Lev Karsavin

In this name that follows Eastern Slavic naming customs, the patronymic is Platonovich and the family name is Karsavin.

Lev (Leo) Platonovich Karsavin (Russian: Лев Платонович Карсавин; Lithuanian: Levas Karsavinas; 13 December 1882 – 17 or 20 July 1952^[2]) was a Russian religious philosopher, historian-medievalist, and poet.^[3][4]

Lev Karsavin
Лев Карсавин
Born	(1882-12-13)13 December 1882 Saint Petersburg, Russian Empire (now Russia)
Died	17 February 1952(1952-02-17) (aged 69) Abez, Komi ASSR, Russian SFSR, Soviet Union (now Komi Republic, Russia)
Alma mater	Saint Petersburg Imperial University
Era	20th-century philosophy
Region	Russian philosophy Western philosophy
School	Continental philosophy

Biography

Early years

Lev Platonovich Karsavin was born into the family of Platon Konstantinovich Karsavin, a ballet actor at the Mariinsky Theatre, and his wife Anna Iosifovna, née Khomyakova, the daughter of the cousin of Aleksey Khomyakov, a famous Slavophile.^[5] He was the brother of the ballerina Tamara Karsavina.

He was a student of Ivan Grevs, graduated from the Faculty of History and Philology of Saint Petersburg State University.^[6] From 1909 he taught at the Petrograd Institute of History and Philology (professor since 1912, inspector since 1914) and at the Bestuzhev Courses. He was the Privatdozent of the Saint Petersburg Imperial University (from 1912), then professor (from 1916).

His Master's thesis is a monograph entitled Essays on religious life in Italy in the 12th and 13th centuries (1912; defended 1913). His doctoral thesis is The foundations of medieval religiosity in the 12th to 13th centuries, mainly in Italy (1915; defended 1916).

He was a member of the Petrograd Brotherhood of St. Sophia [ru] (1918–1922). He was one of the founding members of the Free Philosophical Association [ru] (1919–1924).^[7] In 1920, he became one of the founders of the Petropolis Publishing House [ru] and one of the founders and professors of the Petrograd Theological Institute [ru]. In 1921 he was elected professor of the Social-Pedagogical and Legal Departments of the Faculty of Social Sciences at Petrograd University, and chairman of its Social-Pedagogical Department.

In August 1922 he was arrested and sentenced to exile abroad without the right to return. He was released shortly before the expulsion.

Emigration and Eurasianism

 

Memorial tables of Lev Karsavin and Vasily Seseman in the Grand Courtyard of Vilnius University

Karsavin was expelled in November 1922, together with a group of forty-five scientific and cultural figures (Nikolai Berdyaev, Sergei Bulgakov, Semyon Frank, Ivan Ilyin and others) and their family members to Germany (see Philosophers' ships). In Berlin, he was elected deputy chairman of the Bureau of the Russian Academic Union in Germany, and became one of the organizers and a member of the Russian Institute of Science [ru]. He was a co-founder (together with Nestor Kotlyarevsky) of the Obelisk publishing house. From 1926 he lived in Clamart near Paris. Karsavin joined the Eurasian movement: he headed the Eurasian Seminar in Paris and was a member of the editorial board of the newspaper Eurasia (1928-1929) and its leading author, he also participated in Eurasian compilations.

Lithuania

At the end of 1927, Karsavin was invited to take up the chair of general history at the Vytautas Magnus University in Kaunas. He lived in Kaunas from 1928. From 1928 to 1940, he was professor of general history at the university (from 1929 he taught in Lithuanian). After Lithuania became part of the USSR, he stayed. With the transfer of the university's Faculty of Humanities to Vilnius in 1940, he became a professor at Vilnius University. From 1941, he simultaneously taught at the Vilnius Academy of Arts. For a short time, he worked at the National Museum of Art.

While living in Lithuania, he edited academic publications and published his own books in Russian, On Personality (1929) and A Poem on Death (1931). He also published works in Lithuanian. These included Theory of History (1929), a fundamental five-volume study The History of European Culture (1931–1937), and several dozen articles on medieval philosophy and theology in the encyclopedia Lietuviškoji enciklopedija and magazines.

Arrest and death

In 1944, the Soviet authorities suspended him from teaching at the Vilnius University and fired him from the museum. In 1949, he was fired from the Academy of Arts as well. Karsavin was arrested and accused of "participating in the anti-Soviet Eurasianist movement and preparing to overthrow the Soviet state". In March 1950, he was sentenced to ten years of labour camps by the Ministry of State Security. He died of tuberculosis in the Abez camp, a special camp for the disabled in the settlement of Abez, Komi Republic.^[8]

Commemoration

 

Memorial plaque in Kaunas

In 1989, the burial place of Lev Karsavin was found in an abandoned camp cemetery near the village of Abez. This happened thanks to the personal archive of the widow of Anatoly Vaneev [ru], a disciple of Karsavin, which preserved a photograph at the grave marked П-11, as well as the testimony of former prisoners of the Abez camp. In 1990, the leaders of Sąjūdis in Lithuania had the idea of transferring Karsavin's remains to the capital, but Karsavin's daughters Susanna and Marianna spoke out against the idea. In 1990, Abez resident Viktor Lozhkin installed a cross on the grave, and Lithuanian NGOs erected a monument to the repressed in the form of a torn metal sheet on a pedestal with a tear in the shape of a cross.

