Elections in China

This article is about elections in the People's Republic of China. For elections in the Republic of China, see Elections in Taiwan.

Elections in the People's Republic of China occur under a one-party authoritarian political system controlled by the Chinese Communist Party (CCP).^[1][2] Direct elections, except in the special administrative regions of Hong Kong and Macau, occur only at the local level people's congresses and village committees, with all candidate nominations preapproved by the CCP.^[1][3] By law, all elections at all levels must adhere to the leadership of the CCP.^[4]

Since the founding of the People's Republic of China, elections have been highly constrained by the CCP's monopoly on power, limitations on free speech, and party control over nominations.^[5][6][7] Elections are not pluralistic as no opposition is allowed.^[8][9] Rory Truex, a researcher of Chinese politics at Princeton University, states that "the CCP tightly controls the nomination and election processes at every level in the people's congress system...the tiered, indirect electoral mechanism in the People's Congress system ensures that deputies at the highest levels face no semblance of electoral accountability to the Chinese citizenry."^[9]

Local people's congresses are directly elected under the control of the CCP. All higher levels of people's congresses up to the National People's Congress (NPC), the national legislature, are indirectly elected by the people's congress of the level immediately below.^[9] Candidate nominations at all levels are controlled by the CCP, and CCP's supreme position is enshrined in the state constitution.^[8]

Electoral system

Direct elections

People's congresses of cities that are not divided into districts (不设区的市), counties (县), city districts (市辖区), towns (镇), townships (乡), and lastly ethnic townships (民族乡), are directly elected.^{[10][non-primary source needed]} Additionally, village (村) committee members and chairpersons are directly elected.^[11]

Local People's Congresses

 

A list of voters posted in a neighbourhood in Shenzhen, Guangdong. April 11, 2014.

Under the electoral law of 1 July 1979, nomination of candidates for direct local elections (in counties, townships, etc.) can be made by the CCP, the various other political parties, mass organizations, or any voter seconded by at least 10 other voters.^{[12][non-primary source needed]} The final list of electoral candidates must be worked out through "discussion and consultation" or primary elections,^[13] which officially is conducted by an election committee in consultation with small groups of voters;^{[12][non-primary source needed]} though the candidates are chosen by CCP officials in practice.^[14] Election committee members are appointed by the standing committees of the people's congresses at the corresponding level.^{[12][non-primary source needed]} The process used for competitive races is known as the "three ups and three downs" (三上三下, sān shàng sān xià).^[15] According to the Chinese government, the "three ups and three downs" process is supposed to operate as follows:

• the election committee collates all of the nominations, checks them, and publishes the list of nominees and their basic details (first "up"). The published list is given to groups of electors, comprising the voters in each geographical or institutional electorate for discussion (first "down");
• the views of the groups of electors are conveyed via group representatives at a committee meeting, in order to reduce the number of candidates (second "up"). The views of different elector groups and the discussions at the committee meeting are then conveyed to voters, and their views are sought (second "down"); and
• the views of the groups of electors are once again collated and reported to the election committee which, by reference to the views of the majority of electors, determine the final list of candidates (third "up"). The list of names and basic details is published by electorate (third "down").^[16]

The number of candidates for a direct election should be 1.3 to 2 times the number of deputies to be elected.^{[12][non-primary source needed]} Where the people's congresses above the county level elect deputies at the next higher level, the number of candidates should be 1.2 to 1.5 times the number of deputies to be elected.^{[12][non-primary source needed]} Voting is done by secret ballot, and voters are entitled to recall elections.^[17]

Eligible voters, and their electoral districts, are chosen from the family (户籍) or work unit (单位 or dānwèi) registers for rural and urban voters, respectively, which are then submitted to the election committees after cross-examination by electoral district leaders.^[18]

Deputies are elected from either single-member districts or multi-member districts using a modified form of block combined approval voting in which a voter is allowed as many votes as there are seats to be filled (only one option may be selected per candidate), with the option to vote for or against a candidate, or abstain. The maximum number of deputies per district is three deputies, and each district within the same administrative region must have approximately an equal number of people.^{[12][non-primary source needed]} Candidates must obtain a majority of votes to be elected. If the number of candidates to receive over 50% of the vote is more than the number of deputies to be elected, only those who have obtained the highest vote up to the number of seats available win.^{[12][non-primary source needed]} A tied vote between candidates is settled with a run-off election. If the number of deputies elected is less than the number of deputies to be elected, a run-off election is held to fill the remaining seat(s).^{[12][non-primary source needed]} In the run-off election, the candidate(s) who receives the most votes is elected a local deputy; however, a candidate has to win at least one-third of the votes in the run-off to be elected.^{[12][non-primary source needed]} Vacancies are filled using by-elections.^{[12][non-primary source needed]}

