Who Goes There?

For the collection containing this story and named after it, see Who Goes There? (collection).

Who Goes There? is a 1938 science fiction horror novella by American author John W. Campbell, written under the pen name Don A. Stuart. Its story follows a group of people trapped in a scientific outpost in Antarctica infested by shapeshifting monsters able to absorb and perfectly imitate any living being, including humans. Who Goes There? was first published in the August 1938 issue of Astounding Science Fiction magazine and was also printed as The Thing from Another World, as well as included in the collection by the same title. Its extended, novel version, found in an early manuscript titled Frozen Hell, was finally published in 2019.

Who Goes There?

Author	John W. Campbell Jr.
Country	United States
Language	English
Genre	Science fiction, horror
Publication date	August 1938
Media type	Novella

Who Goes There? has been directly adapted to film in 1951 as The Thing from Another World, by Christian Nyby, and again in 1982 as The Thing, by John Carpenter. The story's many other adaptations, and works inspired by it, have spanned various media.

Publication history

Two slightly different versions of the original novella exist. It was first published in the August 1938 issue of Astounding Science Fiction in a 12-chapter version, which also appears in Adventures in Time and Space and The Antarktos Cycle: Horror and Wonder at the Ends of the Earth (under the title The Thing from Another World). An extended 14-chapter version was later included in The Best of John W. Campbell and the collection Who Goes There?. In 1973, the story was voted by the Science Fiction Writers of America as one of the stories representing the "most influential, important, and memorable science fiction that has ever been written." It was promptly published with the other top voted stories in The Science Fiction Hall of Fame, Volume Two.^[1]

In 2018, it was discovered that Who Goes There? was actually a shortened version of a larger novel previously written by Campbell. The expanded manuscript including an entirely different opening, titled Frozen Hell (another working title was Pandora^[2]), was found in a box of manuscripts sent by Campbell to Harvard University. The discovery was made by author and biographer Alec Nevala-Lee, during his research on a biography of Campbell and other authors from the Golden Age of Science Fiction.^[3] Campbell first attempted selling the story to Argosy, but was rejected by its editor John "Jack" Francis Byrne. After some rewriting and significant trimming, it was eventually accepted by Astounding's editor F. Orlin Tremaine.^[4] A Kickstarter campaign was launched to publish the full novel that same year.^[5] When completed on December 1, the campaign had raised more than $155,000, compared to its original $1,000 goal.^[6] An edited version of the two original drafts was published by Wildside Press under the full title Frozen Hell: The Book That Inspired The Thing, illustrated by Bob Eggleton and with a preface by Nevala-Lee and an introduction by Robert Silverberg. E-book versions of the novel began distributing digitally to campaign backers on January 16, 2019, with physical copies following in June the same year.^[7][8]

Plot

A group of American researchers, isolated in their scientific station in Antarctica towards the end of winter, discover an alien spaceship buried in the ice, where it crashed twenty million years before. They try to thaw the inside of the spacecraft with a thermite charge but end up accidentally destroying it when the ship's magnesium hull is ignited by the charge. They do recover an alien creature from the ancient ice, which the researchers believe was searching for heat when it was frozen. Thawing revives the alien, a being which can assume the appearance, memories, and personality of a living thing it devours, while maintaining its body mass for further reproduction. Unknown to them, the alien immediately kills and then imitates the crew's physicist, a man named Connant; with some 90 pounds of its matter left over, it tries to become a sled dog. The crew discovers the dog-Thing and kills it midway through the transformation process. Pathologist Blair, who had lobbied for thawing the Thing, goes insane with paranoia and guilt, vowing to kill everyone at the base to save mankind; he is isolated within a locked cabin at their outpost. Connant is also isolated as a precaution, and a "rule-of-four" is initiated in which all personnel must remain under the close scrutiny of three others.

The crew realizes that they must isolate their base and therefore disable their airplanes and vehicles, yet they pretend that everything is normal during radio transmissions, to prevent any rescue attempts. The researchers try to figure out who may have been replaced by the alien (simply referred to as the Thing), to destroy the imitations before they can escape and take over the world. The task is found to be almost impossibly difficult when they realize that the Thing is shapeshifting and telepathic, reading minds and projecting thoughts. A sled dog is conditioned by human blood injections (from Copper and Garry) to provide a human-immunity serum test, as in rabbits. The initial test of Connant is inconclusive, as they realize that the test animal received both human and alien blood, meaning that either Doctor Copper or expedition Commander Garry is an alien. Assistant commander McReady takes over and deduces that all the other animals at the station, save the test dog, have already become imitations; all are killed by electrocution and their corpses burned.

