Hadiya case

The Hadiya case (Shafin Jahan v. Asokan K.M) was a 2017–2018 Indian Supreme Court case that affirmed the validity of the marriage of Hadiya (formerly Akhila Ashokan) and Shafin Jehan, which was challenged by Hadiya's family. Media outlets have described the underlying dispute as an allegation of "love jihad".^[8]

Shafin Jahan v. Asokan K.M
Court	Supreme Court of India
Full case name	Shafin Jahan v. Asokan K.M & ORS
Citation(s)	^[1]
Case history
Appealed from	High Court of Kerala
Appealed to	Supreme Court of India
Court membership
Judges sitting	Justice Dipak Misra Justice Ajay Manikrao Khanwilkar Justice Dhananjaya Y. Chandrachud
Case opinions
Hadiya was allowed to re-join her medical college to continue her studies and her marriage with Shafin Jahan was restored.

At the time of the case, Hadiya was a homeopathic medical student from Vaikom, Kerala. In early 2016, she was reported missing by her father, Asokan K.M, who filed a police case followed by a habeas corpus petition in the Kerala High Court to trace her; Hadiya has described the circumstances of her leaving as her father forbidding her from practicing Islam. She left her home for college on 6 January, dressed in a hijab.^[9] Hadiya was staying with A.S. Zainaba, president of Popular Front of India (PFI)'s women's wing, the National Women's Front (NWF).^{[10][9][11][12]} She had converted to Islam and married Jehan, a Muslim man.^[9] Jehan was an active member of the PFI-affiliated Social Democratic Party of India (SDPI). Her family alleged that she was brainwashed and that her marriage was forced, but Hadiya said she married of her own volition.^[13][2]

In May 2017, Hadiya's marriage was annulled by the High Court of Kerala on the grounds that Hadiya was a victim of indoctrination and psychological kidnapping, and that their claims of their marriage being arranged through a matrimony website were "bogus".^[14] The High Court of Kerala then handed over Hadiya's custody to her father, Ashokan, arguing that "As per Indian tradition, the custody of an unmarried daughter is with the parents, until she is properly married."^[15]

Jahan appealed the Kerala High Court order, and moved to the Supreme Court. In November 2017, the Supreme Court of India directed Hadiya to resume her internship, and that she was free to meet whomever she wanted.^[16][4] In March 2018, the Supreme Court restored Hadiya's marriage, 10 months after the Kerala High Court annulled it.^[17]

Stakeholders

Key organisations and people involved and mentioned in Hadiya's High Court and Supreme Court cases are as follows.

• People
  • Hadiya (Akhila Ashokan): A student of homeopathy. Hadiya says she converted to Islam of her own will, then married Shafin Jahan of her own will, and wants to return to her husband.^[18] Hadiya claims she was tortured by Siva Sakthi Yoga Centre workers, who tried to convert her back to Hinduism,^[19] who were directed to her by her father.^[9] Claims she has been illegally incarcerated by her father for 11 months.^[20]
  • A.S. Zainaba: Hadiya chose to live with Zainaba after she left her home. Zainaba is a member of PFI, and SDFI; and the President of PFI's women's wing National Women's Front.
  • Shafin Jehan: He married Hadiya.^[11][9] Their marriage was annulled by the Kerala High Court.^[3] He filed the case in Supreme Court to appeal the decision.^[3] He is member of SDPI and PFI.^[11] NIA claims Shafin has 4 criminal cases lodged against him,^[21] but the SP Kerala Police says there's only one case related to campus politics, which had to do with him being admin of a whatsapp group.^[22][23]
  • Asokan K. M.: Akhila's father, an atheist and ex-serviceman, who went to the High Court claiming that his brainwashed daughter Hadiya's marriage was based on forced conversion and her safety was at risk.^[11] His daughter, Hadiya, has accused Ashokan of holding her in "unlawful custody" for 11 months, from forbidding her from practicing the faith of her choice, and who is trying to keep her from the man she chose as her husband.^[24]
• Hindu Organizations
  • Siva Sakthi Yoga Centre: a Hindu centre that visited Hadiya upon Ashokan's request, and whom Hadiya alleges "tortured" her and tried to re-convert her.^[25] There have been numerous other allegations of torture at the hands of Siva Sakthi Yoga Centre, where Hindu women are forced by their families to go and reconvert to Hinduism.^{[26][27][28][29][30]}
• Islamic organisation
  • Popular Front of India (PFI): An Islamic fundamentalist organisation. According to NIA, PFI and its partner Islamic state Al-Hindi have plans to launch terrorist actions in India.^[11] Shafin Jehan and Zainaba are PFI members.^[4][9]
  • National Women's Front (NWF): PFI's women's wing headed by Zainaba.^[10][11]
  • Social Democratic Party of India (SDPI): Another wing of PFI. Shafin Jehan and Zainaba are SDPI members.^[4][9]
  • Sathya Sarani: An Islamic Charitable Trust.^[10]
• Government organisations
  • High Court of Kerala (HCK): Annulled Hadiya's marriage held under suspicious circumstances.^[3]
  • Supreme Court of India (SC): Currently hearing the ongoing case filed by Safin Jehan to gain access to Hadiya.
  • National Investigation Agency NIA: India's premier national agency that investigates terrorism cases, was asked by the SC to investigate if there has been large scale systematic forced conversions to Islam with the view to carry out terrorist activities. NIA told SC that Hadiya is "a victim of indoctrination and psychological kidnapping", claims that their marriage was arranged through a matrimony website were totally false, and her handlers who arranged her marriage were only looking for active worker of radical outfit PFI as her groom.^[3] NIA had recommended to SC and government to ban PFI as it runs terror camps and makes bomb, with plans to carry out terror attacks against India with the help of Islamic state Al-Hindi.^[11]

