James Hamilton, Duke of Châtellerault

For other people named James Hamilton, see James Hamilton (disambiguation).

James Hamilton, 1st Duke of Châtellerault, 2nd Earl of Arran (c. 1519 – 22 January 1575), was a Scottish nobleman and head of the House of Hamilton. A great-grandson of King James II of Scotland, he was heir presumptive to the Scottish throne (1536–1540, 1541–1542, 1542–1566 and 1567–1575). Arran was Regent of Scotland during the minority of Mary, Queen of Scots from 1543 to 1554, when he lost the regency to Mary of Guise. At first pro-English and Protestant, he converted to Catholicism in 1543 and supported a pro-French policy. He reluctantly agreed to Mary's marriage to Francis, eldest son of King Henry II of France, and was rewarded by Henry by being made Duke of Châtellerault in 1549. During the Scottish Reformation, Châtellerault joined the Protestant Lords of the Congregation to oppose the regency of Mary of Guise, and lost his French dukedom as a result.

James Hamilton
1st Duke of Châtellerault 2nd Earl of Arran
The Duke of Châtellerault wearing the collar of the Order of St Michael
Tenure	1529–1575
Predecessor	James, 1st Earl of Arran
Successor	James, 3rd Earl of Arran
Born	c. 1519
Died	22 January 1575 Hamilton Castle, Lanarkshire, Scotland
Spouse(s)	Margaret Douglas
Issue Detail	James, John, Claud, Anne & others
Father	James, 1st Earl of Arran
Mother	Janet Bethune

Family

James Hamilton was born about 1519 in Hamilton in Lanarkshire.^[1] He was the eldest legitimate son of James Hamilton, 1st Earl of Arran by his second wife, Janet Beaton (or Bethune). His paternal grandmother, Mary, was the eldest daughter of King James II. His father's family descended from Walter FitzGilbert, the founder of the House of Hamilton,^[2] who had received the barony of Cadzow from Robert the Bruce.^[3]

James's mother was the daughter of Sir David Beaton of Crich, the widow of Robert Livingstone of Easter Wemyss, and the second wife of the 1st Earl of Arran.^[4][5] Both parents were Scottish. They had married in 1516.

In 1529 he succeeded his father as Earl of Arran while still a minor.^[6] He was made a ward of James Hamilton of Finnart, his illegitimate elder half-brother.^[7]

Marriage

 

Arms of the earl of Arran (left) and his wife Margaret Douglas (right), Kinneil House

In 1532 Lord Arran married Margaret Douglas, who was about ten years older than him. She was a daughter of James Douglas, 3rd Earl of Morton, and Catherine Stewart, herself a natural daughter of James IV.^[8] The marriage was arranged by James Hamilton of Finnart. Margaret Douglas was given the house and lands of Kinneil House for her lifetime should her husband die before her. James Hamilton of Finnart paid Morton 4,000 marks as part of the marriage settlement.^[9]

James and Margaret had five sons:

1. James (1537–1609), succeeded him as the 3rd Earl of Arran but became insane in 1562^[10]
2. Gavin, died young^[11]
3. John (1540–1604), became the 1st Marquess of Hamilton^[12]
4. David (died 1611)^[13][14]
5. Claud (1546–1621), from whom descend the earls, marquesses and dukes of Abercorn^[15]

—and four daughters:

1. Barbara, married in 1553 James Fleming, 4th Lord Fleming^[16][17]
2. Jean, married Hugh Montgomerie, 3rd Earl of Eglinton in 1555^[18][19]
3. Anne (c. 1535 – before April 1574), married George Gordon, 5th Earl of Huntly^[20]
4. Margaret, married Sir Alexander Pethein (Peden)^[21]

In 1544 Arran tried to divorce his wife. She seemed to have been suffering of poor mental health.^[22] Significantly two of their sons, James and Claud, later became insane.