Everyone suspects each other by now but must stay together for safety, deciding who will take turns sleeping and standing watch. Tensions mount and some men begin to go mad, thinking that they are already the last human, or wondering if they could know if they were not human any longer. Ultimately, Kinner, the cook, is murdered and accidentally revealed to be a Thing. McReady realizes that even small pieces of the creature will behave as independent organisms. He then uses this fact to test which men have been "converted" by taking blood samples from everyone and dipping a heated wire in the vial of blood. Each man's blood is tested, one at a time, and the donor is immediately killed if his blood recoils from the wire. Fourteen men, including Connant and Garry, are revealed to be Things. The remaining men go to test the isolated Blair, and on the way, see the first albatross of the Antarctic spring flying overhead; they shoot the bird to prevent a Thing from infecting it and flying to civilization.

When they reach Blair's cabin, they discover that he is a Thing. They realize that it has been left to its own devices for a week, coming and going as it pleased, as it is able to squeeze under doors by transforming itself. With the creatures inside the base destroyed, McReady and two others enter the cabin to kill the Thing that was once Blair. McReady forces it out into the snow and destroys it with a blowtorch. Afterwards, the trio discover that the Thing was dangerously close to finishing the construction of a nuclear-powered anti-gravity device that would have allowed it to escape to the outside world.

Characters

Humans

Although the expedition based at Big Magnet comprises 37 members, only 16 are named in the story, and all but three by last name alone. By the end of the story, 15 of them have been replaced by alien impostors.

• Barclay: present at alien excavation.
• Benning: aviation mechanic. He survives. He appears in the 1982 adaptation renamed George Bennings with the occupation of meteorologist, and is portrayed by Peter Maloney.
• Blair: biologist, present at alien excavation. Blair goes insane after the Thing escapes, due to his desire to thaw the Thing. Blair is locked in the tool shed, where he is replaced by a Thing. Blair appears in the 1982 adaptation portrayed by A. Wilford Brimley.
• (Bart) Caldwell: a member of the team.
• Clark: dog handler. Clark is later revealed to be a Thing. He appears in the 1982 adaptation, played by Richard Masur.
• Connant: physicist, cosmic ray specialist. He is the first member of the team to be assimilated. In Frozen Hell, he is given the first name Jerry.
• Dr. Copper: physician, present at the alien excavation. Copper appears in the 1982 adaptation portrayed by Richard Dysart.
• (Samuel) Dutton: revealed to be a Thing.
• Garry: expedition commander. Garry is eventually revealed as a Thing and killed. Garry appears in the 1982 adaptation portrayed by Donald Moffat.
• Kinner: scar-faced cook. Kinner is later revealed to be a Thing.
• McReady: expedition second-in-command, meteorologist, present at alien excavation. McReady appears in the 1982 adaptation portrayed by Kurt Russell, now with the name "R.J. MacReady" and the occupation of the helicopter pilot. MacReady reappears in the video game played by Russell and in the comics based on the film.
• (Vance) Norris: muscular physicist. Norris appears in the 1982 adaptation portrayed by Charles Hallahan, though he is given Kinner's fate and much of Kinner's characterization.
• Pomroy: livestock handler.
• Ralsen: sledge keeper.
• Van Wall: chief pilot, present at alien excavation.

Non-humans

• "The Thing", the antagonist, is a malevolent, shapeshifting alien life form. It appears in all three film adaptions. In the first film (1951), the Thing is depicted as a tall, menacing humanoid alien that is composed of vegetable matter. In the two later film adaptions, the Things retain their ability to shapeshift, although they do not have telepathic abilities.
• Charnauk: lead Alaskan husky, first openly attacked by the Thing.
• Chinook and Jack: two other huskies.

