Palace of Justice, Brussels

The Palace of Justice of Brussels (French: Palais de Justice de Bruxelles, pronounced [pa.lɛ d(ə) ʒys.tis də bʁy.sɛl]; Dutch: Justitiepaleis van Brussel^ⓘ) or Law Courts of Brussels^[b] is a courthouse in Brussels, Belgium. It is the country's most important court building, seat of the judicial arrondissement of Brussels, as well as of several courts and tribunals, including the Court of Cassation (Belgian supreme court), the Court of Assizes (highest criminal court), the Court of Appeal of Brussels (appellate court), the Tribunal of First Instance of Brussels (general jurisdiction), and the Bar Association of Brussels.

Palace of Justice of Brussels
Palais de Justice de Bruxelles (French) Justitiepaleis van Brussel (Dutch)
View of the Palace of Justice from The Hotel Brussels (then Hilton) in 2009
Alternative names	Law Courts of Brussels
General information
Type	Courthouse
Architectural style	Eclectic Neoclassical
Address	Place Poelaert / Poelaertplein 1
Town or city	1000 City of Brussels, Brussels-Capital Region
Country	Belgium
Coordinates	50°50′12″N 4°21′06″E / 50.83667°N 4.35167°E / 50.83667; 4.35167
Current tenants	Belgian courts
Construction started	31 October 1866 (31 October 1866)
Inaugurated	15 October 1883
Renovated	1947–48 (partial reconstruction) 1984–present
Cost	50 million Belgian francs^[a]
Client	Belgian Government
Owner	Belgian Government
Height	105 m (344 ft)
Dimensions
Diameter	160 m × 150 m (520 ft × 490 ft)
Technical details
Floor area	26,000 m^2 (280,000 sq ft)
Design and construction
Architect(s)	1860–1879: Joseph Poelaert 1879–1883: Joseph Joachim Benoît
Other designers	François Wellens [fr]
Designations	Protected (03/05/2001)
Other information
Public transit access	Metro: Louise/Louiza (lines 2 and 6) Tram: Louise/Louiza (lines 8 and 92)
Website
Official website
References
^[1]

Designed by the architect Joseph Poelaert, in an eclectic style of Greco-Roman inspiration, to replace an older courthouse,^[2] the current building was erected between 1866 and 1883. With a ground surface of 26,006 m² (279,930 sq ft), the edifice is reputed to be the largest constructed in the 19th century and remains one of the largest of its kind.^[3] The total cost of the construction, land, and furnishings approximated 50 million Belgian francs.^[4][a] The building suffered heavy damage during World War II, when the cupola was destroyed and later rebuilt higher than the original. The structure has been under renovation since 1984 and scaffolding from that era still hangs on the building, though it is set to come down in 2024.^[5]

The Palace of Justice is located on the Place Poelaert/Poelaertplein in the Marolles/Marollen district (southern part of Brussels' city centre). A notable landmark of Brussels, this site is served by Louise/Louiza metro station (on lines 2 and 6 of the Brussels Metro), as well as the homonymous tram stop (on lines 8 and 92).^[6][7] From the lower part of town, it is also possible to take the public Poelaert Elevators up to the square.^[8]

History

First courthouse (1818–1892)

The current Palace of Justice is located on the Galgenberg hill (French: Mont aux potences; "Gallows Mount"), between Brussels' upper and lower town, where in the Middle Ages convicted criminals were hanged, hence its name.^[9] A first courthouse had been erected, at a different location, in the Sablon/Zavel district, on the Place du Palais/Paleisplein (today's Place de la Justice/Gerechtsplein), between the Rue de l'Empereur/Keizerstraat (today's Boulevard de l'Empereur/Keizerlaan) and the (now-disappeared) Rue d'Or/Guldenstraat.^[10]

Built between 1818 and 1823 by the French architect François Verly [fr] on the site of a former Jesuit church,^[11] this first neoclassical structure had quickly deteriorated, and the question of building a new and larger courthouse arose as early as 1837. The condition was that the building could accommodate all civil and military jurisdictions under one roof.^[2] The choice of location, however, gave rise to heated controversies. It was indeed initially planned to rebuild it in the same place, but this project, the cost of which was estimated at 3 million Belgian francs,^[c] quickly aborted.^[12] The idea of building it in the newly developed Leopold Quarter in the eastern part of town was no more successful. In 1846–47, another reconstruction project was also buried.

