Mychal Judge

This article is about the Roman Catholic priest. For the NY Waterways ferry, see Mychal Judge (ship). For the snooker player, see Michael Judge. For the animator, see Mike Judge.

Mychal Fallon Judge, OFM (born Robert Emmett Judge; May 11, 1933 – September 11, 2001), was an American Franciscan friar and Catholic priest who served as a chaplain to the New York City Fire Department. While serving in that capacity he was killed, becoming the first certified fatality of the September 11 attacks.^[2]

The Reverend Mychal Judge OFM
Mychal Judge
Orders
Ordination	1961
Personal details
Born	Robert Emmett Judge (1933-05-11)May 11, 1933 Brooklyn, New York City, U.S.
Died	September 11, 2001(2001-09-11) (aged 68) World Trade Center, Manhattan, New York City, U.S.
Cause of death	Collapse of 2 World Trade Center as part of September 11 attacks
Denomination	Roman Catholic
Occupation	Chaplain to the New York City Fire Department
Education	St. Bonaventure University, Holy Name College Seminary
Sainthood
Feast day	September 11 (OCCA)
Venerated in	Orthodox-Catholic Church of America
Title as Saint	Saint Mychal Judge or Saint Mychal the Martyr
Canonized	July 27, 2002 by Orthodox-Catholic Church of America^[1]
Attributes	Brown Robes
Shrines	St. Mychal the Martyr Parish at 3564 Clays Mill Rd. Lexington, Kentucky
Firefighter career
Department	New York City Fire Department
Service years	1992–2001

Early life

Mychal Judge was born Robert Emmett Judge on May 11, 1933, in Brooklyn, New York, the son of immigrants from County Leitrim, Ireland, and the firstborn of a pair of fraternal twins. His twin sister Dympna was born two days later. Judge was baptized in St. Paul's Church in Brooklyn on June 4. They and their older sister Erin grew up during the Great Depression.^[3]

From the ages of three to six, he watched his father suffer and die of mastoiditis, a slow and painful illness of the skull and inner ear. To earn income following his father's death, Judge shined shoes at New York Penn Station and would visit St. Francis of Assisi Church, located across the street. Seeing the Franciscan friars there, he later said, "I realized that I didn't care for material things. ...I knew then that I wanted to be a friar."^[4]

Career

After spending his freshman year at the St. Francis Preparatory School in Brooklyn, where he studied under the Franciscan Brothers of Brooklyn, in 1948, at the age of 15, Judge began the formation process to enter the Order of Friars Minor. He transferred to St. Joseph's Seraphic Seminary in Callicoon, New York, the minor seminary of the Holy Name province of the Order. After graduation, he enrolled at St. Bonaventure University in Allegany, New York. In 1954 he was admitted to the novitiate of the Province in Paterson, New Jersey. After completing that year of formation, he received the religious habit and professed his first vows as a member of the Order.^[5] At that time, he was given the religious name of Fallon Michael. He later dropped 'Fallon' and changed 'Michael' to Mychal.^[6] According to Queer There and Everywhere by Sarah Prager, Mychal changed his name to "differentiate himself from all the other 'Father Michaels.'"^[7] He resumed his college studies at St. Bonaventure University, where he earned a bachelor's degree in 1957.^[8] He professed his solemn vows as a full member of the Order in 1958.^[5] Following this, he did his theological studies at Holy Name College Seminary in Washington, D.C. Upon completing these studies in 1961, he was ordained a priest.^[9]

After his ordination, Judge was assigned to the Shrine of St. Anthony in Boston, Massachusetts. Following his assignment there, he served in various parishes served by the Franciscans: St. Joseph Parish in East Rutherford, New Jersey, Sacred Heart Parish in Rochelle Park, New Jersey, Holy Cross Parish in the Bronx and St. Joseph Parish in West Milford, New Jersey. For three years he served as assistant to the President of Siena College, operated by the Franciscans in Loudonville, New York. In 1986 he was assigned to St. Francis of Assisi Church in Manhattan, where he had first come to know the friars. He lived and worked there until his death.^[10]