In December 1992, on the occasion of his 110th birthday anniversary, on the house at Krėvos Street 7 in Kaunas, where Karsavin lived in 1935–1940, a memorial plaque was installed.^[9] The current Žaliakalnis Progymnasium school in Kaunas was named after Karsavin from 1994 to 2008 and a school in Vilnius was named after him in 1996.^[10]

In October 2005, a bilingual marble memorial plaque by sculptor Romualdas Kvintas [lt; ru] was installed on the façade of the house on Didžioji Street in Vilnius, where Karsavin lived from 1940 to 1949.^[11] In February 2006, a memorial plaque was placed on the so-called "professor's house" (Žemuogių Street 6) in Kaunas in memory of the Vytautas Magnus University professors who lived in the building, mentioning Karsavin who lived there in 1928–1929.^[9]

The History of European Culture and other his works have been republished in Lithuanian. Selected treatises and poetry were included in a Lithuanian edition compiled by poet and translator Alfonsas Bukontas [ru; lt].^[12] A book of Karsavin's sonnets and tercets was also published in a translation by Bukontas, with a parallel text in Russian.^[13]

Scientific activities

His based on extensive material works of the early period are devoted to the history of medieval religious movements and the spiritual culture of the Middle Ages.

Philosophy

Karsavin developed a special version of the philosophy of all–unity as applied to the problem of personality, methodology of history, history of culture, gnoseology, ethics, and sociology. He strove to create an integral system of the Christian worldview. He drew on early Christian teachings (Patristics, Origen) and Russian religious philosophy, especially the tradition of Vladimir Solovyov. For Karsavin, the idea of all-unity was understood as a dynamic principle of the formation of being and as a fundamental category of the historical process lying at the heart of historiosophy.

One of the main places in his writings is occupied by the concept of human personality. Karsavin believed that the development of human personality is closely linked to the process of its deification. Therefore, one of the issues that interested the philosopher was the question of whether a child is a person. According to Karsavin, a person with a developed personality, who has put it together from the fragmented state that characterizes the modern age, becomes spiritual and approaches God, but has no way of reaching Him.

Karsavin's concept of personality is connected with the concept of being. It is understood as a supreme existence in God, whereas real, earthly life is called бывание (presence; attendance), which emphasizes its finitude, its imperfection. Hence, a man, born into this world, is not yet a person in the sense that Karsavin understood it. They are just a kind of "blanks" or "substrates" that could potentially approach the state of an individual. However, they can become part of the Divine Hypostasis by dedicating their lives to the process of deification, that is, to an existence analogous to the life of Christ. Also, in becoming a person, one should not aspire to do something unique. Personality develops in a person through the process of internalization of common divine values. Here the idea of all-unity is noticeable, as individuals, on the one hand possessing a certain natural individuality, internalize the same higher values, and, in addition, aim their lives toward the universal goal.^[14]

The philosopher understands the totality of personalities aspiring to God as the "symphonic", or sobor, personality. Here Karsavin was drawing on a tradition of reflection of the "Man of the first creation" going back to Gregory of Nyssa.^[15]

Works

• From the History of the Spiritual Culture of the Falling Roman Empire. The Political Views of Sidonius Apollinaris — file (in Russian): Из истории духовной культуры падающей римской империи. Политические взгляды Сидония Аполлинария. Petersburg. 1908.
• Essays on Religious Life in Italy in the 12th and 13th centuries. Очерки религиозной жизни в Италии XII—XIII вв. СПБ. 1912.
• Monasticism in the Middle Ages. — СПб.: Брокгауз и Ефрон, 1912. — [2], 109, [1] p. PDF
• The Foundations of Medieval Religiosity in the 12th to 13th centuries, mainly in Italy — Основы средневековой религиозности в XII—XIII веках преимущественно в Италии. — Petersburg. Nauchnoe delo publishing house. 1915. — XVI, 360 p.
• Culture of the Middle Ages — Культура средних веков. Petersburg. 1914.
• Introduction to History — Введение в историю. Petersburg. 1920.
• East, West, and the Russian Idea — Восток, Запад и русская идея, Petersburg. 1922. — 80 p.
• G. Bruno. Дж. Бруно. Berlin. 1923.
• Philosophy of History — Философия истории. Berlin. 1923.
• On the Beginnings — О началах. Berlin. 1925.
• Response to Berdyaev's Article on the Eurasians — Ответ на статью Бердяева об евразийцах. // The magazine Put' ("Path"). — 1926. — #2. — p. 124—127
• An Apologetic Study — Апологетический этюд. // The magazine Put'. — 1926. — #3. — p. 29-45
• On the Perils and Overcoming of Abstract Christianity — Об опасностях и преодолении отвлеченного христианства. // The magazine Put'. — 1927. — #6. — p. 32-49
• Prolegomena to the Doctrine of Personality — Пролегомены к учению о личности. // The magazine Put'. — 1928. — #12. — p. 32-46
• Perí archon. Ideen zur christlichen Metaphysik. Memel, 1928.
• On Personality — О личности. Kaunas, 1929.
• A Poem on Death — Поэма о смерти. 1931.
• The History of European Culture — Europos kultūros istorija. Kaunas, 1931–1937.
• The Path of Orthodoxy — Путь православия. Berlin, 1923.
• St. Augustine and Our Age — Святой Августин и наша эпоха. // Symbol. — 1992. — #28. — p. 233—241

