Thermidorian Reaction

In the historiography of the French Revolution, the Thermidorian Reaction (French: Réaction thermidorienne or Convention thermidorienne, "Thermidorian Convention") is the common term for the period between the ousting of Maximilien Robespierre on 9 Thermidor II, or 27 July 1794, and the inauguration of the French Directory on 2 November 1795.

Closing of the Jacobin Club by Louis Legendre, in the early morning of 28 July 1794. Four days later it was reopened by him.^[1]

The "Thermidorian Reaction" was named after the month in which the coup took place and was the latter part of the National Convention's rule of France. It was marked by the end of the Reign of Terror, decentralization of executive powers from the Committee of Public Safety and a turn from the radical Jacobin policies of the Montagnard Convention to more moderate positions. Economic and general populism, dechristianization, and harsh wartime measures were largely abandoned, as the members of the convention, disillusioned and frightened of the centralized government of the Terror, preferred a more stable political order that would have the approval of the plurality. The Reaction saw the Left suppressed by brutal force, including massacres, as well as the disbanding of the Jacobin Club, the dispersal of the sans-culottes, and the renunciation of the Montagnard ideology.

Etymology and definitions

The name Thermidorian originated with 9 Thermidor Year II (27 July 1794), the date according to the French Republican Calendar when Maximilien Robespierre and other radical revolutionaries came under concerted attack in the National Convention.^[2] Thermidorian Reaction refers to the remaining period until the National Convention was superseded by the Directory; this is also sometimes called the era of the Thermidorian Convention.^[3] Prominent figures of Thermidor include Paul Barras, Jean-Lambert Tallien, and Joseph Fouché.

Background

Main article: Fall of Maximilien Robespierre

 

Gendarme Charles-André Merda shooting at Maximilien Robespierre

Conspiracies against Robespierre, who had dominated the Committee of Public Safety, came together on 9 Thermidor (27 July) 1794. Jean-Lambert Tallien, a member of and previously President of the National Convention, impugned Saint-Just and then went on to denounce the tyranny of Robespierre. The attack was taken up by Jacques Nicolas Billaud-Varenne. Cries went up of "Down with the tyrant! Arrest him!"^[4] Robespierre then made his appeal to the deputies of the Right, yet failed. An order was made to arrest Robespierre and his followers.^{[citation needed]}

Troops from the Paris Commune, who were loyal to Robespierre, arrived to liberate him and the other prisoners. The Convention responded by ordering troops of its own under Paul Barras to counteract. The Robespierrists barricaded at the Hôtel de Ville.^[5] The Convention declared them to be outlaws, meaning that they could be executed within 24 hours without a trial. The Commune forces at the Hôtel de Ville deserted. The Convention troops under Barras approached the Hôtel around 2 a.m. on 28 July.^[5] Robespierre, his jaw broken by a possibly self-inflicted shot, was taken with most of his supporters.

 

The execution of Robespierre on 28 July 1794 marked the end of the Reign of Terror

On that very day, Robespierre was executed with twenty-one of his closest associates, including^[6] François Hanriot, ex-commander of the Parisian National Guard; Jean-Baptiste Fleuriot-Lescot, mayor of Paris; Georges Couthon, Louis Antoine de Saint-Just and René-François Dumas, ex-president of the Revolutionary Tribunal.

The Reaction

The events of 9 Thermidor proved a watershed in the revolutionary process. The Thermidorian regime that followed proved to be an unpopular one, facing many rebellions after its execution of Robespierre and his allies, along with seventy members of the Paris Commune, the largest mass execution to have ever taken place in Paris.^[7] This led to a very fragile situation in France.^[8]

The hostility toward Robespierre did not just vanish with his execution. Instead, the people decided to blame those who were involved with Robespierre in any way, namely the many members of the Jacobin Club, their supporters, and individuals suspected of being past revolutionaries. The massacre of these groups became known as the White Terror, and was partially carried out by the Muscadin, a group of dandyish street fighters organized by the new government.^[8]

Often, members of these targeted groups were the victims of prison massacres or put on trial without due process, which were overall similar conditions to those provided to the counter-revolutionaries during the Reign of Terror. At the same time, its economic policies paved the way for rampant inflation. Ultimately, power devolved to the hands of the Directory, an executive of five men who assumed power in France in November 1795 (in year III of the French Revolutionary calendar).^{[9][page needed]}

