Geoffrey Archer (colonial administrator)

For other people named Geoffrey Archer, see Geoffrey Archer (disambiguation).

Sir Geoffrey Francis Archer KCMG (4 July 1882 – 1 May 1964) was an English ornithologist, big game hunter and colonial official. He was Commissioner and then Governor of British Somaliland between 1913 and 1922, and was responsible for finally quelling the twenty-year-long Dervish resistance.

Sir Geoffrey Archer KCMG
Commissioner of British Somaliland
In office May 1914 – October 1919
Preceded by	Horace Archer Byatt
Governor of British Somaliland
In office October 1919 – 17 August 1922
Succeeded by	Gerald Henry Summers
Governor of Uganda
In office 1922–1925
Preceded by	Robert Coryndon
Succeeded by	William Gowers
Governor-General of Sudan
In office 5 January 1925 – 6 July 1926
Preceded by	Lee Stack
Succeeded by	John Maffey
Personal details
Born	4 July 1882^[1] Kensington, London, England^[2]
Died	1 May 1964(1964-05-01) (aged 81) Cannes, France

From 1922 to 1925, Archer was appointed Governor of Uganda. He later served as Governor-General of the Anglo-Egyptian Sudan between 1925 and 1926. In the Sudan, Archer paid a formal but friendly visit to Abd al-Rahman al-Mahdi, son of the self-proclaimed Mahdi Muhammad Ahmad, whose forces had killed General Gordon in 1885. Abd al-Rahman was leader of the neo-Mahdists in Sudan. Archer was eventually forced to resign due to the resultant flap, and spent the remainder of his career organising salt works in India.

Early career

In 1901, the nineteen-year-old Archer joined his uncle Frederick John Jackson, the acting high commissioner in Uganda. His uncle sent him on an ornithological collecting trip the next year. He visited Lake Albert, the Semliki valley and the Rwenzori Mountains, discovering over twenty species and subspecies that had been previously unknown to science. He went to Baringo in 1904 where he conducted extensive surveys.^[3] Archer was almost tempted to become a professional big game hunter.^[4]

On the basis of his survey work, Archer was appointed District Commissioner of the Northern Frontier district in Kenya.^[4] The district was treated as a closed zone with little contact with the rest of Kenya. It was basically a buffer against the Ethiopians, and was not considered to have any other value.

In 1920, Archer said of northern Kenya: "There is only one way to treat the northern territories and that was to give them whatever protection one can under the British flag and otherwise leave them to their own customs. Anything else is certainly uneconomic".^[5]

Archer was able to supplement his District Commissioner salary by money earned from an annual elephant hunt. An official in his position was allowed to take two elephants per year, and the sale of their tusks could be worth several hundred pounds.^[4] Much later, when he introduced hunting stories into an address to the Royal Geographical Society, Archer was informed by the President that "gentlemen hunt only with the camera".^[6]

British Somaliland

Background

In 1913, Archer was appointed Acting Commissioner in British Somaliland, later becoming Governor from 1919 to 1922. He was also Commander in Chief of the forces in British Somaliland.^[3]

The Darawiish proclamation of independence letter posits a triumvirate with an emir, a Dhulbahante sultan and government.^[7] The emir was Muhammad Abdullah Hassan^[7] whilst Dhulbahante head was Diiriye Guure,^[8] and the government was called haroun.^[9] This triumvirate and their Darawiish forces had managed to successfully resist British troops in four consecutive expeditions sent out against them over a period of two decades. In 1919, the British government decided on a final push to quell the insurgency. However, the army was reluctant to undertake yet another drawn-out campaign. Archer proposed using air power as a way to reduce the cost of ground troops, a suggestion that was greeted with scorn by the military. However, in January 1920, a flight of RAF bombers attacked the Haroun's headquarters and nearby Dhulbahante garesas in Taleh. By mid-February, Somaliland Camel Corps troops, assisted by the King's African Rifles, rounded up the remaining Dervish forces. Abdullah Hassan retreated to the Ogaden region where he attempted to regroup for yet another counter-expedition. However, he died of influenza a few months later, effectively ending the insurgency.^[10]