•  
  The former Palace of Justice (Verly, 1823) on the Place du Palais/Paleisplein
•  
  Beginning of the former Palace of Justice's demolition (1892)
•  
  Demolition in progress and construction of the Rue Lebeau/Lebeaustraat (1892)

Inception of the project (1858–1866)

In 1858, the then-Minister of Justice, Victor Tesch, suggested for the first time the gardens of the House of Merode, where the extension of the Rue de la Régence/Regentschapsstraat would be constructed. The governor of the Province of Brabant suggested that it would be possible at the same time to link the new Louise/Louiza district to the city centre. Following a proposal from the advisor to the Court of Appeal, Gustave Bosquet [nl], aiming at installing the building perpendicular to the Rue de la Régence rather than to the right of this extension,^[13] a study was entrusted to the Chief Engineer Groetaers. In his report, Groetaers recommended to erect a building of 26,000 m² (280,000 sq ft), with a 100 m (330 ft) fronting facing a 100 m square. Disagreements having arisen between Groetaers and the city's mayor, the latter called for a competition for the building's design.^[14]

 

The Palace of Justice's architect, Joseph Poelaert

On 27 March 1860, an international architectural competition, endowed with three prizes, was therefore organised by royal decree.^[15] After several failed proposals, Tesch appointed the city's municipal architect, Joseph Poelaert, to draw plans of the building in 1861.^[16] The architect already enjoyed an excellent reputation, having to his credit a series of very prestigious projects in the capital, such as the commemorative Congress Column (1850), the Church of St. Catherine (1854) and the restoration of the Royal Theatre of La Monnaie (1855).^[17]

In April 1862, Poelaert submitted a preliminary draft, which was approved by Tesch. It was then in Paris, far from the pressures and influences of Brussels, that Poelaert withdrew to put the final touches to his plans. There, he gathered a team of designers including Charles Laisné [fr] and Édouard Corroyer. Given the prominent place that the Palace of Justice was called upon to occupy in the urban landscape, Poelaert opted for an eclectic style of Greco-Roman inspiration. Although he was inspired by classicism, he created a totally personal and original work.^[2]

Construction (1866–1883)

The first stone was laid on 31 October 1866.^[18] At Poelaert's request, the management of the works was entrusted to the engineer François Wellens [fr], Inspector General of the Ministry of Public Works and President of the Royal Commission of Monuments between 1865 and 1897.^[19][17] After Poelaert's death on 3 November 1879, the construction was taken over by the architect Joseph Joachim Benoît.^[17] The building was inaugurated on 15 October 1883 by King Leopold II in the presence of his wife Queen Marie-Henriette, his daughter Princess Clémentine, and members of the Belgian royal family.^[20][3] As for the old courthouse, it was demolished in 1892 for the construction of the Rue Lebeau/Lebeaustraat, which leads into the Place de la Justice.^[21]

For the Palace of Justice's construction, a section of the Marolles/Marollen neighbourhood was demolished, while most of the garden belonging to the House of Merode was also expropriated.^[22] The 75 landlords belonging to the nobility and the high bourgeoisie, many of whom lived in their homes,^[23] received large indemnities, while the other more modest inhabitants, about a hundred, were also forced to move by the Belgian Government, though they were compensated with houses in the Tillens-Roosendael garden city (French: cité-jardin Tillens-Roosendael) in the Quartier du Chat in the Uccle municipality.^[24]

Poelaert himself resided in the Marolles, only a few hundred metres from the building, on the Rue des Minimes/Minimenstraat, in a house adjoining his vast offices and workshops and communicating with them.^[25][26] It is thus unlikely he saw himself as ruining the neighbourhood. Nonetheless, many angry citizens personally blamed Poelaert for the forced relocations, and the expression schieven architect (meaning "shameful architect") became one of the most serious insults in the dialect of the Marolles.^[9] Although the construction took place during the reign of Leopold II, the king showed little interest in the building, and it is not considered part of his extensive architectural programme in Brussels nor his legacy as the "Builder-King".^[27][28]

•  
  Development plan (1866)
•  
  Groundwork (1867)
•  
  Assemblage of the scaffolding (1875)
•  
  Last stone laying (1882)

Damage and renovation (1945–present)

 

The Palace of Justice on a pre-1944 postcard. Note the lower dome.