Heads of Local People's Governments

Heads of People's Governments are formally elected by the People's Congress of that level pursuant to the Organic Law on Local People's Congresses and Governments,^[19] but the heads of township governments have been experimentally elected by the people through various mechanisms.^[20] There are several models used:^[21]

• direct nomination and election (Chinese: 直推直选; pinyin: zhi tui zhi xuan)
• direction election (Chinese: 直选; pinyin: zhi xuan)
• two ballots in three rounds (Chinese: 三轮两票制; pinyin: san lun liang piao zhi)
• competition based on mass recommendation (Chinese: 民推竞选; pinyin: min tui jing xuan)
• nomination and election by the masses (海选 or hǎi xuǎn; literally "sea election")
• public recommendation and public election (Chinese: 公推公选; pinyin: gong tui gong xuan)
• vote of confidence (Chinese: 信任投票; pinyin: xin ren tou piao)

Village chiefs

After taking power in 1978, Deng Xiaoping experimented with direct democracy at the local level.^[22] Villages have been traditionally the lowest level of government in China's complicated hierarchy of governance.^[23] Under the Organic Law of Village Committees, all of China's approximately 1 million villages are expected to hold competitive, direct elections for sub-governmental village committees. A 1998 revision to the law called for improvements in the nominating process and enhanced transparency in village committee administration.^[24] The revised law also explicitly transferred the power to nominate candidates to villagers themselves, as opposed to village groups or CCP branches.^[25]

Many have criticized the locally elected representatives as serving as "rubber stamps", with the local CCP secretaries still holding the ultimate power, though during some eras the Communists have flirted with the idea of potentially allowing some competition.^[6] In the early 1980s, a few southern villages began implementing "Vote for your Chief" policies, in which free elections are intended to be held for the election of a village chief, who holds a lot of power and influence traditionally in rural society.^[26] Many of these multi-candidate elections^[27] were successful, involving candidate debates, formal platforms, and the initiation of secret ballot boxes.^[28] Initial reforms did not include universal suffrage.^[29] Such an election comprises usually no more than 2000 voters, and the first-past-the-post system is used in determining the winner,^{[citation needed]} with no restriction on political affiliation.^[30] The elections, initially held every three years^[31] but later changed to five,^[6] are always supervised by a higher level of government, usually by a County Government. Part of the reason for these early elections was to shift the responsibility of ensuring good performance and reduced corruption of local leaders from the Chinese bureaucracy to the local villagers.^[32]

Since 2018, the central authorities in the CCP officially called for the yijiantiao (一肩挑) model, in which the village committees and the CCP village committees to have the same membership, with both led by the CCP village committee secretary.^[6] It announced in a five-year plan in 2018 that one-third of the more than 500,000 "administrative villages" were already following this system, and called for at least half of the village leaderships to follow this system. This had led to tighter vetting of candidates, involving blocking activists and others deemed to transgress political sensitivities.^[6]

A 2022 study conducted by the American Economic Association delved into the implementation of village elections in rural China and the eventual decline in village autonomy in later years. The researchers posited that this decline is linked to bureaucratic capability. As the administrative capacity at the village level strengthens, autocratic figures curtail the influence of elected bodies to reassert control.^[33]

Indirect elections

People's Congresses of provinces (省), directly administered municipalities (直辖市), and cities divided into districts (设区的市) are indirectly elected by the People's Congress of the level immediately below.^{[10][non-primary source needed]} Governors, mayors, and heads of counties, districts, townships and towns are elected by the respective local People's Congresses.^{[34][non-primary source needed]} Presidents of people's courts and the regional prosecutors general of people's procuratorates are elected by the respective local People's Congresses above the county level.^{[34][non-primary source needed]}

Local People's Governments

The Local People's Congress at each administrative level—other than the village level in rural areas, which hold direct elections—elects candidates for executive positions at that level of government and the Chairmen/Chairwomen of their regional People's Congress Standing Committees.^{[citation needed]}

