Mentmore Towers

Mentmore Towers, historically known simply as "Mentmore", is a 19th-century English country house built between 1852 and 1854 for the Rothschild family in the village of Mentmore in Buckinghamshire. Sir Joseph Paxton and his son-in-law, George Henry Stokes,^[1][2] designed the building in the 19th-century revival of late 16th and early 17th-century Elizabethan and Jacobean styles called Jacobethan.^[3][4] The house was designed for the banker and collector of fine art Baron Mayer de Rothschild as a country home, and as a display case for his collection of fine art. The mansion has been described as one of the greatest houses of the Victorian era.^[5][6] Mentmore was inherited by Hannah Primrose, Countess of Rosebery, née Rothschild, and owned by her descendants, the Earls of Rosebery.

Mentmore Towers

Mentmore was the first of what were to become virtual Rothschild estates in the Vale of Aylesbury. Baron Mayer de Rothschild began purchasing land in the area in 1846.^[7] Later, other members of the family built houses at Tring in Hertfordshire, Ascott, Aston Clinton, Waddesdon and Halton.^[8]

The Grand Hall at Mentmore. Aged just five months, Hannah de Rothschild helped lay the foundation stone for the great mansion on 31 December 1851. She is pictured here in white with her mother circa 1863.^[9]

Much of the estate was sold in 1944, but the mansion, its grounds, formal gardens several farms and the majority of the village of Mentmore remained in the ownership of Harry Primrose, 6th Earl of Rosebery, until his death in 1974. The Earl's executors explored the possibility of Mentmore Towers along with its contents being preserved intact as a heritage property and opened to the public, as has been the case with some other National Trust properties. Despite prolonged discussions between the Executors and Government representatives over the following three years, no agreement to save the house for the nation was reached. Thus, in 1977, the contents of the house were sold at public auction by Sotheby's. The following year the empty mansion with its formal gardens and 80 acres were sold to the Maharishi Foundation who occupied it for the next two decades. In 1999, it was again sold, to investor Simon Halabi, who planned to build additional hotel and conference facilities; the plan did not proceed and the property was allowed to deteriorate. In 1992 the Mentmore Golf and Country Club opened, on land previously owned by the estate.

Mentmore Towers is a Grade I listed building, with its park and gardens listed Grade II*.^[10]

Architecture

 

Mentmore, the ground floor; many of the rooms named for the collections they once contained. 1:Grand Hall; 2:White Drawing Room; 3:Dining Room; 4:Library; 5:Amber Room; 6:limoges Room; 7:Imperial staircase; 8:Study; 9:Vestibule; 10:Green drawing Room; 11:South Entrance Hall; 12:Blarenberghe Room; 13:du Barry Room; 14:Billiards Room; 15:Smoking Room/Armoury; 33: Italian garden; 34:Servants' courtyard; 35:Cour d'honneur; 36:South Terrace; ST:minor service staircases. For other rooms, please see Servants' quarters

 

The dining room (3). The boiseries, or elaborately carved wood panels, were from the Hôtel de Villars, Paris, and are the first example of this type of decoration to be used in an English house. The fragments of the boiseries not used at Mentmore were later installed at Waddesdon Manor

Baron Rothschild commissioned Sir Joseph Paxton, who was then designing and supervising construction of the much-admired Crystal Palace, to design Mentmore. Paxton was responsible for the ridge and furrow glass roof which covered the central hall, designed to imitate the arcaded courtyard of a Renaissance palazzo, while Stokes was co-architect and clerk of works.^[11][12][13] The builder was the London firm George Myers, frequently employed by members of the Rothschild family.^[14]

In keeping with the contents intended to be displayed within, the interiors take their inspiration principally from the Italian Renaissance, although the house also contains drawing rooms and cabinets decorated in the gilded styles of late 18th-century France.^[15] The external design is closely based on that of Robert Smythson's Wollaton Hall.^[16]

Earls of Rosebery

See also: Rothschild properties in the Home counties

Baron Mayer de Rothschild and his wife enjoyed the house for over twenty years before their deaths, his in 1874 and the Baroness's some eighteen months later. The house and estate were then inherited by their daughter Hannah, later Countess of Rosebery.^[17] Following her death from Bright's disease in 1890 at age 39, the house became the home of her widower Archibald Philip Primrose, 5th Earl of Rosebery, later Prime Minister for two years from 1894.^[17] In 1922, the fifth earl gave the estate to his son Harry Meyer Archibald Primrose, Lord Dalmeny, who in 1929, on the death of his father, became the sixth Earl.^[17]

