Virtual currency

For fictional currencies used within games, such as Monopoly money, see Virtual economy.

Not to be confused with Cryptocurrency.

Virtual currency, or virtual money, is a digital currency that is largely unregulated, issued and usually controlled by its developers, and used and accepted electronically among the members of a specific virtual community.^[1] In 2014, the European Banking Authority defined virtual currency as "a digital representation of value that is neither issued by a central bank or a public authority, nor necessarily attached to a fiat currency but is accepted by natural or legal persons as a means of payment and can be transferred, stored or traded electronically."^[2] A digital currency issued by a central bank is referred to as a central bank digital currency.

Definitions

In 2012, the European Central Bank (ECB) defined virtual currency as "a type of unregulated, digital money, which is issued and usually controlled by its developers, and used and accepted among the members of a specific virtual community".^[1]: 13

In 2013, the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN), a bureau of the US Treasury, in contrast to its regulations defining currency as "the coin and paper money of the United States or of any other country that [i] is designated as legal tender and that [ii] circulates and [iii] is customarily used and accepted as a medium of exchange in the country of issuance", also called "real currency" by FinCEN, defined virtual currency as "a medium of exchange that operates like a currency in some environments, but does not have all the attributes of real currency". In particular, virtual currency does not have legal tender status in any jurisdiction.^[3]

In 2014, the European Banking Authority defined virtual currency as "a digital representation of value that is neither issued by a central bank or a public authority, nor necessarily attached to a fiat currency, but is accepted by natural or legal persons as a means of payment and can be transferred, stored or traded electronically".^[2]

In 2018, Directive (EU) 2018/843 of the European Parliament and of the Council entered into force. The Directive defines the term "virtual currencies" to mean "a digital representation of value that is not issued or guaranteed by a central bank or a public authority, is not necessarily attached to a legally established currency and does not possess a legal status of currency or money, but is accepted by natural or legal persons as a means of exchange and which can be transferred, stored and traded electronically".^[4]

History of the term

In a 2013 congressional hearing on virtual currencies, Ben Bernanke said they "have been viewed as a form of 'electronic money' or area of payment system technology that has been evolving over the past 20 years", referencing a 1995 congressional hearing on the Future of Money before the Committee on Banking and Financial Services.^[5] The Internet currency Flooz was created in 1999.^[6] The term "virtual currency" appears to have been coined around 2009, paralleling the development of digital currencies and social gaming.^[7]

Although the correct classification is "digital currency", the US government prefers and has uniformly adopted the term "virtual currency". The FinCEN was first, followed by the FBI in 2012,^[8] the General Accounting Office in 2013,^[9] as well as the government agencies testifying at the November 2013 US Senate hearing on bitcoin, including the Department of Homeland Security, the US Securities and Exchange Commission, the Office of the Attorney General.^[10]

Limits on being currency

Attributes of a real currency, as defined in 2011 in the Code of Federal Regulations, such as real paper money and real coins are simply that they act as legal tender and circulate "customarily".^[11]

The IRS decided in March 2014, to treat bitcoin and other virtual currencies as property for tax purposes, not as currency.^[12][13] Some have suggested that this makes bitcoins not fungible—that is one bitcoin is not identical to another bitcoin, unlike one gallon of crude oil being identical to another gallon of crude oil—making bitcoin unworkable as a currency.^[14] Others have stated that a measure like accounting on average cost basis would restore fungibility to the currency.^[14]

Categorization by currency flow

Closed virtual currencies

Main article: Virtual economy

Virtual currencies have been called "closed" or "fictional currency" when they have no official connection to the real economy, for example, currencies in massively multiplayer online role-playing games such as World of Warcraft. While there may be a grey market for exchanging such currencies or other virtual assets for real-world assets, this is usually forbidden by the games' terms of service.

Virtual currencies with currency flow into one direction

This type of currency, units of which may also be circulated as (printed) coupons, stamps or reward points, has been known for a long time in the form of customer incentive programs or loyalty programs. A coupon loses its face value when redeemed for an eligible asset or service (hence: flow in one direction), may be valid for only a limited time and subject to other restrictions set by the issuer. The business issuing the coupon functions as a central authority.^{[15][dubious ]} Coupons remained unchanged for 100 years until new technology enabling credit cards became more common in the 1980s, and credit card rewards were invented. The latest incarnation drives the increase of internet commerce, online services, development of online communities and games. Here virtual or game currency can be bought, but not exchanged back into real money. The virtual currency is akin to a coupon. Examples are frequent flyer programs by various airlines, Microsoft Points, Nintendo Points, Facebook Credits and Amazon Coin.