Religious conversion

Hadiya, who grew up as Akhila Ashokan, belonged to a family from Vaikom, Kottayam. She is the only child of an atheist ex-serviceman, K.M. Ashokan and his wife Ponnamma. She lived with her parents and studied at local schools until 12th standard, which she passed at the second attempt.^[31] While pursuing her bachelor's degree at Sivaraj Homeopathic Medical College at Salem, she converted to Islamic faith. She became interested in Islam after seeing two of her collegemates, Faseena and Jaseela.^[32][9][4] On 6 January 2016 Akhila went missing from a house in Selam, where she was staying with her friends, Faseena and Jaseena, and parents filed the police complaint against the friends and their father Aboobacker^[9] Hadiya insisted in the High Court that it was a personal choice, her family argued that she is the victim of love jihad, and court annulled her marriage with the observation that she was a "weak and vulnerable girl capable of being exploited".^[31] Court also said in its order that "Shefin Jahan is one such person who has been assigned to play the role of going through a sham of a marriage with Ms. Akhila, with the object of transporting her out of India."^[9] She told the court that she was "impressed" by her friends' "timely prayers and good character."^[9] She told the court she had been practicing Islam for 3 years without formally announcing the change of faith, but she started the legal procedure for conversion only by September 2015.^[9][31] Her parents learnt about the conversion when she refused to participate in her grandfather's funeral ritual at her home.^[32][31] She subsequently returned to college wearing a headscarf.^[31]

In January 2016, Akhila left her home and joined a course on Islam at "Therbiathul Islam Sabha", a Kozhikode Islamic study centre, as an 'external candidate' after filling an affidavit that she converted on her on accord. She planned to stay at her roommates' residence in Kerala during the study period. However, her roommates' father Aboobacker refused to let her continue at his residence, following which she approached Satya Sarani, an educational institution and conversion centre at Manjeri, Malappuram. While at Satya Sarani, she stayed with A.S. Zainaba, president of NWF and member of its parent radical Islamist organisation PFI as well as member of PFI's other front SDPI.^[10][9][11] NWF is women's wing of PFI.^[33] PFI, having links with banned Islamist terrorist organisation group SIMI^[34][35][36] and Pakistan's ISI,^[37][12] is involved with Islamic terrorist acts and groups.^{[38][39][35][40]}

Meanwhile, Hadiya's father had filed a missing person's police case,^[10] and after being unable to trace her, he filed the first case in the high court.^{[9][10][5][6]}

High Court lawsuit

In February 2016, Akhila's father Ashokan filed a missing person's case at the local police station.^[10] Following the case, Aboobacker was arrested by the police.^[10] Despite the police case, Akhila could not be traced,^[9] meanwhile Akhila was in contact with the "Sathya Sarani" organisation which placed Zainaba in charge of Akila.^[10] During this period, she changed her name to Hadiya.^[10] At the High Court of Kerala, Hadiya's father filed a habeas corpus petition alleging that Satya Sarani has involved in "forced and illegal" religious conversions. Hadiya testified that she was staying with Zainaba out of her free will. The court dismissed Ashokan's petition and let Hadiya continue learning Islam and live with Zainaba, observing that she was not in illegal confinement.^[10]