See also

• Platon Karsavin
• Tamara Karsavina
• Ivan Grevs
• Vasily Seseman
• Vladimir Solovyov

References

1. Sauvé, Ross J. "Georges V. Florovsky And Vladimir N. Lossky: An Exploration, Comparison And Demonstration Of Their Unique Approaches To The Neopatristic Synthesis" (PDF). Durham E-Theses. Retrieved 21 August 2022.
2. Шаронов Владимир (2019-03-08). "Подлинная дата кончины Льва Карсавина". Информационное Агентство "Регнум". regnum.ru. Retrieved 2019-03-09.
3. "Karsavin Lev". relstud-hist.spbu.ru. Retrieved 20 August 2022.
4. Davydov, Oleg. "Lev Karsavin: Theological path of all-unity". HTS Theological Studies.
5. Мелих, Ю.Б. "О личности Л.П. Карсавина. К 125-летнему юбилею" (PDF). Вестник МГТУ. Вестник МГТУ, том 10, №3, 2007 г. Retrieved 29 August 2022.
6. Свешников, Антон. "Как поссорился Лев Платонович с Иваном Михайловичем". polit.ru. Retrieved 10 September 2022.
7. "Энциклопедия Санкт-Петербурга". encspb.ru. Retrieved 10 September 2022.
8. "Карсавин Лев Платонович (1882)". Открытый список (in Russian). Retrieved 2022-08-21.
9. "Atminimo įamžinimas". atminimas.kvb.lt. Retrieved 10 September 2022.
10. "Levo Karsavino mokykla". Levo Karsavino mokykla (in Lithuanian). Retrieved 10 September 2022.
11. "Vilnius - Levas Karsavinas". statues.vanderkrogt.net. Retrieved 10 September 2022.
12. Karsavinas Levas. (2000). Toje akimirkoje – amžinybė: studijos, traktatai, poezija. Vilnius: Lietuvos rašytojų sąjungos leidykla. ISBN 9986-39-136-9.
13. Karsavinas Levas. (2002). Tai tu mane kvieti. Sonetai ir tercinos. Vilnius: Daigai. ISBN 9986-767-09-1.
14. Цепелева, Н. В. (2014). "Философия личности Л. П. Карсавина и христианство". Logos et Praxis. Volgograd State University.
15. Гутова, С. Г. (2015). "Личность и мир в философии всеединства Л. П. Карсавина". Вестник Челябинского государственного университета. Chelyabinsk State University.

