Committee of Safety (Hawaii)

For other Committees of Safety, see Committee of Safety (disambiguation).

The Committee of Safety, formally the Citizen's Committee of Public Safety, was a 13-member group of the Annexation Club. The group was composed of mostly Hawaiian subjects of American descent and American citizens who were members of the Missionary Party, as well as some foreign residents in the Kingdom of Hawaiʻi. The group planned and carried out the overthrow of the Kingdom of Hawaiʻi on January 17, 1893. The goal of this group was to achieve annexation of Hawaiʻi by the United States. The new independent Republic of Hawaiʻi government was thwarted in this goal by the administration of President Grover Cleveland, and it was not until 1898 that the United States Congress approved a joint resolution of annexation creating the U.S. Territory of Hawaiʻi.^[1][2][3]

Committee of Safety

The Committee of Safety
Formation	1887
Dissolved	1893 (succeeded by Provisional Government)
Type	Secret society
Purpose	Overthrow of the government of Hawaii, annexation by the United States
Location	Oʻahu, Hawaii
Membership	Elite business and political leaders
Official language	English
Unofficial leader	Lorrin A. Thurston
Main organ	Committee of Thirteen, Committee of Safety
Affiliations	Honolulu Rifles

Lorrin A. Thurston long advocated annexation by the United States

Formation

The Committee of Safety originated from a leadership group when members of the Missionary Party began to run as Independent Party candidates. For the elections of 1884 the Missionary Party strictly ran all candidates as Independent Party candidates. To ensure that Missionaries were on the Independent ticket the "Committee of Nine" was formed January 14, 1893, to assume the leadership position of the Independent Party. The Committee of Nine were staunchly loyal to the Missionary Party, having social and economic philosophies that reflected the Missionary values. The Independent Party won 13 seats and was the minority party in the Hawaii legislature. For the following elections of 1886 the committee reconvened, this time calling themselves the "Committee of Thirteen" due to the change in members. Their intent was to make the Independent Party the majority party in the legislature. At the end of the elections the Independents won ten seats, a net loss of three seats.

Hawaiian League

In January 1887 the Committee of Thirteen formed a secret society called the Hawaiian League. No official records were kept, but Lorrin A. Thurston (the grandson of American missionaries Asa Thurston and Lorrin Andrews) drafted the group's constitution. The group was headed by an executive committee of lawyers and businessmen mostly of non-aboriginal non-indigenous naturalized United States citizens. Membership grew through the year, including some German and British citizens, and a few part-Hawaiians. Although the politicians changed the name of their party from "Missionary" to "Reform", many wanted to become part of the United States, not just reform the monarchy.^{[4]: 347–350} This was why the Hawaiian League was also called the Annexation Club, although not often in public.

The Hawaiian League came into control of the Honolulu Rifles. Made of about 200 armed local (non-native) men, who fought under the command of enthusiastic annexationist Volney V. Ashford.^{[4]: 352–353} In June 1887, the Hawaiian League used the Rifles to force King Kalākaua to enact the Bayonet Constitution which limited his power. After Queen Liliʻuokalani came to power in 1891, she attempted to restore power to the throne. This caused the group to act again.

Overthrow

See also: Overthrow of the Kingdom of Hawaii

The precipitating event^[4]: 582 leading to the overthrow was the attempt by Queen Liliʻuokalani to promulgate a new constitution which would have strengthened the power of the monarch relative to the legislature in which Euro-American business elites held disproportionate power, a political situation that was a direct result of the 1887 constitution. The conspirators' stated goals were to depose the queen, overthrow the monarchy, and seek Hawaii's annexation to the United States.^{[4]: 353, 587–88}

On January 16, the Marshal of the Kingdom Charles B. Wilson was tipped off to the imminent planned coup. Wilson requested warrants to arrest the 13-member Committee of Safety, and put the Kingdom under martial law. Because the members had strong political ties with United States Government Minister John L. Stevens, the requests were repeatedly denied, fearing if approved, the arrests would escalate the situation. After a failed negotiation with Thurston,^[5] Wilson began to collect his men for the confrontation. Wilson and Captain of the Royal Household Guard, Samuel Nowlein, had rallied a force of 496 men who were kept at hand to protect the Queen.

