fbpx
Wikipedia

Pruitt–Igoe

The Wendell O. Pruitt Homes and William Igoe Apartments, known together as Pruitt–Igoe (/ˈprɪt ˈɡ/), were joint urban housing projects first occupied in 1954 in St. Louis, Missouri, United States. The complex of 33 eleven-story high rises was designed in the modernist architectural style by Minoru Yamasaki. At the time of opening, it was one of the largest public housing developments in the country. It was constructed with federal funds on the site of a former slum as part of the city's urban renewal program. Despite being legally integrated, it almost exclusively accommodated African Americans.

Pruitt–Igoe
The Wendell O. Pruitt Homes and William Igoe Apartments complex
General information
LocationSt. Louis, Missouri, US
Coordinates38°38′32.24″N 90°12′33.95″W / 38.6422889°N 90.2094306°W / 38.6422889; -90.2094306
StatusDemolished
Area57 acres (23 ha)
No. of blocks33
No. of units2,870
Density50 units per acre (120/ha)
Construction
Constructed1951–1955
ArchitectMinoru Yamasaki
StyleInternational Style, modern
Demolished1972–1976

Although initially viewed as an improvement over the tenement housing it replaced, living conditions in Pruitt–Igoe began to deteriorate soon after completion. By the mid-1960s it was plagued by poor maintenance and crime, particularly vandalism and juvenile delinquency. Numerous initiatives to reverse the decline failed, and by 1970 more than two-thirds of the complex was vacant. Demolition of the complex began in 1972 with a televised implosion of several of the buildings. Over the next four years, the rest of the complex was vacated and demolished.

In the aftermath of its demolition, Pruitt–Igoe became a symbol of the failings of the society-changing aspirations of modernist architecture, as the project's problems were widely attributed to architectural flaws that created a hostile and unsafe environment. Critic Charles Jencks described its demolition as "the day Modern architecture died".[1] More recent appraisals have placed a greater emphasis on St. Louis's precipitously declining population, and fiscal problems with the local housing authority. The Architectural Review states in a summary of the modern consensus that the project was "doomed from the outset".[2] As of 2023, most of the Pruitt–Igoe site remained vacant, although new development was pending.

Description edit

Pruitt–Igoe consisted of 33 eleven-story concrete apartment buildings, clad in brick, on a 57-acre (23 ha) site, on St. Louis's north side, bounded by Cass Avenue on the north, North Jefferson Avenue on the west, Carr Street on the south, and North 20th Street on the east.[3][4] Each building was 170 feet (52 m) long; most contained between 80 and 90 units,[5] although some buildings had up to 150.[6] The complex totaled 2,870 apartments (1,736 in Pruitt and 1,132 in Igoe[7]) housing more than 10,000 people at full occupancy.[8]

The apartments were deliberately small, with undersized kitchen appliances, and few units were designed for larger families.[9] The apartments were not equipped with balconies.[10] "Skip-stop" elevators stopped only at the first, fourth, seventh, and tenth "anchor" floors in an attempt to lessen elevator congestion, forcing many residents to use the stairs. The same anchor floors were equipped with large south-facing communal corridors called "galleries", as well as laundry rooms and garbage chutes.[11]

History edit

Background edit

During the 1940s, the city of St. Louis was overcrowded, with housing conditions in some areas being said to resemble "something out of a Charles Dickens novel".[12] Its housing stock had deteriorated by the 1940s, and more than 85,000 families lived in 19th century tenements. An official survey from 1947 found that 33,000 homes had communal toilets.[12] Middle-class, predominantly white, residents were leaving the city, and their former residences became occupied by low-income families. Black slums in the north and white slums in the south were expanding and threatening to engulf the city center. To save central properties from an imminent loss of value, city authorities settled on redevelopment of the inner ring around the central business district.[3] Due to the state of decay, neighborhood gentrification never received serious consideration.[12]

The first generation of St. Louis public housing was enabled by the Housing Act of 1937 and opened in 1942 as two identical but racially segregated low-rise developments: Carr Square in the northwest for African Americans, and Clinton Peabody in the southwest for whites. The projects, intended for the working poor rather than the truly destitute, were successful.[13]

In 1947, St. Louis planners proposed to replace DeSoto-Carr, a run-down neighborhood with many black residents, with new two- and three-story residential blocks and a public park.[14] The plan did not materialize; instead, Democratic mayor Joseph Darst, elected in 1949, and Republican state leaders favored clearing the slums and replacing them with high-rise, high-density public housing. They reasoned that the new projects would help the city through increased revenues, new parks, playgrounds and shopping space.[12] Darst stated in 1951:

We must rebuild, open up and clean up the hearts of our cities. The fact that slums were created with all the intrinsic evils was everybody's fault. Now it is everybody's responsibility to repair the damage.[8]

In 1948, voters rejected the proposal for a municipal loan to finance urban redevelopment, but soon the situation was changed with the Housing Act of 1949 and Missouri state laws that provided co-financing of public housing projects. The approach taken by Darst, urban renewal, was shared by President Harry S. Truman's administration and fellow mayors of other cities overwhelmed by industrial workers recruited during the war.[15] Specifically, the St. Louis Land Clearance and Redevelopment Authority was authorized to acquire and demolish the slums of the inner ring and then sell the land at reduced prices to private developers in the hopes of fostering middle-class development and luring families back from the suburbs. Another agency, the St. Louis Housing Authority, had to clear land to construct public housing for the former slum dwellers.[16]

Design and construction edit

By 1950, St. Louis had received a federal commitment under the Housing Act of 1949 to finance 5,800 public housing units.[17] The first large public housing in St. Louis, Cochran Gardens, was completed in 1953. It contained 704 units in a mix of medium- and high-rise buildings. It was followed by three more projects: Pruitt–Igoe, Vaughn, and Darst–Webbe.[18] Pruitt–Igoe was named for St. Louisans Wendell O. Pruitt, an African-American fighter pilot in World War II, and William L. Igoe, a former US Congressman.[19] Originally, the city planned two partitions: Pruitt for black residents and Igoe for whites,[20] as St. Louis public housing was segregated until 1955.[21]

In 1950, the city picked Leinweber, Yamasaki & Hellmuth, an architectural firm based in St. Louis, to design the new public housing complex. The project was led by architect Minoru Yamasaki, then early in his career,[2] and performed under supervision and constraints imposed by the federal authorities. His initial proposal, which included walk-up and mid-rise buildings as well as high-rises, was accepted by the St. Louis authorities, but exceeded the federal cost limits imposed by the Public Housing Administration; the agency intervened and imposed a uniform building height of 11 floors.[16] Shortages of materials caused by the Korean War and tensions in the Congress further tightened federal controls.[16] Overall density was set at a level of 50 units per acre,[22] higher than in downtown slums.[16] Although each row of buildings was supposed to be flanked by a "river of open space",[23] landscaping was omitted from the final plan and few trees were planted.[22]

Construction began in 1951.[24] Pruitt accepted its first tenants in November 1954, Igoe in July 1955.[25] When the two projects opened, they were one of the largest public housing developments in the country.[26] Even under federal cost-cutting regulations, Pruitt–Igoe initially cost $36 million,[27] 60 percent above the national average for public housing; one factor was the installation of an expensive heating system.[28] Despite the poor build quality, material suppliers cited Pruitt–Igoe in their advertisements to capitalize on the national exposure of the project.[8]

