Shoulder (road)

A shoulder, hard shoulder (British)^[1] or breakdown lane is an emergency stopping lane by the verge of a road or motorway, on the right side in countries which drive on the right, and on the left side in countries which drive on the left. Many wider (U.S.) freeways, or expressways elsewhere have shoulders on both sides of each directional carriageway — in the median, as well as at the outer edges of the road, for additional safety. Shoulders are not intended for use by through traffic, although there are exceptions.

The shoulder of Saskatchewan Highway 11 in this picture (shown to the right of the solid white line) is wide enough to accommodate a stopped car without impeding the flow of traffic in the travel lanes

Purpose

Shoulders have multiple uses, including:

• Emergency vehicles such as ambulances, fire trucks and police cars may use the shoulder to bypass traffic congestion in some countries.
• In the event of an emergency or breakdown, a motorist can pull into the shoulder to get out of the flow of traffic and obtain a greater degree of safety.
• Active traffic management, used on busy multi-lane roads, may allow 'hard shoulder running' by general traffic at reduced speeds during periods of high traffic volumes.
• In some places a "bus bypass shoulder" may be provided which allows bus services to pass stationary traffic.
• Paved shoulders provide additional space should a motorist need to take evasive action (such as avoiding a wrong-way driver) or need to recover control of their vehicle before a run-off-road collision occurs.
• In some rural areas without sidewalks, pedestrians and cyclists may be allowed to walk or ride on the shoulders.
• On curbed roadways, shoulders move the gutter away from the travel lanes which reduces the risk of hydroplaning, and reduces splash and spray of stormwater onto pedestrians using any adjacent sidewalk.
• Paved shoulders move water away from the roadway before it can infiltrate into the road's subbase, increasing the life expectancy of the road surface.
• Shoulders help provide extra structural support of the roadway.
• When semi-truck drivers need sleep and there are no available parking spaces at truck stops and rest areas, either because there are no such facilities nearby or because all semi-truck parking spaces are filled to capacity, drivers may pull over to the highway shoulder and sleep in their truck cabin.
• In some countries, parking in the shoulder is not prohibited by the law, and mushroom and berry pickers commonly use them on roads going through a forest.

General characteristics

 

In Ireland, dashed yellow lines demarcate hard shoulders on non-motorways, as can be seen along this dual carriageway on the N11.

The shoulder is usually slightly narrower than a full traffic lane. In some cases, particularly on older rural roadways, shoulders that initially existed were hardened with gravel rather than being paved with asphalt or concrete. In Britain, motorway shoulders are now paved, but are still known as 'hard shoulders.' Older, gravel shoulders have sometimes been termed soft shoulders by comparison. Because the paved surface ends at that point, they are less safe if they need to be used for emergency maneuvers. Notably, the section of Ontario Highway 401 between Windsor and London had soft shoulders with a sharp slope which was blamed for facilitating vehicle rollovers, if drivers accidentally drifted off the paved section of the road and then overreacted after hitting the gravel. Modern practice is to build a continuous paved shoulder whenever possible.^[2]

The US Federal Highway Administration encourages the placement of a Safety Edge—a 30° compacted taper on the end of the pavement dropoff—to ensure that any driver running off the edge of the roadway is better able to maintain control while trying to steer back onto the roadway. The Safety Edge is effective on roads where the shoulder is narrow or nonexistent.^[3]

To save money, the shoulder was often not paved to the same thickness as the through lanes, so if vehicles were to attempt to use it as a through lane regularly, it would rapidly deteriorate. In Britain, shoulder running can occur during roadworks, and full depth construction is now standard. In some metro areas, road authorities also allow shoulders to be used as lanes at peak periods. However, rural shoulders often collects various bits of road debris that can make driving there less safe.

Drivers will sometimes drift into the shoulder when being overtaken by passing vehicles, particularly on two-lane roads. However, it is extremely unsafe, and in most jurisdictions illegal, to abuse the shoulder by 'undertaking' passing vehicles that are nearer the center of the road.

On older roads, the shoulder may disappear for short periods, near exits or when going across or under bridges or tunnels where the cost savings were thought to outweigh the safety benefits of the shoulder. Some roads have a narrow shoulder for significant distances. This makes it difficult for large vehicles to pull into the hard shoulder altogether.

The Jingjintang Expressway in northeastern China is an example of this phenomenon. Its shoulder is only 2.4 metres (7.9 ft) wide, which is not wide enough for some automobiles—a standard lane in the U.S. and UK is 12 feet (3.7 m). As a result, some motorists are unable to fully exit the mainline when they need to pull over, so they end up in a position that is halfway in the rightmost lane and only partly on the shoulder. The end result is often a traffic jam and occasionally a collision.

