Edward Arthur Milne

For other people named Edward Milne, see Edward Milne (disambiguation).

"Arthur Milne" redirects here. For the Scottish footballer, see Arthur Milne (footballer).

Edward Arthur Milne FRS^[1] (/mɪln/; 14 February 1896 – 21 September 1950) was a British astrophysicist and mathematician.^{[2][3][4][5][6]}

Arthur Milne
Born	(1896-02-14)14 February 1896 Kingston upon Hull, Yorkshire, England
Died	21 September 1950(1950-09-21) (aged 54) Dublin, Ireland
Alma mater	Trinity College, Cambridge
Known for	Milne model Degenerate stars
Scientific career
Institutions	Victoria University of Manchester University of Oxford
Doctoral students	Thomas Cowling

Biography

Milne was born in Hull, Yorkshire, England. He attended Hymers College and from there he won an open scholarship in mathematics and natural science to study at Trinity College, Cambridge in 1914, gaining the largest number of marks which had ever been awarded in the examination.^{[citation needed]} In 1916 he joined a group of mathematicians led by A. V. Hill for the Ministry of munitions working on the ballistics of anti-aircraft gunnery, they became known as ′Hill's Brigands′. Later Milne became an expert on sound localisation.^[7] In 1917 he became a lieutenant in the Royal Navy Volunteer Reserve. He was a fellow of Trinity College, Cambridge, 1919–1925, being assistant director of the solar physics observatory, 1920–1924, mathematical lecturer at Trinity, 1924–1925, and university lecturer in astrophysics, 1922–1925. He was Beyer professor of applied mathematics, Victoria University of Manchester, 1924–1928, before his appointment as Rouse Ball Professor of Mathematics and to a fellowship at Wadham College, Oxford, in 1928. Milne's earlier work was in mathematical astrophysics. Much of his research in the 1930s was concerned with the theory of relativity and cosmology. His later work, concerned with the interior structure of stars, aroused controversy. Milne was President of the Royal Astronomical Society, 1943–1945. During World War II he again worked on ballistics.

Milne married Margaret Scott Campbell on 26 June 1928 at Withington, Manchester. Campbell, from Dornoch, Sutherland, Scotland, was the daughter of Hugh Fraser Campbell, an advocate in Aberdeen. Milne's brother, Geoffrey, then a lecturer in agricultural chemistry at the University of Leeds, was best man.^[8] Margaret Scott Milne died on the 5 October 1938 at Oxford.^[9] He married secondly, Beatrice Brevoort Renwick, the third daughter of William Whetten Renwick, on 22 June 1940 at St Andrew's Church, Oxford.^[10][11] William Whetten was the nephew of American architect James Renwick Jr., and designed Saints Peter and Paul, a Roman Catholic cathedral in Indianapolis, Indiana, United States.^[12] Beatrice Brevoort Milne died at Oxford on 28 August 1945, aged just 32 years.^[13] Milne died of a heart attack in Dublin, Ireland, while preparing to give a set of lectures. These can be found written down in one of his last published books: Modern Cosmology and the Christian Idea of God (1952).

Research into stellar atmospheres and structure

In the 1920s much of Milne's research was concerned with stars, particularly the outer layers known as stellar atmospheres that produce the radiation observed from the Earth. He considered a grey atmosphere, a simplifying approximation in which the strength of the absorption of light by the hot ionized gas is the same at all wavelengths. This produced predictions of how temperature varies through the atmosphere, including the mathematical expression now known as the Milne Equation. He also calculated how the intensity of light from a star varies with wavelength on the basis of this model.^[14][15]

Milne moved on to consider the more realistic case where the strength of the absorption of light by gas within stars (expressed by the absorption coefficient) does vary with wavelength. Using simplifying assumptions he calculated how for the Sun the strength of the absorption depends on wavelength. His results could not be explained adequately at the time, but later negatively-charged hydrogen ions (H⁻) were shown to be a major contributor to Milne's results.^[15]

Milne, working with Ralph H. Fowler, studied how the strengths of spectral lines of stars depend on their spectral type. In doing this they applied the work of Meghnad Saha about the ionization of gases to stellar atmospheres.^[15]

Milne worked on the structures and interiors of stars in the late 1920s and early 1930s. He often took opinions opposed to those of Arthur Eddington.^[15]

Research into cosmology and relativity

From the early 1930s, Milne's interests focused increasingly on relativity theory and cosmology.^[16]

