Vasily Grossman

Vasily Semyonovich Grossman (Russian: Васи́лий Семёнович Гро́ссман; 12 December (29 November, Julian calendar) 1905 – 14 September 1964) was a Soviet writer and journalist. Born to a Jewish family in Ukraine, then part of the Russian Empire, Grossman trained as a chemical engineer at Moscow State University, earning the nickname Vasya-khimik ("Vasya the Chemist") because of his diligence as a student. Upon graduation, he took a job in Stalino (now Donetsk) in the Donets Basin. In the 1930s he changed careers and began writing full-time, publishing a number of short stories and several novels.

Vasily Grossman
Grossman with the Red Army in Schwerin, Germany, 1945
Born	Iosif Solomonovich Grossman (1905-12-12)12 December 1905 Berdichev, Kiev Governorate, Russian Empire
Died	14 September 1964(1964-09-14) (aged 58) Moscow, Soviet Union
Occupation	Writer, journalist
Nationality	Soviet Union
Period	1934–1964
Subject	Soviet history World War II
Notable works	Life and Fate Everything Flows [de]
Spouse	Anna Petrovna Matsuk ​ ​ (m. 1928; div. 1933)​ Olga Mikhailovna ​ (m. 1936)​

At the outbreak of the Second World War, Grossman was engaged as a war correspondent by the Red Army newspaper Krasnaya Zvezda; he wrote first-hand accounts of the battles of Moscow, Stalingrad, Kursk, and Berlin. Grossman's eyewitness reports of a Nazi extermination camp, following the discovery of Treblinka, were among the earliest accounts of a Nazi death camp by a reporter.

There is some dispute over the extent of the state repression Grossman endured after the war. While he was never arrested, his two major literary works (Life and Fate and Everything Flows [de]) were censored by Nikita Khrushchev's government as unacceptably anti-Soviet. At the time of Grossman's death from stomach cancer in 1964, these books remained unreleased. Hidden copies were eventually smuggled out of the Soviet Union by a network of dissidents, including Andrei Sakharov and Vladimir Voinovich, and first published in the West in 1980, before appearing in the Soviet Union in 1988.

Early life and career

Born Iosif Solomonovich Grossman in Berdychiv, Ukraine, Russian Empire, into an emancipated Jewish family, he did not receive a traditional Jewish education. His father Semyon Osipovich Grossman was a chemical engineer, and his mother Yekaterina Savelievna was a teacher of French.^[1] A Russian nanny turned his name Yossya into Russian Vasya (a diminutive of Vasily), which was accepted by the whole family. His father had social-democratic convictions and joined the Mensheviks, and was active in the 1905 Revolution; he helped organise events in Sevastopol.^[2] From 1910 to 1912, he lived with his mother in Geneva after his parents had separated.^[1] After returning to Berdychiv in 1912, he moved to Kiev in 1914 where, while living with his father, he attended secondary school and later the Kiev Higher Institute of Soviet Education.^[2] Young Vasily Grossman idealistically supported the hope of the Russian Revolution of 1917.^[2]

In January 1928, Grossman married Anna Petrovna Matsuk; their daughter, named Yekaterina after Grossman's mother, was born two years later.^[2] When he had to move to Moscow, she refused to leave her job in Kiev, but in any case, she could not get a permit to stay in Moscow. When he moved to Stalino, she certainly did not want to go; she had started having affairs.^[1] Their daughter was sent to live with his mother in Berdychiv.

Grossman began writing short stories while studying chemical engineering at Moscow State University and later continued his literary activity while working running chemical tests at a coal-mining concern in Stalino in the Donbas, and later in a pencil factory.^[1] One of his first short stories, "In the Town of Berdichev" (В городе Бердичеве), drew favourable attention and encouragement from Maxim Gorky and Mikhail Bulgakov. The film Commissar (director Aleksandr Askoldov), made in 1967, suppressed by the KGB and released only in October 1990, is based on this four-page story.