Early years edit

Pruitt–Igoe was initially seen as a breakthrough in urban renewal.[8] One early resident described her 11th floor apartment as a "poor man's penthouse".[29] Pruitt–Igoe was officially desegregated by a Supreme Court decision in 1954,[21] and as many as 40 percent of the initial tenants were white,[30] but by the mid 1960s it had become exclusively African American.[31]

Decline edit

By 1958, just four years after the opening of the project, deteriorating conditions were already evident.[32] Elevator breakdowns and vandalism were cited as major problems[33]—Yamasaki later lamented that he "never thought people were that destructive".[34] Ventilation was poor despite St. Louis's hot and humid summers.[35] Meanwhile, the St. Louis Housing Authority was in the midst of a decades-long problem with inefficient and costly maintenance of its buildings, partly attributed to the power of labor unions.[36] The stairwells and corridors attracted muggers, a situation exacerbated by the skip-stop elevators.[33] Its location in "a sea of decaying and abandoned buildings" and limited access to shopping and recreation (ground-floor businesses had been eliminated from the design to save money,[22] and the complex had no public mailbox[37]) contributed to its problems.[38] The huge, 11-story buildings of the development were reportedly a magnet for criminals and vagrants from the surrounding low-rise slums;[38] a 1959 audit reported that most of the vandalism was done by transients rather than residents,[39] and a 1967 report similarly found that a "relatively large proportion" of crimes were committed by outsiders.[40] Large criminal gangs were not common in the project.[41]

The Recession of 1958 led to increased crime, vacancy, and rent delinquency in the development, which cut into the housing authority's revenue. In response, the authority reduced maintenance by 10 percent, and the reduction in maintenance coupled with a grand jury report that criticized crime levels in Pruitt–Igoe caused a significant drop in applications to the development.[42] Increasing vacancy rates set off a feedback loop where the loss of revenue from rent forced the housing authority to curtail maintenance, further reducing the project's desirability.[33] Occupancy at both Pruitt and Igoe peaked in the first years, at 95 and 86 percent, respectively. In the 1960s, Pruitt remained about 75 percent full and Igoe 65 percent. In 1969, those numbers fell to 57.1 percent and 48.9 percent;[43] at one point the vacancy rate was higher than any other public housing complex in the country.[20] The annual turn-over rate was 20 percent.[6]

After 1960, the rental income from Pruitt–Igoe failed to cover the cost of operation, forcing the housing authority to tap into its reserves and causing cutbacks at other developments, which were themselves profitable.[44] Attempts by local authorities to improve living conditions were handicapped by lack of resources, though numerous programs, including the hiring of private security, rent incentives to attract new tenants, and grants for academic studies, were tried.[45] As the financial position of the authority worsened, it raised the minimum rent from $20 a month in 1952, to $32 in 1958, $43 in 1962, and $58 in 1968. The increases forced some families to devote as much as 75 percent of their income to rent.[46] In addition to the rent increases, tenants were charged for basic services like replacing fuses and door locks.[47] The rent increases were a major factor in a nine-month rent strike by tenants in 1969.[33] The strike began on February 2 at other public housing projects in the city[48] and spread to Pruitt–Igoe by April 1.[49] It ended with a settlement under which the board of commissioners of the housing authority resigned and tenant organizations were granted more influence.[50]

In 1965, the project received a federal grant to improve the physical condition of the buildings and establish social programs for residents, but the grant failed to reverse the decline.[33] Between 1963 and 1966 it was the subject of a sociological study by Lee Rainwater.[51] In 1966, the Pruitt–Igoe Neighborhood Corporation commissioned a survey of the housing project that catalogued numerous issues with its maintenance, security, and management.[52] Basic services like elevators and heating often failed, and maintenance sometimes took years to respond to tenant requests.[53]

The withdrawal in 1967 of a private security force that patrolled the buildings led to a further escalation in crime and vandalism,[54] which was partially attributed to the large number of juveniles in single-parent households;[55] a census undertaken in September 1965 found that 69.2 percent of inhabitants were minors, and less than 30 percent of households with children had both parents present.[56] Teenage pregnancy and juvenile delinquency were considered major problems by the residents.[57] Families at Pruitt–Igoe were large: the average household had four minors. Nearly half of births (and 73 percent of first-born children) were out of wedlock, though this statistic was no higher in Pruitt–Igoe than in nearby private housing.[58]

In spite of the widespread issues, most inhabitants of Pruitt–Igoe continued to live ordinary lives,[59] and, according to Rainwater and activist Joan Miller, "the vast majority... responded to their sick society in a healthy manner."[60] 78 percent of residents reported that they were satisfied with their apartment, and 80 percent said that Pruitt–Igoe met their needs "a little better" or "much better" than their previous place of residence.[61] The project contained isolated pockets of well-being throughout its worst years, and apartments clustered around small, two-family landings with tenants working to maintain and clear their common areas were often relatively successful.[62]

Demolition edit

 
The second, widely televised demolition of a Pruitt–Igoe building on April 21, 1972.

In 1968, the federal Department of Housing of Urban Development (HUD) began encouraging the remaining residents to leave Pruitt–Igoe.[63] A 1970 report assessed the extent of the physical damage to the buildings as "nearly unbelievable" and far worse than in the other St. Louis projects.[64] Many buildings had been practically ransacked, with broken windows and doors, walls stripped for wire and pipe, and garbage strewn about the site. Only 10 of the original 33 buildings were still occupied.[65] In December 1971, state and federal authorities agreed to demolish two of the Pruitt–Igoe buildings. They hoped that a gradual reduction in population and building density could improve the situation; by this time, Pruitt–Igoe had consumed $57 million, an investment which they felt could not be wholly abandoned.[27] Authorities considered different possibilities for rehabilitating Pruitt–Igoe, including conversion to a low-rise neighborhood by collapsing the towers down to a few floors to reduce the density.[27] After 1971, most tenants were consolidated into the Igoe section. Despite the impending demolition, more than $1 million was spent on renovation in the 1970s, mainly funded by grants from the federal government.[66]

After months of preparation, the first building was demolished with explosives on March 16, 1972. More buildings followed on April 21, June 9, and July 15.[27][67] HUD announced in August 1973 their decision to demolish the rest of the complex. A last-minute attempt to purchase and rehabilitate a few of the buildings by a neighborhood community development corporation was rejected by HUD. The last tenant moved out in May 1974, and the project was fully cleared by 1976 at a total cost of $3.5 million – becoming the first major housing projects in the United States to be demolished.[68][69] Footage of the demolition was featured in the film Koyaanisqatsi.[70]

Site edit

Since Pruitt–Igoe's demolition, various plans have been put forth for the use of its site, including a golf course, a business park,[71] and a 50-story tower.[72] An elementary school was built on part of the site in 1995,[71] but as of 2023 most of it remains vacant,[73] even as adjacent lots have been redeveloped.[74]

In 2020, Ponce Health Sciences University announced its intention to construct an $80 million facility on the site.[75] When completed, the facility is planned to house the Ponce Health Sciences University School of Medicine in St. Louis.[76] In 2021, a developer submitted zoning applications for the construction of office buildings and a hotel on the site.[77] An urgent care center named after the former Homer G. Phillips Hospital was built in 2022,[78] but restrictions related to the construction of a new headquarters for the National Geospatial-Intelligence Agency on an adjacent lot were reportedly stalling the redevelopment of the site.[79]

