Advisory Neighborhood Commission district 7F08

Single-member district 7F08 of Advisory Neighborhood Commission 7F in Washington, D.C., has existed since 2023, its electorate consisting entirely of inmates of the D.C. Jail. From 2013 to 2022, the jail's residents made up a majority of district 7F07, from which 7F08 was then carved out. As of December 2023^[update], 7F08's commissioner is Shameka Hayes.

Advisory Neighborhood Commission district 7F08
Constituency for the Advisory Neighborhood Commissions
Map of Advisory Neighborhood Commission district 7F08
Region	Washington, D.C.
Population	‹See Tfd› ≈ 1,700
Current constituency
Created	2022
Number of members	1
Member(s)	Shameka Hayes

While district 7F07 first appeared in the 2012 general election, no election was contested until 2020, partly because convicted felons—the longest-term residents of the jail, where stays typically last less than a year—could not vote and were thus barred from running for the Commission. After D.C. enfranchised all felons in 2020, several inmates ran write-in campaigns in 2020, but all failed on procedural grounds. Joel Castón, who would have won in 2020 but for a paperwork error, won a special election the next year to fill the vacancy caused by his own disqualification—the first election in American history in which both the victor and all members of the electorate were incarcerated.^[1] After receiving parole from his life sentence and moving to the one residential complex within 7F07, Castón successfully lobbied to carve out a district for just the jail, 7F08. In 2022, Leonard Bishop was elected to be the new district's first commissioner. Bishop was transferred to another facility in July 2023 and replaced by Hayes in a special election. Hayes, who is incarcerated pending trial, is one of only roughly 100 female residents of the 1,700-person district.

2013–2022: District 7F07

The Advisory Neighborhood Commissions (ANCs) of Washington, D.C., advise the district government on a variety of matters. Commissioners serve two-year terms. They draw no salary but receive funding for expenses and staffing.^{[P 1]} ANC 7F is part of Ward 7. During redistricting in 2011 after the 2010 census, the D.C. Council created district 7F07, encompassing the D.C. Jail; the D.C. General homeless shelter (since demolished); the Harriet Tubman Women's Shelter; and St. Coletta of Greater Washington, a school for students with intellectual disabilities.^[2][3] According to the District of Columbia Board of Elections (BOE) and Department of Corrections (DOC), inmates are eligible to serve as commissioners provided they meet residency requirements. The average stay in the jail as of 2020^[update] is 285 days, less than the two-year term.^[3]

2020 and 2021 elections

No candidates contested the seat from its inaugural election in 2012 through 2018. In 2020, D.C. restored felons' right to vote; since commissioners must be eligible to vote, this increased the pool of potential candidates, including those serving the longest sentences. The same year, the advocacy group Neighbors for Justice began to pressure the DOC to make inmates aware of the election and their eligibility to run in it. The DOC refused to distribute material not originating from the BOE, while the BOE refused as it was not in "the business of encouraging particular people or particular groups to run for office".^[3] The election proceeded in November 2020 without any listed candidates.^[4] Of 23 write-in votes cast, 21 went to candidates who had not signed the required affirmation of write-in candidacy, leaving only Joel Castón,^[4] who had run at the suggestion of his former professor, Marc Morjé Howard of Georgetown University's Prison Scholars Program.^{[1]: 5:08 [5]} However, Castón was registered to vote in Ward 8 and was thus ruled ineligible. Castón, who had not lived in Ward 8 since he received a life sentence for murder 26 years prior, attributed the issue to incorrect guidance given by prison staff when he registered. Nearby ANC 6B denounced the board's decision.^[4]

Elections to fill empty seats were subsequently canceled due to COVID-19. The D.C. Council ordered the BOE to resume elections in March 2021, partly because of the 7F07 vacancy.^{[2][P 2]} Twenty-five signatures are required for running in a special election, and amidst a 23-hour-a-day COVID lockdown, guards circulated petitions on inmates' behalves. Castón qualified for the ballot, as did four other inmates.^[2] The DOC produced a video, later published on YouTube by Neighbors for Justice, of the candidates giving statements.^{[P 3]} The election on June 15 saw 142 votes cast, 141 of them by inmates.^[6] Castón won with 33% of the vote,^[6] making him the first incarcerated person to win an election in D.C.^[7] and marking the first election in U.S. history where both the electorate and winning candidate were incarcerated.^[1]