In the mid-1930s Grossman left his job and committed himself fully to writing. By 1936 he had published two collections of stories and the novel Glyukauf, and in 1937 was accepted into the privileged Union of Writers. His novel Stepan Kol'chugin (published 1937-40) was nominated for a Stalin prize, but deleted from the list by Stalin himself for alleged Menshevik sympathies.^[3]

Grossman's first marriage ended in 1933, and in the summer of 1935 he began an affair with Olga Mikhailovna Guber, the wife of his friend, the writer Boris Guber. Grossman and Olga began living together in October 1935, and they married in May 1936, a few days after Olga and Boris Guber divorced. In 1937 during the Great Purge Boris Guber was arrested, and later Olga was also arrested for failing to denounce her previous husband as an "enemy of the people". Grossman quickly had himself registered as the official guardian of Olga's two sons by Boris Guber, thus saving them from being sent to orphanages. He then wrote to Nikolay Yezhov, the head of the NKVD, pointing out that Olga was now his wife, not Guber's, and that she should not be held responsible for a man from whom she had separated long before his arrest. Grossman's friend, Semyon Lipkin, commented, "In 1937 only a very brave man would have dared to write a letter like this to the State's chief executioner." Astonishingly, Olga Guber was released.^[4]

War reporter

 

Photo of Grossman published in Ogonyok (1941)

When Nazi Germany invaded the Soviet Union in 1941, Grossman's mother was trapped in Berdychiv by the invading German Army, and eventually murdered together with 20,000 to 30,000 other Jews who had not evacuated. Grossman was exempt from military service, but volunteered for the front, where he spent more than 1,000 days. He became a war correspondent for the popular Red Army newspaper Krasnaya Zvezda (Red Star). As the war raged on, he covered its major events, including the Battle of Moscow, the Battle of Stalingrad, the Battle of Kursk and the Battle of Berlin. In addition to war journalism, his novels (such as The People are Immortal (Народ бессмертен)) were published in newspapers and he came to be regarded as a legendary war hero. The novel Stalingrad (1950), later renamed For a Just Cause (За правое дело), is based on his experiences during the siege. A new English translation, with added material from Grossman's politically risky early drafts, was published in 2019 under the original title, Stalingrad.^[5] In December 2019 the book was the subject of the series Stalingrad: Destiny of a Novel in BBC Radio 4's Book of the Week.^[6]

Grossman described Nazi ethnic cleansing in German-occupied Ukraine and Poland and the liberation by the Red Army of the German Nazi Treblinka and Majdanek extermination camps. He collected some of the first eyewitness accounts—as early as 1943—of what later became known as the Holocaust. His article The Hell of Treblinka (1944) was disseminated at the Nuremberg Trials as evidence for the prosecution.^[7]

The Hell of Treblinka

Grossman interviewed former Sonderkommando inmates who escaped from Treblinka and wrote his manuscript without revealing their identities. He had access to materials already published.^[8] Grossman described Treblinka's operation in the first person.^[9] Of Josef Hirtreiter, the SS man who served at the reception zone of the Treblinka extermination camp during the arrival of transports, Grossman wrote:^[9]

This creature specialized in the killing of children. Evidently endowed with unusual strength, it would suddenly snatch a child out of the crowd, swing him or her about like a cudgel and then either smash their head against the ground or simply tear them in half. When I first heard about this creature—supposedly human, supposedly born of a woman—I could not believe the unthinkable things I was told. But when I heard these stories repeated by eyewitnesses, when I realized that these witnesses saw them as mere details, entirely in keeping with everything else about the hellish regime of Treblinka, then I came to believe that what I had heard was true".^[9]

Grossman's description of a physically unlikely method of killing a living human through tearing-by-hand originated from the 1944 memoir of the Treblinka revolt survivor Jankiel Wiernik, where the phrase to "tear the child in half" appeared for the first time. Wiernik himself never worked in the Auffanglager receiving area of the camp where Hirtreiter served, and so was repeating hearsay.^[10] But the narrative repetition reveals that such stories were retold routinely. Wiernik's memoir was published in Warsaw as a clandestine booklet before the war's end, and translated in 1945 as A Year in Treblinka.^[10] In his article, Grossman claimed that 3 million people had been killed at Treblinka, the highest estimate ever proposed, rather than the now widely-accepted 750,000 to 880,000; this was because of an error made by Grossman when he calculated the amount of trains that could arrive at the extermination camp each day.^[11]

Conflict with the Soviet government

Grossman participated in the compiling of the Black Book, a project of the Jewish Anti-Fascist Committee to document the crimes of the Holocaust. The post-war suppression of the Black Book by the Soviet state shook him to the core, and he began to question his own loyal support of the Soviet government. First the censors ordered changes in the text to conceal the specifically anti-Jewish character of the atrocities and to downplay the role of Ukrainians who worked with the Nazis as police. Then, in 1948, the Soviet edition of the book was scrapped completely. Semyon Lipkin wrote:

In 1946... I met some close friends, an Ingush and a Balkar, whose families had been deported to Kazakhstan during the war. I told Grossman and he said: "Maybe it was necessary for military reasons." I said: "...Would you say that if they did it to the Jews?" He said that could never happen. Some years later, a virulent article against cosmopolitanism appeared in Pravda. Grossman sent me a note saying I had been right after all. For years Grossman didn't feel very Jewish. The campaign against cosmopolitanism reawoke his Jewishness.

Grossman also criticized collectivization and political repression of peasants that led to the Holodomor tragedy. He wrote that "The decree about grain procurement required that the peasants of Ukraine, the Don and the Kuban be put to death by starvation, put to death along with their little children."^[12]

Because of state persecution, only a few of Grossman's post-war works were published during his lifetime. After he submitted for publication his magnum opus, the novel Life and Fate (Жизнь и судьба, 1959), the KGB raided his flat. The manuscripts, carbon copies, notebooks, as well as the typists' copies and even the typewriter ribbons were seized. It has been said by many, including Grossman's translator, Robert Chandler (see, for example his introduction to Life and Fate^[13] that the Politburo ideology chief Mikhail Suslov told Grossman that his book could not be published for two or three hundred years. However, Chandler and Yury Bit-Yunan, in Vasily Grossman: Myths and Counter-Myths, say that their research into the notes about that meeting of both Grossman and Suslov show that this was not the case, and in note 2 of that article, Chandler expresses regret for having made the claim.^[14]

Grossman wrote to Nikita Khrushchev: "What is the point of me being physically free when the book I dedicated my life to is arrested... I am not renouncing it... I am requesting freedom for my book." However, Life and Fate and his last major novel, Everything Flows (Все течет, 1961) were considered a threat to the Soviet power and remained unpublished. Grossman died in 1964, not knowing whether his greatest work would ever be read by the public.

Death

Grossman died of stomach cancer on 14 September 1964. He was buried at the Troyekurovskoye Cemetery on the edge of Moscow.

Legacy

 

Memorial plaque in Donetsk where Grossman worked in the early 1930s.

Life and Fate was first published in Russian in 1980^[5] in Switzerland, thanks to fellow dissidents: the physicist Andrei Sakharov secretly photographed draft pages preserved by Semyon Lipkin, and the writer Vladimir Voinovich smuggled the photographic films abroad. Two dissident researchers, professors and writers Efim Etkind and Shimon Markish, retyped the text from the microfilm, with some mistakes and misreadings due to the bad quality. The book was finally published in the Soviet Union in 1988 after the policy of glasnost was initiated by Mikhail Gorbachev. The text was published again in 1989 after further original manuscripts emerged after the first publication. Everything Flows was also published in the Soviet Union in 1989, and was republished in English with a new translation by Robert Chandler in 2009. Life and Fate was first published in English in 1985; a revised English translation by Robert Chandler was published in 2006 and widely praised, being described as "World War II's War and Peace.^[5]

Life and Fate is considered to be in part an autobiographical work. Robert Chandler wrote in his introduction to the Harvill edition that its leading character, Viktor Shtrum, "is a portrait of the author himself," reflecting in particular his anguish at the murder of his mother at the Berdichev Ghetto. Chapter 18, a letter from Shtrum's mother, Anna, has been dramatized for the stage and film as The Last Letter (2002), directed by Frederick Wiseman and starring Catherine Samie. Chandler suggests that aspects of the character and experience of Shtrum are based on the physicist Lev Landau. The late novel Everything Flows, in turn, is especially noted for its quiet, unforced, and yet horrifying condemnation of the Soviet totalitarian state: a work in which Grossman, liberated from worries about censors, spoke honestly about Soviet history.