Legacy edit

Pruitt–Igoe has received extensive commentary in the architectural literature;[80] architect William Ramroth describes it as "the most infamous public housing disaster in American history" and a "poster child" for the failures of public housing projects.[19] Nonetheless, the initial reception of Pruitt–Igoe was positive, although contrary to popular belief the project never won any architectural awards.[81] In 1951, before construction had finished, an Architectural Forum article lauded Yamasaki's original proposal,[5] praising the layout as "vertical neighborhoods for poor people",[8] and Yamasaki biographer Paul Kidder appraised it as "an amazingly ambitious effort to turn the embarrassment of tenement squalor in a great American city into something decent and good".[82]

Although Yamasaki's design followed modernist conventions and was influenced by Le Corbusier's ville radieuse concept,[11] many design decisions were imposed by federal authorities, including vetoing the original proposal of a mix of structures of different heights.[16] Even before the completion of the project, Yamasaki was skeptical that high-rise buildings would be beneficial to tenants, stating that "The low building with low density is unquestionably more satisfactory than multi-story living."[83] Nonetheless, he defended the high-rise design as a practical necessity for clearing slums.[83]

Criticism of the project's architectural design began in the 1960s.[33] The skip-stop elevators forced many residents to use the stairwells, where muggings were frequent.[84] The galleries, which were unpainted, unfurnished, and dimly-lit, served as hang-outs for criminal gangs rather than communal spaces.[85] The landscaping intended to make Pruitt–Igoe "towers in the park" was cut from the final plan, and the surrounding area subsequently turned to wasteland.[22] In addition to the architectural flaws, the overall quality of construction was extremely poor: the buildings were described by housing researcher Eugene Meehan as "little more than steel and concrete rabbit warrens, poorly designed, badly equipped, inadequate in size, badly located, unventilated, and virtually impossible to maintain".[35]

After the demolition of the first buildings in 1972, Pruitt–Igoe received wider attention and began to be perceived as a failure of modernist architecture as a whole.[33] By the late 1970s, this view had coalesced into "architectural dogma",[86] especially for the nascent movements of postmodern architecture and environment and behavior architecture.[87] Postmodern architectural historian Charles Jencks called its destruction "the day Modern architecture died" and considered it a direct indictment of the society-changing aspirations of the International school of architecture and an example of modernists' intentions running contrary to real-world social development.[1]

Pruitt–Igoe served as a case study for Oscar Newman's concept of defensible space, in which structures are laid out so that residents have control and responsibility over their surroundings. Newman criticized the large spaces shared by dozens of families as "anonymous public spaces [that] made it impossible for even neighboring residents to develop an accord about acceptable behavior", and attributed Pruitt–Igoe's social problems to its high-rise design and lack of defensible space, contrasting it unfavorably with the adjacent Carr Village, a low-rise area with a similar demographic makeup that remained fully occupied and largely trouble-free in the same period.[88] Newman's analysis was one of the most influential in attributing the project's failure to "environmentally determined architecture".[89]

Other critics argue that the Pruitt–Igoe's architecture has been overemphasized compared to political and social factors,[89] a view prominently advanced by Katharine Bristol (at the time a doctoral student in architecture) in a 1991 article titled "The Pruitt–Igoe Myth".[11] While acknowledging flaws in the project's design, Bristol cited the underfunding of public housing and consequent inability for the housing authority to properly maintain the buildings and the deleterious effects of poverty and racial discrimination on its residents as crucial factors in Pruitt–Igoe's decline.[90] The steep fall in St. Louis's population exacerbated the project's vacancy problem—instead of growing from 850,000 in the 1940s to 1 million in 1970 as projected, the city lost 30 percent of its residents in that timespan due to suburbanization and white flight,[11] as well as 11,000 manufacturing jobs in an overall shift from a blue collar to white collar economy.[80] The Pruitt-Igoe Myth, a 2011 documentary film, largely followed Bristol's view.[11]

In his book-length study of St. Louis public housing policy, Eugene Meehan assessed the root cause as "a set of policies programmed for failure",[91] in particular the requirement of the Housing Act of 1949 that local housing authorities pay their expenses from rental income, which made them vulnerable to fiscal problems.[92] The "mindless concentration on dollar costs" and "voracious and inefficient" local construction industry also contributed to the project's maintenance woes.[6] Widespread voter opposition to public housing, both locally and nationally, created a "hostile climate" that limited financial assistance from the government;[93] in turn, the eventual failure of the project contributed to the further unpopularity of public housing, both locally[94] and nationally.[89] According to The Architectural Review, the modern consensus is that the underfunded project was "doomed from the outset".[2]

The failure and demolition of Pruitt–Igoe damaged Yamasaki's reputation as an architect, and he personally regretted designing the buildings.[2]