Convertible virtual currencies

A virtual currency that can be bought with and sold back is called a convertible currency. A virtual currency can be decentralized, as for example bitcoin, a cryptocurrency. Transacting or even holding convertible virtual currency may be illegal in particular jurisdictions and to particular national citizens at particular times and the transactor/recipient/facilitator liable for prosecution by the State.^[16]

Centralized versus decentralized

FinCEN defined centralized virtual currencies in 2013 as virtual currencies that have a "centralized repository", similar to a central bank, and a "central administrator".

A decentralized currency was defined by the US Department of Treasury as a "currency (1) that has no central repository and no single administrator, and (2) that persons may obtain by their own computing or manufacturing effort".^[3] Rather than relying on confidence in a central authority, it depends instead on a distributed system of trust.^[17]

Money matrix

Digital currency is a particular form of currency which is electronically transferred and stored, i.e., distinct from physical currency, such as coins or banknotes. According to the European Central Bank, virtual currencies are "generally digital", although their enduring precursor, the coupon, for example, is physical.^[1]

A cryptocurrency is a digital currency using cryptography to secure transactions and to control the creation of new currency units.^[18] Since not all virtual currencies use cryptography, not all virtual currencies are cryptocurrencies.

Cryptocurrencies are not always legal tender, but some countries have moved to regulate cryptocurrency-related services as they would financial institutions. Ecuador is the first country attempting a government run a cryptography-free digital currency; during the introductory phase from Christmas Eve 2014 until mid February 2015 people can open accounts and change passwords. At the end of February 2015 transactions of electronic money will be possible.^[19][20]

Estonia has been exploring various possibilities for blockchain technology, such as Estcoin and the use of crypto tokens within its e-residency program, which gives both Estonians and foreigners a digital form of identification.^[21]

The money matrix adapted from an ECB work, Virtual Currency Schemes^[1]^: 11			Money format
			Physical	Digital
				Cryptography-free	Cryptography-based or cryptocurrency
Legal status	Unregulated	Centralized	Coupon	Internet coupon^[note 1]
				Mobile coupon
			Local currencies	Centralized virtual currencies
		Decentralized	Physical commodity money	Digital currency, Ripple, Stellar^[22]	Decentralized cryptocurrencies
	Regulated		Banknotes, coins, and cash	E-money
				Commercial bank money (deposits)

1. The cells with the blue background denote a virtual currency.

Regulation

See also: Legality of bitcoin by country and United States virtual currency law

Virtual currencies pose challenges for central banks, financial regulators, departments or ministries of finance, as well as fiscal authorities and statistical authorities. Gareth Murphy, Central Bank of Ireland, described the regulatory challenges posed by virtual currencies as relating to:^{[citation needed]}

• Economic statistics
• Monetary and exchange rate policy
• Tax leakage
• Payment systems and settlement infrastructure
• Consumer protection
• Anti-money laundering
• Impact of financial regulation on financial service providers

United States

Commodity Futures Trading Commission guidance

The US Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) has determined virtual currencies are properly defined as commodities in 2015.^[23] The CFTC warned investors against pump and dump schemes that use virtual currencies.^[24]

Internal Revenue Service guidance

The US Internal Revenue Service (IRS) ruling Notice 2014-21^[25] defines any virtual currency, cryptocurrency and digital currency as property; gains and losses are taxable within standard property policies.

Treasury guidance

On 20 March 2013, the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network issued a guidance to clarify how the US Bank Secrecy Act applied to persons creating, exchanging and transmitting virtual currencies.^[3]

Securities and Exchange Commission guidance

In May 2014 the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) "warned about the hazards of bitcoin and other virtual currencies".^{[citation needed]}

State regulations

New York state regulation

In July 2014, the New York State Department of Financial Services proposed the most comprehensive regulation of virtual currencies to date commonly referred to as a BitLicense. Unlike the US federal regulators it has gathered input from bitcoin supporters and the financial industry through public hearings and a comment period until October 21, 2014, to customize the rules. The proposal, per NY DFS press release "sought to strike an appropriate balance that helps protect consumers and root out illegal activity".^[26] It has been criticized by smaller companies to favor established institutions, and Chinese bitcoin exchanges have complained that the rules are "overly broad in its application outside the United States".^[27]

