Temperance movement in the United Kingdom

The temperance movement in the United Kingdom was a social movement that campaigned against the recreational use and sale of alcohol, and promoted total abstinence (teetotalism). In the 19th century, high levels of alcohol consumption and drunkenness were seen by social reformers as a danger to society's wellbeing, leading to social issues such as poverty, child neglect, immorality and economic decline. Temperance societies began to be formed in the 1830s to campaign against alcohol. Specific groups were created over periods of time dedicated to the different aspects of drinking. For example, in 1847, the Band of Hope was created to persuade children not to start drinking alcohol. Most of these temperance groups were aimed at the working class. Temperance was also supported by some religious groups, particularly the Nonconformist Churches. Although the temperance movement met with local success in parts of Britain, it failed to impose national prohibition, and disappeared as a significant force following the Second World War.

Origins

 

Gin Lane by William Hogarth, 1751

Before the 19th century, there were diatribes published against drunkenness and excess, but total abstinence from alcohol was very rarely advocated or practised. In the 18th century, there was a "gin craze" in Great Britain, as satirised in William Hogarth's Gin Lane.^[1] The bourgeoisie became increasingly critical of the widespread drunkenness among the lower classes. Motivated by the bourgeoisie's desire for order, and amplified by the population growth in the cities, the drinking of gin became the subject of critical national debate.^[2] In 1743, John Wesley, the founder of the Methodist Churches, proclaimed "that buying, selling, and drinking of liquor, unless absolutely necessary, were evils to be avoided".^[3]

Early movement

The early temperance movement was inspired by the actions of Irish Presbyterian Church minister John Edgar, who poured his stock of whiskey out of his window in 1829. On 14 August 1829 he wrote a letter in the Belfast Telegraph advocating temperance. Edgar and other early advocates concentrated their efforts on the elimination of spirits rather than wine and beer.^{[4][5]: 141–144} The first organisation that promoted temperance was founded in 1829 by John Dunlop and his aunt, Lilias Graham of Gairbraid,^[6] and named the Glasgow and West of Scotland Temperance Society.^[7]

Joseph Livesey was another British temperance advocate who financed his philanthropic work with the profits attained from cheese production, following an introduction to the food product by a doctor he had consulted with regards to a serious ailment in 1816.^[8] Livesey opened the first temperance hotel in 1833 and the next year founded the first temperance magazine, The Preston Temperance Advocate (1834–37).^[5]: 146 The British Association for the Promotion of Temperance was established by 1835.^[4]: 132

As a response to rising social problems in the newly-industrialised cities, a stricter form of temperance emerged called teetotalism, which promoted the complete abstinence from alcoholic beverages, this time including wine and beer, not just ardent spirits. The term teetotal is apocryphally said to derive from a speech by Richard "Dickie" Turner, a follower of Livesey, in Preston in 1833.^[9]

In 1838, the mass working class movement for universal suffrage, Chartism, included a current called "temperance chartism". Faced with the refusal of the parliament of the time to give the right to vote to working people, the temperance chartists saw the campaign against alcohol as a way of proving to the elites that working-class people were responsible enough to be granted the vote.^[10][11] In short, the 1830s was mostly characterised by moral persuasion of workers.^[12]: 25

 

Band of Hope Banner located in the village of Constantine in Cornwall supporting temperance

In 1847, the Band of Hope was founded in Leeds, with the stated aim of saving working class children from the perils of drink. It promoted alcohol education. Band members had to pledge to abstain "from all liquors of an intoxicating quality, whether ale, porter, wine or ardent spirits, except as medicine"^[13]: 99

In 1853, inspired by the Maine liquor law in the US, the United Kingdom Alliance was formed with the aim of promoting a similar law prohibiting the sale of alcohol in the UK. This hard-line group of prohibitionists was opposed by other temperance organisations who preferred moral persuasion to a legal ban. This division in the ranks limited the effectiveness of the temperance movement as a whole. The impotence of legislation in this field was demonstrated when the Sale of Beer Act 1854 which restricted Sunday opening hours had to be repealed, following widespread rioting. In 1859 a prototype prohibition bill was overwhelmingly defeated in the House of Commons.^{[13]: 99–100}