An inventory of a chest of Margaret Douglas's clothes includes a purple velvet night gown with gold passementerie lined with red taffeta, a gown of black cloth of gold with gold passementerie lined with black taffeta, and other gowns and kirtles.^[23]

Regent of Scotland

In 1536, on the death of John Stewart, Duke of Albany, grandson of King James II, Lord Arran, came to be next in line to the throne after the King's descendants. Several of the children of the immediate royal family proved to be short-lived, so on the death of King James V on 14 December 1542 at only 30, the Earl of Arran stood next in line to the Scottish throne after the king's six-day-old daughter Mary, Queen of Scots, for whom Arran was appointed Governor and Protector of Scotland.^[24] In 1543, supporters of Matthew Stewart, 4th Earl of Lennox, challenged Arran's claim and legitimacy by suggesting that his father's divorce and second marriage were invalid.^[25][26]

Pro-English policy

 

Henry VIII by Hans Holbein the Younger, 1540

Initially, Arran was a Protestant and a member of the pro-English party. In 1543 he helped to negotiate the marriage of the young Queen Mary to Edward, son of King Henry VIII of England, who had broken with Rome. In the same year he authorised the translation and reading of the Bible in the vernacular.^[27] On 27 January 1543 he arrested Cardinal Beaton, who favoured the Auld Alliance. Beaton was imprisoned at Dalkeith Palace and then Blackness Castle. However, Henry VIII doubted Arran's commitment to English policy and wanted him deposed. On 18 March 1543, Sir George Douglas of Pittendreich, brother of Lord Angus, told the English ambassador, Ralph Sadler, that:

"if there be any motion now to take the Governor from his state, and to bring the government of this realm to the king of England, I assure you it is impossible to be done at this time. For, there is not so little a boy but that he will hurl stones against it, and the wives will handle their distaffs, and the commons universally will rather die in it, yea, and many noblemen and all the clergy be fully against it."^[28]

Pro-French policy

In September 1543 Arran turned around. He secretly met Cardinal Beaton at Callendar House and reconciled himself with his former enemy. Shortly after he became Catholic and joined the pro-French faction.^[29] Around this time Friar Mark Hamilton wrote a history of the Hamilton family.^[30][31] A seven-year war with England now called the Rough Wooing followed, which was declared on 20 December 1543, and signed by Arran the following month.^[32] The declaration of war was brought by Henry Ray to give to the Parliament of Scotland. Arran replied that the parliament was dissolved, and so he thought it expedient not to answer Henry VIII on the points raised at the time.^[33]

In 1544 an attempt was made to transfer the regency from him to Mary of Guise, Queen Mary's mother, but Arran fortified Edinburgh and her forces retired. However, in March 1545 he agreed to abandon some of his responsibilities to her.^[34]

In June 1547 Arran gathered a large army to expel the English from Langholm and the surrounding area. He had a banner made from taffeta decorated with gold foil and colours, and another banner for his trumpeter. Horses dragged the artillery and carts laden with cannonballs and tents out of Edinburgh Castle. The guns were dragged toward Langholm with oxen.^[35] Arran had an armoured "jack" covered with purple taffeta, then changed his mind, choosing purple velvet.^[36] A Scottish spy, David Maitland, who signed himself "Ye Wait Quha" wrote of the preparations to Thomas Wharton, that it was "the starkest host and the monest, and with the best order that wes sen Flodwn", that is, "the strongest host and most numerous, in the best order since Flodden."^[37]

 

A 1558 coin depicting Queen Mary and King Francis

In September 1547 Arran assembled a large Scottish army to resist an English invasion led by Edward Seymour, Duke of Somerset but was defeated at the battle of Pinkie.^[38] He was forced to abandon some of his clothes at the battlefield.^[39] He nevertheless held onto the regency and continued to lead forces against the occupying troops. For two weeks in February 1548 Arran led a campaign in Teviotdale with Monsieur d'Essé to recapture Ferniehirst Castle and punish borderers. He held discussions at Jedburgh with Nicolas Durand de Villegaignon over the site and financing of a new fort.^[40]

Arran reluctantly agreed in July 1548 to Mary's marriage to Francis, eldest son of King Henry II of France. Henry II rewarded him by making him Duke of Châtellerault on 8 February 1549 and a knight of the Order of Saint Michael.^[41][38]

On 19 April 1550 Regent Arran and his Privy Council made legislation about foodstuffs and rising prices. The people of Scotland were to reduce their diets and banqueting. Prices were set for wild birds and rabbits, swans would be 5 shillings, plovers 5 pence. River birds including herons and ducks were to be caught by hawking. It was forbidden to shoot deer or birds for the table with "half hag or culverin or pistolate". These acts were ratified by Parliament.^[42]

Post-regency

 

Mary, Queen of Scots, by François Clouet, c. 1555

In 1554, Châtellerault, as he was now, surrendered the regency to Mary of Guise, and was appointed her lieutenant in Scotland.^[43] He gave up the regency on the condition that he would be Queen Mary's heir if she died childless. The Scottish succession, however, had been secretly promised to France.

