Presidential transition of Franklin D. Roosevelt

The presidential transition of Franklin D. Roosevelt began when he won the United States 1932 United States presidential election, becoming the president-elect of the United States, and ended when Roosevelt was inaugurated at noon EST on March 4, 1933.

Presidential transition of Franklin D. Roosevelt

Outgoing president Hoover (left) and incoming president Roosevelt (right) ride together to the United States Capitol for Roosevelt's inauguration
Date of election	November 8, 1932
Inauguration date	March 4, 1933
President-elect	Franklin D. Roosevelt (Democrat)
Vice president-elect	John Nance Garner (Democrat)
Outgoing president	Herbert Hoover (Republican)
Outgoing vice president	Charles Curtis (Republican)

At the time that Roosevelt's occurred, the term "presidential transition" had yet to be widely applied to the period between an individual's election as president of the United States and their assumption of the office.^[1]

The transition has been regarded as a rough transition, with tremendous tensions between president-elect Roosevelt and outgoing president Herbert Hoover, whom Roosevelt had defeated in the election. It took place against the backdrop of the Great Depression.

Roosevelt's election victory

 

Concession telegram from Herbert Hoover to Roosevelt

Main article: 1932 United States presidential election

Roosevelt won a landslide victory over the incumbent Hoover in the 1932 presidential election. From his residence in California, Hoover sent Roosevelt a concession telegram at 10pm Pacific time.^[2]

Advisors to the transition

 

President-elect Roosevelt at his personal retreat in Warm Springs, Georgia with Henry Morgenthau Jr. and W. Forbes Morgan on November 30, 1932

Roosevelt was advised by members of his "Brain Trust".^[3] Also advising Roosevelt were aides such as Louis McHenry Howe.^[4] Additionally, friends and associates such as Edward J. Flynn, Joseph P. Kennedy Sr., Jesse I. Straus, Frank C. Walker, and William H. Woodin advised Roosevelt during the transition.^[5] Working out of the Roosevelt campaign's national headquarters at the New York Biltmore Hotel was Chair of the Democratic National Committee James Farley.^[3] Initially, for daily help in Albany, while he was finishing his tenure as governor of New York before January, Roosevelt was assisted by governor's counsel Samuel Rosenman.^[3] Also providing some assistance to Roosevelt's transition were James F. Byrnes, Homer Cummings, Josephus Daniels, Lewis W. Douglas, Felix Frankfurter, Edward M. House, Daniel Roper, and Swagar Sherley.^[6]

Disagreement over economic policies

 

Roosevelt meeting with Cardinal George Mundelein, Archbishop of Chicago, in Albany, New York on November 18, 1932

 

Roosevelt in Hyde Park, New York in February 1933

 

Counting of the United States Electoral College votes on February 8, 1933

During the transition, Hoover attempted to get Roosevelt to give his endorsement to Hoover's policies for addressing the ongoing economic depression. Roosevelt refused, having campaigned against Hoover's approach and promised a "New Deal" if elected.^[7] Hoover attempted to get Roosevelt to abandon his "New Deal", which Hoover believed would be catastrophic.^[7] Roosevelt consistently refused to make any public statement regarding Hoover's proposals or his own plans, telling Hoover that he would take up official decisions no sooner than March 4.^[7]

At their November 22 meeting, Roosevelt told Hoover that if he and the lame duck Congress would pass a farm bill incorporating Roosevelt's farm relief ideas, that Roosevelt might be able to avoid needing to call a special session of Congress after his inauguration.^[8] While there was much room for the passage of the farm policy Roosevelt was seeking in Congress (including among Republicans), Hoover made it clear he would not be willing to sign such legislation.^[9]

In December, Hoover attempted to get Roosevelt to participate in the appointing of the delegation that would be sent to the London Economic Conference. Roosevelt did not accept.^[7] After this, Hoover made their telegrams discussing this public, and released a White House statement suggesting that Roosevelt found it "undesirable" to engage in joint efforts relating to the economy. Roosevelt responded to this White House statement, by saying "it is a pity" that Hoover was making the suggestion he was opposed to "cooperative action".^[7] The New York Times, at the time, reported that the telegrams Hoover had released revealed a "clash of methods" between the two.^[10]

Roosevelt had promised many times that he would pass a balanced budget, but would not pledge to pass new taxes to accomplish this. On February 18, Roosevelt received a letter from Hoover attempting to convince Roosevelt to promise to pass new taxes if needed to accomplish a balanced budget. The letter also urged Roosevelt not to abandon the gold standard. Hoover had been worried since summer 1932 that Roosevelt might do this if he became president (after a Democratic campaign economist warned Hoover that Roosevelt was considering doing so).^[11] Roosevelt discussed the letter with his advisors, but sent Hoover no immediate reply.^[12] Hoover sent Roosevelt another letter and, on March 1, Roosevelt sent replies to both this and the previous letter, pretending that the late reply to the earlier letter was due to a mistake by a secretary.^[13]