On 5 June 1920, Archer was appointed Knight Commander of the Order of St Michael and St George.^[11][12]

While in British Somaliland, Archer collected 3,000 skins and 1,000 clutches of eggs. He discovered three new bird species and several new races. His collection and observations were basis for a later book on the birds of the region co-authored with Miss Eva Godman.^[3] In 1921, the Colonial Secretary Sir Winston Churchill called a conference in Cairo attended by experts on the Middle East. Sir Geoffrey Archer brought along two young lions who were being sent to the London Zoo. They broke loose at a reception held at the British residency and almost caught the pet stork that belonged to General Edmund Allenby, the high commissioner.^[13]

Taxation disconcertment

Main article: 1922 Burao Tax Revolt

In early 1922 the Protectorate authorities announced that they would impose a heavy tax on the people of Burao and initiate a programme of disarmament. This policy was proposed to raise much needed revenues to run the Somaliland Protectorate which was a net drain on Colonial Office coffers. As well to enhance British control in the interior of Somaliland after the Dervish War.^[14] As a result the people of Burao revolted and clashed with the British in opposition to the tax and this led to targeting of British government officials. In the ensuing disturbances a shootout between the British and Burao residents broke out, Captain Allan Gibb, a Somaliland Campaign veteran and district commissioner, was shot and killed after the Camel Corps refused to fire on the rioters.^[15]

After the incendiary bombardment and destruction of Burao, the leaders of the rebellion acquiesced, agreeing to pay a fine in livestock for Gibbs death but refused to identify and apprehend the individuals guilty. Most of the men responsible for Gibb's murder would evade capture. In light of the failure to peacefully implement taxation Governor Archer abandoned the policy altogether being a victory for the Somalis in the Protectorate.^[16][17][18] Governor Archer would soon be replaced after this blunder and policy in British Somaliland would be revised in light of this resistance.^[19]

1916 important members of haroun list

The 1916 British Intelligence Report diary from the Berbera colonial office of Geoffrey Archer, published a list of the most notable members of the Dervish haroun (government), the list being revised in 1917 and 1918. The list details two scores of names, including their position, their tribe, as well as a short annotation with miscellaneous information. Geoffrey Archer subdivides the majority of these Dervish leaders into advisors, natively called khusuusi, and commanders, natively called amaanduule. A small minority have other positions including governors, a logistics coordinator, and arbitrators natively called muqaddim. The two score of Dervish personalities listed by Archer rejects the notion that these Dervish leaders have a rank over one another, but rather that the position of one khusuusi was egalitarian to another khusuusi, and that of a muqaddim egalitarian to another Dervish muqaddim.^[20]

Generals

Dervish generals

Name	Tribe	Position
Cusman Boos	Bah Ali Gheri (Dhulbahante)	general / amaanduule
Xirsi Cartan	Jama Siad (Dhulbahante)	general / amaanduule
Xaashi Suni Fooyaan	Baharsame (Dhulbahante)	general / amaanduule
Samatar Bullalleh	Barkad (Dhulbahante)	general / amaanduule
Xirsi Bile	Arap (Hashim Reer Cali)	general / amaanduule
Cabbaas Muse	Baharsame (Dhulbahante)	general / amaanduule
Omar Tage	Baharsame (Dhulbahante)	general / amaanduule
Ali Geele Darwiish	Arap (Hashim Reer cali)	general / amaanduule
Haji Ahmed El Fiki	Hawiye	general / amaanduule
Mahdi Sayyid Mohamed	Ogaden	general / amaanduule
Osman Nur	Ogaden	general / amaanduule
Ibrahim Hassan Nur	Ogaden	general / amaanduule
Xandulle Dif	Bah Ali Gheri (Dhulbahante)	general / amaanduule
Xaashi Aadan Barre Chaatami	Ugaasyo (Dhulbahante)	general / ammaanduule
Ibrahim Galgol	Reer Jibril (Naleye Ahmed Dhulbahante)	general / ammaanduule
Liban Dugarri	Hamud Ugaas (Ugaasyo Dhulbahante)	general / ammaanduule
Cartan Mullo	Ogaden	general / ammaanduule
Warsame Ali Gulaydh	Ugaadhyahan (Dhulbahante)	general / ammaanduule