Around 1971, Judge developed alcoholism, although he never showed obvious signs. In 1978, with the support of Alcoholics Anonymous, he became sober and continued to share his personal story of alcoholism to help others facing addiction.^[11]

In 1992, Judge was appointed a chaplain to the New York City Fire Department. As chaplain, he offered encouragement and prayers at fires, rescues, and hospitals, and counseled firemen and their families, often working 16-hour days. "His whole ministry was about love. Mychal loved the fire department and they loved him."^[12] Judge was a member of AFSCME Local 299 (District Council 37).^[13]

Judge was also well known in the city for ministering to the homeless, the hungry, recovering alcoholics, people with AIDS, the sick, injured, and grieving, immigrants, gays and lesbians, and those alienated by society.^[14] Judge once gave the winter coat off his back to a homeless woman in the street, later saying, "She needed it more than me." When he anointed a man who was dying of AIDS, the man asked him, "Do you think God hates me?" Judge picked him up, kissed him, and silently rocked him in his arms.^[15] Judge worked with St. Clare's Hospital, which opened the city's first AIDS ward, in order to start an active AIDS ministry. He visited hospitals and AIDS patients and their families, presided over many funerals, and counseled other Catholics such as Brendan Fay and John McNeill. Judge continued to be an advocate for gay rights throughout the rest of his life, marching in pride parades and attending other gay events.^[16]

Even before his death, many considered Judge to be a living saint for his extraordinary works of charity and his deep spirituality. While praying, he would sometimes "become so lost in God, as if lost in a trance, that he'd be shocked to find several hours had passed."^[17] Judge's spiritual director, the late Jesuit John J. McNeill, observed that Judge achieved an "extraordinary degree of union with the divine. We knew we were dealing with someone directly in line with God."^[18]

September 11 attacks

 

Judge's memorial inscription:

"FR. MYCHAL JUDGE

MAY 11, 1933 – SEPTEMBER 11, 2001

Lord, Take me where you want me to go, Let me meet who you want me to meet, Tell me what you want me to say and Keep me out of your way.

On September 11, 2001, upon learning that the World Trade Center had been hit by the first of two jetliners, Judge rushed to the site. He was met by Rudolph Giuliani, the Mayor of New York City, who asked him to pray for the city and its victims. Judge prayed over bodies lying on the streets, then entered the lobby of the World Trade Center North Tower, where an emergency command post had been organized. There he continued offering aid and prayers for the rescuers, the injured, and the dead.

 

Judge died when debris from the South Tower was ejected into the lobby of the North Tower during the collapse of the World Trade Center. This image of the South Tower was photographed nine days before Judge's death.

When the neighboring South Tower collapsed at 9:59 a.m., debris went flying through the North Tower lobby, killing many inside. Judge died at this moment, too, and it was initially assumed that he was struck and killed by the debris, but according to a later interview with 1st Battalion Chief Joseph Pfeifer, it turned out that he had suffered a heart attack.^[19] In the moment before his death, Judge was repeatedly praying aloud, "Jesus, please end this right now! God, please end this!", according to Judge's biographer and New York Daily News columnist Michael Daly.^[20][21]

Shortly after his death, Judge's body was found and carried out of the North Tower by five people (Firefighters Christian Waugh and Zachary Vause, NYPD Lt. William Cosgrove, civilian John Maguire and FDNY EMT Kevin Allen) shortly before it collapsed at 10:28 a.m. This act was photographed by Reuters photographer Shannon Stapleton, and became one of the most famous photographs taken during the attacks. This event was captured in the documentary film 9/11, shot by Jules and Gedeon Naudet. The Philadelphia Weekly reported that the photograph is "considered an American Pietà."^[22] Judge's body was placed before the altar of St. Peter's Catholic Church before being taken by ambulance and fire department colleagues to Engine 1/Ladder 24, the fire station opposite the Franciscan Friary on W 31st Street in Manhattan.^[23] He was later taken from the fire station to the medical examiner.^[24]

Judge was designated as "Victim 0001" and thereby recognized as the first official victim of the attacks. Although others had been killed before him, including the crews, passengers, and hijackers of the first three planes, and occupants of the towers and the Pentagon, Judge was the first certified fatality because his body was the first to be recovered and taken to the medical examiner.^[25]