Shaping of Roosevelt's policies

Agricultural policy

During the transition, Roosevelt had several of his top advisors work with leaders of agricultural organizations to devise a program to address the agricultural crisis. Among the advisors of Roosevelt's who partook in these discussions were Henry Morgenthau Jr., Raymond Moley, and Rexford Tugwell. Roosevelt also recruited Henry A. Wallace to join his advisors in these discussions with agricultural leaders.^[14]

Tennessee Valley

In December, Roosevelt reached out to Senator George W. Norris, author of the Muscle Shoals Bill (which Hoover had vetoed in 1931), about making a trip together to the Tennessee Valley to assess the projects proposed by that bill. In January 1933, Roosevelt and Norris traveled together on a train from Washington, D.C. to the Tennessee Valley to assess the proposed projects that had been the subject of the vetoed bill. Afterwards, they traveled to the Alabama State Capitol in Montgomery, Alabama, where Roosevelt spoke extemporaneously from the building's portico about the values of the proposed projects. The projects would become the nucleus of the Tennessee Valley Authority that Roosevelt would authorize shortly after becoming president.^[15][16]

Meetings between Roosevelt and Hoover

November 22

On November 22, the president-elect and outgoing president held their first post-election in-person meeting in the White House's Red Room.^[7][17] Hoover was surprised, at the meeting, to witness the extent of Roosevelt's paralytic disability.^[7] Hoover began the meeting by delivering to Roosevelt an hour long lecture on international economic matters.^[7] He would later tell an advisor that he had been, "educating a very ignorant" but "well-meaning young man".^[7][18] During this meeting, Hoover proposed that Roosevelt cooperate with him in forming a foreign debt commission, and mistook Roosevelt for having agreed.^[7]

January 20

By January the lack of cooperation between the president-elect and the outgoing president was publicly discussed. Arthur Krock of The New York Times wrote that they were "congenitally unable to understand each other or to go along on methods".^[7] Wanting to avoid looking uncooperative, in early January, Roosevelt made a telephone call to Hoover and arranged for a second meeting.^[7] By this time, Hoover so distrusted Roosevelt that he insisted on having a stenographer present during the phone call in which they arranged for this meeting.^[7][18] The president and president-elect met again on January 20. They agreed to have the United States hold talks with the United Kingdom relating to its war debts to the United States, which they agreed would be scheduled to be held after Roosevelt assumed the presidency.^[7]

March 3

Instead of hosting the Roosevelts for a then-traditional pre-inauguration dinner, the Hoovers invited them for an afternoon tea the day prior to the inauguration.^[18] When Roosevelt arrived at the White House, he found that Hoover wanted to pull him into another meeting, this time with the Secretary of the Treasury and Chair of the Federal Reserve.^[7] The meeting went poorly.^[7] Roosevelt's wife, Eleanor, would later recount to reporters that she had been able to hear the conversation through an open door, and heard Hoover ask Roosevelt to give public support to temporarily closing the country's banks in order to stave off panic withdrawals. Roosevelt allegedly responded, "Like hell I will! If you haven’t the guts to do it yourself, I’ll wait until I’m president to do it."^[7] Hoover called Roosevelt's staff that night urging him to change his mind, without success.^[7] Roosevelt would indeed, as president, proclaim a bank holiday only three days later.^[7]

Legislation during the transition period

Laws signed by Hoover

While a lame duck, Hoover did manage to sign some legislation into law during the transition period. This included the Buy American Act.^[19]

Legislation in Congress

President-elect Roosevelt initially sought to have some of his agenda passed by the lame duck Congress.^[20] Vice president-elect John Nance Garner was still speaker of the House for the lame duck session, and could have been a useful ally in passing legislation through Congress.^[21] However, disunity in the Congress and the near certainty of Hoover vetoing such legislation quickly made this a moot opportunity.^[20] The first test which showed a lack of a unified Democratic Party in the lame-duck Congress was a December 5 vote on an amendment of the United States Constitution that would repeal the Eighteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution. This vote saw the amendment fail to receive congressional approval by a margin of six votes. Eleven Democratic who were lame ducks, having lost reelection, were among those voting against the amendment.^[22]

On February 20, 1933, another repealing amendment was approved by Congress, and was submitted to state ratifying conventions in each state for ratification. It would later be ratified by December, becoming the Twenty-first Amendment to the United States Constitution.^[23]