Following this, Ashokan filed a second petition in August 2016, alleging that Hadiya is likely to be transported out of the country after getting her married off to a Muslim man. The High court passed an interim order to keep Hadiya in surveillance to ensure that she was not taken outside of India. While she was in surveillance, the police found that she has moved from Zainaba's house to an undisclosed location.^[9] Though Hadiya denied the plan to travel abroad, the court directed her to stay at a women's hostel in Kochi.^[10] In September, the court let her live with Zainaba again, when she testified that she does not possess a passport, and pleaded that she was being lodged in the hostel "for no fault of hers". On 19 December, the court directed Hadiya to move to the college hostel in Salem to complete her medical studies. Her father, Ashokan, was asked to produce her certificates on 21 December so that she could resume her studies.^[9]

Marriage

On 21 December 2016, Akhila appeared before the high court accompanied by "a stranger."^[9] This was nearly a year after she had left home and formally converted, she appeared in court with a man named Shafin Jahan, who she said she had married.^[32] Shafin Jehan is an active member of SDPI^[11] and allegedly also a member of the radical Islamic outfit PFI,^[41] with 4 criminal cases against him.^[11] SDPI is political front of Islamic fundamentalist organisation PFI.^{[42][43][44][45][46][47]} Hadiya married Shafin Jehan on 19 December 2016, the same day she had appeared before the court.^[11][41] The marriage was solemnized under Muslim law. Hadiya's lawyer later informed that she had signed up on a Muslim matrimony website "waytonikah.com", and that Shafin's proposal came through the site.^[9][48] In May 2017, the High Court annulled Hadiya's marriage with Shefin, and sent her to her parents’ house in Vaikom.^[32]

Although the court order was to only provide her police protection, she was not permitted by her father to leave her home or meet anyone,^[32] an allegation denied by her father as she was fully surrounded by police inside and outside the house.^[4] According to Asokan, Hadiya refused to leave the house and go outside even though she was allowed to.^[49] Chairperson of State Women's commission,^[50] and several activists were prevented from meeting Hadiya, among those a trespassing case was registered against seven people.^[51] However, the chairperson of National Commission for Women visited her and noted that she was "happy and smiling", "her health and security are good", and that Hadiya did not report any atrocities or harm done to her.^[5][41]

At Supreme Court

Her husband, Shafin Jehan approached the Supreme Court for challenging the High Court order. At Supreme Court, Hadiya expressed her will to continue practicing Islam, live with her husband and complete her internship. She told that she was unlawfully kept under custody at her parents' home and demanded freedom.^[6] NIA, which investigates terror cases, was asked by the court to investigate if there are organised groups attempting to recruit Hindu women as terrorists by getting Muslim men to convert and marry them, had submitted to court that Hadiya's is an example of "psychological kidnapping", there is evidence of nearly 90 "similar cases" of indoctrination and radicalisation in Kerala, and that the court should not go by her statement.^[5][41] Evidence adduced by the NIA showed that claims that Hadiya met Safin Jehan through matrimony website 'waytonikah.com' was "totally false and entirely bogus".^[3] NIA further alleged that the only condition of the handlers who arranged their marriage was that the groom should be an active worker of the PFI, a radical outfit.^[3] The judges were livid with what had happened and questioned why the court had been kept in the dark regarding the marriage.^[9] The court raised several doubts about the hurried nature of the marriage, and doubted the manner in which the wedding ceremony was conducted.^[9]

The Supreme Court allowed her to return to Salem and pursue her internship. Further hearing in this case, including the decision on the annulment of marriage will be considered by the court in January 2018.^[52] Hadiya responded that she was happy with the Supreme Court's decision allowing her to continue her education.^[53]

On 23 January 2018 19 February 2018 at the Wayback Machine, the Supreme court continued hearing the Hadiya Marriage case. When the Counsel for Mr Ashokan (Hadiya’s father) argued that the circumstances leading to the marriage must be investigated, the court emphasised that Hadiya’s marital status could not be looked into by the Court. Being a 24-year old adult, Hadiya had the power to make her own decisions, and the Court could not compel her to go to her father or husband against her will. Neither could the Court look into the character of the person Hadiya had married. The bench reiterated that investigating the marriage in such a manner would set a bad precedent in law. Hadiya has now been made a party to the proceedings as per the request of Mr Kapil Sibal. She can file her own response. This is a positive development as earlier Supreme Court was criticised for not adding Hadiya as a party and denying an adult woman agency in an important matter like marriage choice. The matter has been listed to be next heard on 22 February 2018.^[54]

On 8 March 2018, Hadiya's marriage was restored by the Supreme Court.