Judge's body was formally identified by NYPD Detective Steven McDonald, a long-time friend. The New York Medical Examiner found that Judge died of "blunt force trauma to the head".^[25]

Personal life

Following his death, a few of Judge's friends and associates revealed that Judge was gay.^[26] According to Fire Department Commissioner Thomas Von Essen: "I actually knew about his homosexuality when I was in the Uniformed Firefighters Association. I kept the secret, but then he told me when I became commissioner five years ago. He and I often laughed about it, because we knew how difficult it would have been for the other firemen to accept it as easily as I had. I just thought he was a phenomenal, warm, sincere man, and the fact that he was gay just had nothing to do with anything."^[27]

Judge developed a romantic relationship with a Filipino nurse named Al Alvarado in the last year of his life, which Judge documented in his diaries. The two often did not see each other for months because of Judge's work as a firefighter.^[28]

The revelations about his sexual orientation were not without controversy. Dennis Lynch, a lawyer, wrote an article about Judge that appeared on the website catholic.org. Lynch said that Judge was not gay and that any attempt to define him as gay was due to "homosexual activists" who wanted to "attack the Catholic Church" and turn the priest into a "homosexual icon".^[29] Others refuted Lynch with evidence that Judge did in fact identify himself as gay, both to others and in his personal journals.^[30]

Judge was a long-term member of Dignity, a Catholic LGBT activist organization that advocates for change in the Catholic Church's teaching on homosexuality.^[31][32] On October 1, 1986, the Vatican's Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith issued an encyclical, On the Pastoral Care of Homosexual Persons,^[33] which declared homosexuality to be a "strong tendency ordered toward an intrinsic moral evil". In response, many bishops, including John Cardinal O'Connor, banned Dignity from diocesan churches under their control. Judge then welcomed Dignity's AIDS ministry to the Church of St. Francis of Assisi, which is under the control of the Franciscan friars, thereby partially circumventing the cardinal's ban of Dignity.^[34]

Judge disagreed with official Catholic teaching regarding homosexuality.^[35] Judge often asked, "Is there so much love in the world that we can afford to discriminate against any kind of love?"^[36]

Legacy

 

The FDNY Memorial to Judge at Engine 1, Ladder 24 in Manhattan

 

Judge's name is located on Panel S-18 of the National September 11 Memorial's South Pool, along with those of other first responders.

On September 15, 2001, 3,000 people attended Judge's funeral Mass at St. Francis of Assisi Church, which was presided over by Cardinal Edward Egan, the Archbishop of New York. Former President Bill Clinton and Senator Hillary Rodham Clinton also attended. President Clinton said that Judge's death was a "special loss. We should lift his life up as an example of what has to prevail. We have to be more like Father Mike than the people who killed him."^[37]

Judge was buried in the friars' plot at Holy Sepulchre Cemetery in Totowa, New Jersey.^[38] On October 11, 2001, Brendan Fay organized a "Month's Mind Memorial" in Good Shepherd Chapel, General Theological Seminary, New York. It was an evening of prayer, stories, traditional Irish music, and personal testimonials about Judge.

Three people in the Roman Catholic Church called for the canonization of Judge.^[39][31] The Orthodox-Catholic Church of America declared him a saint.^[40][41] Two people say they experienced miraculous healings through prayers to Judge. Evidence of miracles is required for canonization in the Catholic Church.^[42]

Judge's fire helmet was presented to Pope John Paul II. France awarded him the Légion d'honneur. Some members of the United States Congress nominated him for the Congressional Gold Medal,^[43] as well as the Presidential Medal of Freedom. In 2002, the City of New York renamed the portion of West 31st Street on which the friary where he lived is located as "Father Mychal F. Judge Street", and christened a commuter ferry the Father Mychal Judge in his honor in 2002.^[44]

In 2002, the United States Congress passed The Mychal Judge Police and Fire Chaplains Public Safety Officers Benefit Act into law.^[45] The law extended federal death benefits to chaplains of police and fire departments, and also marked the first time^[46] the federal government extended equal benefits for same-sex couples by allowing the domestic partners of public safety officers killed in the line of duty to collect a federal death benefit. This act was signed into law on June 24, 2002, but would be retroactive only to September 11, 2001.