The Revolution ignited on January 17 when a policeman was shot and wounded while trying to stop a wagon carrying weapons to the Honolulu Rifles. The Committee of Safety feared the shooting would bring government forces to rout out the conspirators and stop the coup before it could begin. The Rifles garrisoned Ali'iolani Hale across the street from ʻIolani Palace and waited for the Queen's response.

As these events were unfolding, the Committee of Safety expressed concern for the safety and property of American residents in Honolulu. United States Government Minister John L. Stevens, advised about these supposed threats to non-combatant American lives and property^[6] by the Committee of Safety, obliged their request and summoned a company of uniformed U.S. Marines from the USS Boston and two companies of U.S. sailors to land on the Kingdom and take up positions at the U.S. Legation, Consulate, and Arion Hall on the afternoon of January 16, 1893. 162 sailors and marines aboard the USS Boston in Honolulu Harbor came ashore well-armed but under orders of neutrality. The sailors and marines did not enter the Palace grounds or take over any buildings, and never fired a shot, but their presence served to intimidate royalist defenders. Historian William Russ states, "the injunction to prevent fighting of any kind made it impossible for the monarchy to protect itself."^[7] Due to the Queen's desire "to avoid any collision of armed forces, and perhaps the loss of life" for her subjects and after some deliberation, at the urging of advisers and friends, the Queen ordered her forces to surrender. The Honolulu Rifles took over government buildings, disarmed the Royal Guard, and declared a Provisional Government.

The Committee of Safety issued the following proclamation, read aloud on January 17 by its chairman Henry E. Cooper to a large crowd assembled in front of the royal residence ʻIolani Palace:^[8]

"First – The Hawaiian monarchial system of government is hereby abrogated.

Second – A Provisional Government for the control and management of public affairs and the protection of public peace is hereby established, to exist until terms of union with the United States of America have been negotiated and agreed upon".

 

Executive council of the Provisional Government (left to right): James A. King, Sanford B. Dole, W. O. Smith and P. C. Jones

The Hawaiian League unofficially adopted the American Flag to appeal to the US and promote annexation. The flag was raised over ʻIolani Palace by Stevens on January 17, 1893. The flag was eventually lowered by James H. Blount that April for spreading a false presumption that the US had taken control.

International response

During the overthrow, the Japanese Imperial Navy gunboat Naniwa was docked at Pearl Harbor. The gunboat's commander, Heihachiro Togo, who later commanded the Japanese battleship fleet at Tsushima, refused to accede to the Provisional Government's demands that he strike the colors of the Kingdom, but later lowered the colors on order of the Japanese Government. Along with every other international legations in Honolulu, the Japanese Consulate-General, Suburo Fujii, quickly recognized the Provisional Government as the legitimate successor to the monarchy.^[9]

Every government with a diplomatic presence in Hawaii recognized the Provisional Government within 48 hours of the overthrow, including the United States, although the recognition by the United States government and its further response is detailed in the section above on "American Response". Countries recognizing the new Provisional Government included Chile, Austria-Hungary, Mexico, Russia, the Netherlands, Germany, Sweden, Spain, Japan, Italy, Portugal, Great Britain, Denmark, Belgium, China, Peru, and France.^[10] When the Republic of Hawaii was declared on July 4, 1894, immediate recognition was given by every nation with diplomatic relations with Hawaii, except for Britain, whose response came in November.^[11]

Members of the committees

 

The Committee of Safety, formally the Citizen's Committee of Public Safety, was a 13-member group of the Hawaiian League also known as the Annexation Club. Henry E. Cooper, chairman, Theodore F. Lansing, Henry Waterhouse, Lorrin A. Thurston, Ed Suhr, F.W. McChesney, John Emmeluth, Wm. R. Castle, Wm. O. Smith, J.A. McCandless, C. Bolte, W.C. Wilder, and Andrew Brown.

