Alfred Ely Beach

Alfred Ely Beach (September 1, 1826 – January 1, 1896) was an American inventor, entrepreneur, publisher, and patent lawyer, born in Springfield, Massachusetts. He is most known for his design of New York City's earliest subway predecessor, the Beach Pneumatic Transit, which became the first subway in America.^[1] He was an early owner and cofounder of Scientific American and Munn & Co., the country's leading patent agency, and helped secure patents for Thomas Edison, Alexander Graham Bell, Cornelius Vanderbilt, and other innovators.^[2] A member of the Union League of New York, he also invented a typewriter for the blind and a system for heating water with solar power.^[3]

Alfred Ely Beach
Beach c. 1870
Born	(1826-09-01)September 1, 1826 Springfield, Massachusetts, US
Died	January 1, 1896(1896-01-01) (aged 69) New York City, US
Education	Monson Academy (now Wilbraham & Monson Academy)
Occupations	Inventor publisher patent lawyer
Known for	Designing the Beach Pneumatic Transit
Children	Frederick Converse Beach
Parent	Moses Yale Beach (father)
Relatives	Moses S. Beach, brother William Yale Beach, brother Charles Yale Beach, nephew Stanley Yale Beach, grandson
Family	Yale

Childhood home of Alfred Ely Beach, built by his father in 1846

Early years

 

Scientific American in 1845, a magazine that was a major force for the diffusion of innovations during the 19th century

Beach was born in Springfield, Massachusetts, and was the son of a prominent publisher, Moses Yale Beach, owner of the New York Sun and member of the Yale family.^[4][5] His brother William Yale Beach was a banker while his other brother, Moses S. Beach, took over the family newspaper and supported the policies of Abraham Lincoln during his ownership. Alfred's brother was also later a trustee and shareholder in his Broadway Underground Railway Company, along with his son Frederick C. Beach, and his nephew Charles Yale Beach.^[6]

Charles Yale's brothers-in-law were Commodore Holland Newton Stevenson, and John McAllister Stevenson, a Yale graduate and board director of the Pittsfield Electric Street Railway Company in 1892, which operated electric trolley cars, replacing horsecars.^[7][8] His three nephews and his great-grandnephew, Rev. Brewster Yale Beach, all attended Yale University.^[9][10]

Alfred worked for his father at the "Sun" until he and a friend, Orson Desaix Munn, decided to buy Scientific American, a relatively new publication, becoming the early founders of that company.^[11] He also brought in the venture Salem Howe Wales, President of the New York City Department of Docks and co-founder of the Metropolitan Museum of Art. Beach was the editor and publisher of Scientific American for fifty years, and they ran the magazine until their deaths decades later, and it was carried on by their sons and grandsons for decades more.^[12]

Scientific American is now the oldest continuously published magazine in the United States, and has featured prominent scientists over time such as Albert Einstein, Nikola Tesla, Marie Curie, and Thomas Edison. They reported the invention and patent of Abraham Lincoln relating to his device that intended to help boats navigate shallows.

Munn & Co.

 

Munn & Co. in 1859, patent office headquarters in Washington, next to the United States Patent Office

In 1846, Munn and Beach established a prominent patent agency within Scientific American named Munn & Co., in synergy with the scientists featured in the magazine who wanted to patent their inventions.^[13] They provided the service for the patent applications and tracked the progress once it reached the U.S. Patent Office, having their headquarters next door in Washington.

As a boy, Thomas Edison used to walk a few miles every week to get his copy of the magazine, and later on in his career, he walked in Beach's office one day and showed him a device he called the phonograph, being the first to see his invention.^[14][15][16] Beach tested the device with Edison, liked it, and helped him filed the patent.^[17] Edison would become a frequent visitor of Beach.^[18]

He also helped Alexander Graham Bell, Samuel F. B. Morse, Elias Howe, R. J. Gatling, Capt. John Ericsson, Cornelius Vanderbilt, Col. John Jacob Astor IV, who later died on the Titanic, and thousand of other inventors, and the magazine's patent department eventually filed about three thousand patents a year, forcing Beach to split his time between New York and Washington, defending the patents of the inventors in court.^[19][20][21]