See also edit

References edit

  1. ^ a b Jencks 1984, p. 9.
  2. ^ a b c d Gyure 2019.
  3. ^ a b Bristol 1991, pp. 163–164.
  4. ^ Kidder 2022, p. 47.
  5. ^ a b Meehan 1979, p. 67.
  6. ^ a b c Meehan 1979, p. 72.
  7. ^ Wilensky, Harry (September 9, 1956). "The Fight Against Decay". St. Louis Post-Dispatch. p. 142. Retrieved April 28, 2022 – via Newspapers.com.
  8. ^ a b c d e Ramroth 2007, p. 164.
  9. ^ Meehan 1979, pp. 70–72.
  10. ^ James P. Hubbard, Decent, Safe and Sanitary Dwellings: The National Conversation About Public Housing, 2018.
  11. ^ a b c d e Cendón 2012.
  12. ^ a b c d Larsen & Kirkendall 2004, p. 60.
  13. ^ Meehan 1979, pp. 56–58.
  14. ^ Ramroth 2007, p. 169.
  15. ^ Larsen & Kirkendall 2004, p. 61.
  16. ^ a b c d e Bristol 1991, p. 164.
  17. ^ Meehan 1979, p. 64.
  18. ^ Meehan 1979, pp. 67, 74.
  19. ^ a b Ramroth 2007, p. 163.
  20. ^ a b Rainwater 1970, p. 8.
  21. ^ a b Meehan 1979, p. 85.
  22. ^ a b c d Ramroth 2007, p. 170.
  23. ^ Hall 2004, p. 256.
  24. ^ Montgomery 1985, p. 231.
  25. ^ "Igoe Homes' First Families Move Into 72-Unit Apartment Building". St. Louis Post-Dispatch. July 23, 1955. p. 3. Retrieved April 28, 2022 – via Newspapers.com.
  26. ^ Larsen & Kirkendall 2004, p. 62.
  27. ^ a b c d Ramroth 2007, p. 165.
  28. ^ Meehan 1979, p. 71–73.
  29. ^ Kimmelman, Michael (January 25, 2012). "Towers of Dreams: One Ended in Nightmare". The New York Times. Retrieved March 29, 2022.
  30. ^ "Segregation Banned Here in Public Housing Projects". St. Louis Globe-Democrat. December 29, 1955. p. 1. Retrieved April 28, 2022 – via Newspapers.com.
  31. ^ Rainwater 1970, p. 10.
  32. ^ Bristol 1991, p. 165.
  33. ^ a b c d e f g Bristol 1991, p. 166.
  34. ^ Marshall, Colin (April 22, 2015). "Pruitt-Igoe: the troubled high-rise that came to define urban America". The Guardian. Retrieved March 27, 2022.
  35. ^ a b Meehan 1979, p. 73.
  36. ^ Meehan 1979, p. 63.
  37. ^ Miller & Rainwater 1967, p. 4.
  38. ^ a b Meehan 1979, p. 68.
  39. ^ Meehan 1979, p. 78.
  40. ^ Miller & Rainwater 1967, p. 9.
  41. ^ Rainwater 1970, p. 282.
  42. ^ Meehan 1979, p. 78–79.
  43. ^ Meehan 1979, p. 77.
  44. ^ Meehan 1979, p. 76.
  45. ^ Meehan 1979, pp. 79–81.
  46. ^ Meehan 1979, p. 83.
  47. ^ Miller & Rainwater 1967, p. 8.
  48. ^ "Pruitt-Igoe Leaders Split Over Joining Rent Strike". St. Louis Post-Dispatch. March 17, 1969. p. 12. Retrieved April 28, 2022 – via Newspapers.com.
  49. ^ "Rent Strike Spreads to Pruitt-Igoe". St. Louis Post-Dispatch. March 12, 1969. p. 3. Retrieved April 28, 2022 – via Newspapers.com.
  50. ^ Meehan 1979, pp. 91–92.
  51. ^ Rainwater 1970, p. vii.
  52. ^ Miller & Rainwater 1967, pp. 6–7.
  53. ^ Miller & Rainwater 1967, pp. 7–8.
  54. ^ Meehan 1979, p. 97.
  55. ^ Meehan 1979, pp. 86–87.
  56. ^ Rainwater 1970, pp. 13–14.
  57. ^ Rainwater 1970, pp. 57, 64.
  58. ^ Rainwater 1970, p. 215.
  59. ^ Rainwater 1970, p. 12.
  60. ^ Miller & Rainwater 1967, p. 6.
  61. ^ Rainwater 1970, p. 11.
  62. ^ Newman 1996, p. 11.
  63. ^ Ramroth 2007, p. 171.
  64. ^ Meehan 1979, p. 94–96.
  65. ^ Meehan 1979, p. 96.
  66. ^ Meehan 1979, p. 112.
  67. ^ "Taking a Tumble". St. Louis Post-Dispatch. June 10, 1972. p. 3A. Retrieved August 24, 2022.
  68. ^ Montgomery 1985, pp. 232–233.
  69. ^ Meehan 1979, p. 56, 112.
  70. ^ "Why the Pruitt-Igoe housing project failed". The Economist. October 15, 2011. Retrieved October 17, 2011.
  71. ^ a b Brown, Sylvester (May 8, 2005). "School on Pruitt-Igoe land is testament to area's past, residents' determination". St. Louis Post-Dispatch. ProQuest 402578777.
  72. ^ Barker, Jacob (August 14, 2016). "McKee buys Pruitt-Igoe site, a symbol of St. Louis's decline, and now, rebirth". St. Louis Post-Dispatch. ProQuest 1811169215.
  73. ^ Barker, Jacob (March 2, 2023). "Development of former Pruitt-Igoe site, near St. Louis' new NGA campus, advances". St. Louis Post-Dispatch. ProQuest 2781262277.
  74. ^ Brown, Sylvester (March 1, 2005). "Development plans for Pruitt-Igoe site quietly faded away". St. Louis Post-Dispatch. ProQuest 402551048.
  75. ^ Ruff, Corinne (March 16, 2020). "For-Profit Medical School Plots $80 Million North St. Louis Facility". St. Louis Public Radio.
  76. ^ "From Triage to Recovery: Pruitt Igoe Becomes New Medical Campus in St. Louis". United States Environmental Protection Agency. July 5, 2022.
  77. ^ Barker, Jacob; Kukuljan, Steph; Schlinkmann, Mark (September 24, 2021). "McKee, Clayco plan office buildings and hotel on Pruitt-Igoe site near new NGA headquarters". St. Louis Post-Dispatch. ProQuest 2575847796.
  78. ^ Kull, Katie (July 15, 2022). "Nurses group sues to stop 'Homer G. Phillips' from being used on St. Louis hospital". St. Louis Post-Dispatch. ProQuest 2689565965.
  79. ^ Barker, Jacob (March 14, 2022). "Measure to control development around new NGA campus in north St. Louis advances". St. Louis Post-Dispatch. ProQuest 2638699647.
  80. ^ a b Comerio 1981, p. 26.
  81. ^ Bristol 1991, p. 168.
  82. ^ Kidder 2022, p. 4.
  83. ^ a b Yamasaki 1952, p. 226.
  84. ^ Rainwater 1970, p. 10–11.
  85. ^ Ramroth 2007, pp. 170–171.
  86. ^ Bristol 1991, p. 169.
  87. ^ Bristol 1991, p. 170.
  88. ^ Newman 1996, pp. 9–11.
  89. ^ a b c Montgomery 1985, p. 239.
  90. ^ Bristol 1991, p. 167.
  91. ^ Meehan 1979, p. 1.
  92. ^ Meehan 1979, pp. 64–65.
  93. ^ Meehan 1979, p. 65.
  94. ^ Mendelson & Quinn 1985, p. 163.

Sources edit

Books edit

  • Hall, Peter Geoffrey (2004). Cities of Tomorrow: An Intellectual History of Urban Planning and Design in the Twentieth Century. Wiley, John & Sons, Incorporated. ISBN 978-0-631-23252-0.
  • Jencks, Charles (1984). The Language of Post-Modern Architecture. Rizzoli. ISBN 978-0-8478-0571-6.
  • Kidder, Paul (2022). Minoru Yamasaki and the Fragility of Architecture. Routledge. ISBN 978-0-367-62952-6.
  • Larsen, Lawrence Harold; Kirkendall, Richard Stewart (2004). A History of Missouri: 1953 to 2003. University of Missouri Press. ISBN 978-0-8262-1546-8.
  • Meehan, Eugene (1979). The Quality of Federal Policymaking: Programmed Failure in Public Housing. University of Missouri Press. ISBN 0-8262-0272-1.
  • Mendelson, Robert E.; Quinn, Michael A. (1985). "Residential Patterns in a Midwestern City: The Saint Louis Experience". The Metropolitan Midwest. University of Illinois Press. ISBN 978-0-252-01114-6.
  • Montgomery, Roger (1985). "Pruitt–Igoe: Policy Failure or Societal Symptom". The Metropolitan Midwest. University of Illinois Press. ISBN 978-0-252-01114-6.
  • Newman, Oscar (1996). Creating Defensible Space. US Department of Housing and Urban Development Office of Policy Development and Research. ISBN 978-0-7881-4528-5.
  • Rainwater, Lee (1970). Behind Ghetto Walls: Black Families in a Federal Slum. Aldine Publishing Company. ISBN 978-0-202-30907-1.
  • Ramroth, William G. (2007). Planning for Disaster: How Natural and Man-made Disasters Shape the Built Environment. Kaplan Publishing. ISBN 978-1-4195-9373-4.

Articles edit

  • Bristol, Katharine (May 1991). "The Pruitt–Igoe Myth". Journal of Architectural Education. 44 (3): 163–171. doi:10.1080/10464883.1991.11102687. ISSN 1531-314X. S2CID 219542179.
  • Cendón, Sara Fernández (February 3, 2012). . American Institute of Architects. Archived from the original on March 14, 2014. Retrieved December 31, 2014.
  • Comerio, Mary C. (Summer 1981). "Pruitt Igoe and Other Stories". Journal of Architectural Education. 34 (4): 26–31. doi:10.1080/10464883.1981.10758667.
  • Gyure, Dale Allen (February 21, 2019). "Minoru Yamasaki (1912–1986)". The Architectural Review. Retrieved March 27, 2022.
  • Miller, Joan; Rainwater, Lee (October 1967). Frances A. Koestler (ed.). "Pruitt-Igoe: Survival in a Concrete Ghetto". Social Work. 12 (4): 3–13. doi:10.1093/sw/12.4.3.
  • Yamasaki, Minoru (1952). "High Buildings for public housing?". Journal of Housing. 9 (7).