Some critics have compared Grossman's novels to the work of Leo Tolstoy.^[15][16]

Publications

• Kolchugin's Youth: A Novel, translated by Rosemary Edmonds (1946). Hutchinsons International Authors Ltd.
• The People Immortal, translated by Elizabeth Donnelly (1943), Moscow, Foreign Languages Publishing House (published in U.S. as No Beautiful Nights, New York, J. Messner (1944) and in U.K. as The People Immortal, London: Hutchinson International Authors (1945)). A new translation by Robert and Elizabeth Chandler, including previously censored passages reinstated by Julia Volohova from Grossman's original typescript, was published in 2022 by NYRB Classics (US edition) and the MacLehose Press (UK edition).
• The Black Book: The Ruthless Murder of Jews by German-Fascist Invaders Throughout the Temporarily-Occupied Regions of the Soviet Union and in the Death Camps of Poland during the War 1941–1945. By Vasily Grossman and Ilya Ehrenburg (ISBN 0-89604-031-3)
• For a Just Cause (1956), originally titled Stalingrad. Published in the Soviet Union in Russian in 1952. English translation with additional material from Grossman's unpublished manuscripts by Robert and Elizabeth Chandler published under original name Stalingrad by New York Review Books, June 2019, ISBN 9781846555794.^[5]
• Life and Fate (1960) (ISBN 0-00-261454-5 - first English translation edition, other editions ISBN 0-09-950616-5; ISBN 1-59017-201-9; ISBN 1-86046-019-4) The novel was praised as a masterpiece in Chandler's 2006 translation.^[5]
• Forever Flowing (1972) (European Classics - ISBN 0-8101-1503-4) It was republished as Everything Flows, translated by Robert & Elizabeth Chandler (2010), Harvill Secker and New York Review Books (ISBN 978-1-59017-328-2).^[17]
• The Road: Stories, Journalism, and Essays, translated by Robert and Elizabeth Chandler with Olga Mukovnikova, commentary and notes by Robert Chandler with Yury Bit-Yunan, afterword by Fyodor Guber, New York, New York Review Books, 2010, ISBN 1-59017-361-9
• A Writer at War: Vasily Grossman with the Red Army, 1941-1945, edited and translated by Antony Beevor and Luba Vinogradova from Grossman's wartime notebooks. New York: Pantheon Books, 2005. ISBN 0-375-424-07-5. Also published as A Writer at War: A Soviet Journalist with the Red Army, 1941-1945. Vintage Canada. ISBN 978-0-307-36378-7.
• An Armenian Sketchbook (written in 1962). Translated by Robert Chandler. New York Review Books Classics, 2013, ISBN 1590176189.
• "In The War" and Other Stories. Translated by Andrew Glikin-Gusinsky. Sovlit.net
• (in Russian) Grossman's publications at lib.ru

See also

• History of the Soviet Union
• History of the Jews in Russia and Soviet Union
• History of the Jews in Ukraine
• Ilya Ehrenburg
• Varlam Shalamov
• Solomon Mikhoels
• Jewish Anti-Fascist Committee
• Doctors' plot
• Stalin and antisemitism
• Gulag
• Samizdat

Notes

1. "The Great Patriotic War, 1941-1945". Yale University. 25 October 2017. Retrieved 6 March 2018.
2. Grossman, Vasily (25 August 2011). The Road: Short Fiction and Essays (ebook). Translated by Chandler, Elizabeth; Chandler, Robert. London: MacLehose Press. pp. Introduction. ISBN 9781906694265.
3. Chandler, Robert. Introduction to Life and Fate, pages viii-ix. New York, NYRB Classics. 1985.
4. "Find in a library : The road : stories, journalism, and essays". www.worldcat.org.
5. Marcel Theroux (7 June 2019). "Stalingrad by Vasily Grossman review – the prequel to Life and Fate". The Guardian.
6. "BBC Radio 4 - Grossman's War, Stalingrad: Destiny of a Novel". BBC.
7. Василий Семенович Гроссман, Internet Archive. (in Russian). Brochure "Treblinka Hell" was passed from hand to hand at the Nuremberg Trials as a document of the indictment. Original: Брошюра "Треблинский ад" передавалась из рук в руки на Нюрнбергском процессе в качестве обвинительного документа.
8. Vasily Grossman, The Road: Stories, Journalism, and Essays with Commentary by Robert Chandler, New York Review of Books 2010, page 165. ISBN 1590174097.
9. Vasily Semenovich Grossman, The Road: Stories, Journalism, and Essays. Translated by Elizabeth Chandler and Olga Mukovnikova with contribution by Yury Bit-Yunan; edited by Robert Chandler, illustrated edition, New York Review Books 2010, page 101, ISBN 1590173619.
10. Yankel Wiernik (1945), A Year in Treblinka: An Inmate who Escaped Tells the Day-to-day Facts of One Year of His Torturous Experience (see scanned 1945 original in PDF format), New York: digitized by Zchor.org, OCLC 233992530, retrieved 25 April 2014, Complete text, 14 chapters; see: chapter 7 {{citation}}: External link in |type= (help)
11. Beevor, Antony (2006). A Writer at War: Vasily Grossman with the Red Army 1941-45. London: Pimlico. pp. 284–5. ISBN 978-1-4070-9201-0.
12. Robert Conquest (1986) The Harvest of Sorrow: Soviet Collectivization and the Terror-Famine. Oxford University Press. ISBN 0-19-505180-7.
13. Chandler, Robert. Life and Fate: Introduction. New York, New York Review of Books Classics, 1985.
14. Bit-Yunan, Yury; Chandler, Robert (13 November 2019). "Vasily Grossman: Myths and Counter-Myths". LA Review of Books. Retrieved 31 October 2021.
15. Tolstoy Studies Journal: Ellis, Frank. "Concepts of War in L.N. Tolstoy and V.S. Grossman." Volume II, 1989, pp. 101-108.
16. Biography of Grossman (PDF) by Gregory Freidin, Stanford University
17. Tayler, Christopher (22 May 2010). "Everything Flows by Vasily Grossman". The Guardian. Retrieved 18 September 2021.