European Union

European Central Bank guidance

In February 2015 the ECB concluded "Virtual currency schemes, such as Bitcoin, are not full forms of money as usually defined in economic literature, nor are virtual currencies money or currency from a legal perspective. Nevertheless, Virtual currency may substitute [for] banknotes and coins, scriptural money and e-money in certain payment situations".^[28] In a May 2019 report ECB expressed concerns that "crypto assets provide opportunity for anonymous participation in illegal activities of all sorts".^[29]

Legal classification

In the European Union, a legal definition of cryptocurrency was introduced to be broadly be regarded as “a digital representation of value that can be digitally transferred, stored or traded and is accepted… as a medium of exchange” in the 5th Anti Money Laundering Directive. This also means that within the European Union cryptocurrencies and cryptocurrency exchanges are considered “obliged entities” subject to the European Union's Anti-Money Laundering Directives, and face the same CFT/AML regulations. As of July 20, 2021, the European Commission has proposed replacing the previous Directive 2015/849/EU with provisions from the 6th Anti-Money Laundering Directive.^[30]

Virtual currencies are defined as "a digital representation of value that is not issued or guaranteed by a central bank or a public authority, is not necessarily attached to a legally established currency and does not possess a legal status of currency or money, but is accepted by natural or legal persons as a means of exchange and which can be transferred, stored and traded electronically".

The fact that European Union lawmakers regard Bitcoin as the archetypal example of virtual currencies and that Bitcoin therefore fulfills all elements of the legal definition can serve as an anchor point for interpretation. Basically, the definition consists of six elements:^[31][32]

1. Virtual currencies are digital representations of value. Thus, digital assets must have a certain value in business transactions in order to be considered virtual currencies under EU law.
2. Virtual currencies are not issued or guaranteed by a central bank or public authority. Issuing is the first placement of a digital asset in the market. Guaranteeing is the assumption of third-party or own liabilities. If digital assets are issued or guaranteed by a central bank or public body, they are not virtual currencies.
3. Virtual currencies can be attached to a legal currency. Attachment is a legal or economic mechanism that links the value of the digital asset to a legal currency.
4. Virtual currencies do not have the legal status of a currency or money. This depends on the status of a digital asset in the EU or a Member State.
5. Virtual currencies are accepted by natural or legal persons as a means of exchange. This is the core element of the legal definition: The term "medium of exchange" is best understood in negative terms and requires that a digital asset is neither e-money as defined by the EU E-Money Directive, nor a payment service or payment instrument as defined by EU Payment Services Directive II, nor any other means of payment as defined by EU Capital Requirements Directive IV. The concept of acceptance requires a certain minimum of actual demand for the digital asset on the market to be considered a virtual currency.
6. Virtual currencies can be transferred, stored and traded electronically. Only digital assets that can be transferred electronically to a person (transfer), whereby the owner also has the option of preventing transfers without his intervention (storage), fulfill this concept.

The authors of the legal definition under EU law primarily had blockchain technology in mind – and Bitcoin as an archetypal form.^[33] Against this background, it is remarkable that the definition does not contain any elements tailored to the use of a particular technology. On the contrary, the legal definition is strikingly technology neutral.

In a CNN interview, the financial crime expert Veit Buetterlin explained that the raise of the cryptocurrency market opened creative channels for terror groups to finance themselves.^[34]

See also

•  Numismatics portal

• Complementary currency
• List of digital currencies
• Token money
• Virtual goods