Further reading edit

  • Birmingham, Elizabeth (1998). "Reframing the Ruins: Pruitt–Igoe, Structural Racism, and African American Rhetoric as a Space for Cultural Critique". Positionen. 2 (2).
  • Bristol, Kate; Montgomery, Roger (1987). Pruitt–Igoe: An Annotated Bibliography. Council of Planning Librarians. ISBN 978-0-86602-205-7.
  • Cornetet, James (2013). Facadomy: A Critique on Capitalism and Its Assault on Mid-Century Modern Architecture. Process Press. ISBN 978-0-9888108-0-8.
  • Fishman, Robert (2004). "Rethinking Public Housing". Places. 16 (2). ISSN 0731-0455.
  • Pipkin, John S.; et al. (1983). Remaking the City. SUNY Press. ISBN 978-0-87395-677-2.
  • von Hoffman, Alexander. . Joint Center for Housing Studies, Harvard University. Archived from the original on August 30, 2002.

External links edit


pruitt, igoe, philip, glass, musical, piece, pruit, igoe, koyaanisqatsi, music, wendell, pruitt, homes, william, igoe, apartments, known, together, were, joint, urban, housing, projects, first, occupied, 1954, louis, missouri, united, states, complex, eleven, . For Philip Glass s musical piece Pruit Igoe see Koyaanisqatsi Music The Wendell O Pruitt Homes and William Igoe Apartments known together as Pruitt Igoe ˈ p r uː ɪ t ˈ aɪ ɡ oʊ were joint urban housing projects first occupied in 1954 in St Louis Missouri United States The complex of 33 eleven story high rises was designed in the modernist architectural style by Minoru Yamasaki At the time of opening it was one of the largest public housing developments in the country It was constructed with federal funds on the site of a former slum as part of the city s urban renewal program Despite being legally integrated it almost exclusively accommodated African Americans Pruitt IgoeThe Wendell O Pruitt Homes and William Igoe Apartments complexGeneral informationLocationSt Louis Missouri USCoordinates38 38 32 24 N 90 12 33 95 W 38 6422889 N 90 2094306 W 38 6422889 90 2094306StatusDemolishedArea57 acres 23 ha No of blocks33No of units2 870Density50 units per acre 120 ha ConstructionConstructed1951 1955ArchitectMinoru YamasakiStyleInternational Style modernDemolished1972 1976 Although initially viewed as an improvement over the tenement housing it replaced living conditions in Pruitt Igoe began to deteriorate soon after completion By the mid 1960s it was plagued by poor maintenance and crime particularly vandalism and juvenile delinquency Numerous initiatives to reverse the decline failed and by 1970 more than two thirds of the complex was vacant Demolition of the complex began in 1972 with a televised implosion of several of the buildings Over the next four years the rest of the complex was vacated and demolished In the aftermath of its demolition Pruitt Igoe became a symbol of the failings of the society changing aspirations of modernist architecture as the project s problems were widely attributed to architectural flaws that created a hostile and unsafe environment Critic Charles Jencks described its demolition as the day Modern architecture died 1 More recent appraisals have placed a greater emphasis on St Louis s precipitously declining population and fiscal problems with the local housing authority The Architectural Review states in a summary of the modern consensus that the project was doomed from the outset 2 As of 2023 update most of the Pruitt Igoe site remained vacant although new development was pending Contents 1 Description 2 History 2 1 Background 2 2 Design and construction 2 3 Early years 2 4 Decline 2 5 Demolition 2 6 Site 3 Legacy 4 See also 5 References 5 1 Sources 5 1 1 Books 5 1 2 Articles 5 2 Further reading 6 External linksDescription editPruitt Igoe consisted of 33 eleven story concrete apartment buildings clad in brick on a 57 acre 23 ha site on St Louis s north side bounded by Cass Avenue on the north North Jefferson Avenue on the west Carr Street on the south and North 20th Street on the east 3 4 Each building was 170 feet 52 m long most contained between 80 and 90 units 5 although some buildings had up to 150 6 The complex totaled 2 870 apartments 1 736 in Pruitt and 1 132 in Igoe 7 housing more than 10 000 people at full occupancy 8 The apartments were deliberately small with undersized kitchen appliances and few units were designed for larger families 9 The apartments were not equipped with balconies 10 Skip stop elevators stopped only at the first fourth seventh and tenth anchor floors in an attempt to lessen elevator congestion forcing many residents to use the stairs The same anchor floors were equipped with large south facing communal corridors called galleries as well as laundry rooms and garbage chutes 11 History editBackground edit During the 1940s the city of St Louis was overcrowded with housing conditions in some areas being said to resemble something out of a Charles Dickens novel 12 Its housing stock had deteriorated by the 1940s and more than 85 000 families lived in 19th century tenements An official survey from 1947 found that 33 000 homes had communal toilets 12 Middle class predominantly white residents were leaving the city and their former residences became occupied by low income families Black slums in the north and white slums in the south were expanding and threatening to engulf the city center To save central properties from an imminent loss of value city authorities settled on redevelopment of the inner ring around the central business district 3 Due to the state of decay neighborhood gentrification never received serious consideration 12 The first generation of St Louis public housing was enabled by the Housing Act of 1937 and opened in 1942 as two identical but racially segregated low rise developments Carr Square in the northwest for African Americans and Clinton Peabody in the southwest for whites The projects intended for the working poor rather than the truly destitute were successful 13 In 1947 St Louis planners proposed to replace DeSoto Carr a run down neighborhood with many black residents with new two and three story residential blocks and a public park 14 The plan did not materialize instead Democratic mayor Joseph Darst elected in 1949 and Republican state leaders favored clearing the slums and replacing them with high rise high density public housing They reasoned that the new projects would help the city through increased revenues new parks playgrounds and shopping space 12 Darst stated in 1951 We must rebuild open up and clean up the hearts of our cities The fact that slums were created with all the intrinsic evils was everybody s fault Now it is everybody s responsibility to repair the damage 8 In 1948 voters rejected the proposal for a municipal loan to finance urban redevelopment but soon the situation was changed with the Housing Act of 1949 and Missouri state laws that provided co financing of public housing projects The approach taken by Darst urban renewal was shared by President Harry S Truman s administration and fellow mayors of other cities overwhelmed by industrial workers recruited during the war 15 Specifically the St Louis Land Clearance and Redevelopment Authority was authorized to acquire and demolish the slums of the inner ring and then sell the land at reduced prices to private developers in the hopes of fostering middle class development and luring families back from the suburbs Another agency the St Louis Housing Authority had to clear land to construct public housing for the former slum dwellers 16 Design and construction edit By 1950 St Louis had received a federal commitment under the Housing Act of 1949 to finance 5 800 public housing units 17 The first large public housing in St Louis Cochran Gardens was completed in 1953 It contained 704 units in a mix of medium and high rise buildings It was followed by three more projects Pruitt Igoe Vaughn and Darst Webbe 18 Pruitt Igoe was named for St Louisans Wendell O Pruitt an African American fighter pilot in World War II and William L Igoe a former US Congressman 19 Originally the city planned two partitions Pruitt for black residents and Igoe for whites 20 