In the first months of the Scottish Reformation Châtellerault continued to support Mary of Guise. He faced a Protestant army with the French commander at Cupar Muir in June 1559. He changed his allegiance in August 1559, joining the Protestant Lords of the Congregation to oppose the regency of Mary of Guise, and lost his French dukedom as a result. In order to discredit him with the English government a letter was forged by his enemies, in which Châtellerault declared his allegiance to Francis II of France, but the plot was exposed. On 27 February 1560 he agreed to the Treaty of Berwick with Queen Elizabeth I of England, which placed Scotland under English protection.^[44]

After the death of Mary of Guise on 15 June 1560, Châtellerault persuaded the Parliament of Scotland to back a plan to marry his son James to Elizabeth I, and then after the death of Francis II on 5 December 1560 he attempted, without success, to arrange for James to marry the young widowed Queen Mary.^[45][38] However, Mary married Lord Darnley in 1565.

In 1566 Châtellerault withdrew to his estates in France, where he made vain attempts to regain his confiscated duchy. In 1569, he returned to Scotland in support of Mary but was imprisoned by Murray who assembled a parliament and had him declared a traitor. Murray was assassinated on 23 January 1570 while Châtellerault was still in prison. Nevertheless, Châtellerault was rumoured to have been an accomplice in the regent's murder.^[46] Châtellerault was released from prison on 20 April 1570. In 1573 he gave up his support for Mary and recognised Mary's infant son James VI as king.^[47]

Châtellerault died at Hamilton on 22 January 1575.^[48] He was succeeded by his eldest son James as the 3rd Earl of Arran. However, as James was insane, John his younger brother stood in for him.

Timeline

Timeline
As his birth date is uncertain, so are all his ages.
Age	Date	Event
0	1519, about	Born, probably in Hamilton, South Lanarkshire, Lanarkshire, Scotland.^[1]
2–3	1522, about	Mother died
9–10	1529	Father died; he succeeded as the 2nd Earl of Arran^[6]
12–13	1532, c. 23 September	Married Margaret Douglas, daughter of the Earl of Morton^[8]
22–23	1542, 14 Dec	Accession of Mary I of Scotland, succeeding King James V^[49]
23–24	1543, early	Appointed regent for Mary Queen of Scots^[24]
23–24	1543, Sep	Turned around: Met Cardinal Beaton at Callendar House and became Catholic
23–24	1543, 20 Dec	England declared war, starting the Rough wooing
24–25	1544	Tried to divorce his wife but failed
27–28	1547, 10 Sep	Defeated by the English at the Battle of Pinkie Cleugh
29–30	1549, 8 Feb	Created Duke of Châtellerault by Henry II of France^[41]
34–35	1554	Lost the regency to Mary of Guise
38–39	1558	Queen Mary married Francis, Dauphin of France
39–40	1559, 10 Jul	Henry II of France died.
40–41	1560, 27 Feb	Treaty of Berwick negotiated.
40–41	1560 5 Dec N.S.	Francis II of France died.
42–43	1562	Son James, his eldest, declared insane
45–46	1565	Queen Mary remarried to Darnley
47–48	1567, 24 Jul	Accession of King James VI of Scotland, succeeding Queen Mary I^[50]
48–49	1568, 13 May	Queen Mary lost the Battle of Langside and fled to England.
50–51	1570, 23 Jan	Regent Moray murdered; Châtellerault might have been involved
55–56	1575, 22 Jan	Died at Hamilton, South Lanarkshire^[48]

Genealogical chart

Hamilton's relationship to the house of Stuart^[51]
James II Mary of Guelders James III Alexander Stewart, Duke of Albany Mary Stewart James Hamilton, 1st Lord Hamilton James IV John Stewart, Duke of Albany James Hamilton, 1st Earl of Arran Elizabeth Hamilton James Hamilton, Duke of Châtellerault John Stewart, 3rd Earl of Lennox Mary of Guise James V Matthew Stewart, 4th Earl of Lennox Mary I Henry Stuart, Lord Darnley James VI