Notable competitors in New York were Seth Perkins Staples and George Sickles, father of Congressman Daniel Sickles, who married the granddaughter of Venetian artist Lorenzo Da Ponte.^[22] Lorenzo, a friend of Casanova, was partner of Mozart and Habsburg Emperor Joseph II, brother of Marie Antoinette, and became the great-grandfather of Mary Yale Ogden's husband, member of the Yale family.^[23][24][25]

Beach patented some of his own inventions, notably an early typewriter designed for use by the blind, an engineering first for the Americas. He received the gold medal by the American Institute at the New York Crystal Palace for the Great Exhibition of 1853, and his invention served as the prototype for typewriters over the next century. He invented a cable traction railway system, and designed and built one of the world's first tunnelling shields in the same year as famed engineer James Henry Greathead.^[26]

His patent agency eventually brought him fame and fortune, and his magazine helped stimulate 19th-century technological innovations and became one of the most prestigious scientific magazines of its time.^[27][28] During its peak years, Munn & Co., as the patent agency of Scientific American, prosecuted about one third of all the patents issued by the US Patent Office.^[29] By 1924, they had filled more than 200,000 patents, gaining a virtual monopoly in the patent business, representing about 15% of all the patents filled in the United States, and was partly responsible for the rapid growth of the US patent system.^[30] After opening an office in Washington, they opened new offices across the globe and became recognized as the most successful patent law firm in the world.^[31]

Invention of a subway

 

Broadway underground railway (1872) , New York, next to City Hall

 

Socialites waiting in the Beach Pneumatic Transit station under Broadway

Beach's most famous invention was New York City's first subway, the Beach Pneumatic Transit.^[32] He received his first charter by the legislature in 1868, four years before Commodore Vanderbilt's attempt of building a subway in New York, which would have linked New York City Hall to Grand Central Station.^[33][34] Beach created his own enterprise using the pneumatic tube technology, naming it the Beach Pneumatic Transit Company, and made himself its President. This idea came about during the late 1860s, when traffic in New York was a nightmare, especially along its central artery of Broadway, as people were mostly travelling by foot and horse carriages during this time. "The city was ruled by the notoriously corrupt William “Boss” Tweed, who among many illegal doings was getting kickbacks from the city's steampowered train and horse-pulled bus lines."^[35] Beach was one of a few visionaries who proposed building an underground railway under Broadway to help relieve the traffic congestion. The inspiration was the underground Metropolitan Railway in London but in contrast to that and others' proposals for New York, Beach proposed the use of trains propelled by pneumatics instead of conventional steam engines, and construction using a tunnelling shield of his invention^[36] to minimize disturbing the street.^[37]

Beach used a circular design based upon Marc Isambard Brunel's rectangular shield, which may represent the shift in design from rectangular to cylindrical. It was unclear when or who transitioned tunneling shield design from rectangular to circular until The New York Times wrote an article describing the original Beach tunneling shield in 1870.^[38]

 

London Pneumatic Despatch Company, inspiration for Beach's mail system

 

Plan of the patent of Beach Pneumatic Transit mailing system with pneumatic cars used to deliver packages through an underground railroad network

Beach was also interested in pneumatic tubes for the transport of letters and packages, another idea recently put into use in London by the London Pneumatic Despatch Company.^[39] He refused to blackmail "Boss" Tweed to have his proposal approved.^[40][41] He set out a way to bypass the corrupt politicians by building his tunnel in secret during the night, carting away the dirt under the cover of darkness, with the city officials at City Hall just across the street.^[42][43] He put up $350,000 of his own money to bankroll the project, allowing him to bypass the corruption and extortion schemes of Tammany Hall, which included the Governor, the Mayor, the City comptroller, and countless of other corrupted officials.^[44][45] His thinking was that once the public will see the completed subway, the politicians would not dare to stop him.^[46] With a franchise from the state he began construction of a tunnel for small pneumatic tubes in 1869, but diverted it into a demonstration of a passenger railway that opened on February 26, 1870.^[47] It is most interesting to note that Beach's tunnel design was likely the first cylindrical tunnel design ever used in the Americas and built using a design inspired by James Henry Greathead's successful shield patents in London for construction of the Tower Subway project. Greathead invented and built his own design of a shield as the contractor for that project, under Peter W Barlow whom was the engineer. Since Beach was a patents lawyer, it is likely he discovered the 1869 Greathead patent and the patent application by Barlow from 1864, using an imitated Barlow's patent design for engineering the PTS tunnel design.