Bus bypass shoulder

 

The Dulles Airport Express bypassing traffic using the shoulder lane

In some jurisdictions in the United States and Canada, buses are allowed to drive on the shoulder to pass traffic jams, which is called a bus-only shoulder or bus-bypass shoulder (BBS);^[4] the term "bus-only shoulder lane" is incorrect from a technical and legal standpoint.^[5] In Ontario, Highway 403 had its shoulders between Hurontario Street and Erin Mills Parkway widened in 2003 so they serve a dual purpose as bus lanes and accident lanes. In the Minneapolis–Saint Paul region of Minnesota, over 270 miles of shoulder have been designated for use by buses.^[6] The Route 9 BBS in Central New Jersey which runs along two stretches of shoulders are dedicated for exclusive bus use during peak hours.^[7][8] The bus lanes, which run for approximately 3 miles (4.83 km) are the first component of a planned 20-mile (32.19 km) BBS corridor.^[9] In the Chicago area, Pace buses are authorized to use the shoulder of the Jane Addams Memorial Tollway, Edens Expressway, and Stevenson Expressway to avoid traffic congestion.^[10]

In the Seattle area, Community Transit and Sound Transit Express commuter buses are authorized to use the shoulders of Interstate 5 and Interstate 405 on small segments in Snohomish County as part of a pilot project that aims to reduce delayed bus trips.^[11]

There are also some bus-bypass shoulders in the United Kingdom, on the motorways of Northern Ireland heading towards Belfast and the M90 motorway in Scotland towards Edinburgh.

Peak period use by all traffic

 

Sign-controlled peak shoulder lane on Interstate 405 near Seattle, Washington, U.S.

 

The M42, with lowered speed limits and hard-shoulder running, as seen on the matrix Variable Message Sign (VMS) on the left.

In the United Kingdom, usage of the hard shoulder is known as "hard shoulder running". A pilot project on an 11-mile stretch of the M42 motorway, near Birmingham, began in September 2006. Active traffic management with special signage, new turnouts (laybys) and a variable speed limit have been put in place to improve safety. This has proved very successful, with journey times decreasing by 26% northbound and 9% southbound. Drivers can also better predict their journey times as the variability decreased by 27%. The average accident rate dropped from 5.2 to 1.5 per month.^[12] It has also proved popular with motorists, 60% of whom want to see it expanded to other English motorways. This 'smart motorway' system has been expanded to the M6,^[13] M1^[14] and M25,^[15] as well as parts of the M60 and M62.^[16]

In the United States, on Interstate 93 between Exit 35 (formerly 41)^[17] and Exit 43 (formerly 46)^[18] and SR 3 between Exit 27 (formerly 12)^[19] and Exit 38 (formerly 16)^[20] in the Boston metro area, cars are allowed to use the shoulder as they would a normal lane during morning and evening rush hours. The same scheme is employed elsewhere, such as on Interstate 580 in California on the Richmond-San Rafael Bridge, on Interstate 66 in Virginia between the Capital Beltway and US-50,^{[citation needed]} and on Interstate 405 between SR 527 and I-5 in Bothell.^[21]

Emergency use by all traffic

Emergency shoulder use (left shoulder only) on eastbound Interstate 4 the day before the arrival of Hurricane Irma

Florida has developed a plan for the use of shoulders by moving traffic during hurricane evacuations on select portions of Interstate 4, Interstate 10, Interstate 75, and Interstate 95.^[22][23] The shoulder-use plan was implemented in place of labor- and resource-intensive contraflow lane reversal, in which both sides of an interstate highway are used for one direction of traffic.^[23] The first implementation of the plan occurred on 8–9 September 2017 before the arrival of Hurricane Irma.^[24][25][26] Texas has also considered emergency shoulder use for hurricane evacuations.^[23]

Increased cyclist safety

Although direct rear impacts only make up 3% of motorist-on-cyclist collisions,^{[citation needed]} they are a more prominent collision type in arterial road type situations. When they occur in such circumstances, they are also associated with significantly increased risk of fatality. Data collated by the OECD indicates that rural locations account for 35% or more of cycling fatalities in Denmark, Finland, France, Great Britain, Japan, the Netherlands, and Spain.^[27]

The use of appropriately designed segregated space on arterial or interurban routes appears to be associated with reductions in overall risk. In Ireland, the provision of hard shoulders on interurban routes in the 1970s reportedly resulted in a 50% decrease in accidents.^[28] It is reported that the Danes have also found that separate cycle tracks lead to a reduction in rural collisions.^[29]

In some countries, the use of shoulders is optional for cyclists, who may choose not to use it for reasons such as: it being too narrow, inviting dangerously close passes at high speed by motorists; it having a road surface unsuitable for cycling or putting the path of the cyclist in direct conflict with the paths of other road users, such as those turning across the shoulder. Generally, the usable width of the road begins where one can ride without increased danger of falls, jolts or blowouts. A road may have a gravel shoulder, its edge may be covered with sand or trash and the pavement may be broken.^[30]

Characteristics in various countries

Republic of Ireland

 

A junction on the M4 motorway in Ireland, with an unbroken yellow line (that peels away and follows the sliproad) demarcating the hard shoulder.