The Thermidorian regime excluded the remaining Montagnards from power, even those who had joined in conspiring against Robespierre and Saint-Just. The White Terror of 1795 resulted in numerous imprisonments and several hundred executions, almost exclusively of people on the political left. These numbers, while significant, were considerably smaller than those associated with the previous Reign of Terror, which killed over 40,000. Many executions took place without a trial.^{[10][page needed]}

On July 29 the victors of the 9th Thermidor condemned seventy members of the Paris Commune to death; thereafter the Commune was subject to the convention.^[7]

As part of the reorganization of French politics, practitioners of the terror were called to defend their records; some such as Tallien, Barras, Fouché and Fréron rejoined the leadership. Others such as Billaud-Varenne, Collot d’Herbois, Barère and Vadier were sentenced to exile in South America, though the latter two managed to evade arrest. Many Jacobin clubs were closed. Freedom of worship was extended first to the Vendée and later to all France. On 24 December 1794 the Maximum (controls on prices and wages) was abolished. The government exacerbated this inflationary move by issuing more assignats.^{[citation needed]}

In April and May 1795, protests and riots in support of the radicals broke out culminating in an invasion of the convention by an insurrectionist mob on 20 May. On 22 May the Convention struck back, having troops under Pichegru surround the Faubourg St-Antoine and force the capitulation of the armed rebels. In May and June 1795, a "White Terror" raged in which Jacobins were victims and the judges were bourgeois "Moderates".^[11] Throughout France the events of the September Massacres were repeated; however this time the victims were imprisoned officials of the Terror. In Paris, Royalist sentiments were openly tolerated.

Meanwhile, French armies overran the Netherlands and established the Batavian Republic, occupied the left bank of the Rhine and forced Spain, Prussia and several German States to sue for peace, enhancing the prestige of the convention. A new constitution called the Constitution of the Year III was drawn up on 22 August 1795, which eased back some of the democratic elements of the constitution of 1793, establishing an electoral college for the election of officials, a bicameral legislature and other provisions designed to protect the current holders of power. On 5 October (13 Vendémiaire), a revolt led by Royalists challenged the convention. It was put down by troops led by general Napoleon Bonaparte with "a whiff of grapeshot". On 25 October the Convention declared itself dissolved and was replaced by the Directory on 2 November 1795.^{[citation needed]}

Other uses of the term

For historians of revolutionary movements, the term Thermidor has come to mean the phase in some revolutions when power slips from the hands of the original revolutionary leadership and a radical regime is replaced by a more conservative regime, sometimes to the point where the political pendulum may swing back towards something resembling a pre-revolutionary state.^[12]

About the Russian Revolution

In his book The Revolution Betrayed, Leon Trotsky alleges that the rise of Joseph Stalin to power was a Soviet Thermidor for not restoring capitalism, yet still being a counterrevolutionary regression within the regime of the USSR, just like the Thermidor in France did not restore the monarchy but did, in his opinion, reverse revolutionary gains.^[13]

Some Marxist-Leninists argue that Nikita Khruschev's rise to power in Russia, and his economic policies were a kind of Thermidor within the Soviet Union.^[14] A CIA document considers Khruschev's denunciation of Stalin may have marked the "Thermidor" of the Russian Revolution.^[15]