Castón's tenure

Castón was sworn in by Judge Milton C. Lee, wearing a suit provided by the DOC. The DOC gave Castón an office for his work as commissioner, including a computer and a landline phone.^[7] He used Zoom to conduct official business with people outside the jail,^[1] including participating in "hybrid" ANC meetings that had been established in April 2020 because of the pandemic.^[8] The program was extended in July 2021, during Castón's tenure.^[9] Neighborhood activists connected him to residents of the women's shelter and Park Kennedy, an apartment building then under development across the street.^[7] Castón was nearly transferred to a prison outside of D.C. on November 9, 2021, on the eve of planned testimony to the D.C. Council about prison conditions, but the transfer was canceled amid outcry.^[10] He was released on parole on November 22,^[11] having had his sentence reduced under D.C.'s Incarceration Reduction Amendment Act.^[7] Castón, who moved in to Park Kennedy, remained the commissioner after his release.^[11][12][13] He would later become a member of the D.C. Sentencing Commission.^[14]

2023–present: District 7F08

 

District 7F08 was carved out to exclusively represent the inmates of the D.C. Jail.

During the 2021 redistricting of the ANCs based on the 2020 census, advocates lobbied to make the D.C. Jail its own ANC district. After initial plans were drawn for such a carve-out, Council Chairman Phil Mendelson proposed to keep the jail and Park Kennedy in the same district, citing the jail's small population (1,300) compared to the average district population of 2,000. Councilmember Elissa Silverman, a member of the redistricting subcommittee, criticized Mendelson in strong terms. Castón, who had been a co-chair of the Ward 7 redistricting task force, said in a letter to the D.C. Council that "having an incarcerated resident represent the residents of the jail as ANC Commissioner is important not only because of the hope and public safety benefits it brings, but also because the residents of the jail are a vulnerable population with their own unique challenges and they cannot be adequately represented by somebody on the outside". In response, Mendelson reverted to the original plan for a standalone district for the jail, 7F08.^[12]

2022 election and Bishop's tenure

In the November 2022 D.C. general election, 68 write-in votes were cast for seat 7F08,^{[P 4]} of which 46 were for people who had affirmed their write-in candidacy.^{[P 5]} Leonard Bishop won 12 votes, a plurality.^{[P 5]} He was sworn in on January 12, 2023, by Councilmember Brooke Pinto. Like Castón, Bishop was serving a life sentence and was at the D.C. Jail pending consideration of an IRRA motion.^[15]

Bishop, a student at Georgetown and Ashland University and a youth mentor,^[15][16] attended ANC meetings via Zoom and received guidance from other commissioners on procedural matters. He told the Washington City Paper that he met with Castón, who advised him, "Listen to the people, man". Bishop's chief concerns with the jail included slow mail delivery, low-quality and unhealthy food, and limits on commissary purchasing that do not adapt to inflation-borne price hikes. He also sought to increase access to vocational education for inmates.^[15] Bishop worked with alleged participants in the 2021 assault on the U.S. Capitol, whose presence in the jail had brought Congressional scrutiny into living conditions there.^[15][17] He told the City Paper, "Those other things they been complaining about, but we've been complaining about [them] for years. And it went ignored. The food, the conditions. I guess they just helped shed light on an ongoing situation."^[15]

Bishop, who had advocated for inmates' right to testify before the D.C. Council, was scheduled for transfer to United States Penitentiary, McCreary, a high-security prison in Kentucky where he had previously been incarcerated, shortly after he testified in favor of a proposed law to improve food at the jail.^[16][18] Bishop still had an actual innocence petition pending under the Innocence Protection Act.^[16][19] Stating his desire to serve out his two-year term on ANC 7F, he reached out to other elected officials.^[16] Sixty other commissioners sought to prevent Bishop's transfer, alongside Pinto and Eleanor Holmes Norton, D.C.'s delegate to Congress. However, he was moved on July 20, rendering him ineligible to remain a commissioner.^[18][19][20] As of December 2023^[update], he was imprisoned at USP McCreary.^{[P 6]}

2023 election and Hayes's tenure

A special election was held in December 2023 to replace Bishop, with about 100 ballots cast in the jail's branch of the D.C. Public Library. The League of Women Voters registered over 100 inmates to vote. Media were allowed to observe the election, although under strict restrictions as to access. Shameka Hayes won a special election to replace Bishop, becoming the first woman to represent the D.C. Jail.^[21] (The main facility at the D.C. Jail, the Central Detention Facility, houses only men.^[15] As a result, only around 100 of the 1,700 residents in 7F08 are women.^[21]) Hayes defeated 10 other candidates with a 25-vote plurality.^[21] Hayes, who like Howard and Bishop has attended classes at Georgetown University while in jail,^[22] was awaiting trial on drug charges; it was unclear if she would be at the D.C. Jail long enough to serve out the remainder of Bishop's term.^[21]