National People's Congress

The National People's Congress (NPC) has 2,977 members, elected for five year terms. Deputies are elected (over a three-month period) by the people's congresses of the provinces of China, autonomous regions, municipalities directly under the Central Government, as well as by electoral college in the special administrative regions of Hong Kong and Macau, and by the armed forces which function as at-large electoral districts.^{[35][better source needed]} Generally, seats are apportioned to each electoral district in proportion to their population, though the system for apportioning seats for Hong Kong, Macau, Taiwan and the People's Liberation Army differ.^[35][36] No electoral district may be apportioned fewer than 15 seats in the NPC.^[35]

The NPC elects and appoints the following personnel:^[37]

• President of the People's Republic of China
• Vice President of the People's Republic of China
• Chairperson of the Central Military Commission (PRC)
• Chairperson of the National Commission of Supervision
• President of the Supreme People's Court
• Prosecutor-General of the Supreme People's Procuratorate

The NPC also appoints the premier of the State Council based on the president's nomination, other members of the State Council based on the premier's nomination, and other members of the Central Military Commission based on the CMC chair's nomination.^[37]

Party control

Elections in China occur under a political system controlled by the Chinese Communist Party (CCP),^{[1][2][38][39]} with all candidate nominations preapproved by the CCP.^{[1][3][5][9][40]} CCP regulations require members of the People's Congresses, People's Governments, and People's Courts to implement CCP recommendations (including nominations).^[41] Elected leaders remain subordinate to the corresponding CCP secretary, and most are appointed by higher-level party organizations.^[41]

There are a small number of independent candidates for people's congress, particularly in neighborhoods of major cities, who sometimes campaign using Weibo.^[42] Independent candidates are strongly discouraged and face government intervention in their campaigns.^[7] In practice, the power of parties other than the CCP is eliminated.^[42] Because none of the minor parties have independent bases of support and rely on CCP approval for appointment to positions of power, none have true political power independent of the CCP. Whereas there are CCP committees in people's congresses at all levels, none of the other parties operate any form of party parliamentary groups.^{[citation needed]}

Legislation

The first electoral law was passed in March 1953, and the second on 1 July 1979.^[13] The 1979 law allowed for ordinary voters to nominate candidates, unlike the 1953 law which provided no such mechanism.^[13] The 1979 law was revised in 1982, removing the reference to the ability of political parties, mass organizations, and voters to use "various forms of publicity", and instead instructing that the "election committees should introduce the candidates to the voters; the political parties, mass organizations, and voters who recommend the candidates can introduce them at group meetings of the voters".^[43] In 1986, the election law was amended to disallow primary elections.^[44]

Traditionally, village chiefs were appointed by the township government.^[11] The Organic Law of Village Committees was enacted in 1987 and implemented in 1988, allowing for direct election of village chiefs instead.^[45] The 2020 revisions to the electoral law mandated that all elections at all levels must adhere to the leadership of the CCP.^[4]

Criticism

The performed elections in China do not meet free and fair election criteria such as ballot access and political media access.^[46] Freedom of political speech and freedom of political assembly are all severely restricted by the government.^[47][48] The general Chinese public has virtually no say on how the top leaders of the country are elected.^[49][47] Political censorship is widespread and political dissent is harshly punished in the country.^[50] China is 3rd least electoral democratic country in the world and second least electoral democratic country in Asia according to 2023 V-Dem Democracy indices.^[51]

See also

•  China portal
•  Politics portal

• Legislative system of China
• List of voting results of the National People's Congress of China
• Politics of China
• Yao Lifa
• Human rights in China