The New York Press Club instituted The Rev. Mychal Judge Heart of New York Award, which is presented annually for the news story or series that is most complimentary of New York City.^[47]

A campaign has been started in East Rutherford, New Jersey, to have a statue of Judge erected in its Memorial Park.^[48]

Alvernia University, a private independent college in the Franciscan tradition in Reading, Pennsylvania, named a new residence hall in honor of Judge.^[49]

The Father Mychal Judge Memorial in the village of Keshcarrigan, County Leitrim, Ireland, was dedicated in 2005, on donated land which had belonged to Judge's ancestors. People from the village and surrounding area celebrate his life every year on the 9/11 anniversary.^[50][51]

In 2006, a documentary film, Saint of 9/11, directed by Glenn Holsten, co-produced by Brendan Fay and narrated by Sir Ian McKellen, was released.

Larry Kirwan, leader of the Irish-American band Black 47, wrote a tribute song entitled "Mychal" in honor of Judge that appeared in the band's 2004 album New York Town.^[52]

The Father Mychal Judge Walk of Remembrance takes place every year in New York on the Sunday before the 9/11 anniversary. It begins with a Mass at St. Francis Church on West 31st Street, then proceeds to the site of Ground Zero, retracing Judge's final journey and praying along the way.^[53] Every September 11, there is a Mass in memory of Judge in Boston, attended by many who lost family members on 9/11.^[54]

At the National 9/11 Memorial, Judge is memorialized at the South Pool, on Panel S-18, where other first responders are located.^[55]

In 2014, Judge was inducted into the Legacy Walk, an outdoor public display which celebrates LGBT history and people.^[56][57]

In 2015, a statue was dedicated to Judge at St. Joseph's Park in East Rutherford, New Jersey, across the street from St. Joseph's Parish where he served for several years.

In recognition of his heroic actions and his commitment to the dignity of LGBTQ people, Judge was posthumously awarded the Dooley Award by GALA-ND/SMC, an alumni organization of the University of Notre Dame, a prominent American Catholic university.^[58]

In September 2021, Judge was nominated for sainthood in the Catholic Church.^[59]

A documentary film directed by Brendan Fay that focuses on Judge, Remembering Mychal, premiered on October 26, 2021, in New York City. Featured voices in the film include Malachy McCourt and Pete Hamill.^[60]

Canonization Debate

Several organizations have proposed to the Vatican a possible canonization, to which the Archdiocese of New York and the Franciscan Third Order have not given clear answers. However, Christian denominations that are not in communion with Rome have canonized him, recognizing him as a saint and a martyr^[61][62] while his tomb, in the Holy Sepulchre Cemetery of Totowa, has been becoming a kind of "informal sanctuary".^[63]

While there is an active campaign to open his cause of beatification (the first step to canonization), there remains a controversy over his illicit sexual activity (despite his vow of chastity) and his disobedience towards Church hierarchy regarding certain circumstances which has represented a serious obstacle to his being named a saint.

The fact that Mychal had a homosexual orientation is an impediment to beatification. Postulators have argued that there are precedents of saints and openly LGBT martyrs.^[64] Recently, in 2021, 20 years after his death, an official cause has been initiated, but without the official support of the Archdiocese of New York, but from an independent postulator, the Rv. Luis Fernando Escalante, directly in charge of the cause in Rome.^[65]

References

General references

• Ford, Michael (2002). Father Mychal Judge: an Authentic American Hero. Paulist Press. ISBN 0-8091-0552-7.
• Daly, Michael (2008). The Book of Mychal: The Surprising Life and Heroic Death of Father Mychal Judge. St. Martin's Press. ISBN 978-0-312-30150-7.