Hayes retained the accommodations that had been granted to Castón and Bishop. Entering her term, she cited hygiene concerns in her unit, which she said had two working showers and was failing to provide clean jumpsuits to women who were menstruating.^[22] She also criticized food and medical issues in the jail (saying she had gone from a large to a triple-extra-large clothing size while incarcerated) and gender disparities in access to education in what she called a "male-run facility".^[22][23] Hayes was sworn in in January with Councilmember Vincent C. Gray in attendance.^[23]

Election results

As of January 2024^[update], the Board of Elections' website does not include results for special elections.^{[P 7]} The results of the 2021 special election can be reconstructed from news reports, although with some details missing. News coverage of the 2023 special election does not include detailed figures, and thus no table is included below.

2020 Washington, D.C. Advisory Neighborhood Commission district 7F07 election^[4]

Party		Candidate	Votes	%
	Nonpartisan	Joel Castón (write-in)	2	8.70
	Disqualified write-ins		21	91.30
Total votes			23	100.0

2021 Washington, D.C. Advisory Neighborhood Commission district 7F07 special election^[24]

Party		Candidate	Votes	%
	Nonpartisan	Joel Castón^[a]	48	33.80
	Nonpartisan	Kim Thompson^[a]	31	21.83
	Nonpartisan	Gary Proctor^[a]	23	16.20
	Nonpartisan	K. Littlepage-El^[a]	21	14.79
	Nonpartisan	Aaron Success Brown^[a]	19	13.38
Total votes			142^[b]	100.0

2022 Washington, D.C. Advisory Neighborhood Commission district 7F08 election^{[P 4][P 5]}

Party		Candidate	Votes	%
	Nonpartisan	Leonard Eugene Bishop (write-in)	12	17.65
	Nonpartisan	Seth Andrews (write-in)	9	13.24
	Nonpartisan	Arik Adani Sims (write-in)	5	7.35
	Nonpartisan	Aaron Brown (write-in)	3	4.41
	Nonpartisan	E'Monnie Barnes (write-in)	3	4.41
	Nonpartisan	Brittany Jones (write-in)	2	2.94
	Nonpartisan	Xavier Lee (write-in)	2	2.94
	Nonpartisan	Curtis Donnell Roach (write-in)	2	2.94
	Nonpartisan	Rasheed Carroll (write-in)	2	2.94
	Nonpartisan	Kim Thompson (write-in)	1	1.47
	Nonpartisan	Philip McDaniel (write-in)	1	1.47
	Nonpartisan	Lache Cuffey (write-in)	1	1.47
	Nonpartisan	Lashawn Alexander (write-in)	1	1.47
	Nonpartisan	Robert Santana (write-in)	1	1.47
	Nonpartisan	Harold Cunningham (write-in)	1	1.47
	Disqualified write-ins		22	32.35
Total votes			68	100.0

Notes

1. Source does not say whether candidates ran as write-ins or were on the ballot.
2. Source does not say whether any disqualified write-in votes were cast.