At the end of the Second World War, on the eve of the liberation of Brussels, the retreating German forces started a fire in the Palace of Justice in order to destroy it, as well as the legal records it contained. As a result, the cupola collapsed and part of the building was heavily damaged. The explosion of a V-1 rocket in the Rue des Minimes two months later caused additional damage.^[29] In 1947, the restoration work was entrusted to the architect-engineer and custodian of the Palace, Albert Storrer [fr].^[30][31] By 1948, most of the building was repaired, and the cupola was rebuilt 2.5 metres (8 ft 2 in) higher than the original, whose somewhat flat shape had previously been criticised.^[32]

Renovations on the building have been in progress since 1984.^[33] These renovations pertain to the repair and strengthening of the roof structure and the walls, as well as putting a new layer on the gilded cupola. In 2002–03, the roofing was renewed and the structural structure was repaired and reinforced. On 1 September 2003, the protective foil was removed from the dome, thus becoming once again an eye-catcher in the skyline of Brussels.^[34] Progress is slow, however, and in 2013, it was reported that the decade-old scaffolding was so rusted and unsafe that the scaffolding itself was in need of renovation.^[35]

Since the end of the 20th century, many jurisdictions have successively left the Palace of Justice on the grounds that it no longer meets the criteria required for the exercise of contemporary justice, particularly in terms of the required workspace. The Government of the Brussels-Capital Region ended up issuing two designations orders, on 3 May 2001 and on 28 February 2008, "Because of its historical, artistic and technical interest". In 2008, a proposal was made for the building's recognition as a World Heritage Site by UNESCO.^[3] In 2016, the World Monuments Fund placed the courthouse on its list of endangered monuments.^[36] In 2018, following the collapse of part of the ceiling, Jean de Codt, first president of the Court of Cassation and highest magistrate in the country, spoke openly in the media to demand additional financial resources to ensure the building's sustainability and the safety of those who work there.^[37] Several plans have followed to find solutions to the dilapidated rooms and to security problems, but the work is expected to last for many more years, leaving the building's future uncertain. As of 2022, additional renovation plans have been announced, with completion expected now for "2024 or 2025".^[38]

Dimensions

Brussels' Palace of Justice was, at the time of its construction, the largest building in the world, and remains today one of the largest courthouses.^[3][d] The edifice is currently 160 by 150 metres (520 by 490 ft),^[3] and has a total built ground surface of 26,006 m² (279,930 sq ft),^[39] bigger than St. Peter's Basilica in Rome. The 105-metre-high (344 ft) dome weighs 24,000 tonnes (53,000,000 lb).^[40] The building has 8 courtyards with a surface of 6,000 m² (65,000 sq ft), 27 large court rooms and 245 smaller court rooms and other rooms. Situated on a hill with a steep incline, there is a level difference of 20 metres (66 ft) between the upper and lower town,^[41] which results in multiple entrances to the building at different levels.

The building includes huge interior statues of Demosthenes and Lycurgus by the sculptor Pierre Armand Cattier [fr], and figures of the Roman jurists Cicero and Ulpian by Antoine-Félix Bouré.^[42] The central portico, 39 metres (128 ft) high, is surmounted by a helmeted bust of the ancient Greek Titaness Themis, personification of divine law and order, by Joseph Ducaju [fr].^[43] Moreover, the impressive main hall or salle des pas perdus (lit. 'room of the lost steps') is around 3,600 m² (39,000 sq ft) including the first floor gallery: 90 metres (300 ft) long and 40 metres (130 ft) wide. A compass rose with sixteen rays marks the centre of the room.^[44]

Many questions remain on this project, which saw its budget exceed 50 million Belgian francs^[4][a] (which was equivalent to an entire year of public works in the country at the time) for an initial estimate of barely 4 million.^[e] The excessiveness of the site, and the freedom left to the architect to override almost all the rules initially imposed, remain a great mystery.