Twentieth Amendment

The Twentieth Amendment to the United States Constitution was ratified on January 23, 1933. This moved the date of all regularly-scheduled presidential inaugurations subsequent to the 1933 inauguration from March 4 to January 20. It also outlined procedures for instances in which a president-elect dies or otherwise fails to qualify for the presidency before taking office.^[24]

Roosevelt's selection of appointees

Attorney General

Roosevelt, likely on his January 19 visit to Washington, D.C., offered Thomas J. Walsh the position of Attorney General. Walsh accepted in the first week of February.^[25] Walsh died unexpectedly in early March, and Homer Stille Cummings was quickly selected to be Roosevelt's Attorney General.^[26]

Postmaster General

Roosevelt had already talked to James Farley about him being his Postmaster General even before election day.^[27]

Secretary of Agriculture

Henry A. Wallace had entered Roosevelt's orbit during the transition. In early February, Roosevelt wrote him a letter offering him the position of Secretary of Agriculture.^[28]

Secretary of Commerce

In Roosevelt's circle, Jesse I. Straus, president of the department store chain Macy's, was a favorite for the position of Secretary of Commerce. Straus had been a strong contributor to Roosevelt's campaign. Initially, he seemed incredibly likely to receive the post.^[29]

Reportedly, in exchange for William Gibbs McAdoo securing Roosevelt California's delegation on the fourth ballot at the 1932 Democratic National Convention (which won Roosevelt the party's nomination), Roosevelt promised to seek McAdoo's advice in selecting the secretaries of state and treasury. Laurin L. Henry speculated that McAdoo may have disapproved of Roosevelt's choice of Carter Glass, and that Roosevelt possibly had disregarded this input. Henry speculates that it was likely in seeking to appease McAdoo that Roosevelt offered the position to Daniel C. Roper, who had been the one that had brokered the agreement between Roosevelt and McAdoo at the Democratic National Convention.^[30]

Secretary of the Interior

Laurin L. Henry speculated the Roosevelt had made a decision early into his transition to appoint a progressive Republican to the position of Secretary of the Interior. Roosevelt initially offered the post to Hiram Johnson, who quickly rejected the offer. Bronson Cutting was offered the job, but had not yet given his decision by mid-February. At this time, Roosevelt had begun working with Harold L. Ickes on preparations for international economic talks. Ickes wanted to serve in Roosevelt's administration, At his first meeting with Roosevelt on February 22 (at Roosevelt's New York residence), Ickes told Arthur Mullen that he was interested in the office, and Mullen agreed to inform Roosevelt of this. The next day, at another meeting between him and Roosevelt, Roosevelt told Ickes he was now considering him for the job.^[31]

Secretary of Labor

On February 22, Roosevelt offered the position of Secretary of Labor to Frances Perkins.^[32] She would be the first woman to be appointed to a Cabinet post.^[33]

Secretary of the Navy

Roosevelt offered the position of Secretary of the Navy to Claude A. Swanson.^[34]

Secretary of State

Raymond Moley would later recount that Roosevelt had strongly considered Robert Worth Bingham, Cordell Hull, and Owen D. Young for Secretary of State.^[35] On either January 19 or 20, during Roosevelt's trip to Washington, D.C. for his second meeting with Hoover, Roosevelt met with Hull at the Mayflower Hotel, and offered him the position. Hull requested time to contemplate the offer.^[36]

Secretary of the Treasury

On January 19, on his visit to Washington, D.C. for his second meeting with Hoover, Roosevelt offered Carter Glass the position of Secretary of the Treasury. After contemplating the offer for several weeks, on February 8, Glass turned down the job. Roosevelt attempted to persuade him to change his mind, holding a meeting with him in a train car, and holding several telephone conversations with him. However, on February 19, Roosevelt came to accept Glass was not going to change his mind. That evening, he offered the position to William H. Woodin, who McHenry Howe and Raymond Moley had recommended to Roosevelt.^[37]

Secretary of War

Roosevelt offered George Dern the position of Secretary of War.^[34]

Attempted assassination of Roosevelt

On February 15, in Miami, Florida, Giuseppe Zangara fired gunshots towards Roosevelt's open convertible. A woman in the crowd bumped Zangara's arm as he was shooting, causing him to miss the president-elect and shoot five bystanders. Among those shot was Chicago mayor Anton Cermak, who was sitting next to Roosevelt in his car and died from his injuries on March 6.^{[7][38][39][40]}

Inauguration and aftermath

 

Roosevelt (right) and Hoover ride to the United States Capitol for the inauguration