Adaptations and spin-offs

Films

The Thing from Another World (1951) is a loose adaptation of the original story.^[9] It features James Arness as the Thing, Kenneth Tobey as Air Force officer, and Robert O. Cornthwaite as the lead scientist. In this adaptation, the alien is a humanoid invader (i.e., two arms, two legs, a head) from an unknown planet. A plant-based life form, the alien and its race need animal blood to survive. He, or rather it, is a one-alien army, capable of creating an entire army of invaders from seed pods contained within its body.

Horror Express (1972) was the second film adaptation of the story.^[10] Starring Christopher Lee and Peter Cushing, it moves the setting to the Trans-Siberian Railway in the year 1906, where the unfrozen monster stalks the passengers. A blood test reveals the alien is capable of jumping from person to person as well as absorbing memories, forcing a search for who among the train the alien is while it attempts to obtain the knowledge it needs to build a space craft.

The John Carpenter 1982 adaptation The Thing, from a screenplay by Bill Lancaster, sticks more closely to Campbell's original story.^[9] Carpenter remade the film due to The Thing from Another World being one of his favorite films, and the 1951 adaptation featured on a television in Carpenter's original Halloween. Carpenter's idea was not to compete with the direction of the earlier film. In both the novella and this adaptation, the Thing can imitate any animal-based life form, absorbing the respective hosts' personalities and memories along with their bodies (although the telepathy aspect is omitted). When the story begins, the creature has already been discovered and released from the ice by another expedition. This version maintains the digestions and metamorphoses alluded to in the original novella, via practical effects such as animatronics.^[11]

A prequel to the Carpenter version, also titled The Thing, was released in 2011. It was directed by Matthijs van Heijningen Jr. and written by Eric Heisserer, replacing traditional special effects of the original film with computer graphics.

During the early 2000s, Frank Darabont and David Leslie Johnson-McGoldrick of Darkwoods Productions worked on Return of the Thing, a four-part miniseries project for Sci Fi Channel.^[12] In 2020, a new film was announced to be produced by Jason Blum's Blumhouse Productions and released and distributed by Universal Pictures (as a part of the former's first-look deal). The project is based on the Frozen Hell edition of the story.^[13] John Carpenter later confirmed that he was involved with the project.^[14] In May 2023, he acknowledged his involvement with a direct sequel to his original film.^[15][16]

Literature

Héctor Germán Oesterheld and Alberto Breccia adapted the story as "Tres ojos" (Spanish: "Three Eyes") for their Sherlock Time series, published in the Argentine comic book Hora Cero (issues 89–104) from May to August 1959.^[17] In 1976, the story was also published in comic book form in issue 1 of Starstream with script by Arnold Drake and art by Jack Abel.^[18]

William F. Nolan, author of Logan's Run, wrote an unfilmed screen treatment of Who Goes There? for Universal Studios in 1978; it was published in 2009 in the Rocket Ride Books edition of Who Goes There?.^[19] Nolan's alternate take on Campbell's story reduced the number of characters and downplayed monster elements in favor of an "impostor" theme in a vein similar to The Body Snatchers by Jack Finney.^[20][19]

An early draft of Lancaster's screenplay for The Thing was novelised by Alan Dean Foster in 1982 and released simultaneously with the film. Because it was an early draft, it featured several scenes that differed greatly from those found in the finished film, and two of the supporting characters have different names.

In 1991, Dark Horse Comics published a two-issue miniseries The Thing from Another World written by Chuck Pfarrer and drawn by John Higgins.^[21] It was followed in 1992 by a four-issue sequel, The Thing from Another World: Climate of Fear, written by John Arcudi,^[22] and further by The Thing from Another World: Eternal Vows drawn by Paul Gulacy in 1993. An alternative sequel to the film, The Thing from Another World: Questionable Research, drawn by Ted Naifeh, was serialized in 1993. An unrelated standalone prequel story, The Thing: The Northman Nightmare, written by Steve Niles, was published as a digital comic in 2011.