Notes and references

Notes

Citations

1. Merriman 2004, p. 827, right column: "Hamilton, James, second Earl of Arran ... (c. 1519–1575) ... was born at Hamilton, Lanarkshire, the eldest son of James Hamilton, first Earl of Arran (1475?) and his second wife, Jane Beaton (d. c. 1522)."
2. Chisholm 1911b, p. 878, lines eight and nine: "... the first authentic ancestor is one Walter FitzGilbert. He first appears in 1294–1295 ..."
3. Paul 1907, p. 341, line 12: "At a later but uncertain date he received the barony of Cadzow from King Robert ..."
4. Paul 1907, p. 360: "The Earl married secondly Janet Beaton, said to be a daughter of Sir David Beaton of Creich, widow of Sir Robert Livingstone of Easter Wemyss and Drumry ..."
5. Dunlop 1890, p. 168, left column, line 1a: "... Janet Beaton of Easter Wemyss ..."
6. Dunlop 1890, p. 168, left column, line 1b: "... succeeded to the earldom on the death of his father in 1529."
7. Paul 1907, p. 366, line 1: "III James, second Earl of Arran succeeded to his father while yet a minor being left under the tutory of his uncle Sir James Hamilton of Finnart ..."
8. Paul 1907, p. 368, line 30: "He married, about 23 September 1532, Margaret, eldest daughter of James Douglas, third Earl of Morton."
9. Laing 1850, p. 72, line 5: "Appended to a Receipt granted by him [Hamilton, Sir James] to James Earl of Morton for 3400 merks ... for the marriage of Margaret Douglas, daughter of the Earl of Morton, with his brother James, Earl of Arran. A.D. 1532."
10. Paul 1907, p. 368, line 34: "... who was born in 1537 or in 1538 ..."
11. Paul 1907, p. 369, line 11: "Gavin, styled second son ... appears to have died before August 1547 in his youth."
12. Debrett 1828, p. 443, line 10: "John, 2d son of the Duke of Chatelherault, succeeded on his father's death to the family estates ..."
13. Chatellherault's will, NAS ECC8/8/4
14. Burke & Burke 1915, p. 54, left column, line 55: "3. David, d. [died] unm. [unmarried] 1611."
15. Debrett 1828, p. 443, line 9: "Claud, ancestor of the marquess of Abercorn ..."
16. Dunlop 1890, p. 170, line 32: "Barbara, who married James, fourth lord Fleming, high chamberlain of Scotland."
17. Paul 1907, p. 370, line 4: "Barbara, the eldest daughter, was first contracted to Alexander, Lord Gordon ... but it is not certain that the marriage took place ... She was married (contract dated 22 December 1553) to James, Lord Fleming, chamberlain of Scotland."
18. Dunlop 1890, p. 170, right column, line 37: "Jane, who married Hugh Montgomery, third earl of Eglintoun."
19. Paul 1907, p. 370, line 15: "Jean or Jane ... was married (contract dated 13 February 1553-4) to the earl of Eglinton."
20. Dunlop 1890, p. 170, right column, line 36: "Anne who married George, fifth Earl of Huntly."
21. Dunlop 1890, p. 170, right column, line 34: "Margaret, who married Alexander, lord Gordon, eldest son of George, fourth earl of Huntly;"
22. Amy Blakeway, 'The attempted divorce of James Hamilton, earl of Arran, Governor of Scotland', The Innes Review, Volume 61 Issue 1 (May 2010), pp.1–23 ISSN 0020-157x [1]
23. Melanie Schuessler Bond, Dressing the Scottish Court 1543-1553: Clothing in the Accounts of the Lord High Treasurer of Scotland (Boydell, 2019), p. 657-8.
24. Chisholm 1911a, p. 643, third para, lines two and three: "... was, in consequence of his position as next successor to the throne after the infant Mary, proclaimed protector of the realm and heir-presumptive of the crown in 1543"
25. Dickinson 1942, p. 7, line 25: "Further, the Earl of Lennox had been put forward by the French as the rightful heir, after Mary, to the throne; and Arran was not considered legitimate by Protestants or by Catholics because of the uncertain validity of his mother's marriage and the particular circumstances of his father's divorce ..."