Both earls bred numerous winners of classic horse races at the two stud farms on the estate, including five Epsom Derby winners. These were Ladas, Sir Visto, and Cicero from the Crafton Stud; plus Ocean Swell and Blue Peter from the Mentmore stud. Both stud farms were within a kilometre of the mansion and together with the stable yard were designed by the architect George Devey, who also designed many cottages in the estate's villages of Mentmore, Crafton and Ledburn.^[7]

Second World War

The second wife of the sixth Earl, Eva Primrose, Countess of Rosebery (DBE), was interested in the arts and was acquainted with Kenneth Clark and other national art museum directors.^[18] As a result of Lady Rosebery's friendships, Mentmore was chosen by the British government to store part of the British national art collections during the Second World War. The collections of the National Portrait Gallery were subsequently stored at Mentmore for the duration of the war, along with pieces from the Royal Collection, including the Gold State Coach.^[18] Further works transferred to Mentmore included the portraits from Speaker's House in the Palace of Westminster, and tapestries, furniture and Grinling Gibbons carvings from Hampton Court Palace.^[19]

The royal coach was stored in the "battery room" subsequently nicknamed the "refuge", part of the "gas house", a group of outbuildings where gas and electricity had once been produced for the estate.^[20] Four men guarded the refuge at night, and two during the day.^[18]

Sale and dispersal

 

Cover of "SAVE Mentmore for the Nation". This booklet was published by SAVE Britain's Heritage in February 1977

The possible purchase of Mentmore for the nation through the government's National Land Fund was the desire of Roy Strong, the director of the V&A, who hoped that Mentmore would become a "branch" of his museum devoted to 19th-century decorative arts as Ham House was for the 17th century and Osterley was for the 18th century.^[21] The government refused to spend such large sums from the fund, and the sale fell through.^[21][when?] Following the death of the sixth earl in 1974, the Labour government of James Callaghan refused to accept the contents in lieu of inheritance taxes, which could have turned the house into one of England's finest museums of European furniture, objets d'art and Victorian era architecture.^[22] The government was offered the house and contents for UK £2 million (equivalent to £25,731,749 in 2021), but the offer was declined by the Department for the Environment.^[23] The department cited the high cost of maintaining Mentmore, which it estimated could rise above £80,000 per year. The possibility of sourcing the money from the National Land Fund was also explored, but the government was only willing to commit a portion of the necessary funding from the NLF, insisting that the rest should come by private means, which were "not forthcoming".^[24]

After three more years of fruitless discussion, the executors of the estate sold the contents by public auction, and the large collection was dispersed. The estate made over £6,000,000 (equivalent to £39,658,090 in 2021), but a tiny fraction of its estimated worth today. Among the paintings sold were works by Gainsborough, Reynolds, Boucher, Drouais, Moroni and other well known artists, and cabinet makers, including Jean Henri Riesener and Chippendale. Also represented were the finest German and Russian silver- and goldsmiths, and makers of Limoges enamel. This Rothschild/Mentmore collection is said to have been one of the finest ever to be assembled in private hands, other than the collections of the Russian and British royal families.^[25] The house itself was purchased by the Maharishi International College in December, 1978 for £240,000.^[23] The sale of Mentmore has been described as a "turning point for the preservation movement".^{[26][clarification needed]}

Several family portraits, sculptures and furnishing were relocated from Mentmore prior to the sale by the Roseberys to their ancestral Scottish home, Dalmeny House, near Edinburgh.^[27] Items from Mentmore at Dalmeny include tapestries, Sèvres porcelain, and an equestrian statue by Joseph Boehm of "King Tom", the foundation stallion for Baron Mayer de Rothschild's Mentmore and Crafton Studs.^[28]

Maharishi Foundation

Mentmore became the headquarters for Maharishi Mahesh Yogi's educational charity, the Maharishi Foundation, in 1978.^[29] As of 1997 the Natural Law Party also rented rooms there.^[29] The building was put up for sale in 1997 but did not change owners until 1999 when it was purchased by investor Simon Halabi.^[30]

Simon Halabi

 

Rear of the house

Under the ownership of Halabi, the property was renamed Mentmore Towers Ltd, with the intention of converting it into a luxury hotel with 171 suites, including 122 in a new wing on the slope below the house.^[31] However, in September 2004, Jonathan Davey, a local resident, won a last-minute injunction in the High Court to halt work on the hotel while a judicial review investigated whether the planning permission granted had followed the correct procedures. In March 2005, the High Court ruled that Aylesbury Vale District Council's decision to grant planning permission to the developers was "unimpeachable" and legally sound.