 

Illustration of the Broadway underground railway (1872) by New York Parcel Dispatch Company

To build a passenger railway he needed a different franchise, something he lobbied for over four legislative sessions, 1870 to 1873. Construction of the tunnel was obvious from materials being delivered to Warren Street near Broadway, and was documented in newspaper reports, but Beach kept all details secret until the New York Tribune published a possibly planted article a few weeks before opening.^[48] The Mayor of New York, Abraham Oakey Hall, grew suspicious and sent an aide over to the construction site with a written order to inspect Beach's work, but his workers blocked the inspectors.^[49]

When it was finished, after 58 successive nights, it became New York City's first underground subway.^[50][51] Beach hosted a gala on February 26, 1870, to which he invited city and state officials, enraging "Boss Tweed" for not having profited from the venture, and for challenging his monopoly on streetcars.^[52][53] In less than a year, Beach's underground system was used by 400,000 people, and he requested his line to extend to Central Park, with an injection of 5 million dollars in capital, hoping to get financiers such as John Jacob Astor III in the venture.^[54]

Downfall

In 1870 New York state Senator William M. Tweed introduced a bill to fund the full construction of Beach's subway but the bill did not pass.^[55] By the end of 1871 Tweed's Tammany Hall political machine was in disgrace and from then on Beach, in an effort to gain support from reformers, claimed that Tweed had opposed his subway.^[56] The real opposition to the subway was from politically connected property owners along Broadway, led by Alexander Turney Stewart and John Jacob Astor III, who feared that tunnelling would damage buildings and interfere with surface traffic.^[57] Bills for Beach's subway passed the legislature in 1871 and 1872 but were vetoed by Governor John T. Hoffman because he said that they gave away too much authority without compensation to the city or state. In 1873 Governor John Adams Dix signed a similar bill into law, but Beach was not able to raise funds to build over the next six months, and then the Panic of 1873 dried up the financial markets.^[37]

During this same time, other investors had built an elevated railway at Greenwich Street and Ninth Avenue, which operated successfully with a small steam engine starting in 1870. This elevated railway gave an Idea to James Henry Greathead for the Docker's Umbrella in Liverpool which, was a similar idea for an overhead railway for the purpose of easing congestion on the ground in England. The wealthy property owners did not object to the New York City railway well away from Broadway, and by the mid-1870s it appeared that elevated railways were practical and underground railways were not, setting the pattern for rapid transit development in New York City for the remainder of the 19th century.^[37]

 

General design, station - Broadway Underground Railway, 1872

Beach operated his demonstration railway from February 1870 to April 1873. It had one station in the basement of Devlin's clothing store, a building at the southwest corner of Broadway and Warren Street. The Woolworth Building would be built next door, with an underground entrance connecting to the subway station, but it was later closed down because of fear of criminal activities.^[58]

It ran for a total of about 300 feet, first around a curve to the center of Broadway and then straight under the center of Broadway to the south side of Murray Street.^[47] He spent $70,000 of his own savings to make the station luxurious and comfortable, with chandeliers, mirrors, a towering grandfather clock, a fountain with fish, paintings and a piano.^[59] The former Devlin's building was destroyed by fire in 1898.^[60] When the subway tunnel closed down, Beach rented out the space as a wine cellar, and later as a shooting range and a storage vault.^[61][62]

The profits made by Beach from the subway were given to charities, promising to donate all the money raised to the United Home for the Orphans of Soldiers and Sailors.^[63][64] He later also developed a pneumatic tube systems for New York's mails, building the first mail tube in the country.^[65]