In 2010, Canadian science fiction writer Peter Watts published a short story in Clarkesworld Magazine titled "The Things"^[23] in which the alien entity from Who Goes There? is the first-person narrator. The characters and events are the same as those in the 1982 John Carpenter adaptation. Clarkesworld also released an audio version of this story as part of their podcast series.^[24]

In 2019, Wildside Press published Short Things, a collection of short stories inspired by Who Goes There? and The Thing. Edited by John Betancourt, Short Things features written contributions by G.D. Falksen ("Appolyon"), Paul Di Filippo ("Thingmaker"), Mark McLaughlin ("The Horror on a Superyacht"), Alan Dean Foster ("Leftovers"), Darrell Schweitzer ("The Interrogator"), Nina Kiriki Hoffman ("Good As Dead"), Kristine Kathryn Rusch ("A Mission at T-Prime"), Chelsea Quinn Yarbro ("The"), Kevin J. Anderson ("Cold Storage"), Pamela Sargent ("Two Wars"), Allen M. Steele ("According to a Reliable Source"), Allan Cole ("The Monster at World's End"), and Betancourt himself ("The Nature of the Beast"). It also contains illustrations by Dan Brereton, Marc Hempel and Mark Wheatley, among others.

Radio dramas

The story has been adapted as a radio drama multiple times, including by BBC Radio 4 in their Chillers series (24 January 2002), and the Suspense radio drama series (2013).^[25] The earliest adaptation was for the Exploring Tomorrow radio series in 1958 (under the title The Escape), hosted by John W. Campbell, Jr. himself; however, no recordings of this episode are known to exist.^[25]

Games

The Thing (2010 card game)^[26] and The Thing: Infection at Outpost 31 (2017 board game)^[27][28] are both based on the John Carpenter 1982 film. In 2002, Universal Interactive and Konami co-published the video game The Thing, a third-person shooter and survival horror sequel to the film.^[29][30]

Who Goes There?, a board game from Certifiable Studios, was released in May 2018, following a Kickstarter campaign, which raised over $612,000 compared to its $54,097 goal.^[31][32][33] In March 2020, Certifiable Studios launched a Kickstarter for a second edition of the game, promising updated mechanics and additional characters. It is available either as a complete game or as an add-on for those who have already bought the first edition.

Rockstar Dundee was working on a video game adaptation of the film, but in 2020 it was cancelled after the studio became part of Rockstar Games.^[34][35]

Cultural impact

Literature

In December 1936, John W. Campbell himself had published a short story titled "Brain Stealers of Mars" in Thrilling Wonder Stories, which also features shape-shifting, mind-reading aliens. The earlier story has a humorous tone, but takes a philosophical note as members of another alien race describe living stoically alongside the shapeshifters.^[36]

Writer A. E. van Vogt was inspired by Who Goes There? to write Vault of the Beast (1940), which he submitted to Astounding Science Fiction. "I read half of it standing there at the news-stand before I bought the issue and finished it," van Vogt later recalled. "That brought me back into the fold with a vengeance. I still regard that as the best story Campbell ever wrote, and the best horror tale in science fiction."^[37]

The Thing is one of the aliens featured in Barlowe's Guide to Extraterrestrials (1979; second edition 1987). Barlowe's main illustration depicts the Thing halfway through its transformation into a sled dog.^[38]

The story is referenced, and embedded within The Rack of Baal (1985), a 'choose-your-own-adventure' gamebook written by Mark Smith and Jamie Thomson, about a time-travelling special agent called "The Falcon".^[39] A section of the plot plays out on a frozen world occupied by a single mining station crewed by only a few people. One inhabitant is called 'Sil McReady', who, in a cynical inversion of the original story, actually turns out to be infected with the alien organism.

Film and television

The 1972 film Horror Express is loosely based on the story, where the frozen remains of a prehistoric corpse comes to life after it thaws out on a train, and the alien within takes over human host bodies and telepathically absorbs their memories and knowledge.^[40]

The 1993 episode "Ice" of the science fiction TV series The X-Files borrows its premise from the storyline.

The 1993 episode of Star Trek: The Next Generation "Aquiel" contains an isolated space outpost and the murderer is eventually be revealed to be a shapeshifting lifeform.

In the 1995 Star Trek: Deep Space Nine episode "The Adversary", a shapeshifting alien infiltrates the crew of a starship. The episode explores similar themes of paranoia and contains a "blood test" scene. The writers have cited The Thing from Another World as inspiration.

