Moses Finley

Sir Moses Israel Finley FBA (born Finkelstein; 20 May 1912 – 23 June 1986) was an American-born British academic and classical scholar. His prosecution by the United States Senate Subcommittee on Internal Security during the 1950s, resulted in his relocation to England, where he became an English classical scholar and eventually master of Darwin College, Cambridge. His most notable publication is The Ancient Economy (1973) in which he argued that the economy in antiquity was governed by status and civic ideology, rather than rational economic motivations.

Sir Moses Finley Fellow of the British Academy
Born	Moses Israel Finkelstein (1912-05-20)20 May 1912 New York City, New York, United States
Died	23 June 1986(1986-06-23) (aged 74) Cambridge, Cambridgeshire, England
Spouse	Mary ​ (m. 1932⁠–⁠1986)​
Academic background
Alma mater	Syracuse University Columbia University
Academic work
Discipline	Classics
Sub-discipline	Ancient History Ancient Greece Economy of ancient Greece Roman economy
School or tradition	Frankfurt School
Institutions	Columbia University City College of New York Rutgers University Jesus College, Cambridge Faculty of Classics, University of Cambridge Darwin College, Cambridge
Doctoral students	Paul Millett

Personal life

Finley was born in 1912 in New York City to Nathan Finkelstein and Anna Katzenellenbogen. About 1946, he adopted the surname Finley.^[1] He was educated at Syracuse University, where, aged fifteen, he graduated magna cum laude in psychology, and at Columbia University. Although his M.A. was in public law, most of his published work concerned ancient history, especially the social and economic aspects of the classical world.

In 1932 Finley married Mary (née Moscowitz, who later changed to her mother's surname, Thiers), a schoolteacher, and the two enjoyed a happy and mutually reinforcing marriage. On the day of her death he suffered a cerebral haemorrhage, and he died the following day on 23 June 1986 at Addenbrooke's Hospital, Cambridge.^[1] The New York Times obituary adds: "He had suffered a stroke the previous day, an hour after learning of the death of his wife."^[2]

Career

United States

Finley taught at Columbia University and City College of New York, where he was influenced by members of the Frankfurt School who were working in exile in America. He then taught at Rutgers University.

On 5 September 1951, an ex-communist, Karl Wittfogel, testified before the House Un-American Activities Committee that Finley was a communist. On 28 March 1952, Finley appeared before the Committee and invoked the Fifth Amendment regarding his association with communism. On 7 September 1952, Lewis Webster Jones, the president of Rutgers University, announced his intention to appoint Trustee and Faculty Committees to review the cases of professors involved in government inquiries. On 15 November 1952, FBI Director J. Edgar Hoover met with Jones to discuss the cases. On 12 December 1952, Rutger's Board of Trustees resolution declared, "It shall be cause for immediate dismissal of any member of faculty or staff" to fail to co-operate with government inquiries. On 31 December 1952, Rutgers dismissed Finley.^[3] Rutgers University records show:

On 3 December 1952, the Special Faculty Committee issued a report stating there should be no charges against Heimlich or Finley and that the University should take no further action in the matter. However, the Trustees, who had the final say in the matter, issued a resolution on 12 December 1952: "it shall be cause for immediate dismissal of any member of faculty or staff" who invokes the Fifth Amendment before an investigatory body in refusing to answer questions relating to communist affiliations and that Professors Heimlich and Finley would be dismissed as of December of 31, 1952 unless they conformed to the new policy. Neither chose to do so. There was protest at the decision by members of the faculty, who formed an Emergency Committee on the matter.^[4]

In 1954, he appeared before the United States Senate Subcommittee on Internal Security, which asked him whether he had ever been a member of the Communist Party USA. He again invoked the Fifth Amendment and refused to answer.

Britain

Finley immigrated to Britain, where he was appointed university lecturer in classics at Cambridge (1955–1964) and, during 1957, elected to a fellowship at Jesus College. He was reader of ancient social and economic history (1964–1970), professor of ancient history (1970–1979) and master of Darwin College (1976–1982).^[5] He gave the 1974 Mortimer Wheeler Archaeological Lecture.^[6]

He broadened the scope of classical studies from philology to culture, economics, and society. He became a British subject in 1962, and a Fellow of the British Academy in 1971, and was knighted by Queen Elizabeth II during 1979. He was a doctorate adviser to Paul Millett, now a senior lecturer in Classics at the University of Cambridge.

Work

Among his works, The World of Odysseus (1954, revised ed. with additional essays 1978) proved seminal. In it, he applied the findings of ethnologists and anthropologists like Marcel Mauss to interpret Homer, a radical method that was thought by his publishers to require a reassuring introduction by an established classicist, Maurice Bowra. Paul Cartledge asserted in 1995, "... in retrospect Finley's work can be seen as the seed of the present flowering of anthropologically-related studies of ancient Greek culture and society".^[7]

Following the example of Karl Polanyi, Finley argued that the ancient economy should not be analysed using the concepts of modern economic science, because ancient man had no notion of the economy as a separate part of society, and because economic actions in antiquity were determined not primarily by economic, but by social concerns. This text was later criticized by, amongst others, Kevin Greene,^[8] who argues that Finley underplays the importance of technological innovation, and C. R. Whittaker,^[9] who rejects the concept of a "consumer city".