In 1912 workers for Degnon Contracting excavated the tunnel proper during the construction of a subway line running under Broadway, discovering the old tunnel and the old station that was buried underground. They also discovered Beach's old tunnelling shield and remains of Gotham's original subway car.^[66] The new tunnel was completely within the limits of the present day City Hall station under Broadway, near the old City Hall station.^[67] The British pneumatic tube also failed to attract much attention and eventually fell into disrepair and disrepute in spite of the fact that Royal Mail had contracted to use the tunnels. Ultimately the English experiment failed due to technical issues as well as lack of funds.^{[citation needed]}

Beach's designs for US Postal Mail Service

•  
  US Pneumatic Dispatch Company, proposed by Alfred Ely Beach, 1868
•  
  The Pneumatic Dispatch, taking letters from the lamp-post
•  
  The Alfred Ely Beach Plan of Dispatching Letters for a Branch Station
•  
  Proposed Postal Tube Lines in New York City

Death and legacy

 

"Men of Progress", published by Scientific American and Munn & Co. in 1862, showing American inventors Samuel Morse, John Ericsson, Elias Howe, Samuel Colt, Cyrus McCormick, Charles Goodyear, Peter Cooper, etc^[68]

 

The Beach Institute, founded by Alfred Ely Beach for newly freed African Americans

Much of the Beach subway story was recalled as precedent by Lawrence Edwards in his lead article of the August 1965 issue of Scientific American, which described his invention of Gravity-Vacuum Transit.^[69] Beach's story is also featured in Gotham: A History of New York City to 1898, which won a Pulitzer Prize for History.^[70]

The Beach Tunnelling shield, similar to the 1864 English patent idea of Barlow's, was used in the construction of the Grand Trunk Railway, headquartered in Montreal, Canada's first St. Clair Tunnel between Port Huron, Michigan and Sarnia, Ontario.^[71] This tunnel opened in 1890. His hydraulic shield system was also used in the excavating of the underground railway tunnels in London and Glasgow, the Hudson river tunnel and other construction works.^[72]

Beach's pneumatic system was the first air-powered train in America, a concept that would be proposed once again about 150 years later by billionaire Elon Musk, rebranded as the Hyperloop.^{[73][74][75][76][77][78]} The team Hyperloop II of the Hyperloop pod competition sponsored by SpaceX also used Beach's pneumatic concept and made the pneumatic vehicle more efficient.^[79]

In January 1887, Beach allowed his son and six other men to start a yacht club on his property in Stratford, Connecticut. The Housatonic boat club is the oldest operating Yacht club in Connecticut, and the land purchased for the club came from his estate in 1954.^[80]

After the Civil War, Beach founded a school for freed slaves in Savannah, Georgia, the Beach Institute, which is now the home of the .^[81] It was the first school in Savannah erected specifically for the education of African Americans, and was built by Freedmen’s Bureau, at the initiation of President Lincoln, and was managed by the American Missionary Association.^[82] Alumni include Mayor Otis Johnson and Senator Regina Thomas.^[83][84]

Beach was also a member of the Union League Club of New York, an abolitionist society that supported the policies of Abraham Lincoln.^[85] Pneumatic tubes are still used today by banks and the CIA for their headquarters, and less than a decade after Beach's death, New York City will finally build a full subway system in 1904, and have him featured in the history of the New York City subway.

He died of pneumonia on January 1, 1896, in New York City at the age of 69.^[81][86]

He had a son named Frederick Converse Beach, who invented a photolithographic process and ran Scientific American Magazine, and a grandson named Stanley Yale Beach, who worked for the magazine as well but also became an aviation pioneer, and an early financier of Gustave Whitehead, the contested first maker of a powered controlled flight before the Wright brothers.^[87][88][89]

Both were Yale graduates, having graduated from Yale's Sheffield Scientific School.

