Tsui Po-ko

Tsui Po-ko (Chinese: 徐步高) (17 May 1970 – 17 March 2006) was a Police Constable of the Hong Kong Police Force, bank robber and serial killer. He is one of Hong Kong's most known serial killers.

Tsui Po-ko
Police Portrait of Tsui Po-ko, from the East Kowloon Regional Police Mobile Unit
Born	17 May 1970 Shaowu, Fujian, China
Died	17 March 2006(2006-03-17) (aged 35) Yau Tsim Mong District, Hong Kong
Cause of death	Gunshot wounds
Occupation	Police constable
Spouse	Lee Po-ling (1997–2006; his death)
Children	1 daughter
Call sign	PC53533
Criminal charge	Bank Robbery, Murder

In this Chinese name, the family name is Tsui.

Tsui Po-ko
Chinese	徐步高
Transcriptions Standard Mandarin Hanyu Pinyin Xú Bùgāo Yue: Cantonese Jyutping ceoi4 bou6 gou1

He was killed during an ambush on two Police Constables in a Tsim Sha Tsui subway which led to a shootout. The inquest into the events leading up to his death aroused great interest in Hong Kong, as it unravelled a string of intriguing events, and revealed the secret life of a policeman with a delusional state of mind.^[1] On 25 April 2007, the five-person jury in the coroner's court unanimously decided that Tsui was responsible for injuring one and killing two fellow police officers and a bank security guard, on three separate occasions. The jury returned a verdict that he had been "lawfully killed" by fellow officer Tsang Kwok-hang in a shootout.^[2] The inquest lasted 36 days, one of the longest ever inquests in Hong Kong.

Assistant Police Commissioner John Lee said that this was "an exceptional case",^[3] while Coroner Michael Chan Pik-kiu called it "the most difficult" inquest for a jury he had ever encountered.^[4]

Biography

Tsui was the elder of two children born in Shaowu, Fujian, and arrived in Hong Kong in 1978 with his mother. His father and brother arrived a year later. He attended the Kwun Tong Government Secondary Technical School (now Kwun Tong Kung Lok Government Secondary School). After graduation, he had several jobs, including a stint with the Royal Hong Kong Regiment.

Tsui joined the Royal Hong Kong Police in 1993; he regarded it as a well paid job with good benefits, and was a police constable for 13 years until his death in 2006.^[5] He was an outstanding cadet at the Hong Kong Police College, having won the "silver whistle".^[6]

Tsui was an excellent marksman, scoring full marks in target shooting and simulated bank robbery shooting in 1993. From 2001 to 2005, in the tests held three times a year, he scored a perfect 48 points. According to shooting range records, Tsui was a left-handed shooter but had also claimed that he was ambidextrous to a superior.^[7]

From 1996 to 2001, Tsui made four attempts at the 'Police Constable/Senior Police Constable to Sergeant Promotion Qualifying Examination',^[8] He scored 68 marks in his 2000 attempt which earned him an interview,^[9] but his stubbornness and difficulty in communication meant that he was never promoted,^[6] and had given up applying for promotion by 1999. From then on until 2003, Tsui applied three times to join the Airport Security Unit, but failed in every attempt. He failed a personality assessment during the first attempt, and subsequently failed because of insufficient fitness. Between 2002 and 2005, he was attached to the Tsing Yi district.

Tsui's wife, Lee Po-ling, worked at the Social Welfare Department as a social security assistant. The couple met when she worked as a sales assistant at the airport, and Tsui was also stationed there. They married in 1997 and had a daughter in 2000.^[10]

In October 2001, Tsui and his wife appeared together in a couples version of Who Wants to Be a Millionaire? on ATV and won HK$60,000 and stated that they would donate some of the money to charity.^[11]

Tsui was an avid sportsman and Oxfam Trailwalker, and was known to participate in marathons and paragliding. Unbeknownst to his wife, he would also frequent massage parlours, karaoke bars, and prostitutes in Mong Kok and Shenzhen.^[12] Tsui was a habitual heavy gambler and was known to have made a HK$75,000 wager on Japan to win the 2004 Asian Cup final at odds of 2.8:1 on 7 August 2004.^[13]

Murder of Police Constable Leung Shing-yan

In March 2001, Tsui murdered constable Leung Shing-yan (Chinese: 梁成恩) and stole his revolver.^[4] The 24-year-old Leung, who was engaged, had been on the force for five years.^[14][15]