Inline citations

1. . The Orthodox Catholic Church of America. Archived from the original on June 29, 2010. Retrieved November 13, 2017.
2. Hagerty, Barbara Bradley. "Memories Of Sept. 11's First Recorded Casualty Endure". NPR. Retrieved 20 October 2013.
3. Ford (2002), p. 44
4. Daly (2008), pp. 7–19
5. "Deceased Friars: Mychal F. Judge, O.F.M." Franciscan Friars of Holy Name Province. Archived from the original on 2013-09-11.
6. Daly (2008), pp. 30, 31, 46, 81
7. Prager, Sarah (2017). Queer there and Everywhere. New York City: Harper Collins. pp. 196–203. ISBN 978-0-06-247431-5.
8. "St. Bonaventure honors victims of 9/11 at prayer service, Mass". St. Bonaventure University. September 9, 2011. Retrieved September 11, 2013.^{[permanent dead link]}
9. Daly (2008), pp. 23–33
10. Daly (2008), pp. 37–77
11. Daly (2008), p. 62
12. Epps, David (September 2, 2011). . The Citizen. Archived from the original on July 25, 2021. Retrieved July 25, 2021.
13. "PEP, October 2018: Local 299 rewards top scholars". District Council 37. Retrieved 2020-07-25.
14. Ford (2002), pp. 107–139
15. Holsten, Glenn (Director). Saint of 9/11 (2006), Virgil Films & Entertainment.
16. . LGBT Religious Archives Network (LGBT-RAN). October 2011. Archived from the original on April 23, 2018. Retrieved April 22, 2018.
17. Daly (2008), p. 320
18. Ford (2002), pp. 114–115
19. "Chief Joseph Pfeifer of Battalion 1". The New York Times. 2002-07-05. from the original on 2022-03-25. Retrieved 2023-01-29.
20. [1] 2010-11-24 at the Wayback Machine. Daily News (New York). February 11, 2002. "Judge stood alone at a plate glass window overlooking the carnage and devastation. A fire department photographer heard him praying aloud, Jesus, please end this right now! God, please end this!
21. Daly (2008), p. 336
22. Prigge, Matt (May 3, 2006). "Upward Christian Soldier". Philadelphia Weekly.
23. Murphy, Dean E. (August 27, 2002). September 11: An Oral History. Doubleday. p. 174-177. ISBN 978-0385507684.
24. Daly (2008), p. 343
25. Daly (2008), p. 347
26. Cassels, Peter (2001-09-27). . Bay Windows. Archived from the original on 2004-04-26. Retrieved 2004-04-16.
27. Senior, Jennifer (November 12, 2001). . New York. Archived from the original on March 26, 2006. Retrieved 2006-09-14.
28. Dwyer, Jim (2008-09-09). "Missions of Hate and Love, With 9/11 at the Center". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved 2018-04-22.
29. Lynch, Dennis (June 26, 2002). "A September 11th Hijacking" 2005-05-05 at the Wayback Machine. Catholic Online.
30. Daly (2008), pp. 86, 301–302
31. Newman, Andy (2005-09-25). "Admirers of Fallen 9/11 Hero Disdain the Vatican's Likely Plan to Bar Gays as Priests". The New York Times. Retrieved 2008-04-17.
32. "What is Dignity?" 2007-04-04 at the Wayback Machine DignityUSA.
33. "Letter to the Bishops of the Catholic Church on the Pastoral Care of Homosexual Persons" 2006-10-07 at the Wayback Machine. DignityUSA.
34. Ford (2002), pp. 119–120
35. Ford (2002), p. 182
36. Ford (2002), p. 124
37. Glenn Holsten (director). Saint of 9/11. Equality Forum. 2006.
38. . Holy Name Province of the Franciscan Friars. 2007-11-07. Archived from the original on 2007-11-09. Retrieved 2008-04-14.
39. Shane, Larry (December 25, 2002). "Sainthood call for chaplain rises from Sept.11 ashes" 2012-10-04 at the Wayback Machine. The Seattle Times.
40. . The Orthodox Catholic Church of America. Archived from the original on June 29, 2010. Retrieved November 13, 2017.
41. . St. Mychal the Martyr Parish. Archived from the original on 2006-08-10. Retrieved 2006-09-22.
42. Charisse, Jones (June 19, 2003). "The Making of Saint Mychal". USA Today.