References

1. Swift as Aeolus" American contribution in developing pneumatic railways as compared to European achievements, Society for the History of Technology, Sławomir Łotysz, 2003.
2. William I. (1915). Patent History Materials Index - Patent Materials from Scientific American, vol 112 (June 1915), Scientific American, v 112, p 533, 5 June 1915, The Patent Office and Invention Since 1845, How the Government Has Kept Pace With the Inventor Wyman
3. "The Union League Club of New York", The Club-house, University of Michigan, 1905, page 89.
4. "Yale genealogy and history of Wales : the British kings and princes, life of Owen Glyndwr, biographies of Governor Elihu Yale, for whom Yale University was named, Linus Yale, Sr". Archived.org. pp. 237–238. Retrieved November 27, 2022.
5. America's successful men of affairs. An encyclopedia of contemporaneous biography, p. 66-67
6. N. Y. Supreme Court, Association of the Bar, Library City of New York, 1880.
7. Rollin Hillyer Cooke (1906). Historic Homes and Institutions and Genealogical and Personal Memoirs of Berkshire County, Massachusetts, John McAllister Stevenson, Lewis Publishing Co., Vol I. New York and Chicago, p. 252-256
8. 1902 - Periodicals - STREET RAILWAY JOURNAL (SEPTEMBER 13, 1902), p. 345
9. Rollin Hillyer Cooke (1906). Historic Homes and Institutions and Genealogical and Personal Memoirs of Berkshire County, Massachusetts, John McAllister Stevenson, Lewis Publishing Co., Vol I. New York and Chicago, p. 252-256
10. The Courier-News, 25 Sep 1979, Tue ·Page 16
11. America's successful men of affairs. An encyclopedia of contemporaneous biography, p. 66-67
12. Beach, Stanley, Archives at Yale, Stanley Yale Beach papers, Number: GEN MSS 802, 1911-1948
13. America's successful men of affairs. An encyclopedia of contemporaneous biography, p. 66-67
14. William I. (1915). Patent History Materials Index - Patent Materials from Scientific American, vol 112 (June 1915), Scientific American, v 112, p 533, 5 June 1915, The Patent Office and Invention Since 1845, How the Government Has Kept Pace With the Inventor Wyman
15. Alfred Ely Beach And His Wonderful Pneumatic Underground Railway, American Heritage, Volume 12, Issue 4, Robert Daley, 1961
16. From The Race Underground: Boston, New York and the Incredible Rivalry That Built America’s First Subway, Scientific American, Doug Most, 2014
17. From The Race Underground: Boston, New York and the Incredible Rivalry That Built America’s First Subway, Scientific American, Doug Most, 2014
18. Alfred Ely Beach And His Wonderful Pneumatic Underground Railway, American Heritage, Volume 12, Issue 4, Robert Daley, 1961
19. Alfred Ely Beach And His Wonderful Pneumatic Underground Railway, American Heritage, Volume 12, Issue 4, Robert Daley, 1961
20. From The Race Underground: Boston, New York and the Incredible Rivalry That Built America’s First Subway, Scientific American, Doug Most, 2014
21. William I. (1915). Patent History Materials Index - Patent Materials from Scientific American, vol 112 (June 1915), Scientific American, v 112, p 533, 5 June 1915, The Patent Office and Invention Since 1845, How the Government Has Kept Pace With the Inventor Wyman
22. Kenneth W. Dobyns (1994). History of the United States Patent Office, The Patent Office Pony, A History of the Early Patent Office, Chapter 22 -- The Most Successful Patent Law Firm Ever, p. 129-131
23. Rodney Horace Yale (1908). "Yale genealogy and history of Wales. The British kings and princes. Life of Owen Glyndwr. Biographies of Governor Elihu Yale". Milburn and Scott company. pp. 348–349.
24. William Ogden Wheeler (1907). "The Ogden Family in America and Their English Ancestry". J. B. Lippincott Company Philadelphia. p. 444.
25. Rodney Horace Yale (1908). "Yale genealogy and history of Wales. The British kings and princes. Life of Owen Glyndwr. Biographies of Governor Elihu Yale". Milburn and Scott company. p. 348-349.
26. Copperthwaite 1906, p. 20.
27. From The Race Underground: Boston, New York and the Incredible Rivalry That Built America’s First Subway, Scientific American, Doug Most, 2014