From 1932 he worked on the problem of the "expanding universe" and in Relativity, Gravitation, and World-Structure (1935), proposed an alternative to Albert Einstein's general relativity theory. With McCrea (1934) he also showed that the 3 models which form the foundations of modern cosmology first proposed by Friedmann (1922) using the general theory of relativity, can also be derived using only Newtonian mechanics.^[17]

Milne's alternative to general relativity theory based on kinematics was known as Kinematic Relativity. His theory was built on the special but not general theory of relativity. Because of this it has been described as a "nonrelativistic cosmology".^[18] Milne’s theory met with opposition from others but inspired the steady-state theorists.^[19]

Relativity, Gravitation, and World Structure

The main difference between the Milne model of an expanding universe, and the current (Einstein's) model of an expanding universe was that Milne did not assume a priori that the universe has a homogeneous matter distribution. He did not include the gravitation interaction into the model either.

Milne argued that under the context of Einstein's special relativity, and the relativity of simultaneity, that it is impossible for a nonstatic universe to be homogeneous. Namely, if the universe is spreading out, its density is decreasing over time, and that if two regions appeared to be at the same density at the same time to one observer, they would not appear to be the same density at the same time to another observer. However, if each observer measures its local density at the same agreed-upon proper time, the measured density should be the same. In Minkowskian coordinates, this constant proper time forms a hyperbolic surface which extends infinitely to the light-cone of the event of creation. This is true even when proper time approaches 0, the time of the creation. The universe is already infinite at the creation time!

Milne's model is, therefore, that of a sphere, with an approximately homogeneous matter distribution within several billion light years of the center which then increases to an infinite density. It can be shown that this infinite density is actually the density of the universe when at the time of the big bang. The spherical distribution is unique in that it is essentially the same after a Lorentz transformation, except that a different stationary particle is at the center. As it is the only distribution that has this property, it is the only distribution which could satisfy the cosmological principle of "no preferred reference frame." Based on this cosmological principle Milne created a model that can be described entirely within Euclidean geometry.

As of 1935, using this model, Milne published a prediction of the cosmic background radiation which appears to be of a much different character than that predicted by Eddington. In fact, many passages in Relativity, Gravitation and World Structure are devoted to attacking Eddington's preconceptions.

Religious views

Milne was a Christian theist.^[20][21] In 1950, Milne gave ten lectures on Christianity and cosmology for the Edward Cadbury lectures which he was invited to give at the University of Birmingham. The lectures were published in the book Modern Cosmology and the Christian Idea of God, edited by Gerald James Whitrow and published in 1952.^[20]

Milne was a theistic evolutionist who held the view that God intervenes with "deft touches" to steer mutations in the right direction.^[22]

Honours

Awards

• MBE (1918)
• Smith's Prize (1922)
• Gold Medal of the Royal Astronomical Society (1935)
• Royal Society's Royal Medal (1941)
• Bruce Medal (1945)

Named after him

• Milne, a crater on the Moon
• The E.A. Milne Centre for Astrophysics at the University of Hull (opened 2015)^[23]

Books by Milne

• Thermodynamics of the Stars, Berlin: J. Springer, 1930.
• The White Dwarf Stars, Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1932.
• Relativity, gravitation and world-structure, Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1935.
• The Inverse Square Law of Gravitation, London: Harrison and Son, 1936.
• The Fundamental Concepts of Natural Philosophy, Edinburgh: Oliver & Boyd, 1943.
• Kinematic relativity; a sequel to Relativity, gravitation and world structure, Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1948.
• Vectorial Mechanics, New York: Interscience Publishers, 1948.
• Modern Cosmology and the Christian Idea of God, Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1952.
• Sir James Jeans: A Biography, Cambridge University Press, 1952.

See also

• Alternatives to general relativity
• Herbert Dingle § Controversies
• List of science and religion scholars
• Blanketing effect
• Dirac large numbers hypothesis
• Milne's definition of local thermodynamic equilibrium
• Saha ionization equation