Statesmen

Dervish statesmen

Name	Tribe	Position
Abdirahman Ali Dis	Ogaden	statesman / khusuusi
Ahmed Warsame Sudi (Haji Sudi)	Adan Madoba (Habr Je'lo)	statesman / khusuusi
Ibrahim Boghol	Adan Madoba (Habr Je'lo)	statesman / khusuusi
Abdallah Shihiri	Adan Madoba (Habr Je'lo)	statesman / khusuusi
Deria Arale	Adan Madoba (Habr Je'lo)	statesman / khusuusi
Haji Yusuf Hassan	Habr Je'lo	statesman / khusuusi
Sadiq Arabi	Asharaf	statesman / khusuusi
Siad Sadiq	Arap	statesman / khusuusi
Duale Mire	Arap (Hashim Reer Ali)	statesman / khusuusi
Muse Ahmed	Arap (Hashim Reer Ali)	statesman / khusuusi
Haji Ali Adan	Arap (Abdale Arab)	statesman / khusuusi
Mohammud Hassan	Arap (Hashim Reer Ali)	statesman / khusuusi
Haji Ahmed	Hawiye	statesman / khusuusi
Haji Ahmed El Fiki	Hawiye	statesman / khusuusi
Obsiiye Seed	Bah Ali Gheri (Dhulbahante)	statesman / khusuusi
Diiriye Guure	Baharsame (Dhulbahante)	statesman / khusuusi
Maxmud Guure (sultan Diiriye Guure's brother)	Baharsame (Dhulbahante)	statesman / khusuusi
Jama Seed	Bah Ali Gheri (Dhulbahante)	statesman / khusuusi
Yusuf Hassan Nur	Ogaden	statesman / khusuusi
Abshir Dhoorre	Majeerteen	statesman / khusuusi
Sheikh Adan	Geri Koombe	statesman / khusuusi
Adan Cali	Ogaden	statesman / khusuusi

Miscellaneous

miscellaneous Dervish

Name	Tribe	Position
Cabdullaahi Aaden Oogle	Bah Ali Gheri (Dhulbahante)	first Somali doctor
Serar Shawe	Jama Siad (Dhulbahante)	geographic intelligencer / dalyaqaan
Cali Axmed Aaden Meggar	Ararsame (Dhulbahante)	cavalry + navy / fardaha + badmaax
Nuurxaashi Cali	Warsangeli	Jidali arbitrator / muqaddim Jidali
Xaaji Firxad	Hawiye	Abyssinian diplomat / danjire
Ismail Kharras	Warsangeli	logistics of Dhulbahante garesas
Hirsi Dihaal Halanje	Bahgeri Dhulbahante	Dervish spokesman-poet / abwaan-afhayeen
Mataan Cabdi	Ogaden	mentor / caalim
Cabbaas Xaaji Cabdiraxmaan Ghalal	Bahgeri Dhulbahante	Taleh governor
Siciid Jigrati	Majeerteen	mentor / caalim
Jama Yusuf Tamiinlaaye	Habr Awal	mentor / caalim
Musa Mahun	Bah Ali Gheri (Dhulbahante)	mentor / caalim

Uganda

Archer was appointed Governor of Uganda in 1923, and made his first priority the control of 19,000 highly destructive elephants in the colony.^[3]

He took an interest in education of the native people, asking for advice on the curriculum, buildings, organization and so on, although he was limited in what he could achieve by shortage of funds.^[21] Where he was deemed successful was in training Africans to replace European bureaucrats in several parts of the protectorate.^[22] Large portions of the governors staff were switched from British bureaucrats imported to do tasks to mission-educated Africans trained to do the same tasks. These became some of the most sought-after jobs in the Protectorate.^[23]

Archer founded a department of education in Uganda and appointed a director. However, due to doubts that the local Ugandans could handle higher education the establishment at Makerere Hill in Kampala only gave training for low-level clerical work. Archer himself wanted the locals to gain the higher education needed for senior positions so the administration would have to depend less on Indians.^[24]