28. Britannica, Alfred Ely Beach, American publisher and inventor
29. Kenneth W. Dobyns (1994). History of the United States Patent Office, The Patent Office Pony, A History of the Early Patent Office, Chapter 22 -- The Most Successful Patent Law Firm Ever, p. 129-131
30. Kenneth W. Dobyns (1994). History of the United States Patent Office, The Patent Office Pony, A History of the Early Patent Office, Chapter 22 -- The Most Successful Patent Law Firm Ever, p. 129-131
31. Kenneth W. Dobyns (1994). History of the United States Patent Office, The Patent Office Pony, A History of the Early Patent Office, Chapter 22 -- The Most Successful Patent Law Firm Ever, p. 129-131
32. Most, Doug, The Race Underground: Boston, New York, and the incredible rivalry that built America's first subway (New York: St. Martin's Press, 2014), ISBN 9780312591328.
33. Wallace B. Katz (1979). The New York Rapid Transit Decision of 1900: Economy, Society, Politics, Historic American Engineering Record, Interborough Rapid Transit Subway, N-Y-122, p. 22-23
34. The American Almanac, Year-book, Cyclopaedia and Atlas, p. 878
35. "The First Subway in New York City Was a Cylindrical Car Pushed by Air". Scientific American. September 2020.
36. Copperthwaite, William Charles (1906). Tunnel shields and the use of compressed air in subaqueous works (1 ed.). New York: Van Nostrand Co. p. 20. hdl:2027/uc2.ark:/13960/t2r49hs0g. Retrieved May 21, 2018.
37. James Blaine Walker, "Fifty Years of Rapid Transit / 1864 to 1917". New York: The Law Printing Company, 1918.
38. "www.nycsubway.org: Beach Pneumatic Transit". www.nycsubway.org. February 4, 1912. Retrieved January 2, 2019.
    • See also: "THE BROADWAY TUNNEL.; Opening the Bore to Public Inspection—Success of the Undertaking Great Crowd of Visitors". The New York Times. February 27, 1870. Retrieved January 2, 2019.
39. Alfred E Beach, "The Pneumatic Dispatch". New York: The American News Company, 1868.
40. "Speaking III of the Dead: Jerks in New York History", Kara Hughes, November 8, 2011, page 18.
41. Reconstructing America, A Villain, a Dreamer, a Cartoonist, p. 98
42. The Secret Pneumatic Subway: Beach vs Tweed, American Studies Biographical Stories, Business Environmental History, Political History, April 17, 2018
43. "Speaking III of the Dead: Jerks in New York History", Kara Hughes, November 8, 2011, page 18.
44. The Secret Pneumatic Subway: Beach vs Tweed, American Studies Biographical Stories, Business Environmental History, Political History, April 17, 2018
45. Alfred Beach, Beach Pneumatic Transit System
46. Alfred Beach, Beach Pneumatic Transit System
47. "Scientific American", March 5, 1870.
48. "New York Tribune", January 11, 1870.
49. Scientific American’s Owner Built the First New York Subway, One of America’s First Attempts at Underground Transportation was Powered Pneumatically, Built covertly—and Illegal, 2014
50. Reconstructing America, A Villain, a Dreamer, a Cartoonist, p. 98
51. The Secret Pneumatic Subway: Beach vs Tweed, American Studies Biographical Stories, Business Environmental History, Political History, April 17, 2018
52. The Secret Pneumatic Subway: Beach vs Tweed, American Studies Biographical Stories, Business Environmental History, Political History, April 17, 2018
53. Alfred Ely Beach And His Wonderful Pneumatic Underground Railway, American Heritage, Robert Daley, June 1961, Volume 12, Issue 4
54. Scientific American’s Owner Built the First New York Subway, One of America’s First Attempts at Underground Transportation was Powered Pneumatically, Built covertly—and Illegal, 2014
55. "New York Herald" and "New York Tribune", March 11, 1870.
56. Alfred E Beach, "The Broadway Underground Railway". New York: Beach Pneumatic Transit, 1872.
57. For example see "New York Herald", March 21, 1871, and "New York Tribune", March 29, 1871, and "New York Times", March 30, 1872.
58. Buder, Leonard (June 26, 1983). "Coping with Crime in Office Buildings". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. from the original on March 3, 2020. Retrieved January 23, 2019.