Committee of Nine

• Joseph B. Atherton
• William R. Castle
• Sanford B. Dole
• William W. Hall (1841–1910) Business partner of his printer father Edwin Oscar Hall^[12]
• James A. Hopper (1831–1900)^[13]
• Peter C. Jones
• Henry W. Mist (1833–1895)^[14]
• John H. Paty
• William O. Smith

Committee of Thirteen

• Joseph B. Atherton
• Jonathan Austin
• William H. Bailey
• William R. Castle
• Benjamin F. Dillingham
• Sanford B. Dole
• Henry F. Glade (1883–1894) German consul to Hawaii^[15]
• William W. Hall
• Peter C. Jones
• Thomas May
• John H. Paty
• Lorrin A. Thurston
• George N. Wilcox

Committee of Safety

Six Hawaiian subjects, five American citizens, a German subject, and a British subject signed the January 16 letter:^[16][17]

Hawaiian Kingdom subjects:

• Crister Bolte, naturalized Hawaiian subject^[18] of German birth, member
• William Richards Castle, Hawaiian subject, born in Honolulu 1849, attorney general for Kalākaua 1876, Hawaiian legislator 1878–88, member
• Chairman Henry Ernest Cooper, American citizen who arrived in 1890, denizen of the Kingdom,^[19] named chairman at mass meeting January 14, 1893
• William Owen Smith, Hawaiian subject, born on Kauaʻi 1838 of American missionaries, member
• Lorrin A. Thurston, Hawaiian subject, born in Hawaii of American grandparents, member
• Henry Waterhouse, naturalized Hawaiian subject^[20] of Tasmanian birth, came to Hawaiʻi 1851, member
• William C. Wilder, naturalized Hawaiian subject,^[20] brother of Samuel Gardner Wilder, member

Non-subject Members:

• Andrew Brown, Scottish, member
• John Emmeluth, American citizen, member
• Theodore F. Lansing, American citizen, member
• John A. McCandless, American citizen, member
• Frederick W. McChesney, American citizen, member
• Edward Suhr, German citizen, member

Others who assisted in the overthrow:

• Charles L. Carter, American, naturalized Hawaiian subject, member, son of Henry A. P. Carter, brother of George R. Carter, died during the 1895 counter-revolution
• Samuel Mills Damon, Hawaiian subject with American parents, vice president of Provisional Government
• Sanford B. Dole, Hawaiian subject with American parents, selected to head Provisional Government and Republic
• Peter Cushman Jones, American, naturalized Hawaiian subject, provisional government minister of finance
• James A. King, Scottish, named minister of interior

See also

• 1887 Constitution of the Kingdom of Hawaii
• Reform Party of the Hawaiian Kingdom
• Provisional Government of Hawaii
• Republic of Hawaii
• Territory of Hawai'i