Literature

• Архив Л. П. Карсавина. Вып. I: Семейная корреспонденция. Неопубликованные труды / Сост., предисловие, комментарий П. И. Ивинского. — Вильнюс: Vilniaus universiteto leidykla, 2002. ISBN 9986-19-517-9
• Архив Л. П. Карсавина. Вып. II: Неопубликованные труды. Рукописи / Сост., вступит. статья, комментарий П. И. Ивинского. — Вильнюс: Vilniaus universiteto leidykla, 2003. ISBN 9986-19-591-8
• Библиография трудов Льва Карсавина / Изд. Александра Клементьева. Предисл. Никиты Струве. — Париж: Ин-т славянских исследований, 1994. — 63 с.
• Бойцов М. А.
• Ванеев А. А. Два года в Абези. В память о Л. П. Карсавине. — Брюссель: Жизнь с Богом, 1990. — 386 с.
• Вебер Д. И. Исследование религиозной культуры в трудах Л. П. Карсавина // Религиоведение. — Благовещенск, 2017 — Т. 1.—С. 109–116.
• Контексты Л. Карсавина. Вильнюс, 2004 (рец. Andrius Konickis. Levo Karsavino kontekstai // Naujoji Romuva. — 2004. — No. 1 (546). — P. 3–11);
• Ласинскас П. Лев Карсавин. Универсальная личность в контекстах европейской культуры. — М.: Изд-во Ипполитова, 2011. — 206 с., 100 экз. ISBN 978-5-93856-184-7
• Лев Платонович Карсавин. — М. : РОССПЭН, 2012.
• Мелих Ю. Б. Философия Всеединства Карсавина и концепция единого у Плотина // Историко-философский ежегодник, 1997. — М., 1999. — С. 169−182.
• Мелих Ю. Б. Персонализм Л. П. Карсавина и европейская философия. М., 2003.
• Оболевич Т. Семён Франк, Лев Карсавин и евразийцы. М.: Модест Колеров, 2020. (Исследования по истории русской мысли. Т. 24). 304 с.
• Резниченко А. И., Казарян А. Т. Карсавин // Православная энциклопедия. — М., 2013. — Т. XXXI : «Каракалла — Катехизация». — С. 341–357. — 752 с. — 33 000 экз. — ISBN 978-5-89572-031-8.
• Русские философы в Литве: Карсавин, Сеземан, Шилкарский: [сб. науч. публ. / сост., подгот. к публ. вступ. ст. В. И. Повилайтис]. — Калининград: Изд-во Рос. гос. ун-та, 2005. — 93 с.
• Свешников А. В. Анализ философии гностиков в трудах Л. П. Карсавина (методы и формы научного исследования). // Античный вестник, выпуск 3, Омск, ОмГУ, 1995.
• Свешников А. В. Лев Карсавин : миф свободы в тексте жизни // Мифологема свободы в культуре XX века. Омск, ОмГУ, 1998.
• Свешников А. В. Как поссорился Лев Платонович с Иваном Михайловичем (история одного профессорского конфликта) // Новое литературное обозрение. — 2009. — No. 96.
• Свешников А. В., Степанов Б. Е. История одного классика: Лев Платонович Карсавин в постсоветской историографии // Классика и классики в социальном и гуманитарном знании. — М. : НЛО, 2009. — С. 332–360.
• Свешников А. В., Степанов Б. Е. Как Карсавин не «вышел в классики». К вопросу о характере и контекстах механизма классикализации в постсоветской историографии // Мир историка: историографический сборник / под ред. В. П. Корзун, С. П. Бычкова. — Вып. 7. — Омск. : Изд-во Ом. гос. ун-та, 2011. — С. 193–204.
• Степанов Б. Е. Проблема достоверности в методологии истории культуры Л. П. Карсавина // Достоверность и доказательность в исследованиях по теории и истории культуры. Кн. 1. — М., 2002. — С.183-215.
• Хоружий С. С. Жизнь и учение Льва Карсавина // С. С. Хоружий После перерыва. Пути русской философии. — СПб.: Алетейя, 1994. — С.131-187.
• Хоружий С. С. Карсавин // Новая философская энциклопедия : в 4 т. / пред. науч.-ред. совета В. С. Стёпин. — 2-е изд., испр. и доп. — М. : Мысль, 2010. — 2816 с.
• Шаронов В.
• Шаронов В.
• Ястребицкая А. Л. Историк-медиевист Лев Платонович Карсавин (1882—1952). — М., 1991.

External links

• Лев Карсавин (1882—1952): биография и тексты 2011-06-17 at the Wayback Machine
• — Documentary film (Russia, 2007). The director is Oleg Baraev.
• Карсавин Лев Платонович // Биографика СПбГУ
• «Душа любить осуждена...» к 130 летию Льва Карсавина — Документальный фильм (Россия. 2012) автор: Владимир Шаронов. (1882 г.-1922 г. Л. П. Карсавин и Е. Ч. Скржинская).
• «Уроки обреченной веры» к 130 летию Льва Карсавина — Документальный фильм (Россия. 2012) автор: Владимир Шаронов (1922—1927. Берлин, Париж, критика католицизма, евразийство и евразийцы) .
• «Пока не требует поэта...» к 130 летию Льва Карсавина — Документальный фильм (Россия. 2013) автор: Владимир Шаронов (1928—1949. Каунас, Вильнюс, вклад в литовскую культуру, отношения с католиками и католичеством, переписка с Г. А. Веттером, «Поэма о смерти»)
• Эпитафия. Телефильм Натальи Петренко с участием Константина Иванова и Ярослава Слининна
• Могилы Льва Карсавина и Николая Пунина на мемориальном кладбище заключенных на станции Абезь в Республике Коми.
• «Иная лучшая потребна мне свобода....» Четвертый фильм документального проекта «Симфоническая личность» (Россия. 2015) автор: Владимир Шаронов (1949—1952 г.г.).
• Степанов Б., Свешников А. История одного классика: Лев Платонович Карсавин в постсоветской историографии