as St Louis public housing was segregated until 1955 21 In 1950 the city picked Leinweber Yamasaki amp Hellmuth an architectural firm based in St Louis to design the new public housing complex The project was led by architect Minoru Yamasaki then early in his career 2 and performed under supervision and constraints imposed by the federal authorities His initial proposal which included walk up and mid rise buildings as well as high rises was accepted by the St Louis authorities but exceeded the federal cost limits imposed by the Public Housing Administration the agency intervened and imposed a uniform building height of 11 floors 16 Shortages of materials caused by the Korean War and tensions in the Congress further tightened federal controls 16 Overall density was set at a level of 50 units per acre 22 higher than in downtown slums 16 Although each row of buildings was supposed to be flanked by a river of open space 23 landscaping was omitted from the final plan and few trees were planted 22 Construction began in 1951 24 Pruitt accepted its first tenants in November 1954 Igoe in July 1955 25 When the two projects opened they were one of the largest public housing developments in the country 26 Even under federal cost cutting regulations Pruitt Igoe initially cost 36 million 27 60 percent above the national average for public housing one factor was the installation of an expensive heating system 28 Despite the poor build quality material suppliers cited Pruitt Igoe in their advertisements to capitalize on the national exposure of the project 8 Early years edit Pruitt Igoe was initially seen as a breakthrough in urban renewal 8 One early resident described her 11th floor apartment as a poor man s penthouse 29 Pruitt Igoe was officially desegregated by a Supreme Court decision in 1954 21 and as many as 40 percent of the initial tenants were white 30 but by the mid 1960s it had become exclusively African American 31 Decline edit By 1958 just four years after the opening of the project deteriorating conditions were already evident 32 Elevator breakdowns and vandalism were cited as major problems 33 Yamasaki later lamented that he never thought people were that destructive 34 Ventilation was poor despite St Louis s hot and humid summers 35 Meanwhile the St Louis Housing Authority was in the midst of a decades long problem with inefficient and costly maintenance of its buildings partly attributed to the power of labor unions 36 The stairwells and corridors attracted muggers a situation exacerbated by the skip stop elevators 33 Its location in a sea of decaying and abandoned buildings and limited access to shopping and recreation ground floor businesses had been eliminated from the design to save money 22 and the complex had no public mailbox 37 contributed to its problems 38 The huge 11 story buildings of the development were reportedly a magnet for criminals and vagrants from the surrounding low rise slums 38 a 1959 audit reported that most of the vandalism was done by transients rather than residents 39 and a 1967 report similarly found that a relatively large proportion of crimes were committed by outsiders 40 Large criminal gangs were not common in the project 41 The Recession of 1958 led to increased crime vacancy and rent delinquency in the development which cut into the housing authority s revenue In response the authority reduced maintenance by 10 percent and the reduction in maintenance coupled with a grand jury report that criticized crime levels in Pruitt Igoe caused a significant drop in applications to the development 42 Increasing vacancy rates set off a feedback loop where the loss of revenue from rent forced the housing authority to curtail maintenance further reducing the project s desirability 33 Occupancy at both Pruitt and Igoe peaked in the first years at 95 and 86 percent respectively In the 1960s Pruitt remained about 75 percent full and Igoe 65 percent In 1969 those numbers fell to 57 1 percent and 48 9 percent 43 at one point the vacancy rate was higher than any other public housing complex in the country 20 The annual turn over rate was 20 percent 6 After 1960 the rental income from Pruitt Igoe failed to cover the cost of operation forcing the housing authority to tap into its reserves and causing cutbacks at other developments which were themselves profitable 44 Attempts by local authorities to improve living conditions were handicapped by lack of resources though numerous programs including the hiring of private security rent incentives to attract new tenants and grants for academic studies were tried 45 As the financial position of the authority worsened it raised the minimum rent from 20 a month in 1952 to 32 in 1958 43 in 1962 and 58 in 1968 The increases forced some families to devote as much as 75 percent of their income to rent 46 In addition to the rent increases tenants were charged for basic services like replacing fuses and door locks 47 The rent increases were a major factor in a nine month rent strike by tenants in 1969 33 The strike began on February 2 at other public housing projects in the city 48 and spread to Pruitt Igoe by April 1 49 It ended with a settlement under which the board of commissioners of the housing authority resigned and tenant organizations were granted more influence 50 In 1965 the project received a federal grant to improve the physical condition of the buildings and establish social programs for residents but the grant failed to reverse the decline 33 Between 1963 and 1966 it was the subject of a sociological study by Lee Rainwater 51 In 1966 the Pruitt Igoe Neighborhood Corporation commissioned a survey of the housing project that catalogued numerous issues with its maintenance security and management 52 Basic services like elevators and heating often failed and maintenance sometimes took years to respond to tenant requests 53 The withdrawal in 1967 of a private security force that patrolled the buildings led to a further escalation in crime and vandalism 54 which was partially attributed to the large number of juveniles in single parent households 55 a census undertaken in September 1965 found that 69 2 percent of inhabitants were minors and less than 30 percent of households with children had both parents present 56 Teenage pregnancy and juvenile delinquency were considered major problems by the residents 57 Families at Pruitt Igoe were large the average household had four minors Nearly half of births and 73 percent of first born children were out of wedlock though this statistic was no higher in Pruitt Igoe than in nearby private housing 58 In spite of the widespread issues most inhabitants of Pruitt Igoe continued to live ordinary lives 59 and according to Rainwater and activist Joan Miller the vast majority responded to their sick society in a healthy manner 60 78 percent of residents reported that they were satisfied with their apartment and 80 percent said that Pruitt Igoe met their needs a little better or much better than their previous place of residence 61 The project contained isolated pockets of well being throughout its worst years and apartments clustered around small two family landings with tenants working to maintain and clear their common areas were often relatively successful 62 Demolition edit nbsp The second widely televised demolition of a Pruitt Igoe building on April 21 1972 In 1968 the federal Department of Housing of Urban Development HUD began encouraging the remaining residents to leave Pruitt Igoe 63 A 1970 report assessed the extent of the physical damage to the buildings as nearly unbelievable and far worse than in the other St Louis projects 64 Many buildings had been practically ransacked with broken windows and doors walls stripped for wire and pipe and garbage strewn about the site Only 10 of the original 33 buildings were still occupied 65 In December 1971 state and federal authorities agreed to demolish two of the Pruitt Igoe buildings They hoped that a gradual reduction in population and building density could improve the situation by this time Pruitt