References

1. Thomas A. Bailey, "The United States and Hawaii during the Spanish–American War" American Historical Review 36#3 (1931), pp. 552-560 JSTOR 1837915 doi:10.2307/1837915
2. Kam, Ralph Thomas; Lyons, Jeffrey K. (2019). "Remembering the Committee of Safety: Identifying the Citizenship, Descent, and Occupations of the Men Who Overthrew the Monarchy". The Hawaiian Journal of History. Honolulu: Hawaiian Historical Society. 53: 31–54. doi:10.1353/hjh.2019.0002. ISSN 2169-7639. OCLC 60626541. S2CID 212795443.
3. McWilliams, Tennant S. (Feb 1988). "James H. Blount, the South, and Hawaiian Annexation". Pacific Historical Review. 57 (1): 25–36. doi:10.2307/3639673. JSTOR 3639673. from the original on 2016-02-16. Retrieved 2014-10-08.
4. Ralph Simpson Kuykendall (1967). Hawaiian Kingdom 1874–1893, the Kalakaua Dynasty. Vol. 3. University of Hawaii Press. ISBN 978-0-87022-433-1.
5. Twombly, Alexander (1900). Hawaii and its people. Silver, Burdett and company. p. 333.
6. Kinzer, S. (2006) America's Century of Regime Change from Hawaii to Iraq. p. 30. [Minister Stevens] "certainly overstepped his authority when he brought troops ashore, especially since he knew that the 'general alarm and terror' of which the Committee of Safety had complained was a fiction."
7. William Adam Russ (1992). The Hawaiian Revolution (1893–94). Associated University Presses. p. 350. ISBN 0-945636-43-1.
8. Westervelt, William Drake, "Hawaiian Historical Legends", Forgotten Books Easy Reading Series, 2008.
9. The Morgan Report, p1106-1107, "The receipt of your communication, dated the 17th instant, inclosing a copy of proclamation issued on the same day, informing me that for reasons set forth in said proclamation the Hawaiian monarchy has been abrogated and a Provisional Government established, which is now in possession of the Government departmental buildings, the archives, and the treasury, and requesting me on behalf of H. I. J. M.'s Government to recognize said Provisional Government as the de facto Government of the Hawaiian Islands, pending the receipt of instructions from H. I. J. M.'s Government, to whom advices of your action and of the position which I have taken in relation thereto have been despatched."
10. The Morgan Report, p 1103-1111
11. Andrade, Ernest (1996). The Unconquerable Rebel. The University Press of Colorado. p. 147. ISBN 0-87081-417-6. "The provisional government, whatever its faults, had had little difficulty in obtaining recognition, even from Cleveland, and it was not considered likely that the republic would have any foreign problems. Recognition came even more quickly than it had in 1893, for at least there was no question of a revolution's having taken place or of the government's control of the domestic situation."
12. "In Memoriam, William W. Hall". The Hawaiian Star. June 1, 1910.
13. "Body Comes on Sierra-James A. Hopper". The Hawaiian Gazette. December 21, 1900.
14. "Death of Captain Henry Wentworth Mist - Newspapers.com". The Independent. October 25, 1895.
15. "Death of Henry F. Glade Occurs in Fatherland". The Honolulu Advertiser. January 29, 1902.
16. Congressional Record: Proceedings and Debates of the Congress. U.S. Government Printing Office. 1894. WHO WERE THE PARTIES THAT ASKED FOR AMERICAN AID. Six of them were Hawaiians, one English, and one German; five were Americans, but residents of Honolulu; a majority alien to us.
17. Kam, Ralph Thomas; Lyons, Jeffrey K. (2019). "Remembering the Committee of Safety: Identifying the Citizenship, Descent, and Occupations of the Men Who Overthrew the Monarchy". The Hawaiian Journal of History. Honolulu: Hawaiian Historical Society. 53: 31–54. doi:10.1353/hjh.2019.0002. ISSN 2169-7639. OCLC 60626541. S2CID 212795443.
18. "Hawaiian Kingdom - Registry of Naturalized Subjects - B". www.hawaiiankingdom.org. Retrieved 2021-10-26.
19. "Hawaiian Kingdom - Registry of Denizens (c. 1840-1893)". www.hawaiiankingdom.org. Retrieved 2021-10-26.
20. "Hawaiian Kingdom - Registry of Naturalized Subjects - W". www.hawaiiankingdom.org. Retrieved 2021-10-26.

Further reading

• Collins, Stephen (2014). Taking Hawaii : How Thirteen Honolulu Businessmen Overthrew the Queen of Hawaii in 1893, With a Bluff. Open Road Media. ISBN 978-1-4976-3808-2. OCLC 874921510.
• Liliuokalani (1898). Hawaii's Story by Hawaii's Queen, Liliuokalani. Boston: Lee and Shepard. ISBN 978-0-548-22265-2. OCLC 2387226.
• Twigg-Smith, Thurston (1998). Hawaiian Sovereignty: Do the Facts Matter?. Honolulu: Goodale Pub. ISBN 978-0-9662945-0-7. OCLC 607514169.