Halabi's property company, Buckingham Securities Holdings, was also proposing to develop the In & Out Club at 79–81 Piccadilly, London, also known as Cambridge House, before it became the Naval and Military Club (once occupied by Lord Palmerston). The intention was to turn both properties into Europe's first six-star hotels, one located in town and the other to be the sister Country Manor hotel with a 36 hole private golf club. The original architects, EPR, were replaced by AFR in 2005, but the development stalled in 2007. In 2004, Hotel Design Inc were retained as interior designers for both projects, leading to a 2005 launch event for the marketing of the properties as a private members' club with hotel facilities (the PM Club).

 

The Great Hall, circa 1880s

The last proposal, after the sister Piccadilly property was sold to the Rueben Brothers in 2009, was to renovate the original Mentmore Towers building and not construct the new extension containing guest-room suites, conference facilities and a large spa. However, with Halabi's property empire in serious trouble due to the housing market's collapse, the project stalled, and the property was in decline. By April 2022, a report described it as "abandoned" and "left to rot".^[32]

"At risk" condition

The house needs urgent work on the roof and chimneys. There is concern that weather will penetrate to the interiors, considered among the finest examples of Victorian design and craftsmanship in Britain. Historic England (previously English Heritage) has placed Mentmore Towers on the "At Risk" register, listing it in "poor" condition with "immediate risk of further rapid deterioration or loss of fabric", explaining that "the service wing roof is in very poor condition and the deterioration of the main house is accelerating with areas of water ingress into the main hall and adjacent reception rooms".^[33] By 2022, the need for restoration was classified as priority A (up from priority B in 2016-2021). The report states "immediate risk of further rapid deterioration or loss of fabric: no solution agreed' in spite of a restoration plan that had been previously completed".^[34][35]

A video published at the end of 2021 confirmed the extent of the deterioration.^[36]

Golf courses

Much of the historic estate^[10] was sold off in 1944^[37] and reverted to agricultural use before becoming the Mentmore Golf and Country Club, established in 1992, which had two eighteen-hole golf courses designed by Bob Sandow, the Rothschild Course and the Rosebery Course. The club ceased trading in 2015.^[38]

Film location

The house has appeared in many films,^[39] including: Brazil (1985), Slipstream (1989), Incognito (1997), Eyes Wide Shut (1999), Quills (2000), The Mummy Returns (2001), Ali G Indahouse (2002),^[40] Johnny English (2003),^[41] Batman Begins (2005), and Infinite (2021). Mentmore Park also featured as a location in the Inspector Morse episode "Cherubim and Seraphim".^[42]

In addition, it has been used as a location for music videos, including the Roxy Music video for "Avalon" (1982), "Magic Touch" by Mike Oldfield (1987), Enya's "Only If..." (1997), "Until the Time Is Through" by Five (1998) and "Goodbye" by the Spice Girls (1998).

See also

• Rothschild properties in Buckinghamshire
• Rothschild family
• Rothschild banking family of England
• Château de Ferrières
• Fitzroy Robinson Ltd. v Mentmore Towers Ltd., a High Court case raising a claim of fraudulent misrepresentation