Temperance clubs and institutes came into being, one of the largest in the UK, formed in 1864 and still in use, was Wisbech Working Men's Club and Institute, Isle of Ely. One of its trustees was the banker and Quaker Baron Peckover, Lord Lieutenant of Cambridgeshire.^[14]

The US-based (but international) Woman's Christian Temperance Union (WCTU) was founded in 1873,^[15] becoming one of the largest women's societies in the world in the 19th century, campaigning for temperance and women's suffrage.^[16]: 1 In 1876 the British Women's Temperance Association was formed by women to persuade men to stop drinking, rebranded in 2006 as the White Ribbon Association.^[17]

One of the most active advocates of temperance was Dr. Norman Shanks Kerr. He promoted the treatment of inebriates and held that inebriety was a disease, not a vice, and that it should be treated accordingly. In 1884, in response to the inadequacy of the Habitual Drunkards Act of 1879, he founded the Society for the Study and Cure of Inebriety and was the first president.^[18]: 135 The society still exists as the Society for the Study of Addiction.

In 1884 the National Temperance Federation, which was associated with the Liberal Party, was founded as an umbrella organisation. The Conservative Party largely supported the interests of the alcohol industry and opposed temperance.^[19]

Religious support

See also: Christian views on alcohol

 

Methodist Temperance Magazine, a Wesleyan Methodist publication in Cardiff

The various Nonconformist Churches actively encouraged total abstinence among their congregations, and lobbied parliament to restrict alcohol sales. By the 1870s most young ministers abstained from alcohol. In 1886 a survey of 1,900 Baptist ministers revealed that 1,000 were total abstainers.^[19]

In the 19th century, the Methodist Churches were aligned with the temperance movement.^[20] Methodists believed that despite the supposed economic benefits of liquor traffic such as job creation and taxes, the harm that it caused society through its contribution to murder, gambling, prostitution, and political corruption outweighed its economic benefits.^[21]: 7 Both Wesleyan Methodists and Primitive Methodists championed the cause of temperance.^[22] The Wesleyan Methodists built around 100 'Central Halls', large venues which hosted cheap concerts, comedy shows and films, intended to keep the urban working classes away from public houses.^[23]

In 1864, another Methodist group, the Salvation Army was founded in London with a heavy emphasis on abstinence from alcohol and ministering to the working class, which led publicans to fund a Skeleton Army in order to disrupt their meetings. The Salvation Army quickly spread internationally, maintaining an emphasis on abstinence.^{[24][18]: 542}

In Wales Lady Llanover, motivated by Calvinistic Methodist teachings, was an outspoken critic of the evils of alcohol and closed all the public houses on her estate.^[25]

Many Quakers (members of the Religious Society of Friends) took an active role in the temperance movement. Chocolatier John Cadbury was a temperance Quaker and he viewed drinking chocolate as an alternative to alcoholic beverages.^[26] He prohibited the sale of alcohol in Bournville, the model village he founded, and no public houses have been built there.^[27]

The Church of England Temperance Society, which had roots in the Anglo-Catholic tradition was founded in 1862 by Henry Ellison,^[28][29] and its volunteers within the court system would lead to the first probation service. The League of the Cross was founded in 1873 by Cardinal Manning. A Roman Catholic-only organisation, the League's members took a pledge of total abstinence.^[30]

From 1880 to 1882 the cause of abstinence was revived by the Gospel Temperance or Blue Ribbon movement, based in America. They sent a member named Richard Booth to promote their cause in England through mass meetings held up and down the country.^{[5]: 153–4}

Later movement and decline

 

Temperance fountain at the end of Blackfriars Bridge, London. Temperance fountains were installed to encourage people not to drink beer by the provision of safe and free water.

By the end of the 19th century, it was estimated that about a tenth of the adult population were total abstainers of alcohol.^[19][31]

The temperance movement received an unexpected boost due to state intervention when the Liberal government passed the Defence of the Realm Act in 1914 at the beginning of the First World War. According to the provisions of the Act, pub hours were licensed, beer was watered down and was subject to a penny a pint extra tax.^[13]: 106 This situation was maintained by the subsequent establishment of the State Management Scheme in 1916 which nationalised breweries and pubs in certain areas of Britain where armaments manufacture was taking place.^[32]