References

1. After Robespierre THE THERMIDORIAN REACTION By ALBERT MATHIEZ, p. 23 Translated from the French by Catherine Alison Phillips
2. Abbott, John Stevens Cabot (1887). The French Revolution of 1789 As Viewed in the Light of Republican Institutions. Vol. II. New York: Harper & Brothers. p. 379.
3. For the definition of the Thermidorian Reaction as the 15-month period following Robespierre's demise, see: Mason, Laura (2012). "The Thermidorian Reaction". In McPhee, Peter (ed.). A Companion to the French Revolution. Oxford: Wiley-Blackwell. p. 311. doi:10.1002/9781118316399.ch19. ISBN 9781118316399.; Andress, David, ed. (2015). The Oxford Handbook of the French Revolution. Oxford University Press. pp. 522–523.; Mona Ozouf, François Furet (ed.), A Critical Dictionary of the French Revolution. Harvard University Press (1989). p. 400.
4. de Maillane, Durand; Lanjuinais, Jean-Denis (1825). Histoire de la Convention Nationale (in French). Paris: Baudouin Freres. p. 200.
5. Merriman, John (2004). "Thermidor". A history of modern Europe: from the Renaissance to the present (2nd ed.). W.W. Norton & Company. p. 507. ISBN 0-393-92495-5.
6. Beauchesne, Alcide; Dupanloup, Félix (1868). Louis XVII, sa vie, son agonie, sa mort: captivité de la famille royale au Temple. H. Plon. pp. 218–9.
7. Durant & Durant 1975, p. 83.
8. Clay, Stephen (29 October 2012). "The White Terror: Factions, Reactions, and the Politics of Vengeance". In McPhee, Peter (ed.). A Companion to the French Revolution. Oxford: Wiley-Blackwell. pp. 359–377. doi:10.1002/9781118316399.ch22. ISBN 9781118316399.
9. Sutherland 2003, ch. 8.
10. Brown 2010.
11. Durant & Durant 1975, p. 84.
12. "Definition of THERMIDOR". www.merriam-webster.com. Retrieved 1 May 2021.
13. Trotsky, Leon (2004) [1937]. "The Soviet Thermidor: Why Stalin Triumphed". The Revolution Betrayed. Translated by Eastman, Max (Dover ed.). Doubleday, Doran & Co. pp. 66–87. A secondary figure before the masses and in the events of the revolution, Stalin revealed himself as the indubitable leader of the Thermidorian bureaucracy, as first in its midst.
14. Buttafava, Ubaldo (1997). Khrushchev's Thermidor - A contribution to the critical analysis concerning the USSR's return to capitalism (PDF).
15. Anonymous CIA agent. "Latest developments of the "anti-Stalin" trend in international Communism, interpretation and possible exploitation" (PDF). CIA.

Works cited

• Brown, Howard G. (2010). "Robespierre's Tail: The Possibilities of Justice after the Terror". Canadian Journal of History. 45 (3): 503–536. doi:10.3138/cjh.45.3.503.
• Durant, Will; Durant, Ariel (1975). The Age of Napoleon. New York: Simon & Schuster.
• Sutherland, D.M.G. (2003). The French Revolution and Empire: The Quest for a Civic Order.

Further reading

• Baczko, Bronislaw (1989), Comment sortir de la Terreur (in French), Gallimard
• Barthou, Louis (1926), Le neuf Thermidor (in French), Hachette
• Brunel, Françoise (1989), Thermidor, la chute de Robespierre (in French), Ed. Complexe
• Héricault, C. d' (1876) (in French), La Révolution de Thermidor, Didier
• Lefebvre, Georges (1937). Les Thermidoriens (in French). Armand Collin.
• Madelin, Louis (2002), Fouché, de la Révolution à l'Empire (in French), vol. 1 (Reedition ed.), Nouveau Monde Editions

• Linton, Marisa (August 2006). . History Today. 56 (8): 23–29. Archived from the original on 2007-03-13.
• Mathiez, Albert (1965) [1931]. After Robespierre: The Thermidorian Reaction (PDF). Translated by Phillips, Catherine Alison. Grosset & Dunlap. LCCN 65-14385. Translation of Mathiez, Albert (1929). La Reaction Thermidorienne (in French).
• Madelin, Louis (2002), Fouché, de la Révolution à l'Empire (in French), vol. 1 (Reedition ed.), Nouveau Monde Editions
• Koekkoek, René (2020). The Citizenship Experiment Contesting the Limits of Civic Equality and Participation in the Age of Revolutions (PDF). Studies in the History of Political Thought. Vol. 15. Leiden: Brill. ISBN 978-90-04-22570-1. ISSN 1873-6548. LCCN 2019038014.
• Neely, Sylvia (2008), A Concise History of the French Revolution
• Palmer, Robert Roswell (1941). Twelve Who Ruled: The Year of Terror in the French Revolution. Princeton University Press. ISBN 978-0-691-05119-2. A study of the Committee of Public Safety.
• Saurel, Louis (1962), Le Jour où finit la Terreur(in French) , Robert Laffont
• Schama, Simon (1989). Citizens: A Chronicle of the French Revolution. New York: Alfred A. Knopf. ISBN 978-0-394-55948-3. A revisionist account.