Digital dark age

The digital dark age is a lack of historical information in the digital age as a direct result of outdated file formats, software, or hardware that becomes corrupt, scarce, or inaccessible as technologies evolve and data decays.^[1] Future generations may find it difficult or impossible to retrieve electronic documents and multimedia, because they have been recorded in an obsolete and obscure file format, or on an obsolete physical medium; for example, floppy disks. The name derives from the term Dark Ages in the sense that there could be a relative lack of records in the digital age as documents are transferred to digital formats and original copies are lost. An early mention of the term was at a conference of the International Federation of Library Associations and Institutions (IFLA) in 1997.^[2] The term was also mentioned in 1998 at the Time and Bits conference,^[3][4] which was co-sponsored by the Long Now Foundation and the Getty Conservation Institute.

A computer terminal set up with a laserdisc containing information from the 1986 BBC Domesday Project. The original Domesday Book is 900 years old and still legible, while the laserdisc is already considered obsolete and difficult to read.

Proprietary and obsolete file formats

The problem is not limited to text documents, but applies equally to photos, video, audio and other kinds of electronic documents. One concern leading to the use of the term is that documents are stored on physical media which require special hardware in order to be read and that this hardware will not be available in a few decades from the time the document was created.

The digital dark age also applies to the problems which arise due to obsolete file formats. In such a case, it is the lack of necessary software which causes problems when retrieving stored documents. This is especially problematic when proprietary formats are used, in which case it might be impossible to write appropriate software to read the file.

Archiving the internet

The Internet Archive has stated that one of their goals is to prevent the digital dark age.^[5]

Vinton Cerf, Vice President of Google, showed his concerns about data preservation in the annual meeting of the American Association for the Advancement of Science in 2015: "As the way that we store information about ourselves develops, memories stored in files that use older technology are becoming harder to access. That could mean that historians of the future are unable to learn about our lives". His suggested solution consists of preserving a sample of every piece of software and hardware that has ever existed so that it never becomes obsolete. He proposed taking an X-ray snapshot of the content, the application and the operating system along with a description of the machine. This information should be then stored, instead of in a museum, in servers in the cloud.^[6]

Historical examples

A famous example is NASA, whose early space records have suffered from a dark age issue more than once. For over a decade, magnetic tapes from the 1976 Viking Mars landing were unprocessed. When later analyzed, the data was unreadable as it was in an unknown format and the original programmers had either died or left NASA. The images were eventually extracted following many months of puzzling through the data and examining how the recording machines functioned.^[7] The original Moon landing tapes were likely erased and reused, with the only video recordings of the Apollo 11 landings being later copies.^[8]

Another example is the BBC Domesday Project in which a survey of the nation was compiled 900 years after the Domesday Book was published. While the original Domesday Book of 1086 is still readable today, there were great fears that the discs of the 1986 Domesday Project would become unreadable as software and disk drives capable of reading the format became rarer and rarer. However, in 2002 the CAMiLEON project migrated the information to a system called DomesEm, allowing it to be accessed on modern computers.^[9] More recently, the Domesday86 Project has continued this preservation effort by developing a digitizer for the original LaserDiscs and emulation software for the original BBC Domesday computer system.

Encryption and data preservation

Encryption may exacerbate the problem of preserving data, since decoding adds complexity even when the relevant software is available.^[10] Historically, encrypted data is quite rare, but even the very simple means available throughout history have provided many examples of documents that can only be read with great effort. For example, it took the capacity of a distributed computing project to break the mechanically generated code of a single brief World War II submarine tactical message.^[11]

Open-source file formats

As more records are stored in digital form, there have been several measures to standardize electronic file formats so software to read them is widely available and can be re-implemented on new platforms if necessary.

PDF/A is an open standard based on Adobe Systems PDF format.^[12] It has been widely adopted by governments and archives around the world, such as the United Kingdom.^[13]

The Open Document Format for Office Applications (OpenDocument) has been standardized by OASIS in 2005, and by ISO in 2006. Since then, support for OpenDocument has been implemented in a large number of open-source and proprietary software. Therefore, using OpenDocument is one option for archiving editable documents from office applications. More broadly, the use of open-source software is a prevention measure.^[14] Since the source code for reading and writing a file format is open, the code can be used as a base for future implementations. In 2007, the chief information officer of the UK's National Archives stated "We welcome open-source software because it makes our lives easier".^[15]

Data storage standardization

In July 2007, Microsoft created a partnership with the UK's National Archives to prevent the digital dark age and "unlock millions of unreadable stored computer files".^[16][17][18] UK's National Archives now accepts various file formats for long-term preservation, including Office Open XML, PDF and OpenDocument.^[19]