References

Citations

1. Gandhi, Jennifer; Lust-Okar, Ellen (2009-06-01). "Elections Under Authoritarianism". Annual Review of Political Science. 12 (1): 403–422. doi:10.1146/annurev.polisci.11.060106.095434. ISSN 1094-2939.
2. Lee, Ching Kwan; Zhang, Yonghong (2013-05-01). "The Power of Instability: Unraveling the Microfoundations of Bargained Authoritarianism in China". American Journal of Sociology. 118 (6): 1475–1508. doi:10.1086/670802. ISSN 0002-9602. S2CID 144559373.
3. Geddes, Barbara; Wright, Joseph; Frantz, Erica (2018). How Dictatorships Work. Cambridge University Press. p. 141. doi:10.1017/9781316336182. ISBN 978-1-316-33618-2. S2CID 226899229.
4. Hao, Mingsong; Ke, Xiwang (5 July 2023). "Personal Networks and Grassroots Election Participation in China: Findings from the Chinese General Social Survey". Journal of Chinese Political Science. 29 (1): 159–184. doi:10.1007/s11366-023-09861-3. ISSN 1080-6954.
5. Hernández, Javier C. (2016-11-15). "'We Have a Fake Election': China Disrupts Local Campaigns". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. from the original on 2021-11-05. Retrieved 2021-11-05.
6. "The West once dreamed of democracy taking root in rural China". The Economist. 2021-01-14. ISSN 0013-0613. from the original on 2021-11-05. Retrieved 2021-11-05.
7. LaFraniere, Sharon (2011-12-04). "Alarmed by Independent Candidates, Chinese Authorities Crack Down". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. from the original on 2023-04-23. Retrieved 2023-04-24.
8. "Democracy". Decoding China. Heidelberg University. 4 February 2021. from the original on 2022-08-16. Retrieved 2022-08-22.
9. Truex, Rory (2016-10-28). Making Autocracy Work: Representation and Responsiveness in Modern China. Cambridge University Press. pp. 52, 111. doi:10.1017/CBO9781316771785. ISBN 978-1-107-17243-2. OCLC 964291909.
10. Article 97 of the Constitution of China
11. Niou 2011, p. 3.
12. "Electoral Law of the National People's Congress and Local People's Congresses of the People's Republic of China". NPC.gov. National People's Congress of the People's Republic of China. from the original on 16 September 2021. Retrieved 12 January 2021.
13. Chen 1999, p. 65.
14. "Democracy's other version: China holds elections". The Economist. November 10, 2016. from the original on June 18, 2017. Retrieved August 26, 2017.
15. McCormick 1990, p. 141.
16. [What is the specific procedure for the "three ups and three downs" method for determining through consultation the official candidates for People's Congress Representatives at the county and prefecture level?] (in Chinese). Hebei People's Congress. 6 December 2011. Archived from the original on 2016-03-04.
17. Chen 1999, p. 66.
18. Leung 1996, pp. 109–110.
19. Lin 2011, pp. 67–69.
20. Lin 2011, p. 66.
21. 林 (Lin), 峰 (Feng) (2011). 郑 (Cheng), 宇硕(Joseph Y. S.) (ed.). Whither China's Democracy: Democratization in China Since the Tiananmen Incident. City University of Hong Kong Press. pp. 65–99. ISBN 978-962-937-181-4. At pp. 77–87.
22. Michelle Phillips (July 4, 2011). "Chinese independents to challenge Communists in 2012". The Washington Times Weekly. from the original on November 9, 2017. Retrieved May 10, 2017.
23. Lei Xie (2012). Environmental Activism in China. Routledge. p. 12. ISBN 9781134020263.
24. Joseph de Rivera (2008). Handbook on Building Cultures of Peace. Springer. p. 162. ISBN 9780387095752.
25. B. He (2007). Rural Democracy in China: The Role of Village Elections. Springer. p. 25. ISBN 9780230607316.
26. Gerald Segal (1989). Political and economic encyclopaedia of the Pacific. Longman. p. 34. ISBN 9780582051614.
27. Jonathan Unger (2002). The Transformation of Rural China. M.E. Sharpe. p. 218. ISBN 9780765605511.
28. Sue Vander Hook (2011). Communism. ABDO. p. 94. ISBN 9781617589478.
29. Hugo Burgh (2004). The Chinese Journalist: Mediating Information in the World's Most Populous Country. Routledge. p. 77. ISBN 9780203323267.
30. Andrew Sancton and Chen Zhenming (2014). Citizen Participation at the Local Level in China and Canada. CRC Press. p. 214. ISBN 9781482228977.