26. Bain 1898, p. 691: "Lennox – If you had been lawfully begotten, I should have nothing to say. But it is most true that your father was married to Elizabeth Hume daughter to Lord Alexander Hume, about the year 1493, and she lived till the year 1543. Many years before her death, your father 'took to his company' Dame Jenet Beton, by whom he had you, and was not his lawful wife."
27. Chisholm 1911a, p. 643, third para, line four: "... authorized the translation and the reading of the Scriptures in the vulgar tongue ..."
28. Clifford 1809, p. 70, line 19(Sadler later attributed a similar speech to Adam Otterburn.)
29. Bain 1892, p. 15, line 15: "... there was an appoyntement betwixt the Governour and the Cardynall to convene and mete togither this daye at an abbey ... orelles at Lord Levenstons house [i.e. Callender House] ..."
30. Thomas James Salmon, Borrowstounness and District (Edinburgh: William Hodge, 1913), p. 24
31. J. Foggie, Renaissance Religion in Urban Scotland: The Dominican Order, 1450-1560 (Brill, 2003), pp. 59, 71, 285.
32. Chisholm 1911a, p. 643, third para, line eleven: "war had broken out with England"
33. Bain 1892, p. 238, line 41: "My lord Governour understanding that the said officiar was direct for shawing of the said writing to the thri estatis of parliament, quhilk was befor his cuming disolvit and thai departit lang of befor : Tharfor douting giff his ansuer wald be acceptable to the King of Ingland and to his msatisfactioun or nocht, thocht nocht expedient to giff ansuer presentlie in that behalf."
34. Chisholm 1911a, p. 643, third para, line ten: "In March 1545 a truce was arranged by which each had a share in the government."
35. James Balfour Paul, Accounts of the Lord High Treasurer of Scotland, vol. 9 (Edinburgh, 1911), pp. 84-97.
36. Accounts of the Treasurer of Scotland, vol. 9 (Edinburgh, 1911), pp. 97-8.
37. Joseph Bain, Calendar State Papers Scotland: 1547-1563, vol. 1 (Edinburgh, 1898), p. 8: Amy Blakeway, 'Spies and Intelligence in Scotland', in Sara Butler & Krista Kesselring, Crossing Borders: Boundaries and Margins in Medieval and Early Modern Britain (Leiden, 2018), pp. 95-6: See Arran's household book, National Records of Scotland, E31/9 ff. 57-59.
38. Chisholm 1911a.
39. James Balfour Paul, Accounts of the Treasurer of Scotland, vol. 9 (Edinburgh, 1911), p. 140.
40. Annie Cameron, Scottish Correspondence of Mary of Lorraine (SHS: Edinburgh, 1927), pp. 289-90.
41. Paul 1907, p. 367, line 25: "On 8 February 1548-49 the duchy of Chatelherault was granted to the earl and his heirs."
42. John Hill Burton, Register of the Privy Council, vol. 1 (Edinburgh, 1877), pp. 94-5.
43. Blakeway 2015, p. 23, line 17: "... Chatelherault, likewise, held the position lieutenant of Mary, Queen of Scots, under Marie de Guise."
44. Chisholm 1911a, p. 643, third para, line twenty: "On the 27th of February 1560 he agreed to the treaty of Berwick with Elizabeth, which placed Scotland under her protection."
45. Acts of the Parliaments of Scotland, vol. ii, (1814), 605–606; HMC Hamilton, (1887), 42, August 1560.
46. Merriman 2004, p. 833, left column, line 28: "The murder of Murray on 23 January 1570, a deed plotted by Archbishop John Hamilton and carried out by James Hamilton of Bothwellhaugh led to accusations that Châtelherault had himself been implicated."
47. Dunlop 1890, p. 170, right column, line 15: "... till 23 Feb. 1573, when action in union with the Earl of Huntly, he consented to acknowledge the king's authority and lay down his sword.
48. Paul 1907, p. 368, line 28: "... died at Hamilton on 22 January 1574-75."
49. Fryde et al. 1986, p. 61, line 8: "Mary ... acc. 14 Dec. 1542 ..."
50. Fryde et al. 1986, p. 61, line 16: "James VI ... acc. 24 Jul. 1567 ..."
51. Warnicke 2006, p. xvi-xvii