Bibliography

• Studies in Land and Credit in Ancient Athens, 500–200 B.C.: The Horos Inscriptions (1951).
• Economy and Society in Ancient Greece (1953).
• The World of Odysseus (1954).
• Aspects of Antiquity: Discoveries and Controversies (1960).^[10]
• The Ancient Greeks: An Introduction to Their Life and Thought (1963).
• A History of Sicily: Ancient Sicily to the Arab Conquest (1968).
• Aspects of Antiquity: Discoveries and Controversies (1968).
• Early Greece: The Bronze and Archaic Ages (1970).
• The Ancient Economy (1973).
• Democracy Ancient and Modern (1973).
• Studies in Ancient Society, editor (1974).
• The Use and Abuse of History (1975).
• Schliemann's Troy: One Hundred Years After (1975).
• Studies in Roman Property, editor (1976).
• The Olympic Games: The First Thousand Years, with H.W. Pleket (1976).
• Ancient Slavery and Modern Ideology (1980; expanded edition edited by Brent D. Shaw, 1998).
• The Legacy of Greece: A New Appraisal (1981).
• Authority and Legitimacy in the Classical City-State (1982).
• Politics in the Ancient World (1983).
• Ancient History: Evidence and Models (1985).
• A History of Sicily, with Denis Mack Smith & Christopher Duggan (1986; abridged from the 1968 edition).

Finley was also the editor of numerous volumes of essays on ancient history.

See also

• Morris U. Cohen
• Jack D. Foner
• Morris Schappes
• Rapp-Coudert Committee

Notes

1. "Finley, Sir Moses I.". Oxford Dictionary of National Biography (online ed.). Oxford University Press. doi:10.1093/ref:odnb/39807. (Subscription or UK public library membership required.)
2. McDowell, Edwin (11 July 1986). "Sir Moses I. Finley, A Scholar in the Classics". The New York Times. Retrieved 25 August 2012.
3. "Additional Resources – Timeline (Red Scare at Rutgers)". Rutgers University. June 1994. Archived from the original on 11 December 2012. Retrieved 25 August 2012.
4. "Inventory to the Records of the Rutgers University Office of the President (Lewis Webster Jones)". Rutgers University. June 1994. Retrieved 25 August 2012.
5. Article on Finley in the Oxford Dictionary of National Biography, 2004
6. Finley, M. I. (1975). (PDF). Proceedings of the British Academy. 60: 393–412. Archived from the original (PDF) on 24 June 2021. Retrieved 26 March 2021.
7. Cartledge, Paul. "The Greeks and Anthropology", Anthropology Today, Volume 10, Number 3. (1994), page 4 (available online 22 October 2006 at the Wayback Machine).
8. Greene, K. (2000). "Technological Innovation and Economic Progress in the Ancient World: M. I. Finley Reconsidered". Economic History Review. 53 (1): 29–59. doi:10.1111/1468-0289.00151.
9. Whittaker, C.R. (1990). "The Consumer city revisited: the vicus and the city". Journal of Roman Archaeology. 3: 110–118v. doi:10.1017/S1047759400010862. S2CID 162690405.
10. Moses I. Finley (1960). Aspects of Antiquity: Discoveries and Controversies. New York: Viking Press.

Further reading

• Derks, Hans. "The Ancient Economy: The Problem and the Fraud," The European Legacy, Volume 7, Number 5. (2002), pages 597–620.
• Hornblower, Simon. "A gift from whom?: [Moses Finley's book The World of Odysseus: Critical Essay]," Times Literary Supplement, 24 December 2004, pages 18–19.
• Morris, Ian. "Foreword [to the updated edition]," The Ancient Economy by Moses I. Finley. Berkeley; Los Angeles; London: University of California Press, 1999 (paperback, ISBN 0-520-21946-5), pages ix–xxxvi.
• Nafissi, Mohammad. "Class, embeddedness, and the modernity of ancient Athens," Comparative Studies in Society and History, Volume 46, Issue 2. (2004), pages 378–410.
• Nafissi, Mohammad. Ancient Athens and Modern Ideology: Value, Theory and Evidence in Historical Sciences. Max Weber, Karl Polanyi and Moses Finley (Bulletin of the Institute of Classical Studies. Supplement; 80). London: Institute of Classical Studies, School of Advanced Study, University of London, 2005 (paperback, ISBN 0-900587-91-1).
• Shaw, Brent D.; Saller, Richard P. Editors' introduction to Economy and society in ancient Greece (with Finley's up-to-date bibliography). London: Chatto & Windus, 1981 (hardcover, ISBN 0-7011-2549-7); New York: The Viking Press, 1982 (hardcover, ISBN 0-670-28847-0); London: Penguin Books, 1983 (paperback, ISBN 0-14-022520-X).
• Silver, Morris. of The Ancient Economy, edited by Walter Scheidel and Sitta von Reden", Economic History Services, 3 January 2003.
• Watson, George. "The man from Syracuse: Moses Finley (1912–1986)," Sewanee Review, Volume 112, Issue 1. (2004), pages 131–137.

External links

 

Wikiquote has quotations related to Moses Finley.

• Moses Finley at the Database of Classical Scholars
• "Inventory to the Records of the Rutgers University Office of the President (Lewis Webster Jones)". Rutgers University. June 1994. Retrieved 25 August 2012.
• "Additional Resources – Timeline". Rutgers University. June 1994. Archived from the original on 11 December 2012. Retrieved 25 August 2012.
• Lancaster University Photo of Moses Finley

Academic offices
Preceded by A. H. M. Jones	Professor of Ancient History, Cambridge University 1970–1979	Succeeded by John Anthony Crook
Preceded by Frank George Young	Master of Darwin College, Cambridge 1976–1982	Succeeded by Arnold Burgen