At 12:05 on 14 March 2001, the Lei Muk Shue Police Station received a call regarding a noise complaint from a flat at Shek Wai Kok Estate. Leung responded to the call alone as his partner was still having lunch.^[15] His final radio call was received at 12:25 when he reported that he had arrived at the flat and nobody was responding to his knocks.^[15] He was subsequently attacked, struggling with his assailant to prevent his revolver being snatched, but was shot five times at close range.^[14][16] Leung took three bullets in the head and two in the back at Flat 552, Shek To House Block B.^[6] Under police guard, paramedics wearing bulletproof vests rushed Leung to Yan Chai Hospital where he was declared deceased upon arrival.^[15] His revolver, a fully loaded Smith & Wesson Model 10 4 Inch heavy barrel type revolver, a speedloader, loaded with six "Calibre 38Spl" bullets were missing.^[14]

The noise complaint was likely bogus and was made from an burner phone. The police suspected that the officer was lured to the scene for his firearm.^[14] Heavily armed police locked down the building and mounted a search.^[15] Some 3,000 people, of which 2,000 were police officers, were interviewed by the police but the perpetrator escaped detection.^[17] Later, forensic tests found that the DNA on a mask left at the crime scene matched Tsui's.^[18]

Leung is survived by his parents and a younger brother and sister.^[14] His wedding with Cheng Ling-chi was scheduled to have been held in May. His funeral in Hung Hom was attended by top officials including Chief Executive Tung Chee-hwa and Police Commissioner Tsang Yam-pui. Leung was buried at Gallant Garden.^[19] In 2002, he was posthumously awarded the Medal for Bravery (Silver) in recognition of his courage and "gallantry of an extremely high order".^[16][20]

Bank robbery

On 5 December 2001, Tsui carried out an armed bank robbery of the Hang Seng Bank branch at Belvedere Garden in Tsuen Wan.^[6]

At 12:10, masked and alone, he burst into the bank. Security Guard Zafar Iqbal Khan, aged 31, struggled with the man. Khan was shot three times in the head, body and wrist. Khan cocked his Remington shotgun during the robbery after being shot twice, but did not manage to fire before his death.^[21][22][23] Tsui fled the bank with HK$490,000 and US$1,000,^[22] entering Cassie Hill Road and then into the Belvedere Garden shopping arcade before escaping through another exit. Police entered the shopping arcade and launched a manhunt but failed to catch the suspect.^[22]

The police located several domestic helpers who witnessed the robber removing his balaclava following the robbery and produced a facial composite image of the suspect.^[24]

The perpetrator was described as a man with short hair and about 1.8 m tall, whom Assistant Police Commissioner Yam described as a "calm, cold-blooded and brutal robber". A HK$2 million reward was issued.^[25] Immediately following the robbery the police noted that the murder weapon appeared to be a police service revolver.^[22] It was later discovered that Tsui matched the description of the perpetrator as captured on closed circuit television; key pieces of evidence were a red T-shirt, Mizuno brand shoes^[6] and the fact that footage showed the killer to be a left-handed gunman. He was placed near the scene by the police; Tsui boarded a bus from Cheung Shun in Kwai Chung at 11:11 using an Octopus card issued to his wife; and boarded a minibus bound for Tsung Kwan at 11:53.^[23] A red T-shirt carrying a similar distinctive logo as captured on CCTV was found at Tsui's home after his death. The T-shirt, bearing the logo of the Yinchuan International Motor-cycle Travel Festival was a gift to Tsui by the club secretary during his visit to the show in 2000. An expert witness identified the T-shirt as having been worn inside-out during the robbery.^[26] Forensic ballistics later identified the gun used in the robbery as the police service revolver taken from police officer Leung Shing-yan in 2001.^[6]

Zafar Iqbal Khan is survived by four children and wife, who lived in Pakistan at the time of his death.^[22] A ceremony attended by his relatives, friends and bank chairman Vincent Cheng was held at the Kowloon Masjid and Islamic Centre on 7 December before his body was returned to Pakistan later in the day.^[21] Khan was posthumously awarded the Medal for Bravery (Gold) for "selfless bravery of the highest order", which was accepted on his behalf by his wife.^[16][27][20]

Financial irregularities

An investigation by the Criminal Intelligence Bureau into Tsui's financial status from January 2000 to March 2006 revealed he had a total of 19 personal banking and investment accounts hidden from his wife, the total assets of which amounted to a total of HK$2,977,513.^[28] Seven personal and 12 investment accounts were opened under his name around mid-February in 2002 using a friend's address. Between February 2002 and October 2004, Tsui deposited HK$557,718 into the 19 accounts. All transactions were in cash.^[28] It was reported that Tsui was active in foreign exchange market, commodities, securities, funds, and margin trading, and had lost a total of HK$371,982 in those investments.^[28]