At the same time, there were temperance organisations connected to the labour movement. An example would be the Scottish Prohibition Party, founded in 1901 by a communist temperance activist called Bob Stewart, who followed the British Labour Party on all other issues. It went on to defeat Winston Churchill in Dundee in the 1922 general election.^[33] There was a Marxist offshoot called the Prohibition and Reform Party, which later became part of the Communist Party of Great Britain in 1920.^[34]

Between the wars, American exponents of the sterling example set to Britain by National Prohibition, such as William "Pussyfoot" Johnson and Mary Harris Armor, toured the country, to be met with derision, and in Johnson's case, violence.^{[5]: 171–3} In the end, the example of the failure of prohibition in America put paid to any remote chance that the temperance lobby would succeed in achieving its aims in the UK.^[13]: 107

Legacy

The former Manchester City F.C. football stadium Maine Road took its name from a street that had been renamed Maine Road (from Dog Kennel Lane) by members of the temperance movement. They selected the name as a result of the 1853 Maine law.^[35]

Vimto, originally "Vim Tonic", was concocted in 1908 as a healthy alternative to alcohol, and originally sold in temperance bars.^[36] Fitzpatrick's Herbal Health in Rawtenstall, Lancashire, is thought to be the oldest surviving temperance bar – other such establishments have become popular in recent times.^[37][38]

Several of the largest temperance organisations survive under different names. For example, the Band of Hope is now named Hope UK, with the stated aim of "providing drug and alcohol education and training for children and young people, parents and youth workers".^[39]

See also

•  United Kingdom portal

• List of Temperance organizations
• Rothwell Temperance Band
• Alcohol and health
• Harriet A. Glazebrook

