why 'being a philosopher in India can get you killed". Mediapart. 27 May 2018.
- ^ "Shaj Mohan bio at Bloomsbury Academic, UK". Bloomsbury Publishing.
- ^ "Une nuit de philosophie (1/4) : Philosopher en Inde". France Culture.
- ^ "Shaj Mohan". École normale supérieure.
- ^ "Book Review: Gandhi as Chrysalis for a New Philosophy". The Wire.
- ^ a b c "The Resurrection of Philosophy". The Wire.
- ^ "The Deconstructive Materialism of Dwivedi and Mohan: A New Philosophy of Freedom". positions politics. Retrieved 7 April 2021.
- ^ "The sound of flicking nails". The Hindu.
- ^ "New book rubbishes BJP aim to assimilate Gandhi". Deccan Chronicle.
- ^ "Two philosophers and a political theorist: An allegory of Indian public sphere". English.Mathrubhumi. Retrieved 5 December 2022.
- ^ Yu, Ai (2020). "Digital surveillance in post‐coronavirus China: a feminist view on the price we pay". Gender, Work & Organization. 27 (5): 774–777. doi:10.1111/gwao.12471. PMC 7280578. PMID 32837009.
- ^ Apter, Emily (2019). "Alphabetic Memes: Caricature, Satire, and Political literacy in the Age of Trump". October. 170: 5–24. doi:10.1162/octo_a_00366. S2CID 208268701.
- ^ Dhanda, Meena. "Philosophical Foundations of Anti-Casteism". Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society. 120.
- ^ "Is privacy a privilege?". The Tribune.
- ^ Mohan, Shaj (2015). "On the relation between the Obscure, the Cryptic, and the Public". The Public Sphere From Outside the West. Bloomsbury Publishing. ISBN 9781472571922 – via Google Books.
- ^ "Courage to Begin". The Indian Express. 30 September 2019.
- ^ "Hindu nationalism and why 'being a philosopher in India can get you killed'". Mediapart.
- ^ "Un nouveau mouvement pour l'indépendance de l'Inde". La Croix.
- ^ Reghu, co-authored by Divya Dwivedi,Shaj Mohan,J. "How upper castes invented a Hindu majority". The Caravan. Retrieved 7 April 2021.
{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link) - ^ "En Inde, les troubles s'expliquent en partie par la Constitution du pays". Le Monde.
- ^ "L'antifascisme, un crime en Inde Par Divya Dwivedi et Shaj Mohan". Libération. 5 September 2018.
- ^ "En Inde, le mensuel " The Caravan " est harcelé par la police". Le Monde.fr (in French). 2 February 2021. Retrieved 7 April 2021.
- ^ a b "Philosophy for Another Time; Towards a Collective Political Imagination". positions politics. Retrieved 11 March 2021.
- ^ a b c "The Deconstructive Materialism of Dwivedi and Mohan: A New Philosophy of Freedom". positions politics. Retrieved 13 March 2021.
- ^ "Class, Caste And Communism: An Interview With J. Reghu| Countercurrents". countercurrents.org. 5 April 2023. Retrieved 9 July 2023.
- ^ "What we need is collective shared political inventions; Shaj Mohan tells ILNA". ILNA. Retrieved 19 July 2020.
- ^ ""The Winter of Absolute Zero": Interview with Shaj Mohan by Auwn Gurmani". Naked Punch.
- ^ ""But, there is nothing outside of philosophy": Conversation between Shaj Mohan and Rachel Adams". positions politics. Retrieved 13 March 2021.
- ^ Mohan, Shaj; Mohammed, Anish (2015). "Principle of Sufficient Reason 2: On Information Metaphysics". The Public Sphere From Outside the West. Bloomsbury Publishing. ISBN 9781472571922 – via Google Books.
- ^ Chambers, Claire (27 December 2021). "Unreliable Witnesses?". 3 Quarks Daily. Retrieved 30 January 2022.
- ^ "Gandhi and philosophy". Bloomsbury Publishing.
- ^ a b Mohan, Shaj; Dwivedi, Divya; Nancy, Jean-Luc (13 December 2018). Gandhi and Philosophy: On Theological Anti-Politics. Bloomsbury Publishing. ISBN 978-1-4742-2173-3 – via Google Books.