Tsui and his wife bought one flat in August 1997 and paid HK$574,800 in cash.^[28] Two years later, he bought a flat at Tung Chung Crescent with a HK$396,173 down payment, paying monthly installments of HK$17,778 for a first and a second mortgage. The mortgages were paid off in just five years, with HK$388,151 in 2001 and HK$500,000 in 2004.^[28]

The police alleged that the transactions were inconsistent with a constable's salary and that the HK$500,000 in unexplained cash would be consistent with the amount stolen during the heist in 2001.^[28]

Ambush of Constable Wilson Sin and Constable Tsang Kwok-hang

 

The pedestrian subway where the ambush and shootout took place

See also: 徐步高槍擊案

At 11pm on 16 March 2006, Police Constable Wilson Sin Ka-keung of the Tsim Sha Tsui Divisional Patrol Team 1 and Police Constable Tsang Kwok-hang, who had been transferred from the Kowloon City Police District a week earlier, arrived at the Hitchin Regal Ferry Pier in a police car after a 15-minute training session at the Tsim Sha Tsui Police Station and started their patrol, they then passed through the pedestrian subway (the scene of the crime), turned right and returned to Battersea Road Middle School. On the way, they stopped and questioned a man near Hinckley Road, who was subsequently cleared and released.^[29]

On 17 March 2006, 28-year-old Constable Wilson Sin Ka-keung (Chinese: 冼家強) and 33-year-old Constable Tsang Kwok-hang (Chinese: 曾國恒) were ambushed by Tsui while on patrol in the pedestrian subway connecting Austin Road and Canton Road between the areas of Tsim Sha Tsui and Kwun Chung. Constable Sin reported seeing Tsui lurking on the northern stairs of the subway and attempted to approach him. When the officers approached, Tsui fired upon both officers, striking Sin in the head and left leg and mortally wounding Tsang in the head. Sin and Tsang returned fire, with Sin missing 2 shots while Tsang hit Tsui with 5 shots to the torso and head, killing him after arrival at Queen Elizabeth Hospital. Tsang would re-holster his revolver and radio for help before succumbing to his wounds at the same hospital, while Sin would survive the incident.^[3] The revolver used by Tsui in the shootout was confirmed to be the service revolver taken from Constable Leung and used in the heist in 2001.^[17]

The Force held a funeral service for Tsang on 4 April 2006 at the World Funeral Parlour, Hung Hom, with the body buried at Wyant Garden, Wo Hop Shek immediately after the service.

Constable Sin was awarded the Medal for Bravery (Gold) for his actions and wrote a book about his experience.^[30][31]

Mental state

As the inquiry continued, Tsui was found to be an ambitious officer who often topped his class and did well in assessments. However, he was often denied promotions or opportunities to join elite units such as the Airport Security Unit.^[32]

He was not media shy, as shown demonstrated by his appearance on Who Wants to Be a Millionaire? and was happily photographed when he won the chance to buy his flat in a draw and during the 1 July March in 2004 where he was dressed in traditional Chinese funeral style clothing ("披麻戴孝").^[33]

An associate professor of social science at the City University of Hong Kong suggested that Tsui, like many criminals, did not know how to face frustration, and chose instead to take an illegal path in obtaining socially approved goals, such as money, prestige or recognition. It was suggested that the police force should pay more attention to talented officers who fail to gain promotion, and recommended that there should be independent and confidential psychological counselling services for such troubled or frustrated officers.^[4]

A Federal Bureau of Investigation criminal profiler believed that Tsui's behaviour fit into most of the definitions of schizotypal personality disorder, while an expert from the Queensland University of Technology said Tsui's personality profile matched that of a serial killer who believed he was destined to change the world, attempting to rise above his self-perceived unremarkable life and playing God by taking lives.^[6]

Legacy

The Tsui Po-ko case has inspired some film and television productions, including:

Documentaries

• Anatomy of a Crime: "HK's Rogue Cop"^[34][35]

Fiction

• Mad Detective, a 2007 film
• A Great Way to Care 《仁心解碼》, a 2009 TVB series
• The Men of Justice, a 2010 ATV series^[36]
• Shades of Rogue, a 2014 short film