Igoe had consumed 57 million an investment which they felt could not be wholly abandoned 27 Authorities considered different possibilities for rehabilitating Pruitt Igoe including conversion to a low rise neighborhood by collapsing the towers down to a few floors to reduce the density 27 After 1971 most tenants were consolidated into the Igoe section Despite the impending demolition more than 1 million was spent on renovation in the 1970s mainly funded by grants from the federal government 66 After months of preparation the first building was demolished with explosives on March 16 1972 More buildings followed on April 21 June 9 and July 15 27 67 HUD announced in August 1973 their decision to demolish the rest of the complex A last minute attempt to purchase and rehabilitate a few of the buildings by a neighborhood community development corporation was rejected by HUD The last tenant moved out in May 1974 and the project was fully cleared by 1976 at a total cost of 3 5 million becoming the first major housing projects in the United States to be demolished 68 69 Footage of the demolition was featured in the film Koyaanisqatsi 70 Site edit Since Pruitt Igoe s demolition various plans have been put forth for the use of its site including a golf course a business park 71 and a 50 story tower 72 An elementary school was built on part of the site in 1995 71 but as of 2023 update most of it remains vacant 73 even as adjacent lots have been redeveloped 74 In 2020 Ponce Health Sciences University announced its intention to construct an 80 million facility on the site 75 When completed the facility is planned to house the Ponce Health Sciences University School of Medicine in St Louis 76 In 2021 a developer submitted zoning applications for the construction of office buildings and a hotel on the site 77 An urgent care center named after the former Homer G Phillips Hospital was built in 2022 78 but restrictions related to the construction of a new headquarters for the National Geospatial Intelligence Agency on an adjacent lot were reportedly stalling the redevelopment of the site 79 Legacy editPruitt Igoe has received extensive commentary in the architectural literature 80 architect William Ramroth describes it as the most infamous public housing disaster in American history and a poster child for the failures of public housing projects 19 Nonetheless the initial reception of Pruitt Igoe was positive although contrary to popular belief the project never won any architectural awards 81 In 1951 before construction had finished an Architectural Forum article lauded Yamasaki s original proposal 5 praising the layout as vertical neighborhoods for poor people 8 and Yamasaki biographer Paul Kidder appraised it as an amazingly ambitious effort to turn the embarrassment of tenement squalor in a great American city into something decent and good 82 Although Yamasaki s design followed modernist conventions and was influenced by Le Corbusier s ville radieuse concept 11 many design decisions were imposed by federal authorities including vetoing the original proposal of a mix of structures of different heights 16 Even before the completion of the project Yamasaki was skeptical that high rise buildings would be beneficial to tenants stating that The low building with low density is unquestionably more satisfactory than multi story living 83 Nonetheless he defended the high rise design as a practical necessity for clearing slums 83 Criticism of the project s architectural design began in the 1960s 33 The skip stop elevators forced many residents to use the stairwells where muggings were frequent 84 The galleries which were unpainted unfurnished and dimly lit served as hang outs for criminal gangs rather than communal spaces 85 The landscaping intended to make Pruitt Igoe towers in the park was cut from the final plan and the surrounding area subsequently turned to wasteland 22 In addition to the architectural flaws the overall quality of construction was extremely poor the buildings were described by housing researcher Eugene Meehan as little more than steel and concrete rabbit warrens poorly designed badly equipped inadequate in size badly located unventilated and virtually impossible to maintain 35 After the demolition of the first buildings in 1972 Pruitt Igoe received wider attention and began to be perceived as a failure of modernist architecture as a whole 33 By the late 1970s this view had coalesced into architectural dogma 86 especially for the nascent movements of postmodern architecture and environment and behavior architecture 87 Postmodern architectural historian Charles Jencks called its destruction the day Modern architecture died and considered it a direct indictment of the society changing aspirations of the International school of architecture and an example of modernists intentions running contrary to real world social development 1 Pruitt Igoe served as a case study for Oscar Newman s concept of defensible space in which structures are laid out so that residents have control and responsibility over their surroundings Newman criticized the large spaces shared by dozens of families as anonymous public spaces that made it impossible for even neighboring residents to develop an accord about acceptable behavior and attributed Pruitt Igoe s social problems to its high rise design and lack of defensible space contrasting it unfavorably with the adjacent Carr Village a low rise area with a similar demographic makeup that remained fully occupied and largely trouble free in the same period 88 Newman s analysis was one of the most influential in attributing the project s failure to environmentally determined architecture 89 Other critics argue that the Pruitt Igoe s architecture has been overemphasized compared to political and social factors 89 a view prominently advanced by Katharine Bristol at the time a doctoral student in architecture in a 1991 article titled The Pruitt Igoe Myth 11 While acknowledging flaws in the project s design Bristol cited the underfunding of public housing and consequent inability for the housing authority to properly maintain the buildings and the deleterious effects of poverty and racial discrimination on its residents as crucial factors in Pruitt Igoe s decline 90 The steep fall in St Louis s population exacerbated the project s vacancy problem instead of growing from 850 000 in the 1940s to 1 million in 1970 as projected the city lost 30 percent of its residents in that timespan due to suburbanization and white flight 11 as well as 11 000 manufacturing jobs in an overall shift from a blue collar to white collar economy 80 The Pruitt Igoe Myth a 2011 documentary film largely followed Bristol s view 11 In his book length study of St Louis public housing policy Eugene Meehan assessed the root cause as a set of policies programmed for failure 91 in particular the requirement of the Housing Act of 1949 that local housing authorities pay their expenses from rental income which made them vulnerable to fiscal problems 92 The mindless concentration on dollar costs and voracious and inefficient local construction industry also contributed to the project s maintenance woes 6 Widespread voter opposition to public housing both locally and nationally created a hostile climate that limited financial assistance from the government 93 in turn the eventual failure of the project contributed to the further unpopularity of public housing both locally 94 and nationally 89 According to The Architectural Review the modern consensus is that the underfunded project was doomed from the outset 2 The failure and demolition of Pruitt Igoe damaged Yamasaki s reputation as an architect and he personally regretted designing the buildings 2 See also edit nbsp Missouri portal Panel house in various former communist countries in Eastern Europe Regent Park in Toronto Canada St James Town in Toronto Canada Ballymun Flats in Dublin Ireland Conjunto Urbano Nonoalco Tlatelolco in Mexico City Mexico Bijlmermeer in Amsterdam Netherlands Red Road Flats in Glasgow United Kingdom