NIA Investigation

According to the ongoing probe by the NIA, Shafin Jahan is accused of having alleged connections with two ISIS members Manseed and P Safvan, accused in the Omar-al-Hindi case, through Facebook group Popular Front of India (PFI) which allegedly deals with activities of SDPI. Muneer, Shafin Jahan's friend, brought Hadiya and him together.

The probe by the investigation agency has also revealed certain discrepancies in what the couple had earlier claimed about meeting on the matrimonial site. According to sources, Shafin had registered his name on the website on 19 September 2015, while Sainaba (the lady who Hadiya stayed with, after leaving her parents’ home) registered the name of Hadiya and her own daughter, Fathima Thesni, on 17 April 2016. Hadiya viewed 49 profiles between 17 April and 23 April, but not of Shafin. In the same way, Jahan viewed 67 profiles, but not Hadiya's. As per NIA's report in the "love jihad" case, the marriage proposal of Shafin Jahan had come through Muneer during August 2016.^[55]

NIA ended the probe saying that they could not find any evidence of love jihad in the 11 marriages it investigated.^[56]

References

1. (PDF). Archived from the original (PDF) on 1 December 2017. Retrieved 29 November 2017.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: archived copy as title (link)
2. Taneja, Richa. "Hadiya's Story: A Timeline Of Kerala 'Love Jihad' Case". NDTV.com. NDTV. Retrieved 28 November 2017.
3. "Hadiya case: Critical findings demolish petitioner's case, says NIA in court". Indian Express. 28 November 2017. Retrieved 28 November 2017.
4. "'Love jihad' case: Cannot have a terrorist in the family, says Hadiya's father - Times of India". The Times of India. 28 November 2017. Retrieved 28 November 2017.
5. Koshy, Sneha Mary. "Hadiya 'Smiling And Safe', Says Women's Panel After Visiting Kerala Woman In 'Love Jihad' Case". NDTV. NDTV. Retrieved 28 November 2017.
6. "Kerala love jihad case: 'I want freedom', says Hadiya; SC allows her to resume medical studies in Salem". Firstpost. First Post. 28 November 2017. Retrieved 28 November 2017.
7. "India's top court upholds marriage in 'love jihad' case". 11 April 2018.
8. ^{[2][3][4][5][6][7]}
9. "From Akhila to Hadiya: What exactly is the Kerala 'Love Jihad' case all about". The News Minute. News Minute. 19 August 2017. Retrieved 28 November 2017.
10. Jacob, George (30 October 2017). "How Akhila became Hadiya". The Hindu. Retrieved 28 November 2017.
11. "Islamist Popular Front Of India 'Involved In Terror Acts', NIA Submits Report To Govt Recommending Ban". Outlook. 12 September 2017. Retrieved 28 November 2017.
12. "retired indian army claimed that PFI". Indian Defence Review. 28 (2). April–June 2013.
13. "Court intervenes in 'love jihad' case". BBC News. BBC. 27 November 2017. Retrieved 28 November 2017.
14. "Hadiya case: Critical findings demolish petitioner's case, says NIA in court". The Indian Express. 28 November 2017. Retrieved 30 November 2017.
15. "Hadiya's Choices". The Indian Express. 30 November 2017. Retrieved 30 November 2017.
16. "Kerala conversion case: Hadiya demands freedom; SC allows her to resume studies, sets next hearing in January". The Indian Express. Indian Express. 27 November 2017. Retrieved 28 November 2017.
17. "Hadiya's marriage valid, can live with husband: SC - Times of India ►". The Times of India. 9 March 2018. Retrieved 9 March 2018.
18. Manorama News (25 November 2017), Hadiya speaking at Nedumbassery Airport, retrieved 30 November 2017
19. "Call for probe into Hadiya 'ghar-wapsi' bid". The Telegraph. Retrieved 30 November 2017.^{[dead link]}
20. PTI (29 November 2017). "Hadiya reiterates desire to meet husband". livemint.com/. Retrieved 30 November 2017.
21. "Islamist Popular Front Of India 'Involved In Terror Acts', NIA Submits Report To Govt Recommending Ban". outlookindia.com/. Retrieved 30 November 2017.
22. "Her journey from Akhila to become Hadiya". The Indian Express. 27 August 2017. Retrieved 30 November 2017.
23. "Kerala love jihad case: All that has happened so far". The Indian Express. 16 August 2017. Retrieved 30 November 2017.