Archer's theories of education were typical of the British colonial administration. He wrote: "For Native Administration the qualities of scholarship and academic attainment are not to be prized so highly as the leadership of men. Brilliance in debate can hardly equal the initial advantage gained in youth by having led in the field a body of well trained and disciplined young men of similar age". Archer disagreed with the idea that Africans were incapable of learning or doing certain jobs, he believed such views were "naive and bigoted." However, he also believed what the immediate economic concerns were could only be addressed with more specified job training to fill certain placements in the economy.^[25][26]

Governor-General of Sudan

Aged 42, Archer was selected for the post of Governor-General of Sudan in December 1924, the first time a civilian had held this office.^[27] He replaced Sir Lee Stack, who had been murdered.^[3] Archer travelled overland from Uganda to Sudan to take up his new appointment, walking from Nimule to Rejaf and then travelling by steamer down the Bahr al Jabal to Khartoum.^[28] Ceremonial etiquette was in flux. In Uganda Archer had travelled up-country by car informally dressed. In one district that he had not visited before the locals saluted his chauffeur, the only person in uniform.^[29] When Archer reached Khartoum in January 1925 he landed in frogged uniform, with sword and plumes, to be greeted on the quay by the members of his council in business suits.^[30]

In 1924, there had been a crisis in Egypt when a government hostile to the British was elected. Egyptian army units in Sudan, bound by their oath to the Egyptian king, refused to obey British orders and mutinied. The British violently suppressed the mutiny, removed the Egyptian army from the Sudan and purged the administration of Egyptian officials.^[31]

One of Archer's early decisions was to initiate the formation of the Sudan Defence Force, with a command completely separate from the Egyptian army. He dropped the Egyptian title "Sirdar" for the supreme commander, and did not wear the Egyptian tarboush. He made it very clear that he was commander in chief of a purely Sudanese army, while reassuring Sudanese officers who had served in the Egyptian army that they would be retained if they had not taken part in the mutiny.^[32]

In the aftermath of the upheaval the British saw educated Sudanese as potential propagators of "dangerous" nationalist ideas imported from Egypt.^[31] During Archer's tenure the main concern of the government was to reduce the power of the local intelligentsia and to transfer greater authority to traditional rulers.^[33] Archer did little about the issue of whether southern administration should be "Arabicized" or given a more English and Christian flavour.^[33] However, he deferred to Lord Lloyd, the British High Commissioner for Egypt and the Sudan, who stated in a memo to the Foreign Office that "on political, educational, religious, and administrative grounds it is desirable that Arabic as a general language should disappear from the Southern provinces".^[34] Archer was enthusiastic about the massive scheme to dam the Blue Nile at Sennar so as to irrigate the Gezira plain for cotton cultivation. He described the plan as the application of "western science to native economic conditions".^[35]

In March 1926, Archer ignored the advice of the Sudan Political Service and made an official visit to the Sayyid Abd al-Rahman al-Mahdi on Aba Island accompanied by a full escort of troops and officials. Abd al-Rahman was the son of the self-proclaimed Mahdi Muhammad Ahmad (1844–1885) and was leader of the Ansar movement.^[36] When Archer arrived on 14 February he was formally welcomed by Sayyid 'Abd al-Rahman with 1,500 Ansar supporters. Escorted by horsemen, the dignitaries went on by car to a reception at the Sayyid's house. Replying to a speech by the Sayyid, Archer said his visit marked "an important stage forward in the relations" between the Sayyid and his followers and the government. Archer said he had come to cement the ties of friendship and understanding.^[37] Archer's visit precipitated a crisis in the colonial administration. Archer was forced to resign, replaced by Sir John Maffey.^[36]

Later life and legacy

After leaving the Sudan, Archer spent most of the next fifteen years organizing the salt industry in Kutch, India.^[3] Archer settled in the south of France when he retired, dying at Cannes on 1 May 1964.^[3]

Archer made significant contributions to the study of birds and their breeding and migration habits in British East Africa, while considering a professional career as a big-game hunter.^[3][4]

In Uganda, Archer sought to employ indigenous residents for higher level clerical work so as to lessen the British administration's dependence on Indians for such activity. This represented something of a break from traditional protocol, as locals had hitherto mainly been recruited for low grade clerical work.^[24]

He was willing to work with the Mahdists, Britain's former enemies, and this open-minded attitude put an end to his career.^[36] Archer was a tall and imposing man, and had a forceful personality.^[38] A young man who met Archer in 1939 said of him: "When I talk to him I experience the feeling one gets when one walks out of a very stuffy room full of tobacco smoke into the open air and is greeted by a heavy buffeting wind, which pushes one back a step but which exhilarates and invigorates."^[39]

Archer's buzzard, Archer's lark (endemic to Somalia) and Archer's ground robin, a species in the Old World flycatcher family, carry Archer's name.