Full-width hard shoulders are provided on most new, upgraded (from the 1980s onwards), and major national roads in the Republic of Ireland, especially on wide two-lane and dual-carriageway roads (the shoulders on most 2+1 roads are narrow however). They are defined within the official document the Rules of the Road as a part of the road that should normally only be used by cyclists and pedestrians. Their provision of on interurban routes in the 1970s reportedly resulted in a 50% decrease in accidents involving pedal cyclists.^[28]

The hard shoulder is usually demarcated by road markings in the form of a single dashed yellow line with the addition of yellow cat's eyes. On motorways, and at critical points on other routes (e.g. between junctions or interchanges, or beneath overpasses) a solid yellow line is used, denoting additional restrictions on usage of the hard shoulder. At junctions and on-ramps and off-ramps, the yellow line peels away into the turn, with a dashed white line (with green cats' eyes) denoting a lane division following the main route (i.e. in most cases the road remains the same width, and a turn lane takes the place of the hard shoulder).

In the 2000s, Bus Éireann coaches were allowed to use the hard shoulders on national roads into Dublin. However, dedicated bus lanes are now present on sections of some routes, such as the N7 Naas Road, and such use of actual hard shoulder is not universal.

Canada and United States

 

A break in the shoulder line is used by California to warn of upcoming freeway exits in foggy areas

The right-hand shoulder is separated by a solid white line, and the left-hand shoulder (if the road is one-way, such as part of a divided highway) is separated from the leftmost through lane by a solid yellow line. On many roads, the lines are supplemented by reflective raised pavement markers or rumble strips to provide additional visual and tactile feedback to drivers crossing the lines.

On freeways in foggy areas of California, there is an obvious break in the line of the shoulder before every exit. This is to help drivers find their exits in heavy fog (especially the dangerous tule fog).^[31]

United Kingdom

 

A2 at Leyton Cross, United Kingdom.

Full width hard shoulders are usually provided only on motorways and are usually 3.3 metres (11 ft) wide, but there are exceptions. Some motorways do not have hard shoulders at all (for example the A57(M) and many smart motorways where the hard shoulder has been converted into a running lane) and there are a small number of dual carriageway A-roads which do possess hard shoulders (for example, parts of the A1, A2 and A27). Hard shoulders are always marked with a reflectorized solid white line which is 20 centimetres (7.9 in) wide and is provided with a rumble strip. A line of red cats' eyes is also used, and is placed to the side of the line.

On many modern non-motorway roads, a hard strip is provided. These are usually 1 metre (3 ft 3 in) wide, and are bounded by thinner solid white lines, and often without a rumble strip.

Italy

The shoulders located on the sides of Italy's highways are normally used as emergency lanes in case of breakdown or by emergency vehicles in case of queues. According to the regulation in force, it is mandatory to wear a high visibility jacket when dismounting from a vehicle stopped in an emergency lane.^[32]

Normally one is not allowed to drive on the shoulder, but in case of traffic blockage, use of the shoulder is allowed to reach an exit if it is within 500 meters.

France

 

French highway, with dashed shoulder markings and sign explaining their significance

In France, roadway shoulders are usually 2.5 metres (8 ft 2 in) wide, or 3 metres (9.8 ft) wide when the roadway carries more than 2,000 vehicles per day. The main difference from other European countries is that the white line is dashed, typically 39 metres (128 ft) long with gaps 13 metres (43 ft) long. The design is intended to provide a guide for drivers to maintain a safe distance between vehicles. Road signs can be found along motorways, to indicate the safe distance (1 line = too close, 2 lines = safe distance). At some points (tunnel, bridge, narrow road with no shoulder, tight curve) the edge line becomes solid.

Australia

In a similar manner to Canada, Italy and the United States, the shoulders located on the side of Australia's highways are normally used as an emergency lane in the case of a breakdown or by emergency vehicles in the case of road congestion. However, no mandatory regulations exist to wear a high visibility jacket when dismounting from the vehicle stopped in an emergency lane.