Roundshaw Estate in Wallington Sutton United Kingdom Aylesbury Estate in London United Kingdom Robin Hood Gardens in Poplar London United Kingdom Cabrini Green in Chicago Illinois Robert Taylor Homes in Chicago Illinois Glenny Drive Apartments in Buffalo New York Father Panik Village in Bridgeport Connecticut Brewster Douglass Housing Projects in Detroit Michigan Vele di Scampia in Scampia Napoli Italy Million Programme in SwedenReferences edit a b Jencks 1984 p 9 a b c d Gyure 2019 a b Bristol 1991 pp 163 164 Kidder 2022 p 47 a b Meehan 1979 p 67 a b c Meehan 1979 p 72 Wilensky Harry September 9 1956 The Fight Against Decay St Louis Post Dispatch p 142 Retrieved April 28 2022 via Newspapers com a b c d e Ramroth 2007 p 164 Meehan 1979 pp 70 72 James P Hubbard Decent Safe and Sanitary Dwellings The National Conversation About Public Housing 2018 a b c d e Cendon 2012 a b c d Larsen amp Kirkendall 2004 p 60 Meehan 1979 pp 56 58 Ramroth 2007 p 169 Larsen amp Kirkendall 2004 p 61 a b c d e Bristol 1991 p 164 Meehan 1979 p 64 Meehan 1979 pp 67 74 a b Ramroth 2007 p 163 a b Rainwater 1970 p 8 a b Meehan 1979 p 85 a b c d Ramroth 2007 p 170 Hall 2004 p 256 Montgomery 1985 p 231 Igoe Homes First Families Move Into 72 Unit Apartment Building St Louis Post Dispatch July 23 1955 p 3 Retrieved April 28 2022 via Newspapers com Larsen amp Kirkendall 2004 p 62 a b c d Ramroth 2007 p 165 Meehan 1979 p 71 73 Kimmelman Michael January 25 2012 Towers of Dreams One Ended in Nightmare The New York Times Retrieved March 29 2022 Segregation Banned Here in Public Housing Projects St Louis Globe Democrat December 29 1955 p 1 Retrieved April 28 2022 via Newspapers com Rainwater 1970 p 10 Bristol 1991 p 165 a b c d e f g Bristol 1991 p 166 Marshall Colin April 22 2015 Pruitt Igoe the troubled high rise that came to define urban America The Guardian Retrieved March 27 2022 a b Meehan 1979 p 73 Meehan 1979 p 63 Miller amp Rainwater 1967 p 4 a b Meehan 1979 p 68 Meehan 1979 p 78 Miller amp Rainwater 1967 p 9 Rainwater 1970 p 282 Meehan 1979 p 78 79 Meehan 1979 p 77 Meehan 1979 p 76 Meehan 1979 pp 79 81 Meehan 1979 p 83 Miller amp Rainwater 1967 p 8 Pruitt Igoe Leaders Split Over Joining Rent Strike St Louis Post Dispatch March 17 1969 p 12 Retrieved April 28 2022 via Newspapers com Rent Strike Spreads to Pruitt Igoe St Louis Post Dispatch March 12 1969 p 3 Retrieved April 28 2022 via Newspapers com Meehan 1979 pp 91 92 Rainwater 1970 p vii Miller amp Rainwater 1967 pp 6 7 Miller amp Rainwater 1967 pp 7 8 Meehan 1979 p 97 Meehan 1979 pp 86 87 Rainwater 1970 pp 13 14 Rainwater 1970 pp 57 64 Rainwater 1970 p 215 Rainwater 1970 p 12 Miller amp Rainwater 1967 p 6 Rainwater 1970 p 11 Newman 1996 p 11 Ramroth 2007 p 171 Meehan 1979 p 94 96 Meehan 1979 p 96 Meehan 1979 p 112 Taking a Tumble St Louis Post Dispatch June 10 1972 p 3A Retrieved August 24 2022 Montgomery 1985 pp 232 233 Meehan 1979 p 56 112 Why the Pruitt Igoe housing project failed The Economist October 15 2011 Retrieved October 17 2011 a b Brown Sylvester May 8 2005 School on Pruitt Igoe land is testament to area s past residents determination St Louis Post Dispatch ProQuest 402578777 Barker Jacob August 14 2016 McKee buys Pruitt Igoe site a symbol of St Louis s decline and now rebirth St Louis Post Dispatch ProQuest 1811169215 Barker Jacob March 2 2023 Development of former Pruitt Igoe site near St Louis new NGA campus advances St Louis Post Dispatch ProQuest 2781262277 Brown Sylvester March 1 2005 Development plans for Pruitt Igoe site quietly faded away St Louis Post Dispatch ProQuest 402551048 Ruff Corinne March 16 2020 For Profit Medical School Plots 80 Million North St Louis Facility St Louis Public Radio From Triage to Recovery Pruitt Igoe Becomes New Medical Campus in St Louis United States Environmental Protection Agency July 5 2022 Barker Jacob Kukuljan Steph Schlinkmann Mark September 24 2021 McKee Clayco plan office buildings and hotel on Pruitt Igoe site near new NGA headquarters St Louis Post Dispatch ProQuest 2575847796 Kull Katie July 15 2022 Nurses group sues to stop Homer G Phillips from being used on St Louis hospital St Louis Post Dispatch ProQuest 2689565965 Barker Jacob March 14 2022 Measure to control development around new NGA campus in north St Louis advances St Louis Post Dispatch ProQuest 2638699647 a b Comerio 1981 p 26 Bristol 1991 p 168 Kidder 2022 p 4 a b Yamasaki 1952 p 226 Rainwater 1970 p 10 11 Ramroth 2007 pp 170 171 Bristol 1991 p 169 Bristol 1991 p 170 Newman 1996 pp 9 11 a b c Montgomery 1985 p 239 Bristol 1991 p 167 Meehan 1979 p 1 Meehan 1979 pp 64 65 Meehan 1979 p 65 Mendelson amp Quinn 1985 p 163 Sources edit Books edit Hall Peter Geoffrey 2004 Cities of Tomorrow An Intellectual History of Urban Planning and Design in the Twentieth Century Wiley John amp Sons Incorporated ISBN 978 0 631 23252 0 Jencks Charles 1984 The Language of Post Modern Architecture Rizzoli ISBN 978 0 8478 0571 6 Kidder Paul 2022 Minoru Yamasaki and the Fragility of Architecture Routledge ISBN 978 0 367 62952 6 Larsen Lawrence Harold Kirkendall Richard Stewart 2004 A History of Missouri 1953 to 2003 University of Missouri Press ISBN 978 0 8262 1546 8 Meehan Eugene 1979 The Quality of Federal Policymaking Programmed Failure in Public Housing University of Missouri Press ISBN 0 8262 0272 1 Mendelson Robert E Quinn Michael A 1985 Residential Patterns in a Midwestern City The Saint Louis Experience The Metropolitan Midwest University of Illinois Press ISBN 978 0 252 01114 6 Montgomery Roger 1985 Pruitt Igoe Policy Failure or Societal Symptom The Metropolitan Midwest University of Illinois Press ISBN 978 0 252 01114 6 Newman Oscar 1996 Creating Defensible Space US Department of Housing and Urban Development Office of Policy Development and Research ISBN 978 0 7881 4528 5 Rainwater Lee 1970 Behind Ghetto Walls Black Families in a Federal Slum Aldine Publishing Company ISBN 978 0 202 30907 1 Ramroth William G 2007 Planning for Disaster How Natural and Man made Disasters Shape the Built Environment Kaplan Publishing ISBN 978 1 4195 9373 4 Articles edit Bristol Katharine May 1991 The Pruitt Igoe Myth Journal of Architectural Education 44 3 163 171 doi 10 1080 10464883 1991 11102687 ISSN 1531 314X S2CID 219542179 Cendon Sara Fernandez February 3 2012 Pruitt Igoe 40 Years Later American Institute of Architects Archived from the original on March 14 2014 Retrieved December 31 2014 Comerio Mary C Summer 1981 Pruitt Igoe and Other Stories Journal of Architectural Education 34 4 26 31 doi 10 1080 10464883 1981 10758667 Gyure Dale Allen February 21 2019 Minoru Yamasaki 1912 1986 The Architectural Review Retrieved March 27 2022 Miller Joan Rainwater Lee October 1967 Frances A Koestler ed Pruitt Igoe Survival in a Concrete Ghetto Social Work 12 4 3 13 doi 10 1093 sw 12 4 3 Yamasaki Minoru 1952 High Buildings for public housing Journal of Housing 9 7 Further reading edit Birmingham Elizabeth 1998 Reframing the Ruins Pruitt Igoe Structural Racism and African American Rhetoric as a Space for Cultural Critique Positionen 2 2 Bristol Kate Montgomery Roger 1987 Pruitt Igoe An Annotated Bibliography Council of Planning Librarians ISBN 978 0 86602 205 7 Cornetet James 2013 Facadomy A Critique on Capitalism and Its Assault on Mid Century Modern Architecture Process Press ISBN 978 0 9888108 0 8 Fishman Robert 2004 Rethinking Public Housing Places 16 2 ISSN 0731 0455 Pipkin John S et al 1983 Remaking the City SUNY Press ISBN 978 0 87395 677 2 von Hoffman Alexander Why They Built the Pruitt Igoe Project Joint Center for Housing Studies Harvard University Archived from the original on August 30 2002 External links edit nbsp Wikimedia Commons has media related to Pruitt Igoe Pruitt Igoe photographs University of Missouri St Louis Before and After Pruitt Igoe Pruitt Igoe Now Retrieved from https en wikipedia org w index php title Pruitt Igoe amp oldid 1209239220, wikipedia, wiki, book, books, library,

article

, read, download, free, free download, mp3, video, mp4, 3gp, jpg, jpeg, gif, png, picture, music, song, movie, book, game, games.