Books

• Sir Geoffrey Francis Archer and Eva M. Godman (1937). The Birds of British Somaliland and the Gulf of Aden: Their Life Histories, Breeding Habits and Eggs. London and Edinburgh.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
• Sir Geoffrey Archer (1963). Personal and Historical Memoirs of an East African Administrator. Edinburgh: Oliver and Boyd.

References

Footnotes

1. Dod's Peerage, Baronetage and Knightage, of Great Britain and Ireland, for ...: Including All the Titled Classes. S. Low, Marston & Company. 1923. p. 27. Retrieved 16 July 2017.
2. "Search Results for England & Wales Births 1837-2006 | findmypast.co.uk".
3. C.W.M.-P. 1964, pp. 260.
4. MacKenzie 1997, pp. 151–152.
5. Hansard 2009, pp. 38.
6. MacKenzie 1997, pp. 307.
7. Omar, Mohamed (2001). The Scramble in the Horn of Africa. p. 402. This letter is sent by all the Dervishes, the Amir, and all the Dolbahanta to the Ruler of Berbera ... We are a Government, we have a Sultan, an Amir, and Chiefs, and subjects ... (reply) In his last letter the Mullah pretends to speak in the name of the Dervishes, their Amir (himself), and the Dolbahanta tribes. This letter shows his object is to establish himself as the Ruler of the Dolbahanta
8. Spearce, Walter (August 1903). Somali Campaign. The third leader is Deeria Goori, of the Dolbahanta tribe, who was badly wounded at the Battle of Gunrburru ... These men are the heads of their respective tribes, and are all wealthy and powerful.
9. Official History of the Operations in Somaliland, 1901-04, page 319, year 1907 "The instructions to Kenna were "to endeavour by every means to locate the position of the Haroun, and having done so, to try and surprise it by long-distance marching with his mounted troops""
10. Hall 2008, pp. 19–20.
11. Chancery...
12. "No. 31931". The London Gazette (Supplement). 4 June 1920. p. 6317.
13. Seale 2011.
14. Millman, Brock (4 December 2013). British Somaliland: An Administrative History, 1920-1960. Routledge. ISBN 978-1-317-97543-4.
15. Millman, Brock (4 December 2013). British Somaliland: An Administrative History, 1920-1960. Routledge. ISBN 978-1-317-97543-4.
16. British Somaliland: An Administrative History, 1920-1960 pp.110
17. Jaques, Tony (2007). Dictionary of battles and sieges P-Z, p.991. Bloomsbury Academic. ISBN 9780313335396.
18. Correspondence between Governor of British Somaliland and Secretary of State for the Colonies. Colonial Office, 26 March 1922.
19. Millman, Brock (4 December 2013). British Somaliland: An Administrative History, 1920-1960. Routledge. ISBN 978-1-317-97543-4.
20. British intelligence report, 1916, PRO CO 535 / 47 ; followed by National Archives, PRO WO 106 / 23 ; for accessibility, see Imperialismo e resistenza in Corno d'Africa. Mohammed Abdullah Hassan e il derviscismo somalo (1899-1920), Gerardo Nicolosi, 2002, page 281
21. Whitehead 2003, pp. 173–174.
22. Whitehead 2003, pp. 175.
23. Whitehead 2003, pp. 176–177.
24. Frost 1992, pp. 86–87.
25. Cotton-growing in Sudan and Uganda: Sir Geoffrey Archer's Important Review of Developments by Sir Geoffrey F. Archer
26. Mangan 1992, pp. 189.
27. Ibrahim 2004, pp. 92.
28. Tvedt 2004, pp. 166.
29. Kirk-Greene 1978.
30. Daly & Hogan 2005, pp. 351.
31. Daly & Hogan 2005, pp. 28–29.
32. Al-Ahram 2001.
33. Collins 2005, pp. 275.
34. Collins 2005, pp. 277.
35. Bernal 1997, pp. 451.
36. Warburg 2003, pp. 90.
37. Daly 2004, pp. 337.
38. Spessartite Garnet.
39. Hartley 2003, pp. 143.