A recent study conducted by the National Coroners Information System (NCIS) in Australia^[33] has revealed 29 closed case fatalities (and at least a dozen case fatalities still under coronial investigation) that had been reported to Australian coroners where a person was "struck in an emergency lane after their vehicle had stopped" between July 2000 and November 2010.^[34]

See also

• Bus lane
• Road verge
• Rumble strip
• Wide outside lane

References

1. "Hard shoulder definition". Cambridge English Dictionary. from the original on October 2, 2016.
2. "Apps - Access My Library - Gale". from the original on 2012-03-12.
3. Federal Highway Administration. "Safety Edge Introduction - Every Day Counts". from the original on 2013-01-08. Retrieved 2013-01-22.
4. "A shoulder to drive on". Traffic Technology Today. from the original on 2013-01-21. Retrieved 2013-04-01.
5. "Bus-Only Shoulders (Minnesota Department of Transportation)" (PDF). state.mn.us. (PDF) from the original on 10 April 2008. Retrieved 4 May 2018.
6. "Bus-Only Shoulders in Minneapolis-St. Paul". metrocouncil.org. from the original on 28 September 2007. Retrieved 4 May 2018.
7. "NJDOT to open Route 9 Bus shoulder lanes in Old Bridge" (Press release). New Jersey Department of Transportation. November 29, 2006. from the original on September 23, 2013. Retrieved 2012-03-03.
8. Synthesis 64: Bus shoulder lanes, Transportation Research Board of the National Academies, 2007, ISBN 9780309097673
9. Baldwin, Zoe (July 10, 2009). "New Jersey gradually clearing away obstacles to bus rapid transit". Mobilizing the Region. Tri-State Transportation Campaign. from the original on July 13, 2009. Retrieved 2014-04-04.
10. "Pace Buses To Start Using Shoulders On Edens". 2017-05-22. Retrieved 2020-04-15.
11. Garnick, Coral (October 3, 2015). "Jammed-up I-405 prompting some buses to run on the shoulder". The Seattle Times. from the original on August 18, 2016. Retrieved June 3, 2016.
12. Extra lane' plan to be extended BBC News
13. Hard shoulders opens on busy M6 by Birmingham 2017-06-30 at the Wayback Machine BBC News
14. Highways Agency M1 Junction 10-13 Project status Archived 2014-02-07 at the UK Government Web Archive Highways Agency
15. Highways Agency M25 Junction 23-37 Project status 2013-08-20 at the Wayback Machine Highways Agency
16. "Page not found – News - Highways England". from the original on 2012-04-18. {{cite web}}: Cite uses generic title (help)
17. "Google Maps". Google Maps. Retrieved 2021-04-13.
18. "Google Maps". Google Maps. Retrieved 2021-04-13.
19. "Google Maps". Google Maps. Retrieved 2021-04-13.
20. "Google Maps". Google Maps. Retrieved 2021-04-13.
21. Gutman, David (May 4, 2017). "New I-405 shoulder lane reduces northbound travel times — for now". The Seattle Times. Retrieved April 10, 2019.
22. "Emergency Shoulder Use (ESU)". Florida Department of Transportation. from the original on 11 September 2017. Retrieved 10 September 2017.
23. Roustan, Wayne (26 May 2017). "State introducing new hurricane evacuation plan this year". Sun-Sentinel. from the original on 11 September 2017. Retrieved 10 September 2017.
24. Travis, Scott (8 September 2017). "Shoulder use allowed on parts of I-75 for Hurricane Irma evacuations". Sun-Sentinel. from the original on 10 September 2017. Retrieved 10 September 2017.
25. Roustan, Wayne (9 September 2017). "Hurricane Irma: I-4 shoulder opened to Tampa evacuees". Sun-Sentinel. from the original on 10 September 2017. Retrieved 10 September 2017.
26. Wright, Pam; Cheney, Eric (8 September 2017). "Florida Air Travel Begins Shutdown; Shoulder Lanes Opened on I-75 as Thousands Flee Hurricane Irma". The Weather Channel. The Weather Company.
27. Figure IV.7 Pedestrian and cyclist accidents by road type. RS7:Safety of Vulnerable Road Users, Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development, August 1998
28. The bicycle, a study of efficiency usage and safety., D.F. Moore, An Foras Forbatha, Dublin 1975
29. Collection of Cycle Concepts 2007-09-27 at the Wayback Machine, Danish Roads Directorate, Copenhagen, 2000
30. "Where to ride on the road". from the original on 2014-10-04. Retrieved 2014-09-04.
31. Richards, Gary (1 December 2014). "Roadshow: Tips for driving in fog". The Mercury News. Bay Area News Group. Retrieved 7 July 2020.
32. "Art 162 Codice della Strada". Archived from the original on 2008-06-06. Retrieved 2007-06-12.
33. . Archived from the original on February 21, 2012.
34. "Deaths in Emergency Lanes - National Coroners Information System (NCIS) Fact-Sheet, January 2011" (PDF). ncis.org.au. (PDF) from the original on 21 November 2011. Retrieved 4 May 2018.

External links

• Traffic Signs about Shoulders
• Deaths in Emergency Lanes - National Coroners Information System (NCIS) Fact-Sheet, January 2011