The 2013 episode "The Thingy!" of the family action-comedy series The Aquabats! Super Show! also borrows the story's premise, albeit in a much more comedic tone.

The fourth episode of the first season of the HBO crime drama True Detective, first broadcast in 2014, is named after the novella.^[41]

The 2020 film Friend of the World is influenced by The Thing with themes of body horror and isolation.^[42][43] A title on the soundtrack is named after the novella.

Other

In 2006, Dark Horse Comics released a pre-painted snap together model kit of the alien as described in the original short story. It was sculpted and painted by Andrea Von Sholly. The model was unlicensed and was simply titled 'The Space Thing'.

See also

• At the Mountains of Madness, an Antarctica-set science fiction horror story by H.P. Lovecraft that was also first published in Astounding.
• Invasion of the Body Snatchers (1956) and Alien (1979), two science-fiction horror films that may have been influenced by Campbell's story.^[44]
• The Seeds of Doom, the 1976 serial which concluded the thirteenth season of the science fiction TV series Doctor Who, combined elements from Campbell's original storyline (an expedition in Antarctica unearths an ancient alien specimen that has lain dormant in the ice for thousands of years) with elements of the 1951 film version (the alien is a carnivorous walking vegetable, not a shape-shifting impersonator).

References

1. Bova, Ben (1973). The Science Fiction Hall of Fame: Vol. 2A. Doubleday.
2. "Rumored 'The Thing' remake based on 'Frozen Hell': How a lost manuscript could change horror movie history". Newsweek. 29 January 2020.
3. Nevala-Lee, Alec (2018-10-23). Astounding: John W. Campbell, Isaac Asimov, Robert A. Heinlein, L. Ron Hubbard, and the Golden Age of Science Fiction. HarperCollins. ISBN 9780062571960.
4. Keiper, Brian (March 7, 2022). "Frozen Hell: The History of 'The Thing' from 1936 to 2011".
5. Liptak, Andrew (2018-10-21). "A new Kickstarter project will publish an undiscovered novel that inspired The Thing". The Verge. Retrieved 2018-11-23.
6. "Frozen Hell: The Book That Inspired The Thing". Kickstarter. Retrieved 2018-11-23.
7. Betancourt, John (2019-01-16). "Update 38: Ebooks now shipping!". Kickstarter. Retrieved 2019-01-21.
8. Betancourt, John (2019-06-23). "Update 54: EveryTHING you need to know about your books!". Kickstarter. Retrieved 2019-07-20.
9. Maçek III, J.C. (2012-11-21). "Building the Perfect Star Beast: The Antecedents of 'Alien'". PopMatters. from the original on 2012-11-27.
10. Tourism in Antarctica: A Multidisciplinary View of New Activities Carried Out on the White Continent
11. National Science and Media Museum (2008-06-17), Exclusive John Carpenter intro to The Thing, archived from the original on 2021-12-12, retrieved 2018-11-26
12. "Did you know Frank Darabont and the writer of 'Aquaman' almost made a 'The Thing' sequel?". SYFY Official Site. September 12, 2022.
13. "Universal and Blumhouse Developing New Version of 'The Thing' That Will Adapt Long Lost Original Novel!". 27 January 2020.
14. Cavanaugh, Patrick (February 22, 2022). "The Thing Director John Carpenter Can't Talk About Blumhouse Reboot". ComicBook.com.
15. Catt, Chris (May 31, 2023). "John Carpenter Teases 'The Thing 2' and Talks About His Latest Directing Work at Texas Frightmare Weekend". Creepy Catalog. Retrieved June 3, 2023.
16. Fuge, Jonathan (June 1, 2023). "The Thing 2 May Finally Be Happening, John Carpenter Suggests". MovieWeb. Retrieved June 3, 2023.
17. Juanmartí, Jordi (2015). "Sherlock Time: Historias de sombras y luces en el encuentro de dos maestros". tebeosfera. Retrieved 6 September 2019.