Notes

1. McCrea, W. H. (1951). "Edward Arthur Milne. 1896–1950". Obituary Notices of Fellows of the Royal Society. 7 (20): 420–426. doi:10.1098/rsbm.1951.0010. JSTOR 769028. S2CID 192057220.
2. O'Connor, John J.; Robertson, Edmund F., "Edward Arthur Milne", MacTutor History of Mathematics Archive, University of St Andrews
3. McCrea, W. H. (1951). "Edward Arthur Milne". Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society. 111 (2): 160–170. Bibcode:1951MNRAS.111R.160.. doi:10.1093/mnras/111.2.160a.
4. Plaskett, H. H. (1951). "Edward Arthur Milne". Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society. 111 (2): 170–172. Bibcode:1951MNRAS.111R.160.. doi:10.1093/mnras/111.2.160a.
5. McCrea, W. H. (1950). "Edward Arthur Milne". The Observatory. 70 (859): 225–232. Bibcode:1950Obs....70..225M. Retrieved 10 June 2016.
6. "Obituary: Edward Arthur Milne". Journal of the British Astronomical Association. 61 (3): 75–77. 1951. Bibcode:1951JBAA...61R..75. Retrieved 10 June 2016.
7. Van der Kloot, W.(2011). ″Mirrors and smoke: A. V. Hill, his brigands, and the science of anti-aircraft gunnery in world war I.″ Notes Rec. R. Soc. Lond. 65: 393–410.
8. "University Professor Weds". Leeds Mercury. Leeds. 27 June 1928. p. 5. OCLC 1016307518. Retrieved 13 August 2021 – via British Newspaper Archive.
9. "Deaths". Aberdeen Press and Journal. 10 October 1938. p. 1. ISSN 2632-1165. OCLC 271459455. Retrieved 13 August 2021 – via British Newspaper Archive.
10. "Forthcoming Marriages". The Times. No. 48643. 15 June 1940. p. 9. ISSN 0140-0460. Gale CS151729871.
11. "Marriages". The Times. No. 48651. 25 June 1940. p. 1. ISSN 0140-0460. Gale CS17118937.
12. Divita, James J. (1994). "General Entries". In Bodenhamer, David J.; et al. (eds.). The Encyclopedia of Indianapolis. Indianapolis: Indiana University Press. p. 1216. ISBN 978-0-253-31222-8. OCLC 940538156. from the original on 13 August 2021. Retrieved 13 August 2021 – via The Encyclopedia of Indianapolis.
13. "Deaths". The Times. No. 50234. 30 August 1945. p. 1. ISSN 0140-0460. Gale CS17252638.
14. Chandrasekhar, S. (1980). "The 1979 Milne Lecture – Edward Arthur Milne: His Part in the Development of Modern Astrophysics". Quarterly Journal of the Royal Astronomical Society. 21 (2): 93–107. Bibcode:1980QJRAS..21...93C. Retrieved 12 June 2016.
15. Tayler, R. J. (1996). "E. A. Milne (1896–1950) and the Structure of Stellar Atmospheres and Stellar Interiors". Quarterly Journal of the Royal Astronomical Society. 37 (3): 355–363. Bibcode:1996QJRAS..37..355T. Retrieved 12 June 2016.
16. Whitrow, G. J. (1996). "E. A. Milne and Cosmology". Quarterly Journal of the Royal Astronomical Society. 37 (3): 365–367. Bibcode:1996QJRAS..37..365W. Retrieved 12 June 2016.
17. McCrea, W. H.; Milne, E. A. (1934). "Newtonian universes and the curvature of space". Quarterly Journal of Mathematics. 5: 73–80. Bibcode:1934QJMat...5...73M. CiteSeerX 10.1.1.630.3318. doi:10.1093/qmath/os-5.1.73. This Newtonian derivation is sometimes incorrectly also ascribed to Friedmann.
18. Nye, Mary Jo. (2003). The Cambridge History of Science: Volume 5, The Modern Physical and Mathematical Sciences. Cambridge University Press. p. 529. ISBN 0-521-57243-6
19. Levy, Michael I. (2010). The Universe: A Historical Survey of Beliefs, Theories, and Laws. Britannica Educational Publishing. p. 185. ISBN 978-1-61530-055-6
20. McCrea, W. H. (1953). "Reviewed Work: Modern Cosmology and the Christian Idea of God by E. A. Milne". The Mathematical Gazette. 37 (370): 137–139. doi:10.2307/3608962. JSTOR 3608962.
21. Painter, Alfred W. (1953). "Reviewed Work: Modern Cosmology and the Christian Idea of God by E. A. Milne". The Journal of Religion. 33 (2): 156. doi:10.1086/484426.
22. Bowler, Peter J. (2001). Reconciling Science and Religion: The Debate in Early-Twentieth-Century Britain. University of Chicago Press. p. 413. ISBN 0-226-06858-7
23. "E.A. Milne Centre for Astrophysics, University of Hull – University of Hull".

References

• Beating the Odds: The Life and Times of E.A Milne by Meg Weston Smith, in June 2013. Published by World Scientific Publishing Co.
• Gale, George, "Cosmology: Methodological Debates in the 1930s and 1940s," Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Milne was a major player in the cosmological controversies described in this article.

Preceded by Sydney Chapman

Beyer Chair of Applied Mathematics at University of Manchester 1925–1928

Succeeded by Douglas Hartree