Further reading

• The Bones of Berdichev: The Life and Fate of Vasily Grossman by John Gordon Garrard, Carol Garrard (ISBN 0-684-82295-4)
• The Life and Fate of Vasily Grossman by John Gordon Garrard and Carol Garrard (ISBN 178159001-X)
• Vasiliy Grossman: The Genesis and Evolution of a Russian Heretic by Frank Ellis (ISBN 0-85496-830-X)
• A Writer at War: Vasily Grossman with the Red Army, 1941-1945 by Antony Beevor and Lyuba Vinogradova (Pantheon, 2006 - ISBN 0-375-42407-5 ) - Based on Grossman's notebooks, war diaries, personal correspondence and articles.
• Between the Icon and the idol. The Human Person and the Modern State in Russian Literature and Thought - Chaadayev, Soloviev, Grossman by Artur Mrówczyński-Van Allen,(Cascade Books, /Theopolitical Visions/, Eugene, Or., 2013). ISBN 978-1-61097-816-3.
• The Myth of Stalingrad in Soviet Literature, 1942-1963 PhD Diss (University of Toronto, 2018) by Ian Garner
• Popoff, Alexandra. 2019. Vasily Grossman and the Soviet Century. Yale University Press.
• Vasily Grossman: Myths and Counter-Myths By Yury Bit-Yunan, Robert Chandler
• Vasily Grossman. A Writer’s Freedom. Edited by Bonola A.-Maddalena G., McGill-Queen’s University Press, Montreal, 2018
• G. Maddalena, Il pensiero di Vasilij Grossman, Rosenberg & Sellier, Torino, 2023

External links

 

Wikiquote has quotations related to Vasily Grossman.

• Study Center Vasily Grossman: Study Center Vasily Grossman (Italian/Russian)
• digital collection of works by and about the author (English, Russian and Italian)
• Grossman, Vasily in Grossman, Vasily, & Chandler, Robert & Chandler, Elizabeth & Mukovnikova, Olga. "The Hell of Treblinka". The Road: Stories, Journalism, and Essays.{{cite news}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
  • Full text in English, PDF^{[permanent dead link]}
• "Out of the Ruins of Stalingrad" March 2006
• (in Russian) Interview with Yekaterina Korotkova (Grossman)
• "Under Siege", from The New Yorker, March 6, 2006.
• (in Russian) "The one who said the forbidden words. To centennial anniversary of Vasily Grossman", an article in Zerkalo Nedeli (Mirror Weekly), Kiev, available online and .
• Chandler, Robert. "Vasily Grossman" (HTML) (PDF), Prospect, Issue 126, September 2006
• Eli Shaltiel: Eyewitness to hell (Ha'aretz, 30 October 2006)
• Introduction from Life and Fate
• (in Russian) (St. Vasily Who Did Not Believe in God) by Antonina Krishchenko. 20 September 2002
• Vasiliy Grossman at IMDb