•  
  The monumental marble staircase
•  
  The main entry hall or salle des pas perdus
•  
  Interior view of the salle des pas perdus
•  
  One of the massive neoclassical doors
•  
  At the centre of the building looking upwards towards the dome

Usage

Further information: Judiciary of Belgium

The Palace of Justice is the most important court building in Belgium, seat of the country's different courts and tribunals, most notably the Court of Cassation, its supreme court. The Court of Cassation handles cases in the two main languages of Belgium, being Dutch and French, and provides certain facilities for cases in German. The Court of Assizes (criminal court that tries the most serious crimes), the Court of Appeal of Brussels (appellate court), as well as the Tribunal of First Instance of Brussels (general jurisdiction), also seat there. The Palace of Justice also includes within it the prosecution services adjoining these jurisdictions, as well as various libraries.^[45]

Courts and tribunals

• Court of Cassation: 1st president, Griffie-Clerck and Prosecution
• Court of Assizes
• Court of Appeal of Brussels: 1st president, Griffie-Clerck and Prosecution
• Tribunal of First Instance of Brussels

Libraries

• Library of the Magistrate
• Library of the Bar Association of Brussels
• Library of the Lawyers

Arrondissement of Brussels

Moreover, the Palace of Justice is the seat of the judicial arrondissement of Brussels (covering the entire Brussels-Capital Region), having split from the Flemish part of the former bilingual arrondissement of Brussels-Halle-Vilvoorde (BHV) in mid-2012 (which made Halle-Vilvoorde a monolingual Flemish electoral and judicial district).^[45]

Bar Association of Brussels

Finally, the Palace of Justice is also home to the Bar Association of Brussels (French: Barreau de Bruxelles, Dutch: Balie te Brussel), a professional order of 7,000 Brussels lawyers, founded on 14 December 1810. Since 1984, the Bar Association of Brussels has been split into two, the French-speaking order (Ordre français des Avocats du Barreau de Bruxelles)^[46] and the Dutch-speaking order (Nederlandse Orde van Advocaten te Brussel).^[47]

•  
  Standard courtroom of the Court of Cassation in the Palace of Justice
•  
  Old image of the Court's grand courtroom, used for larger sessions and judicial ceremonies
•  
  Logo of the Bar Association of Brussels (French-speaking order)

Surroundings

The Place Poelaert/Poelaertplein, in front of the Palace of Justice, is the largest square in Brussels, measuring 155 by 50 metres (509 by 164 ft). The initial development project, which provided for a large square in a semicircle (1862), could not be implemented due to Poelaert's sudden death. Consequently, this square does not have an architectural unity in the buildings that surrounds it, nor the belvedere coming from the original plan, and instead constitutes a vast transit space unsuitable for pedestrians, not functioning as an urban square but as a roundabout for cars preventing the appropriation of the place by walkers. In 1905, it was the scene of prestigious commemorations for the 75th anniversary of Belgian independence.^[48] Nowadays, it offers one of Brussels' finest views. From the elevated vantage point, the famous tower of Brussels' Town Hall on the Grand-Place/Grote Markt is clearly visible. On a sunny day, the Koekelberg Basilica and even the Atomium can be seen.

Next to the Palace of Justice, on the Place Poelaert, stand two war memorials: the Belgian Infantry Memorial by Edouard Vereycken (1935) and the Anglo-Belgian Memorial by Charles Sargeant Jagger (1923). In addition, the Poelaert Elevators,^[49] in popular language the Elevators of the Marolles,^[50][51][52] are a set of two public elevators that connects the upper and lower town between the Place Poelaert and the Square Breughel l'Ancien/Breughel de Oudeplein. They were executed by the AVA Architects office, under the coordination of the architect Patrice Neirinck, and were inaugurated in June 2002.

•  
  The Place Poelaert/Poelaertplein seen from the stairs of the Palace of Justice
•  
  Belgian Infantry Memorial (Vereycken, 1935)
•  
  Anglo-Belgian Memorial (Sargeant Jagger, 1923)
•  
  Poelaert Elevators (Neirinck, 2002)

Influence

 

The Palace of Justice of Lima, Peru, is inspired by that of Brussels.