43. Thomas, Jocelyn (September 15, 2010). "HNP Today newsletter" 2010-12-19 at the Wayback Machine. Vol. 44, No. 19. Franciscan Friars: Holy Name Province.
44. McQuillan, Alice (February 21, 2002). "Ferry Named For FDNY Priest". New York Daily News. Retrieved 15 January 2018.
45. Bumiller, Elisabeth (June 27, 2002). "Washington Memo; The Most Unusual Story Behind a Gay Rights Victory". The New York Times.
46. Same-sex Marriage in the United States: Focus on the Facts ISBN 978-0-739-10882-6 p. 107
47. "The New York Press Club Journalism Awards" 2011-09-06 at the Wayback Machine. New York Press Club. Retrieved November 29, 2013.
48. Fucci, Jeff (2008-03-28). "Sculpted from memories: Statue may be final Judge-ment". Leader (New Jersey). Retrieved 2008-04-14.^{[permanent dead link]}
49. . Archived from the original on March 29, 2008. Retrieved 2008-04-30. Judge Hall, our newest residence hall built in 2005, is named in honor of the late Fr. Mychal Judge, a Franciscan priest who died while ministering to injured firefighters at the World Trade Center site on September 11, 2001.
50. TeVogt, Jim. (April 19, 2007). "H0307: Fr. Mychal Judge Memorial Near Keshcarrigan" 2011-10-08 at the Wayback Machine. Geograph Britain and Ireland. Retrieved November 29, 2013.
51. "Keshcarrigan Peace Garden to honour memory of 9/11 priest" 2011-09-29 at the Wayback Machine. Leitrim Observer. August 31, 2005.
52. Kirwan, Larry. . The Reel Book. Archived from the original on 10 July 2015. Retrieved 9 July 2015.
53. Johnson, Nicole (September 11, 2006). "FDNY Chaplain Honored At Annual Remembrance Walk"^{[permanent dead link]}. NY1.
54. McGonegal, Joe (September 16, 2008). "Seven years of healing" 2009-03-01 at the Wayback Machine. Wicked Local.
55. . National September 11 Memorial & Museum. Archived from the original on July 27, 2013. Retrieved October 29, 2011.
56. "Legacy Walk honors LGBT 'guardian angels'". chicagotribune.com. 11 October 2014.
57. "PHOTOS: 7 LGBT Heroes Honored With Plaques in Chicago's Legacy Walk". Advocate.com. 11 October 2014.
58. . Archived from the original on 2016-11-26. Retrieved 2016-12-05.
59. Kelly, Mike (September 10, 2021). . NorthJersey.com. Archived from the original on September 10, 2021. Retrieved September 13, 2021.
60. "Documentary on 9/11 hero 'Remembering Mychal' premieres in New York". IrishCentral. November 12, 2021. from the original on July 13, 2022. Retrieved July 27, 2022.
61. "St. Mychal Judge". The Reformed Catholic Church. Retrieved 2022-08-12.
62. . 2010-06-29. Archived from the original on 2010-06-29. Retrieved 2022-08-12.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: bot: original URL status unknown (link)
63. . 2021-09-10. Archived from the original on 2021-09-10. Retrieved 2022-08-12.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: bot: original URL status unknown (link)
64. Graham, Ruth (2017-09-11). "Father Mychal Judge Was a 9/11 Hero. Could He Also Become the First Gay Saint?". Slate Magazine. Retrieved 2022-08-12.
65. "It's Time to Canonize Fr. Mychal Judge". New Ways Ministry. Retrieved 2022-08-12.

Further reading

• Lynch, Kelly Ann (2007). He Said Yes: The Story of Father Mychal Judge. Paulist Press (illustrated children's book). ISBN 978-0-8091-6740-1.
• Sapienza, Salvatore (2011). Mychal's Prayer: Praying with Father Mychal Judge. Tregatti Press. ISBN 978-0-615-47331-4.

External links

 

Wikimedia Commons has media related to Mychal Judge.

• Fire Chaplain Becomes Larger than Life
• The Happiest Man on Earth: Eulogy of Fr. Mychal Judge
• An RTE Radio 1 documentary 'Victim No. 0001', September 3, 2011, describes his life and work
• An NPR Radio clip "Slain Priest: 'Bury His Heart, But Not His Love'"
• Saint of 9/11 at IMDb