18. "Starstream No. 1 (1976)". the Grand Comics Database.
19. (Jr.), John Wood Campbell (2009). Who Goes There?: The Novella That Formed the Basis of the THING. Rocket Ride Books. ISBN 9780982332207.
20. "REVIEW: Who Goes There? by John W. Campbell". SF Signal. 2009-09-01. Retrieved 2018-11-26.
21. "The Thing from Another World". Comic Book Realm. Retrieved 2018-11-26.
22. "The Thing From Another World: Climate of Fear". Comic Book Realm. Retrieved 2018-11-26.
23. "The Things". Clarkesworld Magazine. January 2010. Retrieved 2012-06-21.
24. "The Things". Clarkesworld, Issue 40. January 2010.
25. Willis, Jesse (2016-07-31). "Audio Dramas of John W. Campbell's Who Goes There? : SFFaudio". SFF Audio. Retrieved 2018-11-23.
26. "The Thing". boardgamegeek.com. Retrieved 23 July 2018.
27. "The Thing: Infection at Outpost 31". boardgamegeek.com. Retrieved 23 July 2018.
28. "The Thing: Infection at Outpost 31 Board Game". mondotees.com. Retrieved 23 July 2018.
29. "Based on the Hit Film - Replaying 'The Thing' Video Game", Bloody Disgusting, 2018-04-18, retrieved 2021-05-13
30. "The Thing for PlayStation 2 Reviews - Metacritic". Metacritic. 2014-03-20. from the original on 2014-03-20. Retrieved 2020-03-14.
31. "Who Goes There?". boardgamegeek.com. Retrieved 23 July 2018.
32. "Who Goes There? – Certifiable Studios". certifiablestudios.com. Certifiable Studios. Retrieved 23 July 2018.
33. "WHO GOES THERE?". Kickstarter. Retrieved 2018-11-26.
34. "Rockstar Dundee, prior to becoming part of Rockstar Games in 2020, worked on a canceled video game adaptation of John Carpenter's horror classic "The Thing"".
35. "A developer acknowledging the cancelled "the thing" game".
36. Asimov, Isaac (1974). Before The Golden Age: A Science Fiction Anthology of The 1930s. Doubleday. p. 775. ISBN 9780385024198.
37. . efanzines.com. Archived from the original on July 25, 2014.
38. Barlowe, Wayne Douglas; Summers, Ian; Meacham, Beth (1987). Barlowe's Guide to Extraterrestrials. Workman Pub. ISBN 9780894803246.
39. "Falcon". Gamebooks.org. Retrieved 2012-01-08.
40. "Horror Express Was The First Remake Of The Thing (Before John Carpenter's)". ScreenRant. 2021-05-08. Retrieved 2021-06-05.
41. Fukunaga, Cary Joji (2014-02-09), Who Goes There, from the original on 2016-11-23, retrieved 2016-08-07
42. "San Diego's Spielberg? Q&A With Director Brian Butler Near Sci-Fi Film Premiere". Times of San Diego. 2020-07-24. Retrieved 2022-03-16.
43. "'Friend of the World' streaming and on demand Nov 22nd". Horror News Net. 2021-11-17. Retrieved 2022-03-16.
44. Denby, David (June 28, 1982). "Battle of the Stereotypes". New York. 15 (26): 53–54. from the original on May 19, 2015. Campbell's story may have influenced the movies Invasion of the Body Snatchers and Alien.

Further reading

• Campbell, John W; Nolan, William F (2009). Who Goes There? The Novella That Formed the Basis of "The Thing". Rocket Ride Books. ISBN 978-0-9823322-0-7.
• Hamilton, John (2007). The Golden Age and Beyond: The World of Science Fiction. ABDO Publishing Company. pp. 8–11. ISBN 978-1-59679-989-9.
• Leane, Elizabeth. "Locating the Thing: The Antarctic as Space Alien in John W. Campbell's 'Who Goes There'". Science Fiction Studies. Volume 32, Issue 2, July 2005: 225–239 Literature Criticism Online. Web. 3 November 2011.
• Nevala-Lee, Alec (2018-10-23). Astounding: John W. Campbell, Isaac Asimov, Robert A. Heinlein, L. Ron Hubbard, and the Golden Age of Science Fiction. HarperCollins. ISBN 9780062571960.
• Witalec, Janet. "John Carpenter (1948–)." Contemporary Literary Criticism. Vol 161, 2003: 143–204 Literature Criticism Online. Web. 2 Nov. 2011.

External links

• Who Goes There? title listing at the Internet Speculative Fiction Database