References

1. European Central Bank (October 2012). "1". Virtual Currency Schemes (PDF). Frankfurt am Main: European Central Bank. p. 5. ISBN 978-92-899-0862-7. (PDF) from the original on 2012-11-06.
2. "EBA Opinion on 'virtual currencies" (PDF). European Banking Authority. 4 July 2014. p. 5. Retrieved 14 January 2022.
3. . Financial Crimes Enforcement Network. 18 March 2013. p. 6. Archived from the original on 19 March 2013. Retrieved 29 May 2015.
4. Directive (EU) 2018/843 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 30 May 2018 amending Directive (EU) 2015/849 on the prevention of the use of the financial system for the purposes of money laundering or terrorist financing, and amending Directives 2009/138/EC and 2013/36/EU (Text with EEA relevance), vol. OJ L, 2018-06-19, retrieved 2019-09-18
5. SUBCOMMITTEE ON DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL MONETARY POLICY (1995). "The Future of Money". Congressional Hearing. Internet Archive. Retrieved 27 May 2014. {{cite web}}: |author= has generic name (help)
6. Samuelson, Kristin (13 November 2011). "The ins and outs of Bitcoin. Does the latest digital currency have staying power?". Chicago Tribune. from the original on 2012-01-27.
7. Sutter, John D. (19 May 2009). "Virtual currencies power social networks, online games". CNN.
8. "Bitcoins Virtual Currency: Unique Features Present Challenges for Deterring Illicit Activity" (PDF). Cyber Intelligence Section and Criminal Intelligence Section. FBI. 24 April 2012.
9. U.S. Government Accountability Office (May 2013). "Virtual Economies and currencies: Additional IRS guidance could reduce tax compliance risks". GAO Report GAO-13-516. Report to the Committee on Finance, U.S. Senate. from the original on 2013-06-21.
10. Raskind, Max (18 November 2013). "U.S. Agencies to Say Bitcoins Offer Legitimate Benefits". Bloomberg. from the original on 2013-11-19.
11. "31 CFR § 1010.100(m)". Code of Federal Regulations. from the original on 2014-03-24.
12. "Notice 2014-21" (PDF). Fact sheet. IRS. March 2014. Retrieved 25 April 2014.
13. Levitin, Adam (March 26, 2014). "Bitcoin Tax Ruling". Blog. Retrieved 25 April 2014.
14. "Bitcoin is legally property, says US IRS. Does that kill it as a currency?". The Guardian. 31 March 2014. Retrieved 30 May 2014. Adam Levitin is a law professor at Georgetown University, and he believes that the ruling means that bitcoin can never be treated as "fungible"
15. Kanner, Bernice (7 September 1992). New York Magazine. p. 18.
16. Toksabay, Ece (16 April 2021). "Bitcoin tumbles after Turkey bans crypto payments citing risks | Reuters". Reuters.
17. "Bitcoin: Bitcoin under pressure". The Economist. 30 November 2013. from the original on 2013-11-30.
18. Andy Greenberg (20 April 2011). "Crypto Currency". Forbes. Retrieved 8 August 2014.
19. Mellisa Tolentino (1 January 2015). "Ecuador rolls out phase one of state-backed digital currency". SiliconANGLE Network. Retrieved 1 February 2015.
20. Jerin Mathew (25 July 2014). "Ecuador to Create Government-Run Digital Currency as It Bans Bitcoin". International Business Times.
21. Estonia says it won't issue a national cryptocurrency and never planned to
22. "Innovations in payment technologies and the emergence of digital currencies" (PDF). Bank of England. p. 262. There are also a small number of digital currencies, the most prominent of which is Ripple, that seek consensus through non-cryptographic means
23. "A CFTC Primer on Virtual Currencies" (PDF). US Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC). October 17, 2017.
24. Commodity Futures Trading Commission (February 15, 2018). "Beware Virtual Currency Pump-and-Dump Schemes" (PDF). Retrieved May 30, 2018.
25. "US IRS Notice 2014-21" (PDF). US International Revenue Service (irs.gov). 2014.
26. . New York State Department of Financial Services. 17 July 2014. Archived from the original on 14 December 2017. Retrieved 13 October 2014.
27. SydneyEmber (21 August 2014). "More Comments Invited for Proposed Bitcoin Rule". DealBook. NY Times. Retrieved 3 October 2014.
28. "Virtual currency schemes – a further analysis" (PDF). European Central Bank (ECB). February 2015.
29. https://www.ecb.europa.eu/pub/pdf/scpops/ecb.op223~3ce14e986c.en.pdf?f2e9a2596a8f9c38c95f4735c05a0d47^{[bare URL PDF]}
30. European Commission (20 July 2021). "Anti-money laundering and countering the financing of terrorism legislative package". Retrieved 21 July 2021.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: url-status (link)
31. Voelkel, Oliver (2019). "On the term "virtual currency"" (PDF). ZFR 2019/149.
32. "ZFR 2019/149 – Zum Begriff "virtuelle Währung" – LexisNexis Zeitschriften". lesen.lexisnexis.at. Retrieved 2019-09-18.
33. "COM_2016_0450_FIN.DEU.xhtml.1_DE_ACT_part1_v2.docx". eur-lex.europa.eu. Retrieved 2019-09-18.
34. . Archived from the original on 2020-01-14. Retrieved 2020-03-31.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: archived copy as title (link)

External links

• Virtual Currency: Investigative Challenges and Opportunities (FBI)