There is a well-known story that Adolf Hitler was reportedly fond of the building. Albert Speer, the Minister of Armaments and War Production in Nazi Germany, stated in his book Inside the Third Reich that he had been dispatched to Brussels in 1940 to study the building.^[53]

Although lacking the dome and being much smaller, the Palace of Justice in Lima, Peru, which houses the Supreme Court of Peru, is based upon Brussels' Palace of Justice.^[54]

In popular culture

Books

• The Palace of Justice is represented in the album The Last Pharaoh, published in 2019, from the comic strip series Blake and Mortimer, in which it plays a central place of the plot.^[55]

See also

•  Belgium portal

• List of tallest structures built before the 20th century
• Neoclassical architecture in Belgium
• History of Brussels
• Belgium in the long nineteenth century

References

Footnotes

1. This amount is roughly equivalent to €317 million in 2020 when taking into account inflation.
2. French: Cour de Justice de Bruxelles; Dutch: Rechtbank van Brussel
3. Equivalent to €20 million in 2020 when taking into account inflation.
4. It was not until 1965 that it was surpassed as the largest building in the world by NASA's Vehicle Assembly Building (VAB) at Cape Canaveral.
5. Equivalent to €25 million in 2020 when taking into account inflation.

Citations

1. Région de Bruxelles-Capitale (2016). "Palais de Justice" (in French). Brussels. Retrieved 12 January 2022.
2. Vandenbreeden & Loits 2001, p. 24.
3. Centre, UNESCO World Heritage. "Le Palais de Justice de Bruxelles - UNESCO World Heritage Centre". whc.unesco.org. Retrieved 20 May 2018.
4. Vandenbreeden & Loits 2001, p. 42.
5. The Brussels Times (18 February 2023). "The unfathomable scale of justice". www.brusselstimes.com. Retrieved 18 February 2023.
6. "Line 8 to ROODEBEEK - STIB Mobile". m.stib.be. Retrieved 8 January 2022.
7. "Line 92 to FORT-JACO - STIB Mobile". m.stib.be. Retrieved 8 January 2022.
8. "Palais de Justice, Brussels - Opening hours, tickets and location". www.introducingbrussels.com. Retrieved 28 October 2019.
9. (in French). Belgian federal building registry. 29 September 2009. Archived from the original on 24 February 2011. Retrieved 12 August 2009.
10. "Place de la Justice". www.reflexcity.net. Retrieved 30 October 2021.
11. Snaet & Van Besien 2012, p. 78.
12. Vandendaele & Leblicq 1980, p. 251–260.
13. Vandendaele & Leblicq 1980, p. 263.
14. Vandendaele & Leblicq 1980, p. 268.
15. Vandenbreeden & Loits 2001, p. 14.
16. Vandenbreeden & Loits 2001, p. 15.
17. Snaet & Van Besien 2012, p. 79.
18. Vandenbreeden & Loits 2001, p. 20.
19. Vandenbreeden & Loits 2001, p. 25–26.
20. Vandenbreeden & Loits 2001, p. 32.
21. Vandenbreeden & Loits 2001, p. 11.
22. Vandendaele & Leblicq 1980, p. 270.
23. Vandendaele & Leblicq 1980, p. 166: Plan du géomètre Van Keerbergen indiquant les propriétés nécessaires à l'érection du Palais de Justice de Poelaert, 9 février 1863 (A.V.B., T.P., 26.242).
24. Quiévreux 1951, p. 257.
25. Vandendaele & Leblicq 1980, p. 166.
26. Mardaga 1994, p. 466.
27. Emerson 1980, p. 264. sfn error: no target: CITEREFEmerson1980 (help)
28. Demey 2009, p. 172.
29. Vandenbreeden & Loits 2001, p. 33.
30. Vandenbreeden & Loits 2001, p. 34–35.
31. Demey 2009, p. 187.
32. Vandenbreeden & Loits 2001, p. 35.
33. "Bruxelles redécouvre son palais de justice". Luxemburger Wort - Edition francophone (in French). 8 August 2019. Retrieved 29 October 2021.
34. Sports+, DH Les (30 August 2003). "La coupole du Palais de Justice à nouveau blinquante". DH Les Sports + (in French). Retrieved 13 January 2022.
35. "Stellingen Brussels justitiepaleis zelf aan restauratie toe" (in Dutch). De Standaard. 30 November 2013. Retrieved 23 June 2014.
36. "Brussels Palace of Justice". World Monuments Fund. Retrieved 29 October 2021.
37. "Délabrement du palais de justice: "désinvestissement" et "désorganisation" selon Jean de Codt". RTBF Info (in French). 6 September 2018. Retrieved 29 October 2021.
38. The Brussels Times (2 May 2022). "Brussels Justice Palace renovation delayed again as 15% of bricks must be replaced". www.brusselstimes.com. Retrieved 2 May 2022.
39. Vandenbreeden & Loits 2001, p. 21.
40. Vandenbreeden & Loits 2001, p. 28.
41. Vandenbreeden & Loits 2001, p. 41.
42. Vandenbreeden & Loits 2001, p. 35–36.
43. Van Win 2012, p. 272–273.
44. Vandenbreeden & Loits 2001, p. 38.
45. "Judiciary – Organization" (PDF). www.dekamer.be. Parliamentary information sheet № 22.00. Belgian Chamber of Representatives. 1 June 2014. Retrieved 8 November 2020.
46. "Home". Barreau de Bruxelles (in French). Retrieved 13 January 2022.
47. "Home". Balie Brussel (in Dutch). Retrieved 13 January 2022.
48. Bournons 2009, p. 34.
49. "Constructie van de Poelaertliften". Beliris (in Dutch). Retrieved 19 June 2021.
50. "Bruxelles La passerelle de l'ascenseur des Marolles est arrivée samedi Réconcilier le haut et le bas de la ville MODE D'EMPLOI". Le Soir Plus (in French). Retrieved 19 June 2021.
51. "Les ascenseurs des Marolles seront rénovés en 2021". BX1 (in French). 7 July 2020. Retrieved 19 June 2021.
52. "Lift Marollen in nieuw kleedje". www.bruzz.be (in Dutch). Retrieved 19 June 2021.
53. Speer 1995, p. 42.
54. "A PALACE FOR JUSTICE – A never-ending Belgian story". 4 November 2022.
55. "Palais de Justice (Rue de la Régence, Palais de Justice, François Schuiten, Le Dernier Pharaon)". www.reflexcity.net. Retrieved 7 November 2021.