References

1. Hall, p16.
2. Hall (Waddesdon Manor), p31, refers to them as the architectural team.
3. Henry Russell Hitchcock (1958) Architecture: Nineteenth and Twentieth Centuries (Pelican History of Art), London, Penguin Books, p.73
4. Historic England. "Mentmore House (1117863)". National Heritage List for England. Retrieved 19 September 2011.
5. Hall (Waddesdon Manor), p37, makes this assertion
6. Hall (The Victorian Country House), p153
7. Binney, Marcus. John Robinson. William Allan (1977). SAVE Mentmore for the Nation. London: SAVE Britain's Heritage.
8. Cowles, Virginia (1975). The Rothschilds, a family of fortune. London: First Futura Publications. ISBN 08600-7206-1.
9. Robinson, p. 5.
10. Historic England. "Mentmore Towers (1000319)". National Heritage List for England. Retrieved 10 July 2015.
11. Hall (Waddesdon Manor), p37.
12. The Builder Magazine 1852.
13. Hall (The Victorian Country House), p153, names Stokes and Paxton as joint architects.
14. Hall (The Victorian Country House), p16.
15. Crewe, Vol, p116
16. Mark Girouard, The Victorian Country House, Yale 1978
17. McKinstry, Leo (2005). Rosebery, a statesman in turmoil. London: John Murray (publishers). ISBN 0-7195-6586-3.
18. Martin-Robinson 2014, pp. 128
19. Martin-Robinson 2014, pp. 130
20. Martin-Robinson 2014, pp. 129
21. Mandler, Peter (1 May 1999). The Fall and Rise of the Stately Home. Yale University Press. pp. 472–. ISBN 978-0-300-07869-5.
22. Fenton, James; The New Statesman, "No more than an imposing folly": James Fenton at Mentmore. 20 May 1977.
23. Patrick Wright (2009). On Living in an Old Country: The National Past in Contemporary Britain. Oxford University Press. p. 28-33.
24. Patrick Wright (2009). On Living in an Old Country: The National Past in Contemporary Britain. Oxford University Press. p. 29.
25. Sotheby's (1977). Mentmore Volume I -V. London: Sotheby, Parke, Bernet & Co.
26. Jones, Nigel R. (1 January 2005). Architecture of England, Scotland, and Wales. Greenwood Publishing Group. pp. 296–. ISBN 978-0-313-31850-4.
27. Montgomery-Massingberd, Hugh; Christopher Simon Sykes (1 January 1997). Great Houses of Scotland. Laurence King Publishing. pp. 93–. ISBN 978-1-85669-106-2.
28. Montgomery-Massingberd, Hugh; Christopher Simon Sykes (1 January 1997). Great Houses of Scotland. Laurence King Publishing. pp. 100–. ISBN 978-1-85669-106-2.
29. Jury, Louise (13 May 1997). "Stately home for sale: could suit yogic flyer or maharishi". The Independent.
30. "Revealed: Buyer of the In and Out Club". Sunday Business. 12 November 2000.
31. EPR Architects, Mentmore Towers 1 October 2006 at the Wayback Machine – accessed 22 September 2006.
32. "Inside the huge abandoned mansion 50 miles from London that used to be 'Batman's home' and has been left to rot". My London. 19 April 2022. Retrieved 15 February 2023.
33. "Heritage at risk: Mentmore Towers, Mentmore - Buckinghamshire". Retrieved 24 November 2022.
34. "Melrose Abbey, the Scottish Borders: The spectacular ruin where Robert the Bruce's heart is buried". Country Life. 8 February 2023. Retrieved 11 February 2023.
35. "Building record 1067000000 - MENTMORE TOWERS". Buckinghamshire's Heritage Portal. Retrieved 15 February 2023.
36. "Abandoned £31 million mansion". @places_forgotten, TikTok. 24 December 2021.[Video]. Retrieved 24 November 2022.
37. Mentmore Towers 1 January 2014 at the Wayback Machine Di Camillo Companion
38. Shefferd, Neil (8 June 2015). "Golf course folds as business becomes unsustainable". The Bucks Herald. Retrieved 15 December 2020.
39. "Mentmore Towers: The historic 19th-century mansion has been featured in many Hollywood films". 31 August 2017. Abandoned Spaces. 31 August 2017. Retrieved 24 November 2022.
40. "Filming Locations of Ali G Indahouse". www.movieloci.com.
41. Dark Knight Location Guide. Empire Online. Retrieved 23 July 2012.
42. . Archived from the original on 1 January 2014. Retrieved 22 August 2012.

• Hall, Michael (2002). Waddesdon Manor. new York: Harry N Abrams. ISBN 0-8109-3239-3.

• Crewe, Marquess of (1931). Lord Rosebery. London: John Murray.

• Hall, Michael (2009). The Victorian Country House, from the archives of Country Life. London: Aurum Press. ISBN 978-1-84513-457-0.
• Martin-Robinson, John (2014). Requisitioned: The British Country House in the Second World War. London: Arum. ISBN 978-1-781-31095-3.

External links

•   Media related to Mentmore Towers at Wikimedia Commons
• Mentmore Golf and Country Club
• Mentmore Towers in The Rise & Decline of Rothschildshire

51°52′06″N 0°41′26″W / 51.8682°N 0.6906°W / 51.8682; -0.6906