- ^ Adams, Rachel; Soudien, Crain (31 October 2022). "Introduction: Radical Reason". South African Journal of Science. 118 (Special issue: Radical Reason). doi:10.17159/sajs.2022/15000. ISSN 1996-7489. S2CID 253198738.
- ^ a b Stiegler, Bernard (14 November 2018). Qu'appelle-t-on Panser ?: 1. L'immense régression. Les Liens qui Libèrent. ISBN 979-1-02-090559-8 – via Google Books.
- ^ a b "Reviews Gandhi and Philosophy: On Theological Anti-politics". Bloomsbury Academic, UK.
- ^ a b c d "Gandhi as Chrysalis for a New Philosophy". The Wire.
- ^ a b Robert Bernasconi speaking at the launch of 'Gandhi & Philosophy'. Bloomsbury India. 14 March 2019 – via YouTube.
- ^ Singh, Siddharth (27 September 2019). "A philosophical appraisal of Gandhi's outlook and ideas". Open Magazine.
- ^ "Le gandhisme à l'épreuve de la psychanalyse (II) Identification à l'autre et dés-identification par « restance » : les années de formation de Gandhi à Londres (1888-1891) - Collectif de Pantin". www.collectifdepantin.org (in French). Retrieved 12 June 2023.
- ^ a b Tankha, V. "Philosophizing Gandhi". The Book Review.
- ^ Mohan, Shaj; Dwivedi, Divya (13 December 2018). Gandhi and Philosophy: On Theological Anti-Politics. Bloomsbury Publishing. p. 217. ISBN 978-1-4742-2173-3 – via Google Books.
- ^ Suhrud, Tridip (17 August 2019). "'Gandhi and Philosophy – On Theological Anti-Politics' review: Leap of faith". The Hindu.
- ^ Ayyar, Raj. "Bending the binary". The Indian Express.
- ^ Raghuramaraju, A (3 August 2019). "Gandhi in the Company of Western Philosophers". Economic and Political Weekly. Vol. 54, no. 31. pp. 7–8.
- ^ Dwivedi, Divya; Mohan, Shaj (29 February 2024). Indian Philosophy, Indian Revolution: On Caste and Politics. C. Hurst (Publishers) Limited. ISBN 978-1-911723-23-3.
- ^ Nancy, Jean-Luc; Mohan, Shaj (8 February 2024). On Bernard Stiegler: Philosopher of Friendship. Bloomsbury Academic. ISBN 978-1-350-32902-7.
Further reading edit
Secondary literature
- Jean-Luc Nancy, “La religieuse manipulation du pouvoir”, in Libération
- R. Bernasconi, "Welcoming Divya Dwivedi and Shaj Mohan’s Gandhi and Philosophy", episteme, issue 4: philosophy for another time; towards a collective political imagination.
- R. Janardhanan, "The Deconstructive Materialism of Dwivedi and Mohan:A New Philosophy of Freedom", Positions Politics, 2021.
- Anand Sreekumar, “The pacifist and the hypophysical: A cosmological reading of Gandhi”, European Journal of International Security, Cambridge University Press:, 4 August 2023 , pp 1 – 19. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/eis.2023.18
- Marguerite La Caze, "Cocktails more lethal than Molotovs:Freedom, Indestinacy, and Responsibility in Gandhi and Philosophy", episteme, issue 4.
- D. J. Smith "Gandhi and Philosophy: Hypophysics and the Comparison between Caste and Race", episteme, issue 4.
- Raveendran, N. K. “Two philosophers and a political theorist: An allegory of Indian public sphere”, Mathrubhumi.
Articles
- The Crown of the Stasis
External links edit
- Critical assessment of the works of Shaj Mohan and Divya Dwivedi in the special issue of the journal Episteme
- The Resurrection of Philosophy Biographical essay on Shaj Mohan and Divya Dwivedi at The Wire.
- On Pandemics: Nancy, Dwivedi, Mohan, Esposito, Nancy, Ronchi Compendium of articles by Divya Dwivedi, Roberto Esposito, Shaj Mohan, Jean-Luc Nancy and others.