References

1. Dwyer, Devin; Cruz, Abby; Herndon, Sarah (August 1, 2021). "Elected from jail, DC official advances voting rights and racial justice". ABC News (Video and article). Retrieved December 20, 2023.
2. Austermuhle, Martin (June 8, 2021) [June 3, 2021]. "In This Local Election, Every Candidate Is Incarcerated At The D.C. Jail". DCist. WAMU. from the original on June 3, 2021. Retrieved December 16, 2023.
3. Le Dem, Gaspard (October 30, 2020). "Advocates Want a D.C. Jail Resident to Run for an ANC Seat That's Never Been Filled". Washington City Paper. Retrieved December 16, 2023.
4. Le Dem, Gaspard (December 18, 2020). "Advocates Denounce Election Results in ANC 7F07 After D.C. Jail Candidate Is Disqualified for Technical Error". Washington City Paper. Retrieved December 16, 2023.
5. Doerfler, Grace (July 16, 2021). "How Jesuit-educated Joel Castón became the first person to win an election from jail". America. Retrieved December 20, 2023.
6. Austermuhle, Martin (June 17, 2021). "'My Voice Still Matters.': Resident At D.C. Jail Wins Local Election". WAMU. Retrieved December 17, 2023.
7. Lai, Stephanie (July 25, 2021). "D.C. reforms gave inmates a vote. Now an elected official is working from jail". The Washington Post. Retrieved December 17, 2023.
8. Holder, Sarah (December 9, 2021). "The Zoom City Council Meeting Is Here to Stay, Insults and All". Bloomberg Businessweek. from the original on December 14, 2021. Retrieved January 18, 2024.
9. Chaffin, Gordon (July 21, 2021). "DC neighborhood commissions can continue meeting virtually". Street Sense. Retrieved January 18, 2024.
10. Gathright, Jenny (November 9, 2021). "Incarcerated ANC Commissioner Will Not Be Transferred Out Of D.C. Jail". DCist. WAMU. from the original on November 9, 2021. Retrieved December 17, 2023.
11. Gathright, Jenny (November 23, 2021). "Ward 7 ANC Commissioner Joel Castón Is Free After 26 Years Of Incarceration". DCist. WAMU. from the original on November 24, 2021. Retrieved December 17, 2023.
12. Gathright, Jenny; Austermuhle, Martin (June 6, 2022). "Last-Minute Changes To New ANC Boundaries Draw Pushback And Concern Over Fate Of D.C. Jail Seat". DCist. WAMU. from the original on June 6, 2022. Retrieved December 17, 2023.
13. Hall, Lorenzo (February 16, 2022). "DC elected leader adjusts to freedom and new role after release from jail". WUSA. Retrieved January 18, 2024.
14. Davies, Emily; Brice-Saddler, Michael (February 7, 2024). "Man convicted of murder appointed to D.C. sentencing commission". The Washington Post. Retrieved March 17, 2024.
15. Ryals, Mitch (May 9, 2023). "Leonard Bishop Wants to Give Incarcerated People Access to D.C. Council Hearings and ANC Meetings". Washington City Paper. Retrieved December 19, 2023.
16. Ryals, Mitch (July 17, 2023). "D.C. Jail ANC Scheduled for Transfer to Federal Penitentiary". Washington City Paper. Retrieved December 19, 2023.
17. Broadwater, Luke (March 25, 2023). "Lawmakers Tour D.C. Jail Where Jan. 6 Defendants Are Held". The New York Times. Retrieved December 19, 2023.
18. Opperman, Lia (July 21, 2023). "Inside Voices: Jail ANC Transferred Out of D.C. After Council Testimony". Washington City Paper.
19. Silverman, Ellie (July 24, 2023). "A D.C. elected official serving from jail was moved out of town". The Washington Post. Retrieved December 19, 2023.
20. "Incarcerated Advisory Neighborhood Commissioner transferred out of Washington, D.C." The Washington Afro-American. July 29, 2023. Retrieved December 19, 2023.
21. Moyer, Justin Wm (December 15, 2023). "A special election inside a D.C. jail results in a first: a female winner". The Washington Post. Retrieved December 19, 2023.
22. Collins, Sam P. K. (December 15, 2023). "In Special Election, Shameka Hayes Elected as D.C. Jail Advisory Neighborhood Commissioner". The Washington Informer. Retrieved December 19, 2023.
23. Goncalves, Delia (January 11, 2024). "First woman to represent DC jail as ANC sworn-in". WUSA (Video and article). Retrieved February 10, 2024.
24. Korff, Jay (June 15, 2021). . WJLA. Archived from the original on January 10, 2024. Retrieved January 10, 2024.

Primary sources

1. D.C. Code § 1–207.38
2. "Council Extends COVID Emergency Authorization, Slows Budget Process to Allow Inclusion of Federal COVID Aid" (Press release). Council of the District of Columbia. March 3, 2021. Retrieved December 17, 2023.
3. District of Columbia Department of Corrections (June 21, 2021). Candidates running for ANC7F07 Commissioner, June 2021 ANC election, Washington DC (Video). Neighbors for Justice. Retrieved December 16, 2023 – via YouTube.
4. . District of Columbia Board of Elections. Row 6020. Archived from the original on January 29, 2023.
5. (PDF). District of Columbia Board of Elections. p. 2. Archived from the original (PDF) on January 13, 2023.
6. Afrika-Ber, Askia (December 2, 2023). "Lessons from an Incarcerated Officeholder". More Than Our Crimes (Interview). Retrieved December 19, 2023.
7. "DCBOE Election Results". District of Columbia Board of Elections. Retrieved January 18, 2024.

External links

• District 7F07 [2012-2020 Cycle] on OpenANC
• District 7F08 [2022-2030 Cycle] on OpenANC