References

1. Hong Kong nears end of lurid murder case (AFP), The Nation, April 2007. Retrieved 7 July 2007
2. AFP story, Hong Kong policeman blamed for killings, Channel NewsAsia, 25 April 2007
3. Andrea Chiu, Rogue cop planned ambush, say police 4 June 2011 at the Wayback Machine, The Standard, 21 March 2006
4. Una So, Tsui killed two officers and guard, jury finds 4 June 2011 at the Wayback Machine, The Standard, 26 April 2007
5. "Hong Kong 'devil cop' kills colleagues", Brisbane Times, 25 April 2007
6. Una So, Slain officer's path of no return 4 June 2011 at the Wayback Machine, The Standard, 7 April 2007
7. "Ambidextrous marksman Tsui played the markets with proxy address" 29 September 2007 at the Wayback Machine, Sing Tao Daily, 27 March 2007 (in Chinese)
8. In 1996, Tsui gained a "Credit"；a "Pass" in 1999；a "Distinction" in 2000 and "Great Credit" in 2001 「徐步高仕途受挫現怪行 狂抄「牛肉乾」 羅湖橋呼『平反六四』」, Ming Pao, 27 March 2007 (in Chinese)
9. "Diligent duo net exam distinctions", "OffBeat-News", 22 November 2000
10. Una So, Wife knew nothing of Tsui's dark side 4 June 2011 at the Wayback Machine, The Standard, 18 April 2007
11. '"Millionaire" couple wins 60k who said will donate to charity kills 2 months later', The Sun, 21 March 2006
12. 徐步高的生前好友，前警員李藝在庭上作供指出，兩人在1999年至2005年間多次相約到內地嫖妓，每次開支約500 元；兩人亦定期光顧旺角花園街一間娛樂場所，平均每月約1至2次。 "Good friend reveals Tsui's penchant for gambling and prostitutes, weekly visits to Mong Kok and Shenzhen from 1999"、Ming Pao, 24 March 2007 (in Chinese)
13. 徐 步高的生前好友，前警員李藝在庭上作供指出，在本地賭波未合法化的2002年，徐步高曾主動向他詢問世界盃決賽外圍投注的方法，並表示要投注5萬元，李遂建議徐向澳門投注。兩人於2004年亞洲盃的決賽賽事贏得22.4萬元，對於徐步高突然有大 筆現鈔投注賭波，李藝稱當時沒主動問及，並相信是徐平日投資或積蓄所得。"$75,000 Asian Cup bet repays $210,000", Ming Pao, 24 March 2007 (in Chinese)
14. Matthew Lee and Eddie Luk, Officer 'lured to his death' 4 June 2011 at the Wayback Machine, The Standard, 15 March 2001
15. Lo, Clifford (15 March 2001). "Officer lured to his death: Massive manhunt launched as constable killed in Tsuen Wan housing estate after bogus call". South China Morning Post. p. 1.
16. Joanilho, Marcal; Ma, Raymond (30 June 2002). "Bravery awards for fallen heroes". South China Morning Post. p. 4.
17. Tsui eluded suspicion in Leung case 4 June 2011 at the Wayback Machine, The Standard, 21 March 2006
18. Government pathologist Pang Chi-ming gave the probability of another person with matching DNA as 1:1.4 billion. "DNA match to Tsui on mask found in Shek To House shooting" Ming Pao 4 April，2007 (in Chinese)
19. Lee, Stella; Lewis, Tommy (27 March 2001). "Suspect in constable's killing arrested on day of funeral". South China Morning Post. p. 1.
20. "2002 Honours List". Hong Kong Government. 30 June 2002.
21. Lo, Clifford (8 December 2001). "Death stirs debate over armed guards". South China Morning Post. p. 7.
22. Lo, Clifford (6 December 2001). "Guard killed in $.5m bank raid". South China Morning Post. p. 1.
23. Una So, Octopus card pieces together Tsui's movements 4 June 2011 at the Wayback Machine, The Standard, 13 April 2007
24. Lo, Clifford (7 December 2001). "Bank guard's murder condemned". South China Morning Post. p. 3.
25. Eddie Luk, $2m reward for bank killer info 4 June 2011 at the Wayback Machine, The Standard, 12 December 2001
26. 「徐步高神秘紅衣寧夏尋源 三角標誌與劫匪紅衣相似 警千里追查」《明報》，2007年3月15日
27. "Chief Executive presents honours and awards". Hong Kong Government. 12 October 2002.
28. Una So, Slain cop had assets worth nearly $3m 4 June 2011 at the Wayback Machine, The Standard, 11 April 2007
29. 「冼家強中彈還擊 奪槍生死戰」 2007-03-20 at the Wayback Machine《太陽報》，2007年3月17日
30. http://www.police.gov.hk/offbeat/1011/eng/1303.html
31. "Policeman who survived sensational 2006 'devil cop' shoot-out launches book". 28 February 2014.
32. Slain officer had major ambitions, The Standard, 27 March 2007 21 July 2011 at the Wayback Machine
33. 'High profile participation in march as a challenge to the Government' (Article with photo), The Sun，22 March 2006. Retrieved 7 July 2007
34. . Archived from the original on 15 August 2011. Retrieved 30 April 2011.
35. . Archived from the original on 6 October 2011. Retrieved 30 April 2011.
36. "The Men of Justice".