Criticism

The notion of the digital dark age has been criticized by some scholars. Some of these, such as David Anderson and Jon Tilbury, view it as alarmist rhetoric, maintaining that the notion of a "dark age" incorrectly states the current condition. They argue that there has been significant progress in digital preservation and evidenced in the way organizations continue to find and reuse critical long-term digital information while finding new ways of sharing these with the public.^[20] Some historians also fault proponents of the digital dark age for historical inaccuracies. These include Marilyn Deegan and Simon Tanner's claim that the Gutenberg printing revolution led Europe out of the Dark Ages, a period said to be marked by the loss of knowledge of the learning of the ancient Greeks and Romans.^[21] It is argued that knowledge and information about classical learning had been recovered during the Middle Ages and it was not mainly due to the printing revolution but, instead, was largely a result of the intellectual exchange between Islamic and Christian cultures.^[22]

See also

• Abandonware
• Apollo 11 missing tapes
• Dark data
• Data archaeology
• Data corruption
• Data rot
• Digital continuity
• Digital obsolescence
• Digital preservation
• Disc rot
• Document Freedom Day
• M-DISC
• Lost media
• Open-source-software movement
• Orphaned works
• Software rot

References

1. Young, Lauren J. (15 December 2017). "Data Reawakening". Science Friday. Retrieved 1 March 2018.
2. Kuny, Terry (September 1997). "A Digital Dark Ages? Challenges in the Preservation of Electronic Prevention Information" (PDF). 63RD IFLA (International Federation of Library Associations and Institutions) Council and General Conference. (PDF) from the original on 9 May 2008. Retrieved 7 November 2011.
3. MacLean, Margaret (1999). MacLean, Margaret; Davis, Ben (eds.). Time and Bits, Managing Digital Continuity. Getty. ISBN 978-0-89236-583-8.
4. Brand, Stewart (1 February 1999). . Library Journal. 124 (2): 46–69. ISSN 0363-0277. Archived from the original on 23 September 2005.
5. "About the Internet Archive". from the original on 2 October 2013. Retrieved 5 October 2013.
6. Pallab, Ghosh (13 February 2015). "Google's Vint Cerf warns of 'digital Dark Age'". BBC News.
7. Blakeslee, Sandra (20 March 1990). "Lost on Earth: Wealth of Data Found in Space". The New York Times. from the original on 9 November 2012. Retrieved 7 July 2013.
8. . 3 July 2019. Archived from the original on 25 December 2019.
9. McKie, Robin; Thorpe, Vanessa (3 March 2002). "Digital Domesday Book lasts 15 years not 1000". The Observer. from the original on 20 January 2013.
10. Digital Preservation Coalition (2012). . Digital Preservation Handbook. Archived from the original on 29 July 2012. Retrieved 17 August 2013.
11. Wearden, Graeme (27 February 2006). "Distributed computing cracks Enigma code". CNET News. from the original on 10 August 2011.
12. . Adobe. 12 March 2013. Archived from the original on 7 July 2013. Retrieved 7 July 2013.
13. "Viewing government documents". GOV.UK. Cabinet Office. 6 August 2015. Retrieved 10 September 2015.
14. Cassia, Fernando (28 March 2007). . The Inquirer. Archived from the original on 20 January 2011. Retrieved 2 August 2012.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: unfit URL (link)
15. Donoghue, Andrew (19 July 2007). "Defending against the digital dark age". ZDNet. from the original on 23 October 2012.
16. Kennedy, Maev (4 July 2007). "National Archive project to avert digital dark age". The Guardian. from the original on 17 July 2010. Retrieved 7 October 2009.
17. Ferguson, Tim (5 July 2007). . Business Week. Archived from the original on 10 July 2007. Retrieved 7 October 2009.
18. Colvile, Robert (5 July 2007). "How to stave off a digital 'dark age'". The Telegraph. from the original on 24 April 2012. Retrieved 7 October 2009.
19. "File formats for transfer - The National Archives".
20. Harvey, Ross; Weatherburn, Jaye (2018). Preserving Digital Materials (Third ed.). Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield. p. 25. ISBN 9781538102961.
21. Weller, Toni (2013). History in the Digital Age. Oxon: Routledge. p. 58. ISBN 9780415666961.
22. Tredinnick, Luke (2008). Digital Information Culture: The Individual and Society in the Digital Age. Oxford: Chandos Publishing. p. 155. ISBN 9781843341703.

Further reading

• A Digital Dark Ages? Challenges in the Preservation of Electronic Information (PDF), 1997
• Coming Soon A Digital Dark Age - CBS News, 2003
• How huge quantities of data are rapidly falling into a black hole - Guardian Unlimited, 2003
• The digital Dark Age - The Sydney Morning Herald, 2005
• Bit Rot - The Economist, 28 April 2012
• "Raiders of the Lost Web", The Atlantic, USA, October 2015
• What If Digital Dark Age Is Real?, Pallav Gogoi, Dejavublog, 2016 11 April 2018 at the Wayback Machine
• Hansen, Kathleen A.; Paul, Nora (2017). Future-proofing the news : preserving the first draft of history. Rowman & Littlefield. ISBN 978-1-4422-6712-1. OCLC 961007777.

External videos
Digital Dark Age (Computer History Museum, 2011)