Bibliography

• Al-Ahram (8–14 February 2001). "The Sudan Defence Force". Al-Ahram Weekly Online (520). Retrieved 29 August 2011.
• Bernal, Victoria (1997). "Colonial Moral Economy and the Discipline of Development: The Gezira Scheme and "Modern" Sudan" (PDF). Cultural Anthropology. 12 (4): 447–479. doi:10.1525/can.1997.12.4.447. Retrieved 29 August 2011.
• "Chancery of the Order of Saint Michael and Saint George, Downing Street". Supplement to the London Gazette: 6317. 5 June 1920. Retrieved 29 August 2011.
• Collins, Robert O. (2005). Civil wars and revolution in the Sudan: essays on the Sudan, Southern Sudan and Darfur, 1962 - 2004. Tsehai Publishers. ISBN 978-0-9748198-7-7.
• C.W.M.-P. (1964). "Sir GEOFFREY ARCHER, K.C.M.G." Ibis. 107 (2): 260. doi:10.1111/j.1474-919X.1965.tb07307.x.
• Daly, M. W. (2004). Empire on the Nile: The Anglo-Egyptian Sudan, 1898-1934. Cambridge University Press. ISBN 978-0-521-89437-1.
• Daly, M. W.; Hogan, Jane (2005). Images of empire: photographic sources for the British in the Sudan. BRILL. ISBN 978-90-04-14627-3.
• Frost, Richard (1992). Enigmatic proconsul: Sir Philip Mitchell and the twilight of empire. The Radcliffe Press. ISBN 978-1-85043-525-9.
• Hall, David Ian (2008). Strategy for victory: the development of British tactical air power, 1919-1943. Greenwood Publishing Group. ISBN 978-0-275-97767-2.
• Hansard (12 August 2009). "Motion: Increase of Budgetary Allocation to Northern Kenya and Other Arid Lands". Kenya National Assembly Official Record (Hansard).
• Hartley, Aidan (2003). The Zanzibar chest: a story of life, love, and death in foreign lands. Atlantic Monthly Press. p. 143. ISBN 978-0-87113-871-2.
• Ibrahim, Hassan Ahmed (2004). Sayyid ʻAbd al-Raḥmān al-Mahdī: a study of neo-Mahdīsm in the Sudan, 1899-1956. BRILL. ISBN 978-90-04-13854-4.
• Kirk-Greene, Anthony H. M. (1978). "African Pro-consuls: European Governors in Africa". On Governorship and Governors in British Africa. New York: The Free Press/Collier Macmillan Publishers & Hoover Institution. Retrieved 2 September 2013.
• MacKenzie, John M. (1997). The empire of nature: hunting, conservation, and British imperialism. Manchester University Press ND. ISBN 978-0-7190-5227-9.
• Mangan, J. A. (1992). The Cultural bond: sport, empire, society. Routledge. ISBN 978-0-7146-3398-5.
• Seale, Patrick (26 August 2011). "A Line in the Sand". Financial Times. Retrieved 29 August 2011.
• "Spessartite Garnet". Swala Gem Traders. Retrieved 29 August 2011.
• Tvedt, Terje (2004). The Nile: an annotated bibliography. I.B.Tauris. ISBN 978-1-86064-879-3.
• Warburg, Gabriel (2003). "Sayyid 'Abd al-Rahman al-Mahdi, 1885 - 1959". Islam, sectarianism, and politics in Sudan since the Mahdiyya. Univ of Wisconsin Press. ISBN 978-0-299-18294-6.
• Whitehead, Clive (2003). Colonial educators: the British Indian and colonial education service 1858-1983. I.B.Tauris. ISBN 978-1-86064-864-9.