Bibliography

• Bournons, Éric (2009). Bruxelles d'Antan. Bruxelles à travers la carte postale ancienne (in French). Paris: HC Éditions. ISBN 978-2-357-20017-3.
• Debes, Ilona Andrea (2021). Der vergessene Löwe - Anmerkungen zu einer Löwenfigur von Léandre Grandmoulin im Justizpalast von Brüssel in: "Mit Belgien ist das so eine Sache ..." - Resultate und Perspektiven der Historischen Belgienforschung (in German). Münster: Waxmann Verlag. ISBN 978-3-8309-4317-4.
• Demey, Thierry (2009). Léopold II (1865-1909). La marque royale sur Bruxelles (in French). Brussels: Badeaux. ISBN 978-2-9600414-8-4.
• Emerson, Barbara (1994). Léopold II, le royaume et l'empire (in French). Brussels: Duculot.
• Snaet, Joris; Van Besien, Elisabeth (2012). Le Palais de Justice de Bruxelles. Un tour de force monumental. Bruxelles Patrimoines (in French). Vol. 3–4. Brussels: Éditions de la Région de Bruxelles-Capitale.
• Speer, Albert (1995). Inside the Third Reich. R. and C. Winston (trans.). London: Weidenfeld & Nicolson. ISBN 978-1-84212-735-3.
• Quiévreux, Louis (1951). Bruxelles, notre capitale: histoire, folklore, archéologie (in French). Brussels: PIM-Services.
• Vandenbreeden, Jos; Loits, André (2001). Le Palais de Justice. Bruxelles, ville d'Art et d'Histoire (in French). Vol. 31. Brussels: Éditions de la Région de Bruxelles-Capitale. ISBN 978-2-930457-78-9.
• Vandendaele, Richard; Leblicq, Yvon (1980). Poelaert et son temps (exhibition catalogue) (in French). Brussels: Crédit Communal de Belgique.
• Van Win, Jean (2012). Bruxelles maçonnique. Faux mystères et vrais symboles (in French). Brussels: Télélivre. ISBN 978-2-930331-09-6.
• Le Patrimoine monumental de la Belgique: Bruxelles (PDF) (in French). Vol. 1C: Pentagone N-Z. Liège: Pierre Mardaga. 1994.

External links

•   Media related to Law Courts of Brussels at Wikimedia Commons
• (in Dutch) Justitiepaleis or (in French)