Sources

• Bain, Joseph, ed. (1898). Calendar of the State Papers Relating to Scotland and Mary, Queen of Scots 1547–1603. Vol. I. Edinburgh: Her Majesty's General Register House. OCLC 1137227125. – 1547 to 1563
• Bain, Joseph, ed. (1892). The Hamilton Papers. Vol. II. Edinburgh: Her Majesty's General Register House. OCLC 877556059. – 1543 to 1590 (for the letter, dated the 4 September 1543, from Ralph Sadler to Suffolk and Tunstall)
• Blakeway, Amy Louise (2015). Regency in Sixteenth-Century Scotland. Woodbridge, Suffolk: The Boydell Press. ISBN 978-1-84383-980-4.
• Burke, Bernard; Burke, Ashworth Peter (1915). A Genealogical and Heraldic History of the Peerage and Baronetage, the Privy Council, Knightage and Companionage (77th ed.). London: Harrison. OCLC 1155471554.
• Chisholm, Hugh, ed. (1911a). "Arran, Earls of" . Encyclopædia Britannica. Vol. 02 (11th ed.). Cambridge University Press. pp. 642–644.
• Chisholm, Hugh, ed. (1911b). "Hamilton (family)" . Encyclopædia Britannica. Vol. 12 (11th ed.). Cambridge University Press. pp. 878–879. – for Walter FitzGilbert
• Clifford, Arthur (1809). The State Papers and Letters of Ralph Sadler, Knight-Banneret. Vol. I. Edinburgh: Archibald Constable. OCLC 1015501369.
• Debrett, John (1828). Peerage of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland. Vol. II (17th ed.). London: F. C. and J. Rivington. OCLC 54499602. – Scotland and Ireland
• Dickinson, Gladys (1942). "Two Missions of Jacques de la Brosse". Publications of the Scottish History Society. 3. 36: 7–8.
• Dunlop, Robert (1890). "Hamilton, James, second Earl of Arran and Duke of Châtelherault (d. 1575)". In Lee, Sidney (ed.). Dictionary of National Biography. Vol. XXIV. New York: MacMillan and Co. pp. 167–170. OCLC 8544105.
• Fryde, Edmund Boleslaw; Greenway, D. E.; Porter, S.; Roy, I., eds. (1986). Handbook of British Chronology. Royal Historical Society Guides and Handbooks, No. 2 (3rd ed.). London: Offices of the Royal Historical Society. ISBN 0-86193-106-8. – (for timeline)
• Laing, Henry, ed. (1850). Descriptive Catalogue of Impressions from Ancient Schottish Seals. Edinburgh: T. Constable.
• Merriman, Marcus (2004). "Hamilton, James, second earl of Arran (c. 1519–1575)". In Matthew, Colin; Harrison, Brian (eds.). Oxford Dictionary of National Biography. Vol. 24. New York: Oxford University Press. pp. 827–833. ISBN 0-19-861374-1.
• Paul, Sir James Balfour (1907). The Scots Peerage, Founded on Wood's Edition of Sir Robert Douglas's Peerage of Scotland. Vol. IV. Edinburgh: David Douglas. OCLC 505064285. – Fife to Hyndford (for Duke of Hamilton)
• Warnicke, Retha M. (2006). Mary Queen of Scots. New York: Routledge. ISBN 978-0-415-29182-8.

Attribution

•   This article incorporates text from a publication now in the public domain: Chisholm, Hugh, ed. (1911). "Arran, Earls of". Encyclopædia Britannica. Vol. 2 (11th ed.). Cambridge University Press. pp. 642–644.

Further reading

• Franklin, David Byrd (1995). The Scottish Regency of the Earl of Arran: A Study in the Failure of Anglo-Scottish Relations. Edwin Mellen Press.
• Melanie Schuessler Bond, Dressing the Scottish Court: 1543-1553 (The Boydell Press: Woodbridge, Suffolk, 2019).

Peerage of Scotland
Preceded by James Hamilton	Earl of Arran 1529–1548	Succeeded by James Hamilton
French nobility
Vacant Title last held by Charles de Valois	Duke of Châtellerault 1548–1559	Vacant Title next held by Diane de France