31. Gunter Schubert and Anna L. Ahlers (2012). Participation and Empowerment at the Grassroots: Chinese Village Elections in Perspective. Lexington Books. p. 1. ISBN 9780739174807.
32. William A. Joseph (2014). Politics in China: An Introduction. Oxford University Press. p. 302. ISBN 978-0-19-933942-6.
33. Martinez-Bravo, Monica; Padró I Miquel, Gerard; Qian, Nancy; Yao, Yang (2022-09-01). "The Rise and Fall of Local Elections in China". American Economic Review. 112 (9). American Economic Association: 2921–2958. doi:10.1257/aer.20181249. ISSN 0002-8282.
34. Article 101 of the Constitution of China
35. "Allocation of the Number of Deputies". China Internet Information Center. from the original on 12 August 2002. Retrieved 6 May 2021.
36. Ji, Bian (6 March 2011). "China's National People's Congress System: A Brief Introduction". China US Focus. China-United States Exchange Foundation. from the original on 6 May 2021. Retrieved 6 May 2021.
37. Lin 2011, pp. 68–69.
38. Landry, Pierre F.; Davis, Deborah; Wang, Shiru (2010-06-01). "Elections in Rural China: Competition Without Parties". Comparative Political Studies. 43 (6): 763–790. doi:10.1177/0010414009359392. ISSN 0010-4140. S2CID 43175132.
39. Manion, Melanie (2017-03-01). ""Good Types" in Authoritarian Elections: The Selectoral Connection in Chinese Local Congresses". Comparative Political Studies. 50 (3): 362–394. doi:10.1177/0010414014537027. ISSN 0010-4140. S2CID 155166131.
40. Wallace, Jeremy L. (2016). "Juking the Stats? Authoritarian Information Problems in China". British Journal of Political Science. 46 (1): 11–29. doi:10.1017/S0007123414000106. ISSN 0007-1234. S2CID 154275103.
41. Lin 2011, pp. 72–76. "Regulations on the Selection and Appointment Work of Cadres of Both CPC and Government Organs".
42. LaFraniere, Sharon (October 31, 2011). "In China, Political Outsiders Turn to Microblog Campaigns". The New York Times. from the original on November 1, 2011. Retrieved November 1, 2011. an election that is ostensibly open to all comers, but in fact is stacked in favor of the Communist Party's handpicked candidates.
43. Chen 1999, p. 69.
44. McCormick 1990, p. 142.
45. Niou 2011, pp. 4–5.
46. Bishop, Sylvia; Hoeffler, Anke (2016). "Free and fair elections: A new database". Journal of Peace Research. 53 (4): 608–616. doi:10.1177/0022343316642508. S2CID 110571606.
47. "China: Freedom on the Net 2022 Country Report". Freedom House. from the original on 2023-01-23. Retrieved 2022-12-16.
48. Human Rights Watch (2021-01-13), "China: Events of 2020", English, retrieved 2022-12-16
49. George, Nectar Gan,Steve (2021-12-08). "China claims its authoritarian one-party system is a democracy -- and one that works better than the US". CNN. from the original on 2022-06-07. Retrieved 2022-12-16.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
50. Bradsher, Keith; Myers, Steven Lee (2021-12-07). "Ahead of Biden's Democracy Summit, China Says: We're Also a Democracy". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. from the original on 2022-12-15. Retrieved 2022-12-16.
51. V-Dem Institute (2023). "The V-Dem Dataset". from the original on 8 December 2022. Retrieved 14 October 2023.

Sources

• Chen, An (1999). "Two Systems for Electing People's Deputies". Restructuring Political Power in China: Alliances and Opposition, 1978–1998. Lynne Rienner Publishers. pp. 63–96. ISBN 978-1-555-87842-9.
• McCormick, Barrett L. (1990). "Elections to Local People's Congresses". Political Reform in Post-Mao China: Democracy and Bureaucracy in a Leninist State. University of California Press. pp. 130–156. ISBN 978-0-520-06765-3.
• Leung, Kwan-kwok (1996). "The Basic-Level Elections in Guangzhou Since 1979". In Macpherson, Stewart; Cheng, Joseph Y.S (eds.). Economic and Social Development in South China. Edward Elgar Publishing. pp. 107–. ISBN 978-1-858-98301-1.
• Niou, Emerson M. S. (2011), An Introduction to the Electoral Systems Used in Chinese Village Elections (PDF), (PDF) from the original on 2015-09-06, retrieved 2012-06-15
• Truex, Rory (2016). Making Autocracy Work: Representation and Responsiveness in Modern China. Cambridge University Press. ISBN 9781107172432.