References

1. Sooke, Alastair. "Hogarth's London: Gin Lane and Beer Street". www.bbc.com. Retrieved 24 April 2021.
2. Yeomans, Henry (2014). Alcohol and Moral Regulation: Public Attitudes, Spirited Measures and Victorian Hangovers. Policy Press. p. 37. ISBN 9781447309932.
3. Williams, William Henry (1984). The Garden of American Methodism: The Delmarva Peninsula, 1769-1820. Peninsula Conference of the United Methodist Church. p. 151. ISBN 9780842022279.
4. Harrison, Brian (1971). Drink & the Victorians, The Temperance Question in England 1815–1872. Faber and Faber.
5. Peter, Fryer (1965). Mrs. Grundy: Studies in English Prudery. Corgi Books.
6. "The Glasgow Herald [November 19, 1929]". Archived from the original on 31 March 2017. Retrieved 31 March 2017.
7. Schrad, Mark Lawrence (2010). The Political Power of Bad Ideas: Networks, Institutions, and the Global Prohibition Wave. Oxford University Press, USA. p. 35. ISBN 978-0-19974-235-6.
8. . www.waltonledale.co.uk. Walton le Dale. 2000–2012. Archived from the original on 9 March 2012. Retrieved 11 June 2012.
9. "teetotal". Oxford Dictionaries. Oxford University Press. 2012. Retrieved 11 June 2012.^{[dead link]}
10. Harrison, Brian (1973). "Teetotal Chartism". History. 58 (193): 193–217. doi:10.1111/j.1468-229X.1973.tb01282.x. ISSN 0018-2648. JSTOR 24408553. Retrieved 24 April 2021.
11. "To the working men of Great Britain". Chartist Circular. 19 December 1840. p. 1. Retrieved 2 December 2017.
12. Edman, Johan (September 2015). "Temperance and Modernity: Alcohol Consumption as a Collective Problem, 1885–1913". Journal of Social History. 49 (1): 20–52. doi:10.1093/jsh/shv029.
13. Brownlee, Nick (2002). This is Alcohol. London: Sanctuary Publishing. ISBN 978-186074-422-8.
14. Gardiner, FJ (1898). History of Wisbech and Neighborhood, during the last fifty years - 1848-1898. Gardiner & Co. p. 220.
15. Keating, Joseph (1913). "Temperance Movements" . In Herbermann, Charles (ed.). Catholic Encyclopedia. New York: Robert Appleton Company.
16. Osborne, Lori (12 September 2015). Frances Willard and the Historic Link Between the 19th Century Women's Temperance and Suffrage Movements. National Archives in Washington.
17. "Our History". White Ribbon Association. Retrieved 24 April 2021.
18. Blocker, Jack S.; David, M. Fahey; Tyrrell, Ian R., eds. (2003). Alcohol and Temperance in Modern History: An International Encyclopedia. p. 542.
19. . Spartacus Educational. Spartacus Educational Publishers Ltd. Archived from the original on 20 May 2012. Retrieved 9 June 2012.
20. Vickers, John A. (ed.). "Temperance". A Dictionary of Methodism in Britain and Ireland. Retrieved 24 April 2021.
21. Timberlake, James H. (1963). Prohibition and the Progressive Movement 1900-1920. London: Harvard University Press.
22. Wheeler, Henry (1882). Methodism and the Temperance Reformation. Walden and Stowe. p. 278.
23. Moore, Keith (30 August 2012). "What happened to the Methodist central halls?". BBC News.
24. Hare, Chris (1988). "The Skeleton Army and the Bonfire Boys, Worthing, 1884". Folklore. 99 (2): 221–231. doi:10.1080/0015587X.1988.9716444. JSTOR 1260460.
25. "Wales alcohol restrictions: Temperance's long history". BBC News. 4 December 2020. Retrieved 24 April 2021.
26. Wilkes, Aaron; Ball, James (2009). KS3 History by Aaron Wilkes: Industry, Reform & Empire Student Book (1750-1900). Folens Limited. p. 99. ISBN 978-1-85008-346-7.
27. Meller, Helen (1997). Towns, Plans and Society in Modern Britain. Cambridge University Press. p. 20. ISBN 978-0-521-57644-4. Retrieved 24 April 2021.
28. Sherlock, Frederick (1910). Henry John Ellison: Founder of the Church of England Temperance Society.
29. Herbermann, Charles, ed. (1913). "Temperance Movements" . Catholic Encyclopedia. New York: Robert Appleton Company.
30. Dingle, A. E.; Harrison, B. H. (1969). "Cardinal Manning as Temperance Reformer". The Historical Journal. 12 (3): 485–510. doi:10.1017/S0018246X00007251. S2CID 159977906.
31. Mcallister, Annemarie (2016) "Temperance Periodicals". In: The Routledge Handbook to Nineteenth-Century British Periodicals and Newspapers (PDF). Routledge. 2016. ISBN 978-1-4094-6888-2. Retrieved 24 April 2021.
32. Duncan, Robert (2010). "Lord D'Abernon's "Model Farm": The Central Control Board's Carlisle Experiment". Social History of Alcohol & Drugs. 24 (2): 119–140. doi:10.1086/SHAD24020119. S2CID 158837534.
33. Walker, William M. (1973). "The Scottish Prohibition Party and the Millennium". International Review of Social History. 18 (3): 353–79. doi:10.1017/S0020859000004375.
34. Simkin, John (1997). "Prohibition and Reform Party". Spartacus Educational. Retrieved 24 April 2021.
35. James, Gary (2009). The Big Book of City. James Ward. ISBN 978-0-9558127-2-9.
36. Maconie, Stuart (10 September 2015). The Pie at Night: Nights Out in the North. Penguin Random House. p. 337. ISBN 978-0-09-193381-4.
37. Anson, John (12 March 2007). "Rawtenstall: Fitzpatrick's Temperance Bar". Newsquest (North West) Ltd. Lancashire Telegraph. Retrieved 16 May 2018.
38. Eby, Margaret (19 July 2019). "The rise of the sober bar". BBC. Retrieved 21 August 2019. In the late 19th Century, a number of alcohol-free bars known as temperance bars were established in the UK on the heels of the temperance movement, which advocated abstinence. Fitzpatrick's Temperance Bar, founded in 1890 in Rawtenstall, north of Manchester, is still slinging root beer and glasses of dandelion and burdock today. (...) The audience isn't just non-drinkers but anyone who wants a fun bar environment without the threat of a hangover the next day.
39. "Welcome to HOPE UK". Hope UK. 21 February 2017. Retrieved 24 April 2021.

External links

• Drink and the Victorians: a history of the British Temperance Movement (ca. 1200 items) is housed in the Department of Special Collections and University Archives 4 June 2008 at the Wayback Machine at Stanford University Libraries
• Temperance Town, a suburb in Cardiff, Wales, where alcohol was banned
• See more images from temperance movement in United Kingdom by selecting the "Alcohol" subject at the Persuasive Cartography, The PJ Mode Collection, Cornell University Library