59. Scientific American’s Owner Built the First New York Subway, One of America’s First Attempts at Underground Transportation was Powered Pneumatically, Built covertly—and Illegal, 2014
60. "New York Times", "New York Herald", "The World", "New York Tribune", December 5, 1898.
61. Banvard's Folly: Thirteen Tales of Renowned Obscurity, Famous Anonymity, and ..., Paul Collins.
62. Subways : The Tracks That Built New York City, Lorraine B. Diehl, p. 14-15
63. Reconstructing America, A Villain, a Dreamer, a Cartoonist, p. 99
64. Scientific American’s Owner Built the First New York Subway, One of America’s First Attempts at Underground Transportation was Powered Pneumatically, Built covertly—and Illegal, 2014
65. The Pneumatic Mail Tubes: New York's Hidden Highway And Its Development An Historical Perspective It was not a Pipe Dream! By Robert A. Cohen, 1999, p. 3
66. Wallace, Mike (2017). Greater Gotham: A History of New York City from 1898 to 1919, Oxford University Press, New York, p. 239
67. Walker (above), and "Scientific American", February 24, 1912 and September 7, 1912, and "New York Times", February 9, 1912.
68. Scientific American, Inc. (1862)Men of progress : American inventors presented to the subscribers of the Scientific American. Munn & Co. (New York, N.Y.), publisher.
69. "Scientific American", August 1965.
70. Burrows, Edwin G. (1999) Gotham: A History of New York City to 1898, Oxford University Press, p. 932
71. William D. Middleton, Metropolitan Railways: Rapid Transit in America. Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press, 2003; pg. 17.
72. America's successful men of affairs. An encyclopedia of contemporaneous biography, p. 66-67
73. New York Had a Hyperloop First, Elon Musk, Bloomberg, Stephen Mihm, August 14, 2013.
74. Marc Santora (2013). When the New York City Subway Ran Without Rails, The New York Times, Aug. 14, 2013
75. Sarah Jensen (2019). MIT News, Overcoming obstacles with an electric hovercraft, MIT team places first among U.S. universities at 2019 SpaceX Hyperloop Pod Competition, School of Engineering
76. From Beach to Musk – A lot of hype over Hyperloop, Railengineer.co.uk, Lesley Brown
77. Hyperloop wants to change the world. Not everyone’s convinced, Matt McFarland, CNN Business, November 20, 2020
78. Megan Garber (2013). Pneumatic Tubes: A Brief History Elon Musk is not the first inventor to dream of humans being speedily sucked through vacuums, The Atlantic Magazine, AUGUST 13, 2013.
79. Sarah Jensen (2019). MIT News, Overcoming obstacles with an electric hovercraft, MIT team places first among U.S. universities at 2019 SpaceX Hyperloop Pod Competition, School of Engineering
80. "History". Housatonic Boat Club. Retrieved December 30, 2021.
81. "Scientific American", January 11, 1896.
82. King-Tisdell Cottage Foundation, Arts & Culture, Education, Community, www.beachinstitute.org
83. . Archived from the original on May 25, 2008. Retrieved September 5, 2008.
84. Beach Institute, The Historical Marker Database
85. "The Union League Club of New York", The Club-house, University of Michigan, 1905, page 89.
86. "Funeral of Alfred Ely Beach. His Wife Arrives from Europe Just Before the Services". The New York Times. January 7, 1896. Retrieved July 15, 2008. The funeral of Alfred Ely Beach, the Inventor, who died on New Year's morning of pneumonia, after a brief Illness, was held yesterday morning at 9 West ...
87. Jackson, Paul (2013). Jackson, Paul (ed.). "Executive Overview: Justice delayed is justice denied". Jane's All the World's Aircraft 2013. Washington, DC: Macdonald and Jane's: 8–10.
88. Archive of Stanley Yale Beach, aviation pioneer
89. Stanley Yale Beach papers

External links

 

Wikimedia Commons has media related to Alfred Ely Beach.

• by Joseph Brennan
• Alfred Ely Beach – Beach's Bizarre Broadway Subway Klaatu's detailed background article, explaining the technical and political details of the project.
• – American Heritage
• "Pneumatic Transit" Animation by Abby Digital April 2, 2012, at the Wayback Machine