24. "LIVE BLOG- 'I want my freedom': Hadiya tells Supreme Court". The News Minute. 27 November 2017. Retrieved 30 November 2017.
25. "New tangles in Hadiya row: 'Yoga centre' members tortured me to re-convert, she reveals". The News Minute. 29 November 2017. Retrieved 30 November 2017.
26. Mathrubhumi News (6 October 2017), Women tortured at Sivasakthi yoga centre, says ex-instructor|Mathrubhumi News, retrieved 30 November 2017
27. "Another woman alleges torture at yoga centre - Times of India". The Times of India. Retrieved 30 November 2017.
28. "യോഗ സെന്ററില്‍ കൊടിയ പീഡനമെന്ന് മുന്‍ അധ്യാപകന്റെ പരാതി". www.mathrubhumi.com. Retrieved 30 November 2017.
29. "RSS-CPM rivalry in Kerala gets new ammunition: Yoga centre found to be a front for forcible 'Ghar Wapsi' conversions". Firstpost. 27 September 2017. Retrieved 30 November 2017.
30. "In Kerala, a yoga centre 'helps' bring back women from their non-Hindu partners". The Indian Express. 19 November 2017. Retrieved 30 November 2017.
31. Jacob, George (14 October 2017). "Who is Hadiya?". The Hindu. Retrieved 28 November 2017.
32. "Hadiya did not convert for love: Misconceptions busted and case explained". The News Minute. News Minute. 26 November 2017. Retrieved 28 November 2017.
33. . The New Indian Express. Archived from the original on 30 June 2015.
34. . Sify. Archived from the original on 11 August 2011. Retrieved 15 April 2014.
35. . News.outlookindia.com. Archived from the original on 8 April 2014. Retrieved 15 April 2014.
36. "Students Islamic Movement of India (SIMI)". Retrieved 24 August 2012.
37. India's Special Forces: History and Future of Special Forces. Vij Book India Pvt Ltd. 2013. ISBN 9789382573593.
38. Inside a Mangalore jail, two deaths and a communal crack
39. "NIA report on Popular Front of India's 'terror links' on government table". The Indian Express. 12 September 2017. Retrieved 26 September 2017.
40. . The New Indian Express. 28 April 2013. Archived from the original on 13 May 2013. Retrieved 21 April 2015.
41. "Kerala's Hadiya safe, 'happy and smiling', says women's panel post-visit". Deccan Chronicle. Deccan Chronicle. 6 November 2017. Retrieved 28 November 2017.
42. "On the back of a good showing, SDPI sets its sights higher". The Hindu. 12 May 2013. Retrieved 17 April 2014.
43. . The Times of India. 11 August 2009. Archived from the original on 11 August 2011. Retrieved 11 August 2010.
44. "PFI spreading tentacles to Andhra,says police chief", Indian Express, 12 August 2010
45. . Archived from the original on 13 May 2013.
46. "HuJi, Popular Front of India under lens for hate messages - Times of India". The Times of India. 22 August 2012. Retrieved 9 September 2016.
47. "In a pluralistic part of India, fears of rising Islamic extremism". washingtonpost.com. Washingtonpost.
48. Philip, Shaju (26 May 2017). "Day after Kerala HC annuls marriage with Muslim convert, man vows to fight 'injustice'". The Indian Express. Retrieved 28 November 2017.
49. . The New Indian Express. Archived from the original on 1 December 2017. Retrieved 30 November 2017.
50. "Josephine says she is prevented from visiting Hadiya". The Hindu. The Hindu. 14 November 2017. Retrieved 28 November 2017.
51. "Hadiya case: 7 booked for trespassing for trying to meet her while she's under house arrest". The News Minute. 31 August 2017. Retrieved 28 November 2017.
52. Chowdhary, Amit Anand (28 November 2017). "Supreme Court allows Hadiya out of father's custody to resume studies in Tamil Nadu - Times of India". The Times of India. Retrieved 28 November 2017.
53. Scroll Staff (28 November 2017). "Kerala conversion case: Hadiya says she is happy with SC order allowing her to finish her education". Scroll.in. Retrieved 28 November 2017.
54. "Supreme Court Observer". www.scobserver.in. Retrieved 17 June 2021.
55. "Home". newburghgazette.com. Retrieved 11 December 2017.
56. "NIA ends kerala probe, says there is love but no jihad". Hindustan times.

External links

•  India portal
•  Law portal
•  Hinduism portal
•  Islam portal