On the day of the inauguration, Roosevelt and Hoover shared a tense car ride from the White House to the United States Capitol.^[7] They would continue to harbor resentments toward each other for the rest of their lives.^[41]

This would be the last transition to last until March 4. The Twentieth Amendment to the United States Constitution, ratified on January 23, 1933, moved the date for regular presidential inaugurations to January 20.^[24]

Historical assessment

The transition has been considered one of the more troubled presidential transitions in United States history.^[10][42] In 2017, Amy Davidson Sorkin of The New Yorker suggested that Hoover believed the electorate had made a mistake, one that it was his duty to protect them from in his remaining months.^[10] In 2020, Ronald G. Shafer of The Washington Post described the transition from Hoover to Roosevelt as the "most contentious" handing-over of the presidency until the presidential transition of Joe Biden, in which outgoing president Donald Trump refused to concede the 2020 election.^[7] Historian Eric Rauchway observed that Hoover conceded the election in form but not in political substance, and pursued a course of deliberate obstruction that was unequaled by any outgoing president as of November 2020.^[2]

References

1. Riley, Russell L. (January 5, 2021). "Presidential transitions didn't use to matter. Here's what changed". The Washington Post. Retrieved May 21, 2021.
2. Illing, Sean (2020-11-24). "A historian on the perils of chaotic White House transitions". Vox. Retrieved 24 May 2021.
3. Henry, p. 277
4. Henry, p. 276
5. Henry, pp. 276–277
6. Henry, pp. 278–279
7. Shafer, Ronald G. (9 November 2020). "The most contentious transition before Trump and Biden: Herbert Hoover and FDR". Washington Post. Retrieved 22 May 2021.
8. Rauchway, p. 78
9. Rauchway, pp. 78–79
10. Sorkin, Amy Davidson (27 December 2017). "Lessons from an Unseemly Presidential Transition—From Hoover to F.D.R." The New Yorker. Retrieved 24 May 2021.
11. Freidel, p. 88
12. Freidel, p. 89
13. Freidel, p. 90
14. Freidel, p. 86
15. "The Enduring Legacy". TVA.com. Tennessee Valley Authority. Retrieved 24 May 2021.
16. Freidel, p. 87
17. Rauchway, p. 66
18. "6. The Long Transition: From Election Day to Inauguration Day" (PDF). fdr4freedoms.org. fdr4freedoms. Retrieved 24 May 2021.
19. Reinsch, William Alan (10 April 2020). "A World in Crisis: Will Buying American Help or Hurt?". www.csis.org. Center for Strategic International Studies. Retrieved 17 June 2021.
20. Freidel, p. 83
21. Raunchway, p. 77
22. Raunchway, pp. 76–77
23. Huckabee, David C. (September 30, 1997). (PDF). Congressional Research Service reports. Washington D.C.: Congressional Research Service, The Library of Congress. Archived from the original (PDF) on 10 October 2011.
24. "Constitution of the United States: Amendments 11-27". Archives.gov. 4 November 2015. from the original on January 14, 2021. Retrieved November 22, 2020.
25. Henry, p. 337
26. Henry, p. 352
27. Henry, p. 331
28. Henry, p. 338
29. Henry, p. 337
30. Henry, pp. 333, 337–38
31. Henry, p. 339
32. Henry, p. 339–340
33. "Frances Perkins | United States secretary of labor". Encyclopedia Britannica. Retrieved 30 May 2021.
34. Henry, p. 337
35. Henry, pp. 333–334
36. Henry, p. 334
37. Henry, pp. 335–336
38. "FDR escapes assassination attempt in Miami". HISTORY. 16 November 2009. Retrieved 23 May 2021.
39. Evening star. [volume], February 17, 1933, Page A-5, Image 5
40. Kendall, Peter (19 December 2007). "The shooting of Anton Cermak". chicagotribune.com. Chicago Tribune. Retrieved 23 May 2021.
41. Weig, Nick (2021-01-19). "Iowa's Herbert Hoover part of another difficult transfer of power". cbs2iowa.com. KGAN. Retrieved 24 May 2021.
42. Brillman, Dan (2008-11-04). "Politics: A History of Bumpy Transitions". Newsweek. Retrieved 6 June 2021.

Sources cited

• Freidel, Frank (1990). Franklin D. Roosevelt : a Rendezvous with Destiny (1st ed.). Boston: Little, Brown, and Company. ISBN 9780316292603.
• Henry, Laurin L. (January 1961). Presidential Transitions. Washington, D.C.: The Brookings Institution.
• Rauchway, Eric (2018). Winter War: Hoover, Roosevelt, and the First Clash Over the New Deal (First ed.). New York. ISBN 978-0465094585.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)